Nicolas Cinquini

Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu

Tag: whitewashing

  • [Sharing] The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat – Jacques Baud, The Postil Magazine

    We are very happy to bring you this excerpt from Colonel Jacques Baud’s latest book, The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat (L’art de la guerre russe : Comment l’Occident conduisit l’Ukraine à l’échec). This is a detailed study of the two-year old conflict in which the West has brutally used the Ukrainians to pursue an old pipedream: the conquest of Russia.

    The book is being translated into English, and we will update this page when it is published. In the meantime, we provide a generous excerpt, along with a detailed Table of Contents, to give you a taste of this very important and much-needed book.

    Russian Military Thought

    Throughout the Cold War period, the Soviet Union saw itself as the spearhead of a historical struggle that would lead to a confrontation between the “capitalist” system and “progressive forces.” This perception of a permanent and inescapable war led the Soviets to study war in a quasi-scientific way, and to structure this thinking into an architecture of military thought that has no equal in the Western world.

    The problem with the vast majority of our so-called military experts is their inability to understand the Russian approach to war. It is the result of an approach we have already seen in waves of terrorist attacks—the adversary is so stupidly demonized that we refrain from understanding his way of thinking. As a result, we are unable to develop strategies, articulate our forces, or even equip them for the realities of war. The corollary of this approach is that our frustrations are translated by unscrupulous media into a narrative that feeds hatred and increases our vulnerability. We are thus unable to find rational, effective solutions to the problem.

    The way Russians understand conflict is holistic. In other words, they see the processes that develop and lead to the situation at any given moment. This explains why Vladimir Putin’s speeches invariably include a return to history. In the West, we tend to focus on X moment and try to see how it might evolve. We want an immediate response to the situation we see today. The idea that “from the understanding of how the crisis arose comes the way to resolve it” is totally foreign to the West. In September 2023, an English-speaking journalist even pulled out the “duck test” for me: “if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, it’s probably a duck.” In other words, all the West needs to assess a situation is an image that fits their prejudices. Reality is much more subtle than the duck model….

    The reason the Russians are better than the West in Ukraine is that they see the conflict as a process; whereas we see it as a series of separate actions. The Russians see events as a film. We see them as photographs. They see the forest, while we focus on the trees. That is why we place the start of the conflict on February 24, 2022, or the start of the Palestinian conflict on October 7, 2023. We ignore the contexts that bother us and wage conflicts we do not understand. That is why we lose our wars…

    ****

    In Russia, unsurprisingly, the principles of the military art of the Soviet forces inspired those currently in use:

    • readiness to carry out assigned missions;
    • concentration of efforts on solving a specific mission;
    • surprise (unconventionality) of military action vis-à-vis the enemy;
    • finality determines a set of tasks and the level of resolution of each one;
    • totality of available means determines the way to resolve the mission and achieve the objective (correlation of forces);
    • coherence of leadership (unity of command);
    • economy of forces, resources, time and space;
    • support and restoration of combat capability;
    • freedom of maneuver.

    It should be noted that these principles apply not only to the implementation of military action as such. They are also applicable as a system of thought to other non-operational activities.

    An honest analysis of the conflict in Ukraine would have identified these various principles and drawn useful conclusions for Ukraine. But none of the self-proclaimed experts on TV were intellectually able to do so.

    Thus, Westerners are systematically surprised by the Russians in the fields of technology (e.g., hypersonic weapons), doctrine (e.g., operative art) and economics (e.g., resilience to sanctions). In a way, the Russians are taking advantage of our prejudices to exploit the principle of surprise. We can see this in the Ukrainian conflict, where the Western narrative led Ukraine to totally underestimate Russian capabilities, which was a major factor in its defeat. That is why Russia did not really try to counter this narrative and let it play out—the belief that we are superior makes us vulnerable….

    Correlation of Forces

    Russian military thought is traditionally linked to a holistic approach to warfare, which involves the integration of a large number of factors in the development of a strategy. This approach is materialized by the concept of “correlation of forces” (Соотношение сил).

    Often translated as “balance of forces” or “ratio of forces,” this concept is only understood by Westerners as a quantitative quantity, limited to the military domain. In Soviet thinking, however, the correlation of forces reflected a more holistic reading of war:

    There are several criteria for assessing the correlation of strengths. In the economic sphere, the factors usually compared are gross national product per capita, labor productivity, the dynamics of economic growth, the level of industrial production, particularly in high-tech sectors, the technical infrastructure of the production tool, the resources and degree of qualification of the workforce, the number of specialists and the level of development of theoretical and applied sciences.

    In the military field, the factors compared are the quantity and quality of armaments, the firepower of the armed forces, the fighting and moral qualities of the soldiers, the level of staff training, the organization of the troops and their combat experience, the character of the military doctrine and the methods of strategic, operative and tactical thinking.

    In the political sphere, the factors that come into consideration are the breadth of the social base of state authority, its organization, the constitutional procedure for relations between the government and legislative bodies, the ability to take operational decisions, and the degree and character of popular support for domestic and foreign policy.

    Finally, when assessing the strength of the international movement, the factors taken into consideration are its quantitative composition, its influence with the masses, its position in the political life of each country, the principles and norms of relations between its components and the degree of their cohesion.

    In other words, the assessment of the situation is not limited to the balance of forces on the battlefield, but takes into account all the elements that have an impact on the evolution of the conflict. Thus, for their Special Military Operation, the Russian authorities had planned to support the war effort through the economy, without moving to a “war economy” regime. Thus, unlike in Ukraine, there was no interruption in the tax and welfare mechanisms.

    This is why the sanctions applied to Russia in 2014 had a double positive effect. The first was the realization that they were not only a short-term problem, but above all a medium- and long-term opportunity. They encouraged Russia to produce goods it had previously preferred to buy abroad. The second was the signal that the West would increasingly use economic weapons as a means of pressure in the future. It therefore became imperative, for reasons of national independence and sovereignty, to prepare for more far-reaching sanctions affecting the country’s economy.

    In reality, it has long been known that sanctions do not work. Logically enough, they have had the opposite effect, acting as protectionist measures for Russia, which has thus been able to consolidate its economy, as had been the case after the 2014 sanctions. A sanctions strategy might have paid off if the Russian economy had effectively been the equivalent of the Italian or Spanish economy, i.e., with a high level of debt; and if the entire planet had acted in unison to isolate Russia.

    The inclusion of the correlation of forces in the decision-making process is a fundamental difference from Western decision-making processes, which are linked more to a policy of communication than to a rational approach to problems.

    This explains, for example, Russia’s limited objectives in the Ukraine, where it does not seek to occupy the entire territory, as the correlation of forces in the western part of the country would be unfavorable.

    At every level of leadership, the correlation of forces is part of situation assessment. At the operational level, it is defined as follows:

    The result of comparing the quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the forces and resources (sub-units, units, weapons, military equipment, etc.) of one’s own troops (forces) and those of the enemy. It is calculated on an operational and tactical scale throughout the area of operations, in the main and other directions, in order to determine the degree of objective superiority of one of the opposing camps. Force correlation assessment is used to make an informed decision about an operation (battle), and to establish and maintain the necessary superiority over the enemy for as long as possible, when decisions are redefined (modified) during military (combat) operations.

    This simple definition is the reason why the Russians committed themselves with forces inferior to those of Ukraine in February 2022, or why they withdrew from Kiev, Kharkov and Kherson in March, September and October 2022.

    ****

    Structure of the Doctrine

    The Russians have always attached particular importance to doctrine. Better than the West, they have understood that “a common way of seeing, thinking and acting”—as Marshal Foch put it—gives coherence, while allowing for infinite variations in the conception of operations. Military doctrine is a kind of “common core” that serves as a reference for designing operations.

    Russian military doctrine divides military art into three main components: strategy (strategiya), operative art (operativnoe iskoustvo) and tactics (taktika). Each of these components has its own characteristics, very similar to those found in Western doctrines. Using the terminology of French doctrine on the use of forces:

    • The strategic level is that of conception. The aim of strategic action is to lead the adversary to negotiation or defeat.
    • The operative level is that of cooperation and coordination of inter-force actions, with a view to achieving a given military objective.
    • The tactical level, finally, is that of maneuver execution at weapon level as an integral part of the operational maneuver.

    These three components correspond to levels of leadership, which translate into leadership structures and the space in which military operations are conducted. For simplicity’s sake, let us say that the strategic level ensures the management of the theater of war (Театр Войны) (TV); a geographically vast entity, with its own command and control structures, within which there are one or more strategic directions. The theater of war comprises a set of theaters of military operations (Театр Военных Действий) (TVD), which represent a strategic direction and are the domain of operative action. These various theaters have no predetermined structure and are defined according to the situation. For example, although we commonly speak of the “war in Afghanistan” (1979-1989) or the “war in Syria” (2015-), these countries are considered in Russian terminology as TVDs and not TVs.

    The same applies to Ukraine, which Russia sees as a theater of military operations (TVD) and not a theater of war (TV), which explains why the action in Ukraine is designated as a “Special Military Operation” (Специальная Военная Операция – Spetsial’naya Voyennaya Operatsiya—SVO, or SMO in English abbreviation) and not a “war.”

    The use of the word “war” would imply a different structure of conduct than that envisaged by the Russians in Ukraine, and would have other structural implications in Russia itself. Moreover—and this is a central point—as NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg himself acknowledges, “the war began in 2014” and should have been ended by the Minsk Agreements. The SMO is therefore a “military operation” and not a new “war,” as many Western “experts” claim.

    ****

    The Special Military Operation in Ukraine

    The Correlation of Forces

    Consider all the factors that directly or indirectly influence the conflict. Conversely, as we have seen in Ukraine and elsewhere, Westerners have a much more political reading of the war, and end up mixing the two. This is why communication plays such an essential role in the conduct of war: the perception of the conflict plays an almost more important role than its reality. This is why, in Iraq, the Americans literally invented episodes that glorified their troops.

    Russia’s analysis of the situation in February 2022 was undoubtedly considerably more pertinent than that of the West. They knew that a Ukrainian offensive against the Donbass was underway and that it could endanger the government. In 2014-2015, after the massacres in Odessa and Mariupol, the Russian population was very much in favor of intervention. Vladimir Putin’s stubborn clinging to the Minsk Agreements was poorly understood in Russia.

    The factors that contributed to Russia’s decision to intervene were twofold: the expected support of Ukraine’s ethnically Russian population (which we will call “Russian-speaking” for convenience) and an economy robust enough to withstand sanctions.

    The Russian-speaking population had risen up en masse against the new authorities following the coup d’état of February 2014, whose first decision had been to strip the Russian language of its official status. Kiev tried to backtrack, but in April 2019, the 2014 decision was definitively confirmed.

    Since the adoption of the Law on Indigenous Peoples on July 1, 2021, Russian speakers (ethnic Russians) are no longer considered normal Ukrainian citizens and no longer enjoy the same rights as ethnic Ukrainians. They can therefore be expected to offer no resistance to the Russian coalition in the eastern part of the country….

    Since March 24, 2021, Ukrainian forces have been stepping up their presence around the Donbass and have increased the pressure against the autonomists with their fire.

    Zelensky’s decree of March 24, 2021 for the reconquest of Crimea and the Donbass was the real trigger for the SMO. From that moment on, the Russians understood that if there was military action against them, they would have to intervene. But they also knew that the cause of the Ukrainian operation was NATO membership, as Oleksei Arestovitch had explained. That is why, in mid-December 2021, they were submitting proposals to the USA and NATO on extending the Alliance: their aim was then to remove Ukraine’s motive for an offensive in the Donbass.

    The reason for the Russian Special Military Operation (SMO) is indeed the protection of the populations of Donbass; but this protection was necessary because of Kiev’s desire to go through a confrontation to enter NATO. The extension of NATO is therefore only the indirect cause of the conflict in Ukraine. The latter could have spared itself this ordeal by implementing the Minsk Agreements—but what we wanted was a defeat for Russia.

    In 2008, Russia intervened in Georgia to protect the Russian minority then being bombed by its government, as confirmed by the Swiss ambassador, Heidi Tagliavini, who was responsible for investigating this event. In 2014, many voices were raised in Russia to demand intervention when the new regime in Kiev had engaged its army against the civilian population of the five autonomist oblasts (Odessa, Dnepropetrovsk, Kharkov, Lugansk and Donetsk) and applied a fierce repression. In 2022, it could be expected that the population of Russia would not understand the government’s inaction, after no efforts were made from the Ukrainian and Western sides to enforce the Minsk Agreements. They knew that they did not have the means to launch an economic retaliation. But they also knew that an economic war against Russia would inevitably backfire on Western countries.

    An important element of Russian military and political thinking is its legalistic dimension. The way our media present events, systematically omitting facts that could explain, justify, legitimize or even legalize Russia’s actions. We tend to think that Russia is acting outside any legal framework. For example, our media present the Russian intervention in Syria as having been decided unilaterally by Moscow; whereas it was carried out at the request of the Syrian government, after the West had allowed the Islamic State to move closer to Damascus, as confessed by John Kerry, then Secretary of State. Nevertheless, there is never any mention of the occupation of eastern Syria by American troops, who were never even invited there!

    We could multiply the examples, to which our journalists will counter with the war crimes committed by Russian forces. This may well be true, but the simple fact that these accusations are not based on any impartial and neutral investigation (as required by humanitarian doctrine), nor on any international one, since Russia is systematically refused participation, casts a shadow over the honesty of these accusations. For example, the sabotage of the Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines was immediately attributed to Russia, which was accused of violating international law.

    In fact, unlike the West, which advocates a “rules-based international order,” the Russians insist on a “law-based international order.” Unlike the West, they will apply the law to the letter. No more, no less.

    The legal framework for Russia’s intervention in Ukraine has been meticulously planned. As this subject has already been covered in one of my previous books, I will not go into details here…

    ****

    The Objectives and Strategy of Russia

    On February 23, 2023, Swiss military “expert” Alexandre Vautravers commented on Russia’s objectives in Ukraine:

    The aim of the Special Military Operation was to decapitate Ukrainian political and military governance in the space of five, ten, maybe even two weeks. The Russians then changed their plan and their objectives with a number of other failures; so they change their objectives and their strategic orientations almost every week or every month.

    The problem is that our “experts” themselves define Russia’s objectives according to what they imagine, only to be able to say that it has not achieved them. So. Let us get back to the facts.

    On February 24, 2022, Russia launched its “Special Military Operation” (SMO) in Ukraine “at short notice.” In his televised address, Vladimir Putin explained that its strategic objective was to protect the population of Donbass. This objective can be broken down into two parts:

    • “demilitarize” the Ukrainian armed forces regrouped in the Donbass in preparation for the offensive against the DPR and LPR; and
    • “denazify” (i.e. “neutralize”) the ultra-nationalist and neo-Nazi paramilitary militias in the Mariupol area.

    The formulation chosen by Vladimir Putin has been very poorly analyzed in the West. It is inspired by the 1945 Potsdam Declaration, which envisaged the development of defeated Germany according to four principles: demilitarization, denazification, democratization and decentralization.

    The Russians understand war from a Clausewitzian perspective: war is the pursuit of politics by other means. This then means that they seek to transform operational successes into strategic successes, and military successes into political objectives. So, while the demilitarization evoked by Putin is clearly linked to the military threat to the populations of the Donbass in application of the decree of March 24, 2021, signed by Zelensky.

    But this objective conceals a second: the neutralization of Ukraine as a future NATO member. This is what Zelensky understood when he proposed a resolution to the conflict in March 2022. At first, his proposal was supported by Western countries, probably because at this stage they believed that Russia had failed in its bid to take over Ukraine in three days, and that it would not be able to sustain its war effort because of the massive sanctions imposed on it. But at the NATO meeting of March 24, 2022, the Allies decided not to support Zelensky’s proposition.

    Nevertheless, on March 27, Zelensky publicly defended his proposal and on March 28, as a gesture of support for this effort, Vladimir Putin eased the pressure on the capital and withdrew his troops from the area. Zelensky’s proposal served as the basis for the Istanbul Communiqué of March 29, 2022, a ceasefire agreement as a prelude to a peace agreement. It was this document that Vladimir Putin presented in June 2023, when an African delegation visited Moscow. It was Boris Johnson’s intervention that prompted Zelensky to withdraw his proposal, exchanging peace and the lives of his men for support “for as long as it takes.”

    This version of events—which I have already presented in my previous works—was finally confirmed in early November 2023 by David Arakhamia, then chief negotiator for Ukraine196. He explained that Russia had never intended to seize Kiev.

    In essence, Russia agreed to withdraw to the borders of February 23, 2022, in exchange for a ceiling on Ukrainian forces and a commitment not to become a NATO member, along with security guarantees from a number of countries….

    Two conclusions can be drawn:

    • Russia’s objective was not to conquer territory. If the West had not intervened to push Zelensky to withdraw his offer, Ukraine would probably still have its army.
    • While the Russians intervened to ensure the security and protection of the population of the Donbass, their SMO enabled them to achieve a broader objective, which involves Russia’s security.

    This means that, although this objective is not formulated, the demilitarization of Ukraine could open the door to its neutralization. This is not surprising since, conversely, in an interview with the Ukrainian channel Apostrof’ on March 18, 2019, Volodymyr Zelensky’s advisor Oleksei Arestovitch cynically explains that, because Ukraine wants to join NATO, it will have to create the conditions for Russia to attack Ukraine and be definitively defeated.

    The problem is that Ukrainian and Western analysis is fueled by their own narratives. The conviction that Russia will lose has meant that no alternative contingency has been prepared. In September 2023, the West, beginning to see the collapse of this narrative and its implementation, tried to move towards a “freeze” in the conflict, without taking into account the opinion of the Russians, who dominate on the ground.

    Yet Russia would have been satisfied with a situation such as that proposed by Zelensky in March 2022. What the West wants in September 2023 is merely a pause until an even more violent conflict breaks out, after Ukrainian forces have been rearmed and reconstituted.

    ****

    Ukrainian Strategy

    The strategic objective of Volodymyr Zelensky and his team is to join NATO, as a prelude to a brighter future within the EU. It complements that of the Americans (and therefore of the Europeans). The problem is that tensions with Russia, particularly over Crimea, are causing NATO members to put off Ukraine’s participation. In March 2022, Zelensky revealed on CNN that this is exactly what the Americans told him.

    Before coming to power in April 2019, Volodymyr Zelensky’s discourse was divided between two antagonistic policies: the reconciliation with Russia promised during his presidential campaign and his goal of joining NATO. He knows that these two policies are mutually exclusive, as Russia does not want to see NATO and its nuclear weapons installed in Ukraine and wanted neutrality or non-alignment.

    What is more, he knows that his ultra-nationalist allies will refuse to negotiate with Russia. This was confirmed by Praviy Sektor leader Dmitro Yarosh, who openly threatened him with death in the Ukrainian media a month after his election. Zelensky therefore knew from the start of the election campaign that he would not be able to fulfill his promise of reconciliation, and that there was only one solution left: confrontation with Russia.

    But this confrontation could not be waged by Ukraine alone against Russia, and it would need the material support of the West. The strategy devised by Zelensky and his team was revealed before his election in March 2019 by Oleksei Arestovitch, his personal advisor, on the Ukrainian media Apostrof’. Arestovitch explained that it would take an attack by Russia to provoke an international mobilization that would enable Ukraine to defeat Russia once and for all, with the help of Western countries and NATO. With astonishing precision, he described the course of the Russian attack as it would unfold three years later, between February and March 2022. Not only did he explain that this conflict was unavoidable if Ukraine is to join NATO, but he also placed this confrontation in 2021-2022! He outlined the main areas of Western aid:

    In this conflict, we will be very actively supported by the West. Weapons. Equipment. Assistance. New sanctions against Russia. Most likely, the introduction of a NATO contingent. A no-fly zone, and so on. In other words, we won’t lose it.

    As we can see, this strategy has much in common with the one described by the RAND Corporation at the same time. So much so, in fact, that it is hard not to see it as a strategy strongly inspired by the United States. In his interview, Arestovitch singled out four elements that would become the pillars of the Ukrainian strategy against Russia, and to which Zelensky returned regularly:

    • International aid and arms supplies,
    • International sanctions,
    • NATO intervention,
    • Creation of a no-fly zone.

    It should be noted that these four pillars are understood by Zelensky as promises whose fulfillment is essential to the success of this strategy. In February 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of Ukraine’s Defense and National Security Council, declared in The Kyiv Independent that Ukraine’s objective was the disintegration of Russia. The mobilization of Western countries to supply Ukraine with heavy weapons then seems to give substance to this objective, which is consistent with what Oleksiy Arestovich had declared in March 2019.

    A few months later, however, it became clear that the equipment supplied to Ukraine was not sufficient to ensure the success of its counter-offensive, and Zelensky asked for additional, better-adapted equipment. At this point, there was a certain amount of Western irritation at these repeated demands. Former British Defense Minister Ben Wallace declared that Westerners “are not Amazon.” In fact, the West does not respect its commitments.

    Contrary to what our media and pseudo-military experts tell us, since February 2022, it has been clear that Ukraine cannot defeat Russia on its own. As Obama put it, “Russia [there] will always be able to maintain its escalation dominance.” In other words, Ukraine will only be able to achieve its goals with the involvement of NATO countries. This means that its fate will depend on the goodwill of Western countries. So, we need to maintain a narrative that encourages the West to keep up this effort. This narrative will then become what we call, in strategic terms, its “center of gravity.”

    As the months went by, the course of operations showed that the prospect of a Ukrainian victory was becoming increasingly remote, as Russia, far from being weakened, was growing stronger, militarily and economically. Even General Christopher Cavoli, Supreme American Commander Europe (SACEUR), told a US congressional committee that “Russia’s air, naval, space, digital and strategic capabilities have not suffered significant degradation during this war.”

    The West, expecting a short conflict, is no longer able to maintain the effort promised to Ukraine. The NATO summit in Vilnius (July 11-12, 2023) ended in partial success for Ukraine. Its membership is postponed indefinitely. Its situation is even worse than it was at the beginning of 2022, since there is no more justification for its entry into NATO than there was before the SMO.

    Ukraine then turned its attention to a more concrete objective: regaining sovereignty over its entire 1991 territory.

    Thus, the Ukrainian notion of “victory” rapidly evolved. The idea of a “collapse of Russia” quickly faded, as did that of its dismemberment. There was talk of “regime change,” which Zelensky made his objective by forbidding any negotiations as long as Vladimir Putin was in power. Then came the reconquest of lost territories, thanks to the counter-offensive of 2023. But here, too, hopes quickly faded. The plan was simply to cut the Russian forces in two, with a thrust towards the Sea of Azov. But by September 2023, this objective had been reduced to the liberation of three cities.

    In the absence of concrete successes, narrative remains the only element Ukraine can rely on to maintain Western attention and willingness to support it. For, as Ben Wallace, ex-Defence Minister, put it in The Telegraph on October 1, 2023: “The most precious commodity is hope.” True enough. But Western appraisal of the situation must be based on realistic analyses of the adversary. However, since the beginning of the Ukrainian crisis, Western analyses have been based on prejudice.

    ****

    The Notion of Victory

    Russia operates within a framework of Clausewitzian thinking, in which operational successes are exploited for strategic ends. Operational strategy (“operative art”) therefore plays an essential role in the definition of what is considered a victory.

    As we saw during the battle of Bakhmut, the Russians adapted perfectly to the strategy imposed on Ukraine by the West, which prioritizes the defense of every square meter. The Ukrainians thus played into the hands of the attrition strategy officially announced by Russia. Conversely, in Kharkov and Kherson, the Russians preferred to cede territory in exchange for the lives of their men. In the context of a war of attrition, sacrificing potential in exchange for territory, as Ukraine is doing, is the worst strategy of all.

    This is why General Zaluzhny, commander of the Ukrainian forces, tried to oppose Zelensky and proposed withdrawing his forces from Bakhmut. But in Ukraine, it is the Western narrative that guides military decisions. Zelensky preferred to follow the path laid out for him by our media, in order to retain the support of Western opinion. In November 2023, General Zaluzhny had to openly admit that this decision was a mistake, because prolonging the war will only favor Russia.

    The Ukrainian conflict was inherently asymmetrical. The West wanted to turn it into a symmetrical conflict, proclaiming that Ukraine’s capabilities could be enough to topple Russia. But this was clearly wishful thinking from the outset, and its sole purpose was to justify non-compliance with the Minsk Agreements. Russian strategists have turned it into an asymmetrical conflict.

    Ukraine’s problem in this conflict is that it has no rational relationship with the notion of victory. By comparison, the Palestinians, who are aware of their quantitative inferiority, have switched to a way of thinking that gives the simple act of resisting a sense of victory. This is the asymmetrical nature of the conflict that Israel has never managed to understand in 75 years, and which it is reduced to overcoming through tactical superiority rather than strategic finesse. In Ukraine, it is the same phenomenon. By clinging to a notion of victory linked to the recovery of territory, Ukraine has locked itself into a logic that can only lead to defeat.

    On November 20, 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of the National Security and Defense Council, painted a gloomy picture of Ukrainian prospects for 2024. His speech showed that Ukraine had neither a plan to emerge from the conflict, nor an approach that would associate a sense of victory with that emergence: he was reduced to linking Ukraine’s victory to that of the West. In the West, however, the end of the conflict in Ukraine is increasingly perceived as a military, political, human and economic debacle.

    In an asymmetrical situation, each protagonist is free to define his or her own criteria for victory, and to choose from a range of criteria under his or her control. This is why Egypt (1973), Hezbollah (2006), the Islamic State (2017), the Palestinian resistance since 1948 and Hamas in 2023 are victorious, despite massive losses. This seems counter-intuitive to a Western mind, but it is what explains why Westerners are unable to really “win” their wars.

    In Ukraine, the political leadership has locked itself into a narrative that precludes a way out of the crisis without losing face. The asymmetrical situation now working to Ukraine’s disadvantage stems from a narrative that has been confused with reality, and has led to a response that is ill-suited to the nature of the Russian operation [end]

    The original article

    Jacques Baud was a member of the Swiss strategic intelligence, a specialist of Eastern European and a former head of the United Nations peace operations doctrine. In NATO, he was involved in programs in Ukraine in 2014 and 2017

    related

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

  • [Sharing] TRAVEL AGENCY “DEATH”. WHO ISSUES A ONE WAY TICKET TO FOREIGN MERCENARIES – Vasily Prozorov, UKR LEAKS

    Since the beginning of the Special Military Operation in February 2022, the topic of the participation of foreign mercenaries in the conflict in Ukraine has been one of the most discussed ones. I want to remind you that foreigners began to take part in hostilities in Ukraine long before the start of the Special Military Operation. For example, I published a remark “Americans in Donbass,” in which I talked about crimes against the civilian population of what was then Ukraine by such mercenaries as Craig Lang, Quinn David Rickert, Santi Emilio Pirtle, Alex Zwiefelhofer and others. It’s easy to find stories online of many other mercenaries who themselves talk about serving on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces and even write memoirs. When was the Georgian Legion created? Right. Long before SMO. Therefore, the topic of mercenaries is not new in the context of the Ukrainian conflict. But the question remains open: Who, where and how recruits them? I will try to answer this question in this material.

    For a more complete understanding of the issue, I turned to the people who are more versed in this – one of the founders of the telegram channel @TrackNaziMerc, whose name I cannot disclose due to security reasons, the team of the telegram channel @ForeignCombatants, as well as a former French police inspector , intelligence officer Nicolas Cinquini.

    My analysis of the information confirms the conclusions of the channel’s authors. I would like to immediately emphasize that the statements of Ukrainian leaders about several tens of thousands of foreigners already fighting on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces and the same number of “willing” ones are a lie. Loud statements were made solely in order to show that supposedly the whole world is with Ukraine and against Russia. For example, the news about the “Armenian Legion” as part of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.

    There are indeed Armenians in the ranks of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. But their number does not correspond to such a concept as “Legion”. According to my estimate, their total number does not exceed one hundred people. These are mainly militants of the pro-Western Russophobic party “Sasna Tsrer”, wandering between Ukraine and Armenia.

    In addition, the Russian Ministry of Defense has repeatedly reported about the real number of foreign mercenaries in the ranks of the Armed Forces of Ukraine – about 12 thousand people arrived in Ukraine, many of whom have already become “200” (killed) and “300” (wounded). We should not forget that most of them fled to their homeland after seeing the harsh reality.

    In almost every corner of the world there are networks of Western intelligence services engaged in recruiting people to join the “International Legion” of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.

    Who is coming to fight on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces and why?

    I divide these individuals into three categories.

    1. These are ideological neo-Nazis, ardent Russophobes, football ultras recruited through networks of neo-Nazi communities.
    2. Individuals who want to make big money from war.
    3. Active military personnel of foreign armies training Ukrainian military personnel, as well as directly participating in the planning and conduct of operations.

    While evidence of the presence in Ukraine of persons from the first and second categories is obvious, the fact of the participation of active military personnel is carefully hidden. I raised this issue in my video interview with the Caserta family, in which we discussed the mysterious deaths of American military personnel. Let me remind you that Teri and Patrick Caserta are the initiators of the creation of the Brandon Act, according to which all US military personnel have the right to receive psychological help at any time. And this need is caused by regular cases of suicide, the details of which are carefully hidden from the relatives of military personnel.

    Moreover, I also asked experts from the telegram channel @foreigncombatants about active military personnel of foreign armies:

    “All employees of foreign law enforcement agencies who are sent to Ukraine are given a leave (usually three months), but there are not many of them. In general, we can say that the number of mercenaries who arrived through PMCs or former military personnel is currently in the West is considered sufficient and they do not see the need to send personnel employees. The already established scheme for creating NPOs has shown itself to be good for consulting and instructing officers.

    In addition, do not underestimate the various so-called volunteer NPOs that provide supplies and material support to the Armed Forces of Ukraine. A huge number of foreigners are involved in them. This allows to seriously unload the costs of waging war and transfer to them the functions of logistics, supply, supply of provisions, software, delivery of drones and equipment, using micromarketing tools. NATO countries managed to involve their citizens in financing this bloody machine with collections for “aid” to Ukraine through multiple NPOs, which make this machine work smoothly and take new lives. We know the officers of the Czech army who oversee the supply of equipment to Ukraine, and although de jure they do not participate in hostilities, in fact they are full-fledged participants in hostilities.”

    Nicolas Cinquini kindly answered my questions and also confirmed the fact of the participation of active military personnel in Ukraine:

    “I have received confirmation from reliable sources that active French soldiers are being offered false resignations to participate in the Ukrainian war, with a guarantee of reinstatement at the end, and before that, a salary that is difficult to refuse.”

    Representatives of the @TrackNaziMerc channel do not deny the presence of active military personnel of foreign armies in Ukraine. This is evidenced by the following facts:

    – The team was able to identify several mine clearance dog handlers from the United States who are on official missions. We did not post their information on the channel because we do not consider them mercenaries, but humanitarian personnel.

     – The list of people awarded Ukrainian medals includes representatives of official law enforcement agencies of the Baltic countries.

      – From a Ukrainian source participating in the battles in the northern direction, we know about the presence of Polish career military personnel stationed in the Chernigov region. But these are combat control and logistics support units for Polish mechanized divisions.

     – Some of the deaths of combatants have a strange backstory, the conclusions of which may lead one to believe that they were on active service.

      – Daniel Swift, killed on January 15, 2023 in Bakhmut, was de facto on active military service, although he was listed as a deserter. As far as is known, the American side did not demand his extradition, although Swift fought in one of the elite units of the Legion, directly associated with the 73rd Naval Special Operations Center, whose military personnel undergo the strictest checks.

    The conclusions of the @foreigncombatants telegram channel team also completely coincide with the previously provided scheme:

    Recruitment of mercenaries occurs through different channels depending on the countries. Professionals with combat experience in hot spots from the United States and Great Britain mainly end up in Ukraine through contacts with mercenaries who have connections with Western PMCs or who fought on the side of the Kurds (YPG) in Iraq and Syria. As a rule, they then form separate units in Ukraine and may have funding from “private sponsors”. There are recruiters in the French Foreign Legion and in the airborne regiment of engineers in Montauban. The French without combat experience come to Ukraine from right-wing radical movements that have connections with Azov or Right Sector. Latin Americans are recruited through the military attache of the Ukrainian Embassy. Mercenaries come from the police and security forces, leaving for high salaries by local standards. Poles and Scandinavians come to Ukraine through contacts in their armed forces, where they previously served.

    In support of the above scheme of the Ukrainian recruitment network, I propose to study the known facts and ways of entry of foreign mercenaries into Ukrainian units. Looking ahead, I want to emphasize that the United States plays a huge role in recruiting mercenaries, pushing people to enter into an armed conflict against Russia, using both financial, ideological and violent methods of influence.

    USA

    The death of American Marines in Ukraine has become an almost weekly event. Not surprising. One of the first advertisements for the recruitment of mercenaries was published on the American website Silent Professionals. The announcement has been active almost from the very beginning of the Special Military Operation and it does not ambiguously indicate that people are being recruited to participate in hostilities in Ukraine.

    In addition, the media and the Internet regularly reported news about the arrival in Ukraine of employees of a number of private military companies. For example:

    • Kellogg, Brown and Root
    • Amentum (earlier called DynCorp),
    • Blackwater (other names – Xe Services/ Academi/ Constellis)
    • Greystone
    • Northbridge Services Group
    • Mozart

    All of these PMCs (with the exception of Mozart, which ceased to exist without being able to do anything to oppose the Wagner PMC) have close ties with the US government, consist of former military personnel and have enormous opportunities to recruit personnel not only in their own country, but also abroad. Many American mercenaries came to Ukraine precisely through the recruiters of these PMCs. It’s no secret to anyone that PMCs carry out US government tasks, are armed and financed by the government. These are convenient tools for waging war against Russia by supposedly non-state actors.

    France

    Nicolas Cinquini told me about French mercenaries in Ukraine in an exclusive interview. Nicolas is a former French official, police inspector since 1989, judicial police officer, then intelligence officer. He was fired in 2020 for publicly protesting on the street, in court and in the press against the unlawful violence committed against the Yellow Vests. He also highlights the US role in fueling the conflict in Ukraine:

    “I see the conflict in Donbass and Ukraine as a new illustration of the proxy wars that the Western bloc is waging against Russia, China and all those who dare oppose its hegemony. I started getting really interested in this issue in 2014 because I didn’t understand France’s support for the Islamist uprising in Syria. My blog activity intensified during the siege of Mariupol. A number of evidence led me to assume that there were active French civil servants there next to the Ukrainian garrison. To confirm this theory, I began to collect information about French mercenaries operating in Ukraine. I realized that many of them were supporters of neo-Nazi ideas, whom the French press tried to whitewash and turn into heroes. In my opinion, the deceased Frenchman Thibaut Rigon, who was posthumously awarded by Zelensky, could be an active civil servant, since there are a lot of mysterious circumstances surrounding his death, and I am trying to clarify all the details.”

    It is noteworthy that a large number of mercenaries with neo-Nazi views actually arrived from France, and work to attract them to Ukraine is still actively ongoing. Thus, in October 2023, the website of the neo-Nazi Azov appeared in French, the main task of which is to search for radicals to join the unit.

    Great Britain

    There is little information in the public domain about the activities of British organizations recruiting militants for Ukraine. The bulk of mercenaries arrive by signing a contract with the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine and joining the International Legion. However, it is known about the organization Akkadian International, whose members have been spotted in Ukraine and have repeatedly held conferences in Poland and Great Britain, calling for entry into the conflict on the side of the Kiev regime.

    Poland

    @TrackNaziMerc:

    All mercenaries arriving in Ukraine enter the country through Poland.

    The mercenary’s path often includes the following stages:

    Warsaw => Lvov/Drohobych => Rovno, where military unit A7420 and the training ground are located.

    The classic route for militants from Latin America also passes through Poland:

    Capital International Airport => Transit airport in the United Arab Emirates/Egypt/Bahrain => Warsaw => Ternopol International Airport, where the contract is directly signed and the unit is staffed => Frontline unit.

    There are a huge number of Polish mercenaries in Ukraine. It was possible to find out that many of them were trained at the ESA (European Security Academy) center.

    ESA is headquartered in the Wroclaw area of Poland and provides training services to military and law enforcement personnel. ESA has already been at the center of a high-profile scandal related to Ukraine. Bellingcat investigators have proven that a large number of Ukrainian Nazis were trained at its training base. The instructors were not taken aback by swastika tattoos or typical greetings.

    This center had (and most likely still has) an extensive network of branches in all regions of the world, as evidenced by accounts on Instagram. You can find Scandinavia, Romania, Bulgaria, Austria, South America, and other accounts of company branches.

    Representatives of the company removed the section with their foreign representative offices from the official website, but their functioning has not been stopped. They search for and train mercenaries in their areas of responsibility.

    This is easy to prove by studying the social networks of mercenaries – on the Internet it is easy to find photographs of militants fighting in Ukraine with the ESA chevron. As proof, I attach a photo of a Portuguese who arrived in Ukraine through the Polish branch of ESA.

    The activities of the ESA center are closely connected with Spain.

    Spain

    Spain was also at the center of a major scandal involving the recruitment of mercenaries to participate in the fighting in Ukraine. As it became known, the GOA Tactical company provides specialized training for mercenaries for 700 euros and is in close contact with the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine.

    Concerned residents of Spain filed a lawsuit against this company demanding that its leader be held accountable, since mercenary activity is prohibited in the country.

    But the company has very large connections with the country’s Ministry of Defense, as well as directly with NATO. A huge influence on GOA Tactical is Eva Álvarez del Manzano, daughter of Bernardo Álvarez del Manzano, the late Army Lieutenant General and former Chief of Operations at the Spanish Defense Headquarters.

    The direct leader of GOA Tactical is Francisco Galvan, call sign “Siscu”.

    As Galvan stated, Eva Manzano is the link between his company, the Spanish army and NATO. An interesting fact is that in various podcasts Manzano is mentioned as an expert in the field of intelligence, special operations, and espionage.

    Returning to GOA Tactical: the company has branches in Israel, Peru and Poland. In Poland they work closely with the same ESA. It was possible to find out that other Spanish companies also work closely with ESA.

    For example, the Spanish company Geitsinternational listed ESA as a partner on its poster, and the last few training courses took place in Poland.

    This is not the only military and police training company that works closely with the Polish ESA. For example, Astespana, located in Madrid, also actively interacts with the Polish ESA and conducts combat training at its training base.

    Georgia

    On the territory of Georgia, with the financial support of the US Embassy, measures are being taken to train and send mercenaries from both Georgian citizens and nationals of other states to the combat zone in Ukraine. For this purpose, a coordination headquarters has been organized in Georgia (Tbilisi), created on the basis of the non-governmental organization “Free Zone”. The organization includes representatives of the youth wing of the opposition political party “United National Movement”: Gagnidze Bondo, Gigauri Zurab, Keinashvili Demur, Kimadze David, Kumsishvili Guram, Kurkumuli Lola (female), Mamulashvili Vakhtang, Potskhverashvili Tatia (female), Rachveshvili Guram , Anna Siradze (female), Irakli Tkeshelashvili, Boris Khurtsilava, Chokheli Shmagi.

    After combat coordination of the mercenaries, groups are formed for gradual dispatch to the territory of Poland. The transfer is carried out by charter flights, as well as by US military transport aircraft from Novoalekseevka International Airport (Tbilisi, Georgia) to the Chopin international airport (Warsaw, Poland). The arrivals are met and escorted to the Polish-Ukrainian border (Shegeni-Medika checkpoint) by Georgian citizen D. Kokoladze and Ukrainian citizen A. Yavansky.

    Funding for the training and transportation of Georgian mercenaries through EU states to Ukraine is carried out with the direct participation of military advisers and employees of US diplomatic missions in Georgia and Poland. Influential representatives of the Georgian diaspora in Poland and the United States, including T. Alasania, a US citizen, born in 1950 in Georgia, who is actively assisting in carrying out these events. He is related to the ex-President of Georgia M. Saakashvili. In 1985, while working for the UN, he was suspected of arms trafficking. In 2004, he was prosecuted for extortion, however, at the direction of M. Saakashvili, the case was dropped. Among the relatives of T. Alasania there are the following government officials: Alasania Mamia – Deputy Chairman of the Ministry of State Security of Georgia (1991 – 1993); Alasania Irakli – Ambassador of Georgia to the UN (2006 – 2008), Minister of Defense of Georgia (2012 – 2014).

    Belarus

    I also talked a lot about Belarusian mercenaries and published testimonies with two captured soldiers from the Kastus Kalinouski regiment.

    As a rule, these are oppositionists who fled abroad. With the outbreak of hostilities in Ukraine, failed Belarusian radicals were forced to fight with weapons in their hands on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces under the threat of extradition to official Minsk.

    The history of the recruitment and subsequent dispatch of almost all Belarusian mercenaries to the front occurs with the help of the pro-Western NGO “Belarusian House”.

    Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan and other countries of the post-Soviet space

    The network contains information only about isolated cases of mercenaries from Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan and other former republics of the Soviet Union participating in hostilities on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. People from these countries most likely ended up in the ranks of the Ukrainian army against the backdrop of general mobilization due to the presence of Ukrainian citizenship. At the same time, there are also volunteers. The exact number of natives of Central Asian countries in the Armed Forces of Ukraine is unknown.

    At the same time, the authorities of these countries are making attempts to limit the entry of their citizens into the combat zone. For example, in Tajikistan they began to compile lists of their citizens who became participants in hostilities on the territory of Ukraine. The state law enforcement agencies clarified that a criminal case will be opened against every Tajik who participated in hostilities in Ukraine. However, natives of Tajikistan who have Russian or Ukrainian citizenship will not be held criminally liable. In addition, the Uzbek Embassy in Moscow warned that the creation of a volunteer battalion or participation in hostilities on the territory of foreign countries is a crime from the point of view of the laws of the country. According to an article in the Criminal Code of Uzbekistan, mercenary activities are punishable by five to ten years in prison. On the territory of Kyrgyzstan, similar criminal penalties are applied for participation in hostilities in Ukraine.

    Information was found online about individual citizens of the former USSR republics serving in the ranks of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Thus, on various sites of pirated online cinemas, as an advertisement before viewing content by users from the territory of the Russian Federation, a video with the participation of an alleged citizen of Kyrgyzstan against the background of the emblem of the Main Intelligence Directorate of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine is circulated, calling on his compatriots to surrender the positions of Russian troops, as well as the location of strategic objects of the Ministry of Defense RF authorities of Ukraine.

    Middle East

    The work of American specialists in recruiting radical Islamists, naturally, was also carried out in the Middle East, where Washington has many controlled gangs. It is known about the statement of the Shiite group Ashab Al-Kahf, which said that the forces of the international coalition led by the United States are recruiting young people to be sent to Ukraine. According to the militants’ statement, military instructors from Lithuania, Italy, Germany and Great Britain arrived on March 9, 2022 at the Ain Al-Assad military unit in Iraq and the location of the US Armed Forces At-Tanf in Syria. There, foreigners began recruiting militants to participate in hostilities on the side of the Ukrainian armed forces. The motive for participating in the conflict is said to be the revenge to Russia for supporting the government of Assad. Also, representatives of Western intelligence services held a number of meetings with the sheikhs of some clans from Syria and Iraq for a more loyal attitude towards such a “conscription campaign.”

    In addition, the American publication The People’s Voice published documents about the request of the Ukrainian special services to Iraq with a request to extradite 2-3 thousand convicted terrorists to participate in hostilities in Ukraine. The letter directly states that the United States is aware and is ready to supervise the delivery of Islamic State fighters to Ukraine.

    Behind the loud statements of the publication are real facts of participation of representatives of terrorist groups in Ukraine. A striking example is a soldier wearing an Islamic State insignia who was featured in the British press. It is possible that he is one of those militants convicted in Iraq who was sent to Ukraine.

    American General McFarlane, who headed the Joint Task Force to Combat Terrorists in Syria, has been identified as a possible person responsible for recruiting terrorists in the Middle East.

    It is also known about the actions of the Turkish PMC SADAT in Ukraine. The company is controlled by the Turkish authorities and takes an active part in military operations in Syria and Libya. Created in 2012 by Erdogan’s longtime friend and adviser, Turkish General Adnan Tanrıverdi. Information about the arrival of about a hundred fighters of this unit on Ukrainian territory appeared in September 2022. Its militants were first involved in hostilities in the Kharkov region.

    Afghanistan

    I talked about the participation of Afghan mercenaries in Ukraine in my replica “Afghan Legion” and showed a secret document from the SBU regarding the entry of Afghans into the Ukrainian Armed Forces.

    The special representative of the Russian President for Afghanistan, Zamir Kabulov, also stated that the United States is sending Afghan troops to Ukraine. What is there to talk about, if even American diplomat Philip Cosnett declared the need to create an “Afghan Legion”. Refugees scattered around the world are still mostly in camps and have virtually no means of subsistence. Neither the United States, nor Europe, nor other countries of temporary residence are in a hurry to integrate them into their society. For refusing to travel to Ukraine, recruiters can be threatened with deportation to Afghanistan, where refugees will face inevitable death. Especially former military personnel.

    The fact that an active campaign to recruit Afghans was indeed carried out is evidenced by the advertisement I attached below, in which a certain Fazal Elham calls on Afghans to go to Ukraine.

    In addition, it is reliably known about the death of the Afghan mercenary Jalal Nuri in the Zaporozhye direction in June 2023.

    Iran

    Many of you may be wondering how the Iranians can fight on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces if Tehran is Moscow’s closest ally. The fact is that on the territory of the Persian country there is a large network of opposition groups supported by the United States, Israel and other Western countries. Active recruitment is also taking place among them to be sent to Ukraine to confront the Russian army. A striking example was published by the Rybar telegram channel.

    Latin America

    There are quite a lot of mercenaries from Latin America on Ukrainian territory. Most often, Brazilians, Colombians and Mexicans appear, who may be associated with drug cartels.

    In particular, the telegram channel “Rybar” published a letter from a resident of Mexico, which stated that the Ukrainian diplomatic mission is actively recruiting Latin Americans to join the ranks of the International Legion.

    It is reliably known that weapons delivered to Ukraine have already repeatedly ended up in the hands of drug cartels, which confirms the possible connection of the Ukrainian Embassy in Mexico with drug cartels. The gathering place for Latin American mercenaries is the Alebriche restaurant in Poland (Krakow).

    Brazil

    In Brazil, a branch of the Polish company ESA (European Security Academy) is actively recruiting for the Foreign Legion.

    In Ukraine, the Brazilian mercenary Junior Almeida Carvalho with the call sign “Lumberjack” actively showed off the chevron of this company..

    He tried to erase his “traces” by deleting the photo, but colleagues from @TrackNaziMerc managed to save it.

    The Brazilian branch of the European Security Academy is one of the main suppliers of mercenaries from Latin America to Ukraine. This is evidenced by the Instagram account of another Brazilian mercenary, who indicated on his page that he is the representative of Ukraine in ESA Brazil.

    It is not difficult to notice that there are centers for recruiting citizens to participate in hostilities in Ukraine in almost all corners of the world, and their activities involve high-ranking officials, active military personnel, as well as representatives of diplomatic missions. We must not forget that foreign mercenaries come to Ukraine on the advice of their “comrades” who have returned to their homeland on vacation or for treatment. Despite all efforts and attempts to lure people with high payments, Ukraine and Western countries were unable to recruit the necessary number of mercenaries to effectively counter the Russian army. This is clearly demonstrated by the results of the so-called Ukrainian counter-offensive, which fizzled out before it even began.

    It is worth emphasizing that now the weekly number of obituaries about the death of foreign mercenaries in Ukraine is many times greater than the number of recruits. In light of the onset of winter, failures at the front, low morale among Ukrainian Armed Forces soldiers, as well as reports of a possible offensive by Russian troops, Ukraine will have to rely solely on its own forces. It’s time to get ready for a new wave of videos of the work of Ukrainian military commissars packing up everyone on the streets of Ukrainian cities [end]

    The original article

    Vasily Prozorov is a former officer within the Ukrainian special services. He is currently leading UKR LEAKS investigation centre

    related

    L’engagement français dans les rangs ukrainiens

  • [Совместное использование] ТУРАГЕНТСТВО «СМЕРТЬ». КТО ВЫДАЕТ БИЛЕТ В ОДИН КОНЕЦ ИНОСТРАННЫМ НАЕМНИКАМ – Центр расследований Василия Прозорова, UKR LEAKS

    С начала Специальной военной операции в феврале 2022 г. тема участия иностранных наемников в конфликте на Украине является одной из самых обсуждаемых. Я хочу напомнить, что иностранцы начали принимать участие в боевых действиях на Украине еще задолго до начала СВО. Например, я публиковал реплику «Американцы на Донбассе», в которой рассказывал о преступлениях против мирного населения тогда еще Украины таких наемников как Крейг Лэнг, Квинн Дэвид Рикерт, Санти Эмилио Пиртл, Алекс Цвифельхофер и других. В сети легко найти истории и многих иных наемников, которые сами рассказывают о службе на стороне ВСУ и даже пишут мемуары. А когда был создан «Грузинский Легион»? Правильно. Задолго до СВО. Поэтому тема наемников не является новой в контексте украинского конфликта. Но остается открытым вопрос: Кто, где и как их вербует? На этот вопрос я и постараюсь ответить в данном материале.

    Для более полного понимания вопроса я обратился к людям, которые на этом «съели собаку» – одному из основателей телеграм канала @TrackNaziMerc, имя которого я не могу раскрыть из-за соображений безопасности, команде телеграм канала @ForeignCombatants, а также бывшему инспектору французской полиции, офицеру разведки Николя Чинкуини.

    Проведенный мной анализ информации подтверждает выводы авторов канала. Хочу сразу подчеркнуть, что заявления украинских лидеров о нескольких десятках тысяч иностранцев, уже воюющих на стороне ВСУ и таком же количестве «желающих», являются ложью. Громкие высказывания сделаны исключительного для того, чтобы показать, что якобы весь мир с Украиной и против России. Чего только стоит новость об «Армянском легионе» в составе ВСУ?

    В рядах ВСУ действительно присутствуют армяне. Но их количество не соответствует такому понятию как «Легион». По моей оценке, их общее количество не превышает сто человек. В основном это боевики прозападной русофобской партии «Сасна црер», кочующие между Украиной и Арменией.

    Кроме того, о реальном количестве иностранных наемников в рядах ВСУ неоднократно сообщало МО РФ, и многие тз них уже стали «200-ми» и «300-ми». Не стоит забывать, что большая часть сбежала к себе на родину, увидев суровую реальность.

    Кто и зачем едет воевать на стороне ВСУ?

    Я разделяю этих лиц на три категории.

    1. Это идейные неонацисты, ярые русофобы, футбольные ультрас, завербованные через сети неонацистских сообществ.
    2. Лица, желающие заработать большие деньги на войне.
    3. Действующие военнослужащие иностранных армий, осуществляющие подготовку украинских военнослужащих, а также непосредственно участвующие в планировании и проведении операций.

    Если доказательства присутствия на Украине лиц из первой и второй категорий очевидны, то факт участия действующих военнослужащих тщательно скрывается. Я поднимал этот вопрос в своем видео-интервью с семьей Касерта, в котором мы обсуждали загадочные смерти американских военнослужащих. Напомню, что Тери и Патрик Касерта являются инициаторами создания закона «Брендона», согласно которому все военнослужащие армии США имеют право получать психологическую помощь в любое время. А вызвана такая необходимость регулярными случаями суицида, подробности которых тщательно скрываются от родственников военнослужащих.

    Более того, о действующих военнослужащих иностранных армий я также спросил и экспертов телеграм-канала @foreigncombatants:

    “Все сотрудники иностранных силовых структур, которые направляются на Украину, оформляются в отпуск (как правило, трёхмесячный), но их не так много. В целом, можно сказать, что того количества наёмников, прибывших через ЧВК или бывших военных, на данный момент на западе считают достаточным и не видят необходимости отправлять кадровых сотрудников. Для консультирования офицерского состава и инструктажа хорошо показала себя уже сложившаяся схема по созданию НКО.

    Кроме того, не стоит недооценивать различные так называемые волонтёрские НКО, которые занимаются снабжением и материальным обеспечением ВСУ. В них вовлечено огромное количество иностранцев. Это позволяет серьёзно разгрузить затраты на ведение войны и переложить на них функции логистики, снабжения, подвоза провизии, матобеспечения, доставки дронов и снаряжения, используя инструменты микромаркетинга. Странам НАТО удалось вовлечь своих граждан в финансирование этой кровавой машины сборами на «помощь» Украине через множественные НКО, которые заставляют эту машину работать бесперебойно и уносить новые жизни. Нам известны офицеры чешской армии, которые курируют поставки экипировки на Украину, и хотя де-юре в боевых действиях они не участвуют, но фактически они являются полноценными участниками военных действий.”

    Николя Чинкуини любезно ответил на мои вопросы и также подтвердил, факт участия действующих военных на Украине:

    «Из надежных источников я получил подтверждение того, что действующим французским солдатам предлагают ложные отставки для участия в Украине, с гарантией восстановления в должности в конце, а до этого – зарплату, от которой трудно отказаться».

    Не отрицают наличие на Украине действующих военнослужащих иностранных армий и представители канала @TrackNaziMerc. Об этом свидетельствуют следующие факты:

    – Команде удалось идентифицировать нескольких кинологов из Соединенных Штатов, занимающихся разминированием, которые находятся в официальных командировках. Мы не размещали их данные на канале, потому что считаем их не наемниками, а гуманитарным персоналом.

    – В списках людей, награжденных украинскими медалями, есть представители официальных правоохранительных органов стран Балтии.

    – От украинского источника, участвующего в боях на северном направлении, нам известно о присутствии польских кадровых военнослужащих, дислоцированных в Черниговской области. Но это подразделения боевого управления и материально-технического обеспечения польских механизированных дивизий.

    – Некоторые из смертей комбатантов имеют странную предысторию, выводы из прочтения которой могут навести на мысль, что они находились на действительной службе.

    – Дэниел Свифт, убитый 15 января 2023 года в Бахмуте, де-факто находился на действительной военной службе, хотя и числился дезертиром. Насколько известно, американская сторона не требовала его экстрадиции, хотя Свифт воевал в одном из элитных подразделений Легиона, напрямую связанного с 73 морским центром специальных операций, военнослужащие которого проходят строжайшие проверки.

    Выводы команды телеграм-канала @foreigncombatants также полностью совпадают с ранее предоставленной схемой:

    Вербовка наёмников происходит по разным каналам в зависимости от стран. Профессионалы с боевым опытом в горячих точках из США и Великобритании в основном попадают на Украину через контакты с наёмниками, имеющими связи с западными ЧВК или воевавшими на стороне курдов (YPG) в Ираке и Сирии. Как правило, затем они формируют отдельные подразделения на Украине и могут иметь финансирование от «частных спонсоров». Есть вербовщики во французском иностранном легионе и в инженерно-десантном полку в Монтобане. Французы без боевого опыта на Украину попадают из праворадикальных движений, которые имеют связи с «Азовом» или «Правым сектором». Латиноамериканцы вербуются через военный атташат посольства Украины. Наёмники приходят из полиции и силовых структур, увольняясь ради высокой по местным меркам зарплаты. Поляки и скандинавы попадают на Украину через контакты в своих вооружённых силах, где они служили ранее.

    В подтверждение приведенной схемы вербовочной сети Украины предлагаю изучить известные факты и пути вступления иностранных наемников в подразделения Украины. Забегая вперед, хочу подчеркнуть, что огромную роль в вербовке наемников играют Соединенные Штаты, которые подталкивают людей вступать в вооруженный конфликт против России, используя как финансовые, идеологические, так и насильственные методы воздействия.

    США

    Гибель американских морпехов на Украине стала практически еженедельным событием.Не удивительно. Одно из первых объявлений о наборе наемников было опубликовано именно на американском сайте Silent Professionals. Объявление активно практически с самого начала СВО и в нем не двусмысленно указано, что ведется набор людей для участия в боевых действиях на Украине.

    Кроме того, в СМИ и Интернете регулярно проходили новости о прибытии на Украину сотрудников целого ряда частных военных компаний. Например:

    • Kellogg, Brown and Root
    • Amentum (ранее DynCorp),
    • Blackwater (другие названия – Xe Services/ Academi/ Constellis
    • Greystone
    • Northbridge Services Group
    • Mozart

    Все эти ЧВК (за исключением «Моцарт», прекратившим свое существование так и не сумев ничего противопоставить ЧВК «Вагнер») имеют тесные связи с правительством США, состоят из бывших военных и имеют огромные возможности по набору личного состава не только у себя в стране, но и за рубежом. Многие американские наемники попали на Украину именно через вербовщиков этих ЧВК. Ни для кого, ни секрет, что ЧВК выполняют государственные задачи США, вооружаются и финансируются правительством. Это удобные инструменты ведения войны против России якобы негосударственными структурами.

    Франция

    О французских наемниках на Украине в эксклюзивном интервью мне рассказал Николя Чинкуини. Николя – бывший французский чиновник, инспектор полиции с 1989 года, офицер судебной полиции, затем офицер разведки. Его уволили в 2020 году за то, что он публично протестовал на улице, в суде и в прессе против незаконного насилия, совершенного в отношении «Желтых жилетов». Он также подчеркивает роль США в разжигании конфликта на Украине:

    «Я рассматриваю конфликт на Донбассе и Украине как новую иллюстрацию прокси-войн, которые Западный блок ведет против России, Китая и всех тех, кто осмелится выступить против его гегемонии. Я начал по-настоящему интересоваться этой проблемой в 2014 году, так как не понимал поддержки Францией исламистского восстания в Сирии. Моя деятельность в блоге активизировалась во время блокады Мариуполя. Ряд улик заставили меня предположить, что рядом с украинским гарнизоном там находились действующие французские госслужащие. Чтобы подтвердить эту теорию, я начал собирать информацию о действующих на Украине французских наемниках. Я понял, что многие из них были сторонниками идей неонацизма, которых французская пресса пыталась обелить и превратить в героев. По моему мнению, погибший француз Тибо Ригон, посмертно награжденный Зеленским, мог являться действующим госслужащим, так как вокруг его смерти очень много загадочных обстоятельств, и я стараюсь прояснить все детали.

    Примечательно, что из Франции действительно прибыло большое количество наемников с неонацистскими взглядами и работа по их привлечению на Украину активно продолжается до сих пор. Так, в октябре 2023 года на французском языке появился сайт неонацистского «Азова», основной задачей которого является поиск радикалов для вступления в подразделение.

    Великобритания

    Информации о деятельности британских организаций по вербовке боевиков на Украину в открытом доступе немного. Основная масса наемников прибывает путем подписания контракта с Министерством обороны Украины и вступления в Интернациональный легион. Тем не менее, известно об организации «Аккадиан Интернэшнл», члены которой были замечены на Украине, неоднократно проводили конференции в Польше и Великобритании, призывая вступать в конфликт на стороне киевского режима.

    Польша

    @TrackNaziMerc:

    Все наемники, прибывающие на Украину, попадают в страну через Польшу.

    Путь наемника часто включает в себя следующие этапы:

    Варшава => Львов/Дрогобыч => Ровно, где расположена воинская часть А7420 и учебный полигон.

    Классический маршрут для боевиков с Латинской Америки также проходит через Польшу:

    Столичный международный аэропорт => Транзитный аэропорт в Объединенных Арабских Эмиратах/Египте/Бахрейне => Варшава => Тернопольский международный аэропорт, где непосредственно подписывается контракт и укомплектовывается подразделение => Передовое подразделение.

    Польских наемников на Украине огромное количество. Удалось выяснить, что многие из них прошли обучение в центре ESA (European Security Academy).

    Штаб-квартира ESA расположена в районе польского города Вроцлав и оказывает обучающие услуги военным и сотрудникам правоохранительных органов. ESA уже фигурировала в центре громкого скандала, связанного с Украиной. Расследователи группы «Беллингкэт» доказали, что на ее тренировочной базе прошли обучение большое количество украинских нацистов. Инструкторов не смущали ни татуировки со свастикой, ни характерные приветствия.

    Данный центр располагал (и скорее всего до сих пор имеет) обширную сеть филиалов во всех регионах мира, о чем свидетельствуют аккаунты в Инстаграм. Можно найти Скандинавию, Румынию, Болгарию, Австрию, Южную Америку, и другие аккаунты филиалов компании.

    Представители компании удалили с официального сайта раздел с своими зарубежными представительствами, но их функционирование не остановлено. Они занимаются поиском и тренировкой наемников в зонах своей ответственности.

    Это легко доказать изучив социальные сети наемников – в интернете легко найти фотографии боевиков, воюющих на Украине с шевроном ESA. В качестве доказательства прикладываю фото португальца, прибывшего на Украину через польский филиал ESA.

    Деятельность центра ESA тесно связана и с Испанией.

    Испания

    Испания также попала в центр крупного скандала, связанного с вербовкой наемников для участия в боевых действиях на Украине. Как стало известно компания GOA Tactical за 700 евро проводит специализированную подготовку для наемников и находится в тесном контакте с Министерством обороны Украины.

    Неравнодушные жители Испании подали иск в суд на данную компанию с требованием привлечь ее руководителя к ответственности, так как наемничество в стране запрещено.

    Но компания обладает весьма крупными связями с Министерством обороны страны, а также непосредственно с НАТО. Огромное влияние на GOA Tactical оказывает Eва Альварез Мансано (Eva Álvarez del Manzano) – дочь Бернардо Альвареза Мансано (Bernardo Alvarez del Manzano), покойного генерал-лейтенанта Сухопутной армии, бывшего начальника оперативного командования штаба обороны Испании.

    Непосредственно руководителем GOA Tactical является Франциско Галван, позывной («Сиску» Siscu).

    Как заявлял Галван,Eва Мансано является связующим звеном между его компанией, армией Испании и НАТО. Любопытен тот факт, что в различных подкастах Мансано упоминается как эксперт в области разведки, проведения специальных операций, шпионажа.

    Возвращаясь к GOA Tactical, то компания имеет филиалы в Израиле, Перу и Польше. В Польше они тесно взаимодействуют с той самой ESA. Удалось выяснить, что и другие испанские компании тесно сотрудничают с ESA.

    Например, испанская компания «Geitsinternational» на своем постере указала ESA в качестве партнера, а последние несколько курсов по обучению прошли именно на территории Польши.

    Это не единственная компания, занимающаяся обучением военнослужащих и полицейских, которая близко взаимодействует с польским ESA. Например, «Astespana», расположенная в Мадриде, также активно взаимодействует с польской ESA и проводит на ее тренировочной базе боевое обучение.

    Грузия

    На территории Грузии при финансовой поддержке посольства США осуществляются мероприятия по подготовке и отправке в зону боевых действий на Украине наемников как из числа грузинских граждан, так и подданных других государств. С этой целью в Грузии организована работа координационного штаба (г. Тбилиси), созданного на базе неправительственной организации «Свободная зона». В состав организации входят представители молодежного крыла оппозиционной политической партии «Единое национальное движение»: Гагнидзе Бондо, Гигаури Зураб, Кеинашвили Демур, Кимадзе Давид, Кумсишвили Гурам, Куркумули Лола (жен.), Мамулашвили Вахтанг, Поцхверашвили Татия (жен.), Рачвешвили Гурам, Сирадзе Анна (жен.), Ткешелашвили Ираклий, Хурцилава Борис, Чохели Шмаги.

    После проведения боевого слаживания наемников формируются группы для поэтапной отправки на территорию Польши. Переброска осуществляется чартерными рейсами, а также самолетами военно-транспортной авиации США из международного аэропорта Новоалексеевка (г. Тбилиси, Грузия) до международного аэропорта им. Ф.Шопена (г. Варшава, Польша). Встречу прибывших, их сопровождение до польско-украинской границы (пункт пропуска «Шегени-Медика») осуществляют гражданин Грузии Д.Коколадзе и гражданин Украины А.Яванський.

    Финансирование подготовки и переправки грузинских наемников через государства ЕС на Украину осуществляется при непосредственном участии военных советников и сотрудников дипломатических представительств США в Грузии и Польше. Активное содействие в проведении указанных мероприятий оказывают влиятельные представители грузинской диаспоры в Польше и США, среди которых Т.Аласания – гражданин США, родился в 1950 году в Грузии. Состоит в родственных связях с экс-президентом Грузии М.Саакашвили. В 1985 году, работая в структуре ООН, подозревался в торговле оружием. В 2004 году привлекался к уголовной ответственности за вымогательство, однако, по указанию М.Саакашвили, дело было прекращено. В числе родственников Т.Аласания имеются следующие государственные деятели: Аласания Мамия – заместитель председателя министерства государственной безопасности Грузии (1991 – 1993 гг.); Аласания Ираклий – посол Грузии при ООН (2006 – 2008 гг.), министр обороны Грузии (2012 – 2014 гг.).

    Беларусь

    Про белорусских наемников я также рассказывал очень много и публиковал показания с двумя пленными бойцами из полка «Кастуся Калиновского».

    Как правило, это сбежавшие заграницу оппозиционеры.С началом боевых действий на Украине несостоявшихся белорусских радикалов заставили с оружием в руках воевать на стороне ВСУ под угрозой выдачи официальному Минску.

    История вербовки и дальнейшей отправки практически всех белорусских наемников на фронт происходит при помощи прозападной НПО «Белорусский дом».

    Таджикистан, Киргизия, Узбекистан, Казахстана и другие страны постсоветского пространства

    В сети имеются сведения лишь о единичных случаях участия в боевых действиях на стороне ВСУ наемников из Таджикистана, Киргизии, Узбекистана, Казахстана и других бывших республик Советского Союза. Выходцы из данных стран скорее всего попали в ряды украинской армии на фоне всеобщей мобилизации ввиду наличия украинского гражданства. В то же время есть и добровольцы. Точное количество уроженцев стран Центральной Азии в составе ВСУ неизвестно.

    При этом, власти этих стран предпринимают попытки ограничить попадание своих граждан в зону боевых действий. Например, в Таджикистане начали составлять списки своих граждан, которые стали участниками боевых действий на территории Украины. В силовых ведомствах государства уточнили, что в отношении каждого таджика, участвовавшего в боевых действиях на Украине, будет возбуждено уголовное дело. Однако уроженцы Таджикистана, имеющие гражданство РФ или Украины, к уголовной ответственности привлекаться не будут. Кроме того, посольство Узбекистана в Москве предупреждало о том, что создание добровольческого батальона или участие в боевых действиях на территории иностранных государств является преступлением с точки зрения законов страны. По статье уголовного кодекса Узбекистана за наемничество грозит от пяти до десяти лет тюрьмы. На территории Киргизии за участие в боевых действиях на Украине применяется аналогичное уголовное наказание.

    В сети были обнаружены сведения об отдельных гражданах бывших республик СССР, проходящих службу в рядах ВСУ. Так, на различных площадках пиратских онлайн-кинотеатров в качестве рекламы перед просмотром контента пользователями с территории Российской Федерации «гуляет» видеоролик с участием якобы гражданина Киргизии на фоне эмблемы ГУР МО Украины, призывающего своих соотечественников сдавать позиции российских войск, а также расположение стратегических объектов МО РФ властям Украины.

    Ближний Восток

    Работа американских специалистов по набору радикальных исламистов, естественно, проводилась и на Ближнем Востоке, где у Вашингтона много подконтрольных бандформирований.Известно о заявлении шиитской группировки «Асхаб Аль-Кахф», в котором говорилось, что силы международной коалиции во главе с США вербуют молодых людей для отправки на Украину. Согласно заявлению боевиков, военные инструкторы из Литвы, Италии, Германии и Великобритании 9 марта 2022 года прибыли в воинскую часть «Айн Аль-Асад» в Ираке и расположение ВС США «Ат-Танф» в Сирии. Там иностранцы занялись вербовкой боевиков для участия в боевых действиях на стороне вооруженных сил Украины. В качестве мотива для участия в конфликте наемникам называют месть России за поддержку правительства Б.Асада. Также представители западных спецслужб провели ряд встреч с шейхами некоторых кланов из Сирии и Ирака для более лояльного отношения к такой «призывной кампании».

    Кроме того, американское издание The People’s Voice опубликовало документы о запросе украинских спецслужб к Ираку с просьбой выдать 2-3 тысяч осужденных террористов для участия в боевых действиях на Украине. В письме прямо говорится, что США в курсе и готовы курировать доставку боевиков ИГ* на Украину.

    За громкими заявлениями издания стоят реальные факты участия на Украине представителей террористических группировок. Ярким примером является засветившийся в объективе британской прессы военнослужащий с шевроном Исламского Государства. Не исключаю, что он является одним из тех самых осужденных в Ираке боевиков, отправленным на Украину.

    В качестве возможного лица, ответственного за вербовку террористов на Ближнем Востоке, указан американский генерал МакФарлейн, возглавлявший Объединенную оперативную группу по борьбе с террористами в Сирии.

    Известно и о действиях на Украине турецкой ЧВК SADAT. Компания подконтрольна турецким властям и принимает активное участие в военных действиях в Сирии и Ливии. Создана в 2012 году давним другом и советником Эрдогана, турецким генералом Аднаном Танрыверди. Информация о прибытии около сотни бойцов данного подразделения на украинскую территорию появилась в сентябре 2022 года. Ее боевики впервые были задействованы в боевых действиях в Харьковской области.

    Афганистан

    Об участии афганских наемников на Украине я рассказывал в своей реплике «Афганский Легион» и демонстрировал секретный документ СБУ относительно вступления афганцев в ВС Украины.

    О том, что США отправляют на Украину афганских военных, заявлял и спецпредставитель президента РФ по Афганистану Замир Кабулов. О чем говорить, если даже американский дипломат Филипп Коснетт заявлял

    о необходимости создания «Афганского легиона». Разбросанные по всему миру беженцы до сих пор находятся по большей части в лагерях и практически не имеют средств к существованию. Ни США, ни Европа, ни другие страны временного пребывания не спешат интегрировать их в свое общество. За отказ от поездки на Украину вербовщики могут пригрозить депортацией в Афганистан, где беженцев ждет неминуемая смерть. В особенности, бывших военнослужащих.

    О том, что активная компания по вербовке афганцев действительно проводилась, свидетельствует и приложенное мною ниже объявление, в котором некий Фазал Элхам призывает афганцев отправиться на Украину.

    Кроме того, достоверно известно о гибели афганского наемника Джалала Нури на запорожском направлении в июне 2023 года.

    Иран

    Многие из Вас могут задаться вопросом, как иранцы могут воевать на стороне ВСУ, если Тегеран является ближайшим союзником Москвы. Дело в том, что на территории персидской страны действует большая сеть оппозиционных формирований, поддерживаемых США, Израилем и другими странами Запада. Среди них также проходит активная вербовка для отправки на Украину для противостояния российской армии. Яркий пример публиковал телеграм-канал «Рыбарь».

    Латинская Америка

    Наемников из Латинской Америки на территории Украины достаточно много. Чаще всего фигурируют бразильцы, колумбийцы и мексиканцы, которые могут быть связаны с наркокартелями.

    В частности, телеграм канал «Рыбарь» публиковал письмо жителя Мексики, в котором говорилось о том, что дипмиссия Украины активно занимается вербовкой латиноамериканцев для вступления в ряды «Интернационального легиона».

    Достоверно известно, что поставленное на Украину оружие уже неоднократно светилось в руках наркокартелей, что подтверждает возможную связь посольства Украины в Мексике с наркокартелями. Место сбора латиноамериканских наемников – ресторан «Alebriche» в Польше (г. Краков).

    Бразилия

    В Бразилии активной вербовкой в «Иностранный легион» занимается филиал польской компании ESA (European Security Academy).

    На Украине с шевроном данной фирмы активно красовался бразильский наемник Джулио Альваро Карвальо с позывным «Лесоруб» (Lumberjack).

    Он попытался стереть «следы», удалив фотографию, но коллеги из @TrackNaziMerc успели ее сохранить.

    Бразильский филиал European Security Academy один из главных поставщиков наемников из Латинской Америки на Украину. Об этом свидетельствует и инстаграм аккаунт другого бразильского наемника, который указал у себя на странице, что является представителем Украины в ESA Brazil.

    Не трудно заметить, что центры вербовки граждан для участия в боевых действиях на Украине имеются практически во всех уголках мира, а в их деятельность вовлечены высокопоставленные чиновники, действующие военные, а также представители дипломатических миссий. Нельзя забывать, что иностранные наемники приезжают на Украину и по совету своих «товарищей», вернувшихся к себе на Родину в отпуск или на лечение. Несмотря на все усилия и попытки заманить людей высокими выплатами, Украина и страны Запада не смогли набрать необходимое количество наемников для эффективного противодействия российской армии. Это наглядно демонстрируют результаты так называемого украинского контрнаступления, которое захлебнулось, не успев начаться.

    Стоит подчеркнуть, что теперь еженедельное количество некрологов о гибели иностранных наёмников на Украине кратно превышает количество новобранцев. В свете наступления зимы, неудач на фронте, низкого МПС среди солдат ВСУ, а также сообщениях о возможном наступлении российских войск, Украине придется рассчитывать исключительно на свои силы. Стоит приготовиться к новой волне видеороликов работы украинских военкомов, пакующих всех подряд на улицах украинских городов [конец]

    Оригинальная статья

    соответствующая статья

    L’engagement français dans les rangs ukrainiens

  • [Sharing] Nazigate – Max Blumenthal & Aaron Mate, The Grayzone

    Max Blumenthal and Aaron Mate cover the international scandal that unfolded when the Liberal Party of Canada’s Justin Trudeau honored a Ukrainian Nazi veteran of the Waffen-SS, and the dark history it forced to the surface

    [end]

    Related pieces

    Babi Yar, September 29, 1941

    Nazism in Ukraine

    its roots before WW2, its collaboration with Nazi Germany, its legacy in modern Ukraine, how NATO has continually supported Nazism in Ukraine

    Chrystia Freeland’s Nazi Problem

    by Scott Ritter

    The footprint of the Ukrainian Nazism in the West

    interactions between Ukrainian Nazi organizations and Western supremacist militants

  • [Sharing] Interview with Boneface – US neo Nazi, ex member of Azov battalion

    November 12, 2022, by Truthseeker77 & Fearless John

    The first time I learned about Kent McLellan “Boneface” was through the investigation of Vasily Prozorov a former employee of the Ukrainian Security Services now uncovering the hidden truths of Ukraine on his channel UKRLEAKS [on Telegram].

    Then Boneface himself contacted my colleague Truthseeker77 wanting to challenge some of the reports I have made on my channel about him. We decided to ask Boneface for an interview, we would laid the questions together, and Truthseeker77 would conduct all the “interrogatory” to the US Neo Nazi.

    The results of this work not only produced the written interview with Mclellan about his time in Ukraine but also videos and information about his past troubles with the American authorities and a insight to the mindset of a US white supremacist thanks to the excellent job of my colleague.

    Kent Ryan McLellan, April 22, 1990, St. Cloud (Florida). Son of the front man of neo Nazi rock band Brutal Attack, in high school, he already became a member of the racist organization “The American Front”. He was first arrested at the age of 18 in September 2008 for racist graffiti. In 2010, he served time for vandalism and beating immigrants. In May 2012, the FBI detained McLellan and his accomplices from the “American Front” for preparing a terrorist act against national minorities in Florida.

    He joined the ranks of the “Ukrainian Volunteer Corps of the Right Sector” (DUK RS) in 2014 for a number of months going back to the US to keep running Misanthropic Division and its recruitment campaign for Ukraine. In January 2022, returned to Ukraine and joined Azov Battalion.

    When did you heard about Ukraine first?

    Ukraine as political situation; I’ve always known it existed as a nation. That’s clear. As far as being a skinhead/white nationalist goes, the videos from Tesak, in which he had a huge following in Ukraine, not just Russia. 

    What organizations did you contact and how?

    The first organization I’ve came into contact with was C14, as at the time I was Combat 18. Which is it’s Western equivalent. 

    I kept contact with them predominantly with vk.com [VKontakte, Russian social networking service], it was difficult and still is difficult to maintain a page on most social media. My original vk.com account was vk.com/kenthate [blocked for violation of VK terms of service]. 

    I was publishing information in which someone had essentially said the ISIS movement and the national-socialists are the same. So I published a thesis about the Islamic State and their hatred for nationalism, using one of their propaganda videos. 

    After C14 shared it, Francisco got in contact with me. He was Misanthropic Division.

    From there I didn’t immediately joined, but I respected a lot of their publishing. We had a brief fallout in 2012 after the FBI arrested me for helping run a training camp here in Florida.

    I remember the Kiev protests were just starting. A lot of the guys from C14 and at the time what became Right Sector, (Svoboda, Blue Boys, C14, Blood and Honor, Slavic Union), we’re attending this. It wasn’t long before things got crazy into it. People we’re leaving the protest sites and simply vanishing. It wasn’t long before Vodafone started getting jammed up. So I formed a squad of guys to essentially get around the DNS, and create a patch in network so people could coordinate with one another

    How did you travel there? 

    I earned an OSCP [hacking] certification with Offensive Security, got a passport. I got there in 2014. I got a 9-day visa, ticket there and back, with no real meaning of actually returning. That was the first time. 

    By the time I went I was already running Misanthropic Division in the United States.

    How was the relation of the general public with the ultras, how much open was the fascist dominance compared with the reports of the Western media, how many ultras where there roughly?

    The public were the ultras, as crazy as it sounds. Everyone was patriotic. Back then, everyone knew what was happening. BBC reported, Americans reported it. 

    As far as ultra groups went, there wasn’t that many in number of actual organizations. Everyone was pretty much C14 and the title “Pravyi sektor [Right Sector] absorbed everything else. 

    They hosted events nearly daily in every oblast that wasn’t seeing war.

    How many people from foreign countries were there?

    Foreign members included a lot from Georgia, Latvia, America, Finland, a lot of skinheads. 

    In case the world wonders what happened to all the real skinheads. They all went to Ukraine.

    What groups in the US support them? 

    Ukraine doesn’t work very closely anymore with the Americans. There is a American DUK, even Misanthropic Division had its own goals here vs what they had going on there. Ukraine has their shit together. 

    Just look at Florida, It’s all literal trash. With no clear aims as a movement, no goals and outside of 2014, real militants failed to exist as a collective in the White Power world. 

    In fact, most militias existing in the United States today are a result of Atom Waffen [Atom Waffen Division, international Nazi group based in the US], and the Misanthropic Division [international Nazi organization based in Ukraine].

    What you did while in Ukraine, what people and from where you met there?

    I wasn’t by far the first person to go to Ukraine. We sent several others, we kept having hiccups in all this. Dalton; Lane, are noted individuals. We did this entirely on our own, out of our pockets, etc. 

    I never knew the circumstances of Lane, and what he was running from. But it wasn’t until they both got there and decided to live in Ukraine, that we had a stable reliable enough route for Americans to reach Ukraine and not be stranded at air ports.

    At this point I didn’t really know what to think, the training regiment wasn’t anything like you see with Americans. 

    It wasn’t dehumanizing. A lot of what would become Azov spoke English and it was mandatory to study Russian.  

    Right Sector controlled nearly everything as far as the militant nationalists went.

    How did fellow Azov members accepted you? 

    They weren’t Azov yet, but yeah they took me well. Ukrainians didn’t really, because of the language barrier. They must’ve thought I was retarded. 

    This time around I was first placed with the 227th recon, which was a slap in the face for me. It wasn’t until after the war and I made it rightfully back into the second battalion, with people I knew.

    How was your deployment time in Mariupol with Azov Battalion?

    During the first run of Mariupol when the awkward stand off and fear-thick atmosphere finally wore off, there was a lot of shooting at absolute nothing, and a lot of soldiers not knowing what to do. Myself included at that.

    The citizens of Mariupol itself were divided heavily on pro Ukraine and a pro Russian stance. 

    There were occasional Russian soldiers in the mix of things, this can be attested to a dozen or so pro Russian separatist prisoners

    Did the U.S. government entice you or help you in any way?

    As far as the government goes. During the Maidan coup, I got caught teaching the UKR guys DNS poisoning (placing false information in a DNS resolver cache on internet). 

    They wanted to sit in and help. They didn’t want names or anything, but they wanted to monitor the situation. Without this backing I would’ve been charged with violation of American neutrality act. Which is a law written in 1784.

    Have you witnessed war crimes committed by any Ukrainian battalions? 

    Before I was even deployed I remember hearing about a bunch of red anarchists killed in Odessa. 

    Tornado [Ukrainian Nazi battalion] was by far the most horrifying thing I’ve ever seen or dealt with in my life. I’m in that botched crucifying video I’m not even wearing a mask. 

    I remember being deployed from Kiev to Mariupol. The dress uniform of what became Azov, was not by any means tactical. We were told to expect the presence of GRU [Russian military intelligence] as-well as militia formed by leftists in Donbass.

    I’ve seen some shit with the first go around in Ukraine. I can only really sum up Mariupol with, ” It’s war”. This is were a lot of heinous shit started.

    Interrogation happens. I had a job interrogating a lot. The treatment of such people is the same with the Russians I would guess. 

    I remember being asked to photograph Aidar [Ukrainian Nazi battalion] and Tornado members posing with the corpses of a lynched pregnant woman and a man they said was her husband. 

    The video can be found it’s titled “Kikes get the rope” but it literally has nothing to do with Jewish people. I wouldn’t have supported an action like that anyway. 

    Tornado was a weird bunch of guys. Some of them were of Chechen decent and that’s were I learned the history of Dagestan and the insanity that happened in Grozny.

    What is the weapon of your choice? 

    I was a gunner for the most part. PKM [light machine gun], Kalashnikov. 

    Why- being a gunner requires a knowledge of all aspects. It’s not simply firing blindly. 

    You have to understand infantry, you have to understand armor. 

    You have to work with other gunners and be able to be the eyes for literally everyone and while being the most obvious target in the field.  

    Without gunners, armored columns are useless.

    Areas outside of a chain, that are not visible, you have to reach. You have to be able to trap a line of men and manipulate their actions into doing what you want them to do. 

    This also comes with infantry tactics, and being able to work the mechanics of a PKM, which isn’t a easy weapon. 

    Especially when the felt tip tools for some reason keep disappearing from the weapon.

    Were you paid to do this? And by whom? Did you get a salary? 

    I was never paid, I in fact ruined myself economically by going to Ukraine. I couldn’t imagine doing that for any value.

    I wasn’t paid. No. 

    During the time we were in talks with the CIA and the Pentagon, (Mariupol). It is true the Pentagon conducted intelligence operations during the war there.

    Why did you return to the U.S.? 

    I didn’t intend too. I was shipped back on a order after some SBU [Ukrainian State security agency, counter-intelligence] guys got caught cooperating with Russians, they planned on apparently killing me in the SBU hospital in Kiev.

    Are Russian and DNR [Donetsk People’s Republic] troops worthy opponents?

    Russia in comparison to the DPR:

    The DPR we’re at first the best soldiers in the field this time go around, as far as Russian allies go. Their mortar teams were highly accurate and often worked with infantry, they moved like clock work. They generally had no fear for any actions they carried out. 

    The first waves of Russian soldiers I nearly felt bad for. The air force, is obviously a very skilled endeavor on the Russian team. 

    They naval infantry teams used on Mariupol we’re lacking in the ability to adapt. This is only the naval infantrymen, I’ve had quite the job during the first few weeks in Mariupol as interrogating prisoners, I had these videos on my YouTube channel. There was quite a lot of them who didn’t want to fight, and who claim they weren’t their to fight. 

    Then the third guard Spetznaz [Russian special forces] came. Which was a entirely different story. 

    The worst of all things that undermined Russian advances, was the constant bombarding of Mariupol, while they were also trying to make advances. To understand this, you’ll have to understand how explosives work. 

    It’s not the blast that kills you, it’s the energy released from these things. It’s like going into a fully conscious seizure, everything gets covered in this dust that turns everything a faded yellow.  You can literally taste it. It’s chemical as fuck. 

    Whereas the Azov Regiment, and The DPR both were native to Mariupol and the Donetsk oblast, in theory. The Russian infantry would often become lost on hostile land.  

    The DPR and LPR [Lugansk People’s Republic] guys seemed to be the ones who knew how to navigate through Mariupol a lot better. They were fearsome. The second battalion (Azov) and them (Sparta [pro-Russia battalion from Donetsk]) have a historic feud, as you know. 

    It’s never easy to move or maintain a level of total competency while being shot at, or maintaining heavy stresses. They did. You have got to respect them off the field

    Are you in direct contact with your old comrades there?

    I talk to a number of them daily.

    Frostovik had most of my footage along as his own. David Ruslan as well. That guy’s a fucking beast. I was with him when he lost his leg. The attack killed another Azov member.

    Will you go back to fight?

    I’m not entirely sure of going back. Depends on my health. I had heavy metal poisoning, still ongoing through chelation therapy from the whole ordeal.  

    I support Azov, to the fullest. But I don’t support NATO, or the EU, but ultimately I feel as if NATO gets involved there won’t be anything, as far as a nationalist goes, worth or left fighting for.

    How do you see the conflict from a geopolitical perspective?

    American meddling in Ukraine has caused the Russian invasion.

    Ukraine war can be simply placed by two prospectives, the nationalist war, and Zelenski’s war. 

    Zelenski is the powers which be, and the nationalists are the obvious. 

    It needs to be noted that; 

    The Ukrainian Government has tried to bench Azov, and the DUK on three different occasions. Once their usefulness for the NATO regime ran out.  

    The head of the Right Sector even said before he was assassinated in Kiev: “We’re not finished yet, in the Maidan”. 

    This is clearly World War three. 

    I would like to see Russia just go home, and while the government in Kiev is frail another (Maidan) revolution. 

    I don’t see Russia as the victim here. But I do see Russia as provoked. Beyond all realms of reason, people have to be able to see that not everything is black and white here.

    In fact this war only helped us get denied for NATO. No one wants that war with Russia. 

    I don’t believe that Ukraine has any issues in the future with Russia nuclear capability. Russia can handle a loss to Ukraine, but I don’t for see Russia handling a loss if NATO jumps in this. Does that make sense? 

    Moscow won’t be Berlin in 1945. 

    As long as the war stays in Ukraine, I think nuclear war isn’t in the goal post.

    What do you think of how Western media reports on it?

    There is a ton of liberal white washing when it comes to fascists in Ukraine: 

    “Nazis don’t exist’ “Azov battalion and Azov regiment are different “ , “They took all the Nazis out of Azov”.

    We know all these to be false, and to a guy who knew and been there; I see it has pure disrespect to tarnish the legacy of a lot of those who died.

    Clearly they don’t know what to think of it. I speak out against the white washing of nationalists by the media. Despite the fact they blasted us for years and even the Ukrainians tried to force fully uproot Azov at one point.

    I use Twitter to mainly troll the (western) left, as they believe Ukraine military isn’t full of nationalist ideals. 

    So you actually can grasp what’s happened. Do you admit that it was a mistake for you to go to Ukraine?

    I don’t regret Ukraine. I just can’t make it clear enough that the nationalists in Ukraine are not the same as the nationalists here in the US who are all basically inbred. 

    I feel the war that the nationalists are fighting is entirely different than the one the state is fighting. I know there was massive celebration when Ukraine was denied for NATO. 

    I notice a lot of Americans don’t even know nations like Ossetia exist, the Georgian invasion of such places, so on so fourth. They just think Russia decides to bomb the fuck out of places for no reason. 

    Similar to World War two, everything and every move had a reason. Ukraine unfortunately is stuck in the middle of that.

    The butler documentary strikes a chord.

    The United States has only been at peace for 22 years of it’s existence. 

    The right to maintain a navy, (The Marines are owned by the department of the navy, though controlled by the president) has kept us in a state of conflict, which obviously keeps the military at a rate. The Obama administration hurt the American military. Badly. I can hardly tell what losses we will take as a nation if we put troops on the ground there.

    Did you have a fascist upbringing? Someone in your family filling your head with that ideology? Just curious. US/CIA media brainwashed Americans to hate Russia. Is that what happened in your case?

    Honestly I grew up in the north. When I was a skinhead originally I was a traditional. I didn’t have any say in politics. I was 12. 

    I didn’t really know how big of a deal my dad was as he lived in England.

    Even growing up and eventually getting into third position politics I was asked to not talk about it, as it would piss off people, in the sense of making me look entitled to something. So I didn’t. 

    I came up under David Lynch, Mark Faella and James Porozzo in the American Front. 

    Smartest people I knew, they had differing beliefs and forming your own opinion was a big deal to them. 

    I think James is actually pro Russian for whatever reason. Dave is dead and Mark retired after the FBI arrest [end]

    The original article

    Related

    Nazism in Ukraine

    its roots before WW2, its collaboration with Nazi Germany, its legacy in modern Ukraine, how NATO has continually supported Nazism in Ukraine

    The footprint of the Ukrainian Nazism in the West

    interactions between Ukrainian Nazi organizations and Western supremacist militants

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia

  • Les oeils de Moscou

    ils sont partout, ils sont l’anti-France

    Heureux sans abonnement à l’Express, je n’ai pas accès à l’article, seulement un titre et un chapô, qui à eux seuls, sont une joyeuse source d’inspiration

    Avec ou sans faux-nez, ils cherchent à dynamiter l’unité occidentale face à la folie destructrice de Vladimir Poutine. Par anti-américanisme, par haine de notre démocratie libérale, ceux que l’on surnomme les prorusses et les « idiots utiles » du Kremlin s’activent sur les réseaux sociaux et dans les sphères politiques. On les croyait condamnés au silence depuis l’invasion russe, ils n’ont jamais été aussi dangereux

    Comme ils sont méchants, comme ils nous font peur, ces vilains pro-russes. Comment pourrait on [on est un con, m’a t on appris quand j’étais tout petit] les condamner au silence ? Par l’accentuation de la censure sur les réseaux sociaux ? Commandement bureaucratique d’un espace libre-échangiste subordonné à l’OTAN, l’Union européenne y songe pour ce mois d’août.

    Afin de conjurer son angoisse, l’Express a entrepris d’étiqueter les différents canaux pro-russes, de ficher leurs têtes de gondole : Henri Guaino, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, Marine le Pen, Ségolène Royal… etc Anti-américains, militaires, covido-sceptiques, hommes d’affaire, russophiles, pacifistes, extrême-droite…, les oeils de Moscou sont partout, c’est effrayant. Sans désemparer, les employés de presse se sont saisis de leur clavier pour atténuer les malheurs de l’Occident.

    Les envolées lyriques partisanes me font rire et l’hilarité me permet de surmonter mon dégoût pour l’excrétion des états d’âme franchouillards. Aussi cruels qu’ils puissent être, les faits sont plus intéressants sans fioriture littéraire. Contrairement aux personnalités politiques citées plus haut, mon analyse n’est pas polluée par le patriotisme, forme théorisée de l’instinct grégaire. La justice est ma seule patrie.

    La guerre au Donbass éclata en 2014, quand après un coup d‘État fasciste à Kiev, les nouvelles autorités entreprirent d’écraser les aspirations autonomistes de leurs citoyens russophones. En renfort de militaires encore fidèles, elles expédièrent au Donbass des militants nazis légalisés en bataillons nationaux de volontaires.

    Plutôt que de contribuer à désamorcer la crise, l’OTAN y vit l’opportunité stratégique d’une guerre par procuration contre la Russie. Son fantasme était de la démembrer, pour améliorer son rapport de force à la Chine. Alors que l’hypocrisie occidentale ne laissait pas d’autre solution, l’opération militaire spéciale est devenue une nécessité technique en février 2022. La Russie a relevé le défi, s’est portée au secours de la population russophone du Donbass.

    La paix était enfin possible en mars, après quelques semaines seulement de combat, mais les Anglo-États-uniens y opposèrent leur veto. Le champ de bataille se dresse désormais entre la réalité et les fantasmes de médiocres politiciens occidentaux.

    À l’instar de la rédaction de l’Express, les jeunes Français me paraissent en général peu équipés pour y briller. Alors que l’OTAN perd cette guerre et accélère l’inéluctable déclin de l’hégémonie occidentale, les employés de l’Express semblent peu pressés de remplacer fusil en main la chair à canon ukrainienne hachée en vain pour atténuer leurs angoisses. Ils font le choix ancré dans une tradition bien française d’établir le fichier de leurs concitoyens pro-russes. Ils donnent leur sang, donnez votre voisin. Puisque son champ d’action demeure derrière le clavier, j’ai hâte que la rédaction s’intéresse aux nazis français partis en Ukraine défendre l’Europe, la démocratie et la liberté.

    Je suis assez vieux pour avoir observé les précédentes entreprises criminelles et catastrophiques des États-unis et de leurs alliés, tentatives de préserver leur hégémonie d’un déclin mécanique et inéluctable. Je suis de ceux que les couveuses koweïtiennes et autres armes de destruction massive ont échaudés.

    À l’époque indépendante, la France s’opposa en 2003 à l’invasion de l’Irak. Plus tard hélas, Nicolas Sarkozy fut le complice de la destruction de la Libye. Folie destructrice ? De loin le plus crétin, François Hollande paya la note et quelques Français avec lui, quand le 13 novembre 2015, une opération djihadiste fut l’anecdotique dommage collatéral à Paris du soutien occidental à l’insurrection sunnite radicale contre le gouvernement laïc de Syrie. Au train où vont les choses en Ukraine, ces désagréments ne sont pas finis

    Par mon âge et mon expérience professionnelle, je me targue d’une culture historique et politique supérieure à celle de l’auteur de romans policiers Charles Haquet ou de l’étudiante en affaires internationales Emma Collet, qui ont commis cet article d’anthologie.

    Au déclenchement de l’opération militaire spéciale, voilà plus d’un an, mes sentiments étaient plus neutres. Mais à la façon dont les mêmes pressetitués ont encore une fois déversé des torrents de boue -mensonges, propagande ukrainienne pour demeurés et autre fantôme de Kiev– ont cherché sans vergogne à blanchir le nazisme endémique ukrainien et ses crimes, j’ai vite compris où étaient dans cette affaire le droit et la justice. D’ailleurs, l’immense majorité des vastes restes du monde est arrivée aux mêmes conclusions

    Cet article est aussi l’authentique expression d’un pays dont le courage n’est pas la première qualité qui vient à l’esprit, quand il est évoqué à l’étranger. D’une presse à ce point servile et caricaturale, qu’un Philippe Henriot ne la renierait pas. D’un peuple froussard à l’arrogance rurale, dont la compréhension des questions internationales est aussi mièvre que chauvine. Car enfin, comme il faut être lâche et rompu aux petits arrangements d’alcôve, pour encencer en qualité de Français, un régiment Azov qui arbore fièrement l’emblème de la 2. SS-Panzer-Division, Das Reich, qui le 10 juin 1944, massacra 643 habitants d’Oradour sur Glane. Impensable à l’étranger.

    Je vous laisse votre démocratie libérale -quand votre libéralisme ne résiste pas à la première éraflure sur la carosserie de votre automobile à crédit- votre chef d’État élu par 25% du corps électoral, ses Gilets jaunes mutilés, son 49.3 et sa presse subventionnée. Elle ne m’intéresse plus, mais fait encore plier de rire une large majorité du globe. Elle est digne de vous, employés de l’Express, petits bourgeois du blême Hexagone, racaille macroniste. Vous avez au moins compris une chose : votre défaite par procuration au Donbass est le début de votre fin.

  • [Sharing] Leaks reveal FBI helps Ukraine censor Twitter users and obtain their info – Aaron Maté, the Grayzone

    The FBI aided a Ukrainian intelligence effort to ban Twitter users and collect their data, new leaks show. Twitter declined to censor journalists targeted by Ukraine, including The Grayzone’s Aaron Maté

    The Federal Bureau of Investigation has aided a Ukrainian intelligence effort to censor social media users and obtain their personal information, leaked emails reveal.

    In March 2022, an FBI Special Agent sent Twitter a list of accounts on behalf of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), Ukraine’s main intelligence agency. The accounts, the FBI wrote, “are suspected by the SBU in spreading fear and disinformation.” In an attached memo, the SBU asked Twitter to remove the accounts and hand over their user data.

    The Ukrainian government’s FBI-enabled targets extend to members of the media. The SBU list that the FBI provided to Twitter included my name and Twitter profile. In its response to the FBI, Twitter agreed to review the accounts for “inauthenticity” but raised concerns about the inclusion of me and other “American and Canadian journalists.”

    The FBI’s attempt to ban Twitter accounts at the request of Ukrainian intelligence is among the most overt requests for censorship revealed to date in the Twitter Files, a cache of leaked communications from the social media giant.

    The FBI’s censorship request was relayed in a March 27th, 2022 email from FBI Special Agent Aleksandr Kobzanets, the Assistant Legal Attaché at the US Embassy in Kyiv, to two Twitter executives. Four FBI colleagues were copied on the exchange.

    “Thank you very much for your time to discuss the assistance to Ukraine,” Kobzanets wrote. “I am including a list of accounts I received over a couple of weeks from the Security Service of Ukraine. These accounts are suspected by the SBU in spreading fear and disinformation. For your review and consideration”

    The attached document, drafted by Ukraine’s SBU, contained 163 accounts, including mine. (The list is numbered to 175, but some accounts have two corresponding numerical lines).

    The listed Twitter profiles, the SBU alleged, have been “used to disseminate disinformation and fake news to inaccurately reflect events in Ukraine, justify war crimes of the Russian authorities on the territory of the Ukrainian state in violation of international law.”

    In order “to stop Russian aggression on the information front,” the SBU continued, “we kindly ask you to take urgent measures to block these Twitter accounts and provide us with user data specified during registration.”

    The SBU expressed its “gratitude for the existing level of interaction”

    If granted, the users on the list would not only have been banned from Twitter but had their phone number, date of birth, and email address disclosed to both the FBI and SBU.

    Read the full list of accounts targeted by the FBI and SBU here:

    Twitter-Dissinf_20220327 SBU list

    In response, Yoel Roth, Twitter’s then-Head of Trust and Safety, informed Special Agent Kobzanets and his FBI colleagues that Twitter would “review the reported accounts under our Rules.” But he warned that the list included “a few accounts of American and Canadian journalists (e.g. Aaron Mate).” Therefore, Roth said, Twitter’s review would “focus first and foremost on identifying any potential inauthenticity.”

    Roth then suggested that he would be open to suspending authentic accounts if it could be proven that they have a hidden tie to a foreign government. Journalists “who cover the conflict with a pro-Russian stance are unlikely to be found in violation of our rules absent other context that might establish some kind of covert/deceptive association between them and a government,” Roth wrote. “Any additional information or context in those areas is of course welcome and appreciated”

    Twitter executive Yoel Roth’s response to the FBI’s censorship request flags its inclusion of journalists, “e.g. Aaron Mate.”

    In his reply, Kobzanets did not directly acknowledge Roth’s concerns about Ukraine’s FBI-abetted effort to censor journalists. “Understood,” Kobzanets told Roth. “Whatever your review determines and action Twitter deem[s] is appropriate.” He also indicated that the FBI would not meet Roth’s request for any “context” that might establish ties between journalists and a foreign government: “Unlikely there will be any additional information or context.”

    Inside Twitter, Roth forwarded the FBI request to two colleagues. “This is the output of our meeting with the FBI last week,” he wrote. “The list of accounts is a mixed bag – there’s some state media mixed in with a bunch of other stuff – but given the context, I think a deep dive here warranted.” (Roth left Twitter in November 2022).

    In an email, I asked Special Agent Kobzanets if he had vetted Ukraine’s censorship request list before sending it to Twitter. I also asked Kobzanets if, after being informed by Twitter’s Roth that the FBI was trying to censor journalists on the SBU’s behalf, whether that had prompted any review or revision of his assistance to Ukrainian intelligence. Kobzanets did not respond.

    The FBI’s National Press Office also declined to answer questions. Among several queries, I invoked Twitter’s warning that the FBI’s “assistance to Ukraine” entailed censoring journalists, and asked if that has prompted any changes to the bureau’s collaboration with Ukrainian intelligence.

    “While we appreciate your inquiry, as a matter of practice we do not confirm, deny, or otherwise comment on specific interactions nor confirm the veracity of correspondence,” an FBI spokesperson wrote.

    Read the full FBI-Twitter correspondence here:

    FBI-SBU Twitter Request

    The FBI officials copied on the Kobzanets’ exchange with Twitter include Elvis Chan, an Assistant Special Agent in Charge (ASAC) of the FBI’s San Francisco field office, where he manages its Cyber Branch. Chan was active in the FBI’s contacts with Twitter when the social media giant’s censorship of reporting on Hunter Biden’s laptop shortly before the November 2020 election. (As I recently reported, he was also involved in FBI’s decision to forego a direct inspection of the DNC servers and instead rely on the Hillary Clinton-funded cyber firm CrowdStrike in the bureau’s probe of alleged Russian hacking in 2016).

    Of the 163 accounts named by the SBU, 34 were suspended and 20 no longer exist. The rest remain active.

    Those marked for censorship by Ukraine but remain online include Russian politicians Gennady Zyuganov, a longtime member of Russia’s Communist Party and parliamentarian who lost to Boris Yeltsin in Russia’s 1996 president election; Dmitry Rogozin, Russia’s former Deputy Prime Minister; and Sergey Mironov, a Russian politician and parliamentarian. The list also includes Russian journalists Vladimir Solovyov, a television news host; and Margarita Simonyan, editor-in-chief of the Russian state-controlled network RT. Several Russian government agencies and media outlets were also listed.

    The Ukrainian nationals targeted by the SBU’s suppression request include Anatoly Shariy, a video blogger and politician who fled Ukraine in 2012 and subsequently received European Union asylum; and Andriy Portnov, a Ukrainian lawyer and politician who served as a senior official under Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych until the latter’s ouster in the February 2014 Maidan coup. (Both Shariy and Portnov’s Twitter accounts remain active).

    The disclosure of a collaboration on censorship between the FBI and SBU is the latest documented instance of Ukrainian state-tied attempts to target foreign voices. A Ukrainian website known as Myrotvorets maintains a list of what it calls “enemies of Ukraine.” I was recently added to that list along with The Grayzone’s Anya Parampil, as well as the comedian and YouTube host Jimmy Dore. The Myrotvorets database was co-founded by Anton Gerashchenko, former deputy minister at the Ukraine’s Ministry of Internal Affairs, where he now serves as an advisor.

    Last year, the global tech/media conference Web Summit withdrew a speaking invitation to The Grayzone’s Max Blumenthal and I after Olena Zelenska, the wife of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, demanded our cancellation. (Another Grayzone colleague, Kit Klarenberg, was recently detained and interrogated about his journalism by British authorities).

    News of the FBI’s work with Ukrainian intelligence to censor Twitter users also follows reporting from journalist Lee Fang that the FBI has pressured Facebook to remove accounts and posts deemed by the SBU to be Russian “disinformation.” According to Fang, a senior Ukrainian official in regular contact with the FBI defined “disinformation” in such broad terms that it could mean viewpoints that “simply contradict the Ukrainian government’s narrative.”

    The original article

    Related

    State censorship on social networks : the Twitter Files

    after his takeover of Twitter, Elon Musk disclosed the political censorship that the social networking service was previously enforcing on behalf of the FBI

    Deviation of the British counter-terrorism police

    Scotland Yard counter terrorism command (SO15) is embezzling anti-terrorist laws, has already arrested for political reasons one French editor and one British journalist

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia

  • [Sharing] EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    The European Union’s enforcers have told Twitter owner Elon Musk that the EU’s voluntary information code is not voluntary and that the EU will fine the pants off Twitter if Musk does not play by NATO’s self-serving rules. Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished.

    From the point of view of von der Leyen and NATO’s other EU puppets, that makes absolutely perfect sense. As legacy media’s active shelf life is fast expiring, that just leaves the EU with alternative media to kill off with massive fines in Twitter’s case or, more generally, by crowding out and muzzling any and all truth tellers.

    Look at the treatment being meted out to Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters, a life-long anti-fascist, whose father was killed in action fighting the Nazis but which the usual suspects, led as always by the BBC and the Guardian, are trying to ban for supposedly being a Jew-hating Nazi simply because of his support for Palestinian rights, for Julian Assange and for being stupid enough to still be doing live concerts with those unreconstructed views, as he touches 80 years of age.

    The EU’s code Waters and Musk are falling foul of “aims to prevent profiteering from disinformation and fake news, as well as increasing transparency and curbing the spread of bots and fake accounts”.

    By disinformation, in addition to Waters, von der Leyen’s thugs mean the work of folk like our own excellent Stephen Karganovic, who is not only a quality thinker and writer, but is on every EU and NATO hit list imaginable because he speaks his truths to their power. And others like Fyodor Lukyanov and Timur Fomenko, who file excellent analytical copy for Russia Today which, with this site, is subject to a string of sanctions and name-calling that are as libellous and ignorant as those these EU and NATO morons throw at Waters or any other of their betters.

    The objective in labelling SCF, Russia Today, Waters and even Masha and Mishka as dis-information is to control the common space and not to give the ideas of heretics like Jeremy Corbyn, Robert F Kennedy Junior or their type space to survive.

    With fake news, the EU is primarily concerned with folk who expose their crimes, family folk like Roger Waters and Julian Assange, who has now done the equivalent of a life tariff for exposing the tiniest fraction of the war crimes the Yanks committed in Iraq, crimes which, remember, included the gang rape of little girls by these harbingers of US-style democracy.

    And then there is Gonzalo Lira, who is in the worst of all places, in Ukraine, whose soldiers rape corpses, and whose politicians ban all opposition parties, all opposition media and all religions that do not worship their utterly corrupt system but yet, as the corpse rapists do God knows what to Gonzalo Lira in God knows where, Ukraine has seen its ranking in NATO’s Press Freedom and Transparency Indexes soar like an American bald eagle that is oblivious to the stench below. The Nazi rump Reich is, the EU’s disinformation experts proclaim, the land of the free and the land of the brave, even as it is hell on earth for Lira and millions of Zelensky’s other victims.

    The torture of Assange and Lira has silenced countless others and thereby made way for NATO’s own quack journalists to fill the void with their own fake news, which was presented to us up till recently by sexual predators like Philip Schofield, ITV’s equivalent of the BBC’s Jimmy Savile.

    Not to put too fine a point on it, but corrupt countries and institutions that elevate Jimmy Saville, Philip Schofield, Ghislaine Maxwell, Lord Boothby, Tom Driberg MP, Jeffrey Epstein, Sir Ted Heath, Cyril Smith, Karim Ahmad Khan, Imran Ahmad Khan and Prince Andrew to positions of power and authority are not in a position to lecture to anyone on transparency or to spin their fake news line on their own terrorist attack on Nordstream.

    As regards bots and fake accounts, that smear should have died a death with the end of Russiagate, one of a number of massive CIA/EU efforts to disseminate fake news and opaqueness through their own bots and fake accounts.

    But why, the Clinton, Biden, Obama and other organised crime families would ask, re-invent the wheel, when the old smears NATO’s media spin work as well as ever?

    What we have with all these rafts of EU laws, fines, sanctions, bluster and bluff is a sort of NATO Cosplay, where von der Leyen and her fellow Cosplay conspirators get to moralise, whilst the Biden, Kerry and Pelosi families get to sprinkle Ukraine with enough bio labs to take out half of Europe’s population, and the New York Post, the only media outlet that reported on the crimes Hunter Biden’s laptop revealed, gets banned and harassed by the FBI goon squads.

    Von der Leyen’s Digital Services Act will further criminalise offensive humour such as comparing French dictator Macron to Hitler (though Waters will remain fair game). Some 19 companies, including Alphabet’s Google Maps, Google Play, Google Search, Google Shopping, YouTube, Meta’s Facebook and Instagram, Amazon’s Marketplace, Apple’s App Store, Twitter, Microsoft’s two units LinkedIn and Bing, booking.com, Pinterest, Snap Inc’s Snapchat, TikTok, Wikipedia, Zalando, and Alibaba’s AliExpress will all have to obey von der Leyen’s diktats “to make the internet safer” by erasing so-called disinformation in whatever way von der Leyen and her fellow plagiarists decide to define it from one moment to the next.

    Not that war is their only earner needing the censor’s protection. Over 3,400 peer-reviewed papers questioning NATO’s Covid narrative have also been sidelined and ignored. Fake news, Russian propaganda, dis-information or some such stuff. I am one of many who did not take the vaccine von der Leyen’s husband made a fortune pimping. And I am glad I didn’t fall for their dancing nurses and their relentless marketing, irrespective of whether they were peddling fake news with their fake vaccines or not. I have no idea whether those vaccines are effective or not. I am not qualified to opine.

    But what I do know is this. There are large groups of American and European politicians, like American fugitive Lindsey Graham who have been promoted because, thick as bricks though they are, they are sufficiently spineless to pimp the wars, vaccines and other societal wrecking balls those who fund and control them are selling.

    Speaking of war, NATO and KFOR mercenaries have just slaughtered a bunch of Serbs in Zvecan (northern Kosovo). Though I look forward with interest to getting a proper analysis of this latest NATO war crime from Fyodor Lukyanov, Timur Fomenko and our own excellent Stephen Karganovic, I do know that not only will their take be totally at odds with that of the EU’s semi-literate fact-checkers but that Russia Today and Karganovic will be much nearer to the truth than any of von der Leyen’s minions could ever be because those EU yellow packs are groomed to paint over and hide the crimes against Serbs and Palestinians this article and a thousand others on this site draw attention to [end]

    The original article

    Related

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia

    Pauvre Sacré Charlemagne

    in French, about the European Union mythology

  • La Police nationale est peuplée de petites frappes

    nouvel épisode le 23 mars 2023

    J’étais encore capitaine de police en 2012, lorsque deux jeunes cadres administratifs du ministère de l’intérieur tentèrent de me convaincre que Philippe Pétain méritait d’être loué, car il aurait sauvé les Juifs de nationalité française, quand les 16 et 17 juillet 1942, la Police nationale rafla à Paris 13 000 personnes, dont 4 000 enfants, qui furent ensuite conduits au Vernichtungslager [camp d’extermination] d’Auschwitz, où 99 % d’entre eux ont été assassinés. Tel est le niveau de révisionnisme au sein d’une coterie de fonctionnaires censés gérer la sûreté en France. Le vice est moins dans le simple antisémitisme que dans le nationalisme et la loyauté absolue à l’État, de ronds de cuir d’extrême-droite.

    Voici quelques cas pratiques. Une majorité de Français est actuellement indignée qu’Emmanuel Macron tente d’imposer, sans accord du parlement, une réforme néolibérale des retraites. Une nouvelle vague de grèves et de manifestations éclate à travers le pays le 23 mars 2023. 425 personnes sont interpellées mais seulement 52 sont ensuite poursuivies pour diverses infractions, comme outrage à agent de la force publique, une incrimination bien pratique et usée jusqu’à la corde. 373 arrestations sont simplement illégales. Une telle répression est inacceptable dans une prétendue démocratie.

    Lors de précédentes manifestations à Paris le 20 mars, des témoins sont parvenus à enregistrer les propos de policiers contre des personnes détenues illégalement et même battues dans la rue, ont remis ensuite le document aux médias

    Je vous laisse de soin d’écouter ce document, d’apprécier l’éthique professionnelle et le niveau culturel de ces fonctionnaires payés avec vos impôts, contre une courageuse victime lycéenne. Victime, car ces interpellations, détentions et violences sont illégales, ce qui fait de ces policiers des délinquants.

    Ces exemplaires flics français sont membres de la BRAV-M, une unité de maintien de l’ordre à moto, qui a été formée à Paris en mars 2019, afin de réprimer les Gilets Jaunes

    Dans le contexte du mouvement social des Gilets Jaunes, la BRAV-M fut la résurrection d’une précédente formation de maintien de l’ordre, les voltigeurs, qui fut dissoute après qu’un jeune innocent, Malik Oussekine, eut été battu à mort le 6 décembre 1986. Je suis devenu inspecteur de police en septembre 1989, alors que le gouvernement français était socialiste.

    Depuis une première réforme, qu’un gouvernement de droite mena en 1995, d’autres ensuite jusqu’à nos jours, la police française a radicalement changé, se concentre toujours plus sur le maintien de l’ordre, c’est-à-dire la répression de manifestants opposés à des réformes néolibérales, au dépens de la Police judiciaire, dont Georges Clemenceau a dit autrefois qu’elle était la seule qu’une démocratie pouvait avouer. Au dépens de l’enquête criminelle, c’est-à-dire de la justice. Ces voltigeurs modernes sont des flics bon marché, recrutés au rabais et dressés comme des chiens d’attaque, alors que les actions illégales de la Police nationale sont devenues systémiques. Après une trentaine d’années comme inspecteur de police, puis officier de renseignement en contre-terrorisme, capitaine de la vieille école, alors que les Gilets Jaunes étaient réprimés, je fus révoqué en 2020 et heureux de prendre mes cliques, après avoir déclaré publiquement que ces flics sont inaptes et lâches. Car légale ou illégale, leur violence aurait eu le mérite d’être utile, si les mêmes avaient eu le courage d’affronter cette fois là des hommes armés, le 13 novembre 2015

    Dans le même registre, car je suis le dossier de très près

    Une Police nationale peuplée de petites frappes, nouvel épisode le 11 mars 2023

    Mais que fait la police ?

    Les tueurs à gage arrondissaient les fins de mois du brigadier de la DGSI

    Une Police nationale peuplée de petites frappes, nouvel épisode le 19 janvier 2023

    Tuerie terroriste à Paris

    La débâcle du 13 novembre 2015

    La rafle du Vél’d’Hiv

  • [Sharing] How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    The West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    Larry Johnson, an ex-CIA analyst, writes “I no longer hold clearances and have not had access to the classified intelligence assessments. However, I have heard that the finished intelligence being supplied to U.S. policymakers continues to declare that Russia is on the ropes – and their economy is crumbling. Also, analysts insist that the Ukrainians are beating the Russians”.

    Johnson responds that – lacking valid human sources – “western agencies are almost wholly dependent today on ‘liaison reporting’” (i.e., from ‘friendly’ foreign intelligence services), without doing ‘due diligence’ by cross-checking discrepancies with other reporting.

    In practice, this largely means western reporting simply replicates Kiev’s PR line. But there does occur a huge problem when marrying Kiev’s output (as Johnson says) to UK reports – for ‘corroboration’.

    The reality is UK reporting itself is also based on what Ukraine is saying. This is known as false collateral – i.e., when that which is used for corroboration and validation actually derives from the same single source. It becomes – deliberately – a propaganda multiplier.

    In plain words however, all these points are ‘red herrings’. Bluntly, so-called western ‘Intelligence’ is no longer the sincere attempt to understand a complex reality, but rather, it has become the tool to falsify a nuanced reality in order to attempt to manipulate the Russian psyche towards a collective defeatism (in respect not just to the Ukraine, but to the idea that Russia should remain as a sovereign whole).

    And – to the extent that ‘lies’ are fabricated to accustom the Russian public to inevitable defeat – the obverse edge clearly is intended to train the western public towards the ‘groupthink’ that victory is inevitable. And that Russia is an ‘unreformed evil Empire’ which threatens all Europe.

    This is no accident. It is highly purposeful. It is behavioural psychology at work. The ‘head-spinning’ disorientation created throughout the Covid pandemic; the constant rain of ‘data-driven’ model analysis, the labelling of anything critical of the ‘uniform messaging’ as anti-social disinformation – enabled western governments to persuade their citizens that ‘lockdown’ was the only rational answer to the virus. It was not true (as we now know), but the ‘pilot’ behavioural nudge-psychology trial worked better – better even than its own architects had imagined.

    Professor of Clinical Psychology, Mattias Desmet, has explained that mass disorientation does not form in a vacuum. It arises, throughout history, from a collective psychosis that has followed a predictable script:

    Just as with lockdown, governments have used behavioural psychology to instil fear and isolation to mass large groups of people into herds, where toxic sneering at any contrariness cold-shoulders all critical thinking or analysis. It is more comfortable being inside the herd, than out.

    The dominant characteristic here is remaining loyal to the group – even when the policy is working badly and its consequences disturb the conscience of members. Loyalty to the group becomes the highest form of morality. That loyalty requires each member to avoid raising controversial issues, questioning weak arguments, or calling a halt to wishful thinking.

    The ‘Groupthink’ allows some self-imagined reality to detach; to drift further and further from any connection to reality, and then to transit into delusion – always drawing on like-minded peer cheerleaders for its validation and extended radicalisation.

    So, it’s ‘goodbye’ to traditional Intelligence! And ‘welcome’ to western Intelligence 101: Geo-Politics no longer revolves around a grasp on Reality. It is about the installation of ideological pseudo-realism – which is the universal installation of a singular groupthink, such that everyone lives passively by it, until it is far too late to change course.

    Superficially, this may seem clever new psyops – even ‘cool’. It is not. It is dangerous. By deliberately working on deeply ingrained fears and trauma (i.e. the Great Patriotic War for Russians (WW2)), it awakens a type of multi-generational existential plight within the collective unconscious – that of total annihilation – which is a danger that America has never faced, and towards which there is zero American empathetic understanding.

    Perhaps, by resurrecting long, collective memories of plague in European countries (such as Italy) western governments have found that they were able to mobilise their citizens around a policy of coercion, that otherwise ran wholly against their own interests. But nations have their own distinct myths and civilisational mores.

    If that were the purpose (to acclimatise Russians to defeat and ultimate Balkanisation), Western propaganda has not only failed, but it has achieved the converse. Russians have coalesced closely together against an existential western threat – and are prepared to ‘go to the wall’, if necessary, in defeating it. (Let those implications sink in.)

    On the other hand, falsely promoting a picture of inevitable success for the West inevitably has raised expectations of a political outcome that is not only not feasible, but which recedes further into the far horizon, as these fantastical claims of Russian setbacks persuade European leaders that Russia can accept an outcome in line with their constructed false reality.

    Another ‘own goal’: The West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation and decomposition. There will be anger and further distrust for the Élites in the West to follow. Existential risk ensues when people believe nothing the élites say.

    Plainly put, this resort to clever ‘nudge theories’ has succeeded only in toxifying the prospect for political discourse. Neither the U.S. nor Russia can now move directly to pure political discourse:

    Firstly, the parties inevitably must come to some tacit psychological assimilation of two quite dis-connected realities, now hyped into palpable, vital beings through these psychological ‘Intelligence’ techniques. There will be no acceptance by either side of the validity or moral rightness of the Other Reality’s, yet its emotive contents must be acknowledged psychically – together with the traumas underlying them – if politics is to be unlocked.

    In short, this western exaggerated psyops perversely is likely to lengthen the war until facts-on-the ground finally grind the contrasting expectations closer to what may be the ‘new possible’. Ultimately, when perceived realities cannot be ‘matched’ and nuanced, war rubs one or the other into more emollient form.

    The degeneracy in western intelligence did not start with the recent collective ‘excitement’ at the possibilities of ‘nudge-psychology’. The first steps in this direction began with a shift in ethos reaching back to the Clinton/Thatcher era in which the intelligence services were ‘neo-liberalised’.

    No longer was the role of ‘devil’s advocate’ – of bringing ‘bad news’ (i.e. hard-edged Realism) to the relevant political leadership valued; instead what was inserted was a radical shift towards ‘Business School’ practice of services being tasked with ‘adding value’ to existing government policies, and (even) of creating ‘a market’ system in Intelligence!

    The politician-managers demanded ‘good news’. And to make ‘it stick’, funding was tied to the ‘value added’ – with administrators skilled at managing bureaucracy moved into leadership jobs. It marked the end to classical Intelligence – which always was an art, rather than science.

    In short, it was the outset to fixing the intelligence around policies (to add value), rather than the traditional function of shaping policies to sound analysis.

    In the U.S., the politicisation of intelligence reached its apex with Dick Cheney’s initiation of a Team ‘B’ intelligence unit reporting personally to him. It was intended to furnish the anti-intelligence to combat the intelligence service output. Of course, the Team ‘B’ initiative shook confidence amongst the analysts, and by-passed the work of the traditional cadre – just as Cheney had intended. (He had a war (the Iraq war) to justify).

    But there were separately other structural shifts. Firstly, by 2000, woke narcissism had begun to eclipse strategic thought –creating its own novel groupthink. The West just could not shake off the sense of itself at the centre of the Universe (albeit no longer in a racial sense, but via its awakening to ‘victim politics’ – requiring endless redress and reparations – and such woke values serendipitously seemed to anoint the West with a renewed global ‘moral primacy’).

    In a parallel shift, U.S. neo-cons piggy-backed on this new woke universalism to cement the meme of ‘Empire matters primordially’. The unspoken corollary to this, of course, is that original values of the American Republic or of Europe, cannot be re-conceived and brought forward into the present, as long as ‘liberal’ Empire groupthink configures them as a threat to western security. This conundrum and struggle lies at the heart of U.S. politics today.

    Yet the question remains just how can the intelligence being supplied to U.S. policymakers insist that Russia is imploding economically, and that Ukraine is winning – against what can be easily observed facts on the ground?.

    Well, no problem; Washington thinks-tanks have big, big finance from the Military Industrial World, with the preponderance of these funds going to the neo-cons – and their insistence that Russia is a small ‘gas-station’ posing as a state, and not a power to be taken seriously.

    Neo-con claws tear at anyone gain-saying their ‘line’ – and think-tanks employ an army of ‘analysts’ to turn out ‘academic’ reports suggesting that Russia’s industry – to the extent it exists at all – is imploding. Since last March, western military and economic experts have been regularly-as-clockwork, predicting that Russia has run out of missiles, drones, tanks and artillery shells – and is expending its manpower throwing human-waves of untrained troops upon the Ukrainian siege lines.

    The logic is plain, but again flawed. If a combined NATO struggles to supply artillery shells, Russia with the economy the size of a small EU state (logically) must be worse off. And if only we (the U.S.) threaten China hard enough against supplying Russia,then the latter will ultimately run out of munitions – and NATO supported Ukraine ‘will win’.

    The logic then is that a war prolonged (until the money runs out) must deliver a Russia bereft of munitions, and NATO-supplied Ukraine ‘wins’.

    This framing is entirely wrong because of conceptual differences: Russian history is one of Total War that is fought in a long, ‘all-out’, uncompromising engagement against an overwhelming peer force. But inherent to this idea, is its all-important grounding in the conviction that such wars are fought over the course of years, with their outcomes conditioned by the capacity to surge military production.

    Conceptually, the U.S. shifted in the 1980s away from its post-war military-industrial paradigm, to off-shore manufacturing to Asia and to ‘just-in-time’ supply lines. Effectively, the U.S. (and the West) shifted in the opposite direction to ‘surge capacity’, whereas Russia did not: It kept alive the notion of sustainment which had contributed to saving Russia during the Great Patriotic War.

    So, western intelligence services again got it wrong; they misread the reality? No, they didn’t get it ‘wrong’. Their purpose was different.

    The few who got it right were mercilessly caricatured as stooges to make them seem absurd. And Intelligence 101 was re-conceived as the purposeful denialism of all off-Team thinking, whilst the majority of western citizens would live passively in the embrace the groupthink – until too late for them to awaken, and to change the dangerous course on which their societies were embarked.

    Unverified Ukrainian reports (liaison reporting) served up to western leaders therefore is not a ‘glitch’ – it is a ‘feature’ of the new Intelligence 101 paradigm intended to confuse and dull its electorate [end]

    The original article

    my related piece

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia