Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu
Marco Rubio’s speeches invoking a shared Western civilization are part of the ideological consolidation of fascism, mobilizing white racial solidarity to defend a declining capitalist order
Bally Bagayoko, the mayor of St. Denis, France, standing between student protesters and police
We want allies who can defend themselves so that no adversary will ever be tempted to test our collective strength. This is why we do not want our allies to be shackled by guilt and shame. We want allies who are proud of their culture and of their heritage, who understand that we are heirs to the same great and noble civilization, and who, together with us, are willing and able to defend it [Marco Rubio speech at Munich Security Conference, February 2026]
And the world communism envisions is a world without God. For these architects of revolutionary violence, the towering achievement of our civilization – for them it’s an unbearable humiliation, a reminder of what they cannot do and a reminder of what they cannot be. So they choose instead to destroy. They attack pipelines; they attack railroads; they attack power grids and laboratories, the physical embodied symbols of power and invention and achievement. This is the nature of the terrorism we face today. They despise the West because the West is great [Marco Rubio, U.S. Ministerial on the Resurgence of Political Terrorism]
Marco Rubio’s July 16, 2026, speech at the opening of the U.S. Ministerial on the Resurgence of Political Terrorism should be understood as part of the ideological consolidation of fascism in the West. Its significance extends beyond the criminalization of the radical left. Rubio invokes a supposedly shared Western civilization to mobilize white racial and cultural solidarity in defense of a moribund order whose economic foundations are in irreversible decline. But it is precisely that decline that explains the pathetic weaponization of an idea of Western civilizational superiority that must be protected. Rubio understands his audience and the anxiety generated by the decline of the Western European colonial/capitalist era. Rubio and the other white supremacists making political and economic policy in the United States from Elon Musk and Peter Thiel – both from apartheid Southern Africa – to U.S. President Donald Trump. They understand that this civilizational framing is shared, in different forms, by rightist political forces across Europe—from Marine Le Pen and Éric Zemmour in France to Germany’s Alternative for Germany (AfD), Austria’s Freedom Party (FPÖ), and Nigel Farage’s Reform Party political movement in Britain.
This brings me to what is referred to as the French student uprising. African, Arab, and Muslim students and youth from working-class Paris banlieue suburbs played a significant role in the mobilization against deteriorating educational conditions and diminishing prospects for their futures. Their presence generated a violent ideological reaction as intense as the violence unleashed on the students by the French police. It was precisely the racialized character of the uprising that enabled right-wing political forces across Europe to recast a struggle over material conditions as a conflict over immigration, Islam, and European identity, even as increasing numbers of white French workers joined the protests and the demands expanded to cover all of the contradictions produced by four decades of neoliberal policies in France.
The political right understood what mainstream reporting often de-centers: the participation of racialized youth provided an opportunity to distort demands for social justice produced by the contradictions of capitalism as an assault on European civilization. The student becomes the immigrant; the immigrant becomes the cultural enemy; and the cultural enemy becomes a security threat whose presence justifies repression and ultimately expulsion!
This is the dangerous convergence embedded in Rubio’s politics: left, Black, Muslim, “terrorist” that collapses legitimate political opposition, racial and religious identity, and terrorism into a single ideological and security threat. Anti-capitalist and anti-imperialist politics become evidence of hostility to “civilization,” while the political agency of African and Muslim youth is treated as an existential threat to the state. The consequence is a framework both in the U.S. and Europe that legitimizes expanded state surveillance, police violence, and the criminalization of dissent.
It must be understood with unambiguous historical clarity that what is unfolding in Europe and the U.S. is not a turn to something called authoritarianism but the consolidation of fascism, with white supremacist ideology providing the axis of a cross-class white supremacist legitimation. This obvious turn to white identity politics makes the positions of left racial integrationists like Adolph Reed so incredibly dangerous. [1]
At a historical moment when appeals to racialism and white supremacy are becoming normalized, Reed and other leftists are ideologically disarming opposition to this development by pretending that white supremacist ideology and the materiality of white supremacy is a phantom, a figment of the imagination of petit-bourgeois nationalists and “identitarians” while the mother of all identitarianism – white identity politics and white supremacy is given a pass.
But the ideologues of white supremacy understand that the appeal to the fiction of white civilization supplies the racial glue intended to bind the white working class to the interests of capitalist elites, redirecting anger away from the capitalist relations producing class-wide precarity and toward racialized populations who are themselves the disproportionate victims of colonial/capitalist contradiction. [2]
The European normalization of “remigration”
Across Europe the significance of Rubio’s intervention becomes clearer when placed alongside the growing normalization of a political phenomenon labelled as “remigration.” The growing popularity of remigration, that is, the return of non-Europeans back to their countries of origin, is not simply a debate about enforcing immigration rules. It is a political project whose language of return reveals an ominous turn to a broader racialized struggle over who belongs to Europe and who should be expelled from it.
In Germany, the AfD formally embraced “remigration” in its 2025 election program. Party leader Alice Weidel advocated large-scale repatriations and the term was elevated from a slogan associated with far-right movements into an explicit party demand. The party defines its policy in terms of returning foreigners required to leave under law, while the wider remigration movement includes proposals directed at legally resident migrants and people considered insufficiently assimilated. The distinction matters: the political struggle is over whether formal legal status remains sufficient to establish belonging, or whether racialized definitions of culture and ancestry can supersede it. [3]
Austria’s FPÖ has advocated an EU commissioner for remigration. In Italy, politicians from the Lega have supported a “Remigration and Reconquest” initiative seeking parliamentary consideration. In France, Éric Zemmour has advocated a ministry of remigration, while Geert Wilders in the Netherlands has called for mass deportations in response to unrest in France. Spain’s Vox has also advanced large-scale return proposals for people with migrant backgrounds. [4] These developments do not represent identical policies, but they demonstrate how a once-marginal vocabulary is entering mainstream political debate and linking far-right forces across national boundaries.
The racialization of the French uprising provides a justification for this agenda. When African, Arab, and Muslim youth are depicted as enemies of European civilization, collective expulsion can be presented as a legitimate response to social disorder. The same narrative helps normalize violence against racialized communities and intensifies the danger posed by police forces already notorious for their treatment of youth in the immigrant banlieues. The recent deadly shooting near Paris, in which an African was killed and others wounded, must be understood within this wider atmosphere of racial hostility. [5]
The material Contradictions beneath the civilizational rhetoric
The uprising in France and across Europe cannot be understood apart from declining wages and living standards, deteriorating public services, austerity, debt pressures, and the narrowing prospects confronting working-class youth across racial and ethnic backgrounds. These pressures are often more acute in African, Arab, and Muslim communities because economic marginalization intersects with racial discrimination and unequal access to education, employment, and housing.
France’s fiscal crisis intensifies the struggle over public resources. Debt servicing and demands for fiscal consolidation constrain political choices even as communities require greater investment in education, health, housing, and employment. The war against Iran and the resulting energy-price pressures have added to the burdens confronting working-class households. At the same time, European governments have embraced military Keynesianism, mobilizing resources for military production while social needs remain subject to austerity and fiscal discipline. [6]
These contradictions have emerged throughout the advanced capitalist economies expressing the structural crisis of Western capitalism: a system increasingly unable to provide broad material security while preserving the accumulation and geopolitical power and interests of monopoly capital. But France’s specific crisis is also connected to the weakening of its historical ability to maintain its parasitic relations of extraction that allowed capital to bribe workers in France.
However, as the ability of France and other Western capitalist states to dictate economic and political terms to the Global South that allowed a continuous flow of value to the metropoles became more contested resulting in declining wages and living standards, white civilizational nationalism offered an ideological substitute for the failed promise of unbroken material prosperity to the Euro-American and European masses.
The appeal of Trump, Rubio, Le Pen, Farage, and other figures rests on the continued obscurantist policies emanating from the consolidating global fascist movement. They promise national renewal through exclusion hoping that the white working classes never catch on to the fact that the defense of white civilization is the defense of oligarchic capitalist rule.
The fascist response to capitalist crisis is to reorganize domination through white supremacy and civilizational exclusion. The peoples’ response must be to organize for liberation beyond the colonial and capitalist relations that have produced the crisis [end]
1 mort, 10 blessés dont 4 blessés graves, une fillette touchée par 8 tirs : un passage à l’acte encouragé par les politiques et discours d’extrême droite
une saga française, entre Ukraine et Lyon, où apparaissent aussi des morceaux de SS de la division Charlemagne et plus récemment, Alice Kerviel, dite Cordier
mensonges, coups de communication, complaisance médiatique, fascisation du débat public : la mort de Quentin Deranque a servi de catalyseur à l’ensemble de l’échiquier politique, du centre à l’extrême droite, pour en faire un puissant instrument de récupération politique. Ce climat a permis à des groupes néonazis et fascistes d’organiser des hommages publics saturés de références idéologiques explicites au nazisme, sans susciter la moindre réaction politique
Agence France-Presse, “Macron Condemns ‘Racist Terrorist Attack’ After Deadly Shooting Near Paris,” October 23, 2026. Reporting on the investigation and official statements should be checked for updates as the case develops. ↩︎
Comment comprendre la marginalisation actuelle de la France sur la scène internationale, ainsi que son hystérie belliciste sous l’égide de Macron ? Pourquoi avons-nous à ce point renoncé à défendre nos intérêts industriels nationaux, contrairement aux États-Unis et à l’Allemagne ? Comment l’oligarchie techno-financière française a-t-elle pu en arriver à trahir aussi complètement le peuple avec l’appui de la petite-bourgeoisie de gauche hexagonale, armée d’une fausse conscience pro-européenne ? Marc de Sovakhine, haut-fonctionnaire écrivant sous pseudonyme pour QG, émet une série d’hypothèses fascinantes. À lire ce week-end
Du rêve impérial à l’ordre néolibéral
Nous n’avons pas suffisamment pris la mesure du rôle central que les élites françaises ont joué depuis près d’un demi-siècle dans la construction de l’ordre néolibéral tant à l’échelle européenne que mondiale. Si cet ordre a été pensé et initié par des penseurs et acteurs austro-allemands et anglo-américains, ce sont, dans une large mesure, des technocrates français qui ont mis leur savoir-faire d’organisateurs au service de sa construction juridico-institutionnelle au sein des organisations supranationales créées à cet effet. Ils ont également été parmi les premiers à se porter volontaires pour occuper les places dans les conseils d’administration et les comités exécutifs des nouveaux acteurs globalisés de la finance, grandes banques et fonds internationaux.
L’ordre néolibéral actuel se donne à voir comme le reflet troublé des anciens empires européens : les Britanniques ont transmis le flambeau de l’hégémonie mondiale (économique et militaire) à leurs cousins américains, les Austro-Allemands à l’Union européenne leur rêve impérial conçu à l’échelle du continent sur le modèle des empires centraux et les Français à leurs élites frustrées par l’échec de leur vocation impériale l’espace déterritorialisé des institutions du marché globalisé ; comme si l’universalisme abstrait de la fille aînée de l’Eglise, revisité par l’idéal hugolien de la « République universelle » (« O France, adieu! tu es trop grande pour n’être qu’une patrie »), s’était finalement dissous dans les abstractions de la marchandise et du capital. Si les deux premières utopies impériales s’attachent encore à des territoires (le monde et le continent européen), la troisième se projette dans un espace de règles de droit et d’institutions supranationales qui viennent mailler les flux mondiaux de marchandises et de capitaux. La France comme fille aînée du Marché globalisé aura sans doute été la plus sensible aux visions eschatologiques de Francis Fukuyama.
A partir de la fin de années 1970, le FMI a été dirigé par des haut fonctionnaires français de façon ininterrompue de 1978 à 2000, puis de 2007 à 2019. Les Américains qui, de leur côté, s’étaient attribué la direction de la Banque mondiale, poussèrent dans ce sens, trop contents de pouvoir bénéficier de leur expertise bureaucratique reconnue et d’arrimer à leur agenda des élites françaises dont les ambitions se sont mises à devenir trop grandes pour se contenter de leur patrie. De 1985 à 1995, dans ces années décisives pour ladite « construction européenne », entre l’entrée en vigueur de l’Acte unique et la création de la monnaie unique, le démocrate-chrétien Jacques Delors présidera la Commission européenne. C’est sous sa conduite et sur la base d’un pacte franco-allemand que la future Union européenne prendra sa forme actuelle d’un Empire du droit marchand et capitaliste qui place ses États membres sous souveraineté limitée dans un espace marchand unique où s’organise, une fois levés tous les obstacles au commerce et à l’investissement et sous le régime du droit de la concurrence, la division internationale du travail à l’échelle du continent. Certes, si Mitterrand, qui portait sur le monde un regard de politique, a accepté de renouveler le compromis avec l’Allemagne, vingt ans après le Traité de l’Elysée, c’est surtout parce qu’il ne se doutait pas que l’URSS s’écroulerait aussi vite, offrant à son voisin d’outre-Rhin la possibilité de reconstituer sa zone d’expansion économique en Europe centrale. En 1991, il est déjà trop tard mais il espère pouvoir encore enfermer l’Allemagne réunifiée dans un vaste espace politique eurasiatique borné à l’est par la Russie, l’autre puissance nucléaire. De leur côté, les technocrates dont il s’est entouré nourrissent en parallèle d’autres projets
Dominique Strauss-Kahn fut président du Fond monétaire international de 2007 à 2011, avant d’être remplacé par une autre personnalité française, Christine Lagarde, présidente de l’institution de 2011 à 2019. Cette dernière est aujourd’hui présidente de la Banque centrale européenne(BCE)
À la même époque, le cœur de l’Etat français se met au service de la constitution de grands groupes bancaires dans la perspective de faire de Paris la plus grande place financière du continent. De la décision prise par Mitterrand de maintenir la France dans le système monétaire européen en 1983 jusqu’au grand mouvement de concentration, sous le gouvernement Jospin, du secteur bancaire à la fin des années 1990, la fraction la plus modernisatrice de la haute fonction publique va prêter main forte à la constitution de grandes banques universelles, privatisées quelques années plus tôt et adossées à un marché de capitaux profond, profitant de la force de la monnaie allemande, poumon industriel du continent. Delors à Bruxelles, le ministre Bérégovoy engage la modernisation et le décloisonnement des marchés de capitaux en France au mitan des années 1980. Il réformera, dans le même mouvement, les instruments de dette publique pour les adapter aux demandes de liquidité des marchés modernisés. Quinze ans plus tard, comme pour clore le cycle, Dominique Strauss-Kahn supervise depuis Bercy, à la veille de l’entrée en vigueur de la monnaie unique, l’achèvement des grandes opérations de concentration bancaires. Les contours de la répartition des rôles entre la France et l’Allemagne se dessinent nettement au début du siècle. Le modèle mercantiliste allemand soutient une monnaie forte qui autorise l’Etat français à s’endetter à moindre coût – pour maintenir la paix sociale face aux conséquences de la désindustrialisation et ménager les passions rentières de la vieille bourgeoisie française – et aux banques hexagonales de consolider leurs ambitions internationales, entraînant dans leur sillage l’industrie nationale.
Depuis 2017, Bercy et la place financière de Paris sont plus que jamais résolus à poursuivre le cap que la France s’est fixé il y a quarante ans. « Paris est en première ligne, comme le titrait récemment Les Echos, pour faire avancer l’Union des marchés de capitaux », dans la foulée du rapport rendu par l’ancien gouverneur de la Banque de France Christian Noyer et de celui de Mario Draghi, accueilli dans un concert de louanges. L’idée est de décloisonner les marchés de capitaux européens par la standardisation des produits financiers et l’assouplissement des règles de « titrisation » des créances bancaires en titres négociables sur les marchés. En somme, accélérer la prise de pouvoir du capital financier qui a déjà mis plusieurs cordes au cou des Etats toujours plus endettés, au motif de « financer l’avenir ». Du reste, en favorisant la montée en puissance des produits d’épargne retraite par capitalisation à travers le P.E.R, petite sœur du produit paneuropéen d’épargne retraite (PEPP), la récente réforme des retraites en France constitue l’une des étapes-clés de ce processus : « désocialiser » le financement des retraites et pousser les assurés sociaux, à l’unisson des épargnants, à placer leur épargne désocialisée auprès de fonds à long terme peu liquides et au capital non garanti, sur le modèle de fonds de pension néerlandais, pourtant enclins à des crises répétées depuis vingt ans. Pas de quoi effrayer les artisans de l’omnipotence du capital financier, pour qui la crise agit comme un pharmakon de choc, poison pour les sociétés et remède pour justifier l’extension de son pouvoir.
L’unification des forces de la bourgeoisie française sous la forme d’une oligarchie techno-financière
À la faveur de cet accord plus ou moins tacite entre la France et l’Allemagne, toutes les composantes de la bourgeoisie française, qui autrefois pouvaient encore s’opposer entre elles, ont entrepris nolens volens leur unification pour se placer sous le commandement du capital financier. L’ancienne « noblesse d’État » a amorcé sa fusion avec la grande bourgeoisie financière internationalisée, formant avec elle une oligarchie techno-financière dénationalisée à laquelle se sont assujetties la bourgeoisie industrielle et à la petite bourgeoisie, comme toujours à la remorque. On a fait sortir Fouquet de prison pour l’installer à Versailles où chaque année est organisée la grand-messe de l’attractivité, « Choose France ». Emmanuel Macron, candidat de la grande banque et de la haute fonction publique logée à Bercy, est à la fois le produit et l’artisan terminal de cette mutation
« Choose France », la grand-messe de l’attractivité lancée en 2018 par Macron, peu après son accession à la présidence de la République, vise à séduire les multinationales et à les inciter à investir en France
Là où les banques allemandes continuent encore de financer un tissu industriel composé d’entreprises dont le capital demeure très contrôlé et les chaînes de valeur resserrées en Europe centrale, leurs homologues françaises, arrimées à un horizon sans territoire et façonnées pour affronter les marchés mondiaux, se sont détournées du tissu productif national, accompagnant l’internationalisation des grandes entreprises françaises dont la détention capitalistique et les chaînes de valeur offrent un degré d’ouverture et d’extraversion parmi les plus élevés des économies occidentales. Ce fut l’appel du large pour les grandes banques universelles et les anciens fleurons industriels, pressés, avec le concours de l’Etat, de s’ébrouer dans les eaux tumultueuses des marchés internationaux encadrés par un ordre supranational assis sur les droits imprescriptibles de la marchandise et du capital. Un appel doublé de celui à prendre des places pour ces nouveaux mercenaires attachés, en guise de politique industrielle, à louer les vertus de « l’attractivité » d’un pays qu’ils prostituent pour pouvoir eux-mêmes se prostituer comme individus dont les trajectoires sociales ont changé d’échelle.
Se plaçant sous la protection de la monnaie unique – un Deutschemark européen – et s’en remettant aux mânes du marché globalisé, l’oligarchie techno-financière ne voyait plus aucune raison de conserver en France une base industrielle sans laquelle l’exercice effectif de la souveraineté devient pourtant illusoire. Nostalgique de son rêve impérial, elle lit dans le destin des Etats-Unis celui dont l’Histoire l’a privée dans un pays qui n’a plus les moyens de la hisser sur le pavois du monde ; pour lui redonner vie, il lui fallait encore l’associer à celui que l’Allemagne se surprend, elle aussi, à mûrir dans les territoires libérés par la fonte du glacis soviétique. L’Union européenne deviendra le cadre économique et juridique où peut s’incarner un destin impérial enchâssé dans celui de l’hégémon américain. Comme l’a bien montré Quinn Slobodian dans son livre Les globalistes – Une histoire intellectuelle du néolibéralisme, la pensée néolibérale nait dès les années 1920 dans les décombres de l’Empire des Habsbourg qui constituait, aux yeux de Friedrich Hayek et de Wilhelm Röpke, un modèle d’organisation efficace pour repenser un espace articulé autour de la primauté juridique du dominium marchand sur l’imperium d’Etats interdépendants, déclinaison de la distinction ancienne entre l’auctoritas de l’empereur et la potestas des rois. Leurs successeurs, réunis au lendemain de la Seconde guerre mondiale au sein de l’école ordo-libérale, s’attacheront à ériger, dans une filiation avec la tradition juridique allemande du Rechtsstaat, les libertés économiques et le droit de propriété au rang de droits de l’homme garantis par des institutions s’imposant aux Etats souverains. Il s’agit, en dernier ressort, de tenir les peuples à l’écart au sein d’un ordre pensé comme un ajustement souple aux mouvements du marché globalisé et du capital.
Au terme de ce vaste mouvement de recomposition de la division internationale du travail ordonné par des institutions supranationales, l’oligarchie techno-financière française s’est libérée de sa chrysalide nationale pour rejoindre les grandes citadelles – Bruxelles, Londres, Francfort, Washington – de son nouvel empire sans territoire. On ne fait carrière aujourd’hui au Ministère de l’Economie et des finances qu’en acceptant de passer par l’une d’entre elles. En liant le destin de la France aux lois de cet ordre néolibéral stratifié, elle l’a, du même coup, délibérément amputée d’une partie de sa souveraineté et privée de ses marges de manœuvre. C’est ainsi qu’il faut comprendre actuellement l’isolement et la marginalisation de la France sur la scène internationale.
Au sein des élites dirigeantes, une partie importante, souvent des gens de qualité animés du sens de l’intérêt général, s’est vu confier la fastidieuse gestion de la province française de l’Empire anglo-américain secondé par son délégataire allemand. On en trouve encore dans le corps préfectoral, mais aussi dans tous les échelons décentralisés et démembrés de l’État, collectivités locales et autres établissements publics placés sous contrainte budgétaire, où leurs soutiers tentent chaque jour de colmater la carène d’un navire navigant au gré des courants impétueux de la mondialisation et des possibilités de débarquement des troupes de choc de l’oligarchie qu’il convoie. Réduite à une opposition stérile et placée sous perfusion de dette publique dans les fiefs subventionnés où elle cultive une opposition stérile, la petite bourgeoisie dont le cœur penche à gauche permet, quant à elle, à l’oligarchie techno-financière hors-sol, avec qui elle communie dans les dogmes de la construction européenne et de la « société ouverte », de s’accrocher au pouvoir. Jamais, dans l’histoire de la République, n’avait-on vu une classe dirigeante aussi minoritaire dans la société. Sans le renfort de la petite bourgeoisie armée d’une fausse conscience qui vient se nicher dans un barragisme aussi inconséquent qu’indispensable à sa perpétuation en tant que classe d’appoint, l’oligarchie ne pourrait pas continuer à diriger le pays.
Une nouvelle donne ?
Le « moteur franco-allemand » avait déjà commencé à s’enrayer ; depuis le déclenchement de la guerre en Ukraine, il menace d’exploser. Sommes-nous préparés à ce que nous imaginions encore impensable il y a quelques années ?
Le Premier ministre britannique Keir Starmer avec Olaf Scholz, alors chancelier allemand, Volodymyr Zelensky, président de l’Ukraine, et Emmanuel Macron à l’occasion du sommet de la Communauté politique européenne (CPE) en 2024
L’un des enjeux de l’après-guerre est de savoir qui, de l’Allemagne ou de la France, s’imposera – en retenant l’hypothèse d’une perspective de sortie prochaine du conflit – comme le principal interlocuteur de la Russie et chef de file européen pour rebâtir une sécurité collective en Europe. Privée de gaz russe, l’Allemagne a renforcé sa dépendance aux États-Unis et assiste à l’agonie de son modèle économique, mais refuse de se laisser mourir et pousse à la signature rapide de traités de libre-échange afin de se ménager de nouveaux débouchés et subventionner son industrie par la baisse attendue du prix des produits agricoles en Europe. Sa ligne est constante depuis les négociations du Traité de Rome en 1957 au cours desquelles elle avait tenté de s’opposer aux accords préférentiels avec le continent africain en voie de décolonisation, avant de voir son objectif satisfait à la faveur du « Consensus de Washington » dans les années 1990. Après avoir annoncé un plan d’investissement de cent milliards d’euros en vue de son réarmement, elle entend faire de son industrie de défense la base matérielle de « l’Europe de la défense », alors que tous les projets d’armement franco-allemands sont au point mort. La ministre des affaires étrangères Annalena Baerbock a déclaré le 13 novembre au Bundestag vouloir une « Europe unie » avec une Allemagne « prête à diriger ».
La France, de son côté, a abandonné depuis longtemps toute réflexion géostratégique. Son oligarchie n’a aucun intérêt à renoncer à l’utopie fukuyamesque d’une harmonie par le marché conduite par les États-Unis et garantie en Europe par une discipline juridico-marchande d’inspiration germanique, consentie en contrepartie d’une monnaie unique à l’ombre de laquelle elle s’est constituée comme classe unifiée. Les efforts de la diplomatie française sont désormais presque exclusivement orientés vers la signature de contrats d’armement pour offrir des débouchés à son industrie militaire et maintenir une autonomie stratégique qui s’avère illusoire en l’absence de stratégie et d’un plan de paix. Depuis que son mini-complexe militaro-industriel a entrepris de mettre ses armements aux normes de l’OTAN, elle espère, face à l’Allemagne, trouver de nouveaux clients parmi les autres Etats européens qui se fournissent presque exclusivement auprès des Etats-Unis, aggravant les risques d’une escalade guerrière.
Si la France adoptait une conduite rationnelle et conforme à ses intérêts, à l’instar des Etats-Unis ou de l’Allemagne, elle profiterait de ce retour du politique dans les affaires du monde pour repenser l’équilibre du continent, dans le cadre d’une relation raisonnée avec la Russie, et desserrer l’étau germano-américain. Ceci exigerait de s’affranchir du carcan des traités européens et de recouvrer les instruments de la souveraineté ; de ne plus tourner le dos à une Histoire que l’oligarchie techno-financière, enchaînée à ses abstractions impériales, a prétendu vouloir « dépasser ». Rien n’est moins sûr de la part de cette classe attachée à ses privilèges et à la préservation desquels elle a sacrifié des pans entiers de notre économie.
Il est des débâcles moins spectaculaires que celle de 1940 mais de celle-ci, insidieuse et lancinante, il sera difficile de s’en remettre sans un sursaut du peuple français qui, comme souvent dans son histoire, ne peut compter que sur lui-même pour ne pas disparaitre et échapper à l’impasse du rêve impérial à laquelle le condamnent ses élites [fin]
chronique alphabétique et nécrologique de l’engagement français dans les rangs atlantistes en Ukraine, ce que les journalistes serviles ne vous raconteront pas
There’s a gaping hole in Kyiv’s finances that no amount of tax increases or Western donations will be able to fill
There is no plan in place to fund the Ukrainian budget after 2025.
Even if the war ends by the summer of 2025, it will take some time to reduce military expenditures, leaving European nations on the hook. It’s not clear that European elites have fully understood the political costs, however much longer the war continues.
With intensive, U.S.-brokered negotiations ongoing in Saudi Arabia involving separate Ukrainian and Russian delegations, hopes are rising that the Trump administration will finally be able to bring an end to the war.
But even if the war ends tomorrow, it would be unwise to assume that Ukraine could reduce military spending close to prewar levels.
Ukraine now has almost 900,000 men and women at arms, a threefold increase from peacetime, and that doesn’t take into account irrecoverable losses through death and injury. Estimates vary widely, but the casualty rate is commonly thought to number in the hundreds of thousands, with compensation provided to the injured and families of the deceased.
The war in Ukraine has therefore come at a vast financial cost to that country. Ukraine’s defense spending has risen tenfold since the 2021 budget was announced, when social welfare payments were the country’s biggest expenditure.
This has left a gaping hole in Ukraine’s finances that no amount of tax increases or Western donations will be able to fill over a sustained period without political consequences.
Since 2022, Ukraine has run an average budget deficit of over 22% of GDP. Based on the current exchange rate, Ukraine’s budget shortfall in 2025 amounts to around $41.5 billion. And that assumes defense spending falling slightly this year. In the hopefully unlikely event that war continues to the end of the year, the Ukrainian state would need to revise its budget upwards as it did in 2024.
Today, Ukraine’s domestic revenue, including taxes, excise, and duties, just about covers the cost of the defense effort, which in 2024 accounted for 64% of its total budget expenditure. That includes significant tax increases as the war has gone on. Total tax revenue will have risen by more than 100% since the war started and personal income taxes by over 200%. This in a country in which, according to the Wilson Center, 50% of the population lives at a basic subsistence level.
As Ukraine is cut off from international capital markets, it has had to meet the difference through aid and loans from Western nations.
Put simply, Western donations and loans have paid the salaries of Ukrainian state officials and kept the lights on in their buildings. At the start of the war, donations took the form of free financial aid to meet the country’s budgetary and military needs. According to the Kiel Institute, the United States has provided just above $50 billion in direct budgetary assistance. The European Union provided $51.5 billion in financial assistance – i.e., budgetary support – between 2022 and 2024.
However, since the start of 2024, free aid has progressively shifted to lending as Western governments have felt the political and economic cost of unlimited financial assistance.
So, Ukraine has increasingly resorted to borrowing money. In some regards, that is to be expected. Governments tend to borrow heavily at times of war. The UK only settled its World War II war debts to the United States and Canada in 2006.
Ukrainian debt has therefore soared to over 100% of GDP and, critically, the cost of servicing its debt has tripled, and now makes up the second largest line of expenditure in Ukraine’s budget, after military spending. To put that into context, Ukraine will spend more than twice the amount on servicing its debt in 2025 than it spends on the health of its population. That ratio will only widen the longer the war continues.
Ukraine should just about be able to make ends meet in 2025 thanks to the G7 Extraordinary Revenue Acceleration loan agreed in June 2024. As part of a last-ditch compromise by the outgoing Biden Administration, the $20 billion U.S. contribution to the G7 loan was directed through the World Bank to provide specific project-based support – i.e., to help rebuild power infrastructure – rather than generalized budgetary support.
The crucial point is that I’ve seen no plans for how Ukraine’s budgetary needs will be met from 2026 onward. Even if the war ends tomorrow, Ukraine may still be at risk of running out of money in 2026 if Western donor countries falsely assume that it will be able to return to prewar spending on Day One.
Therefore, the big question is how quickly Ukraine can reduce military spending in 2026 and who will cover the shortfall. To balance the books in 2026, Ukraine would need to reduce its military spending by 80%, or around $41 billion.
But decision-makers in Kyiv may understandably push to maintain a big army against the threat of future Russian aggression. While the huge expenditure in weapons and ammunition from war fighting may fall away, maintaining a standing army, even if its numbers are reduced, would still carry a heavy price. Even if Ukraine’s future budget deficit wasn’t as high as $41 billion, it is easy to imagine that it might be $20 billion.
The International Monetary Fund also doesn’t expect Ukraine to be able to access international lending markets before 2027. That will leave the Ukrainian state reaching out to donor nations for additional funding. With the Trump administration looking to pare back its financial commitments to Ukraine and focus instead on investing, including in minerals, the pressure will be on European states. There is significant political risk here. In the past few days, the Europeans struggled to agree to an additional weapons package of $5 billion for Ukraine. Funding $20 billion in budgetary support to Ukraine in 2026 following a ceasefire this year may still herald a backlash from those on the nationalist left and right who believe the war should have ended in 2022. I assess the UK and Europe would find it economically and politically unsustainable to prop up the war beyond this year without the United States. That’s another reason why European leaders should get behind ongoing peace negotiations [end]
Ian Proud was a member of His Britannic Majesty’s Diplomatic Service from 1999 to 2023. He served as the Economic Counsellor at the British Embassy in Moscow from July 2014 to February 2019. Prior to Moscow, he organized the 2013 G8 Summit in Lough Erne, Northern Ireland, working out of 10 Downing Street. He recently published his memoir, “A Misfit in Moscow: How British diplomacy in Russia failed, 2014-2019”
The BRICS Summit in Kazan, Russia, aims to be a turning point towards a truly multipolar or multi-nodal world that has been in transition for a few years now
The changes announced in Kazan regarding the payment system and the reserves of nations are concrete steps towards independence from the U.S. imperialistic system. This system is symbolized by a small piece of green paper that no longer has real backing—just an empty promise.
An Imperialistic Structure Does Not End in One Day
The U.S. has managed to build an imperial structure based on more than 800 military bases around the world, the imposition of the dollar as the currency of international trade and reserve, the extraterritorial application of its laws, and by creating a network of vassal and semi-vassal states around its hegemony. Nonetheless, the core of its imperial system relies on the dollar. The de-dollarisation led by the BRICS is driving the U.S. to despair, making their sanctions system increasingly meaningless too.
BRICS has taken on the responsibility of driving substantial change for a new world order
No empire lasts forever, especially one that lacks a strategic vision, as is the case with the U.S. The American empire lost wars or promoted further chaos in Vietnam (1955-1975), Afghanistan (2002-2021), Iraq (2003-2011), Libya (2011) and did not win in Syria and has shown an inability to control its ally Israel, which continues to commit war crimes, uphold apartheid, engage in state terrorism, and carry out genocide. Moreover, the U.S. has been incapable of formulating its Middle East policy independently of Israel’s prism.
On top of that, domestically, its infrastructure is crumbling, and its social indicators are rapidly approaching those of developing countries. The U.S. is the only major nation where life expectancy is declining, extreme poverty is increasing swiftly, and so is homelessness. Its citizens do not have universal, free access to healthcare, as happens in most developing countries, such as Latin America. All these issues highlight the fragility of the empire.
The New Sick Man
Once, during its decline, the Ottoman Empire was known as the “sick man of Europe.” Now, it seems the U.S. is playing this role, or perhaps it’s more like a drowning person: it pulls those who are close to it into its struggle and demands loyalty in this slow demise, particularly from European countries that have greatly benefited from its generous policies after WWII. In Latin America, the Monroe Doctrine is still very much in effect, which is why Brazil sometimes seems reluctant to commit fully to BRICS.
Europeans, especially the Germans, have shown signs of wanting independence, and the idea of strategic autonomy has become wishful thinking. Former Chancellor Angela Merkel, who was economically liberal, listened to German business leaders who argued that the future lay not in the Atlantic, but Eastwards toward Russia and China.
The U.S. did not like this shift and managed to make Europeans feel that they still needed Uncle Sam for their protection. Turning their backs on the U.S. was seen as an ungrateful response to American roles in WWII and the Marshall Plan.
The U.S. meddled in Central Europe and Ukraine, expanding NATO eastwards. This move was highly discouraged by prominent American foreign policy strategists like Henry Kissinger, Robert Kagan, John Mearsheimer, and even William Burns, a former Ambassador to Russia and ex-CIA director. The coup orchestrated by the CIA and led locally by Victoria Nuland in 2013 in Ukraine was just the beginning, alongside the sabotage of Nord Stream by the U.S., all part of this complex game to make Europeans dependent on the U.S.
BRICS Ignites Hopes of the Global South and the Discontented
Once again, two blocks are forming, with some countries caught in the middle. The war in Ukraine and the Global South’s refusal to impose sanctions on Russia have highlighted the divisions in the world. The war in Gaza and the resulting genocide, supported by many Western nations while they preach values and human rights, has led the Global South to lose faith in the West’s moral standards. They have denounced its double standards and are nearly unanimously supporting the idea of a new world order.
The expansion of BRICS, with over 40 nations waiting to join—including Serbia, Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Nigeria and Bolivia—clearly signals that change is expected.
Some European nations are unhappy with the expected outcomes of remaining tied to the old regime– the EU tied to the U.S.- and wish to be part of a more dynamic and prosperous future. For instance, Spain has rejected imposing extra tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles, and Turkey wants to join BRICS too, as does Serbia, even if it means giving up potential EU memberships, along with many other nations.
Bulgaria is also unhappy with its EU membership and is sending representatives to BRICS meetings. Moldova was divided over an EU membership referendum. The narrow victory of 0.2% was due to the votes of Moldovans living abroad. Still in Europe, Norway, not being subject to EU rules, has recently taken steps to strengthen economic ties with China, surprising many Atlanticists in Europe.
Therefore, BRICS has taken on the responsibility of driving substantial change for a new world order. However, it is fair to say that BRICS nations have tried to reform the Bretton Woods institutions—especially the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF)—and the United Nations to better reflect the new economic, population, and trade realities, but they have not succeeded.
New institutions are being built within BRICS, particularly the New Development Bank (NDB), which, unlike the IMF or World Bank, does not impose economic regime changes and has inclusive practices.
In sum, there are several political and economic groups of nations around the world, but none has the political will or the capacity to promote major geoeconomic and geopolitical changes as BRICS does. Therefore, the 16th BRICS Summit in Kazan comes at the right time and with the right political will to build a better, more prosperous, inclusive, free, and less ideologically driven world. The next step should be the merger of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) with BRICS [end]
Ricardo Martins ‒PhD in Sociology, specializing in policies, European and world politics and geopolitics, especially for the online magazine “New Eastern Outlook”
Five major trends illustrate how the world is changing, and that the West must grapple with the reality that it can no longer impose its “leadership” on the world as it once did
This is part 2 of “Why There Is Still No Peace on Earth: Washington’s Folly From The Persian Gulf to Ukraine.” Read part 1
[my illustration : on June 4, 2019, the TIP (east Turkestan Islamic party, Doğu Türkistan İslâm Harriet in Turkish) releases a new propaganda video (screenshot). These Uyghur jihadists are fighting in northwestern Syria, against the Syrian secular forces, within al Qaeda’s local branch (Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham, Organization for the Liberation of the Levant, HTS), which is settled under NATO protection in Idlib pocket]
THE FIRST GULF WAR – A CATASTROPHIC ERROR
Confronted with the greatest opportunity for global peace in nearly a century, George H. W. Bush did not hesitate: Upon the advice of his retainers, he immediately elected the path of war in the Persian Gulf.
This endeavor was hatched by Henry Kissinger’s economically illiterate protégés at the National Security Council and Bush’s Texas oilman secretary of state, James Baker. They falsely claimed that the will-o’-the-wisp of “oil security” was at stake, and that 500,000 American troops needed to be planted in the sands of Arabia.
That was a catastrophic error, and not only because the presence of “crusader” boots on the purportedly sacred soil of Arabia offended the CIA-recruited and trained mujahedin of Afghanistan, who had become unemployed when the Soviet Union collapsed.
The CNN-glorified war games in the Gulf during early 1991 also further empowered another group of unemployed crusaders. Namely, the neocon national-security fanatics who had misled Ronald Reagan into a massive military buildup to thwart what they claimed to be an ascendant Soviet Union bent on nuclear-war-winning capabilities and global conquest.
Needless to say, by the 1980s the gray men of the Kremlin were as evil as ever, but they were also quite rational and did not embrace a nuclear war winning strategy in any way, shape or form. That was just a pack of neocon lies, which, in any event, led to a massive defense build-up that had virtually nothing to do with containing the ballyhooed Soviet strategic nuclear threat. As it happened, the latter was being handled well enough by the already built, in-place and paid for strategic nuclear triad – forces which well pre-dated the Reagan build-up.
So when the defense budget rose by a staggering $170 billion, from $134 billion in 1980 to $304 billion in 1989, only a tiny fraction of the increase was applied to upgrading the strategic nuclear deterrent. Instead, this unprecedented 130% peacetime rise (+50% in inflation-adjusted dollars) went overwhelmingly to the building of a globe-spanning conventional forces armadathat was utterly unneeded for America’s homeland security in a world with or without the Soviet Union.
Accordingly, everything on land, sea and air was upgraded and expanded. This included the 600-ship Navy and 12 carrier battle groups; massive upgrades of the fleet of M1 tanks and Bradley Fighting Vehicles; and endless procurement of cruise missiles, fixed-wing planes, rotary aircraft, air-and sea-lift capacity, surveillance and electronic warfare capacity and a black budget so large as to dwarf anything that had gone before.
In a word, the misguided Reagan defense build-up enabled the invasions and occupations that commenced almost instantly after the Soviet demise. That is to say, the neocon defense build-up of the 1980s fathered the “Forever Wars” of the 1990s and beyond.
The folly and deceit of the purportedly anti-Soviet defense build-up was evident enough at the time because by the mid-1980s the Evil Empire was already unraveling at the seams economically. The reason was simply that communism and rigidly centralized command-and-control economics don’t work—as became abundantly clear to the entire world via the spectacle of Boris Yeltsin, vodka flask in hand, facing down the Red Army in 1991.
Like the proverbial last straw on the camel’s back, in the end the mighty Soviet Union was taken down by one of its own drunken apparatchiks.
That is to say, the entire neocon narrative of an ascendant, bent on world conquest Soviet Union was made a mockery. That alone should have sent the neocons into the permanent disrepute and obscurity they so richly deserved.
But Dick Cheney, Paul Wolfowitz and rest of the neocon gang surrounding Bush the Elder managed to deftly pull a “bait and switch” maneuver of no mean extent. Suddenly, it wasn’t about the Soviet Union at all, but the alleged lesson from Washington’s Pyrrhic victory in Kuwait that “regime change” among the assorted tyrannies of the Middle East was in America’s national interest.
More fatally, the neocons now insisted that the first Gulf War proved regime change could be achieved through a sweeping interventionist menu of coalition diplomacy, security assistance, arms shipments, covert action and open military attack and occupation via the spanking new conventional forces armada that the Reagan Administration had bequeathed.
What the neocon doctrine of regime-change actually did, of course, was to foster the Frankenstein that ultimately became ISIS. In fact, the only real terrorists in the world who have threatened normal civilian life in the West during the last three decades were the rogue offspring of Imperial Washington’s post-1990 machinations in the Middle East.
The CIA-trained and CIA-armed mujahedin of Afghanistan mutated into al-Qaeda not because bin Laden suddenly had a religious epiphany that his Washington benefactors were actually the Great Satan owing to America’s freedom and liberty.
His murderous crusade was inspired by the Wahhabi fundamentalism loose in Saudi Arabia. This benighted religious fanaticism became agitated to a fever pitch by Imperial Washington’s violent plunge into Persian Gulf political and religious quarrels, the stationing of troops in Saudi Arabia, and the decade-long barrage of sanctions, embargoes, no-fly zones, covert actions and open hostility against the Sunni regime in Baghdad after 1991.
Yes, bin Laden would have amputated Saddam’s secularist head if Washington hadn’t done it first, but that’s just the point. The attempt at regime change in March 2003 was one of the most foolish acts of state in American history.
Indeed, Bush the Younger’s neocon advisers had no clue about the sectarian animosities and historical grievances that Hussein had bottled up by parsing the oil loot and wielding the sword under the banner of Baathist nationalism. But “shock and awe” blew the lid and the de-Baathification campaign unleashed the furies.
Indeed, no sooner had George Bush pranced around on the deck of the Abraham Lincoln declaring “mission accomplished” than Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, a Jordanian militant and small-time specialist in hostage taking and poisons, emerged as a flamboyant agitator in the now-dispossessed Sunni heartland of Iraq.
The founder of ISIS succeeded in Fallujah and Anbar province just like the long list of other terrorist leaders Washington claims to have exterminated. That is, Zarqawi gained his following and notoriety among the region’s population of deprived, brutalized and humiliated young men by dint of being more brutal than their occupiers.
Indeed, even as Washington was crowing about its eventual liquidation of Zarqawi, the remnants of the Baathist regime and the hundreds of thousands of demobilized republican guards were coalescing into al-Qaeda in Iraq, and their future leaders were being incubated in a monstrous nearby detention center called Camp Bucca that contained more than 26,000 prisoners.
As one former U.S. Army officer, Mitchell Gray, later described it,
“You never see hatred like you saw on the faces of these detainees,” Gray remembers of his 2008 tour. “When I say they hated us, I mean they looked like they would have killed us in a heartbeat if given the chance. I turned to the warrant officer I was with and I said, ‘If they could, they would rip our heads off and drink our blood.
What Gray didn’t know – but might have expected – was that he was not merely looking at the United States’ former enemies, but its future ones as well. According to intelligence experts and Department of Defense records, the vast majority of the leadership of what is today known as ISIS, including its leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, did time at Camp Bucca.
And not only did the US feed, clothe and house these jihadists, it also played a vital, if unwitting, role in facilitating their transformation into the most formidable terrorist force in modern history.
Early in Bucca’s existence, the most extreme inmates were congregated in Compound 6. There were not enough Americans guards to safely enter the compound – and, in any event, the guards didn’t speak Arabic. So the detainees were left alone to preach to one another and share deadly vocational advice . . .
Bucca also housed Haji Bakr, a former colonel in Saddam Hussein’s air-defense force. Bakr was no religious zealot. He was just a guy who lost his job when the Coalition Provisional Authority disbanded the Iraqi military and instituted de-Baathification, a policy of banning Saddam’s past supporters from government work.
According to documents recently obtained by German newspaper Der Spiegel, Bakr was the real mastermind behind ISIS’ organizational structure and also mapped out the strategies that fueled its early successes. Bakr, who died in fighting in 2014, was incarcerated at Bucca from 2006-’ 08, along with a dozen or more of ISIS’ top lieutenants.”
The point is, regime change and nation building can never be accomplished by the lethal violence of 21st-century armed forces; and they were an especially preposterous assignment in the context of a land rent with 13 century-old religious fissures and animosities.
In fact, the wobbly, synthetic state of Iraq was doomed the minute Cheney and his bloody gang decided to liberate it from the brutal but serviceable and secular tyranny of Saddam’s Baathist regime. That’s because the process of elections and majority rule necessarily imposed by Washington was guaranteed to elect a government beholden to Iraq’s Shiite majority.
After decades of mistreatment and Saddam’s brutal suppression of their 1991 uprising, did the latter have revenge on their minds and in their communal DNA? Did the Kurds have dreams of an independent Kurdistan spilling into Turkey and Syria that had been denied their 30-million-strong tribe way back at Versailles and ever since?
Yes, they did. So the $25 billion spent on training and equipping the putative armed forces of post-liberation Iraq was bound to end up in the hands of sectarian militias, not a national army.
In fact, when the Shiite commanders fled Sunni-dominated Mosul in June 2014 they transformed the ISIS uprising against the government in Baghdad into a vicious fledgling state in one fell swoop. But it wasn’t by beheadings and fiery jihadist sermons that it quickly enslaved dozens of towns and several million people in western Iraq and the Euphrates Valley of Syria.
THE ISLAMIC STATE WAS WASHINGTON’S VERY OWN FRANKENSTEIN
To the contrary, its instruments of terror and occupation were the best weapons that the American taxpayers could buy. That included 2,300 Humvees and tens of thousands of automatic weapons, as well as vast stores of ammunition, trucks, rockets, artillery pieces and even tanks and helicopters.
And that wasn’t the half of it. The Islamic State also filled the power vacuum in Syria created by its so-called civil war. But in truth that was another exercise in Washington-inspired and Washington-financed regime change undertaken in connivance with Qatar and Saudi Arabia.
The princes of the Petro-states were surely not interested in expelling the tyranny next door. Instead, the rebellion was about removing Iran’s Alawite/Shiite ally from power in Damascus and laying the gas pipelines to Europe – which Assad had vetoed – across the upper Euphrates Valley.
In any event, due to Washington’s regime change policy in Syria, ISIS soon had even more troves of American weapons. Some of them were supplied to Sunni radicals by way of Qatar and Saudi Arabia.
More came up the so-called “ratline” from Qaddafi’s former arsenals in Benghazi through Turkey. And still more came through Jordan from the “moderate” opposition trained there by the CIA, which more often than not sold them or defected to the other side.
That the Islamic State was Washington’s Frankenstein monster, therefore, became evident from the moment it rushed upon the scene in mid-2014. But even then, the Washington War Party could not resist adding fuel to the fire, whooping up another round of Islamophobia among the American public and forcing the Obama White House into a futile bombing campaign for the third time in a quarter century.
But the short-lived Islamic State was never a real threat to America’s homeland security.
The dusty, broken, impoverished towns and villages along the margins of the Euphrates River and in the bombed-out precincts of Anbar province did not attract thousands of wannabe jihadists from the failed states of the Middle East and the alienated Muslim townships of Europe because the caliphate offered prosperity, salvation or any future at all.
What recruited them was outrage at the bombs and drones dropped on Sunni communities by the U.S. Air Force and by the cruise missiles launched from the bowels of the Mediterranean that ripped apart homes, shops, offices and mosques which mostly contained as many innocent civilians as ISIS terrorists.
The truth is, the Islamic State was destined for a short half-life anyway. It had been contained by the Kurds in the North and East and by Turkey with NATO’s second-largest army and air force in the Northwest. And it was further surrounded by the Shiite Crescent in the populated, economically viable regions of lower Syria and Iraq.
Absent Washington’s misbegotten campaign to unseat Assad in Damascus and demonize his confession-based Iranian ally, there would have been nowhere for the murderous fanatics who had pitched a makeshift capital in Raqqa to go. They would have run out of money, recruits, momentum and public acquiescence in their horrific rule in any event.
But with the U.S. Air Force functioning as their recruiting arm and France’s anti-Assad foreign policy helping to foment a final spasm of anarchy in Syria, the gates of hell had been opened wide, unnecessarily.
What has been puked out was not an organized war on Western civilization as former French president Hollande so hysterically proclaimed in response to one of the predictable terrorist episodes of mayhem in Paris.
It was just blow-back carried out by that infinitesimally small contingent of mentally deformed young men who can be persuaded to strap on a suicide belt.
In any event, bombing did not defeat ISIS; it just temporarily made more of them.
Ironically, what did extinguish the Islamic State was the Assad military, the Russian air force invited into Syria by its official government and the ground forces of its Hezbollah and the Iranian Revolutionary Guard allies. It was they who settled an ancient quarrel Sunni/Shiite that had never been any of America’s business anyway.
But Imperial Washington was so caught up in its myths, lies and hegemonic stupidity that it could not see the obvious. Accordingly, 31 years after the Cold War ended and several years after Syria and friends extinguished the Islamic State, Washington has learned no lessons.
The American Imperium still stalks the planet for new monsters to destroy – presently in the precincts of Russian-speaking eastern and southern Ukraine that are utterly irrelevant to America’s peace and security.
Next On Deck – The Ukraine Disaster
The present disaster in Ukraine incepted with the Washington-sponsored Maidan coup of February 2014. Among other things it was a “revenge intervention” designed to punish Russia for being so bold as to thwart the neocon regime change adventure in Syria; and especially to haze Putin for persuading Assad to give up his chemical weapons, thereby removing any pretext for Washington military intervention.
As it happened, the Russian-friendly president of Ukraine at the time, Vicktor Yanukovych, had at the last minute in late 2013 ditched a long-pending EU affiliation agreement and IMF stabilization plan in favor of a more attractive deal with Moscow. Under the so-called rule of law, that reversal would hardly seem outside the realm of sovereign prerogative.
But not by the lights of Washington, red-hot from being check-mated in Syria. Accordingly, the neocon operatives in the Obama national security apparatus, spear-headed by the horrid Victoria Nuland, insisted that the Russian deal not be allowed to stand and that Ukraine’s accession to NATO should be fast-tracked.
So doing, they demonstrated an immense ignorance about the 800-year history of the various territories which had been cobbled together in the artificial state of Ukraine, and the long-history of these pieces and parts as vassals and appendages of both Greater Russia and various eastern European kingdoms and empires that had marched back and forth across the pages of history.
In a word, they dove into a rabbit hole that has made Washington’s misadventures in the middle east small potatoes by comparison. But the War Party would not be stopped, believing that its vast conventional military armada and the reach of its global economic sanctions could bring Putin to heel, as well.
In this context, however, it can be truly said that occasionally a few words are worth a thousand pictures–at least when it comes to Ukraine. Here’s one of them:
The Ukrainian leader said that his country hadn’t been willing to cede territory from the beginning. “Had we been willing to give up our territory, there would have been no war,” Zelensky said.
He got that right!
So the question recurs. Why is it worth Washington’s sweeping Sanctions War on Russia, which is destroying the dollar-based global trading and payments system and triggering a worldwide inflationary calamity, to defend every inch of a sketchy map located on Russia’s doorstep? And that’s to say nothing of risking nuclear war!
Indeed, as we elaborate below, the present Ukrainian territorial map exists only due to the handiwork of Lenin, Stalin and Khrushchev. Here is how and when these brutal tyrants attached each piece of today’s Ukrainian map (in purple, light blue and red, respectively) to the territories acquired or seized by the Russian Czars over 1654-1917 (yellow)
Nor should any mystery linger as to where these pieces and parts came from. When the creators of the Soviet Empire carved out a convenient administrative entity during the early 1920s that they were pleased to call the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic they were shuffling around blocks of territory and peoples that had mostly been ruled by Czarist Russia during its final centuries.
In fact, prior to the commie takeover of Russia, no country that even faintly resembled today’s Ukrainian borders had ever existed.
To the contrary, much of the territories which comprise present day Ukraine have been been joined at the hip with mother Russia for most of the last three centuries: During Imperial times that was via old-fashioned vassal protection and sponsorship and during the brutal rule of the Soviet communists between 1922-1991 it was via totalitarian command.
But remove the dastardly work of Lenin, Stalin and Khrushchev during the latter interval, and nothing like today’s map would exist, nor would Washington be starting a global economic war and triggering soaring energy, food and commodity prices. That’s because the four territories recently “annexed” by Russia would already have been integral parts of Russia!
For want of doubt here are sequential maps that tell the story and which make mincemeat of the Washington sanctity of borders malarkey. In fact, the approximate territory of the four annexed regions – Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia – plus Crimea are evident in the yellow area of this 220-years ago map (@1800).
Collectively, they were known as Novorossiya or “New Russia” and had been acquired by Russian rulers, including Catherine the Great between 1734 and 1791.
As is evident from the year-markings in red on the map, the Russian Empire had gradually gained control over the area, signing peace treaties with the Cossack Hetmanate (1734) and with the Ottoman Empire at the conclusion of the various Russo-Turkish Wars of the 18th century.
Pursuant to this expansion drive – which included massive Russian investment and the in-migration of large Russian populations to the region – Russia established the Novorossiysk Governaorate in 1764. The latter was originally to be named after the Empress Catherine, but she decreed that it should be called “New Russia” instead.
Completing the assemblage of New Russia, Catherine forcefully liquidated the Zaporizhian Sich (present day Zaporizhzhia) in 1775 and annexed its territory to Novorossiya, thus eliminating the independent rule of the Ukrainian Cossacks. Later in 1783 she also acquired Crimea from the Turks, which was also added to Novorossiya.
During this formative period, the infamous shadow ruler under Catherine, Prince Grigori Potempkin, directed the sweeping colonization and Russification of the land. Effectively, the Russian Empress had granted him the powers of an absolute ruler over the area from 1774 onward.
The spirit and importance of “New Russia” at this time is aptly captured by the historian Willard Sunderland,
The old steppe was Asian and stateless; the current one was state-determined and claimed for European-Russian civilization. The world of comparison was now even more obviously that of the Western empires. Consequently it was all the more clear that the Russian empire merited its own New Russia to go along with everyone else’s New Spain, New France and New England. The adoption of the name of New Russia was in fact the most powerful statement imaginable of Russia’s national coming of age.
Well, yes, but borders!
In fact, the passage of time solidified the border of Novorossiya even more solidly. One century latter the light yellow area of this 1897 map gave an unmistakable message: To wit, in the late Russian Empire there was no doubt as to the paternity of the lands adjacent to the Azov Sea and the Black Sea—they were now part of the 125 years-old “New Russia”.
After the madness of WWI and the Bolshevik Revolution, of course, the borders of much of eastern and central Europe were drastically re-arranged. For instance, at the so-called Versailles Peace Conference in 1919 new countries were fashioned from whole cloth (Czechoslovakia) and long dead countries (Poland) were revived—both upon their own ancient lands as well as those of their former neighbors.
Another of these post-WWI creations was Yugoslavia. The kingdom was formed in December 1918, with Serbia’s royal family, the Karadjordjevics, becoming the monarchs of the new country, which was officially called the Kingdom of the Serbs, Croats and Slovenes until 1929 – when it became Yugoslavia. By 1946 it had been incorporated into the Soviet Warsaw Pact, with the borders and constituent parts shown below.
Needless to say, all of these circa 1919 creations and borders have long ceased to exist.After a decade of civil wars and civilian slaughter in the 1990s, Yugoslavia has become seven independent nations. And not only that: The apparently non-sacrosanct borders of Yugoslavia were rent asunder by NATO bombs, armaments, economic and political aid and covert operations!
And then having torn up the old maps like a mere “scrap of paper”, NATO made the new national entities its very own, with the majority now actually members of the North Atlantic Treaty Alliance – a vestigial organ that was designed to keep the Balkans contained and the Soviet Union throttled, neither of which condition any more even exists.
By the same token, the present-day borders of Poland were moved far to the west at Stalin’s insistence at Yalta. Consequently, the revived nation of “Poland”, which had earlier been created by Woodrow Wilson at Versailles to court the growing Midwestern Polish vote, took on a wholly new map.
That is to say, Poland had been dismembered and deleted from the maps by the European powers in the 1790s; had been revived by Wilson’s ignorant demands at Versailles that moved it deep into historic German territories and provided the political fuel for Hitler’s revanchism; and then drastically rearranged again at Yalta where the cynical Churchill and the malevolent Stalin outmaneuvered the senile Roosevelt.
Thus, the area outlined in dark blue was Wilson’s Poland, but the huge swath in pink was gifted to Stalin by FDR and Churchill at Yalta. At the same time, the brown areas including the free city of Danzig (Gdansk) and the Danzig Corridor to its right were swiped from the remains of Hitler’s Germany and given back to what amounted to Poland 3.0 – and just within the first half of the 20th century!
The same story holds for Czechoslovakia. Its three constituent nations were hammered together at Versailles from the remnants of the Austrian Empire, but eventually went their separate ways after the rule of communism ended in 1991. Today the Czech State and Slovakia exist peacefully side-by-side, and the world is no worse for the wear after their partition.
As it happens, however, there is one politically engineered post-WWI map from the region that hasn’t been undone. For reasons known only by the Washington neocons and Warfare State apparatus, the modern borders of Ukraine – hammered together by the writ of Lenin, Stalin and Khrushchev after 1918 – are apparently the exception to the rule.
Indeed, they are deemed to be so sacrosanct as to justify monkey-hammering the global economy with a destructive Sanctions War, even to the point of risking hot military confrontation between the world’s two major nuclear powers.
Of course, had the above mentioned 20th century communist trio been benefactors of mankind, perhaps their map-making handiwork might have been justified. Under this benign contrafactual, they would have presumably combined peoples of like ethnic, linguistic, religious and politico-cultural history into a cohesive natural polity and state. That is, a nation worth perpetuating, defending and perhaps even dying for.
Alas, the very opposite was true. From 1922 to 1991 modern Ukraine was held together by the monopoly on violence of its brutally totalitarian rulers. And when they temporarily lost control during the military battles of World War II, the administrative entity called Ukraine came apart at the seams.
That is, local Ukrainian nationalists joined Hitler’s Wehrmacht in its depredations against Jews, Poles, Roma and Russians when it first swept through the country from the west on its way to Stalingrad; and then, in turn, the Russian populations from the Donbas and south campaigned with the Red Army during its vengeance-wreaking return from the east after winning the bloody battle that turned the course of WWII.
Not surprisingly, therefore, virtually from the minute it came out from under the communist yoke when the Soviet Union was swept into the dustbin of history in 1991, Ukraine has been engulfed in political and actual civil war. The elections which did occur were essentially 50/50 at the national level but reflected votes of 80/20 within the regions. That is, the Ukrainian nationalist candidates tended to get vote margins of 80% + in the West/Central areas, while Russian-sympathizing candidates got like pluralities in the East/South.
This pattern transpired because once the iron-hand of totalitarian rule ended in 1991, the deep and historically rooted conflict between Ukrainian nationalism, language and politics of the central and western regions of the country and the Russian language and historical religious and political affinities of the Donbas and south came rushing to the surface. So-called democracy barely survived these contests until February 2014 when one of Washington’s “color revolutions” finally “succeeded”. That is to say, the aforementioned Washington fomented and financed nationalist-led coupe d état ended the tenuous post-communist equilibrium.
As to the adverse shock effect of the Maidan coup on Ukrainian governance and external policy with respect to Russia, the maps below tell you all you need to know. The first map is from the 2004 presidential election, which was won by the Ukrainian nationalist candidate, Yushchenko, who predominated in the yellow areas of the map, over the pro-Russian Yanukovych, who swept the blue regions in the east and south.
The second map is from the 2010 election, showing the same stark regional split, but this time the pro-Russian candidate, Yanukovych, won.
In the map below, the dark blue parts to the far east (Donbas) indicate an 80% or better vote for Viktor Yanukovych in the 2010 election. By contrast, the dark red areas in the west voted 80% or more for the Ukrainian nationalist, Yulie Tymoshenko. That is to say, the skew in the Ukrainian electorate was so extreme as to make America’s current red state/blue state divide seem hardly noteworthy by comparison.
As it happened, the sum of the pro-Yanukovych skews from the east and south (Donbas and Crimea) added up to 12.48 million votes and 48.95% of the total, while the sum of the extreme red skews in the center and west (the lands of old eastern Galicia and Poland) amounted to 11.59 million votes and 45.47% of the total.
Stated differently, it is hard to imagine an electorate more sharply divided on a regional/ethnic/language basis. Yet it was one which still produced a sufficiently clear victory margin (3.6 percentage points) for Yanukovych – so as to be reluctantly accepted by all parties. That became especially clear when Tymoshenko, who was the incumbent prime minister, withdrew her election challenge a few weeks after the run-off in February 2010.
At that point, of course, Russia had no beef with the Kiev government at all because essentially Yanukovych’s “Regions Party” was based on the pro-Russian parts (blue areas) of the Ukrainian electorate.
During the next several years the economic basket case which was Ukraine attempted to improve its circumstances by running a bake-off of sorts between the European Union and Russia with respect to aid and trade deals.
And well its leaders might have: After the fall of communism, Ukraine had become a cesspool of financial corruption in which a handful of oligarchs had robbed the country blind. By 2014 its real GDP had consequently fallen to $568 billion (2017$), which amounted to a 37% shrinkage from even the threadbare communist economics of 1990.
Accordingly, the supposedly pro-Russian Yanukovych administration initiated in March 2012 the above-mentioned Association Agreement with the European Union that was to provide trade advantages and an IMF aid package.
However, the EU leaders insisted that no agreement could be ratified unless Ukraine addressed concerns over a “stark deterioration of democracy and the rule of law”, including the imprisonment of Yulia Tymoshenko in 2011. In order to address these concerns, in fact, President Yanukovych urged the parliament to adopt laws so that Ukraine would meet the EU’s criteria.
Crash of Ukraine’s Real GDP, 1990-2014
But it was the parallel $4 billion IMF loan that turned out to be the straw that broke the camel’s back. According to then Prime Minister Mykola Azarov “the extremely harsh conditions” of the IMF loan (presented by the IMF in November 2013) included big budget cuts and a 40% increase in natural gas bills. Those proved to be hills too high to climb for most of the factions within the fractionated Ukraine polity.
Accordingly, the IMF demands became the clinching argument behind the Ukrainian government’s abrupt decision to suspend preparations for signing the Association Agreement with the EU. Instead, Kiev quickly pivoted to a deal with Russia in the fall of 2013, which was willing to offer $15 billion in loans without the harsh IMF pre-conditions. Also, Moscow offered Ukraine a discount on Ukraine’s large gas purchases from Russia.
The rest is history, as it were. As mentioned above, the Washington neocons were not about to accept Kiev’s pivot to Russia come hell or high water.
So they swung into action bringing all the instruments of the Empire – the CIA, the State Department, NED, the NGOs and favored Ukrainian oligarchs – to bear on scuttling the Russian deal and removing Yanukovych from office.
In a later interview with a US journalist, in fact, Ukrainian billionaire oligarch and opposition leader, Petro Poroshenko (who later became president), said quite clearly that the plan was to subvert the nation’s constitution and install an unelected, anti-Russian government that would deep-six the deal with Moscow:
“From the beginning, I was one of the organizers of the Maidan. My television channel – Channel 5 – played a tremendously important role. … On the 11th of December, when we had U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland and E.U. diplomat Catherine Ashton in Kyiv, during the night they started to storm the Maidan.”
It should never be forgotten, therefore, that the coup which overthrew the constitutionally elected government in Kiev was a $5 billion all-hands Washington undertaking. It would never have come to fruition as a successful regime change putsch without the heavy hands of the US State Department along with the other above-mentioned arms of the empire.
Needless to say, nullification of a country’s election – backed by the stick of NATO’s military might and the carrot of billions from a Washington/EU/IMF consortium – is big league meddling. Well, except by the clueless hypocrisy of the Washington foreign policy blob.
Indeed, as former president Obama told CNN at the time, Washington was just going about its “indispensable nation” business. It had helpfully encouraged another “flowering of democracy” and to that end it had,
“……brokered a deal to transition power in Ukraine.”
Brokered a deal my eye!
This was a blatant and inexcusable breach of so-called “international law” because it served the will-to-power objectives of the Washington neocons and kept the now largely obsolete US foreign policy apparatus in the hegemony game – to say nothing of recruiting a new customer for arms sales.
Never mind that Washington’s massive political and financial support for the Maidan uprising on the streets of Kiev, and then nearly instantaneous recognition of the resulting putsch as the official government of the Ukraine, was a frontal assault on the nation’s sovereignty.
The late and detestable Senator John McCain even went to Kiev to show solidarity with the Euromaidan activists. McCain dined with opposition leaders, including members of the ultra-right‐wing Svoboda Party and later appeared on stage in Maidan Square during a mass rally.
There he stood shoulder to shoulder with Svoboda leader Oleh Tyahnybok, who made no secret of his pro-Nazi convictions.
But McCain’s actions were a model of diplomatic restraint compared to the conduct of Victoria Nuland, the assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian Affairs, who, by your way, was soon back in the same position in the Biden Administration, conducting the same pro-war neocon policies.
As Ukraine’s political crisis deepened, Nuland and her subordinates became more brazen in favoring the anti‐Yanukovych demonstrators. Nuland noted in a speech to the U.S.-Ukraine Foundation in December 2013, that she had traveled to Ukraine three times in the weeks following the start of the demonstrations. Visiting the Maidan on December 5, she famously handed out cookies to demonstrators and expressed support for their cause.
Washington’s conduct not only constituted meddling, but it also bordered on puppeteering. At one point, US Ambassador Pyatt mentioned the complex dynamic among the three principal ultra-nationalist opposition leaders, Arseniy Yatsenyuk, Oleh Tyahnybok, and Vitali Klitschko
Both Pyatt and Nuland wanted to keep Tyahnybok and Klitschko out of an interim government. In the former case, they worried about his extremist neo-Nazi ties; in the latter, they appeared to want him to wait and make a bid for office on a longer‐term basis (This former boxing champion became the current pugnacious mayor of Kiev).
Nuland thus famously stated that,
“I don’t think Klitsch should go into the government. I don’t think it’s necessary.” She added that what Yatseniuk needed “is Klitsch and Tyahnybok on the outside.”
The two diplomats were also prepared to escalate the already extensive U.S. involvement in Ukraine’s political turbulence by bringing in the Big Guy.
Pyatt stated bluntly that,
“…..we want to try to get somebody with an international personality to come out here and help to midwife this thing [the political transition].”
Nuland clearly had Vice President Joe Biden in mind for that role. Noting that the vice president’s national security adviser was in direct contact with her, Nuland related that she told him,
“…probably tomorrow for an atta‐boy and to get the details to stick. So Biden’s willing.”
That is to say, Victoria Nuland didn’t merely tell some undercover operatives to buy ads on Ukrainian social media, as Russia was accused of doing during the 2016 US election. To the contrary, she actually picked Yanukovych’s successor and the entire cabinet!
And we know this from a hacked phone call between Nuland and the US ambassador in Kiev. In discussing who should lead the Washington-installed government, Nuland made clear who the next prime minister would be and who he should be talking to for advice.
Nuland: I think Yats (Arseniy Yatseniuk) is the guy who’s got the economic experience, the governing experience. … what he needs is Klitsch and Tyahnybok on the outside. He needs to be talking to them four times a week, you know.
As it turned out, the putsch leaders followed Nuland’s advice to the letter, installing “Yats” as the new prime minister. But it also filled four cabinet posts out of eleven with rabid anti-Russian neo-Nazis.
Indeed, at the heart of the putsch were Ukrainian organizations called Svoboda (national socialist party of Ukraine) and Right Sector.Their national hero was one Stepan Bandera – a collaborator with Hitler who led the liquidation of thousands of Poles, Jews and other minorities as the Nazi Wehrmacht, as previously mentioned, made it way through Ukraine toward Stalingrad in the early 1940s.
In fact, another founder and leader of Svoboda, Andriy Parubiy, was given a portfolio which included the Ministry of Defense, the Armed Forces, Law Enforcement, National Security and Intelligence. That the Kremlin was alarmed by these developments and that the Russian-speaking populations of Crimea and the Donbas (the blue areas on the electoral map above) feared an ethnic cleansing led by the new Ukrainian nationalist government in Kiev is hardly surprising.
Indeed, the first legislative act of the new government was the abolition, on February 23, 2014, of the Kivalov-Kolesnichenko law of 2012 which made Russian an official language. As one commentator noted, it was a bit as if putschists decided that French and Italian would no longer be official languages in Switzerland.
The Russian language ban caused a storm in the Russian-speaking population. This resulted in fierce repression against the Russian-speaking regions (Odessa, Dnepropetrovsk, Kharkov, Lugansk and Donetsk) which began in February 2014 and led to a militarization of the situation and some notorious massacres (those in Odessa and Mariupol were the most odious).
By the end of summer 2014, Crimea had return to Mother Russia after an overwhelming plebiscite and the self-proclaimed republics of Donetsk and Lugansk became the object of a vicious civil war conducted by Kiev.
As we have amplified elsewhere, Sevastopol in Crimea has been the homeport of the Russian Naval Fleet under czars and commissars alike. After 171 years as an integral part of the Russian Motherland, it only technically became part of Ukraine during a Khrushchev inspired shuffle in 1954.
The fact is, only 10% of the Crimean population is Ukrainian speaking, and it was the coup on the streets of Kiev by extremist anti-Russian Ukrainian nationalists and proto-fascists that caused the Russian speakers in Crimea to panic and Moscow to become alarmed about the status of its historic naval base, for which it still had a lease running to the 2040s.
Thus, during a referendum in March 2014 83% of eligible Crimeans turned out to vote and 97% of those approved cancelling the 1954 edict of the Soviet Presidium that gifted Russian-Crimea to Ukraine. There is absolutely no evidence that the 80% of Crimeans who thus voted to sever their historically short-lived affiliation with Ukraine were threatened or coerced by Moscow.
Indeed, what they actually feared were the edicts against Russian language and culture coming out of Kiev. And exactly the same thing was true of the overwhelmingly Russian-speaking populations of the Donbas.
So in the context of a relentless and pointless NATO expansion to the very borders of the shrunken Russian state, Washington did not merely sponsor and fund the overthrow of Ukraine’s constitutionally elected government in February 2014. But once it had unleashed a devastating civil war, it also relentlessly blocked for eight years running the obvious alternative to the bloodshed that had claimed 14,000 civilian and military casualties, even before the current hot war commenced.
To wit, Ukraine could have been partitioned with autonomy for the Russian-speaking Donbas provinces – or even accession to the Russian state from which these communities had essentially originated.
So the appalling truth of the matter is this: Adding insult to injury after its blatantly foolish and reckless coup in February 2014, Washington now insists that the grandsons and granddaughters of Stalin’s industrial army in the Donbas are to be ruled by the grandsons and granddaughters of Hitler’s collaborators in Kiev, whether they like it or not.
Yet that historic chasm is exactly where the present civil war originated.
And its also why partition of an artificial polity forced together by 20th century communist dictators is the only way out.
THE NATO FACTOR
The current CIA director, William J Burns, actually recognized the eventual crack-up of Ukraine back in 2008, when he served as U.S. ambassador to Russia. After Ukraine’s NATO aspirations were announced at that year’s Bucharest Security Conference, Burns wrote a secret cable (subsequently published by Wikileaks) entitled,
“Nyet Means Nyet: Russia’s NATO Enlargement Redlines”.
The missive to Washington contained a stern warning of trouble to come:
Ukraine and Georgia’s NATO aspirations not only touch a raw nerve in Russia, they engender serious concerns about the consequences for stability in the region. Not only does Russia perceive encirclement, and efforts to undermine Russia’s influence in the region, but it also fears unpredictable and uncontrolled consequences which would seriously affect Russian security interests.
Experts tell us that Russia is particularly worried that the strong divisions in Ukraine over NATO membership, with much of the ethnic-Russian community against membership, could lead to a major split, involving violence or at worst, civil war. In that eventuality, Russia would have to decide whether to intervene; a decision Russia does not want to have to face.
He got that right!
For more than two decades, Washington’s NATO expansion policy has been a dagger aimed at the heart of an inherently divided Ukrainian polity—a division that had been suppressed by 69 years of brutal communist rule, but which broke into the open after the Soviet Union fell in 1991.
So, as Burns predicted, in response to the 2014 putsch, Russian-speaking Ukrainians in the eastern Donbas region rose up against the coup government in Kiev, which they denounced as an illegitimate Western puppet regime, riddled with anti-Russian Neo-Nazis.
Independence activists declared the creation of two new autonomous states, the Donetsk and Lugansk People’s Republics. In turn, the new anti-Russian Ukrainian government in Kiev, with abundant Western military support and weapons, launched a brutal war against these breakaway republics–an assault that went on until the Russian invasion of February 24, 2022.
As Kiev’s assault in the Donbas unfolded, upwards of 14,000 Ukrainians were killed, and hundreds of thousands more were displaced – all before the Russian invasion commenced.
Moreover, the manner in which the two new breakaway republics armed themselves for combat against Kiev’s forces tells you all you need to know about the deep divisions in the Ukrainian polity. These were fissures which were instantly brought to the surface by the Maidan coup.
According to Jacques Baud, a NATO adviser to Ukraine during that period, the breakaway Republic fighters got their arms mainly from defecting Ukrainian units, not Russia!
Folks, when entire military units defect with their arms and fighting wherewithal, you are not dealing with minor differences of opinion among a nation’s population; it’s a sign of deep and likely irreconcilable strife. As Baud has further noted,
In 2014, I (was) at NATO, responsible for the fight against the proliferation of small arms, and we (were) trying to detect Russian arms deliveries to the rebels in order to see if Moscow (was) involved.
The rebels are armed thanks to the defections of Russian-speaking Ukrainian units which cross over to the rebel side. As the Ukrainian failures progressed, the entire tank, artillery or anti-aircraft battalions swelled the ranks of the autonomists. This is what (drove) the Ukrainians to commit to the Minsk Accords.
Just after signing the Minsk 1 Accords in September 2014, however, then Ukrainian President and corrupt oligarch, Petro Poroshenko, launched a vast anti-terrorist operation against the Donbas. But poorly advised by NATO officers, the Ukrainians suffered a crushing defeat at Debaltsevo, which forced them to commit to the Minsk 2 Agreements in February 2015.
As it happened, these Agreements provided for neither the separation nor the independence of the Republics, but their autonomy within the framework of Ukraine. That is, the ultimate status of the republics was to be negotiated between Kiev and the representatives of the republics, for an internal solution to the crisis of Ukraine’s split polity.
But owing to Washington’s writs this was not to be. Instead, the post-coup Kiev government waged a brutal civil war against the Donbas for eight years. This attack was resisted by Russian-speaking Ukrainians who were deathly afraid of being ruled by the neo-Nazi elements which permeated the Kiev government, military and security forces (SBU).
Indeed, even though he had run as the peace candidate, Zelensky put the kibosh on Minsk 2 soon after he was installed in office in 2019. The Minsk agreements, of course, had detailed how Kiev could reintegrate its breakaway regions by offering them a general amnesty, greater autonomy, and representation in the government.
But after having his very life threatened by the Azov militias embedded in Ukraine’s military, Zelensky and other senior officials declared that the Minsk agreements could not be implemented. Instead, they claimed that they could only proceed with their obligations under the agreements after retaking control of the rebel-held areas.
Needless to say, as far as the breakaway republics were concerned, disarmament first and negotiations later was an absurd non-starter. In fact, after the fall of 2019, the Zelensky government made a bee line toward severe intensification of the raging civil war,
To that end, it caused ascension to NATO to be added to its constitution, even as Zelensky issued at executive order vowing to recover Crimea. Yet as we have frequently explained that territory and the site of Russia’s most strategic naval base had never been part of Ukraine until 1954 when Khrushchev gifted it to the brutal communist rulers in Kiev for their help in securing the succession after Stalin’s death.
Moreover, once Zelensky intensified the civil war the idea that Ukraine had anything to do with a functioning democracy lost all meaning. Zelensky’s government soon arrested the leading opposition politicians, shut-down all opposition media by combing multiple TV outlets into a single government propaganda network and, as we saw earlier, initially even outlawed the use of the Russian language.
So long before Russia invaded on February 24, 2022, a bloody civil war raged in the unnatural polity called Ukraine. The latter was inherently not built to last given its deep ethnic divisions and especially the legacy of the aforementioned bloody history during WWII, when the country was bitterly divided between populations loyal to Hitler’s Wehrmacht versus those aligned with Stalin’s Red Army. Like after the American civil war, the animosity lasted for decades.
So again, as Jacques Baud noted, this was a civil war: There were never major Russian troops in the Donbass before February 24, 2022. Even the US intelligence map published by the Washington Post on December 3, 2021 does not show Russian troops in the Donbass.
Indeed, as far back as October 2015, Vasyl Hrytsak, director of the Ukrainian Security Service (SBU), confessed that only 56 Russian fighters had been observed in the Donbass. It was hardly even comparable to that of the Swiss going to fight in Bosnia during the weekends, in the 1990s, or the French mercenaries who are going to fight in Ukraine today.
The Ukrainian army was then in a deplorable state. In October 2018, after four years of war, Ukraine’s chief military prosecutor, Antoly Matios, said that Ukraine had lost 2,700 men in the Donbass but not from the much larger combat losses. Instead, he referenced losses including 891 from disease, 318 from traffic accidents, 177 from other accidents, 175 from poisoning (alcohol, drugs), 172 from careless handling of weapons, 101 from breaches of safety rules, 228 from murder and 615 from suicide!
In fact, like everything else in Ukraine, the Army has been severely undermined by the corruption of its cadres. According to a UK Home Office report, when reservists were called up in March-April 2014, 70% did not show up for the first session, 80% for the second, 90% for the third and 95% for the fourth.
Thus, to compensate for the lack of soldiers, the Ukrainian government resorted to paramilitary militias. They were essentially made up of foreign mercenaries. As of 2020, they constituted around 40% of Ukraine’s forces and numbered around 102,000 men according to a in-depth Reuters investigation. That is to say, much of what constituted the Ukrainian military force on the eve of the Russian invasions was armed, financed and trained by the United States, Great Britain, Canada and France.
These militias, stemming from the far-right groups that led the Euromaidan revolution in 2014, are made up of fanatical and brutal individuals. The best known of these is the Azov regiment, whose emblem is reminiscent of that of the 2nd SS Das Reich Panzer Division. The latter is the object of nationalist veneration in Ukraine for having liberated Kharkov from the Soviets in 1943.
None of this is a secret, even if it has been banned from the 24/7 news narrative. So the West supports and continues to arm militias that have been guilty of widespread crimes against the civilian populations of the Donbas since 2014, including rape, torture and massacres.
Moreover, the integration of these paramilitary forces into the National Guard was not at all accompanied by a “denazification”, as is frequently claimed. Among the many examples, that of the insignia of the Azov Regiment is edifying:
Finally, on the eve of the invasion the Kiev government moved to drastically intensify the civil war and its brutal campaign against the breakaway republics. Beginning on February 16th – a week before the invasion – Ukrainian artillery shelling of the civilian populations of the Donbass increased dramatically, as shown by the daily reports of OSCE (Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe) observers.
Naturally, neither the media, nor the European Union, nor NATO, nor any Western government reacted or intervened even verbally.
At the same time, there were also reports of acts of sabotage in the Donbass. On January 18, Donbass fighters intercept saboteurs equipped with Western equipment and speaking Polish seeking to create chemical incidents in Gorlivka.
The Ukrainian artillery bombardments on the populations of Donbass continued to intensify as shown below – so on February 23, the two Republics requested military aid from Russia. And on the 24th, Vladimir Putin invoked Article 51 of the United Nations Charter which provides for mutual military assistance within the framework of a defensive alliance.
At that point, the Ukrainian civil war became international, and the artificial nation that was not “Built to Last” was ushered into its death throes
Indeed, the real truth of the matter is that Imperial Washington is now reaping the whirlwind it sowed over decades by massive interference in the internal politics and governance process of countries all over the world – of which the vignette above about the Ukrainian coup and its bloody aftermath is only the latest flock of chickens to come home to roost.
Contrary to the bombast, jingoism, and shrill moralizing flowing from Washington and the mainstream media, America had absolutely no national security interest – even to this day – in the spat between Putin and the coup that unconstitutionally took over Kiev in February 2014. That changed everything and knocked the props out from under Washington’s current sanctimonious attacks on Putin for finally resorting to its own game.
As we said, Ukraine was “Not Built to Last”. Yet notwithstanding all of these damning realities, Zelensky continues to peevishly and arrogantly demand that Washington and the west stand-up an on-ramp to WWIII (e.g. a No-Fly Zone) in order to defend every inch of this artifact of recent history called Ukraine.
After all, if according to the horse’s mouth itself there would have been no war had Ukraine been willing to give up the historic Russian territories of Crimea and the Donbas in the first place, then why isn’t Washington making a bee line toward the negotiating table to offer just that?
If the truth be told, of course, it is not interested in ending the Ukraine War or saving a nation which cannot and should not be saved.
To the contrary, Washington and its fawning media acolytes have become so crazed with anti-Putin hysteria that they will not be satiated until Russia itself is brought down – even if that threatens to bring down the entire dollar-based global trade and payments system on which America’s tenuous prosperity depends [end]
[my illustration : Nigerian vice-president Kashim Shettima and Vladimir Putin, on July 27, 2023 (official)]
The successful second Russia-Africa Summit on July 27-28 represents an extraordinary breakthrough in the development of a new world order free from the domination of Western imperialist powers. Delegations from 49 African countries participated in the summit, including seventeen heads of state. They adopted a 74-point final declaration on virtually all areas of cooperation, trade and security, with a preamble clarifying the fundamental principles that should govern international relations. The summit built on the initiative of the first Russia-Africa forum held in 2019, reaffirming the historic bonds of fraternal cooperation resulting from their common struggle in the 20th century against Western colonialism.
In fact, the Final Declaration of the Summit is a clear challenge to the West because it asserts strongly the growing role and global influence of Africa and the African Union as an essential pillar of a multipolar world. It insists on the need to oppose neocolonialism expressed in the imposition of conditions and double standards that prevent sovereign decision-making about countries’ different paths to development. Russia and Africa also reject the use of coercive measures and expressed the commitment of the signatory countries “to the fundamental principles and purposes of the United Nations Charter, subscribing to safeguarding and upholding international law and emphasizing the need for the adherence thereto by all States,”
The Russian Federation pledged to promote an expansion of Africa’s representation in the UN Security Council. The African countries and Russia are going to create a strategic partnership mechanism and Russia will negotiate opening new embassies in Africa among other measures to improve diplomatic relations between African countries and the Russian Federation. Along with these decisions, it should be noted that the Russian Federation has cancelled bilateral debt with African countries worth US$23 billion dollars is supporting African nations to develop their energy infrastructure. Currently, Russia is engaged in over 30 electricity generating projects in 16 African countries while gas infrastructure projects are also being negotiated to facilitate the shipment of liquefied gas.
President Vladimir Putin thanked Africa’s proposals to settle the conflict in Ukraine, commenting, “The initiative itself, like any other peace initiative, is good… There are things that are already being implemented after we discussed them at our meeting in St. Petersburg a month and a half ago.” Regarding the failure of the agreement on the export of grain through the Black Sea, noting the bad faith and hypocrisy of the West benefiting its large agribusiness corporations, President Putin observed that under the grain agreement: “Countries like Ethiopia, Sudan, Somalia and some others received, please note this, less than 3% of the total volume, less than one million tons.” On the other hand, it was announced that, in the near future, Russia will supply grain free to six African countries (Burkina Faso, Zimbabwe, Mali, Somalia, Central African Republic and Eritrea), while during the current year the trade of agro-industrial products between Russia and Africa has grown by 60%.
The speeches by the heads of State participating in the Summit touched on issues of global relevance, especially for Latin America, stressing the issues of colonialism, neocolonialism and the imperative of defending national sovereignty. President Putin commented, “Sovereignty cannot be viewed as something that can be achieved once and for all. It is something you must fight for all the time.” Regarding the same issue of sovereignty, the head of the Libyan Presidential Council Mohamed Younis Ahmed Al-Manfi said: “Africa believes that it was subjected to unfair exploitation for several centuries and that although formally all countries got rid of the colonial yoke, we haven’t yet managed to create genuinely national states. Now we must strive, together with the African Union, to change the membership system in the UN Security Council. Despite a number of unimportant reforms, the West has recently continued preserving its dominant position. It is trying to exert all-round pressure on us, using our financial debts in its own interest, destroying our economies and increasing poverty and misery in our countries in every possible way.”
Of central importance at the Summit was the topic of financial independence and the use of national currencies in trade. Russian exports of oil and its derivatives to African countries have multiplied by two point six times in the last two years. Being able to pay for these imports in their local currencies would be a great financial relief for African countries and would be in line with the decision recently announced by the president of the New Development Bank of the BRICS bloc, Dilma Rousseff, to offer at least 30% of the bank’s loans in local currencies. Interviewed on July 29th, Russian Deputy Prime Minister Aleksey Overchuk noted, “We propose the creation of an independent financial infrastructure. This implies mutual settlements in national currencies, the use of national payment systems, which requires an interaction between the relevant structures: central banks, ministries of finance, financial institutions, without this nothing will develop.”
The African countries went through a long drawn out, arduous process of struggle for independence. In North Africa, Egypt had been an independent monarchy since 1922 but it was not until 1954 under Gamal Abdel Nasser that it was possible to end the British occupation of the Suez Canal and, in 1956, to win the independence of neighboring Sudan. France accepted defeat in its brutal colonial war against Algeria in 1962. Morocco and Tunisia had already won their independence in 1956, Niger and Mauretania in 1960. Similar to Egypt, the former Italian colony Libya became an independent kingdom in 1951 but it was not until 1966 that it became an independent republic under the leadership of Muammar al Gaddhafi. By the end of 1961 almost the entire western and central part of Africa had become politically independent from the former colonial powers, France, the United Kingdom and Belgium.
In East Africa, Ethiopia was declared independent in 1947 after being liberated from Italy’s colonial aggression. Somalia became independent in 1960, followed in the coming years by Rwanda, Burundi, Kenya, Uganda, Zambia, Malawi, Tanzania and Madagascar. Portugal maintained its colonial rule over Guinea-Bissau until 1974 and, after many years of armed conflict, in 1975 finally recognized the independence of Angola, Mozambique, and Cape Verde. In southern Africa, Botswana achieved its independence in 1966. But Zimbabwe only achieved independence in 1980 after a fierce, bloody war. Namibia was occupied by the apartheid regime of South Africa until 1990. South Africa itself only held its first democratic elections in 1994, won by Nelson Mandela, to end the brutal apartheid regime.
The reaction of the imperialist powers to the independence of their former colonies has been to seek to consolidate their control of Africa’s natural resources and economies through their domination of global trade, international finance and their control of international institutions such as the United Nations, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. Speaking in Algeria in February 1965, Che Guevara explained: “As long as imperialism exists, by definition, it will exercise its domination over other countries; that domination is today called neocolonialism. Neocolonialism developed first in South America, in an entire continent, and today it is beginning to be noticed with increasing intensity in Africa and Asia. Its way of penetration and development has different characteristics; one is the brutal one we met in Congo. Brute force, without considerations or cover-ups of any kind, is his extreme weapon. There is another more subtle one: penetration into countries that are politically liberated”.
During the second Russia-Africa Summit, the heads of state of the African continent spoke repeatedly to condemn the decades of neocolonialism that have continued the impoverishment of their peoples through unfair and unequal treatment by the United States and the countries of the European Union. Among them were the President of the African Union Azali Assoumani, and the presidents of Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Uganda, Congo, Egypt, Eritrea, Guinea-Bissau, Libya and Mali, among others.
Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni commented, “The independence of most African countries does not mean healthy disengagement with the imperialist economies. Up to now, many of the African economies still face the bottlenecks and distortions of the colonial era. Although some progress has been achieved, a lot remains to be done. That is why you hear that the GDP of Africa is currently $2.7 trillion smaller than the individual economies of countries such as Japan, Germany, etc. Not to mention the US or China.”
The President of the Congo, Denis Sassou Nguesso, commented to President Putin: “It is impossible to industrialise our continent without electrification. You will remember the famous slogan of the great revolutionary of your country – ‘Communism is Soviet power plus the electrification of the whole country.’ Meanwhile, today, 600 million Africans – I will repeat this figure – 600 million Africans live without electricity.”
The President of Mali, Assimi Goïta, said: “Russia has been able to show in difficult moments its status as Mali’s faithful partner, has been loyal, dynamic and has helped us in dealing with difficulties, accompanied us and respected our sovereignty. That is very important in restoring peace, stability and security, which is why we must now, above all, protect our population and defend the territorial integrity of our country. This strategic choice is very important to us, and we must, of course, become completely independent and self-sufficient and strengthen our armed forces. That is why we, in Mali, have a military partnership with the Russian Federation..”
Given these comments by a majority of African leaders, it is no surprise that right now the first Deputy Secretary of State of the United States, Victoria Nuland, is on a visit to South Africa, Ivory Coast and the Democratic Republic of Congo. She is visiting there to communicate her country’s imperial dictates to be shared among the other governments of the region. But the vast majority of African countries have shown that they want to emancipate themselves from the neocolonial yoke, from the racism and arrogance, from the cynicism and hypocrisy, of the United States and the European Union. With their inevitable defeat in Ukraine in sight, it remains to be seen to what extent the United States and the European Union can maintain their accustomed power and privilege in their relations with African countries whose leaders have categorically shown their anti-imperialist position at this second Russia-Africa summit [end]
[mon illustration : des militants nazis affrontent la police à Kiev le 19 janvier 2014 (Sergueï Spnisky / AFP)]
[…] Le mouvement EuroMaidan a démarré avec mille manifestants pacifiques à Kiev, le 21 novembre 2013, protestant contre le refus de Ianoukovytch de signer l’accord avec l’UE. Pourtant, un sondage montrait que 48% des Ukrainien soutenaient la décision du Président de ne pas signer l’accord à ce stade, 35% la désapprouvant.
Le mouvement a alors gonflé, atteignant 500 000 manifestants le 1er décembre – la majorité des manifestants venaient de l’Ouest. On voit dans cette vidéo édifiante des milliers d’étudiants scandant à Lviv des slogans : « Pour l’UE », « Mort aux ennemis » et « Les sales russophones à la potence »…
Les Américains mirent de l’huile sur le feu. Ainsi, le 5 décembre, la secrétaire d’État américaine aux Affaires européennes, Victoria Nuland a appelé le « gouvernement ukrainien à écouter la voix de son peuple. » Pourtant, les sondages (fiables) montraient que les manifestants de Maidan n’ont jamais recueilli 50% de soutien dans la population… Nuland est alors allée soutenir les manifestants. Une conversation volée l’a même montrée en train de choisir les membres du futur gouvernement, avant de lâcher un éloquent « Fuck the EU » (« L’Europe puissance », qu’ils disaient…).
Maïdan comprenait trois branches politiques : le parti de droite dure « Patrie » de Tymochenko (dont le modèle est Margaret Thatcher), le parti libéral Udar du boxeur Vitali Klitschko (soutenu par Merkel) et… Svoboda. Mouvement pas très gauchiste, donc… Oleg Tiagnybok rencontra même le Gotha mondial : Nuland, Ashton, Mc Cain et… Fabius.
Si la majorité des manifestants étaient de fervents démocrates, une minorité active de nationalistes néo-nazis a infiltré le mouvement, devenant son bras armé, les milliers de fascistes affrontant régulièrement les forces de l’ordre.
Le 18 février, les nationalistes ont ouvert le feu sur les policiers : dix de ces derniers sont tués. Dès lors le Gouvernement autorisa le tir à balles réelles en situation de légitime défense. Les événements basculèrent dans le sang le 20 février : on releva plus de cent morts […]