Nicolas Cinquini

Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu

Tag: EW

  • [Sharing] Escaping Attrition: Ukraine Rolls the Dice – Big Serge

    The Zaporizhia Summer Blockbuster

    It has been a while since I published anything long-form commenting on the ongoing Russo-Ukrainian War, and I confess that writing this article gave me a modicum of trouble. Ukraine’s much anticipated grand summer counteroffensive has now been underway for about eighty days with little to show for it. The summer has seen fierce fighting in a variety of sectors (to be enumerated below), but the contact line has shifted very little. I have been reluctant to publish a discussion of the Ukrainian campaign simply because they have continued to hold assets in reserve, and I did not want to post a premature commentary that went to press right before the Ukrainians showed some new trick or revealed a hidden ace up their sleeve. Sure enough, I wrote the bulk of this article last week, right before Ukraine launched yet another major attempt to force a breach in the Orikhiv sector.

    At this point, however, the appearance of some of Ukraine’s last remaining premier brigades, which had previously been held in reserve, confirms that the axes of Ukraine’s attack are concretized. Only time will tell if these precious reserves manage to achieve a breach in the Russian lines, but enough time has passed that we can sketch out what exactly Ukraine has been trying to do, why, and why it has failed to this point.

    Part of the problem with narrating the war in Ukraine is the positional and attritional nature of the fighting. People continue to look for bold operational maneuver to break the deadlock, but the reality seems to be that for now some combination of capability and reticence has turned this war into a positional struggle with a plodding offensive pace, which far more resembles the first world war than the second.

    Ukraine had aspirations of breaking open this grinding front and reopening mobile operations – escaping the attritional struggle and driving on operationally meaningful targets – but these efforts have so far come to naught. For all the lofty boasts of demonstrating the superior art of maneuver, Ukraine still finds itself trapped in a siege, painfully trying to break open a calcified Russian position without success.

    Ukraine may not be interested in a war of attrition, but attrition is certainly interested in Ukraine.

    Ukraine’s Strategic Paradigm

    For those that have been following the war closely, what follows will probably not be new information, but I think it is worth thinking holistically about Ukraine’s war and the factors that drive their strategic decision making.

    For Ukraine, the conduct of the war is shaped by a variety of disturbing strategic asymmetries.

    Some of these are obvious, like Russia’s much larger population and military industrial plant, or the fact that Russia’s war economy is indigenous, while Ukraine is entirely reliant on western deliveries of equipment and munitions. Russia can autonomously ramp up armaments production and there are abundant signs from the battlefield that the Russian war economy is beginning to find its groove, with new systems like the Lancet present in increasing abundance, and western sources now admitting that Russia has successfully serialized a domestic version of the Iranian Shahed Drone. Furthermore, Russia has the asymmetrical capacity to strike Ukrainian rear areas to an extent that Ukraine cannot reciprocate, even if they are given the dreaded ATACMs (these will give Ukraine the range to strike operational depth targets in the theater, but they can’t hit facilities in Moscow and Tula the way Russian missiles can strike anywhere in Ukraine)

    Medvedev inspects a tank production run

    With significant Russian asymmetries in population size, industrial capacity, strike capability, and – let us be blunt – sovereignty and decision-making freedom, an attritional-positional struggle is simply bad math for Ukraine, and yet that is precisely the sort of war in which it has become trapped.

    What is important for us to understand, however, is that the strategic asymmetry goes beyond physical capacities like population base, industrial plant, and missile technology, and extends into the realm of strategic objectives and timelines.

    Russia’s war has been deliberately framed in a fairly open-ended way, with goals largely tied to the idea of “demilitarizing” Ukraine. In fact, Russia’s territorial objectives remain rather nebulous beyond the 4 annexed oblasts (though it is safe to say that Moscow would like to acquire far more than just these). All that to say, Putin’s government has deliberately framed the war as a military-technical enterprise focused on destroying the Ukrainian armed forces, and has shown itself to be perfectly free to give up territory in the name of operational prudentia.

    In contrast, Ukraine has maximalist goals that are explicitly territorial in nature. The Zelensky government has been open about the fact that it aims – however fanciful this may be – to restore the entirety of its 1991 territories, including not just the four mainland oblasts but also Crimea.

    The confluence of these two factors – Ukrainian territorial maximalism combined with asymmetrical Russian advantages in a positional-attritional struggle – forces Ukraine to seek a way to break open the front and restore a state of operational fluidity. Remaining locked in a positional struggle is unworkable for Kiev, partially because Russia’s material advantages will inevitably shine through (in a fight between two big guys swinging big bats at each other, bet on the bigger guy with the bigger bat), and partially because a positional war (which amounts essentially to a massive siege) is simply not an efficient way to retake territory.

    This leaves Ukraine with no choice but to unfreeze the front and try to restore mobile operations, with an eye towards creating some asymmetry of their own. The only feasible way to accomplish this is to launch an offensive aimed at severing critical lines of Russian communication and supply. Contrary to some suggestions that were popular this spring, a large Ukrainian offensive against Bakhmut or Donetsk simply did not fit the bill.

    Frankly, there are only two suitable operational targets for Ukraine. One is Starobils’k – the beating heart at the center of Russia’s Lugansk front. Capturing or screening Svatove and then Starobils’k would create a genuine operational catastrophe for Russia in the north, with cascading effects all the way down to Bakhmut. The second possible target was the land bridge to Crimea, which could be cut by a thrust across lower Zaporizhia towards the Azov coast.

    It was probably inevitable that Ukraine would select the Azov option, for a few reasons. The land bridge to Crimea is a more self-contained battlespace – an offensive in Lugansk would occur under the shadow of the Belgorod and Voronezh regions of Russia, making it relatively more difficult to put significant Russian forces out of supply. Perhaps even more significant, however, is Kiev’s complete obsession with Crimea and the Kerch Bridge – targets that hold hypnotic sway in a way that Starobils’k never could.

    Again, this may sound like fairly intuitive review, but it’s worth contemplating how and why Ukraine ended up launching an offensive that was widely telegraphed and expected. There was no strategic surprise whatsoever – a definitely real video of GUR chief Budanov smirking didn’t fool anyone. The Russian armed forces certainly weren’t fooled, as they spent months saturating the front with minefields, trenches, firing emplacements, and obstacles. Everyone knew that Ukraine was going to attack toward the Azov Coast, specifically with an eye towards Tokmak and Melitopol, and that’s exactly what they did. A frontal attack against a prepared defense without the element of surprise is generally considered a poor choice, but here is Ukraine not only attempting such an attack but even launching it against a backdrop of global celebration and phantasmagorical expectations

    Ukraine’s infantile plea for OPSEC

    It’s impossible to make sense of this without understanding the way that Ukraine is shackled by a particular interpretation of the war to this point. Ukraine and its supporters point to two successes in 2022 where Ukraine was able to retake a substantial swathe of territory, in Kharkov and Kherson oblasts. The problem is that neither of these situations is portable to Zaporizhia.

    In the case of the Kharkov offensive, Ukraine identified a sector of the Russian front that had been hollowed out and was defended only by a thin screening force. They were able to stage a force and achieve a measure of strategic surprise, due to the thick forests and general paucity of Russian ISR in the area. This is not to mitigate the scale of Ukraine’s success there; it was certainly the best uses of forces available to them and they did exploit a weak section of front. This success is hardly relevant to circumstances in the south today; mobilization has ameliorated Russia’s force generation problems so that they now longer have to make hard choices about what to defend, and the heavily fortified Zaporizhia frontline is nothing like the thinly held front in Kharkov.

    The second case study – the Kherson counteroffensive – is even less germane. In this case, Ukrainian leadership is rewriting history in record time. The AFU banged its head on Russian defenses in Kherson for months throughout the summer and autumn last year and took atrocious losses. An entire grouping of AFU brigades was mauled in Kherson without achieving a breakthrough, and this even with Russian forces in a uniquely difficult operational disposition where they had their backs to a river. Kherson was only abandoned months later due to concerns that the Kakhovka dam might fail or be sabotaged (for those keeping score, it did in fact end up failing), and due to Russia’s need at the time to economize forces.

    Again, this can easily be misconstrued as arguing that Russia’s withdrawal from Kherson did not matter. Obviously, abandoning a hard-earned bridgehead is a major setback, and retaking west-bank Kherson was a boon for Kiev. But we need to be honest about why it happened, and it plainly did not happen because of Ukraine’s summer counteroffensive – to underscore this, recall that Ukrainian officials openly wondered if the Russian withdrawal was a trick or a trap. The question is simply whether Ukraine’s Kherson offensive is predictive of future offensive success. It is not.

    So, we have one case where Ukraine identified a lightly defended section of front and ran through it, and another where Russian troops abandoned a bridgehead due to logistical and force allocation concerns. Neither is particularly relevant to the situation on the Azov coast, and in fact an honest reflection of the AFU’s Kherson Counteroffensive might have given Ukraine second thoughts about a frontal assault on prepared Russian defenses.

    Instead, Kharkov and Kherson have both been presented as proof positive that Ukraine can shatter Russian defenses in a straight up fight – in fact, we still have no examples from this war of the AFU defeating strongly held Russian positions, particularly post-mobilization when Russia finally began to resolve its manpower deficiencies. But Ukraine is caught in the grip of its own particular story about this war, which has imparted unearned confidence in its ability to conduct offensive operations. Tragically for mobilized Ukrainian Mykolas, this has dovetailed with a second swagger-producing mythology.

    A major selling point for the Ukrainian counteroffensive has been the assessed superiority of the AFU’s big-ticket donations from the west – the main battle tanks and infantry fighting vehicles. Since the first deliveries were announced, there has been no shortage of boasting about the many superior qualities of western models like the Leopards and Challengers. The suggestion has essentially been that skilled Ukrainian tankers are only waiting to be unleashed once they get behind the wheel of superlative western builds. My personal favorite motif has been the practice of dismissing Russian tanks as “Soviet Era” – neglecting to note that the Abrams (designed 1975) and the Leopard 2 (1979) are also Cold War models

    A burn out Leopard in Syria

    It must be stated, again, that there is nothing wrong with western tanks. The Abrams and the Leopard are fine vehicles, but confidence in their game-changing capabilities stems from a mistaken assumption about the role of armor. It must be appreciated that tanks always have been and always will be mass-consumption items. Tanks blow up. They are disabled. They break down and are captured. Tank forces attrit – much faster than people expect. Given that the brigades prepared for Ukraine’s assault on the Zapo line were significantly understrength in vehicles, it was simply irrational to expect them to have an oversized impact. This is not to say that tanks aren’t important – armor remains critical to modern combat – but in a peer conflict one should always expect to lose armor at a steady clip, especially when the enemy retains fires superiority.

    One can see, then how a measure of hubris can easily creep in to Ukrainian thinking, fueled by a healthy dose of desperation and strategic need. Reasoning from a distorted understanding of its successes in Kharkov and Kherson, emboldened by their shiny new toys, and guided by an overriding strategic animus that requires them to unlock the front somehow, the idea of a frontal attack without strategic surprise against a prepared defense really could seem like a good idea. Add in the good old fashioned trope about Russian incompetence and disorder, and you have all the recipes for an imprudent roll of the dice by Ukraine.

    The Misfire

    So now we come to the operational minutia. For a variety of reasons, Ukraine has chosen to attempt a frontal assault on Russia’s fortified Zaporizhia front, with the intention of breaching towards the sea of Azov. How can this be accomplished?

    We had a few clues early on, accruing from a variety of geographic features and alleged intelligence leaks. In May, the Dreizin Report published what was purported to be a Russian synthesis of Ukraine’s OPORD (Operational Order). An OPORD functions as a broad sketch of an operation’s intended progression, and the document shared by Dreizin was billed as a summary of Russia’s expectation for Ukraine’s offensive (that is, it is not a leak of Ukraine’s internal planning documents, but a leak of Russia’s best guess at Ukraine’s plans).

    In any case, in a vacuum it was anybody’s guess as to whether Dreizin’s OPORD was authentic, but we’ve subsequently been able to cross-check it. This is because of the other, even more infamous leak from earlier this spring, which included the Pentagon’s combat power build plan for Ukraine.

    NATO was very generous and built Ukraine a mechanized strike package from scratch. However, because this mechanized force was cobbled together with a variety of different systems from all corners of the NATO Cinematic Universe, Ukraine formations are uniquely identifiable by their particular combination of vehicles and equipment. So, for example, the presence of Strykers, Marders, and Challengers indicates the presence of the 82nd Brigade in the field, and so forth.

    Thus, despite Ukrainian pretensions of operational security, it’s actually been trivially easy for observers to know which Ukrainian formations are in the field. There have been a few deviations from the script – for example, the 47th Brigade was supposed to field the Frankenstein Slovenian M55 tanks, but in the end the decision was made to send the underpowered M55’s to the northern front and the 47th was deployed with a contingent of Leopard Tanks originally operated by the 33rd Brigade. But these are minor details, and on the whole we’ve had a good sense of when and where specific AFU formations get on the field.

    Based on identifiable units, the Dreizin OPORD looks very close to what we actually saw at the onset of the Ukrainian offensive. The Dreizin OPORD called for an assault by the 47th and 65th Brigades on the Russian lines south or Orikhiv, in the sector bounded by Nesterianka and Novoprokopivka. Directly in the middle of this sector is the town of Robotyne, and sure enough that’s where the first big AFU assault came overnight on June 7-8, spearheaded by the 47th Brigade.

    Now, from this point it becomes difficult to evaluate the Dreizin OPORD simply because Ukraine’s attack became instantaneously derailed, but one thing we can say is that Dreizin’s source was correct about the order that Ukrainian units would be introduced into battle. Based on this, we can flesh out the OPORD and feel pretty safe wagering that this is what the Ukrainians were hoping to achieve:

    Ukraine’s Dream: The Drive to the Sea

    The intention seems to have been to force a breach in the Russian line using a concentrated armored assault by the 47th and 65th Brigades, after which a follow on force of the 116th, 117th, and 118th would begin the exploitation phase, driving for the Azov Coast and the towns of Mikhailivka and Vesele to the west. The objective was clearly not to get bogged down in urban fighting attempting to capture places like Tokmak, Berdyansk, or Melitopol, but to bypass them and cut them off by taking up blocking positions on the main roads.

    Simultaneously, a lesser – but no less critical – thrust would come out of the Gulyaipole area and drive along the Bilmak axis. This would have the effect of both screening the main advance to the west and wedging the Russian front open, splintering the integrity of the Russian forces caught in the middle. Overall, this is a fairly sensible, if ambitious and uncreative plan. In many ways, this was really the only option.

    So what went wrong? Well, conceptually it’s easy. There is no breach. The bulk of the maneuver scheme is dedicated to exploitation – reaching such and such a line, taking up this blocking position, masking that city, and so forth. But what happens when there’s no breach at all? How can such a catastrophe occur, and how can the operation be salvaged when it comes untracked in the opening phase?

    Indeed, this is precisely what has happened. Ukraine finds itself stuck on the edge of Russia’s outermost screening line, spending substantial resources trying to capture the small village of Robotyne, and/or bypass it to the east by infiltrating the gap between it and the neighboring village of Verbove. So instead of that rapid breach and turning maneuver towards Melitopol, we get something like this:

    Ukrainian Counteroffensive with Mapped Russian Defensive Lines

    We could be generous and say that Robotyne is the last village before the Ukrainian attack reaches the main Russian defensive belt, but we’d be lying – they will also have to clear the larger town of Novoprokopivka, two kilometers to the south. Just for reference, here’s a closer look at the mapped Russian defenses in the battlespace, based on the excellent work of Brady Africk

    Russian defenses in the Robotyne Sector

    The discussion about these emplacements can get a little muddled, simply because it’s not always clear what is meant by that popular phrase “first line of defense.” Clearly there are some defensive works around and in Robotyne, and the Russians chose to fight for the village, so in some sense Robotyne is part of the “first line” – but it is more proper to speak of it as part of what we would call a “screening line”. The first line of continuous fortifications across the front is several kilometers further south, and this is the belt that Ukraine has yet to even reach, let alone breach.

    As of this moment, it appears that Russian troops have lost total control of Robotyne but continue to hold the southern half of the village, while Ukrainian troops in the northern half of the village remain subject to heavy Russian shelling. We should probably at this point consider the village to be continuously contested and a feature of the gray zone

    Robotyne, in all its glory

    Now, a quick note about Robotyne itself and why both sides are so determined to fight for it. It seems rather odd on the surface, given that the Russian preference in 2022 was to make tactical withdrawals under their fires umbrella. This time though, they are fiercely counterattacking to contest Robotyne. The value of the village lies not only in its location on the T-0408 Highway, but also its excellent perch on top of a ridge. Both Robotyne and Novoprokopivka lie on a ridge of elevated ground which is as much as 70 meters higher than the low-lying plain to the east.

    What this means is fairly simple; if the AFU presses forward in attempts to bypass the Robotyne-Novoprokopivka position by pushing into the gap between Robotyne and Verbove, it will be vulnerable to fire on the flanks (particularly by ATGMs) by Russian troops on the high ground. We already have seen footage of this, with Ukrainian vehicles being taken in the flank by fire from Robotyne. I am highly skeptical that Ukraine can even attempt an earnest assault on the first defensive belt until they have captured both Robotyne and Novoprokopivka.

    This would all be a tough nut to crack under ideal circumstances, with a variety of engineering problems to mediate, obstacles designed to funnel the attacker into firing lanes, perpendicular trenches to allow enfilade fire on advancing Ukrainian columns, and robust defenses on all the major roadways. But these are not the best of circumstances. This is a tired force that has exhausted much of its indigenous combat power, which is attempting to organize the attack using a piecemeal and understrength assault package.

    Several factors conspired against the Ukrainian offensive, and synergistically they have created a bona fide military catastrophe for Kiev. Let us enumerate them.

    Problem 1: The Hidden Defensive Layer

    At this point, we need to acknowledge something that everybody missed about Russia’s defense. I previously expressed high confidence that Ukraine’s forces would be unable to breach the Russian defenses, but I mistakenly believed that the Russian defense would function according to the classic Soviet defense-in-depth principles (elucidated in great detail by the writings of David Glantz, for example)

    Idealized Defense in Depth by a Motor Rifle Brigade

    Such a defense, put simply, is open to the idea that the enemy will breach the first or even second lines of defense. The purpose of the multilayered (or “echeloned” in the classic terminology) defense is to ensure that the enemy force gets stuck as it tries to break through. It may penetrate the first layer, but as it goes it is continually chewed up by the subsequent belts. The classic example is the Battle of Kursk, where powerful German panzers broke into the Soviet defensive belts but subsequently became stuck as they were ground down. You can think of this as being analogically similar to a Kevlar vest, which uses a web of fibers to stop projectiles: rather than bouncing off, the bullet is caught and its energy is absorbed by the layered fibers.

    I was actually quite open to the idea that Ukraine would generate some penetration, but I anticipated them getting stuck in the subsequent belts and sputtering out.

    What was missing from this picture – and this is a credit to Russian planning – was an unseen defensive belt forward of the proper trenches and fortifications. This forward belt consisted of extremely dense minefields and strongly held forward positions in the screening line, which the Russians evidently intended to fight for fiercely. Rather than breaking through the first belt and getting stuck in the interstitial areas, the Ukrainians have been repeatedly mauled in the security zone, and the Russians have consistently counterattacked to knock them back when they do manage to get footholds.

    In other words, while we expected Russia to fight a defense in depth that absorbed the Ukrainian spearheads and shredded them in the heart of the defense, the Russians have actually shown a strong commitment to defending their forwardmost positions, of which Robotyne is the most famous.

    On paper, Robotyne was expected to function as part of a so-called “crumple zone”, or “security zone” – a sort of lightly held buffer that puts the enemy through pre-registered fires before they bump into the first belt of continuous and strongly held defenses. Indeed, a variety of aerial and satellite surveys of the area taken before Ukraine went on the attack showed Robotyne laying well forward of the first solid and continuous Russian fortification belt.

    What was missed, it seemed, was the extent to which the Russian defenders had mined the areas on the approach to Robotyne and were committed to defending within the security zone. The scale of the mining certainly seems to have surprised the Ukrainians, and creates a strain on Ukraine’s limited combat engineering capabilities. Even more importantly, the dense mines have created predictable avenues of approach for the Ukrainian forces, which force them to repeatedly run through the same gauntlet of fires and Russian standoff weaponry.

    Problem 2: Insufficient Suppression

    The signature image of the first great assaults on the Zapo Line has been columns of unsupported maneuver assets, being raked with Russian fires, both ground based (rocketry, ATGMs, and tube artillery) and from air platforms like the Ka-52 Alligator attack helicopter. One of the more startling aspects of these scenes was the way Ukrainian forces would come under heavy fire while still in their marching columns, taking losses before they ever deployed into firing lines to begin their assault proper.

    There are myriad reasons for this. One is the now blasé issue of Ukrainian munition shortages. Consider the following items of interest. In the runup to Ukraine’s counteroffensive, Russia waged a heavy counter-preparatory air campaign that knocked out large AFU ammunition dumps. Ukraine’s initial assaults collapse in the face of heavy and unsuppressed Russian fires. The United States decides to transfer cluster munitions to Ukraine because, in the words of the president, “they’re running out of ammunition.” Add in the degradation of Ukrainian air defense, which allows Russian helicopters to operate with great effect along the contact line, and you have a recipe for disaster. Lacking the tubes to suppress Russian fires or the air defense to chase away Russian aircraft, the AFU opened their offensive by disastrously pushing forward unsupported maneuver elements into a hail of fire.

    Problem 3: Russian Standoff Weapons

    It’s crucial to understand that the Russian toolbox is fundamentally different than it was during the battle for Kherson last year, due to the rapidly expanding production of a variety of Russian standoff weapons – most notably the Lancet and the UMPK glide modifications for gravity bombs.

    The Lancet in particular has been a star performer – there are claims that the trusty little loitering munition is responsible for nearly half of Russia’s artillery kills – and has filled a crucial capability gap that troubled the Russian army episodically throughout the first year of the war. Contrary to some western assessments that Russia simply could not manufacture drones in sufficient quantities, production of the Lancet has been successfully ramped up in a short period of time, and mass production of other systems like the Geran are coming online as well

    A Thing of Beauty: Zala Lancet

    The proliferation of the Lancet and similar systems means, in a nutshell, that nothing within 30km of the contact line is safe, and this in turn disrupts the AFU’s deployment of critical support assets like air defense and engineering, magnifying their vulnerability to Russian mines and fires. In fact, we’ve increasingly seen Ukrainian artillery use decline in the Robotyne area due to the threat of lancets (they seem to be transferring tubes to other fronts), and the AFU is favoring the use of HIMARS in the suppressive role.

    Problem 4: Repetitive Lines of Approach

    Because the AFU failed to breach the Robotyne sector on their first attempt, they’ve been forced to continually move up additional units and resources to hammer on the position. This has particular implications, both in the sense that AFU forces must continually traverse the same lines of approach to contact, and in the fact that they are using the same rear area to assemble and stage their assault forces.

    This makes the burden on Russian ISR (Intelligence, Surveillance, Reconnaissance) significantly easier, since the AFU has no effective way to disperse or hide the assets that they are bringing forward to the assault. Staged Ukrainian forces and material have been hid repeatedly in the villages immediately behind Orikhiv, like Tavriiske and Omeln’yk, and Russia is able to strike rear area infrastructure like ammunition depots because – to put it simply – there are only so many places these these assets can be staged when you are repeatedly assaulting the same 20km wide sector of front.

    We recently had Ukrainian Deputy Minister of Defense Hanna Malair complaining that the 82nd Brigade – newly deployed to the Orikhiv sector – had been hit with a series of Russian airstrikes in its staging areas. According to her, this was because of poor OPSEC revealing the brigade’s location to the Russians. But this really makes very little sense; the entire area of operations around Orikhiv is perhaps 25km deep (from Kopani to Tavriiske) and 20 km wide (from Kopani to Verbove). This is a small area that has seen a huge amount of military traffic along the same roads throughout the summer. The idea that Russia needs insider information to know that they ought to surveil and attack targets in this area is absurd.

    Problem 5: Fragile Brigades

    It actually takes significantly less damage to “destroy” an operational level unit than people think. A unit can become a combat scratch off at 30% losses (with some variance depending on how those are allocated). This is because when people hear the term “destruction”, they think that means total losses. Sometimes that’s how the word is used in colloquial conversation, but what matters for officers trying to manage an operation is whether or not a formation is combat capable of the tasks being asked of it – and those capabilities can vanish much more quickly than people realize.

    This is particularly the case for the Ukrainian mech package, for a variety of reasons. For one, as we discussed in previous articles, these brigades started the fight well understrength (remember, for example, that the Ukrainian 82nd Brigade has only 90 Stryker AFVs, while an American Strkyer Brigade is supposed to have 300). Additionally, the cobbled together nature of these brigades – and the total lack of indigenous sustainment systems like repair and maintenance – means that the Ukrainians will naturally have to cannibalize these vehicles. They’ve already started designating “donor” vehicles that are written off completely to be stripped down for parts. The nexus of these two facts is that Ukraine’s mechanized brigades are understrength on vehicles to begin with, and will have an abysmally poor recovery rate, with hidden attrition behind the scenes due to cannibalization.

    What this means is that when we heard admissions by mid-July that Ukraine had already lost 20% of its maneuver assets, there is an associated catastrophic decline in combat capability. The lead brigades – which chewed through 50% or more of their maneuver vehicles – can no longer shoulder combat tasks appropriate for a brigade, and the Ukrainians are forced to feed in their second echelon units prematurely.

    At this point, partial elements of at least ten different brigades have been deployed in the Robotyne sector, with the 82nd likely to join them soon. Given that the NATO combat power build plan only included 9 NATO trained brigades, plus a few reconstituted Ukrainian formations, it’s safe to say that blooding all of them over a 71 day fight just to break into the screening line was not in the plan.

    Staring at the Abyss

    I’ve seen a variety of analysts and writers lately arguing that the insertion of additional Ukrainian units into the Robotyne sector signals the next phase of the operation.

    This is nonsense. Ukraine is still mired in the first phase. What has happened is instead that the attrition of their first echelon brigades has forced them to commit their second (and third) wave to complete the tasks of the opening phase. The initial attack, led by the 47th Brigade, was intended to create a breach in the Russian screening line around Robotyne and advance to the main Russian belt further to the south. They failed, and the additional brigades earmarked for exploitation – the 116th, 117th, 118th, 82nd, 33rd, and more – are now being systematically fed in to keep the pressure on.

    These brigades have not been destroyed, of course, simply because they are not being committed in their entirety, but rather as subunits. Nevertheless, at this point Ukrainian losses make up the better part of a whole brigade, distributed around the broader package, and over 300 maneuver elements (tanks, IFVs, APCs, etc) have been scratched off.

    We need to say this very explicitly. Ukraine has not moved on to the next phase of their operation. They are stuck in the first phase, and have been forced to prematurely commit portions of the second echelon that was earmarked for later action. They are slowly but surely burning through the entire operational grouping, and so far they have not breached Russia’s screening line. The great counteroffensive is turning into a military catastrophe

    Now, this does not mean that the operation has failed, simply because it is still ongoing. History teaches us that it is unwise to make definitive pronouncements. Luck and human factors (bravery and intelligence, cowardice and stupidity) always have something to say. However, the trajectory is undeniably towards abject failure at the current moment.

    So far, the AFU has shown some adaptability. In particular, we’ve recently seen them shift away from pushing forward unsupported columns of mechanized assets – instead they’ve been leaning on small dismounted units, trying to slowly push forward into the space between Robotyne and Verbove. The move towards dispersal is intended to reduce loss rates, but it also reduces the probability of a dramatic breakthrough even further and marks the temporary abandonment of decisive breaching action in favor of – once again – creeping positional warfare.

    We would be remiss if we failed to note that there have been meaningful Russian losses in all of this. We know that the Russian forces in the Robotyne sector have required rotation and reinforcement, including with elite VDV and Naval Infantry units. Russia has taken counterbattery losses, it has lost vehicles in counterattacking action, and men have been killed holding their trenches. The initial assault groups that the Ukrainians threw in had a lot of combat power, and the fighting was very bloody for both sides. It’s not a one-sided shooting gallery, but a high intensity war.

    But therein is the crux of the matter – Ukraine seems unable to escape the attritional and positional war that it finds itself in. It sounds all well and good to proclaim a return to “maneuver” warfare, but if there is an inability to breach enemy defenses, this is only an empty boast, and the nature of the struggle remains attritional. When the question becomes “will we breach before we run out of combat power”, you are not maneuvering. You are attriting.

    In my series of articles on military history, we’ve looked at a variety of cases where armies tried desperately to unlock the front and restore a state of operational maneuver, but when there is no technical capacity to do so, these intentions do not matter one bit. Nobody wants to be trapped on the wrong side of attritional mathematics, but sometimes what you want does not matter at all. Sometimes attrition is imposed on you.

    In the absence of the capabilities required to successfully breach Russia’s prodigious defenses – more ranged fires, more air defense, more ISR, more EW, more combat engineering, more more more – Ukraine is trapped in a rock fight. Two fighters are swinging bats at each other, and Russia is a bigger man with a bigger bat.

    Two Bad Copes

    Amid a clear misfire and growing strategic disappointment, two new suggestions have increasingly crept into the conversation – “copes”, if you will, that are utilized as a narrative comfort to explain why the Ukrainian operation is actually going just fine (despite nearly universal acknowledgment in the west that the results have been lackluster at best). I would like to briefly address each of these in turn.

    Cope 1: “The first stage is the hardest”

    You frequently see it argued that all the AFU has to do is break open the Russian screening line, and the remainder of the defenses will fall like dominos. The general thrust of this argument is that the Russians lack reserves and that the subsequent defensive lines are not adequately manned – just break open the first line, and the rest will fall apart.

    This is probably a comforting thing to tell oneself, but it’s rather irrational. We could talk, for example, about Russia’s doctrinal schema for defense in depth, which prescribes liberal allocation of reserves at all depths of the defensive system, but it’s probably more fruitful to point at more immediate evidence.

    Let us simply consider Russia’s behavior over the last six months. They have spent a tremendous amount of effort constructing echeloned defenses – are we really to believe that they did all this only to waste all their combat power fighting in front of these defenses? Nor is there any evidence that Russia is having trouble supplying the front with manpower at the present moment. We’ve seen continued rotations and redeployments amid an overall process of military enlargement in Russia. Indeed, of the two belligerents, it is Ukraine that seems to be scraping the barrel for manpower.

    Cope 2: “Get within firing range”

    This is the more fantastical story, and it represents a radical ad-hoc shift of the goalposts. The argument is that Ukraine doesn’t actually need to advance to the sea and physically cut the land bridge, all it has to do is get the Russian supply routes within firing range to cut off Russian troops. This theory has been advance liberally on Twitter X and by personalities like Peter Zeihan (a man who knows nothing about military affairs).

    There are many problems with this line of thought, most of which stem from an inflated notion of “fire control.” To put it simply, being “in range” of artillery fire does not imply effective area denial or severed supply lines. If that were the case, Ukraine would be unable to attack out of Orikhiv at all, since the entire axis of approach is within Russian firing range. In Bakhmut, the AFU continued to fight long after their main supply routes came under Russian shelling.

    The simple fact is that most military tasks are conducted within range of at least some of the enemy’s ranged fires, and the idea that Russia will collapse if the AFU manages to put a shell on the Azov coastal highway is fairly ridiculous. In fact, Russia’s main rail line is already within range of Ukrainian HIMARS, and the Ukrainians have successfully launched strikes on coastal cities like Berdyansk. Meanwhile, Russia strikes at Ukrainian sustainment infrastructure with regularity – yet neither army has collapsed yet. This is because ranged fires are a tool to improve attritional calculus and further operational goals – they do not magically win wars just by tagging the enemy’s supply roads.

    Let’s be charitable though, and indulge this line of thinking. Suppose the Ukrainians managed to advance – not all the way to the coast, but far enough to bring Russia’s main supply routes within range of artillery. What would they do? Wheel up a battery of howitzers, park them at the very front line, and begin firing nonstop at the road? What do you think would happen to those howitzers? Counterbattery systems would surely set upon them. The idea that you can just haul up a big gun and start taking potshots at Russian supply trucks is really quite childish. Putting enemy forces out of supply has always required physically blocking transit, and that’s what Ukraine will have to do if they want to cut Russia’s land bridge.

    The Distraction

    I am cognizant of the fact that I would be raked over the coals if I failed to discuss a secondary area of Ukrainian effort, farther to the east in Donestk oblast. Here, the Ukrainians have worked their way a good distance up the highway out of the town of Velyka Novosilka capturing several settlements.

    The problem with this “other” Ukrainian attack is that it is, in a word, inconsequential. This axis of advance is operationally sterile in a very fundamental way, as it involves pushing groups up a narrow corridor of road that doesn’t lead anywhere important. As in the Robotyne sector, the AFU is still quite some distance from any of the serious Russian fortifications, and to make matters worse the road and settlements on this axis lay along a small river. Rivers, as we know, flow along the floor of the terrain, which means the roadway sits at the bottom of a wadis/embakement/glacis, choose your terminology. In fact, the road network as such consists of nothing except a single-lane roadway on either side of the river

    The Sideshow in the East

    My reading of this axis is essentially that it was intended as a feint to create some semblance of operational confusion, but when the primary effort on the Orikhiv axis turned into a colossal misfire, the decision was made to continue to press here simply for narrative purposes. Ultimately, this is simply not an axis of advance that can exert a meaningful influence on the wider war. The forces deployed here are relatively miniscule in the grand scope of things, and they aren’t going anywhere important. Certainly, a thin, needlelike penetration is not going to drive more than 80 kilometers down a single lane road to the sea and win the war.

    Conclusion: Finger Pointing

    One of the surest signs that Ukraine’s counteroffensive has taken a cataclysmic turn is the way Kiev and Washington have already begun to blame each other, conducting a postmortem while the body is still warm. Zelensky has blamed the west for being too slow to deliver the requisite equipment and ammunition, arguing that unacceptable delays allowed the Russians to improve their defenses. This strikes me as rather obscene and ungrateful. NATO built Ukraine a new army from scratch in a process that already required greatly truncating the training times.

    On the other hand, western experts have begun to blame Ukraine for supposedly being unable to adopt “combined arms warfare”. This is really a very nonsensical attempt to use jargon (incorrectly) to explain away problems. Combined arms simply means the integration and simultaneous use of various arms like armor, infantry, artillery, and air assets. Claiming that Ukraine and Russia are somehow cognitively or institutionally incapable of this is extremely silly. The Red Army had a complex and extremely thorough doctrine of combined arms operation. One professor at the US Arms School of Advanced Military Studies said: “The single most coherent core of theoretical writings on operational art is still found among the Soviet writers.” The idea that combined arms is some foreign and novel concept to Soviet officers (a caste that includes the Russian and Ukrainian high command) is ridiculous.

    This issue is not some sort of Ukrainian doctrinal obstinacy, but a combination of structural factors rooted in the insufficiency of Ukrainian combat power and the changing face of warfare.

    It’s frankly a little silly to say that Ukraine needs to learn about “combined arms” when they are very simply lacking important capabilities that would make a successful maneuver campaign possible – namely, adequate ranged fires, a functioning air force (and no, F-16’s will not fix this), engineering, and electronic warfare. The issue very fundamentally is not one of doctrinal flexibility, but of capability. By way of analogy, this is a bit like sending a boxer out to fight with a broken arm, and then critiquing his technique. The problem is not his technique – the problem is that he’s injured and materially weaker than his opponent. So too, the problem for Ukraine is not that they are incapable of coordinating arms, the problem is that their arms are shattered.

    Secondly – and this, I admit, is rather shocking to me – western observers do not seem open to the possibility that the accuracy of modern ranged fires (be it Lancet drones, guided artillery shells, or GMLRS rockets) combined with the density of ISR systems may simply make it impossible to conduct sweeping mobile operations, except in very specific circumstances. When the enemy has the capacity to surveil staging areas, strike rear area infrastructure with cruise missiles and drones, precisely saturate approach lines with artillery fire, and soak the earth in mines, how exactly can it be possible to maneuver?

    Combined arms and maneuver are predicated on the ability to rapidly concentrate enormous fighting power and attack with great violence at narrow points. This is probably impossible given the density of Russian surveillance, firepower, and the many obstacles they have put up to deny Ukrainian freedom of movement and scleroticize their activity. The main examples of maneuver in recent western memory – the campaigns in Iraq – have only tenuous relevance to circumstances in Zaporizhia.

    Ultimately, we have returned to a war of mass – particularly massed ISR assets and fires. The only way Ukraine can maneuver the way they want is to break open the front, and they can only do this with more of everything – more mine clearing equipment, more shells and tubes, more rocketry, more armor. Only mass can crack open a suitable breach in the Russian lines. Otherwise, they are stuck in a positional creep through the dense Russian defenses, and criticizing them for being unable to grasp some sort of magical western notion of “combined arms” is the strangest sort of finger pointing.

    So, whence goes the war from here? Well, the obvious question to ask is whether we believe Ukraine will ever have a more potent assault package than the one they started the summer with. The answer clearly seems to be no. It was like pulling teeth to scrape together these understrength brigades – the idea that, following on a defeat in the Battle of Zaporizhia, NATO will somehow put together a more powerful package seems like a stretch. More to the point, we have American officials saying fairly explicitly that this was the best mechanized package Ukraine was going to get.

    It does not seem controversial to say that this was Ukraine’s best shot at some sort of genuine operational victory, which at this point seems to be slowly trickling away into modest but materially costly tactical advances. The ultimate implication of this is that Ukraine is unable to escape a war of industrial attrition, which is precisely the sort of war that it cannot win, due to all the asymmetries that we mentioned earlier.

    In particular, however, Ukraine cannot win a positional-attritional war because of its own maximalist definition of “winning.” Since Kiev has insisted that it will not give up until it returns its 1991 borders, an inability to dislodge Russian forces poses a particularly nasty problem – Kiev will either need to admit defeat and acknowledge Russian control over the annexed areas, or it will continue to fight obstinately until it is a failed state with nothing left in the tank.

    Trapped in a bat fight, with attempts to unlock the front with maneuver coming to naught, what Ukraine needs most is a much bigger bat. The alternative is a totalizing strategic disaster [end]

    The original article

    Related

    The Atlanticist counter-offensive

    the last NATO attempt to avoid defeat in its proxy war in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    Panzer, Marsch

    the saga of NATO Panzerkampfwagen in Donbass and Ukraine

  • The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia

    Thanks to journalists Steve Sweeney and Eva Bartlett for this splendid illustration of the censorship spirit about Ukraine in the West, notably among Western journalists themselves. On July 22, Sweeney has received a mail from Jeanne Cavelier, head of the eastern Europe and central Asia desk of RSF (Reporters sans frontières, Reporters Without Borders), a NGO which is supposed to safeguard the right to freedom of information.

    Here is from Bartlett, her article and interview of Sweeney

    Is that a joke ? In the name of freedom of expression and information, RSF is demanding that satellite operator Eutelsat and the French State (20% of shares) censor the Russian media.

    Russian war crimes and propaganda ? Through my remote analysis of known facts, I have detected no single Russian war crime since February 24, beginning of the special military operation in Donbass and Ukraine, but a string of Ukrainian PSYOPs and even false flag crimes, in Mariupol, Bucha, Kramatorsk, Kremenchug, Chasov Yar, Vinnitsa.

    Incitation of hate ? While French Nazi militants are fighting in the Ukrainian ranks, but most Western media are enforcing since February 24 a gag order about Nazism in Ukraine ?

    Moreover, most Western media, like their governments, are broadcasting the Ukrainian propaganda as reliable information, without the most elementary checking.

    I will document in this chronicle the most shameful facts of Western disinformation and censorship of free expression, in the context of the Russian special military operation in Donbass and Ukraine.

    • March 9, 2022

    Leonid and Roman Butusin are brothers. The Russian forces kill them in Chernigov region

    Born in 1971, their father Oleg (up left) is a Russian Nazi militant. He was living in the Far East, where he was calling for the murder of Chinese and Jewish people. Indicted, he fled and the whole family surfaced later in Ukraine, after the West-sponsored right-wing coup in Kiev on February 21, 2014. Since Maidan, Ukraine is an international magnet for Nazis.

    Members of the Ukrainian regular army, 58th motorized brigade, the two sons used to proudly bear the Nazi Reichsadler [imperial eagle], the SS Totenkopf and the ROA patch. Between 1942 and 1945, the German Nazis were recruiting among Soviet prisoners of war, Ukrainian, Belarusian or Russian, the members of the Russkaya Osvoboditel’naya Armiya [Russian liberation army], also called Vlasov army. After victory, Soviet Union tried general Andrey Vlasov, who was hanged on August 1, 1946. After the death of his sons, Oleg will broadcast the photo of a ROA patch (down right), that he will have found on one of the two corpses.

    On April 6, 2022, US propaganda outlet Radio Free Europe will write a piece of anthology

    Roman and Leonid Butusin were born in Vladivostok, in Russia’s Far East, but both died fighting for the Ukrainian Army against Russian invaders. At their funeral, people knelt on the street in a mark of respect. “They were real Ukrainians,” said one mourner. Their father moved the family to Ukraine in 2014, feeling disgusted by Russia’s seizure of Crimea and support for separatists in the country’s eastern Donbas region. Also a soldier, at the funeral he said he would soon be returning to the front line

    On July 8, 2023, Volodymyr Zelenskyy will posthumously confer by decrees the title of hero of Ukraine, with golden star, to Leonid and Roman Butusin. On social networks, international English-speaking Nazi channels will celebrate the Ukrainian official tribute to them.

    • March 16, 2022

    Not censorship, maybe worse, the coarse hijack of information, a despicable disinformation, Italian newspaper la Stampa publishes on its cover a cruel photo, which is showing the aftermath of a Ukrainian shelling in Donetsk, capital of a separatist republic in Donbass, on March 14. 23 civilians have been killed. Ukraine is deliberately shelling civilians in Donbass for eight years

    But the text is a narrative about the situation in Kiev. The wizardry of Western media turns civilian victims of a Ukrainian attack into the result of an alleged Russian strike.

    • April 12, 2022

    Twitter permanently bans Scott Ritter, former intelligence officer within the US Marine Corps, former UN inspector in Iraq, who warned in 2003 that no weapons of mass destruction (WMD) were there

    His crime ? He has suggested as an expert that the mass murder in Bucha was a Ukrainian false flag. It was.

    • April 20, 2022

    Graham Phillips is a British journalist and according to Boris Johnson before the parliament, a war criminal

    His crime ? His interview on April 18 of Aiden Aslin, a British mercenary who has surrendered in Mariupol on April 12 and has asked for the interview. YouTube will later censor his video.

    • June 2, 2022

    Ukraine foreign affairs minister Dmitro Kuleba writes to Josep Borrell, his counterpart in the European Union, demands the censorship of European media about the Ukrainian defeat and prisoners of war (POWs) in Mariupol

    The journalists should deny that Azov regiment is a Nazi formation and has committed war crimes. As supremacists, its members are regarding the Russian-speaking separatist fighters or civilians as Untermenschen. The disclosure of these facts makes the Ukrainian authorities nervous.

    • June 9, 2022

    Censorship has become a professional reward.

    I am usually publishing on Medium, have shared there on June 4 a piece about the death of a French Nazi militant in Ukraine, have enriched my long chronicle about the Western operatives in Mariupol, quote on June 9 UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss and comment that the legitimacy of Donetsk People’s Republic is precisely the point, that Truss supports badly the defendants [British mercenaries], that the British arrogance must be slapped.

    In the evening, my Medium account appears under investigation or was found in violation of Medium rules. No indication of what could be incriminated. For my readers, Medium responds Error 410, indicates that access to the target resource is no longer available at the origin server and that this condition is likely to be permanent

    • June 13, 2022

    First public German TV channel ARD broadcasts footage which are showing the aftermath of a Ukrainian shelling in Donetsk, but the voice-over denounces an alleged Russian attack.

    Three days later, after the outrage on social networks, the channel will regret a mistake

    • June 14, 2022

    Alina Lipp is a German journalist. She is covering the war in Donbass, the deliberate Ukrainian shelling of civilians. The German democratic State is not enjoying her reports and her bank accounts are already blocked

    She is now sued, because she has written on Telegram that denazification has begun in Donbass, where the population is supporting Russia. Which is true. The judicial plot is that the Russian special military operation may become a crime under international law. This harassment is obviously a censorship attempt.

    • June 24, 2022

    Private TV channel LCI is the most zealous broadcaster of Ukrainian propaganda in France. In Kharkov, journalist Claire Cambier has interviewed the day before

    a French soldier in the International Legion, who is fighting since the beginning of the war alongside the Ukrainian troops

    The anchorman adds

    27-year-old Karel is committed to the defense of Europe, has developed a love affair with Ukraine, shows fierce opposition to Russia, to everything it is representing. From various national origins, the foreign volunteers are united by their anti-communism, explains Karel

    Despite his mask, some members of the public will identify the subject, who is also active on social networks. Karel Cherel-Salzburg is a Nazi militant, whom intelligence, police and justice already know. In another interview face uncovered, by an independent Telegram channel on July 25, he will quote Léon Degrelle (1906-1994), a rexiste (Belgian catholic far-right) leader in the 1930s, later Standartenführer (SS colonel) and commander of the 28. SS-Freiwilligen-Panzergrenadier-Division Wallonien (1941-1945)

    • July 5, 2022

    Military defeat has increased the deliberate Ukrainian shelling of civilian areas in Donetsk. British tabloid Daily Mirror dares title

    Russia in blitz on Donetsk. Plumes of smoke over Donetsk, eastern Ukraine, yesterday, after the brutal Russian bombing

    above a photo which is showing the aftermath, the day before, of a Ukrainian attack in the city.

    A few hours after the publication, a shell kills a 10-year-old girl, Veronica

    • July 18, 2022

    The Westerners are monitored from Ukraine, the outpost of the Western civilization and democracy against the Asiatic hordes. On its website, the Center for countering disinformation at the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine reports 78 foreigners so far, analysts, journalists, politicians, scholars… etc, who are accused of promoting narratives consonant with Russian propaganda

    To list and monitor foreign opponents is a legitimate activity for the Ukrainian State security (SBU). The weird stuff is the publication of the list. That’s intimidation, an attempt of censorship, not polite, when the subjects are citizens of allied countries. The Ukrainian authorities are pretty arrogant. When the ambassador to Germany states publicly that the Kanzler is an offended liver sausage, his words are not my concern. I am not Olaf Scholz’ debtor. But when journalist Alice Schwarzer, for example, is publicly reported as a political enemy, Scholz is paid for being concerned.

    • July 26, 2022

    The British government is harassing journalist Graham Phillips (cf. supra, April 20), who is added on the UK government sanctions list. His assets are frozen. The list says

    […] a video blogger who has produced and published media content that supports and promotes actions and policies which destabilize Ukraine and undermine or threaten the territorial integrity, sovereignty or independence of Ukraine […]

    The foreign affairs minister Liz Truss comments

    We will not keep quiet and watch Kremlin-appointed state actors suppress the people of Ukraine or the freedoms of their own people. We will continue to impose harsh sanctions on those who are trying to legitimize Putin’s illegal invasion until Ukraine prevails

    The reality of this war, its facts, their disclosure, are destabilizing Ukraine. Therefore, let us harass the messenger. She admits and justifies the censorship. I guess that the freedoms of their own people is a touch of British humor

    A breath of fresh air : on Fox News, Tucker Carlson stresses the Ukrainian blacklist of Western critics (cf. supra, July 18), interviews two of them, Glenn Greenwald and Tulsi Gabbard

    I cannot imagine nowadays such contradictory words on UK or European mainstream media.

    • July 29, 2022

    In the previous night, the Ukrainian forces have shelled, with US made HIMARS multiple launch rocket systems, the pretrial camp in Yelenovka, Donetsk People’s Republic, where are detained Ukrainian prisoners of war (POWs) from Mariupol, including members of Nazi Azov regiment. Why ? In order likely to wipe out witnesses of their own war crimes, people who may also testify that Western operatives were there. This action is itself a war crime. 53 inmates are killed.

    Karin Bechet Golovko is a French-speaking scholar and political analyst, who writes about the incident on Twitter. The arsenal of moderation rules are equipping the US social networks with all necessary tools to censor information which are not in accordance with the Western narrative

    This explains that, the pathetic European foreign affairs minister, Josep Borell, is broadcasting the fake news

    The matter is not even worth a written analysis. Except the eccentric Ukrainian statements, no single clue suggests that the war crime in Yelenovka could be a Russian or republican false flag. The material evidences are proving a Ukrainian war crime.

    • August 3, 2022

    France is once more performing as the historical homeland of the zealous courtiers, is more than ever a worldwide joke and this is justice, its butt is kicked in Africa. That pathetic situation may be the reason for the censorship of RT Documentary channel on Telegram

    The documentary channel of the Russian television is violating local laws, but I can still access the recruitment outlet of Azov regiment (third line in the screenshot) and many more Ukrainian Nazi media.

    • August 5, 2022

    Breath of fresh air : YouTube channel MSM Narrative shares a video from Scott Ritter (cf. supra, April 12). About the Ukrainian list of foreigners who are promoting narratives consonant with Russian propaganda (cf. supra, July 18), he stresses that

    apparently, US tax payers money is being used to pay the salaries of Ukrainian civil servants, who are preparing lists that include Americans [who according to these civil servants] should be categorized information terrorists

    Scott Ritter is on the list.

    • August 9, 2022

    When I was a child, le Monde was the supposed baseline evening newspaper in France. But hysteria and an obvious paranoia have produced such an article, where supposed journalists deplore the multiplication of Russian propaganda websites, regarded as State sponsored outlets, which means, according to the previous incidents, that they should be censored. The piece is based on a report from a US company, NewsGuard, regarded as a reliable source.

    NewsGuard views for example as myths the claims that Russian troops were not responsible for the massacre of civilians in Bucha, did not attack the railway station in Kramatorsk. These assertions are however the conclusions of my own work. The US company is likely not including criminal investigators, is yet regarding itself as independent.

    Through a mail on August 10, I request an access to the list of 250 websites spreading Russia-Ukraine disinformation […] also peddled by the Kremlin. Junior journalist, managing editor and vice president partnerships in Europe and Canada, Chine Labbe replies that the list is subject to the purchase of a license, that the customers are usually researchers, platforms or government agencies.

    Something is rotten The Ukrainian State security (SBU) makes lists of contradictory foreign independent analysts and speakers (cf. supra, July 18). Such monitoring is a usual job in every State intelligence agency. But the stuff becomes weird, when the SBU publishes these lists under the fallacious pretext of countering disinformation. That is intimidation. Some privatization of intelligence activities is trending in the West. Journalists are falsely believing that they are countering the Russian State activities, make also lists of websites, which are allegedly spreading disinformation. Alongside good intelligence agencies, other journalists access these lists and write that the States should censor these websites. In the case of NewsGuard, I have checked that this disinformation is not. According to my expertise, the massacre in Bucha was indeed a Ukrainian false flag. From Kiev to New York via Paris, the targets are the same, independent analysts, speakers or writers, who do not feed the Western narrative. The goal is censorship, through pillory and crackdown.

    Actually, these lists should have never left the offices of intelligence agencies. I am skeptical about the copulation between intelligence and journalism. The couple seems paranoid. One fact is irrefutable. At least in France, the traditional business, the selling of newspapers, is crumbling. Quality independent websites may be a threat for online newspapers

    • August 13, 2022

    The case is getting worse and worse. Amnesty International to hire independent experts, in order to verify its own previous report about the Ukrainian war crimes, find out what has gone wrong.

    Yet, the laborious report has discovered on August 4, five months late, what every attentive and objective observer had already ascertained : the Ukrainian forces are using human shields in Russian-speaking separatist Donbass, where the nationalists are regarding the population as Untermenschen. The vile politically correct mob has argued that one should not equate aggressors and victims, Russians and Ukrainians. Insanity. The ability to dissect facts, to isolate them from their authors, in order to analyze and qualify them, is the foundation of the law and therefore, civilization.

    Westerners have become feeble slaves, submissive to a dominant thought, childish emotions, crooked media, slaves to money. Their close fate reminds me the sublime gesture of the ancient Parthians, who captured Roman consul Crassus, made him drink molten gold. Each day confirms my certitude of the need to denazify Ukraine. The shameful defeat there of a corrupt and decadent West will be a justice that most of the wide world has long awaited

    • August 14, 2022

    In Germany, the State is still harassing journalist Alina Lipp (cf. supra, June 14) and even her family. Early August, her mother has found out that her bank account had been frozen. Aside the fact, the bank did not give more information. She is now standing alongside her daughter in Donbass.

    Weird situation, Germany is not at war. The fighting ended on May 9, 1945 and the Soviet Union has won

    • August 19, 2022

    The Arbeitsgemeinschaft der öffentlich-rechtlichen Rundfunkanstalten der Bundesrepublik Deutschland (ARD, 1950 – ?), first German public channel, seems to hold the legacy of another famous German institution, the Reichsministerium für Volksaufklärung und Propaganda (RMVP, 1933-1945).

    When on June 13, 2022, the German journalists dared hijack reality, lied and disinformed, pretended that the footage of a Ukrainian shelling in Donetsk would have shown a Russian attack, three days of outrage on social networks were necessary before the channel apologized for its mistake.

    But atavism may be too strong after all and on August 19, in a show called Monitor, the same minions dare trial a real journalist, Alina lipp, who is showing her German public the reality of the Ukrainian war crimes, the deliberate shelling of civilians, an action that even Germany, nowadays, is regarding as terrorist. ARD pretends that Lipp has been spreading Kremlin propaganda and lies, while the German State is already suing her but has not yet scheduled her real trial.

    In my mind, Germany looked better in the 80s, when I was French serviceman within the occupation forces in Berlin

    • August 20, 2022

    28-year-old British national Aiden Aslin was a British mercenary within the Ukrainian regular army, 36th marine brigade, when he has surrendered on April 12, during the Ukrainian defeat in Mariupol, Donetsk People’s Republic.

    British journalist Graham Phillips has interviewed him on April 18, was therefore called a war criminal in the British parliament. On July 26 (cf. supra), the government has added Phillips on a sanctions list, frozen his bank accounts. YouTube has also censored the video of the interview.

    The authorities in Donetsk has later allowed Aslin to publish videos on his YouTube channel, where he has sometimes denounced the Ukrainian war crimes he had witnessed.

    On June 9, the court in Donetsk has sentenced to death mercenaries Aiden Aslin, Shaun Pinner and Brahim Saadoun, but the defendants have appealed. On July 29, with US made rockets, the Ukrainian artillery shelled the pretrial center in Yelenovka, killed 53 inmates. At the same time, the rumor was spreading that the death sentences had been enforced to the three mercenaries.

    Aiden Aslin is alive and has recorded on August 8 a video, which was released on his Youtube account on August 16

    I guess that in his first videos, Aslin was attempting to trigger an action of the British government, which could have exchanged and freed him. He has received a reply on July 29, with the shelling in Yelenovka.

    Today, YouTube has censored Aslin’s channel, likely at the instigation of the British government.

    • August 24, 2022

    The Daily Telegraph has found out the simplest way to achieve its current mission, releases on its YouTube channel, without voice-over but its own logo and English subtitles, a propaganda video from Nazi Azov regiment

    Funny how these British journalists, who are usually denouncing hate speech, are simply translating the words of a Nazi leader, who is proudly displaying on his chest a Nazi symbol, the Wolfsangel

    • August 25, 2022

    From prison in Donetsk People’s Republic, former British mercenary Aiden Aslin is publishing on a new YouTube channel, Captive in Donetsk.

    • August 30, 2022

    Twitter cheap political cops censor for one week a famous account, Levi, for the publication of this cartoon, which is yet factual

    • September 1, 2022

    An unintended breath of fresh air, an epic fail of public propaganda TV channel France 2, which releases a complacent report from Ukraine. And reporter Maryse Burgot shares the video on Twitter. The subject is on the bounds of good taste, but never falls in, a pure piece of crude propaganda. A kid is equipped with fake bulletproof vest and Kalashnikov assault rifle, is saluting from the roadside the vehicles of the Ukrainian army.

    But reality is in the details. On the other side of the road, two young girls give the Nazi salute

    The voice-over do not even comment the nefarious detail. Imagination makes me laugh. I am wondering what was the action of Burgot’s elders, when a Kommandantur was set in their town, when the Propagandastaffel was ruling the information in France.

    The French public propaganda TV channel makes a fool of itself, replies to my previous question, when on September 2, it denies on Twitter that the two young girls have given a Nazi salute, but a friendly gesture, while the synchronized SIEG HEIL is unambiguous in the video.

    Atavism is strong, these French courtiers remind obviously their elders during WW2. Radio Paris was an asset of the French fascist State. Its main speaker was Philippe Henriot, a minister whom a group of resistance fighters gunned down on June 28, 1944

    • September 4, 2022

    Coarse hijack of information, despicable disinformation, usual methods of Western media, le Parisien titles

    War in Ukraine: Kiev wants the Russian invasion to be recognized as a ‘genocide’

    The picture is tragic, appears like a clue that the Russian invasion would be indeed a genocide. Problem : Alexander Ermochenko has taken this photo on September 2, in Donetsk. He is showing a civilian victim of a Ukrainian shelling. And these terrorist shelling since 2014 are one of the reasons for the Russian special military operation in Donbass and Ukraine

    • September 11, 2022

    Ségolène Royal is a former member of the French Socialist Party, presidential candidate in 2007 and minister. On September 1, 2022, on French news private channel BFMTV, she has dared question the war crimes, that the Russian forces would have committed in Ukraine, according to the catechism of the Western mainstream media

    […] Everyone knows that this is fear war propaganda. Moreover, if only the first event, which was told, the shelled motherhood [March 2022 in Mariupol], when Mr. Zelenskyy toured the European parliaments. And this is where the peace process broke down. He used that, he said : I met a pregnant woman who said to me : avenge me… etc He was unable to give us the name of this woman, we did not know the names of the victims. And you can imagine that if there had been the slightest victim, the slightest baby with blood, in the age of cell phones, we would have seen them. There is enough horror in war […] it is monstrous to go and broadcast things like that, just to interrupt the peace process […]

    She has triggered outrage within the journalistic coterie. Interesting how the lie about the alleged Russian war crimes is the cornerstone of the Atlanticist narrative.

    Anyway, the issue is free expression and on September 11, the sentence is imposed. The link is broken, said Marc-Olivier Fogiel, a professional courtier and the current managing director of BFMTV. Royal is now formally persona no grata on the channel.

    • September 27, 2022

    Twitter bans Levi Godman (cf. supra, August 30, 2022), after he has written

    the people of the DPR/LPR are having this high vote turnout, because they were shelled for 8 years, their families killed and leaders assassinated

    Yet, facts (shelling, assassinations) and an inference about the splendid popular turnout in the referendums in Donbass and southern Ukraine for the return to the Russian Federation

    Fortunately, he is still writing on Telegram.

    • October 11, 2022

    Based in Paris, Libération is rather a fanzine for young woke urban readers than a real national newspaper. Its editor publishes on cover the same shocking photo which appears in most British tabloids, but no other French newspaper

    The head injury may be real, light in this case, but the day after, a video will surface and disclose to the public the staging and a swarm of photographs around merry victims

    take a photo of me, Andrej Andreevich. I take a selfie and will send it to my sister in Russia

    The scene has occurred in Kiev, on October 10, Libération describes a terror strategy, while Russia is conducting during several days, all over Ukraine, a heavy offensive of strategic airstrikes against command and communication centers, power plants and other energy facilities. The New York Times disagrees

    the Russian missile attacks that killed at least 19 people across Ukraine on Monday were wide-ranging, but they were not as deadly as they could have been. That has renewed questions over the quality of Russia’s weapons

    Simply unbelievable. The Ukrainian government is demanding that its citizens reduce to 75% their usual energy consumption and the country stops exporting electricity. I guess that Russia has reached its goals, but Vietnamese, Iraqi and Libyan civilians may know what are good quality weapons.

    That is the state of the Western press.

    • October 19, 2022

    BFMTV is the French news private TV channel which has already banned former socialist minister Ségolène Royal, because on September 1, she had dared question the catechism of Russian war crimes in Ukraine. BFMTV is providing a ready-made thinking to all those who are working too much to repay their loans, all the intellectually needy who are nevertheless seeking to shine about news.

    Anne-Laure Banse is reporting from Kherson region

    the evacuation of this city is occurring in view of the advance of Ukrainian troops, in the course of the counteroffensive which is currently underway in the south of the country. Moscow has admitted that the situation is indeed tense for the Russian soldiers in the field. Kherson has been annexed by Russia at the end of September and is now the regular target of Ukrainian strikes at its infrastructure, like hospitals [… OFFLINE]

    oh… we have lost Anne-Laure Banse

    adds the anchorman.

    • October 29, 2022

    The day before, the new boss Elon Musk has sacked Vijaya Gadde, the sergeant major of censorship on Twitter. Scott Ritter (cf. supra, April 12) has tested the reliability of the US social network. The result is negative. Bucha narrative is the backbone of the Western catechism about Ukraine

    • October 31, 2022

    The Intercept reports that in years of internal memos, emails, as well as public documents, the Department of Homeland Security has outlined its strategy and priorities, is targeting inaccurate information on a wide range of topics, including now the nature of US support to Ukraine, through pressure on private platforms like Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn (Microsoft)… etc

    • November 1, 2022

    Great news : the État français [French State] has demanded the censorship of Russian channels on Canadian Rumble video platform, which deactivates its access from France

    The complete corporate statement is

    recently, the French Government demanded that we remove certain Russian news sources from Rumble. As part of our mission to restore a free and open internet, we have committed not to move the goalposts on our content policies. Users with unpopular views are free to access our platform on the same terms as our millions of other users. Accordingly, we have decided to disable access to Rumble for users in France while we challenge the legality of the government’s demands. This decision will not have a material effect on our business, as France represents less than one percent of our users. The French people, however, will lose access to a wide range of Rumble content because of these government demands. We hope the French Government reconsiders its decision so we can restore access soon

    Emmanuel Macron’s successive governments, their political police (DGSI), are the world unchallenged champions in censorship demands on social networks.

    • November 11, 2022

    Funny stuff, I have tested Mastodon, a European federate social network under German law, where the most conventional rebels are fleeing from Twitter, after Elon Musk’s profession of faith about free speech

    My account survived four days, a rich experience, where my fellows has offered me several awards : PUTIN TROLL, TOXIC BEHAVIOR… etc

    • November 16, 2022

    After the incident in Przewodow, where the Ukrainian air defense has shot down an agricultural tractor on Polish territory, the question is accident or crime ? Did Ukraine attempt to provoke the involvement of NATO ? As usual, hysterical Baltic officials and most Western media broadcast the Ukrainian accusations against Russia, when evidences had already been found that the shot was Ukrainian, the debris of a missile from a S-300 system. The day after, Kim Dotcom summarizes

    • November 17, 2022

    Tucker Carlson reacts to the fake news that most Western media have broadcasted about the incident in Przewodow, where Ukrainian air defense has actually shot down a Polish agricultural tractor

    https://youtu.be/HMHBsHtolCA
    • November 30, 2022

    A new low for reliability on the web, such a disgrace for the Anglo-Saxon censors, Wikipedia has censored the English article about the Alley of Angels, the memorial in Donetsk, in tribute to the children whom the Ukrainian shelling have killed in the city since 2014

    At 2:00 pm, Paris time, a small French version is still online.

    • December 13, 2022

    A hilarious way to hear good news : Mykhailo Podolyak is a Ukrainian propagandist and advisor to Volodymyr Zelenskyy, becomes burlesque when he whines about the suppression of the Ukrainian bots since Elon Musk has taken control of Twitter

    • December 16, 2022

    The Twitter Files are shedding a technical light on the issue. Their sixth episode is Twitter, the FBI subsidiary

    https://twitter.com/mtaibbi/status/1603857534737072128

    Within the bureau, the Foreign Influence Task Force (FITF) has been formed in 2017, in order to identify and counteract malign foreign influence operations targeting the United States. Its agents were correspondents of the social networking service. In the cases exposed, they did not flag foreign agents but lambda US users, whose accounts

    may [have] potentially constitute[d] violations of Twitter’s Terms of Service, for any action or inaction deemed appropriate within Twitter policy

    I know that administrative language, could have written that message. The tone was not imperative but actually, the FBI was requesting censorship. It was up to Twitter to find, in its moderation tools, the pretexts for satisfying the requests. Among the cases exposed, a total of 23 flagged accounts, 11 were permanently suspended

    Many tweets were no more than obvious jokes and political satyrs. From my experience in law enforcement and intelligence, I guess that the agents were required to some return, in order to justify their collective payroll. Their production was the volume of suspended accounts. That is my French understating of the mechanism.

    Censorship is a weird mission for investigators or intelligence officers. I have started working before social networks, before web at home, do not understand that strategy. Quite the contrary, social networks are a prolific source of information. That reminds the censorship or self censorship in mainstream media, where alleged journalists seem more concerned with fighting disinformation than reporting information, in Western societies that marketing has rotten to the core, where reality has no more significance.

    • January 21, 2023

    This is an instance of the atavistic State censorship in France

    Under the 9th European package of sanctions against Russia, since December 16, 2022, the French State has frozen the bank accounts of RT (Russia Today) France TV channel, which is forced to cease its activity that day.

    The Russian special military operation in Ukraine is also an opportunity for Emmanuel Macron to muzzle a channel which has broadcast fair reports about the crackdown on the Gilets Jaunes protestors (2018 – ?). The prostitutes who are populating the French mainstream media will be satisfied.

    • January 5, 2023

    So vulgar and hilarious, a great moment of French TV, when private channel LCI reaches a low where French media have not fallen for about 80 years, when Philippe Henriot was minister of information within the French fascist State under Philippe Pétain. A panel discusses the plan that the Ukrainian Nazi deep State has drawn up, in order to decolonize Crimea. The journalists and self-claimed experts do not criticize that project of ethnic cleansing. They detail it with complacency

    • deportation of Russian residents,
    • Ukrainian immigration,
    • derussification of the administration

    I have never liked these people. The speed of their fall is however surprising, confirms how I was right about them. That TV channel is right-wing, usually chauvinistic. The particular indecency of these words lies in the history, that the participants do not ignore, of their own country. Their Police nationale and gendarmerie were involved in the deportation and genocide of Jews during WW2, while the Red Army was defeating the European Nazi armies on the east front. Their country triggered the European colonization of Africa after 1870, was so proud of its empire colonial that even after WW2, it carried out two criminal colonial wars and fortunately, lost both, in Indochina (1946 – 1954) and Algeria (1954 – 1962). Quatremer dares compare Crimea to Algeria, where the Europeans, 9% of the population, emigrated to France during the war and after independence. But according to his own figures, the Russians are more than 66% in Crimea. The Ukrainian minority is sharing there the same rights, nothing in common with the apartheid system that France had enforced in Algeria for the sake of a white minority. I am confident that Quatremer will not achieve in Crimea his revenge for the French defeat in Algeria, the third one in 22 years. These heinous commenters are Russophobic because they are suffering from an inferiority complex.

    • May 17, 2023

    Among numerous liars and mercantile pen pushers who are nowadays populating Western mainstream media, French ones are undoubtedly the worst stooges. I guess the issue is atavistic or otherwise, congenital, a strong courtiers culture

    On May 16, a Russian Kinzhal [dagger] hypersonic missile has managed to destroy in Kiev a US Patriot air defense system, which has launched at least, but in vain, 20 surface-to-air missiles (SAMs) in the previous minutes. CCTV cameras have recorded the event, which is undeniable. The US administration has acknowledged that the Patriot has been hit and even CNN has told that failure. But Volodymyr Zelenskyy is always lying, has stated that without loss the Ukrainian air defense would have shot down six Kinzhals during the raid. However, their debris are nowhere, while the wrecks of several SAMs are found in Kiev

    About 36 hours later, French mainstream media are still broadcasting the Ukrainian propaganda, the myth of the alleged success of the Atlanticist air defense. Not a single report in France about reality. Le Figaro, for example, writes that Kinzhal would be inefficient.

    Meanwhile in Kiev, in the Ukrainian democracy, CCTV cameras are no more functional and the State security agency (SBU) arrests six bloggers who have broadcast footage of the raid.

    Another French syndrome is catechism, since the time when the country was alleging itself the eldest daughter of the church. Many pretended intellectuals have begun with the adoption of an ideology, are later attempting to convert the facts, are denying what is not in compliance with their ideology.

    On May 14, when Volodymyr Zelenskyy was awarded the Karlspreis [Charlemagne price] in Germany, for the defense of Europe and its values, during an event that Bundeskanzler Olaf Scholz and Ursula von der Leyen, president of the European Commission, attended, I wrote in French a piece which is reminding that during WW2, the French SS division, for the defense of Europe, was already named Charlemagne, while nowadays, the legacy of the Ukrainian SS Galizien division is widespread within the armed forces, that Ukraine is celebrating every year, since 2015, the foundation of the UPA, a Nazi paramilitary organization which slaughtered at least 50,000 Polish civilians between 1942 and 1944, conducted later a guerilla, in collaboration with the German SS intelligence (Sicherheitsdienst), against the Soviet liberators. Only undeniable facts and inferences

    I have shared that piece in the blog part of Mediapart, an alleged collaborative and independent online newspaper. Wokism is the main flag of Mediapart, whose tone is also plaintive. But when the subject is more serious -I do not think that people’s sexuality is a major issue- the editorial production is feeble, to say the least. On may 15, for example, correspondent Justine Brabant reported, as an investigation about the Ukrainian morale, from a hospital in Ukraine, where some of the injured servicemen were eager to go back to war. The article is reminding a Monty Python comedy and above all, the journalist has not yet interviewed the forced conscripts whom the military police is abducting in the streets, nor the women who are demonstrating in the cities, failing news about their dead relatives, who are still supposed missing

    The experiment is conclusive. The editorial team restricts today my access and censors my piece about Charlemagne. Of course, I cancel then my subscription, which was still free during a few week. The editor-in-chief is Edwy Plenel, a professional journalist whom the socialist government wiretapped in the 80s. When a judicial case was opened, a former official explained to the court in 2005 that Plenel was a CIA operative. I suspect that he is nowadays close to George Soros. De facto, the editorial line is NEVER against NATO.

    • May 25, 2023

    Le Monde was once a baseline evening newspaper in France, when I was a kid. Its correspondent in Ukraine writes about a few hundred Russian anti-Putin militants, who on May 22, have carried out a raid in Russia, Belgorod region. Noise and panic were the goals. Fake alarming messages were simultaneously addressed to the Russian citizens through social networks. Under the aegis of the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR), the raid was a psychological operation (PSYOP), in order to elude the humiliating defeat in Bakhmut. Le Monde is regarding these militants as partisans.

    That article is a new milestone in the fall of Western mainstream media, a symptom of the Orwellian state of Western societies, the société du spectacle, has already written Guy Debord

    The disgrace is huge : the members of Svoboda Rossii [Free Russia] and Russkiy dobrovol’cheskiy korpus [Russian Volunteer Corps, RDK] are well known Nazi militants, like their leader at the center of that photo, Denis Kapustin, who have fled Russia and settled in Ukraine, the first ones in 2014, after the right-wing coup in Kiev.

    • June 7, 2023

    For the Grayzone, Canadian journalist Aaron Maté reveals how in March 2022, seven months before Elon Musk bought Twitter, the FBI requested the censorship of 163 user accounts, on the behalf of the Ukrainian State security agency (SBU), which is regarding as disinformation anything non-compliant with the Ukrainian official narrative and was also demanding users data

    That proven case does not rule out other instances of US State censorship on the behalf of Ukraine. The list included lambda users, several Russian journalists and Aaron Maté. The former executives of the social networking service were rather moderating protagonists, censored 34 accounts under their own rules and for motives like inauthenticity.

    • June 14, 2023

    Stepan Bandera, die 14. Waffen-Grenadier-Division der SS, Galizien, the war in Donbass has taught us since 2014 that the Ukrainians are in love with stamps. While the Atlanticist counteroffensive is a bloody failure, new ones are honoring the formal chief of staff, Valerii Zaluzhnyi, who however, has not shown signs of life for more than one month, may be in severe condition or even dead

    Moreover, in a wide disinformation campaign through mainstream media in the US and Germany, he is also referred as the sole organizer of the attack against Nord Stream pipelines, on September 26, 2022. Zaluzhnyi is a convenient hero.

    • July 25, 2023

    How hopeless the situation must be for NATO propaganda. Hilarious fail on its YouTube channel for the British Sun tabloid, which is much more reliable when the subject is more slight, like for example the royal family

    The Russian tank engulfs in flames after direct hit by Ukrainian missiles is actually an Atlanticist Leopard 2A6 Panzerkampfwagen, that a Russian Lancet drone demilitarizes. A large part of the public notices the pathetic disinformation attempt and the comments thread is a nightmare for the editorial team. Unlike French, Brits do not like to be played for fools.

    The original document is not showing an anecdotal event, the Atlanticist counteroffensive in the south, between Zaporojie region and Donetsk People’s Republic, is a bloody failure since early June.

    • August 2, 2023

    Wanda Lurie (1911-1989) was a miracle, she survived several gun shots, a baby in her womb, while the Nazi forces were slaughtering about 50,000 people in Wola neighborhood of Warsaw, between August 5 and 8, 1944

    Her testimony is famous, was used for example at Nuremberg trials. One quote is

    I begged the Ukrainians around us to save the children and one of them asked me if I could redeem myself. I gave him 3 gold rings. Having taken it, he wanted to take me out, but the German officer in charge of the execution, the gendarme officer who noticed it, did not allow me and ordered me to join the group to be shot

    From Nachtigall battalion in 1941 to Schutzmannschaft [protection team, auxiliary police], UPA militiamen and SS in 1943, many Ukrainians have joined the Nazi forces during WW2. Most of them were nationalists, whose political leader was Stepan Bandera. All are regarded nowadays as popular and sometimes, official national heroes, in Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s Ukraine, especially within the armed forces.

    In the context of the proxy war that NATO is conducting against Russia, in Donbass and Ukraine, the support to Zelenskyy and also, the same Ukrainian nationalists, their involvement in Nazi crimes during WW2 has become an unbearable disgrace for the Western civilization, which is currently fighting the Asiatic hordes. The solution is lie and in the case of Wanda Lurie, history forgery.

    Public Polish channel TVP Info publishes a piece about Wola massacre, where Lurie’s testimony is counterfeit. The same quote becomes

    I begged the Germans around us to save the children and one of them asked me if I could redeem myself. I gave him 3 gold rings. Having taken it, he wanted to take me out, but the German officer in charge of the execution, the gendarme officer who noticed it, did not allow me and ordered me to join the group to be shot

    After the outrage in independent media and social networks, the mistake will be rectified several days later

    • August 11, 2023

    YouTube has terminated his channel. 62-year-old Scott Ritter is a former intelligence officer within the US Marine Corps (USMC), then inspector of the United Nations in Iraq. When in 2003, the US and their British minions were about to invade the country under this false pretext, Ritter was claiming that there was no weapon of mass destruction (WMD) there. He was right.

    Here is his interview by George Galloway, on March 11, 2022, two weeks after the beginning of the Russian special military operation in Donbass and Ukraine, about the Ukrainian context and the Nazi deep State since 2014

    https://youtu.be/AYm8pDrIXBg

    On April 12, 2022 (cf. supra), Twitter banned Ritter, because he was arguing that the alleged Russian atrocities in Bucha were actually a staging and real Ukrainian false flag war crimes. I am agreeing with him.

    US-funded Center for countering disinformation at the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine (cf. supra, July 18, 2022) was reporting, as information terrorists, 78 foreign analysts, journalists, politicians or scholars who were not compliant with NATO narrative. Ritter was in the list.

    His last videos were Agent Zelensky, Part 1 & 2, about an incredible manipulation, how an ordinary comedian who came to power because he promised a long-awaited peace, dragged his fellow citizens into a bloody massacre. They are likely the reason for that censorship. Ritter’s website is still online.

    • September 6, 2023

    At 2:04 pm, an explosion ravages the market place in Konstantinovka, in the deep of the still Ukraine-occupied part of Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR), 25 km to the southwest of Bakhmut and the front line. Logically and according to the Ukrainian authorities too, the provisional toll is high, at least 16 victims are already dead less than two hours later. A tragedy

    Volodymyr Zelenskyy accuses Russia and publish on social networks a video which is showing the explosion. The CCTV camera is well located and the footage is high quality

    https://youtube.com/watch?v=C2fb6vZKoQc%3Fversion%3D3%26rel%3D1%26showsearch%3D0%26showinfo%3D1%26iv_load_policy%3D1%26fs%3D1%26hl%3Den%26autohide%3D2%26wmode%3Dtransparent

    As usual, most Western media, stooges of the Atlanticist narrative, are regarding the Ukrainian statement as reliable and quickly blame Russia, without the least checking.

    But the video is good enough to show us that when the sound of the engine is heard, people look in the direction where the missile comes from, more or less toward the camera. And that direction is northwest, even deeper in the Ukraine-controlled part of DNR. With no doubt, the missile is an Atlanticist one

    (Military Informant)
    (Military Informant)

    Russia would have been clumsy, to say the least, to target civilians while Secretary of State Antony Blinken is visiting Kiev

    In contrast, I have already assessed that in such occasion, Ukraine is able to commit false flag war crimes. A Ukrainian ballistic missile hit Kramatorsk railway station on April 8, 2022, when the guest in Kiev was the president of the European commission, Ursula von der Leyen. Both cities are in Donbass, where the inhabitants are Russian-speaking and widely pro-Russia. The Ukrainian nationalists are feeling enough hatred to slaughter them for PR purpose, all the more when the Atlanticist counter-offensive is a bloody failure and Ukraine needs more support than ever from NATO.

    In the case of Kramatork, all Western politicians parroted the Ukrainian propaganda, but today, Blinken does not even comment the civilian casualties in Konstantinovka. Annalena Baerbock, the pathetic German foreign affairs minister, is alone when she blames Russia in the evening.

    Julian Röpcke is a Russophobic editor for German tabloid Bild, but a conscientious journalist. Paradoxical situation, he tells reality, that the missile has struck Konstantinovka from the northwest, while in most Western media, the courtiers are carrying on deliberately spreading the Ukrainian fake news. Facts and reality are of no importance to them, their job is propaganda. The collapse of the so-called Western civilization is a promising show.

    • February 15, 2024

    While the Atlanticist forces are committing once more a terrorist attack in Russia, the deliberate shelling of civilians in Belgorod, the French authorities censor 20 French-speaking channels on Telegram, as a retaliation for their ouster from Africa and the failure of their proxy war against Russia, two weeks after the death in Ukraine of two French operatives, whom Paris falsely introduced as humanitarian workers

    When fascist leader Philippe Pétain (1856-1951) was heading the French State between 1940 and 1944, Philippe Henriot (1889-1944) was Secrétaire d’État à l’information et à la propagande [Secretary of State for Information and Propaganda]. France is still the homeland of slavish journalism and a tiny country, but the world champion, in absolute terms, of censorship on social networks, since the rise of Emmanuel Macron to power in 2017. And in 2018, Macron attempted to rehabilitate Philippe Pétain

    • August 15, 2024

    When French journalists seem to discover that the Ukrainian army is plagued by Nazis, that shows how petty the French can be

    On August 6, 2024, the Atlanticist forces have launched toward Kursk, Russia, an offensive which is reminding the battle of the Bulge. In December 1944, the European fascist armies had irretrievably lost against Soviet Union and Nazi Germany attacked on the west front, in a far-fetched attempt to reach a separate peace with Anglo-US allies. The Ukrainian operation is a foolish attempt to terrorize Russian civilians, ward off defeat with a PR stunt and quickly gain territories through a less defended Russian border region, in the prospect of negotiations that the Western puppet is starting evoking, while the Atlanticist forces are unable to contain the Russian onslaught in Donbass

    LCI is a major private news channel in France and as such, one vector for Atlanticist propaganda. NATO and Ukraine can rely on LCI and others in France for their PR stunt in Kursk region. One Ukrainian amateur video appears on August 15. It is controversial but has already buzzed, so the fast news channel cannot bypass it. One Ukrainian fighter boasts on Russian territory with a WW2 SS helmet on his head. The studio is populated with journalists and other lackeys, the latter appointed as experts. Their reaction is priceless. One suggests that the Nazi serviceman should take his helmet off before recording a video. Another complains that the scene breaks a communication strategy.

    • August 24, 2024

    The vile cops, lackeys of the administrative authorities, failing to be justice auxiliaries, on orders from the French state, lackey of NATO, arrest Pavel Durov in Le Bourget. The Franco-Russian citizen is founder and boss of encrypted messaging service Telegram. His company is based in the United Arab Emirates

    I am a daily user of the application, which is allowing me to exchange with sources who are enriching my work on French involvement in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine.

    Fabricated from scratch for political reasons, the file of the archers du guet [French police rank and file], allegedly investigators, is evoking dark offenses ranging from fraud, drug trafficking, cyberbullying, organized crime, including the glorification of terrorism and fraud [Le Monde]. The charges are ridiculous. The management of a messaging service cannot be prosecuted for what some its users possibly do with it. I am eager to know the outcome of the custody, if a judge will be servile enough to plagiarize a mediocre police, which is acting on the orders of the administrative authorities

    Actually, the French state, whose pétainiste [traditional French far right] legacy is atavistic, if not congenital, does not forgive him for having refused to give the FBI, then the pinzuti [French, in Corsican], the technical means to spy on Telegram users. But in the US, liberty is not an empty word

    It is always useful to remember that under Emmanuel Macron, France is the world champion, in absolute value, not in relation to the population, of the number of requests for censorship on social networks, for political reasons, not justice.

    • September 26, 2024

    For Perspectives on Terrorism, Canadian and US political scientists Ivan Katchanovski and Max Abrahms publish a major study on the issue of fascism in modern Ukraine, its role and weight in the conflict since 2014. How Western political, media and even academic spheres are downplaying that reality for the public, even whitewashing the fascist players and their crimes, especially after the beginning on February 24, 2022, of the Russian special military operation in Donbass and Ukraine.

    • November 11, 2024

    When I was a young police lieutenant in Paris, at the beginning of the 90s, Le Parisien [The Parisian] was known as la main-courante de la PP, mouthpiece of the Préfecture de police, police headquarters in the capital. The daily newspaper has apparently become the mouthpiece of the poorest Ukrainian nationalist propaganda. With a hilarious mawkishness, it reports the deaths in combat and funerals of two lovers within the Ukrainian armed forces : Valentyna Nahorna and Daniil Liashkevych. Here is the translation of the first seconds of the video report that Le Parisien publishes today on its Instagram channel. Let us take out the handkerchiefs

    Her name was Valentina ; his name was Daniil ; they were in love and they died on the front line in Ukraine […]

    […] his heart was filled with love […]

    adds Liashkevych’s ex wife. Let us have a look. He was a fascist hooligan and as soon as 2014, at the beginning of the civil war in Ukraine, against the Russian-speaking inhabitants of Donbass who were demanding autonomy but whom the far-right power in Kiev was calling terrorists, he joined Azov battalion, a Nazi paramilitary special police formation within the Ukrainian national guard. His call sign was Berserk, a psychopath viking warrior

    Her call sign was Valkyrie and believe me, that was not a tribute to Claus von Stauffenberg. Her Instagram id was valkyria_ab3, where ab3 was standing for 3rd assault brigade. More confidential, her TikTok account was valkyria__88, where 88 was standing for HH, i.e. Heil Hitler

    Both would have been combat medics, as we already know that the Atlanticist service members, when killed or prisoners, are either combat medics or cooks. Both were members of the 3rd assault brigade, emanation of Azov Nazi organization in the Ukrainian regular army. Its commander is Andriy Biletsky, founder of Azov in 2014 and current leader of the National Corps, a Nazi political party in Ukraine

    Both were killed on November 1, 2024. I have investigated on Telegram, briefly exchanged with Ukrainian Nazi militants who are regarding both as heroes of white Europa and are entitled to express such view. My point is rather the editorial line of Le Parisien.

    I have already spotted the newspaper red-handed in vile media manipulations, for example on September 4, 2022 (cf. supra). As illustration of the alleged genocide that Russia would be committing in Ukraine, Le Parisien published a photo that Alexander Ermochenko had actually taken in Donetsk on September 2. He was showing a victim of the usual Ukrainian deliberate terrorist shelling, since 2014, of the Russian-speaking civilians.

    • December 4, 2024

    While the Western leaders are risking a nuclear war through NATO strategic strikes on Russian territory and are exploiting the rumor of North Korean fighters in the Russian ranks as pretext, the British tabloid Daily Mail affirms that

    Kim Jong Un sends North Korean women to fight as cannon fodder for Putin in Ukraine

    Will Stewart and Miriam Kuepper publish in their article the picture of two alleged North Korean female fighters in Kursk region, which besides, is a Russian territory, not Ukraine

    But, the picture is actually tampered. The original one is a screenshot from a video released on February 2, 2023, which was showing two twin sisters from Donetsk People’s Republic, who are fighting for the liberation of Donbass

    Caught red-handed in a huge fake, thanks to social networks, the Daily Mail starts with the deletion without explanation of the article, apologizes several hours later.

    • April 16, 2025

    Today is the 80th anniversary of the final Soviet offensive, which across Oder river and Seelow heights, led the Red Army to Berlin, less than 100 km away, where the German Nazi state was annihilated 23 days later. Deutsche Welle, a German public TV channel under an alleged social-democratic government, contrives to release a disgusting video. The complacent report of secret military camps in Ukraine where

    kids as young as 10 are getting combat ready

    80 years ago in Germany, during the battle for Berlin, kids as young as 16, within the Volkssturm [People’s Assault], became the last Nazi cannon fodder

    Moreover, these camps are not secret at all. They are reflecting the issue of Nazi infection within the Ukrainian state. They are not state-run but state-sponsored. Nazi youth organizations like Centuria, the youth branch of Azov, are managing them. No journalist can be unaware of that ideological aspect. But Deutsche Welle does not report it.

    • August 13, 2025

    The Times commits an article titled

    Putin fears him – 20,000 Ukrainians want to fight for him

    In the context of the proxy war that Western Europe is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia, the British newspaper, without scruples nor complexes, praises Andriy Biletsky, the leader of Nazi National Corps party and commander of the new 3rd Army Corps, which is holding 12% of the Ukrainian front line and was formed around the 3rd assault brigade, emanation of Nazi Azov organization in the Ukrainian regular army. He assures the Western arms companies of his collaboration

    Our great advantage is that we provide debriefings, test results, and actual data from the battlefield

    I can reply to the British journalists that Nazism is indeed growing on the Ukrainian military-political scene, but I am sorry to rectify: Vladimir Putin does not fear the Nazi paramilitary leader. Europe should.

    • September 1, 2025

    September 1 is the anniversary of WW2. In order to justify the invasion of Poland, Germany staged a fake Polish attack. Ursula von der Leyen, the German president of the European Commission, flied to Bulgaria on August 31, 2025, but according the day after to Western press agencies, based on statement from her staff, her plane would have been the target of a Russian aggression. Here is the translation of an excerpt from French AFP

    The plane carrying European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen was the victim of « GPS jamming » upon its arrival in Bulgaria on Sunday, her team announced, claiming that Russia was suspected of being behind the act

    Like smallpox on lower clergy, the European mainstream media rush on the dispatch and write articles with titles like

    Russia behind GPS jamming of Ursula von der Leyen’s plane?

    A few hours later, the management of the Swedish company which is providing famous Flightradar24 application states on X

    We are seeing media reports of GPS interference affecting the plane carrying Ursula von der Leyen to Plovdiv, Bulgaria. Some reports claim that the aircraft was in a holding pattern for 1 hour. This is what we can deduce from our data

    ٭ The flight was scheduled to take 1 hour and 48 minutes. It took 1 hour and 57 minutes;

    ٭ The aircraft’s transponder reported good GPS signal quality from take-off to landing

    and clarifies later

    The transponder signal transmitted by the aircraft contains a NIC value. The NIC value encodes the quality and consistency of navigational data received by the aircraft. Flightradar24 is using these NIC values to create the GPS jamming map at https://flightradar24.com/data/gps-jamming. The flight with Ursula von der Leyen on board transmitted a good NIC value from take-off to landing

    Clear and indisputable, die alte Schlampe and her staff lied. But not a single European presstitute rectifies his previous article.

    • September 13, 2025

    The Daily Telegraph publishes a glowing article titled

    We won’t stop until Putin falls, say the Russians fighting against him

    The Telegraph meets members of the RDK, who have sacrificed civilian life to stand up to their dictator

    Alas, the British journalists forget to inform their readers over the political identity of the Russkiy dobrovol’cheskiy korpus [Russian Volunteer Corps]. Under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR), the paramilitary formation, maybe a few dozen or hundred-strong, is populated with Russian Nazi militants, some racist criminal fugitives, who have sought refuge in Ukraine after the 2014 West-backed right-wing coup in Kiev

    Some like to bear the patch of the Russian Liberation Army (Russkaya Osvoboditel’naya Armiya, ROA, 1942-1945), Wehrmacht auxiliaries during WW2.

    • December 15, 2025

    Emmanuel Macron is among the European leaders who queue up in Berlin, staging their vacuity to whine and beg once again from the United States. They seem to ignore that the outcome of a war is decided on the battlefield. The Donbass will be liberated by diplomacy or force, whether they like it or not. On the same day, the Council of Europe sanctions several individuals, including Swiss expert Jacques Baud, who according to the statement

    is serving as mouthpiece for pro-Russia propaganda and is spreading conspiracy theories

    The accusation is ludicrous. Jacques Baud has been a Swiss intelligence colonel, specialized in Eastern Europe. Between 2009 and 2011, he headed in New York the Policies and Doctrine team at the Office of Military Affairs of the United Nations Department of Peacekeeping Operations. He participated in NATO programs in Ukraine in 2014 and 2017. His rigor and analytical skills are considerable

    So why that administrative punishment? As early as the end of 2022, like many others and myself, the expert reported the reality: the West is undergoing a humiliating defeat in Donbass and Ukraine. Washington has understood that too. It seems to be gaining traction with the masses today, since according to the vast hysterical majority of French press employees, Russian tanks are dangerously approaching the place de l’Étoile

    Radio Free Europe, a CIA outlet, revealed his sanctions as early as December 10 and the targeted individual was able to comment on them. Upon learning that, I thought I smelled a foul odor, a bit like the breath of Philippe Henriot (1889-1944), Secretary for Information and Propaganda of the French State, a great French voice whom communist resistance fighters snatched from the affection of his family. He bears his usual deranged expression in Brussels, when Jean-Noël Barrot confirms that these sanctions have been taken at the initiative of France

    I believe the Minister of Foreign Affairs is foolish enough to retaliate out of spite for his proxy defeat in Donbass and Ukraine. Because his punishment will amplify the success of Jacques Baud’s excellent analyses

    If the goal is rather to discourage resistance to Western disinformation, then I fear that the French, as is often the case, have projected their own shortcomings. With each passing day, their government is fueling nasty prejudices about them: fearful, petty, coward, incompetent, and arrogant.

    • December 19, 2025

    I have been glad to speak with a Russian journalist for a documentary that Russia Today, censored in Europe but widely watched in the United States, Africa or China, broadcasts today.

    • April 10, 2026

    Since 2022, I am writing a chronicle about French fighters in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine. Their publications on social media are my primary source, that I am often cross-checking with other data, like for example information from mass media reports. I have established that more than half of them are Nazi or pétainistes [traditional French far-right, the heirs of Philippe Pétain, French fascist head of State during WW2] activists

    The French satirical weekly Canard Enchaîné newspaper, in his quarterly « files » supplement, publishes today an article titled

    Russian Interference : Figures of Putin’s Shadow Army in France

    where yours truly is mentioned, alongside Swiss analyst Jacques Baud -whom the Council of Europe unjustly sanctioned (cf. supra, December 15, 2025) at the instigation of France- pacifist journalist Xenia Fedorova -whom the Council of Europe will unjustly sanction on September 24, at the instigation of France- and others

    That paper about interference is a piece of disinformation, a web of lies. The unnamed presstitute accuses me of forgery

    In particular, his right-thinking is unable to tolerate an authentic picture, which is showing a Ukrainian flag with swastika.

    I will forward my reply to the pitiful Gallic duck, which will not publish it.

    • August 23, 2026

    Since June, the owner of The Telegraph is Axel Springer mass media company, led by CEO Mathias Döpfner, a pro-Israel zealot and the kind of German who believes, from one genocide to another, that an extreme support to Tel Aviv would clean his breed from the Nazi crimes. Moreover, Heini Kraut has not accepted so far the victory of Soviet Union over Nazi Germany and is fantasizing about a revenge against Russia.

    The British daily newspaper publishes today a piece of anthology, in the fields of bad faith, perversion and propaganda

    While the prospect of women mobilization becomes a trending issue in Ukraine, that article presents that enlargement of draft as the empowerment of women and a necessity of gender-equality

    Actually, the issue is trending because Ukraine is lacking men. Via amateur videos on social media, the forced mobilization of draft dodgers is a cruel daily spectacle. The Russian army is inexorably gaining ground on the battlefield and Ukraine has already lost more than two millions KIA men. The Ukrainian regime and its Western sponsors desperately need more cannon fodder for its consumption in the meat grinder.