Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu
Media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government have supported censorship, disseminated disinfo, and sought to silence American critics of the war
(Andrew Dunn)
Ukraine’s American-backed fight against Russia is being waged not only in the blood-soaked trenches of the Donbas region but also on what military planners call the cognitive battlefield – to win hearts and minds
Tucker Carlson: No Kremlin stooge, but portrayed as one in Ukraine media (AP)
A sprawling constellation of media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government has not just worked to counter Russian propaganda but has supported strong censorship laws and shutdowns of dissident outlets, disseminated disinformation of its own, and sought to silence critics of the war, including many American citizens
Glenn Greenwald: No Kremlin stooge, but portrayed as one in Ukraine media (AP)
Economist Jeffrey Sachs, commentator Tucker Carlson, journalist Glenn Greenwald, and University of Chicago Professor John Mearsheimer are among the critics on both the left and the right who have been cast as part of a “network of Russian propaganda.”
But the figures targeted by the Ukrainian watchdog groups are hardly Kremlin agents. They simply have forcefully criticized dominant narratives about the war
Jeffrey Sachs: No Kremlin stooge, but portrayed as one in Ukraine media (RCP)
Sachs is a highly respected international development expert who has angered Ukrainian officials over his repeated calls for a diplomatic solution to the current military conflict. Last November, he gave a speech at the United Nations calling for a negotiated peace.
Mearsheimer has written extensively on international relations and is a skeptic of NATO expansion. He predicted that Western efforts to militarize Ukraine would lead to a Russian invasion.
Greenwald is a Pulitzer Prize-winning independent journalist who has criticized not just war coverage but media dynamics that suppress voices that run counter to U.S. narratives.
“What they mean when they demand censorship of ‘pro-Russia propaganda’ is anything that questions the US/EU role in the Ukraine war or who dissents from their narratives,” Greenwald has observed.
There’s no evidence of Kremlin influence over their viewpoints, but their comments alone are enough for a network of U.S.-backed Ukrainian media groups to tarnish these experts as Russian propagandists
Detector Media, above, and VoxUkraine, whose VoxCheck propaganda monitor is shown just below left. They get U.S. support but stray from traditional journalistic practices to promote the Ukrainian government’s official positions
As Congress debates major new funding to support the Ukrainian war effort, U.S. taxpayer dollars are already flowing to outlets such as the New Voice of Ukraine, VoxUkraine, Detector Media, the Institute of Mass Information, the Public Broadcasting Company of Ukraine and many others. Some of this money has come from the $44.1 billion in civilian-needs foreign aid committed to Ukraine. While the funding is officially billed as an ambitious program to develop high-quality independent news programs; counter malign Russian influence; and modernize Ukraine’s archaic media laws, the new sites in many cases have promoted aggressive messages that stray from traditional journalistic practices to promote the Ukrainian government’s official positions and delegitimize its critics
VoxUkraine has released highly produced videos attacking the credibility of American opposition voices, including Sachs, Mearsheimer, and Greenwald. Detector Media, one of the most influential media watchdog groups, similarly produces a flow of social media and posts branding American critics of the war as part of a Russian disinformation operation. The outlets are also devoted to domestic disputes. Detector Media’s broadcasts have lampooned critics of Ukrainian government moves to shut down opposition media outlets.
It’s not only dissident voices targeted by the media groups, which are funded by the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).
Detector Media went after the New York Times in February over a news report about hundreds of Ukrainians in the battle for Avdiivka who were captured or missing. The Ukrainian fact-check site offered little in terms of a rebuttal. Detector Media only cited a spokesperson for the Ukrainian Defense Forces disputing the Times’ story, which it labeled as “disinformation.” The New Voice of Ukraine quoted a Ukrainian official describing the Times story as a “Russian Psyop,” a term for psychological warfare.
Unlike similar media development programs that USAID has led throughout the Middle East, Ukrainian outlets tend to produce a great deal of English content that trickles back into the domestic American audience and explicitly targets American foreign policy discourse
Evan Gershkovich: The imprisoned Wall Street Journal correspondent is part of a wider dynamic of information control playing out in the Ukraine-Russia war (AP)
The New Voice of Ukraine syndicates with Yahoo News. VoxUkraine is a fact-checking partner with Meta, which assists in removing content deemed “Russian disinformation” from Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. Detector Media has similarly led a consortium of nonprofit groups pressuring social media platforms to aggressively remove content critical of Ukraine.
“It makes more sense to have it in English because one of the things that happens is that the narrative that one encounters in the mainstream media in the West is referenced as the official Ukrainian voices,” said Nicolai N. Petro, a professor specializing in Russian and Ukrainian affairs at the University of Rhode Island.
“These then become the known Ukrainian voices, although they’re actually only an echo of the voice that we are projecting into Ukraine,” Petro added.
In the new aid earmarked for the war in Ukraine that Congress is now debating, a small portion of the $60 billion emergency spending package is devoted to continued USAID programs in the country. President Volodymyr Zelensky, in an interview this week with Politico and Bild, argued that legislators skeptical of the aid package were under the influence of Russian propaganda.
“They have their lobbies everywhere: in the United States, in the EU countries, in Britain, in Latin America, in Africa,” Zelenskyy said of Russian influence, without naming names. The pro-Russian pressure groups, the Ukrainian president added, relied on “certain media groups, citizens of the United States.”
Information control is a central dynamic playing out in the Ukraine-Russia war. U.S. media have provided wide coverage of President Vladimir Putin’s efforts to clamp down on critical news outlets, enacting new criminal penalties for those publishing “false information” about the conflict. Many independent outlets in Russia have been forced to close, including the left-leaning radio station Ekho Moskvy. The Russian government has also blocked Russian-language news sites based in the West and arrested at least 22 journalists, including the Wall Street Journal’s Evan Gershkovich
Nina Jankowicz: The polarizing Biden official previously advised the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry on its anti-disinformation work (Department of Homeland Security)
But far less attention has been paid to the Ukraine government’s crackdown on independent and opposition media, a push aided by the U.S.-backed network of anti-disinformation groups. Even as Washington’s efforts to censor information at home are drawing greater scrutiny, its support of Ukraine’s efforts reflects the increasingly global reach of the American government’s propaganda arms.
“There’s an information war going on between Russia and Ukraine, and the United States is not a disinterested party – we’re an active participant,” said George Beebe, a director with the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft. “The U.S. government has been trying to shape perceptions, and it’s very difficult to separate what’s intended for foreign audiences from what seeps into the Anglosphere media, if you want to call it that, including here in the United States.”
American influence in Ukraine’s media environment stretches back to the end of the Cold War, though it has intensified in recent years. Since the outbreak of the war, USAID support has extended to 175 national Ukrainian media entities.
Over the last decade, efforts to crack down on speech have been increasingly justified as an effort to protect social media from disinformation. The U.S. helped set up new think tanks and media watchdogs and brought over communications specialists to guide Ukraine’s approach. Nina Jankowicz, the polarizing official whom President Biden appointed to lead the Department of Homeland Security’s Disinformation Governance Board to police social media content, previously advised the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry on its anti-disinformation work
Vivek Ramaswamy: The ex-GOP presidential hopeful was tarred as part of the Russian disinformation system (AP)
In response to questions about the U.S.-backed anti-disinformation groups in Ukraine targeting Americans, the U.S. State Department provided a statement saying it defines disinformation as “as false or misleading information that is deliberately created or spread with the intent to deceive or mislead.” It added, “We accept there may be other interpretations or definitions and do not censor or coerce independent organizations into adopting our definition.”
While noting that the U.S. “provides funding to credible independent media organizations to strengthen democracies in the countries we work in around the world,” the statement declared, “We do not control the editorial content of these organizations.”
However, disclosures indicate that the U.S. government and its contractors tasked with reforming Ukraine’s institutions have directly set the agenda for Ukrainian outlets. Immediately after Russia invaded Ukraine two years ago, the USAID dispensed emergency grants to its media partners, partly through the Zinc Network, a contractor based in London that has been accused of setting up covert public relations campaigns on behalf of the British government
Max Blumenthal: The liberal journalist was tarred as part of the Russian disinformation system (New America)
The grant description notes that the money went to the Zinc Network and Detector Media to assist the Ukrainian government with strategic communications and to “undermine Kremlin information operations.” Far from independent reporting, the grant instructions asked the recipients to provide “quick, effective PR and media engagement.” In addition to countering Russian disinformation, the money was intended to “maintain public morale” and “bolster international support for solidarity with Ukraine.”
Last September, journalist Jack Poulson reported on a leaked report from the Zinc Network’s Open Information Partnership, which helps coordinate the activities of several anti-Russian disinformation nonprofits around Europe backed by NATO members, including Detector Media.
The lengthy report defines disinformation as not only false or misleading content but also “verifiable information which is unbalanced or skewed, amplifies, or exaggerates certain elements for effect, or uses emotive or inflammatory language to achieve effects which fit within existing Kremlin narratives, aims, or activities.”
In other words, factual information with emotional language that simply overlaps with anything remotely connected to Russian viewpoints is considered disinformation, according to this U.S.-backed consulting firm helping to guide the efforts of Ukrainian think tanks and media.
Many of the broad narratives the report identified as Russian disinformation follow this vague rubric. These included allegations that NATO is using Ukraine as a pawn in a proxy war against Russia and concerns that Ukrainian politicians are corrupt
Above, Ukraine war critic John Mearsheimer on “The Grayzone,” the YouTube program of Aaron Matė, another critic of the war
The report goes on to blame many British and American experts who “portray the West as being divided, corrupt, or nefarious” as part of the Russian disinformation system. The document names liberal journalists Max Blumenthal and Newsweek’s Ellie Cook, as well as Republican figures such as former presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy and Arizona Congressman Andy Biggs, as voices that end up featured in Russian propaganda and disinformation.
The Open Information Partnership report suggests new legislation to counter “malign foreign actors” and for European intelligence agencies to “do more” and provide a “unified approach” against the dangers of disinformation. Zinc Network did not respond to a request for comment.
Ukraine’s government has also worked with U.S. government officials and others to censor its American critics. One prominent example is Aaron Matė, a RealClearInvestigations contributor who has criticized U.S. policy regarding Ukraine in other outlets. Following the Russian invasion, Twitter, under its old ownership, flagged Matė to be censored after the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), the Ukrainian intelligence agency, included him on a list of accounts sent to the FBI that were “suspected by the SBU in spreading fear and disinformation.”
Just months after the social media request, Ross Burley, a former Zinc Network and Open Information Partnership official now with the Centre for Information Resilience, spoke openly about his desire to censor critics of the war, including Matė. Burley, who “designed, implemented, and led several of the UK Government’s counter disinformation programmes,” according to a now-deleted profile, discussed the rise of independent media critical of the Ukrainian government and Western support for a war that has devastated that country. He discussed the conflict at the Opinion Festival in Tallinn, Estonia, in August 2022.
Burley argued that social media platforms needed more “responsibility” regarding what types of content to allow. “Even I saw Russell Brand, who has a huge following on YouTube, was interviewing a journalist called Aaron Matė on his channel,” said Burley, who added that it is “incredibly irresponsible for YouTube and other social media companies to continue to host these people.”
Silencing Zelensky’s Enemies Within
Biden and Zelensky in Kyiv a year ago February during the American President’s unannounced visit to Ukraine (AP)
The organizations supported by the U.S. government have also sought to silence critics inside Ukraine. Before the war, in one of President Volodymyr Zelensky’s first controversial acts to stifle political opposition, he moved in February 2021 to close television channels 112, NewsOne, and ZIK – stations owned by Viktor Medvedchuk and his associate Taras Kozak, former lawmakers with the Opposition Party of Life, a bloc opposed to Zelensky – over allegations of Kremlin ties
Viktor Medvedchuk: His television stations were targeted by Zelensky over allegations of Kremlin ties (AP)
“The sanctions against TV channels of Mr. Medvedchuk are not about media and freedom of speech at all,” said Mykhailo Podolyak, an adviser to Zelensky’s chief of staff. “This is only about effective countermeasures against fakes and foreign propaganda.”
Later that year, in December 2021, the United Nations Deputy High Commissioner for Human Rights released a statement that criticized the Ukrainian crackdown on journalists and peaceful expression. The report cited the closure of opposition television channels and other media.
The USAID-funded Ukrainian media network, however, was quick to defend the Zelensky government. The decision to close the outlets, wrote Detector Media, was “not an attack on freedom of speech” because the channels, the group argued, provided “informational support of Russian aggression against Ukraine.”
In May 2022, the Zelensky government widely expanded its efforts to outlaw the political opposition. Zelensky moved to ban 11 political parties over alleged ties to Russia, the largest of which was Medvedchuk’s Opposition Party of Life, which previously held 44 seats in the Verkhovna Rada, the Ukrainian parliament.
Later that summer, other bills to crack down on media rights that had failed to pass in the past over civil liberty concerns were brought back into consideration. Mykyta Poturayev, a Ukrainian legislator and close ally of Zelensky, re-introduced the On Media Law.
The legislation features provisions to penalize hate speech and disinformation, as well as broad powers to limit certain forms of foreign influence. Among its most contentious provisions is the power granting a council controlled by Zelensky and his allies to ban media outlets without a court order.
Again, the USAID-funded media groups provided pivotal support amid a tightening on journalistic freedom. The push to support the bill was largely led by U.S.-government-backed think tanks and media outlets. As the Ukrainian legislature moved forward, Detector Media reported a new statement from select journalists and nonprofits who supported the controversial legislation. The statement argued that the Zelensky-appointed council overseeing media was an “independent regulator” and urged the adoption of the law as a tool to counteract foreign aggression.
The statement was organized by Ukraine’s Center for Democracy and Rule of Law. In 2022, the group received 76.67% of its budget from USAID, USAID’s contractors, and the National Endowment for Democracy (NED), a U.S. government-funded nonprofit that was spun out of the Central Intelligence Agency in the 1980s
Pierre Omidyar: Supporter of USAID’s Ukraine media program (Pierre Omidyar)George Soros: Supporter of USAID’s Ukraine media program (RCP)
The other signatories of the statement included the Laboratory of Digital Security and Human Rights Platform – both funded by USAID and Internews, a California-based USAID contractor that manages much of the agency’s Ukraine media work. Internews Ukraine, the company’s in-house Ukraine media outlet, also signed the statement supporting the On Media Law.
Internews is a significant pillar of USAID’s $35 million Ukraine media program. Other European governments and private sector donors, led by billionaires Pierre Omidyar via the Omidyar Network and George Soros via the International Renaissance Foundation, have financed the network of media and activists working with the USAID groups.
Disclosures suggest other supplemental funding has been rushed to local Ukrainian media. In 2021, before Russia’s invasion, Detector Media received 35.1% of its nearly $1 million budget from Internews. New data released by the federal government shows that USAID provided a $2.5 million direct grant to Detector Media last year.
In a report titled “Long-Term Investments Pay Dividends in Ukraine,” NED noted that U.S.-backed groups have been pivotal in reshaping the country’s law. It pointed to a coalition of nonprofits led by the Coalition Reanimation Package of Reforms, a USAID-backed group that mobilized civil society to lobby for legal and legislative changes. The group was pivotal in the push for the On Media Law. The group hailed the law’s passage, calling it one of the major achievements of reforms passed during the war.
After the legislation was passed, Detector Media attacked “Pro-Russian Telegram channels” for spreading “fakes and manipulations” about the law. One fact-check published by the group claimed that the law “had to be adopted in the context of Ukraine’s European integration.” The post countered claims that the law introduces authoritarian forms of censorship by pointing to the fact that “media professionals and members of the public were involved in its development.”
NED, the former CIA arm, has publicly touted the effort to pass the On Media Law for its work in reshaping Ukraine’s media landscape. In a report written in collaboration with Detector Media, the group discusses the law with respect to bolstering efforts to “rid the Ukrainian information space of harmful Russian propaganda.” The report noted some journalistic criticism of the proposal, concluded that it was “supported by the majority of media related civil society organizations and international donors for its expansion of democratic accountability in the information space.”
Unmentioned in NED and Detector Media’s claims of widespread media support for the law is its own central role and that of other USAID-backed groups.
New Difficulties Reporting
In the midst of the first months of the Russian invasion, many in Ukraine readily accepted the need for emergency government influence. The Ukrainian government condensed the major television channels into a single “United News” national broadcast that continues today. Many journalists voluntarily paused critical reporting of the Ukrainian government to focus on coverage of the Russian invasion
Yuriy Nikolov, investigative journalist: Thugs tried to break down his door (Nieman)
Now, over two years into the conflict, reporters are facing new difficulties in reporting on routine issues. Journalists taking a critical look at the government are facing intimidation and threats.
The Columbia Journalism Review has chronicled the precarious situation independent journalists face in today’s Ukraine. In January, a pair of thugs went to the home of Yuriy Nikolov, a prominent investigative journalist who has uncovered scandals involving military catering contracts. The men tried to break down Nikolov’s door, and according to his mother, who was home, called him a “provocateur” and a “traitor.”
That same month, an anonymous video released videos from hidden cameras showing journalists with Bihus.Info – a local media outlet that has extensively reported on Ukrainian government corruption – using illegal drugs in private. Denys Bihus, the head of the site, has reported on Ukraine’s intelligence service’s involvement in the surveillance and intimidation of his media outlet.
Anatoly Shariy, a controversial Ukrainian blogger living in exile over repeated death threats, has clashed repeatedly with USAID’s network of media outlets. Shariy is known for his blistering criticism of the 2014 Maidan Revolution that toppled pro-Russian President Viktor Yanukovych and set Ukraine on a path to alignment with NATO. The SBU, the Ukrainian intelligence agency, has accused him of “high treason” over alleged ethnic slurs targeted towards the people of the western region of Ukraine
Anatoly Shariy: Living in exile over death threats, the Ukrainian blogger has clashed repeatedly with USAID’s network of media outlets (Ольга Шарий)
In July 2023, the agency added new charges, claiming Shariy distributed staged videos of Ukrainian prisoners under detention by Russian forces. The SBU has attempted to extradite Shariy, who has moved from the Netherlands to Spain and reportedly to Italy for asylum.
Online reporting in English, though, is dominated by USAID media outlets. A search for Shariy’s name returns half a dozen articles by VoxUkraine, Detector Media, the Institute of Mass Information, and the New Voice of Ukraine. The articles trash Shariy as a pro-Russian propagandist and criminal, guilty of a variety of speech-related crimes.
“In his Telegram posts, Shariy tries to emphasize that Russia is more united and stronger than Ukraine,” Detector Media claimed. “He rejects the severing of any ties between Ukraine and Russia. Even in the face of proven Russian lies and evidence of their crimes, Shariy continues to promote narratives favorable to Russia and disseminate disinformation.”
The Detector Media article provides little substance in terms of any illegal actions beyond Shariy’s viewpoints. But expressing viewpoints that run counter to Ukraine and NATO policies with respect to the war is enough to make an individual an enemy of the state [end]
chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia
Max Blumenthal and Aaron Mate cover the international scandal that unfolded when the Liberal Party of Canada’s Justin Trudeau honored a Ukrainian Nazi veteran of the Waffen-SS, and the dark history it forced to the surface
The FBI aided a Ukrainian intelligence effort to ban Twitter users and collect their data, new leaks show. Twitter declined to censor journalists targeted by Ukraine, including The Grayzone’s Aaron Maté
[my illustration]
The Federal Bureau of Investigation has aided a Ukrainian intelligence effort to censor social media users and obtain their personal information, leaked emails reveal.
In March 2022, an FBI Special Agent sent Twitter a list of accounts on behalf of the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU), Ukraine’s main intelligence agency. The accounts, the FBI wrote, “are suspected by the SBU in spreading fear and disinformation.” In an attached memo, the SBU asked Twitter to remove the accounts and hand over their user data.
The Ukrainian government’s FBI-enabled targets extend to members of the media. The SBU list that the FBI provided to Twitter included my name and Twitter profile. In its response to the FBI, Twitter agreed to review the accounts for “inauthenticity” but raised concerns about the inclusion of me and other “American and Canadian journalists.”
The FBI’s attempt to ban Twitter accounts at the request of Ukrainian intelligence is among the most overt requests for censorship revealed to date in the Twitter Files, a cache of leaked communications from the social media giant.
The FBI’s censorship request was relayed in a March 27th, 2022 email from FBI Special Agent Aleksandr Kobzanets, the Assistant Legal Attaché at the US Embassy in Kyiv, to two Twitter executives. Four FBI colleagues were copied on the exchange.
“Thank you very much for your time to discuss the assistance to Ukraine,” Kobzanets wrote. “I am including a list of accounts I received over a couple of weeks from the Security Service of Ukraine. These accounts are suspected by the SBU in spreading fear and disinformation. For your review and consideration”
The attached document, drafted by Ukraine’s SBU, contained 163 accounts, including mine. (The list is numbered to 175, but some accounts have two corresponding numerical lines).
The listed Twitter profiles, the SBU alleged, have been “used to disseminate disinformation and fake news to inaccurately reflect events in Ukraine, justify war crimes of the Russian authorities on the territory of the Ukrainian state in violation of international law.”
In order “to stop Russian aggression on the information front,” the SBU continued, “we kindly ask you to take urgent measures to block these Twitter accounts and provide us with user data specified during registration.”
The SBU expressed its “gratitude for the existing level of interaction”
In a memo forwarded by the FBI, Ukraine’s SBU asks Twitter to “block” the listed Twitter accounts “and provide us with user data specified during registration.”
If granted, the users on the list would not only have been banned from Twitter but had their phone number, date of birth, and email address disclosed to both the FBI and SBU.
Read the full list of accounts targeted by the FBI and SBU here:
In response, Yoel Roth, Twitter’s then-Head of Trust and Safety, informed Special Agent Kobzanets and his FBI colleagues that Twitter would “review the reported accounts under our Rules.” But he warned that the list included “a few accounts of American and Canadian journalists (e.g. Aaron Mate).” Therefore, Roth said, Twitter’s review would “focus first and foremost on identifying any potential inauthenticity.”
Roth then suggested that he would be open to suspending authentic accounts if it could be proven that they have a hidden tie to a foreign government. Journalists “who cover the conflict with a pro-Russian stance are unlikely to be found in violation of our rules absent other context that might establish some kind of covert/deceptive association between them and a government,” Roth wrote. “Any additional information or context in those areas is of course welcome and appreciated”
Twitter executive Yoel Roth’s response to the FBI’s censorship request flags its inclusion of journalists, “e.g. Aaron Mate.”
In his reply, Kobzanets did not directly acknowledge Roth’s concerns about Ukraine’s FBI-abetted effort to censor journalists. “Understood,” Kobzanets told Roth. “Whatever your review determines and action Twitter deem[s] is appropriate.” He also indicated that the FBI would not meet Roth’s request for any “context” that might establish ties between journalists and a foreign government: “Unlikely there will be any additional information or context.”
Inside Twitter, Roth forwarded the FBI request to two colleagues. “This is the output of our meeting with the FBI last week,” he wrote. “The list of accounts is a mixed bag – there’s some state media mixed in with a bunch of other stuff – but given the context, I think a deep dive here warranted.” (Roth left Twitter in November 2022).
In an email, I asked Special Agent Kobzanets if he had vetted Ukraine’s censorship request list before sending it to Twitter. I also asked Kobzanets if, after being informed by Twitter’s Roth that the FBI was trying to censor journalists on the SBU’s behalf, whether that had prompted any review or revision of his assistance to Ukrainian intelligence. Kobzanets did not respond.
The FBI’s National Press Office also declined to answer questions. Among several queries, I invoked Twitter’s warning that the FBI’s “assistance to Ukraine” entailed censoring journalists, and asked if that has prompted any changes to the bureau’s collaboration with Ukrainian intelligence.
“While we appreciate your inquiry, as a matter of practice we do not confirm, deny, or otherwise comment on specific interactions nor confirm the veracity of correspondence,” an FBI spokesperson wrote.
The FBI officials copied on the Kobzanets’ exchange with Twitter include Elvis Chan, an Assistant Special Agent in Charge (ASAC) of the FBI’s San Francisco field office, where he manages its Cyber Branch. Chan was active in the FBI’s contacts with Twitter when the social media giant’s censorship of reporting on Hunter Biden’s laptop shortly before the November 2020 election. (As I recently reported, he was also involved in FBI’s decision to forego a direct inspection of the DNC servers and instead rely on the Hillary Clinton-funded cyber firm CrowdStrike in the bureau’s probe of alleged Russian hacking in 2016).
Of the 163 accounts named by the SBU, 34 were suspended and 20 no longer exist. The rest remain active.
Those marked for censorship by Ukraine but remain online include Russian politicians Gennady Zyuganov, a longtime member of Russia’s Communist Party and parliamentarian who lost to Boris Yeltsin in Russia’s 1996 president election; Dmitry Rogozin, Russia’s former Deputy Prime Minister; and Sergey Mironov, a Russian politician and parliamentarian. The list also includes Russian journalists Vladimir Solovyov, a television news host; and Margarita Simonyan, editor-in-chief of the Russian state-controlled network RT. Several Russian government agencies and media outlets were also listed.
The Ukrainian nationals targeted by the SBU’s suppression request include Anatoly Shariy, a video blogger and politician who fled Ukraine in 2012 and subsequently received European Union asylum; and Andriy Portnov, a Ukrainian lawyer and politician who served as a senior official under Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych until the latter’s ouster in the February 2014 Maidan coup. (Both Shariy and Portnov’s Twitter accounts remain active).
The disclosure of a collaboration on censorship between the FBI and SBU is the latest documented instance of Ukrainian state-tied attempts to target foreign voices. A Ukrainian website known as Myrotvorets maintains a list of what it calls “enemies of Ukraine.” I was recently added to that list along with The Grayzone’s Anya Parampil, as well as the comedian and YouTube host Jimmy Dore. The Myrotvorets database was co-founded by Anton Gerashchenko, former deputy minister at the Ukraine’s Ministry of Internal Affairs, where he now serves as an advisor.
Last year, the global tech/media conference Web Summit withdrew a speaking invitation to The Grayzone’s Max Blumenthal and I after Olena Zelenska, the wife of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, demanded our cancellation. (Another Grayzone colleague, Kit Klarenberg, was recently detained and interrogated about his journalism by British authorities).
News of the FBI’s work with Ukrainian intelligence to censor Twitter users also follows reporting from journalist Lee Fang that the FBI has pressured Facebook to remove accounts and posts deemed by the SBU to be Russian “disinformation.” According to Fang, a senior Ukrainian official in regular contact with the FBI defined “disinformation” in such broad terms that it could mean viewpoints that “simply contradict the Ukrainian government’s narrative.”
after his takeover of Twitter, Elon Musk disclosed the political censorship that the social networking service was previously enforcing on behalf of the FBI
Scotland Yard counter terrorism command (SO15) is embezzling anti-terrorist laws, has already arrested for political reasons one French editor and one British journalist
chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia
British counter-terror police detained journalist Kit Klarenberg upon his arrival at London’s Luton airport and subjected him to an extended interrogation about his political views and reporting for The Grayzone
As soon as journalist Kit Klarenberg landed in his home country of Britain on May 17, 2023, six anonymous plainclothes counter-terror officers detained him. They quickly escorted him to a back room, where they grilled him for over five hours about his reporting for this outlet. They also inquired about his personal opinion on everything from the current British political leadership to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
At one point, Klarenberg’s interrogators demanded to know whether The Grayzone had a special arrangement with Russia’s Federal Security Bureau (FSB) to publish hacked material.
During Klarenberg’s detention, police seized the journalist’s electronic devices and SD cards, fingerprinted him, took DNA swabs, and photographed him intensively. They threatened to arrest him if he did not comply.
Klarenberg’s interrogation appears to be London’s way of retaliating for the journalist’s blockbuster reports exposing major British and US intelligence intrigues. In the past year alone, Klarenberg revealed how a cabal of Tory national security hardliners violated the Official Secrets Act to exploit Brexit and install Boris Johnson as prime minister. In October 2022, he earned internationalheadlines with his exposé of British plans to bomb the Kerch Bridge connecting Crimea to the Russian Federation. Then came his report on the CIA’s recruitment of two 9/11 hijackers this April, a viral sensation that generated massive social media attention.
Among Klarenberg’s most consequential exposés was his June 2022 report unmasking British journalist Paul Mason as a UK security state collaborator hellbent on destroying The Grayzone and other media outlets, academics, and activists critical of NATO’s role in Ukraine.
Because Klarenberg’s reporting on Mason relied heavily on leaked emails, Mason falsely accused him of “assisting a Russian state-backed hack-and-leak disinformation campaign.” Mason has also reported the leak of his emails to the British police.
Emma Briant, a self-styled disinformation expert who participated in Mason’s campaign to sabotage NATO critics, dispatched lawyers to demand Klarenberg remove all of his articles that mention her from the internet. The lawyer letters also threatened costly super injunctions to prevent further reporting, and challenged the “authenticity” of the emails’ content.
The cease-and-desist letters additionally leveled false and defamatory allegations against Klarenberg, including that he was personally involved in hacking her email and Twitter account
— Kit Klarenberg 🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻 (@KitKlarenberg) June 13, 2022
Did the bogus and obviously malicious complaints by Paul Mason or Emma Briant prompt the UK police to detain and investigate Klarenberg?
Klarenberg’s reports contain neither falsehoods nor anything approaching “disinformation,” which is precisely why intelligence-linked figures like Mason are so frustrated by their existence. Despite Mason and Briant’s allegations, there is not even hard evidence that Russian hackers were the source of the leaks.
While reporting on leaked material, Klarenberg engaged in the same journalistic practice that the West’s most prominent legacy newspapers, from The New York Times to The Washington Post, depend on to break news themselves. In fact, Thomas Rid, a self-styled disinformation expert and professor of Strategic Studies at Johns Hopkins University, has stated that journalists “should not shy away” from covering the leaks first reported by Klarenberg.
It therefore appears that British authorities did not detain Klarenberg for any legal breaches, but because he reported factual stories that exposed the national security state’s own violations of both domestic and international law, as well as the malign plots of its media lackeys
Interrogated under Counter-Terror provisions, grilled about non-existent Russian ties
Journalist Kit Klarenberg arrived in the UK on May 17 from Belgrade, Serbia, where he lives. He was planning to visit friends and family, but first, he would have to pass through an obstacle course British police laid before him.
As soon as his flight landed at Luton Airport, the pilot announced that border police were “just around the corner,” and asked all passengers to prepare their passports. The police were waiting for Klarenberg at the bottom of the stairs leading passengers from the plane to the tarmac. They immediately led him to a back room and informed him of his detention under Schedule Three, Section Four of the 2019 Counter-Terrorism and Border Act.
Six plainclothes officers surrounded Klarenberg and explained he faced arrest if he refused to answer their questions and hand over his personal electronics. They refused to tell him their names and offered call signs instead.
“I’d been expecting something like this since a police interview request arrived last summer,” Klarenberg told The Grayzone, referring to a communique he received from a senior British detective on July 27, 2022. The email requested Klarenberg report to a station to be questioned about allegations by an unnamed complainant of “offences under the computer misuse act”
A 2022 email from British police requesting his presence for an interrogation session about his journalistic work.
Klarenberg was notified in September of 2022 (see below) that the police investigation had been closed, however.
Back in the interrogation room at Luton, Klarenberg was asked which passports he held in his possession. “They seemed surprised that I only had a British passport with me,” he recalled. The police then grilled him about whether he owned foreign property, which countries he had visited, and why. He was compelled to provide his address in Belgrade, disclose how much he paid for rent, and bizarrely, whether his energy costs were included. The officers then demanded to know why Klarenberg lived in Serbia.
From there, police interrogators homed in on Klarenberg’s work with The Grayzone. “They asked which publications I wrote for, and I told them I wrote for many,” he said. “One even remarked they’d never previously heard of ‘MintPress Zone.’ Their overwhelming, if not exclusive, interest was in The Grayzone.”
The officers asked Klarenberg about articles including his report on the CIA’s recruitment of would-be 9/11 hijackers, as well as his thoughts on 9/11 conspiracy theories.
Then came a blizzard of questions relating to The Grayzone: How much was Klarenberg paid by this publication, how often, and into which bank account? Who owned the site? How much contact did he have with Max Blumenthal, the author of this article and editor of The Grayzone? Had he met Blumenthal in person?
The counter-terror officers then rattled off a series of unfounded questions related to Russia: Does The Grayzone have an agreement of any kind with Russia’s Federal Security Bureau (FSB) to publish hacked material? Has Klarenberg knowingly been in contact with any FSB operatives? Is he in touch with current or former personnel of Russian state media? Who owns The Grayzone and is it sponsored by Russia?
(As has been publicly stated many times, The Grayzone is a fully independent outlet founded by me, Max Blumenthal. Unlike many of our adversaries, this outlet does not accept funding or support from any state, including Russia.)
At this point, the officers took Klarenberg’s bank cards out of the room for an extended period. They also seized his camera memory cards and sims, demanding he provide pin codes to open them. “What was done with my bank cards, I do not know,” he remarked. “The same for the SDs – what they got off these old and barely used cards was unclear.”
Next, Klarenberg’s interrogators asked if he had any journalistic materials on hand, requesting that he “warn” them about the contents and where they were located so they did not hoover it up “by accident.”
He wondered if the question was a public relations stunt devised in response to the media outcry this April over the British counter-terrorism police’s detention of Ernest Moret, a French publisher held and questioned about his views on Emmanuel Macron’s widely despised pension reforms. There was also the chance they wanted him to lead them to sensitive content he had or was planning to cover.
Klarenberg’s police interrogators displayed intense interest in whether he belonged to any press organizations, and if he held a press card or any professional qualifications. They then probed his career trajectory, asking how he entered the world of political journalism and about perceived employment “gaps” in Klarenberg’s professional record.
He was repeatedly grilled on his journey from covering financial issues a decade ago to political and national security reporting. “The police professed confusion at the transition,” despite Klarenberg explaining that he studied politics in university. “The officers repeatedly returned to this point, they clearly felt this didn’t make sense,” he recounted. “Were they probing whether I’d been ‘recruited’ at some point, or had been a ‘sleeper agent’ all along?”
Throughout the interview, the counter-terrorism police probed Klarenberg aggressively on his political affiliations and beliefs. Was he involved in any activist causes in Belgrade? What did he think of the Russian government? Did he have an opinion on Russia’s arrest of Evan Gerskovich of the Wall Street Journal? What did he think of Rishi Sunak? One officer complained incessantly about Keir Starmer being “useless,” prompting Klarenberg to wonder if the comments were a dangle aimed at drawing him out.
When Klarenberg noted that he had publicly criticized Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the police demanded to know if “anyone” from the Russian government had contacted him to complain. “Presumably, they wanted to know if my criticisms had pissed off my ‘controllers’,” Klarenberg said. “Which is a completely ridiculous proposition.”
An extended philosophical discussion about journalism and the public interest followed. “Your work might be interesting to the public,” an officer told Klarenberg, “but it’s not in the public interest.” He insisted that a journalist could be furthering the interests of a hostile state actor in reporting on national security issues.
“I tried to explain that if material can be authenticated, then the material is the source. We are not citing claims from a human source that provided the material, we are reporting on provided source material in a factual way,” Klarenberg said.
After five hours, the counter-terror police seemed to have run out of questions. They had, by this point, seized all Klarenberg’s electronic devices, forced him to provide unlock codes for his phone and tablet, taken his SD cards, and combed through thousands of his personal photos. “Pity whoever drew the short straw and had to stare at length at thousands of shots of brutalist architecture across the world I’ve taken over the years,” he remarked.
Authorities also fingerprinted Klarenberg, subjected him to DNA swabs, and repeatedly photographed him. “As long as your prints have never been found on an IED in Afghanistan, we delete this data in six months,” one cop with a Northern Irish accent claimed.
A week after releasing Klarenberg from detention, police returned his tablet with masking tape over its cameras, along with two memory cards. The police kept one old SD card, mostly containing music, on the grounds it may be “relevant to criminal proceedings.”
He remains under investigation by the British state at the time of publication [end]
Scotland Yard counter terrorism command is embezzling schedule 7 of the Terrorism Act 2000 or other legal pretexts, in order to crack down on political opposition to any interest of UK government or its allies. On April 17, 2023, French publisher Ernest Moret was arrested that way in London, due to his involvement in demonstrations in France against a pension reform. That is not counter-terrorism but pure political police, with dishonest means of coercion. So sad that the same sleuths did not manage to prevent the attack on June 3, 2017, between London Bridge and Borough Market
ICC prosecutor Karim Khan meets with Ukrainian President Zelensky on March 3, 2023 (official)
ICC prosecutor general Karim Khan raised millions from NATO states by crafting an arrest warrant for Vladimir Putin while freezing investigations into well-documented US and Israeli war crimes. Along the way, he won powerful friends in Washington, London, Kiev — and Hollywood.
Karim Khan, the chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, stood before a podium on March 3, 2023, and issued an unusual qualifier: “Of course the prosecutor of the ICC does not, whatever affection and regard I may have for my dear friends in Ukraine – has no special affinity to any particular country. We’re not a party to any hostilities.”
“We have an affinity to legality,” Khan insisted in British-accented English. “We have an affinity and commitment to the rule of law.”
Khan made his declaration of legal independence while headlining the “United for Justice” conference, an event personally organized in Lviv, Ukraine, by President Volodymyr Zelensky. There, he pressed the flesh with Ukraine’s president and conferred with US Attorney General Merrick Garland, who had stopped in to advance the Biden administration’s effort to haul Russian President Vladimir Putin before an international war crimes tribunal.
It was Khan’s fourth visit to Ukraine since the Russian military invaded the country in February 2022.
On March 17, 2023, Khan introduced a formal ICC warrant for Putin’s arrest, accusing the Russian president of the “unlawful deportation” of Ukrainian children to a “network of camps” throughout Russia. The warrant arrived days before the 20th anniversary of the NATO invasion of Iraq, a crime directed by US and UK officials whom the ICC has refused to prosecute to this day.
As The Grayzone has reported, the ICC’s warrant was inspired by a State Department-funded report that contained no field reporting, no concrete evidence of war crimes, and no proof that Russia was actually targeting Ukrainian youth with a massive deportation campaign. In fact, the investigators acknowledged finding “no documentation of child mistreatment, including sexual or physical violence, among the camps referenced in this report.” What’s more, the inquiry’s lead author told The Grayzone’s Jeremy Loffredo that “a large amount” of the Russian youth camps his team researched were “primarily cultural education – like, I would say, teddy bear.”
Though Khan pledged his absolute independence in his hunt for Putin, he is closely aligned with the same Western governments that are currently engaged in a proxy battle with Russia on the Ukrainian battlefield. Meanwhile, he has stalled the ICC’s case against Israel, frustrating human rights lawyers who represent the victims of grisly violence in the besieged Gaza Strip. Additionally, Khan formally dropped the international court’s case against the US military for its actions in Afghanistan.
Through his focus on Ukraine, Khan has presided over a massive surge in Western financial support for his office, with much of the money earmarked for his investigation into Russian officials. The ICC’s issuance of Putin’s arrest warrant happened to coincide with a major donor’s conference for the court in London, England.
The ICC prosecutor’s political entanglements do not stop there. Celebrity lawyer Amal Clooney has worked as a special advisor to Khan’s office while simultaneously counseling the Ukrainian government on its initiative to target Russian officials with prosecution, either by the ICC or another international body. Clooney has also served as a special liaison to the British Foreign Secretary.
It is perhaps no surprise, then, that after two decades of unremitting hostile relations with the ICC, official Washington is suddenly warming up to the court, and is endeared by its top prosecutor
Karim Khan (left) with US Attorney General Merrick Garland in Lviv, Ukraine on February 28, 2023
ICC’s Khan inspires “sighs of relief in Jerusalem,” support from the US
US President Joe Biden helped set the tone in Washington with a full-throated endorsement of the ICC prosecutor Khan’s warrant against Putin, declaring it “justified.” On the Republican side of the aisle, the US Senate’s most enthusiastic cheerleader of the Ukraine proxy war, Lindsey Graham, was even more fulsome in his support for the court’s campaign, celebrating the ICC’s prosecutor as a modern-day Nazi hunter.
Washington’s sudden embrace of the ICC represented a sudden and clearly opportunistic break from two decades of antagonism.
Almost as soon as US President George W. Bush entered the White House in 2001, his administration introduced the Servicemembers Protection Act, a measure that authorized a future US military invasion of the Hague in the event the ICC indicted any US personnel for war crimes. When the bill passed the Senate the following year, not one member of the Republican Party opposed it.
The US intensified its campaign against the ICC in 2019, after then-Chief Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda announced an investigation into war crimes committed by Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. While Secretary of State Mike Pompeo personally denounced Bensouda, the Senate introduced a bipartisan resolution calling on him to escalate its attacks on the “politicized” ICC. Graham was among the signatories to the resolution. (The Biden administration also opposes the ICC investigation into Israeli war crimes).
When Bensouda declared her intention to investigate both the US and Taliban for crimes against humanity in Afghanistan the following year, Washington placed the prosecutor under sanctions and revoked her US visa.
Since replacing Bensouda in 2021, Khan has worked to soothe the nerves of the US and its most violence-prone allies. The Jerusalem Post reported in June 2022 that “there have been some sighs of relief in Jerusalem,” as Khan had “not issued a single public statement nor taken any single public action regarding Israel-Palestine” in his first year as prosecutor.
“There has been no significant progress or measures taken, the investigation [into Israeli atrocities] is not a priority for the office of the prosecutor, and no cases have been brought yet,” a member of the legal team representing victims of Israeli violence in the occupied Gaza Strip told The Grayzone. “Every time the issue is raised before Khan, he never takes a position, and there’s never been a statement.”
The lawyer noted the irony of Khan’s obsession with the transfer of civilians from Ukraine to Russia, considering he has ignored the forced deportation of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from the territory now known as “Israel” to occupied territories and refugee camps across the Middle East. “In Palestine civilians have been transferred for decades, it’s the most over documented situation of war crimes in history,” they said. “Palestine should be the final benchmark for the credibility of the court.”
Khan also narrowed the scope of the ICC’s Afghanistan investigation, protecting US forces from prosecution by focusing solely crimes committed by the Taliban. “This decision reinforces the perception that these institutions set up in the West and by the West are just instruments for the West’s political agenda,” Shaharzad Akbar, the former chair of Afghanistan’s Independent Human Rights Commission, complained to The Intercept
“This was clearly a political decision – there’s really no other way it can be interpreted,” Jennifer Gibson, a US lawyer who heads an investigation into US abuses in Afghanistan, said of Khan’s action. “It gave the US and their allies a get out of jail free card.”
With its two most contentious investigations out of the way, a clearly pliant figure in the prosecutor’s office, and Russian troops inside Ukraine, the previously battered ICC suddenly experienced a deluge of Western financial support.
“In the weeks after 24 February [2022, when Russia invaded Ukraine], the [International Criminal] court has been flooded with cash and secondments,” reported JusticeInfo.net.
Much of the money flowed directly to Khan’s office, with special earmarks for efforts targeting Russian officials. As Maria Elena Vignoli of Human Rights Watch told JusticeInfo.net, “In the messaging around the various pledges that were made, states were not always that careful, and they often made the link between their contribution and Ukraine, thus creating this perception of politicization or selectivity in the court’s work.”
Washington, London pave the path for the ICC’s Khan
It was February 28, 2022 when Khan announced his intention to “proceed with opening an investigation into the Situation in Ukraine, as rapidly as possible.” Russia’s military operation inside Ukraine was only four days old at that point.
Days later, on March 2, 2022, the British Embassy in the Hague delivered Khan a referral co-signed by over 40 US and UK diplomats that urged him to investigate Russia for violations of the Rome Statute of the ICC.
That same day, Sen. Graham introduced a resolution in the US Senate calling for “Vladimir Putin and members of the Russian regime to be held accountable for the numerous acts of war, aggression, and human rights abuses that have been conducted under his watch.” Even as hawks like John Bolton warned that support for the ICC’s warrant could validate future legal actions against the US citizens, the resolution passed unanimously.
Just hours after issuing his resolution condemning alleged violations of international law, Graham took to Twitter to call for Putin’s assassination. “Is there a Brutus in Russia? Is there a more successful Colonel Stauffenberg in the Russian military?” the senator pleaded on March 3, 2022. “The only way this ends is for somebody in Russia to take this guy out”
Is there a Brutus in Russia? Is there a more successful Colonel Stauffenberg in the Russian military?
The only way this ends is for somebody in Russia to take this guy out.
You would be doing your country – and the world – a great service.
On April 3, 2022, Biden injected further momentum into the ICC’s campaign against Russia, branding Putin a “war criminal” and demanding he be hauled before “a war crimes trial.”
To further Biden’s objective, and by extension, that of the ICC, the US Department of State announced in May 2022 the establishment of a Conflict Observatory to gather open source evidence of alleged Russian war crimes and disseminate the findings “so that prosecutors can potentially even build criminal cases based on the material that is published.”
With American political winds at his back, Khan embarked on his first officially-curated tour of Ukraine
ICC prosecutor Karim Khan on a government-guided tour of Kharkiv, Ukraine
Four government-guided junkets to Ukraine
Khan made his inaugural visit to Ukraine on March 16, 2022, arriving first in Poland, where he met with Ukrainian migrants at a refugee reception center. He then crossed the Ukrainian border to confer in Lviv with Irina Venediktova, the Ukrainian Prosecutor-General, before holding a virtual meeting with Zelensky.
“We conduct our work with independence, impartiality and integrity. I have underlined that I wish to engage with all parties to the conflict,” Khan insisted
📢 During today's visit to #Ukraine, Prosecutor #KarimAAKhanQC met virtually w/ President @ZelenskyyUa:“I was pleased to hold important exchanges w/ the President while in country; we agreed all efforts are needed to ensure #IHL is respected & to protect the civilian population.” pic.twitter.com/SqAJsdF5oI
His second visit came just weeks later, in April, when Venediktova shepherded him to the town of Bucha, which Russian troops had occupied for weeks before retreating at the start of that month. Ukrainian officials simultaneously led packs of Western journalists to local gravesites, presenting the burial grounds as evidence that Russia had carried out mass-scale executions in the town.
Images of corpses strewn across Bucha prompted Zelensky to accuse the Russian government of “genocide”, while US President Biden demanded that Putin appear before a war crimes tribunal. Biden’s request came despite his own Defense Department concession that it could not “independently and singlehandedly confirm accounts” of execution-style massacres committed by Russian forces in the town.
When Khan made his third visit to Ukraine in July 2022, he went to Kharkiv. Accompanied once again by Ukrainian Prosecutor-General Venediktova, he announced that the ICC planned to establish a field office in Kiev.
By that point, Zelensky’s government had outlawed 13 opposition parties, jailed his main presidential rival, shut down all critical media, banned the Russian patriarchate of the Orthodox Church and was on its way to arresting its top priest. Kiev was also disappearing and torturing political opponents and human rights advocates as part of an assassination campaign targeting Ukrainian officials accused of collaborating with Russia. Neo-Nazi militants had even videotaped themselves executing suspected Russian sympathizers.
Meanwhile, the Ukrainian military was escalating its attacks on civilian targets throughout the independent Republicans of Donetsk and Lugansk, bombingmarkets and in one instance, massacring a bus load of commuters with a Tochka-U missile. Ukrainian soldiers were also recorded executing unarmed Russian prisoners or war and shooting them in the knees.
But as Khan was junketed around Ukraine, he remained studiously disinterested in the documented abuses his official hosts were carrying out right under his nose. He had his eyes firmly fixed on Putin – and on the generous Western donations that propelled his mission
Karim Khan meets with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky during his fourth trip to Ukraine this March
Bring Back Our Girls 2.0
This March, Khan made his fourth trip to Ukraine to, in his words, “deepen our engagement with national authorities.” In Lviv, he headlined a conference called “United for Justice.” Personally hosted by Zelensky, the stated purpose of the event was to “hold Russia’s top leadership accountable for the crime of aggression against Ukraine.”
In promotional material, the United For Justice conference focused on a seemingly new and emotionally potent issue: the supposed deportation of Ukrainian children by Russia, and the urgent need to bring them home.
The theme contained clear echoes of the Kony 2012 campaign launched against Ugandan warlord Joseph Kony, who “kidnapped over 30,000 children to strengthen his army,” according to the now-disgraced online hucksters that initiated it. It also recalled the humanitarian interventionist “Bring Back Our Girls” hashtag campaign launched by former First Lady Michelle Obama and other celebrities to highlight the abduction of several hundred schoolgirls by the Islamist militia Boko Haram in northern Nigeria.
At United for Justice, it seemed NATO officials had landed on a theme guaranteed to pique the outrage of suggestible Western liberals
Above: From the United For Justice promotional trailer. Below: Hollywood actors at the 2016 Oscars ceremony amplify the Obama administration’s Bring Back Our Girls campaign.
Throughout the United for Justice conference, participants repeatedly leveled the allegation of mass youth deportations against Russia. “Small children are being kidnapped, brainwashed, and forced to become Russian citizens,” Dutch Foreign Minister Woepke Hoekstra claimed from the podium, denouncing “the systemic abduction of Ukrainian children.”
Merrick Garland, the US Attorney General, said after his visit to Lviv that he was “trying to find the people” to identify and “build evidence against” in Russia’s alleged “effort to forcibly deport children.”
During his own address, Khan linked a visit he made to an orphanage inside Ukraine to “allegations that we received that children have been deported outside Ukraine, into the territory of the Russian Federation.” He did not indicate that any children were taken from the orphanage he toured, however.
The ICC website currently features a photograph of Khan posing beside empty cribs in the Ukrainian orphanage he referenced in his speech – an apparent public relations ploy designed to suggest that Putin’s minions had snatched the young children from their beds. Though this orphanage was far from the front line, Khan sported a kevlar protective helmet for added effect
Yet just months before Khan posed as the fatherly protector of Ukrainian children from the Kremlin’s predatory clutches, a child abuse scandal hit close to his own home.
In May 2022, Khan’s brother, Imran Ahmad Khan, resigned from his seat in the British House of Commons after he was convicted of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old boy. Ahmad Khan served 18 months in prison after a judge found him guilty of climbing into the boy’s bunk bed and groping his groin while attempting to ply him with gin and pornography. Following the conviction, a second man accused Ahmad Khan of abusing him as a minor.
While there is no indication Karim Khan provided any legal assistance to his convict brother, The Guardian noted that Ahmad Khan remains “close to his family, particularly his brothers Karim and Khaled, both lawyers, the former a prosecutor at the international criminal court in The Hague.”
Khan relies on State Department-sponsored research for “home run pitch”
During public speeches about Ukraine, Karim Khan often emphasizes his trips to battlegrounds like Bucha and Kharkiv, where the Kiev government accused Russia of committing grisly war crimes. However, when he introduced the ICC’s arrest warrant for Putin, his indictment did not mention any alleged Russian atrocities in either location. Instead, it focused entirely on the supposed deportation of Ukrainian children.
The ICC prosecutor’s warrant was clearly inspired by a Yale University’s Humanitarian Research Lab (HRL) report that was funded and supported by the State Department’s Bureau of Conflict and Stabilization Operations – an entity the Biden administration established in May 2022 to advance the prosecution of Russian officials
The ICC accuses Russia's leadership of running a network of "re-education camps" for captive Ukrainian youth.@loffredojeremy did what the ICC refused to do and visited one such camp outside Moscow.
That State Department-sponsored paper, as The Grayzone revealed, contained long passages contradicting the ICC’s prosecutor’s claims, as well as those its author made in media appearances. In a conversation with journalist Jeremy Loffredo, Yale HRL director Nathaniel Raymond stated that “a large amount” of the Russian youth camps his team researched were “primarily cultural education – like, I would say, teddy bear.”
When asked why his research team did not attempt to visit any programs inside Russia, Raymond said, “We’re persona non grata. We’re considered extensions of US intelligence by the Russians.”
At the same time, the Yale HRL director acknowledged his report was driven by State Department objectives, conducted under “a lot of pressure” from the US National Intelligence Council. He also conceded his team relied on the Pentagon’s US Indo-Pacific Command to “expand our satellite access in the Pacific Command to get the Siberian and eastern camps.”
When asked why Khan did not seek arrest warrants over allegations of Russian war crimes in the Ukrainian town of Bucha, which dominated Western media coverage for days, Raymond recalled a phone conversation he held with several foreign correspondents from the New York Times in March 2023:
“I was on the phone with the New York Times on Friday – the folks who did the big Bucha investigation, and they were like, basically, ‘Hey, we want to win a Pulitzer Prize on Bucha. We think it’s weird that Khan charged [the transfer of youth] and didn’t charge Bucha.’ And I said, ‘It would have been the worst thing imaginable.’”
Raymond explained the prosecutor’s logic: “If Khan had charged Bucha, it would have been catastrophic, because he would have been telegraphing weakness to the Russians. Because Bucha is a massacre. But it doesn’t mean that it is Rome Statute-level in terms of intentional systematic and command-and-control orders. To do that, you need the forensics… ballistics, you need the communications. And there’s no evidence the ICC has that.”
So, according to the Yale HRL director, Khan “started with a home run pitch, and basically said, we’re charging Putin on his own statements in a prima facie evidence-proof [case] on a conservative set of indictments. The transfer and deportation was lowball, he didn’t charge first degree murder.”
“For the New York Times,” Raymond continued, “they’re not going to be happy until Bucha gets charged with all the glitz of an ICC indictment. But [Khan would] be basically saying to Putin: ‘go throw a lieutenant colonel from the paratroopers out the window and you’re cool.’”
Besides providing Khan with the easiest route to an arrest warrant for Putin, the indictment also happened to pack the biggest propaganda punch, enabling the prosecutor to cast himself as the savior of Ukraine’s children.
To that end, he has received critical PR assistance from Amal Clooney, the international lawyer who gained fame as the wife of a Hollywood humanitarian interventionist who is one of the US Democratic Party’s most prolific fundraisers
The ICC’s Karim Khan confers with Amal Clooney in April 2022 after appearing at the UN to drum up support for prosecuting Russian officials
The Clooney connection: Khan collaborates with Hollywood humanitarian interventionists
In September 2021, weeks after assuming the role of ICC prosecutor, Khan appointed Amal Clooney as a special advisor to his investigation into atrocities in the Darfur region of Sudan. When Russian forces entered Ukraine five months later, Clooney immediately shifted her focus, accepting a Ukrainian government invitation to join their “legal task force on accountability.”
Her collaborative relationship with Khan, which spanned at least a decade, has raised further questions about the ICC cheif’s pledge of “independence, impartiality and integrity.”
The Lebanese-born Amal Clooney first emerged as a global celebrity through her marriage to Hollywood heartthrob George Clooney, himself a prominent humanitarian interventionist who led the campaign to target Sudan’s government and its former president, Omar Bashir, with economic sanctions and genocide charges over its actions in Darfur. The US Israel lobby and then-US president George W. Bush heavily supported the crusade against Khartoum, with the latter threatening to send US troops to the oil-rich region to confront Bashir. For his part, Clooney invoked the memory of Auschwitz to advocate for UN military intervention in the region. Though the subsequent ICC warrant for Bashir’s arrest ultimately proved futile, Clooney’s campaign established his bonafides within the international human rights industry.
In 2016, George Clooney turned his focus to domestic politics, raising what he described as “an obscene amount of money” for the presidential campaign of former US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. Entry costs ran up to $353,400 per couple at the pro-Hillary fundraisers hosted by George and Amal Clooney
George and Amal Clooney (right) at a 2016 fundraiser they hosted for Hillary Clinton
That same year, George and Amal leveraged their fame to establish the Clooney Foundation for Justice. Like the foundations established by Bill Clinton and Barack Obama after their presidencies, the Clooneys’ initiative relied on funding from liberal billionaires including Bill Gates and George Soros and forged partnerships with Microsoft and the UN. The Clooney Foundation for Justice also lists the US and UK government-sponsored intelligence proxy Bellingcat as an official partner.
The agenda of the Clooneys’ human rights outfit tracks closely with Washington’s foreign policy objectives. The group pushes human rights campaigns in countries where the US seeks regime change, while overlooking well-documented atrocities committed by the US and its allies, including Israel. In Venezuela, for example, which the US has targeted with sanctions and violent military coups in pursuit of regime change, the Clooney Foundation says it is assisting an ICC investigation into President Nicholas Maduro.
While overseeing her foundation, Amal Clooney won several British government appointments, including a two years stint as UK Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt’s Special Envoy for Media Freedom, and a role as a formal international legal advisor to the UK Attorney General.
Though Clooney once served on the legal team of jailed Wikileaks publisher Julian Assange, she said nothing when Hunt denounced her former client, defended his arrest, and endorsed the journalist’s extradition to the US
Amal Clooney (left) and UK Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt, who appointed her as his Special Envoy on Media Freedom in 2019
In April 2022, the Clooney Foundation announced it would dispatch a team to Kiev to assist the Ukrainian government’s ICC investigation. That month, Amal Clooney appeared on a UN Human Rights Council panel alongside Khan, where she introduced the public to the allegations that Russia’s government was engaged in the mass kidnapping of Ukrainian children for the first time.
“Could it be that thousands of children are being forcibly deported to Russia? Could it be that teenage girls are being raped in the street in front of their family and their neighbors? …Unfortunately, the answer is yes,” Clooney proclaimed, providing no evidence to back her claim
Two months later, Khan and Amal Clooney reunited for a meeting with Ukraine’s General Prosecutor, Irina Venediktova, at the European Union’s Eurojust side-event on prosecuting Russian officials
Prosecutor General Iryna Venediktova met with ICC Prosecutor Karim Khan and Amal Clooney, a British lawyer who is part of the Legal Task Force. This working group supports #Ukraine in providing justice for victims of international crimes committed by Russia.⤵ pic.twitter.com/T7pJMPWTFy
Next, in September, Khan participated in another Eurojust “cooperation for accountability in Ukraine” side-event co-sponsored by the governments of Ukraine, Germany, Denmark and Netherlands. The ICC prosecutor moderated the panel alongside Amal Clooney and the Ukraine’s new prosecutor, Dmitri Kostrin. (President Zelensky dismissed Venediktova in July over “concerns of treason”).
Khan’s relationship with Amal Clooney began long before either gained international notoriety. Back in 2010, when she was still Amal Alamuddin, the lawyer contributed to a volume of essays which Khan co-edited. Khan has also blurbed a 2022 book Clooney co-authored with British lawyer Philippa Webb, calling it a “a tour de force.” (Like Clooney, Webb is a member of the Kiev-supported “legal task force on accountability for crimes committed in Ukraine”).
The website of the Clooney Foundation for Justice features Khan showering even more praise on Clooney, hailing her as a “a giant [who has] been willing to speak up even though many would rather [she] quietened down…[her] refusal to be muzzled must inspire us not to be muzzled [and her] refusal to lose hope must inspire us to march forward.”
The ICC prosecutor’s adoration for Clooney apparently inspired his decision to keep her as a special advisor to his office, even as she worked for the British and Ukrainian governments – both belligerents in a war with Russia.
The Grayzone queried the ICC prosecutor’s press officer about Khan’s close collaboration with Clooney, inquiring whether her work on behalf of the Ukrainian and British governments compromised Khan’s stated pledge to “independence, impartiality and integrity.” It received no reply
The ICC’s Khan and UK Justice Secretary Dominic Raab in London, March 20, 2023
ICC undercuts negotiations with indictment timed for London donor conference
This March 20, exactly one week after issuing an arrest warrant for Putin, Khan appeared in London at an event sponsored by the British and Dutch governments to appeal to the Western states sponsoring the Ukraine proxy war for more money. There, he was seen yukking it up with British Justice Minister Dominic Raab and his counterparts from several NATO states and Ukraine.
The Guardian linked the timing of the Putin arrest warrant to the donor conference, noting, “Khan made his dramatic move against the Russian president last week ahead of a conference in London co-hosted by the UK and the Dutch government aimed at raising cash to fund the ICC’s war crimes investigatory work inside Ukraine.”
With justice ministers 40 UK and UK allies on hand, the confab raised $5 million for the ICC’s mission to prosecute Russian officials.
The donor conference just happened to take place three days after the 20th anniversary of the US and UK-led invasion of Iraq, an event that is estimated to have left over 1 million Iraqis dead. In 2020, the ICC dropped its investigation into British atrocities in Iraq.
Meanwhile, it has been over three months since Khan pledged to visit the Occupied Palestinian Territories to further the ICC’s dormant investigation into Israeli abuses. “Nobody knows if Khan has any plans to go to Palestine,” a lawyer representing Palestinian victims of Israeli violence lamented to The Grayzone. “It’s clear that it won’t be a priority.”
It is also clear that the ICC’s arrest warrant for Putin has planted another obstacle in the way of a negotiated end to the conflict in Ukraine. As a top Zelensky aide, Mykhailo Podalyak, stated on Twitter immediately after the court’s indictment of Putin, “There can be no negotiations with the current Russian elite” [end]
as a prosecutor, Karim Khan is either unfit or corrupt. The ICC arrest warrant against Vladimir Putin is a pure judicial scam. The crime is not ascertained and according to basic good practice, the proceeding is abusive
October 14, 2020 [no surprise then that the US and its British stooges are supporting the Ukrainian Nazis since the end of WW2]
(Nick Roney)
The intellectuals cast a veil over the dictatorial character of bourgeois democracy not least by presenting democracy as the absolute opposite of fascism, not as just another natural phase of it where the bourgeois dictatorship is revealed in a more open form
– Bertolt Brecht
Time and again we hear that liberalism is the last bulwark against fascism. It represents a defense of the rule of law and democracy in the face of aberrant, malevolent demagogues intent on destroying a perfectly good system for their own gain. This apparent opposition has been deeply engrained in contemporary so-called Western liberal democracies through their shared origin myth. As every school child in the U.S. learns, for instance, liberalism defeated fascism in World War II, beating back the Nazi beast in order to establish a new international order that—for all of its potential faults and misdeeds—was built upon key democratic principles that are antithetical to fascism.
This framing of the relationship between liberalism and fascism not only presents them as complete opposites, but it also defines the very essence of the fight against fascism as the struggle for liberalism. In so doing, it forges an ideological false antagonism. For what fascism and liberalism share is their undying devotion to the capitalist world order. Although one prefers the velvet glove of hegemonic and consensual rule, and the other relies more readily on the iron fist of repressive violence, they are both intent on maintaining and developing capitalist social relations, and they have worked together throughout modern history in order to do so. What this apparent conflict masks—and this is its true ideological power—is that the real, fundamental dividing line is not between two different modes of capitalist governance, but between capitalists and anti-capitalists. The long psychological warfare campaign waged under the deceptive banner of ‘totalitarianism’ has done much to further dissimulate this line of demarcation by disingenuously presenting communism as a form of fascism. As Domenico Losurdo and others have explained with great historical precision and detail, this is pure ideological pap.
Given the ways in which the current public debate on fascism tends to be framed in relationship to purported liberal resistance, there could scarcely be a timelier task than that of scrupulously re-examining the historical record of actually existing liberalism and fascism. As we shall see even in this brief overview, far from being enemies, they have been—sometimes subtle, sometimes forthright—partners in capitalist crime. For the sake of argument and concision, I will here focus primarily on a conjunctural account of the non-controversial cases of Italy and Germany. However, it is worth stating at the outset that the Nazi racial police state and colonial rampage—which far surpassed Italy’s capabilities—were modeled on the United States.
Liberal Collaboration in the Rise of European Fascism
It is of the utmost importance that Western European fascism emerged within parliamentary democracies rather than conquering them from the outside. The fascists rose to power in Italy at a moment of severe political and economic crisis on the heels of WWI, and then later the Great Depression. This was also a time when the world had just witnessed the first successful anti-capitalist revolution in the U.S.S.R. Mussolini, who had cut his teeth working for MI5 to break up the Italian peace movement during WWI, was later backed by big industrial capitalists and bankers for his anti-worker, pro-capitalist political orientation. His tactic was to work within the parliamentary system, by mobilizing powerful financial supporters to bankroll his expansive propaganda campaign while his black shirts rode roughshod over picket lines and working-class organizations. In October of 1922, magnates in the Confederation of Industry and major bank leaders provided him with the millions necessary for the March on Rome as a spectacular show of force. However, he did not seize power. Instead, as Daniel Guérin explained in his masterful study Fascism and Big Business, Mussolini was summoned by the king on October 29th and was, according to parliamentary norms, entrusted with forming a cabinet. The capitalist state turned itself over without a fight, but Mussolini was intent on forming an absolute majority in parliament with the help of the liberals. They supported his new electoral law in July 1923 and then made a joint slate with the fascists for the election on April 6, 1924. The fascists, who had only had 35 seats in parliament, gained 286 seats with the help of the liberals.
The Nazis rose to power in much the same way, by working within the parliamentary system and courting the favor of big industrial magnates and bankers. The latter provided the financial support necessary to grow the Nazi party and eventually secure the electoral victory of September 1930. Hitler would later reminisce, in a speech on October 19, 1935, on what it meant to have the material resources necessary to support 1,000 Nazi orators with their own cars, who could hold some 100,000 public meetings in the course of a year. In the December 1932 election, the Social Democrat leaders, who were far to the left of contemporary liberals but shared their reformist agenda, refused to form an eleventh-hour coalition with the communists against Nazism. “As in many other countries past and present, so in Germany,” wrote Michael Parenti, “the Social Democrats would sooner ally themselves with the reactionary Right than make common cause with the Reds.” Prior to the election, the Communist Party candidate Ernst Thaelmann had argued that a vote for the conservative Field Marshal von Hindenburg amounted to a vote for Hitler and for war. Only weeks after Hindenburg’s election, he invited Hitler to become chancellor.
Fascism in both cases came to power through bourgeois parliamentary democracy, in which big capital bankrolled the candidates who would do its bidding while also creating a populist spectacle—a false revolution—that marshaled or suggested mass appeal. Its conquest of power took place within this legal and constitutional framework, which secured its apparent legitimacy on the home front, as well as within the international community of bourgeois democracies. Leon Trotsky understood this perfectly and diagnosed what was going on at the time with remarkable insight:
The results are at hand: bourgeois democracy transforms itself legally, pacifically, into a fascist dictatorship. The secret is simple enough: bourgeois democracy and fascist dictatorship are the instruments of one and the same class, the exploiters. It is absolutely impossible to prevent the replacement of one instrument by the other by appealing to the Constitution, the Supreme Court at Leipzig, new elections, etc. What is necessary is to mobilize the revolutionary forces of the proletariat. Constitutional fetishism brings the best aid to fascism.
Once its power was secure, however, fascism revealed its authoritarian face, transforming itself into what Trotsky referred to as a military-bureaucratic dictatorship of the Bonapartist type. It unflinchingly set about—at a rather different pace in Italy than in Germany—completing the task it had been hired to accomplish by crushing organized labor, eradicating opposition parties, destroying independent publications, putting a halt to elections, scapegoating and eliminating racialized underclasses, privatizing public assets, launching projects of colonial expansion and investing heavily in a war economy beneficial to its industrial supporters. In establishing the direct dictatorship of big capital, it even destroyed some of the more plebeian and populist elements in its own ranks, while crushing many confused liberals under the juggernaut of repressive class warfare.
It was not only within Italy and Germany that bourgeois democracy allowed for the rise of fascism. This was also true internationally. Capitalist states refused to form an antifascist coalition with the U.S.S.R., a country that fourteen of them had invaded and occupied from 1918 to 1920 in a failed attempt to destroy the world’s first workers’ republic. During the Spanish Civil War, which historians like Eric Hobsbawm have characterized as a miniature version of the great mid-century war between fascism and communism, Western liberal democracies did not officially support the left-leaning government that had been elected. Instead, they stood idly by while the Axis powers provided massive support to General Francisco Franco as he oversaw a military coup d’état. It is highly revealing that Franco, a self-declared fascist who is often sidelined in discussions of European fascism, understood with remarkable clarity why the epiphenomenal characteristics of fascism would differ considerably based on the precise conjuncture: “Fascism, since that is the word that is used, fascism presents, wherever it manifests itself, characteristics which are varied to the extent that countries and national temperaments vary.” It was the U.S.S.R. that came to the aid of the Republicans battling fascism in Spain, sending both soldiers and materials. Franco would later return the favor, so to speak, by deploying a volunteer military force to fight godless communism alongside the Nazis. Franco would also, of course, become one of the great postwar allies of the United States in its fight against the Red Menace.
In 1934, the United Kingdom, France and Italy signed the Munich Agreement, in which they agreed to allow Hitler to invade and colonize the Sudetenland in Czechoslovakia. “The sheer reluctance of Western governments to enter into effective negotiations with the Red state,” wrote Eric Hobsbawm, “even in 1938-39 when the urgency of an anti-Hitler alliance was no longer denied by anyone, is only too patent. Indeed, it was the fear of being left to confront Hitler alone which eventually drove Stalin, since 1934 the unswerving champion of an alliance with the West against him, into the Stalin-Ribbentrop Pact of August 1939, by which he hoped to keep the U.S.S.R. out of the war.” This non-aggression pact was then disingenuously presented in the Western media as an undeniable indication that the Nazis and communists were somehow allies.
International Capitalism and Fascism
It was not only large industrialists and bankers, as well as landowners, within Italy and Germany that supported and profited from the fascist rise to power. This was equally true of many of the major corporations and banks whose headquarters were in Western bourgeois democracies. Henry Ford was perhaps the most notorious example since in 1938 he was awarded the Grand Cross of the Supreme Order of the German Eagle, which was the highest honor that could be bestowed upon any non-German (Mussolini had received one earlier the same year). Ford had not only funneled ample funding into the Nazi Party, he had provided it with much of its anti-Semitic and anti-Bolshevik ideology. Ford’s conviction that “Communism was a completely Jewish creation,” to quote James and Suzanne Pool, was shared by Hitler, and some have suggested that the latter was so close ideologically to Ford that certain passages from Mein Kampf were directly copied from Ford’s anti-Semitic publication The International Jew.
Ford was only one of the American companies invested in Germany, and many other U.S. banks, firms and investors profited handsomely from Aryanizations (the expulsion of Jews from business life and the forced transfer of their property into ‘Aryan’ hands), as well as from the German rearmament program. According to Christopher Simpson’s masterful study, “a half-dozen key U.S. companies—International Harvester, Ford, General Motors, Standard Oil of New Jersey, and du Pont—had become deeply involved in German weapons production.” In fact, American investment in Germany sharply increased after Hitler came to power. “Commerce Department reports show,” writes Simpson, “that U.S. investment in Germany increased some 48.5 percent between 1929 and 1940, while declining sharply everywhere else in continental Europe.” The German subsidiaries of U.S. companies like Ford and General Motors, as well as several oil companies, made wide use of forced labor in concentration camps. Buchenwald, for instance, provided concentration camp labor for GM’s enormous Russelsheim plant, as well as for the Ford truck plant located in Cologne, and Ford’s German managers made extensive use of Russian POW’s for war production work (a war crime according to the Geneva Conventions).
John Foster Dulles and Allen Dulles, who would later respectively become the Secretary of State and the head of the CIA, ran Sullivan & Cromwell, which some consider to have been the largest Wall Street law firm at the time. They played a very important role in overseeing, advising and managing global investment in Germany, which had become one of the most important international markets—particularly for American investors—during the second half of the 1920s. Sullivan & Cromwell worked with nearly all of the major U.S. banks, and they oversaw investments in Germany in excess of a billion dollars. They also worked with dozens of companies and governments all over the world, but John Foster Dulles, according to Simpson, “clearly emphasized projects for Germany, for the military junta in Poland, and for Mussolini’s fascist state in Italy.” In the postwar era, Allen Dulles worked tirelessly to protect his business partners, and he was remarkably successful in securing their assets and helping them avoid prosecution.
Whereas most liberal accounts of fascism focus on its political theater and epiphenomenal eccentricities, thereby avoiding a systemic and radical analysis, it is essential to recognize that if liberalism allowed for the growth of European fascism, it is capitalism that drove this growth.
Who Defeated Fascism?
It is not surprising that the bourgeois democracies of the West were extremely slow to open the Western front, allowing their erstwhile enemy, the U.S.S.R., to be bled by the pro-capitalist Nazi war machine (which received ample funding from White Russians). In fact, the day after Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union, Harry Truman flatly declared: “If we see that Germany is winning, we ought to help Russia, and if Russia is winning, we ought to help Germany, and that way let them kill as many as possible, although I don’t want to see Hitler victorious in any circumstances.” After the U.S. entered the war, powerful officials like Allen Dulles worked behind the scenes to try and broker a peace deal with Germany that would allow the Nazis to focus all of their attention on eradicating the U.S.S.R.
The widespread idea, at least within the U.S., that fascism was ultimately defeated by liberalism in WWII, due primarily to the U.S. intervention in the war, is a baseless canard. As Peter Kuznick, Max Blumenthal and Ben Norton reminded listeners in a recent discussion, 80% of the Nazis who died in the war were killed on the Eastern Front with the U.S.S.R., where Germany had deployed 200 divisions (versus only 10 in the West). 27 million Soviets gave their lives fighting fascism, whereas 400,000 American soldiers died in the war (which amounts to approximately 1.5% of the Soviet death toll). It was, above all, the Red Army that defeated fascism in WWII, and it is communism—not liberalism—that constitutes the last bulwark against fascism. The historical lesson should be clear: one cannot be truly antifascist without being anti-capitalist.
The Ideology of False Antagonisms
The ideological construction of false antagonisms, in the case of liberalism and fascism, serves multiple purposes:
+ It establishes the primary front of struggle as one between rival positions within the capitalist camp.
+ It channels people’s energy into fighting over the best methods for managing capitalist rule rather than abolishing it.
+ It eradicates the true lines of demarcation of global class struggle.
+ It attempts to simply take the communist option off the table (by removing it entirely from the field of struggle, or disingenuously presenting it as a form of ‘totalitarianism’).
Not unlike sporting events, which are very important ideological rituals in the contemporary world, the logic of false antagonisms amps up and overinflates all of the idiosyncratic differences and personal rivalries between two opposing teams to such an extent that the frenzied fans come to forget that they are ultimately playing the same game.
In the reactionary political culture of the U.S., which has attempted to redefine the Left as liberal, it is of the utmost importance to recognize that the primary opposition that has structured, and continues to organize, the modern world is the one between capitalism—which is imposed and maintained through liberal ideology and institutions, as well as fascist repression, depending on the time, place and population in question—and socialism. By replacing this opposition by the one between liberalism and fascism, the ideology of false antagonisms aims at making the fight of the century into a capitalist spectacle rather than a communist revolution [end]
interactions between Ukrainian Nazi organizations and Western supremacist militants, chronicle
Nazi militants confront police in Kiev on January 19, 2014 (Serguey Spnisky / AFP). They are the core of the riots on Maidan square, which will escalate to a bloodbath and enable the West-backed right-wing coup in Ukraine on February 21, 2014. The Russophobia of the new authorities will trigger the uprising of Russian-speaking citizens and a war in Donbass
In a desperate attempt to protract a hegemony which is mechanically declining, the US is bringing its allies in its cold war against Russia and China. Hot proxy wars are common episodes of that struggle and history has already shown that the local auxiliaries of the West are usually the scum of the earth. That is an empirical rule. But everything is earned, nothing is lost. For geographical reasons, Europe is often the field of collateral damage, like the jihadist operation in Paris on November 13, 2015, which was the result of the Atlanticist support to the so-called Syrian revolution, a radical Sunni uprising against the secular government in Syria.
The last episode is the Western support to Ukraine, in a conflict that a little good will would have prevented since 2014. A country where a Nazi deep State is ruling over the political issue of Russian-speaking Donbass, is controlling the State security agency (SBU), the army and a nebula of Nazi paramilitary formations, that most Western politicians and media are attempting to whitewash since the beginning on February 24, 2022, of a new proxy war against Russia.
I am reading the propaganda channels of the Ukrainian Nazi organizations. As legacy, they are claiming to be right-wing, but the contemporary political scene is confusing them. Early 2024, they are deploring the Republican brake on US military support to Ukraine and for opposite reasons, are praising the Democrats. In that political maelstrom, their compass is the most radical and intolerant racism towards non-European peoples, particularly those from the South, whom they are calling browns or niggers. In their mind, the Russians remain Bolsheviks, Asians and the friends of the niggers. The letter Z was in 2022 the mark of enemy vehicles and the Russians are also referred as ziggers, a neologism. They are reminding sometimes that during the US civil war, the slaveholders were Democrats.
When international volunteers in the Ukrainian ranks are often Western Nazi militants, when the weapons that the West is sending there are spreading on black market, I see here the conditions of a new cruel backlash.
February 21, 2014
The Misanthropic Division is an international Nazi organization, based in Ukraine, which has already been formed in 2013, when its members are involved in the West-backed right-wing coup on Maidan square, in Kiev
Here are some of the patches that the organization will sell early 2024, across the Western societies
Some of its foreign militants will join the Atlanticist forces, after the beginning on February 24, 2022, of the Russian special military operation in Donbass and Ukraine.
December 14, 2014
Ten months after the right-wing coup on Maidan square, Kiev hosts its first edition of Asgardsrei [ride of Asgard in Norwegian], an international festival of Nazi black metal (NSBM) music
Asgardsrei 2017 (Freddy Hagen)
The organizer is Alexey Levkin, a Nazi militant and racist murderer who has fled Russia. In August 2022, he will become a prominent member of the Russian Volunteer Corps (Russkiy dobrovol’cheskiy korpus, RDK), a bunch of Nazi defectors, who will have settled in Ukraine for years, will usually work for the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR). Their leader will be Denis Kapustin, alias Denis Nikitin, alias White Rex, who will have lived in Germany between 2001 and 2017.
May 14, 2015
(Eurosport)
During UEFA Europa League semi-final rematch in Kiev, against Naples, Dniproultras, with Nazi Azov regiment flag, are aside French fellows, members of KOB (Kop of Boulogne), usual supporters of Paris Saint Germain (PSG) club
From left to right : 2. SS-Panzerdivision Das Reich (1939-1945), 4. SS-Polizei-Panzergrenadier-Division (1939-1945), 34. SS-Freiwilligen Grenadier-Division Landstorm Nederland (1943-1945) and Azov (2014- ?)
The Wolsfangel [wolf hook] dates back to XV century, in Germany, not Poland nor Ukraine. Everybody, except specialists, would have forgotten it. But the Nazis have included it in their runic symbols system between the 1930s and 1945. Among the Ukrainian nationalists who started raising their racism as an ideology, after the dissolution of Soviet Union, the Social National Party (SNPU) was created in western Ukraine and chose again the Wolfsangel as its emblem. Some Nazi rioters bore it on Maidan square. The fascist militants became militias, have been later legalized as national battalions of volunteers, against the uprising in Donbass.
April 28, 2017
(Bellingcat)
Leader in Lyon, France, of the fascist GUD (Groupe union défense), Steven Bissuel is guest at the Paneuropa conference, that the Ukrainian National Corps party is holding in Kiev. The woman at left is Olena Semenjaka (cf. infra).
May 12, 2018
Born in 1987, Olena Semenjaka is a PhD student in philosophy and a Ukrainian nationalist militant. She appears in this famous photo, which was taken before 2014 and has spread on social networks
Olena Semenjaka is heading the international department of the National Corps. She is managing a network of relationships within the European far-right. She is speaking today at [RE]generation.Europa, an international meeting in Germany.
August 14, 2019
Bellingcat is a bunch of Western OSINT (Open Source Intelligence) nerds, whom British or US intelligence agencies may use as irregular auxiliaries. They publish on their blog a piece about the translations in Ukrainian and Russian of Brenton Tarrant’s manifesto, which was his claim of responsibility for his terrorist attack against Muslim worshipers in Christchurch, New Zealand, on March 15, 2019. Then 28 years old, Tarrant slaughtered 100 victims with an assault rifle. 51 died. The readers of both translations are mostly in Ukraine, Bellingcat writes. The article would be more complete if it precised that the Nazi organizations are illegal in Russia, where the security agency (FSB) is chasing their militants, while in Ukraine, many members of the armed forces are openly subscribing to that ideology
(Bellingcat)
A Ukrainian reader has sent that photo to the publisher after reception of the manifesto, at left. The bookmark is a flyer of C14, the youth branch of Nazi Svoboda party.
December 20, 2019
(Olena Semenjaka)
He visits Kiev and meets Olena Semenjaka (cf. supra, May 12, 2018). Marc de Cacqueray Valménier is a French Nazi militant, leader of a group called les Zouaves. On December 5, 2021, during a political rally in support to far-right presidential candidate Eric Zemmour, Valménier will be involved in violence against left militants, will be jailed on January 20, 2022.
April 7, 2022
The Rassemblement des étudiants de droite [Right-Wing Student Gathering, RED] is a fascist youth group in Angers, western France, which is cultivating a relationship with Italian fellows, is paying tribute to José Antonio Primo de Rivera (1903-1936), founder of the Spanish Falange [Phalanx]… etc
The photo surfaces on social networks. At home in Denver, Colorado, he displays the flag of Azov regiment, a Nazi formation within the Ukrainian national guard, that the Russian forces are encircling for a few days in Azovstal steel mill, Mariupol, Donetsk People’s Republic, Donbass
69-year-old James Mason is a Nazi militant since 1966, when he was teenager. He has articulated his political dreams in an anthology of essays, Siege, published in 1992, believes that Jews and capitalists would govern the US against the white race, that fascism is enabling the whites to dominate the others, that a terrorist strategy could trigger a war between the races, that the whites would win
Atomwaffen Division
He has inspired the Atomwaffen Division [Nuclear Weapons Division], an international Nazi organization, which was formed in the US in 2013.
May 14, 2022
A tragic combination of circumstances. While the Russian and republican [from Donetsk People’s Republic] troops are crushing the Ukrainian garrison in Mariupol, Donbass, Ukraine wins Eurovision song contest in Torino, Italy. The members of the music band express their solidarity with Azov regiment, which is encircled in Mariupol. Nazi militia in Kharkov in March 2014, after the rightist coup in Kiev, legalized as a national battalion of special police in May, against the uprising in Donbass, Azov punitive formation was attached to the Ukrainian national guard in November 2014
Meanwhile in the US, white supremacist Payton Gendron drives 300 km from his home to a supermarket in Buffalo, New York, where he assassinates ten Black and Hispanic passersby and customers with his assault rifle. He has already explained himself in a manifesto on the web. He used to display the Schwarze Sonne [black sun], legacy of Reichsführer SS Heinrich Himmler, that Azov is also featuring on its publication and badge.
July 25, 2022
in Ukraine (social networks)
As a simple example of the international Nazi involvement in Ukrainian ranks, a French independent media releases on Telegram the 8-minute interview of French Nazi militant Karel Cherel-Salzburg, whom intelligence, police and justice already knew in France. Mainstream media have already met him in Kharkov but tried to whitewash him
Some pictures that Karel Cherel-Salzburg has shared in 2020 on social networks
His hero is Léon Degrelle (1906-1994), a rexiste [catholic far-right] leader in Belgium in the 1930s, later Standartenführer [SS colonel] and commander of the 28.SS-Freiwilligen-Panzergrenadier-Division Wallonien (1941-1945)
Léon Degrelle
September 12, 2022
The Zouaves (cf. supra, December 20, 2019) are a former French Nazi group, that the internal affairs ministry dissolved on January 5, 2022. Its militants are still active on social networks, are still enjoying street fights. Their main obsessions are immigration and communism. They are part of a wide European network, are supporting Ukraine since February, against the Asian hordes of Soviet imperialism which are once again sweeping Europe [since 1945] and Putin’s Islamist dogs [Chechen fighters]. That network is usually in touch with the Ukrainian Nazi organizations like Azov regiment. Here is today a photo from a French militant in Ukraine
Terrorism : neo-Nazi network discovered, four arrests in Naples, Caserta and Avellino. And there are those who thought of attacking a police station. Contact with the Azov Battalion. Among the suspects a Ukrainian citizen who hypothesized an attack on a shopping center in the Nolan. Minister Piantedosi [Matteo Piantedosi, interior] : “The seed of hatred spreads”
So sad, Matteo. After the roundup, 42 year-old Maurizio Ammendola, founder of the Ordine di Hagal [Order of Hagal] association, 47-year-old Michele Rinaldi, 46-year-old Massimiliano Mariano and 25-year-old Giampiero Testa are in pretrial detention. They had come dangerously close to Ukrainian far-right nationalist groups, like most Western politicians and media, I think. The members of the association had contacts with Ukrainian formations defined as ultra-nationalist, including Azov regiment and Pravyi sektor [right sector]
Valhalla Express (IPA)
An unnamed Ukrainian citizen, who has returned to his country, is also under investigation. He has expressed the will to carry out a terrorist attack on a shopping center in the Nolan area.
December 20, 2022
Prison rather than Valhalla for this Scandinavian fighter for democracy. Helge Mossige is a 22-year-old Norwegian Nazi militant, who went for a while to fight in Ukraine within Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s International Legion. The battlefield has hardened him. Back in Norway, he is sentenced and jailed for death threats against local politicians
(Facebook)
January 18, 2023
In Paris, GUD (Groupe union défense) fascist militants pay tribute to Artem Novikov, a Ukrainian fighter who was killed on January 11 within Azov regiment
(Social networks)
The portrait of Novikov is framed with two runes. At left, Algiz means birth. At right, the turned over one, the Todesrune [death rune, in German], means death. The runes are ancient but the German Nazis have ushered in that symbolism. GLORY TO HEROES is written in Ukrainian on the banner.
February 17, 2023
The picture surfaces on social networks. Italian members of the Atlanticist forces in Ukraine are bearing the flag of Salò Republic (RSI), the last Italian fascist State, in northern Italy, between 1943 and 1945
On the monument behind, the graffiti say Bakhmut is Ukraine. Two thousand km to the west, other graffiti said in April 1945 : Berlin bleibt deutsch. If these mercenaries survive the meat grinder, they will come back to Italy.
April 10, 2023
This is an evidence. Before he assassinated 51 Muslim worshipers in Christchurch, New Zealand, on March 15, 2019, Australian terrorist Brenton Tarrant (cf. supra, August 14, 2019) had trained in Ukraine, within Nazi Azov regiment
The “New Zealand shooter” Brenton Tarrant himself came to the school (Instagram). On Telegram, TrackANaziMerc channel is identifying foreign volunteers in Ukraine and monitoring the prominent Nazi militants within the Ukrainian armed forces
In 88kostya, 88 means HH, for Heil Hitler. Ukrainian Nazi militant Konstantin Tsilitskiy, member of Azov regiment, posts on his Instagram account an old photo aside Brenton Tarrant, who holds a rifle. In his manifesto in March 2019, the mass killer told that he had traveled to Ukraine, where the translated document was sold online after the massacre (cf. supra, August 14, 2019).
April 12, 2023
The Pentagon confirms the deaths of two US volunteers within the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine. According to the Daily Beast, a democratic neocon outlet, one is 22-year-old Edward Walter Wilton III
(On Telegram, TrackANaziMerc is identifying the foreign volunteers, monitoring the prominent Nazi militants within the armed forces of Ukraine)
Wilton has been killed in Bakhmut area, the meat grinder in Donetsk People’s Republic, Donbass, Russia.
April 22, 2023
Onboard a FlixBus from Lviv, western Ukraine, they reach Paris in the evening. They are carrying optical aimers and magazines, military equipment which is prohibited in France. Arrested, they will be sentenced on April 24 to six months in prison
Atlantico is not exactly the eye of Moscow, nor its voice. A technical aspect is disclosed in its pages. For the French edition, criminologist Xavier Raufer tells that due to Western arms deliveries to Ukraine and corruption in the outpost of the Atlanticist empire, a Kalashnikov assault rifle is costing only €300 on Marseilles black market, compared to €2500 before. What happened ? The influx of more modern small arms onto the battlefield has prompted the corrupt Ukrainian military to de-stock older Kalashnikov models. Under the law of supply and demand, prices have fallen in Marseilles.
May 11, 2023
He speaks on RADA, the public TV channel of the Ukrainian parliament. 51-year-old Mykhailo Podolyak is journalist and since April 2020, an adviser to Volodymyr Zelenskyy. He is a pure Ukrainian extremist, born in Lviv, the historical hotbed of Ukrainian Nazism
(Screenshot)
Podolyak is often hilarious. On December 13, 2022, for example, he whined on Twitter because Elon Musk had wiped out there the army of Ukrainian bots. But today, Podolyak threatens
Mr Borrell can say “We will stop giving arms to Ukraine”, but that would mean genocide in Ukraine, war would start in other countries. The number of terrorist attacks in Europe will increase significantly. In general, in Europe, one will not sit in restaurants and eat croissants calmly
Now the funny part, it works. A few days later, Germany will announce a €2.7 billion worth delivery of military equipment to Ukraine.
May 22, 2023
In order to ward off the psychological impact of the humiliating defeat in Bakhmut two days earlier, Ukraine is raiding border villages in Belgorod region, Russia. A few motorized/mechanized platoons are involved. Noise and panic are the goals. Fake alarming messages are simultaneously addressed to the Russian citizens through social networks. That is a terrorist operation, under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR)
The RDK holds a press conference on May 24, 2023. Denis Kapustin is in black clothes, at the center. The second man from the right is displaying the Schwarze Sonne [black sun], a legacy of Reichsführer SS Heinrich Himmler (Sergey Bobok / AFP)
The troops are mainly the Russian RDK (cf. supra, December 14, 2014), with reinforcements from the military branch of Tradytsiya ta poryadok [Tradition and Order], a Ukrainian Nazi organization which is recruiting foreign fighters. At least two are French. One is from Lyon, already a veteran, his nickname is Kenneth. César Aujard is a new recruit from Paris. Both are supremacist militants in France
César Aujard and Kenneth on May 25, 2023 (social networks)
June 2, 2023
Block Club Chicago reports that the same day, in Humboldt Park, Chicago, a man has committed suicide, after an all day standoff with police
(Colin Boyle / Block Club Chicago)
For weeks, neighbors have complained of a swastika being hung on scaffolding on the roof of his building. When the police came, the white man shown a submachine gun, a flamethrower and other weapons, what triggered negotiations, until his suicide. Black and Latino neighbors also testified that the man used to make antisemitic commentaries.
On that photo of the aftermath, we can see also on the roof, in descending height order, an upside down Star-Spangled Banner and the national flag of Ukraine.
July 1, 2023
Riots are shaking the French society, after a French cop, Florian Menesplier, has murdered on June 27 a teenager in Nanterre, northwestern suburb of Paris. From Ukraine, a German volunteer expresses his solidarity with the French supremacists. Far-right ideology has rotten for a long time the French Police nationale
(Social networks)
defend Europe, from Ukraine to France ! We must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children
The second sentence is the Fourteen Words, a famous slogan among white supremacists worldwide.
Ukrainian Nazi channel Valhöll [Valhalla in Icelandic], on behalf of the European fraternity, expresses its support for the French nationalists and police officers, pays tribute to the French soldiers, in their common fight against neo-Bolshevism
(Valhöll)
The collage displays historical images of the Légion des volontaires français [LVF, a regiment of French auxiliaries within Wehrmacht during WW2], others of French supremacist militants, RED (cf. supra, April 7, 2022) at bottom right, on trip in Lviv, other ones of French volunteers in Ukraine, including at top left Alan Vigneron and Guillaume Andreoni (cf. supra, April 22, 2023). Written in English, the text says
We express our support to all French nationalists, rightists, hooligans, and simply caring sons and daughters of the French nation. French law-enforcement and armed forces talked about a civil war due to ethnic problems years ago. This all comes at a time when the French police are accused of racism and called for “restructuring”. We remember all the French soldiers who are fighting on the side of Ukraine. We remember all the French who died for our common cause, in the fight against neo-Bolshevism. We remember the support from the French nationalists, and we want to express mutual support. We support our French white brothers in their struggle as they support us in our war. Only by uniting we can build a new world. European Brotherhood!
July 8, 2023
By decrees, Volodymyr Zelenskyy posthumously confers the title of Hero of Ukraine, with Golden Star, to two Russian brothers, Leonid and Roman Butusin
(Social networks)
Born in 1971, their father Oleg (up left) is a Nazi militant. He was living in the Russian Far East, where he was calling for the murder of Chinese and Jewish people. Indicted, he fled and the whole family surfaced later in Ukraine, after the West-sponsored right-wing coup in Kiev on February 21, 2014. Since Maidan, Ukraine is an international magnet for Nazis.
Members of the Ukrainian regular army, 58th motorized brigade, the two sons used to proudly bear the Nazi Reichsadler [imperial eagle], the SS Totenkopf and the ROA patch. Between 1942 and 1945, the German Nazis were recruiting among Soviet prisoners of war, Ukrainian, Belarusian or Russian, the members of the Russkaya Osvoboditel’naya Armiya [Russian Liberation Army], also called Vlasov army. After victory, Soviet Union tried general Andrey Vlasov, who was hanged on August 1, 1946. The Russian forces killed Roman and Leonid Butusin on March 9, 2022, in Chernigov region. Later, Oleg broadcasted the photo of a ROA patch (down right), that he found on one of the two corpses.
On April 6, 2022, US propaganda outlet Radio Free Europe wrote a piece of anthology
Roman and Leonid Butusin were born in Vladivostok, in Russia’s Far East, but both died fighting for the Ukrainian Army against Russian invaders. At their funeral, people knelt on the street in a mark of respect. “They were real Ukrainians,” said one mourner. Their father moved the family to Ukraine in 2014, feeling disgusted by Russia’s seizure of Crimea and support for separatists in the country’s eastern Donbas region. Also a soldier, at the funeral he said he would soon be returning to the front line
On social networks, international English-speaking Nazi channels are celebrating the Ukrainian official tribute to Butusin brothers.
July 12, 2023
According to Berlin Junge Welt daily newspaper, the Deutsches Freiwilligen Korps [German Volunteer Corps, DFK, cf. supra, July 1] was formed in February 2023, with a few members of the III. Weg [Third Way] party, is linked to the RDK, Russian Nazis who are also fighting within the Atlanticist forces in Ukraine (cf. supra, May 22, 2023)
Emblem of the Deutsches Freiwilligen Korps, DFK, where НДК [NDK] is the acronym of Немецкий добровольческий корпус, Nemetskiy Dobrovol’cheskiy Korpus in Latin characters
July 16, 2023
The picture surfaced on social networks, is showing an Atlanticist soldier in Ukraine, likely from Croatia or Bosnia, likely Muslim, who is bearing a patch of the 13. Waffen-Gebirgsdivision der SS, Handschar (1943-1945)
in 1943 (Bundesarchiv)
Formed in 1943, mainly with Muslim volunteers from Bosnia, the SS mountain infantry division was involved against partisans in Yugoslavia, where it also slaughtered Serbian civilians.
July 22, 2023
On July 14, 2023, 19-year-old Oleg Smirnov, alias Kex, has been killed within Revansh [Revenge] battalion, the military branch of Nazi Tradytsiya ta poryadok [Tradition and Order] organization, that he joined at 18 years old, after peacetime military training since 2021 within Centuria, Azov youth branch
(Centuria)
In Angers, western France, RED fascist youth group (cf. supra, April 7, 2022) pays tribute to the fallen Ukrainian Nazi, comments on social networks
(RED)
[…] Gloire au Héros ! Nous nous souvenons ! Vous pouvez soutenir sa famille ici [Glory to the Hero! We remember! You can support his family here]
August 1, 2023
Neither exhaustive nor finalized, my list of French volunteers is including a high proportion, between a third and a half, of proud far-right militants, even Nazis. All are acquiring military experience in Donbass and Ukraine and for novices, the new practice of weapons. Some are forging ideological and operational ties with radically racist and reactionary local organizations, with international comrades of the same ilk. That is posing a new threat to internal security, as some will not be killed and will not decide to remain in Ukraine. This issue is the subject of the written question that deputy of Ille et Vilaine Frédéric Mathieu addresses to the interior minister
Mr. Frédéric Mathieu alerts the Minister of the Interior and Overseas to the risk represented by the presence of French fighters within the Ukrainian International Legion created by Ukrainian President Volodymr Zelensky.
Indeed, among the 400 French people who have left for Ukraine since the start of the conflict, there are around a hundred fighters, most of them clearly identified as being part of the far-right movement. Among them, there are civilians but also many former soldiers. Some have already been identified by the investigative press as gravitating in revolutionary nationalist spheres, such as César A [César Aujard, cf. supra, May 22, 2023], far-right Parisian hooligan and suspect of the assault on the parliamentary attaché of my colleague Aurélie Trouvé , April 29, 2023.
These individuals are fighting together within Ukrainian units such as “Revansh battalion”, an offshoot of the Ukrainian ultranationalist movement “Order and Tradition”. They are displaying unabashedly on social networks flags and tattoos including neo-Nazi symbols and are justifying their participation in this conflict by the “struggle for European civilization”, with white supremacism and the fight against the “Asian hordes” in the background.
If, according to an RTL article of January 1, 2023, French fighters would be debriefed on their return to France by the DGSI [French counter-intelligence agency] for the purpose of collecting military intelligence, we can only be worried when we learn that on April 22, 2023 , two far-right activists [Guillaume Andreoni & Alan Vigneron, cf. supra, April 22, 2023] were arrested at Bercy bus station with assault rifle magazines and sights in their luggage, during an apparently fortuitous check, even though they were both doing subject of forms for undermining state security.
In an article in Le Monde on July 9, 2023, when asked about the terrorist threat from the far-right, the director general of the DGSI affirms: “The terrorist risk it is generating has increased in recent years within Western democracies, in France in particular”. He mentions 10 terrorist projects, of neo-Nazi, accelerationist, racist or conspiratorial inspiration, that have been foiled in France since 2017 and specifies that the threat can emanate from solitary individuals.
In its report in March 2021, the General Prosecutor’s Office of the Paris Court of Appeal highlights transnationalization or porosity between violent far-right French and foreign organizations, citing in particular the example of Génération Identitaire which, although dissolved in March 2021, remains very active through local structures.
I would also like to know whether the Minister of the Interior is taking the full measure of the risk represented by the return of individuals who, for some, are glorifying personalities like the Norwegian mass killer Anders Breivik and return with a certain “know-how” in terms of handling weapons, and whether the necessary means have been put in place to prevent possible attacks.
August 12, 2023
From the Piave to the Don, Europe, get up! Glory to the heroes
In Sassari, Sardinia, CasaPound pays tribute to Revansh [Revenge] battalion, the military branch of Tradytsiya ta poryadok [Tradition and Order] organization. A Ukrainian Nazi channel shares the picture
CasaPound [Pound House, 2003-] is an Italian fascist party. Its name is a tribute to US fascist poet Ezra Pound.
August 14, 2023
Need a vacation? Bolshevik Safari 2023 Action Packed Gateway! Alternative Recreation Therapy Call Kent McLellan Travel Agent
(Social networks)
While the Atlanticist counteroffensive is a bloody failure since early June, the Misanthropic Division (cf. supra, February 21, 2014), an international Nazi organization based in Ukraine since 2013, is recruiting new volunteers against Russia. Five travel agents, three in/from the US, one in/from Canada and one in/from Europe, are the recruitment officers
US supremacist militant, veteran in Ukraine, Kent McLellan, Boneface (cf. supra, November 12, 2022), is the main character of the campaign, which is touting two military formations of Azov political organization : the original brigade within the national guard and the new 3rd assault brigade of the regular army.
August 15, 2023
(Social networks)
Without military experience, French volunteer Fabien Biernat came to Ukraine in April 2023. US PMCs (private military contractors) trained him in May, in Kherson region. He displays on social networks his membership in a brotherhood of international Nazi fighters
In Outpost 318, 318 means CAH and AH, Adolf Hitler. Combat 18 or C18 is a terrorist organization founded in the UK in 1992, which spread later in Canada, the US and Germany, where some members were involved in the assassinations of migrants and one German political figure.
September 2, 2023
Blood Tribe is a US Nazi group based in Maine, parades today in Orlando, Florida. Its leader is a former Marine, Christopher Pohlhaus, Hammer
(Screenshot)
[a journalist] Christopher, there’s a presidential race going on right now. Are you going to vote in the 2024 election? [Polhaus] My vote doesn’t decide anything, but Biden is better than Trump because he’s sending missiles to Ukraine
Then, Kent McLellan, Boneface, gives the Nazi salute and yells
Slava Ukrayini [Glory to Ukraine]
In the screenshot, McLellan is in the second rank, at right. He is a former fighter within Azov organization, a recruiter (cf. supra, August 14) for its military branch, the original formation in the Ukrainian national guard and the 3rd assault brigade of the regular army.
October 20, 2023
The pictures are shared on militant channels, Der Dritte Weg [The Third Way], a German Nazi political organization has delivered equipment in Kiev to nationalist volunteers in Ukraine, for a Europe of youth, brothers and comrades, a Europe in arms
The tall guy at the center is undoubtedly Matthias Fischer, III. Weg leader. For the RDK, Denis Kapustin stands at his left. The still unidentified leader of the NDK is at left (Der Dritte Weg)
The recipients are members of the Russian RDK (cf. supra, May 22, 2023) and German NDK (cf. supra, July 12, 2023). Both formations are under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR). The still unidentified German leader of the NDK expressed his solidarity (cf. supra, July 1, 2023) with the French far-right, during a revolt in France after a French unfit cop had murdered a teenager in Nanterre
(Social networks)
Besides, Ukrainian Azov organization has already enrolled foreigners since 2014. As an example and according to reliable sources, French Nazi militant Karel Cherel Salzburg (cf. supra, July 25, 2022) joined the formation in 2018, through Bastion social, a supremacist group in Lyon, then Gaston Besson, a French war criminal during the civil war in former Yugoslavia, who was then operating as recruiter in Switzerland
Leaflets are even handed out in the streets of Paris. The particular disgrace in France is that Azov emblem, the German Nazi Wolfsangel [wolf hook, cf. supra, May 14, 2015], was previously identifying the 2. SS-Panzerdivision, Das Reich, which on June 10, 1944, slaughtered 643 civilians, both genders, all ages, in Oradour sur Glane.
November 12, 2023
While right militants are demonstrating in Spain against a government project of amnesty for the Catalan separatists, a video surfaces on Ukrainian Nazi channels. From Ukraine, Atlanticist fighters express their solidarity with the fascist heirs of Franco
(Screenshot)
In English, the speaker is glad to see that Europe is not dead and hopes that a second Reconquista will clean Spain from Islam, foreign scum and leftists. At right, another one displays
MAKE SPAIN GREAT AGAIN Reconquista 2.0 Good.night.left.side DEATH TO SEPARATISTS
January 14, 2024
In several European countries, here in Grenoble, France, fascist groups pay tribute to Svetoslav Slavkov
(Social networks)
Prominent supporter of Levski Sofia football club, the hero was a Bulgarian Nazi militant. He had joined the Atlanticist troops in Ukraine, was killed on January 4.
January 22, 2024
Ukrainian Nazi channels are sharing a photography where a militant of the Misanthropic Division (cf. supra, February 21, 2014), international Nazi organization based in Ukraine, stands in front of Fort Sumter, Charleston, South Carolina, where began in 1861 the US civil war.
February 4, 2024
In a photo they are sharing on social networks, white supremacists from Minnesota, the Sons of Hengist, are supporting Ukrainian Nazi Azov organization. Hengist was in the VI century a Germanic mercenary for Celtic king Vortigern in Britain and according to the mythology, founder of a Saxon kingdom in Kent.
February 20, 2024
On X from Paris, GUD (cf. supra, January 18, 2023) fascist organization publishes the photography of two militants within the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine.
February 23, 2024
(Social networks)
In Zwickau, Sachsen, in order to celebrate the second anniversary of the Russian special military operation for liberation of Donbass, demilitarization and denazification of Ukraine, Der III. Weg [The Third Way] Nazi militants express their solidarity with Ukraine, pay tribute to Azov organization, honor the defenders of Europe. Their Ukrainian fellows share the photography on social networks.
March 15, 2024
(Social networks)
English white supremacists are supporting Ukraine, Ukrainian Nazis share the photo on their social networks.
March 17, 2024
(Screenshot)
According to a video that the group releases, the DFK (Deutsches Freiwilligen Korps, German Volunteer Corps, cf. supra, July 12, 2023), emanation in the Atlanticist ranks of a German Nazi party, Der III. Weg [The 3rd Way], is committed, alongside Russian Nazi emigrants of the RDK, in Belgorod direction, where once more (cf. supra, May 22, 2023), the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR) is conducting a propaganda operation, in order to terrorize Russian civilians, while the Russian presidential election is held
A 16-year-old Ukrainian refugee is arrested and jailed in Milan, Italy. The Ukrainian Nazi militant was a reader of Mein Kampf, Adolf Hitler’s bestseller. With the cry I fascisti sono tornati [The fascists are back] in the subway, he used to assault people who were looking like migrants from other countries.
May 8, 2024
In order to start the exploration of the Ukrainian Nazi propaganda vectors, no one can ignore the Misanthropic Division, an international brotherhood founded and based in Ukraine since 2013. Its militants were involved on Maidan square in the right-wing coup (cf. supra, February 21, 2014)
Here are early May 2024 the images of its major channels on Telegram, top, from left to right, the general account, the commercial department and the cultural channel. Below, badges, patches and t-shirts are sold around the world. Customers are mainly in Europe and the US. The recipient on the right is French, has notably received the crest and coat of arms of the SS Charlemagne division. Ukrainian nationalism, anti-communism, racism and references to Nazi Germany are the usual variables in the equation(Misanthropic Division)
The West celebrates today Victory in Europe. Tomorrow will be Victory Day in Russia. The Misanthropic Division mourns with that German image the German Nazi state, that the Red Army destroyed through the conquest of Berlin on May 2, 1945. The depiction of childhood is a usual emotional technique, which is addressing idiots
in Berlin on May 8, 2024 (screenshot)
The day before, Russian troops carried out in Moscow the second rehearsal of the Victory parade
The detachment sings a song of Kino, a Soviet rock band from Leningrad (social networks)
May 22, 2024
(Ukrainian social networks)
Boris Johnson attends inside British parliament a meeting in support of Azov organization. Nazi militia in Kharkov in March 2014, national battalion of special police in May, attached to the Ukrainian national guard in November 2014, Azov regiment has been defeated in Mariupol in 2022
(Social networks)
The last Ukrainian defenders of Mariupol surrendered in Azovstal steel mill on May 20, 2022. Among them, Alexander Kratsov, Medved [Bear], was officer within Azov regiment. In these pictures, 14 stands for the Fourteen Words, a US supremacist slogan
we must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children
88 means HH, for Heil Hitler. A Nazi Reichsadler [imperial eagle] is tattooed on his neck. A Ukrainian trident has replaced the swastika of the WW2 Wehrmacht version.
The Western civilization is including other supporters of Azov. Nazi militant since he was teenager, writer James Mason (cf. supra, April 22, 2022) is one. He has articulated his political dreams in an anthology of essays, Siege, published in 1992, believes that Jews and capitalists would govern the US against the white race, that fascism is enabling the whites to dominate the others, that a terrorist strategy could trigger a war between the races, that the whites would win.
But why the hell does Boris Johnson appear so Nazi ? He has never been leftist, may be now angry. Because from his point of view, the news are bad. He explained it for the Daily Mail on April 12, 2024
(Screenshot)
With Ukrainian cities once again being pounded to rubble and the casualties mounting, I’m afraid I have to ask once again : why the hell we are being so slow in giving those heroic Ukrainians the weapons they so desperately need ? Because if Ukraine falls, it will be a catastrophe for the West, it will be the end of Western hegemony and we will have no one to blame but ourselves
He is embodying the historical and still vivid link between British imperialism and fascism.
August 18, 2024
For the first day of Ligue 1, French professional football league, Toulouse receives Nantes. In the stands, supporters unfurl the banner of the RDK (cf. supra, December 14, 2014), a formation of Russian Nazi militants who have sought refuge in Ukraine after the far-right coup in 2014, are under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR)
Ukrainian Nazi channels on Telegram will proudly share the picture on August 27.
the RDK (cf. supra, December 14, 2014), a combat formation of Russian Nazi militants who have settled in Ukraine after the 2014 coup, are under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (GUR),
the Belarus Volunteer Corps, under Ukrainian command,
Wotan Jugend [Odin Youth, in German], a group of Russian Nazi militants who have settled in Ukraine after the 2014 coup.
Through video-conference, Italian fascist ideologue Gabriele Adinolfi speaks remotely.
September 15, 2024
(Joe Raedle / Getty Images)
As conclusion of a short firefight with the Secret Service, next to Donald Trump’s golf course in Florida, Martin County Sheriff’s deputies arrest 58-year-old Ryan Routh, who was seeking the opportunity to shoot at the former US president with his assault rifle
(Social networks)
Routh is not a fascist nor a Republican, but a Democrat and an ardent supporter of Ukraine, where he traveled at least once in April 2022, stayed several months
(Screenshots)
While Russia was close to completing the liberation of Mariupol, Donetsk People’s Republic, Routh surfaced on April 30, 2022, on Maidan square, Kiev, in a rally and a propaganda video in support to Azov regiment (cf. supra, May 14, 2015), Nazi formation of the Ukrainian national guard which was encircled in Azovstal steel mill
(Amazon)
He has written a 291-page book, Ukraine’s Unwinnable War, which was released on February 28, 2023, though Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing. Max Blumenthal has read it for us. Routh appears as a kind of anti-Trump neocon, who is wishing the assassination of the former president and also Vladimir Putin.
September 26, 2024
Gwendal Delange (left) and his Irish comrade Alex Ryzhuk appear on February 18, 2024 (social networks)
Gwendal Delange is among French servicemen in Ukraine the most assumed and spectacular Nazi militant. I don’t think he’s a fighter, because his military hierarchy is preserving his physical integrity, as a figure of the Ukrainian Nazi propaganda aimed at French public. He is part-time volunteer [Ukrainian nationalist channel on Telegram] within the 3rd assault brigade, emanation of Nazi Azov organization in the Ukrainian regular army. His function is probably not limited to figuration. I am convinced that he also has a conception role, is picking his subjects
(French Nazi channel)
On September 26, 2024, alongside one Ukrainian comrade of the 3rd assault brigade, he pays tribute to Philippine Le Noir de Carlan, whose body was found in Paris on 21st, victim of rape and homicide, a news item that French right-wing figures, including of course the pétainistes [the heirs of French fascist leader Philippe Pétain during WW2], nowadays again the majority and driving force of the right-wing, are also exploiting for xenophobic and security-related political purposes
(Screenshots / now suspended Gwendal Delange’s X account)
In addition to his usual activities – photographed clad in steel and adorned with Ukrainian or international fascist emblems -, the French Nazi activist particularly distinguished himself on June 22, through his apology for the terrorist massacre in Christchurch, New Zealand, on March 15, 2019 (cf. supra, August 14, 2019). On X, he shared a Nazi-inspired video, which included images from Brenton Tarrant’s GoPro camera, when the Australian terrorist murdered 51 Muslim worshipers at prayer.
November 26, 2024
Nicknamed Dark Foreigner, 27-year-old Patrick Macdonald is tried in Ottawa for his involvement in the activity of a terrorist group, the Atomwaffen Division (cf. supra, April 22, 2022), a Nazi one in North America. Among the evidences, several propaganda videos were recorded and released in 2019
As the future of the Ukrainian nation and the greater European race is in freefall, we pledge our allegiance to the Atomwaffen Division
January 23, 2025
Belgian Intelligence has detected a teenager who is believed to have planned an attack, upon next Friday prayer, at a mosque in Molenbeek, Brussels western suburb, where many inhabitants are of Moroccan origins
Molenbeek in 2022 (PhotoNews)
The police raids his home, where edge weapons and documents with Nazi symbols are found. Computer equipment is also seized. His parents are refuges from Ukraine and the investigators have established that the boy is member of a nationalist organization
Football fans in Dnipro on December 18, 2022 (social networks)
Racism and fascism are deeply imbuing the Ukrainian popular culture since the West-backed right-wing coup in Kiev, on February 21, 2014. Before he assassinated 51 Muslim worshipers in Christchurch, New Zealand, on March 15, 2019, Australian terrorist Brenton Tarrant had trained in Ukraine (cf. supra, April 10, 2023), within Azov Nazi organization. With their international public, foreign volunteers in Ukrainian paramilitary formations are still sharing footage from Tarrant’s GoPro camera (cf. supra, September 26, 2024).
February 19, 2025
Serviceman within Azov 12th brigade, German national Peter Talos is interviewed in Diedersdorf castle (BILD / screenshot)
Julian Röpcke is Senior Editor over conflicts and security policy for BILD. He is a staunch supporter of Ukraine and also the Sunni radical uprising in Syria, always against Russia. I guess a historical family neurosis. Today, the German tabloid releases his video report from Diedersdorf castle, south of Berlin. The hotel is hosting the international battalion of the Ukrainian 12th special [police] brigade
That brigade is nothing less than the emanation of Nazi Azov organization in the Ukrainian national guard. From that Brandenburger village, the international Nazi volunteers are seeking financial support and I guess, are recruiting too. Röpcke interviews a former Bundeswehr serviceman, who is introduced as Peter R*. Peter Talos, his real name, is an already known member of Azov organization
Peter Talos is at right, in front of Denys Prokopenko, the brigade commander who surrendered to the Russian forces on May 20, 2022, in Mariupol, Donetsk People’s Republic, Russia (Azov)
Diedersdorf is about 20 km north of Zossen, the site until April 25, 1945, of the Oberkommando der Wehrmacht [OKW, Wehrmacht High Command]. On February 24, 2025, while the 80th anniversary of the Soviet victory over Nazi Germany is approaching, socialist Junge Welt daily newspaper reports that anachronism, to say the least.
[…] in the fight against Neo-Bolshevism […] to defend Europe […] Slava Ukraini […]
(Screenshot)
Emanation on the Atlanticist side in Ukraine of the German Nazi Dritte Weg [Third Way] party, the NDK is henceforth in the ranks of Sich battalion, the military branch of Ukrainian Nazi Svoboda [Liberty] party.
April 9, 2025
The picture is spreading among Ukrainian nationalist internet users. According to the caption, these two men are foreign fighters from Belgium, in the ranks of the Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR)
(Social networks)
Their flag is indeed Belgian, old, dates back to the 30s, is showing the logo of Rex political party, a fascist-catholic one
Recruitment poster for the Légion Wallonie (1941-1943), which will become the 28.SS-Freiwilligen-Grenadier-Division Wallonien (1944-1945)
Its leader was Léon Degrelle (1906-1994, cf. supra, July 25, 2022), later Standartenführer [SS colonel] and commander of the 28. SS-Freiwilligen-Grenadier-Division, Wallonien [Wallonia, 1941-1945]. After WW2, he sought refuge in Francisco Franco’s Spain.
May 21, 2025
Today is the 12th anniversary of his suicide. Son of a WW2 Pétainiste [French fascist militant], Dominique Venner was himself a pétainiste activist and a member of the OAS (Secret Army Organization), a bunch of terrorists who opposed early 60s the liberation of Algeria from French colonialism
Dominique Venner was defeated in Algeria
Later historian, the self-proclaimed samouraï d’Occident blown his brains out on May 21, 2013, inside Notre Dame cathedral, in order to express his angst over the alleged Islamization of France
The Deutsches Freiwilligen Korps [German Volunteer Corps, DFK, NDK, cf. supra, July 12, 2023] is an emanation in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine of III. Weg [Third Way], a German Nazi political party. Since April 1, 2025 (cf. supra), the NDK is fighting within Sich battalion, the military branch of Ukrainian Nazi Svoboda party. A French fascist group has published that picture, that the Germans share on social media, in order to pay tribute to Dominique Venner. Here are the famous European values, as born by people who are actually involved.
October 9, 2025
With this picture, the German Volunteer Corps (DFK, NDK, cf. supra, July 12, 2023) celebrates on social media the birthday of Horst Wessel, who was a pimp and a Nazi militant in Berlin
Communist militant Albrecht Höhler shot him on January 14, 1930. A few years before, Wessel had written a song, which became after his death the anthem of the Nazi party, the Horst Wessel Lied
Die Fahne hoch Die Reihen fest (dicht/sind) geschlossen SA marschiert Mit ruhig (mutig) festem Schritt Kam’raden, die Rotfront und Reaktion erschossen, Marschier’n im Geist In unser’n Reihen mit
Die Straße frei Den braunen Bataillonen Die Straße frei Dem Sturmabteilungsmann Es schau’n aufs Hakenkreuz voll Hoffnung schon Millionen Der Tag für Freiheit Und für Brot bricht an
Zum letzten Mal Wird Sturmalarm (-appell) geblasen Zum Kampfe steh’n Wir alle schon bereit Schon (Bald) flattern Hitlerfahnen über allen Straßen (über Barrikaden) Die Knechtschaft dauert Nur noch kurze Zeit
Die Fahne hoch Die Reihen fest (dicht/sind) geschlossen SA marschiert Mit ruhig (mutig) festem Schritt Kam’raden, die Rotfront und Reaktion erschossen, Marschier’n im Geist In unser’n Reihen mit
November 30, 2025
The Atlanticist military defeat is clear in Donbass and Ukraine, where the peace may be close. In Lyon, the capital of Gaul, ultras [fanatic football fans] express their support to Nazi Azov Ukrainian political organization. The flag at right is the 2014 original version, with Wolfsangel [cf. supra, May 14, 2015] and Schwarze Sonne [black sun, legacy of Reichsführer SS Heinrich Himmler, cf supra, May 14, 2022]
(Social media)
Gwendal Delange (cf. supra, September 26, 2024), the most spectacular French Nazi militant so far in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine, came in September 2022 from these groups in Lyon. He has gained warfare experience and from 2023 to early 2025, was in the 3rd assault brigade, emanation of Azov in the Ukrainian regular army
In Italy, CasaPound fascist militants (cf. supra, August 12, 2023) pay tribute to Denis Kapustin (cf. supra, October 20, 2023), who was commander of the Russian Volunteer Corps (Russkiy dobrovol’cheskiy korpus, RDK, cf. supra, May 22, 2023), a combat formation within the Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR), which is gathering Russian Nazi militants who have sought refuge in Ukraine after the West-backed right-wing coup in Kiev in 2014. A Russian drone denazified him in Zaporozhye region in the night of December 26-27
Long live the White King (Social media)
Kapustin’s personality and these tributes enlighten the global modern fascist movement. Born in Russia and raised in Germany by a Jewish mother, he had built his ideology on hostility towards migrants. CasaPound [Pound House, 2003-] is an Italian fascist party. Its name is a reference to US fascist poet Ezra Pound.
January 1, 2026
(Screenshot)
The announcement of his death was a psyop. Nazi militant Denis Kapustin is still alive, appears in a videoconference with Kyrylo Budanov, head of the Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR).
February 10, 2026
With about 2,000 members, Nazi Núcleo Nacional [National Core] political party is registered in Spain. One of its leaders is 23-year-old Isabel Medina Peralta
(Social media, screenshot)
As emblem, the group has added a Christian cross to the Wolfsangel [wolf hook, cf. supra, May 14, 2015], a former German SS and nowadays, Ukrainian Nazi symbol.
February 14, 2026
French fascist militant Quentin Deranque dies in hospital from a cerebral hemorrhage, following an injury sustained on 12, during a brawl that his group triggered by attacking a conference given by MEP Rima Hassan, famous for her support to Palestine, at the Institute of Political Studies in Lyon
« A tribute to you, Quentin »: Gwendal Delange is the first on the right (social media)
A legal proceeding is opened about the death ; it is related to individuals. As a former police detective in homicide cases, I would have endorsed manslaughter. But in France, the prosecutor is the stooge of the executive power. He is suing the suspects for murder.
Beside, in a strictly political inquisition, which is manipulating the facts and misinforming, government officials including justice minister Gérald Darmanin, French mainstream media, center and right wing politicians, from fascists to liberals, are united in order to incriminate LFI, Hassan’s left wing party.
On February 17, in parliament, their representatives will even observe one minute’s silence in memory of the fascist assailant. Their actuality continues to fuel nasty prejudices about the pinzuti [French, in Corsican]: fearful, petty, coward, incompetent and arrogant.
February 22, 2026
in Lyon on February 21, 2026 (French fascist social media)
The day after the cream of pétainistes [heirs of Philippe Pétain, French fascist Head of State during WW2] mourned fallen fascist militant Quentin Deranque (cf. supra), either present in a political march in Lyon or offering support in the media, III. Weg [Third Way, cf. supra, October 20, 2023] Nazi activists pay tribute to him from Württemberg region, Germany
From Lyon to Donbass, fight the « Rotfront [German communist defense organization between 1924 and 1933]
On the 4th anniversary of the Russian special military operation, activists from Trincea Ucraine [Ukrainian Trench], a subsidiary of Italian fascist CasaPound party (cf. supra, August 12, 2023), put up posters in tribute to KIA Ukrainian comrades. That is an effect of denazification process: the European fascists mourn their dead
On February 18, 2026, Harnizon pays tribute in Kiev to French deceased Nazi thug Quentin Deranque (social media)
On February 18, 2026, Ukrainian Harnizon fascist organization paid tribute in Kiev to French Nazi thug Quentin Deranque (cf. supra, February 14, 2026), fatally wounded when his group had attacked a meeting of the left in Lyon
On April 5, 2026, French fighters with Revansh battalion attend a mass at Saint Nicholas Catholic church in Kiev (Revansh battalion)
Since then, Harnizon has swarmed in several French cities. Its French affiliated members are usually praising Ukrainian Revansh Nazi battalion (cf. supra, July 22, 2023), which under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR), is employing a group of French fighters
The emblem of the Ukrainian parent organization is at left. The French subsidiary, at right, has replaced the Ukrainian trident with a royalist fleur-de-lis (social media)
Garnison royale is the name of Harnizon‘s French subsidiary, plans to demonstrate in Paris on May 23.
April 20, 2026
To illustrate a conference held in Rouen a few days before, Garnison Royale, the French subsidiary of Ukrainian Harnizon fascist organization, publishes this picture on social media
The outfit of the speaker, with an armband, reminds the uniform of the Milice Française [French Militia], a paramilitary force formed in 1943, which was hunting the partisans, while fascist leader Philippe Pétain was heading the French State
The patches of two Nazi formations of the Ukrainian army, the RDK (cf. supra, May 22, 2023) and Revansh, both under command of the Ukrainian military intelligence (HUR), are displayed right of the speaker.
May 12, 2026
A new photo (right) surfaces on social media, from the memorial on Maidan square, Kiev, to French volunteers who have been killed in action in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine
Scattered on the ground, leaflet and stickers are promoting the C9M (Comité du 9 mai), a French Nazi organization whose demonstration in Paris was banned on May 9 by French authorities
(C9M, screenshot)
Undesirable in the capital, one thousand activists gathered in the evening in a field of Paris southern suburb.
June 13, 2026
In a demonstration in Rome, Italy, about one thousand fascist activists are demanding remigration, the deportation of migrants
(Social media)
Members of the Misanthropic Division (cf. supra, February 21, 2014), an international Nazi brotherhood founded and based in Ukraine since 2013, are there.
July 31, 2026
To protest against a wave of migration in Ceuta, a Spanish enclave in North Africa, Nazi Nucleo Nacional (cf. supra, February 10, 2026) activists demonstrate in the vicinity of the Moroccan embassy in Madrid
(Social media)
Their emblem is an adaptation of the Wolfsangel [wolf hook, cf. supra, May 14, 2015], a WW2 German Nazi symbol that their Ukrainian counterparts reintroduced in the 90s. They also display a Ukrainian Nazi flag.
The day after, I read on social media the feelings of a French fascist militant in Ukraine: Europe is henceforth attacked on two fronts, Ukraine and Spain.
Iván Rico Olivares, spokesman of Spanish Nazi Nucleo Nacional party (cf. supra, July 31, 2026), is carrying out a humanitarian visit in Ukraine.
October 20, 2026
Vive la Commune [communist revolution in Paris in 1871]: the city hall is burning down in Limoges on October 17, 2026 (Pascal Lachenaud / AFP)
A student-led social movement is then sweeping France, giving rise to numerous skirmishes with the French State police and fascist thugs. The causes are stemming from social demands of students and more broadly, from a widespread rejection of Emmanuel Macron among the general population. This new wave of dissent is a specific manifestation of tensions that he has built for years, by using the Constitution of the Fifth Republic to effectively hijack democracy. Since 2017, he is stubbornly persisting in implementing his neoliberal agenda, in defiance of the aspirations of the popular majority
Here is at left a French cop in Paris on August 2, 1940 (Mémorial de la déportation)
They are heirs to Philippe Pétain —French fascist leader during WW2— and have once again become the majority within the French right; the pétainistes choose to view these events solely as a rebellion by an impoverished, immigrant-origin population living in ugly suburbs. So their fellow activists in the West and even Donald Trump
(Social media)
On Telegram, the channel of European Nazi football ultras shares the fantasized picture of an Einsatz in Paris of Andriy Biletsky, commander of the 3rd army corps, offshot of Nazi Azov organization in the Ukrainian regular army
The 3rd Assault brigade to restore order in Paris, in exchange for unlimited weapons supply, it’s a good deal:)
But actually, after Ukrainian victory veterans can be used to assist with the Remigration in Europe. There will be 1000s of soldiers who are ideologically minded and perfect for subcontracting
Maksym Zhorin during an interview published on September 2, 2024 (online.ua)
For several days now, “protesters” have been wreaking havoc on French streets without any concrete demands. All of this is happening under the complete silence of major media outlets, which are still unable to clearly identify the ethnic and religious backgrounds of the perpetrators.
All of this is a consequence of many years of promoting a toxic liberal ideology. No words will help overcome this crisis; only a series of firm, radical steps will. In order to survive, Europe must remember its history and its true essence, rather than wallowing in false tolerance
Ukrainian slaughter of enemy civilians in Kupyansk on October 9, 2022 (Maksym Zhorin, screenshots)
I advise that barbarian against any attempt in Corsica. The ground is rough here. He risks shedding tears of rage or even losing his life.
October 23, 2026
A racist terrorist is selecting his victims based on their appearance, as he is wreaking havoc from Trappes to La Verrière, Paris southwestern suburb. With his submachine gun, he kills one person and wounds five others, including a 12-year-old girl whom eight bullets hit
(Le Parisien)
Upon his arrest further, he claims that he has avenged shopkeepers [whose businesses were looted during the protests on October 17, cf. supra] by targeting Black and Arab individuals. A copy of Mein Kampf is later discovered at his home.
November 10, 2026
On November 6, 14 Nucleo Nacional (cf. supra, February 10, 2026) activists were arrested across Spain in an investigation for incitement to hatred, unlawful association and weapon possession
in Madrid on July 31, 2026 (Aaron Heredia / NurPhoto)