Nicolas Cinquini

Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu

Category: Uncategorized

  • [Sharing] Happy birthday, President Putin – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Putin’s race is not yet run because NATO’s game plan remains the same one of subjugating Russia and, mad though it seems, using it as a springboard to dismember China

    Though Russian President Putin has reasons galore to be quietly cheerful when he marks his 72nd birthday this Monday, 7th October, chief of these are that he has been loyal to his faith, his family and his motherland. Were his mother or his elder brother, who died as an infant in Finland’s Siege of Leningrad, to testify to us from beyond the Styx, they would be rightly very proud of how Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin not only stayed true to all of them but to Mother Russia as well.

    The collapse of the Soviet Union around Putin’s ears was a pitiable sight. Red Army soldiers in Budapest sold their kits for pennies to passersby, vodka and depression slashed the life expectancy of Russia’s males, patriotic Russian teachers were paid with cabbage heads and Western gangsters, together with their local collaborators, robbed Russia blind. To the extent that Putin has reversed all of that, he and his helpers should be immensely proud of the work they have done thus far.

    Not that those enemies have gone away. They have not and one very important vector worth examining is the soft war NATO is directing through the cross dressing Ukrainian dictator Zelensky and Russian fifth columnists like the Pussy Riot slappers, who enjoy the same considerable support amongst the brothels and bordellos of Eastern Europe that the Gestapo did in occupied France.

    That Putin’s most vehement Ukrainian critics have, like Hitler’s French collaborators, degenerated into nothing more than hired hitmen, should not unduly surprise us, as they were nothing much better to begin with. What is, at first glance, far more noteworthy is the unrelenting attack on everything Russian, from the great Dostoevsky to the equally great Masha and the Bear, which makes no sense until we read this very day that children in Ukraine are still being brutalised for speaking their Russian mother tongue, the same mother tongue they share with the cross-dressing Ukrainian dictator and far too many immortal musicians, artists and authors to adumbrate here.

    Although those attacks, in the context of the Ukrainian conflagration, might seem trivial, they are anything but. Their purpose, when juxtaposed with the elevation of Pussy Riot, Zelensky and similar Central Asia civil society degenerates, is to demean, denigrate and marginalise all of Russia. Although all that might seem crazy to us, no less a figure than Herr Hitler would have understood its pivotal role in helping NATO physically and spiritually divide and conquer Russia which, as these NATO links here, here, here and here detail, remains its post-Putin Ukrainian end game.

    But Putin, it seems, is going nowhere anytime soon, at least not until his work of consolidating Russia within and without is done. Although the Pussy Rioters are a cancer that must be excised, the Ukrainian conflict must get priority. Although Russia’s recent capture of the fortress city of Vuhledar portends well, so do recent pronouncements of Ukrainian dictator Zelensky and serial British philanderer Boris Johnson.

    Because Zelensky implored American companies to invest in Ukraine’s energy grid during his recent American junket, the Russian air force must now reduce that infrastructure to dust to show that investing in Zelensky’s Ukraine has no upside. As regards Poundland Dr Strangloves like Boris Johnson, who demand that NATO should help its Ukrainian proxies to blitz Moscow and St Petersburg, Putin must show such charlatans that such bravado carries personal risk to obese armchair generals like them.

    Either way, if Russia is to survive, Putin must show NATO and their Ukrainian proxies that their dreams of conquest are not worth the candle and, if the Romanian or Polish juntas or, heaven help us, the non-entity who is Prime Minister of Denmark, have problems with that, so be it, and let the cards fall where they will.

    Although Putin unquestionably has his critics, much of that criticism is no more than cat yowling. Take, for example, this fine BBC piece, where Mariana Katzarova tells us of Putin’s ‘systematic crackdown’ on human rights since the Ukraine invasion. A fine demolition job on Putin, until we check Katzarova’s Wikipedia entry, which tells us that this Bulgarian brasser makes her living writing screeds like that, and that she knows no more about the internal dynamics of Russia than you or I do about the Yaifo tribe of the East Sepik province of Papua New Guinea who, to give them their due, are far more honest and honourable than carpetbaggers like Katzarova.

    Although NATO is also raising the stakes on Russia’s border with Japan, the key to these border brush fires is crushing NATO in Ukraine, so that all 14 countries that border Russia get the message that the Russian bear retains a fearsome bite.

    With her borders secure, Putin can then concentrate on the no less important task of securing Russia’s economic future with trade and other agreements with countries, great and small, that are not NATO’s cats’ paws. Though two of the most important of such countries are North Korea and China. Israel has also made Russian cooperation with Iran far more important than it was even a fortnight ago.

    The key to such co-operation is for each participant to know and to agree upon the extent and depth of their co-operation. Fortunately for Putin and for Russia, NATO’s Ukrainian adventurism has made that co-operation between Russia and a host of other Asian and African countries that bit easier.

    All of that said, Putin’s race is not yet run because NATO’s game plan remains the same one of subjugating Russia and, mad though it seems, using it as a springboard to dismember China. When we look at Russia in NATO’s global context, we can see how cautious Putin must be and what a monumental thorn in the side of NATO he is. That said, in the wider context of Russian and, indeed, European history, that is something Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin and those who work closest with him can be immensely proud of as they have measured themselves against Russia’s Immortal Regiment and they have passed with flying colours. Now, that is something for the septuagenarian Putin to be very happy about, indeed [end]

    The original article

    related

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • Daily pictures : is TrackANaziMerc evil ?

    Norwegian journalists are keen on triggering the censorship of Telegram channels which are identifying international Nazi volunteers and other mercenaries who are fighting in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine

    Verdens Gang [The Walk of the World, VG] is a daily tabloid and the largest circulation in the Norwegian press. On September 25, 2024, VG publishes an article titled, here is an English translation

    Faktisk.no: Over 40 Norwegians named and mocked in Russian Telegram channels

    A network of Telegram channels linked to Russian hacker circles spreads personal information about Norwegians. Some people have had their social security numbers or passports leaked. Several receive threats. In addition, nine Norwegian children are mentioned and three deceased Norwegians are being slandered. This is shown by a survey conducted by Faktisk.no […]

    A nice graphic is provided. In order not to give them any publicity, the two main Telegram channels of that network are not named in the article. The number one is ForeignCombatants ; the number two and major one is TrackANaziMerc. These are actually international clubs of open source intelligence (OSINT). Many members are indeed Russian. I am Corsican and working on the French subjects.

    I am indeed exploiting the information that brilliant Russian IT specialists are collecting within the Ukrainian bureaucracy and making public, am cross-checking them with public data on social networks and information from other sources, press or informants

    Slandered ? Through my French sample, I have established and written on my personal blog that between one third and the half of these French subjects are not exactly mercenaries, in French legal term, but rather far-right and Nazi volunteers. Unless they are personally involved, I am never unveiling identities of relatives whom I however know.

    The Norwegian journalists remind us that on August 24, 2024, French police arrested Pavel Durov, founder and boss of Telegram messaging service, under abusive legal pretexts, to weigh on the company, in expectation of gaining clear access to our encrypted messages. The journalists are also suggesting that our channels should be censored. They are evil.

    related

    The original article (in Norwegian)

    L’engagement français dans les rangs ukrainiens

    in French, alphabetical obituary chronicle of French involvement in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine, what servile journalists will not tell you

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

  • [Sharing] Once upon a time, at sea – RYBAR 30

    adventures in country-404

    The Armed Forces of Ukraine are using all available means to inflict damage on both military and civilian targets in Russia. Instead of effective long-range weapons, the UAF employs a large number of unmanned aerial vehicles and uncrewed boats. Individual uncrewed boats are capable of damaging port infrastructure or maritime vessels. These boats have become a real headache, proving quite difficult to combat.

    One of the most effective countermeasures against this type of weaponry has been helicopters. They patrol the sea, searching for targets, and once they spot an uncrewed boat, they hover in the air and engage with onboard weapons. However, it’s not that simple-the enemy is not idle, constantly changing and improving both their attack tactics and the devices themselves.

    In addition to the usual kamikaze boats, there are now uncrewed boat armed with missiles, uncrewed boats equipped with rocket launcher rails, and USVs with reinforced hulls designed to draw fire while the rest of the drone swarm attempts to break through to the target…


    ©️ RYBAR

    Related

    Related

    Five to One – RYBAR 83

    a reward shared by all

    Autumn near Bakhmut – RYBAR 82

    the balance between command and trust

    Ribbon on the Helmet – RYBAR 81

    how one symbol divided us and them

    The Grey Sky of Hostomel – RYBAR 80

    the way to our guys through fire and smoke

    Half a Meter from Death – RYBAR 79

    under the sights of an enemy drone

    We Don’t Abandon Our Own – RYBAR 78

    battle for Snake Island

    Easter Ceasefire – RYBAR 77

    silence regime or dangerous mercy

    The Road Back – RYBAR 76

    don’t give up your own and return home

    Survive Underground – RYBAR 75

    rescue at the risk of life

    Life on the Front Lines – RYBAR 74

    the moment that divides into before and after

    The Price of Life – RYBAR 73

    the only chance for survival

    Combat Cheburashka – RYBAR 72

    the story of a toy

    Call Sign Yan – RYBAR 71

    loyalty that cost a life

    Once upon a time between the lines – RYBAR 70

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Stepnohirsk – RYBAR 69

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Varvarovka – RYBAR 68

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Pokrovsk – RYBAR 67

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Kostyantynivka – RYBAR 66

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Cherkasy – RYBAR 65

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Aleksandro-Kalinovo – RYBAR 64

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Novohryhorivka – RYBAR 63

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Hnativka – RYBAR 62

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Mala Tokmachka – RYBAR 61

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the borderland – RYBAR 60

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Filiya – RYBAR 59

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Pavlohrad – RYBAR 58

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Crimea – RYBAR 57

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the Serebryanskyi forest – RYBAR 56

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time on the AFU’s positions – RYBAR 55

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Voronezh – RYBAR 54

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in a tank brigade – RYBAR 53

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Toretsk – RYBAR 52

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Tykhe – RYBAR 51

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Skudne – RYBAR 50

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Staromayorske – RYBAR 49

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the basements – RYBAR 48

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the gray zone – RYBAR 47

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the flow – RYBAR 46

    adventures in country-404

    Once on the Platform – RYBAR 45

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, on the way home – RYBAR 44

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Ukrainsk – RYBAR 43

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in hard times – RYBAR 42

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, it couldn’t be otherwise – RYBAR 41

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Vesyoloye – RYBAR 40

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Trudovoe – RYBAR 39

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Kurakhove – RYBAR 38

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Vuhledar – RYBAR 37

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in captivity – RYBAR 36

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Poltava – RYBAR 35

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Krasnohorivka – RYBAR 34

    adventures in country-404

    [Sharing] Once upon a time, in Verkhnya Syrovatka – RYBAR 33

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Pervomais’ke – RYBAR 32

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, while fleeing from the 404 country – RYBAR 31

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, on that very street – RYBAR 29

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, during a surrender – RYBAR 28

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Artemivka – RYBAR 27

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Umanske – RYBAR 26

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Novoselivka Persha – RYBAR 25

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Ostroverkhivka – RYBAR 24

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Krasnohorivka – RYBAR 23

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Chasiv Yar – RYBAR 22

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Kharkiw – RYBAR 21

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Spain – RYBAR 20

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on the election day – RYBAR 19

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Berdychi – RYBAR 18

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Kostyantynivka – RYBAR 17

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Oleshky – RYBAR 16

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on February 24 – RYBAR 15

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Bakhmut – RYBAR 14

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Robotyne – RYBAR 13

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Kreminna – RYBAR 12

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Lugansk – RYBAR 11

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Krynky – RYBAR 10

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Mar’inka – RYBAR 9

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Avdiivka – RYBAR 8

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Nova Kakhovka – RYBAR 7

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in the Azovets camp – RYBAR 6

    adventures in country -404

    Once upon a time, in Klishchiivka – RYBAR 5

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near the Russia-Ukraine border – RYBAR 4

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Novodarivka – RYBAR 3

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on Independence Day in country 404 – RYBAR 2

    the tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Urozhaine – RYBAR 1

    A tale of a failed counter-attack

  • Ritratti di u ghjornu : Aiacciu

    a cità induve un bigliettu di trasportu publicu costa solu un euro

  • [Sharing] Once upon a time, on that very street – RYBAR 29

    adventures in country-404

    In June 2024, in Chasiv Yar, assault groups of the Russian Armed Forces are advancing, pushing the enemy back in the course of intense battles. AFU units are holding their defense, employing numerous FPV drones and artillery shells with cluster warheads.

    In such conditions, even small advances become significant tactical successes in the battle for the city. As the assault troops occupy new positions, the main forces can move closer or relocate unnoticed.

    It’s easy to talk about all this from safety, but under fire, constantly risking both your own life and the lives of your comrades, covering even 200-300 meters can be incredibly difficult. But it’s necessary.


    ©️ RYBAR

    Related

    Related

    Five to One – RYBAR 83

    a reward shared by all

    Autumn near Bakhmut – RYBAR 82

    the balance between command and trust

    Ribbon on the Helmet – RYBAR 81

    how one symbol divided us and them

    The Grey Sky of Hostomel – RYBAR 80

    the way to our guys through fire and smoke

    Half a Meter from Death – RYBAR 79

    under the sights of an enemy drone

    We Don’t Abandon Our Own – RYBAR 78

    battle for Snake Island

    Easter Ceasefire – RYBAR 77

    silence regime or dangerous mercy

    The Road Back – RYBAR 76

    don’t give up your own and return home

    Survive Underground – RYBAR 75

    rescue at the risk of life

    Life on the Front Lines – RYBAR 74

    the moment that divides into before and after

    The Price of Life – RYBAR 73

    the only chance for survival

    Combat Cheburashka – RYBAR 72

    the story of a toy

    Call Sign Yan – RYBAR 71

    loyalty that cost a life

    Once upon a time between the lines – RYBAR 70

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Stepnohirsk – RYBAR 69

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Varvarovka – RYBAR 68

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Pokrovsk – RYBAR 67

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Kostyantynivka – RYBAR 66

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Cherkasy – RYBAR 65

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Aleksandro-Kalinovo – RYBAR 64

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Novohryhorivka – RYBAR 63

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Hnativka – RYBAR 62

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Mala Tokmachka – RYBAR 61

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the borderland – RYBAR 60

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Filiya – RYBAR 59

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Pavlohrad – RYBAR 58

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Crimea – RYBAR 57

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the Serebryanskyi forest – RYBAR 56

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time on the AFU’s positions – RYBAR 55

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Voronezh – RYBAR 54

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in a tank brigade – RYBAR 53

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Toretsk – RYBAR 52

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Tykhe – RYBAR 51

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Skudne – RYBAR 50

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Staromayorske – RYBAR 49

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the basements – RYBAR 48

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the gray zone – RYBAR 47

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the flow – RYBAR 46

    adventures in country-404

    Once on the Platform – RYBAR 45

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, on the way home – RYBAR 44

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Ukrainsk – RYBAR 43

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in hard times – RYBAR 42

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, it couldn’t be otherwise – RYBAR 41

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Vesyoloye – RYBAR 40

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Trudovoe – RYBAR 39

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Kurakhove – RYBAR 38

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Vuhledar – RYBAR 37

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in captivity – RYBAR 36

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Poltava – RYBAR 35

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Krasnohorivka – RYBAR 34

    adventures in country-404

    [Sharing] Once upon a time, in Verkhnya Syrovatka – RYBAR 33

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Pervomais’ke – RYBAR 32

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, while fleeing from the 404 country – RYBAR 31

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, at sea – RYBAR 30

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, during a surrender – RYBAR 28

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Artemivka – RYBAR 27

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Umanske – RYBAR 26

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Novoselivka Persha – RYBAR 25

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Ostroverkhivka – RYBAR 24

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Krasnohorivka – RYBAR 23

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Chasiv Yar – RYBAR 22

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Kharkiw – RYBAR 21

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Spain – RYBAR 20

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on the election day – RYBAR 19

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Berdychi – RYBAR 18

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Kostyantynivka – RYBAR 17

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Oleshky – RYBAR 16

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on February 24 – RYBAR 15

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Bakhmut – RYBAR 14

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Robotyne – RYBAR 13

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Kreminna – RYBAR 12

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Lugansk – RYBAR 11

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Krynky – RYBAR 10

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Mar’inka – RYBAR 9

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Avdiivka – RYBAR 8

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Nova Kakhovka – RYBAR 7

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in the Azovets camp – RYBAR 6

    adventures in country -404

    Once upon a time, in Klishchiivka – RYBAR 5

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near the Russia-Ukraine border – RYBAR 4

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Novodarivka – RYBAR 3

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on Independence Day in country 404 – RYBAR 2

    the tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Urozhaine – RYBAR 1

    A tale of a failed counter-attack

  • [Sharing] Pavel Durov and the Abuse of Law – Craig Murray

    The detention of Pavel Durov is being portrayed as a result of the EU Digital Services Act. But having spent my day reading the EU Services Act (a task I would not wish upon my worst enemy), it does not appear to me to say what it is being portrayed as saying.

    EU Acts are horribly dense and complex, and are published as “Regulations” and “Articles”. Both cover precisely the same ground, but for purposes of enforcement the more detailed “Regulations” are the more important, and those are referred to below. The “Articles” are entirely consistent with this.

    So, for example, Regulation 20 makes the “intermediary service”, in this case Telegram, only responsible for illegal activity using its service if it has deliberately collaborated in the illegal activity.

    Providing encryption or anonymity specifically does not qualify as deliberate collaboration in illegal activity.

    (20) Where a provider of intermediary services deliberately collaborates with a recipient of the services in order to undertake illegal activities, the services should not be deemed to have been provided neutrally and the provider should therefore not be able to benefit from the exemptions from liability provided for in this Regulation. This should be the case, for instance, where the provider offers its service with the main purpose of facilitating illegal activities, for example by making explicit that its purpose is to facilitate illegal activities or that its services are suited for that purpose. The fact alone that a service offers encrypted transmissions or any other system that makes the identification of the user impossible should not in itself qualify as facilitating illegal activities

    And at para 30, there is specifically no general monitoring obligation on the service provider to police the content. In fact it is very strong that Telegram is under no obligation to take proactive measures.

    (30) Providers of intermediary services should not be, neither de jure, nor de facto, subject to a monitoring obligation with respect to obligations of a general nature. This does not concern monitoring obligations in a specific case and, in particular, does not affect orders by national authorities in accordance with national legislation, in compliance with Union law, as interpreted by the Court of Justice of the European Union, and in accordance with the conditions established in this Regulation. Nothing in this Regulation should be construed as an imposition of a general monitoring obligation or a general active fact-finding obligation, or as a general obligation for providers to take proactive measures in relation to illegal content

    However, Telegram is obliged to act against specified accounts in relation to an individual order from a national authority concerning specific content. So while it has no general tracking or censorship obligation, it does have to act at the instigation of national authorities over individual content.

    (31) Depending on the legal system of each Member State and the field of law at issue, national judicial or administrative authorities, including law enforcement authorities, may order providers of intermediary services to act against one or more specific items of illegal content or to provide certain specific information. The national laws on the basis of which such orders are issued differ considerably and the orders are increasingly addressed in cross-border situations. In order to ensure that those orders can be complied with in an effective and efficient manner, in particular in a cross-border context, so that the public authorities concerned can carry out their tasks and the providers are not subject to any disproportionate burdens, without unduly affecting the rights and legitimate interests of any third parties, it is necessary to set certain conditions that those orders should meet and certain complementary requirements relating to the processing of those orders. Consequently, this Regulation should harmonise only certain specific minimum conditions that such orders should fulfil in order to give rise to the obligation of providers of intermediary services to inform the relevant authorities about the effect given to those orders. Therefore, this Regulation does not provide the legal basis for the issuing of such orders, nor does it regulate their territorial scope or cross-border enforcement

    The national authorities can demand content is removed, but only for “specific items”:

    51) Having regard to the need to take due account of the fundamental rights guaranteed under the Charter of all parties concerned, any action taken by a provider of hosting services pursuant to receiving a notice should be strictly targeted, in the sense that it should serve to remove or disable access to the specific items of information considered to constitute illegal content, without unduly affecting the freedom of expression and of information of recipients of the service. Notices should therefore, as a general rule, be directed to the providers of hosting services that can reasonably be expected to have the technical and operational ability to act against such specific items. The providers of hosting services who receive a notice for which they cannot, for technical or operational reasons, remove the specific item of information should inform the person or entity who submitted the notice

    There are extra obligations for Very Large Online Platforms, which have over 45 million users within the EU. These are not extra monitoring obligations on content, but rather extra obligations to ensure safeguards in the design of their systems:

    (79) Very large online platforms and very large online search engines can be used in a way that strongly influences safety online, the shaping of public opinion and discourse, as well as online trade. The way they design their services is generally optimised to benefit their often advertising-driven business models and can cause societal concerns. Effective regulation and enforcement is necessary in order to effectively identify and mitigate the risks and the societal and economic harm that may arise. Under this Regulation, providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines should therefore assess the systemic risks stemming from the design, functioning and use of their services, as well as from potential misuses by the recipients of the service, and should take appropriate mitigating measures in observance of fundamental rights. In determining the significance of potential negative effects and impacts, providers should consider the severity of the potential impact and the probability of all such systemic risks. For example, they could assess whether the potential negative impact can affect a large number of persons, its potential irreversibility, or how difficult it is to remedy and restore the situation prevailing prior to the potential impact.

    (80) Four categories of systemic risks should be assessed in-depth by the providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines. A first category concerns the risks associated with the dissemination of illegal content, such as the dissemination of child sexual abuse material or illegal hate speech or other types of misuse of their services for criminal offences, and the conduct of illegal activities, such as the sale of products or services prohibited by Union or national law, including dangerous or counterfeit products, or illegally-traded animals. For example, such dissemination or activities may constitute a significant systemic risk where access to illegal content may spread rapidly and widely through accounts with a particularly wide reach or other means of amplification. Providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines should assess the risk of dissemination of illegal content irrespective of whether or not the information is also incompatible with their terms and conditions. This assessment is without prejudice to the personal responsibility of the recipient of the service of very large online platforms or of the owners of websites indexed by very large online search engines for possible illegality of their activity under the applicable law.

    (81) A second category concerns the actual or foreseeable impact of the service on the exercise of fundamental rights, as protected by the Charter, including but not limited to human dignity, freedom of expression and of information, including media freedom and pluralism, the right to private life, data protection, the right to non-discrimination, the rights of the child and consumer protection. Such risks may arise, for example, in relation to the design of the algorithmic systems used by the very large online platform or by the very large online search engine or the misuse of their service through the submission of abusive notices or other methods for silencing speech or hampering competition. When assessing risks to the rights of the child, providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines should consider for example how easy it is for minors to understand the design and functioning of the service, as well as how minors can be exposed through their service to content that may impair minors’ health, physical, mental and moral development. Such risks may arise, for example, in relation to the design of online interfaces which intentionally or unintentionally exploit the weaknesses and inexperience of minors or which may cause addictive behaviour.

    (82) A third category of risks concerns the actual or foreseeable negative effects on democratic processes, civic discourse and electoral processes, as well as public security.

    (83) A fourth category of risks stems from similar concerns relating to the design, functioning or use, including through manipulation, of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines with an actual or foreseeable negative effect on the protection of public health, minors and serious negative consequences to a person’s physical and mental well-being, or on gender-based violence. Such risks may also stem from coordinated disinformation campaigns related to public health, or from online interface design that may stimulate behavioural addictions of recipients of the service.

    (84) When assessing such systemic risks, providers of very large online platforms and of very large online search engines should focus on the systems or other elements that may contribute to the risks, including all the algorithmic systems that may be relevant…

    This is very interesting. I would argue that under Article 81 and 84, for example, the blatant use of both algorithms limiting reach and plain blocking by Twitter and Facebook, to promote a pro-Israeli narrative and to limit pro-Palestinian content, was very plainly a breach of the EU Digital Services Directive by deliberate interference with “freedom of expression and information, including media freedom and pluralism”.

    The legislation is very plainly drafted with the specific intent of outlawing the use of algorithms to interfere with freedom of speech and public discourse in this way.

    But it is of course a great truth that the honesty and neutrality of prosecution services is much more important to what actually happens in any “justice” system than the actual provisions of legislation.

    Only a fool would be surprised that the EU Digital Services Act is being shoehorned into use against Durov, apparently for lack of cooperation with Western intelligence services and being a bit Russian, and is not being used against Musk or Zuckerberg for limiting the reach of pro-Palestinian content.

    It is also worth noting that Telegram is not considered to be a very large online platform by the EU Commission who have to date accepted Telegram’s contention that it has less than 45 million users in the EU, so these extra obligations do not apply

    If we look at the charges against Durov in France, I therefore cannot see how they are in fact compatible with the EU Digital Services Act.

    Unless he refused to remove or act over specific individual content specified by the French authorities, or unless he set up Telegram with the specific intent of facilitating organised crime, I do not see how Durov is not protected under Articles 20 and 30 and other safeguards found in the Digital Services Act.

    The French charges appear however to be extremely general and not to relate to particular specified communications. This is an abuse.

    What the Digital Services Act does not contain is a general obligation to hand over unspecified content or encryption keys to police forces or security agencies. It is also remarkably reticent on “misinformation”.

    Regulations 82 or 83 above obviously provide some basis for “misinformation” policing, but the Act in general relies on the rather welcome assertion that regulations governing what speech and discourse is legal should be the same offline as online.

    So in short, the arrest of Pavel Durov appears to be pretty blatant abuse and only very tenuously connected to the legal basis given as justification. This is simply a part of the current rising wave of authoritarianism in western “democracies” [end]

    The original article

    Craig Murray is an author, broadcaster and human rights activist. He was British Ambassador to Uzbekistan from August 2002 to October 2004 and Rector of the University of Dundee from 2007 to 2010

    related

    La Macronie matraque la liberté d’expression

    Pavel Durov a été arrếté au Bourget

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    en Anglais, chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

  • [Sharing] Germany’s far-left disrupter claims credit for limiting aid to Ukraine – Guy Chazan, Financial Times

    Sahra Wagenknecht’s party rises in polls ahead of regional elections in eastern German states

    Sahra Wagenknecht, Germany’s most prominent far-left politician, has taken credit for the government’s decision to limit military aid to Kyiv, saying her strong opposition to arming Ukraine was influencing Berlin’s policy on the war.

    In an interview with the Financial Times, Wagenknecht said the fact that the German government “has said it at least doesn’t want to continue to top up weapons deliveries” was “a result of our high opinion poll ratings”.

    Finance minister Christian Lindner last week warned fellow government members that he would veto any new payment requests for Kyiv.

    Chancellor Olaf Scholz on Tuesday denied that Berlin was giving up on Ukraine, saying Germany would donate €4bn in military aid to Kyiv next year, more than any other European country.

    But Wagenknecht was adamant about the impact her stance made.

    “We are already having an effect, even though we’re not even in power,” she said of her party, the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW). “Our approval ratings are affecting the national debate.”

    After splitting from the established far-left Die Linke party to form BSW seven months ago, Wagenknecht has emerged as the left’s disrupter-in-chief.

    Her rise in the polls inserts fresh instability into a political landscape challenged by the rise of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) — which also espouses Ukraine-sceptical, pro-Russian views.

    BSW has surged in the polls ahead of elections next month in three eastern German states that are expected to confirm the region’s drift to the political extremes and deliver a stinging rebuke to Scholz’s increasingly unpopular three-way coalition.

    A poll by Forsa on Tuesday put BSW on 13 per cent in Saxony and 18 per cent in Thuringia, both of which hold elections on September 1 — an extraordinary achievement for a party that is not even a year old. Scholz’s Social Democrats, by contrast, is at just 6 to 7 per cent in both states

    Squeezed on the left by the BSW and on the right by the AfD, mainstream parties face a major dilemma: should they entertain coalitions with an outfit whose opposition to military aid to Ukraine has placed it firmly outside the political consensus?

    The dilemma is most acute for the centre-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), which has been steadfast in its support for Kyiv since the very start of the war and has frequently castigated Scholz’s government for not doing enough to help the beleaguered country.

    But polls suggest the CDU will not be able to govern — in Thuringia at least — without the BSW as junior partner. Having ruled out co-operation with both the AfD and Die Linke, which at present leads a minority regional government, the CDU has few options left.

    “There’s no way this works without the BSW,” said Martin Debes, author of Germany of the Extremes, a political history of Thuringia.

    CDU leader Friedrich Merz initially banned any coalition with the BSW, describing Wagenknecht as “rightwing extremist on some issues, and on others, leftwing extreme”.

    But he later backpedalled, saying local branches of the CDU should decide on their own whether to team up with Wagenknecht’s party.

    “Essentially we have to figure out what is possible on the local level and what will lead to stable majorities,” Mario Voigt, CDU leader in Thuringia, told the FT. “But one thing is clear: there will be neither a coalition nor co-operation with the AfD.”

    A political contrarian who joined the East German Communist party just months before the fall of the Berlin Wall, Wagenknecht is revelling in her new status as kingmaker.

    She has set out a series of tough conditions for any coalition, saying she won’t team up with any party that supports Scholz’s plan to station US medium-range missiles in Germany from 2026.

    She also said the BSW would only join a government that explicitly backed diplomatic efforts to end the war in Ukraine

    CDU officials make the point that such issues are dealt with only by the federal government, not in regions such as Thuringia. Thuringia’s social democrat leader Georg Maier said: “She is just trying to blackmail all her potential coalition partners, especially the CDU.”

    But Wagenknecht herself said she was only reflecting voters’ wishes. “People in the east want a change in foreign policy — they are scared of being dragged into a major European war,” she told the FT.

    She also said that a majority of Germans living in the east rejected the US missile plan. Recent polling by Forsa shows that about two-thirds of respondents in eastern Germany are against the deployment, while at a national level, 49 per cent oppose it.

    A “key condition” for any regional government was that it “reflects and represents such positions, because otherwise voters will just be disappointed again”, she said.

    Though many in Berlin have bristled at Wagenknecht’s conditions, some in the east have echoed her rhetoric. Michael Kretschmer, the CDU prime minister of Saxony, has also spoken out forcefully against weapons supplies to Kyiv.

    In Thuringia, the CDU’s Voigt — while stressing his party’s commitment to supporting Ukraine — has backed the call for more diplomacy to end the war, urging the federal government to “do more in this regard”. “Germany was always a force for peace and a force for diplomacy, but little of that is happening at the moment,” he said.

    Wagenknecht said she found Voigt’s intervention “remarkable”. “We were always berated for taking this position, and now Voigt is demanding it, too.”

    But others are outraged by the BSW leader’s rhetoric. A recent petition signed by civil rights activists accused Wagenknecht and her party of spreading Kremlin disinformation and called on other parties to “distance themselves much more clearly from the BSW and its ideas about ‘national Socialism’.”

    The suggestion of a link to Nazism is a designation Wagenknecht firmly rejects. But her idiosyncratic platform does represent a curious mix of traditional leftwing ideas such as higher taxes on the rich with rightwing demands for curbs on immigration and sympathy for Russia.

    In her interview, she cemented her status as one of Germany’s leading Putinversteher (Putin apologists), a reputation underscored by her decision to boycott President Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s speech in the Bundestag in June.

    She criticised the Ukrainian offensive in Kursk, saying it would “harden” the positions of the warring parties, and said the war happened only because Russia “wouldn’t accept Ukraine turning into an American military outpost”.

    Wagenknecht said her party had succeeded in changing German politics for the better by peeling votes away from the AfD.

    “Before we existed, all the anger and protest benefited the AfD alone,” she said. “Now you see that when there’s a serious alternative, a lot of people will vote for it.” [end]

    The original article

    beware, that reflects the point of view of a prominent conservative, neoliberal, British outlet

    related

    Soviet Union crushed Nazi Germany

    79 years ago, Soviet Union achieved victory in Berlin. Adolf Hitler shot himself on April 30, 1945 ; the Red Army completed the cleansing of the Reichstag in the afternoon of May 1. The shoot of the banner raising was made in the morning of May 2

    Nazism in Ukraine

    its roots before WW2, its collaboration with Nazi Germany, its legacy in modern Ukraine, how NATO has continually supported Nazism in Ukraine

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Sharing] Once upon a time, during a surrender – RYBAR 28

    adventures in country-404

    Ukrainian soldiers do not always genuinely want to fight against the Russian Armed Forces. Many were simply mobilized (some against their will), trained and sent to the front lines, where command sends them into battle, whether they want to or not.

    Right on the front line, Ukrainian soldiers often find that the face of their enemy is more humane than that of their own commanders. Therefore, they often decide to surrender.

    The brutality of Ukrainian commanders, who send people on ‘meat assaults’ and set up blocking detachments for their subordinates, has long ceased to be a secret. However, not everyone will pursue their wounded soldier trying to surrender.


    ©️ RYBAR

    Related

    Related

    Five to One – RYBAR 83

    a reward shared by all

    Autumn near Bakhmut – RYBAR 82

    the balance between command and trust

    Ribbon on the Helmet – RYBAR 81

    how one symbol divided us and them

    The Grey Sky of Hostomel – RYBAR 80

    the way to our guys through fire and smoke

    Half a Meter from Death – RYBAR 79

    under the sights of an enemy drone

    We Don’t Abandon Our Own – RYBAR 78

    battle for Snake Island

    Easter Ceasefire – RYBAR 77

    silence regime or dangerous mercy

    The Road Back – RYBAR 76

    don’t give up your own and return home

    Survive Underground – RYBAR 75

    rescue at the risk of life

    Life on the Front Lines – RYBAR 74

    the moment that divides into before and after

    The Price of Life – RYBAR 73

    the only chance for survival

    Combat Cheburashka – RYBAR 72

    the story of a toy

    Call Sign Yan – RYBAR 71

    loyalty that cost a life

    Once upon a time between the lines – RYBAR 70

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Stepnohirsk – RYBAR 69

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Varvarovka – RYBAR 68

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Pokrovsk – RYBAR 67

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Kostyantynivka – RYBAR 66

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Cherkasy – RYBAR 65

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Aleksandro-Kalinovo – RYBAR 64

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Novohryhorivka – RYBAR 63

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Hnativka – RYBAR 62

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Mala Tokmachka – RYBAR 61

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the borderland – RYBAR 60

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Filiya – RYBAR 59

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Pavlohrad – RYBAR 58

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Crimea – RYBAR 57

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the Serebryanskyi forest – RYBAR 56

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time on the AFU’s positions – RYBAR 55

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Voronezh – RYBAR 54

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in a tank brigade – RYBAR 53

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in Toretsk – RYBAR 52

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Tykhe – RYBAR 51

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Skudne – RYBAR 50

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time near Staromayorske – RYBAR 49

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the basements – RYBAR 48

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the gray zone – RYBAR 47

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time in the flow – RYBAR 46

    adventures in country-404

    Once on the Platform – RYBAR 45

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, on the way home – RYBAR 44

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Ukrainsk – RYBAR 43

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in hard times – RYBAR 42

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, it couldn’t be otherwise – RYBAR 41

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Vesyoloye – RYBAR 40

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Trudovoe – RYBAR 39

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Kurakhove – RYBAR 38

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Vuhledar – RYBAR 37

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in captivity – RYBAR 36

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Poltava – RYBAR 35

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Krasnohorivka – RYBAR 34

    adventures in country-404

    [Sharing] Once upon a time, in Verkhnya Syrovatka – RYBAR 33

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Pervomais’ke – RYBAR 32

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, while fleeing from the 404 country – RYBAR 31

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, at sea – RYBAR 30

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, on that very street – RYBAR 29

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Artemivka – RYBAR 27

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Umanske – RYBAR 26

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Novoselivka Persha – RYBAR 25

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Ostroverkhivka – RYBAR 24

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Krasnohorivka – RYBAR 23

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, near Chasiv Yar – RYBAR 22

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Kharkiw – RYBAR 21

    adventures in country-404

    Once upon a time, in Spain – RYBAR 20

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on the election day – RYBAR 19

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Berdychi – RYBAR 18

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Kostyantynivka – RYBAR 17

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Oleshky – RYBAR 16

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on February 24 – RYBAR 15

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Bakhmut – RYBAR 14

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Robotyne – RYBAR 13

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Kreminna – RYBAR 12

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Lugansk – RYBAR 11

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Krynky – RYBAR 10

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Mar’inka – RYBAR 9

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Avdiivka – RYBAR 8

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Nova Kakhovka – RYBAR 7

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in the Azovets camp – RYBAR 6

    adventures in country -404

    Once upon a time, in Klishchiivka – RYBAR 5

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near the Russia-Ukraine border – RYBAR 4

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, near Novodarivka – RYBAR 3

    tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, on Independence Day in country 404 – RYBAR 2

    the tale of an unsuccessful counterattack

    Once upon a time, in Urozhaine – RYBAR 1

    A tale of a failed counter-attack

  • [Sharing] The Cost of Kursk – Ted Snider, The Libertarian Institute

    The bold and surprising incursion across the border into the Kursk region of Russia has won Ukraine the temporary possession of several Russian villages and a few hundred square miles of Russian territory. But the strategically cheap Russian land may have been bought at a very costly price. The Ukrainian armed forces managed a lightning advance through largely undefended territory. But that territory is defended now, and the advance seems already to have been slowed. And though it seems to have lost momentum well short of its goals, Ukraine may still have to pay the full price.

    Ukraine’s decision to take the war across the border may have been made out of the desperate realization that the war is lost. The Russian advance in Donbas is slow but inexorable. It moves forward at a horrible cost of Ukrainian lives, military equipment, and ammunition. It now threatens the city of Pokrovsk, a strategic location whose fall could cut off Ukraine’s ability to supply its forces in the east and facilitate Russia’s capture of Donbas.

    Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and his commander-in-chief, Oleksandr Syrsky, made the decision to take the best trained and best equipped troops the Ukrainian armed forces has and remove them from the Donbas front—where the real war is being fought and where they are being existentially missed—and send them into Kursk to win land that few in NATO think they have a hope of holding. What calculation makes sense of that strategic decision, unless Zelensky and Syrsky know that the end is near?

    Perhaps the calculation was that Ukraine’s best troops could be sent to the Donbas front to defend against the Russian invasion or they could be sent to Kursk to invade Russia. In the first case, they would inevitably fail to halt the overwhelming Russian advance; in the second case, they might change the facts on the ground. In either scenario, Ukraine’s best troops will be defeated and their Western equipment lost, but in the first they will be killed while achieving nothing but a short delay in defeat. In the second, they will be killed with the hope of assisting military and political objectives.

    The military objective may have been to create a crisis in Kursk that would force Russia to divert troops from Ukrainian territory to Russian territory and relieve the pressure on the Donbas front. The political objective may have been to seize Russian territory that could be bargained back in exchange for occupied Ukrainian territory and improve Ukraine’s position at a negotiating table at which Ukraine now realizes it has to take a seat, since there is no longer a hope that their political objectives can be won militarily.

    Though Ukraine considered several options for some time, the risky decision may have been catalyzed, not only by national desperation, but also by personal desperation by Ukraine’s commander-in-chief. Sources familiar with the decision-making by Syrsky told The Economist that the general “was under pressure.” Russia was irreversibly on the offensive, Ukraine was running out of weapons and, even more seriously, out of people. Avdiivka had fallen, the Russian front was advancing, the Ukrainian front was crumbling and the pivotal hub of Pokrovsk was in danger. He was even hearing rumours that he “was on the verge of being dismissed.”

    So Syrsky secretly set his plan. Ukraine would invade Russia at a place that was little defended because it was of little value. Russia would not expect it. Highly trained and well equipped and supported Ukrainian troops would advance quickly, seize territory, and perhaps even capture the Kursk nuclear power plant. Russia would be forced to divert troops from Ukraine, relieving the desperate situation in Donbas, and Ukraine would hold a better hand at the negotiating table. Russia would have to negotiate land to secure the return of their land and, especially, of a nuclear plant that would be hazardous to win back militarily.

    But the advance ran out of momentum well short of the nuclear plant. Russia has moved in defenses without moving significant forces out of Ukraine, and Ukraine is now losing troops and equipment in Russia the way it is in Ukraine. Exposed troops, tanks, mobile air defense missile launchers and supply lines have come under massive air strikes.

    If the Ukrainian offensive fails, the spectacular ephemeral gains will have come at a great cost. Costs could include more rapid and painful losses in Donbas, loss of the opportunity to negotiate an end to the war, and loss of trust when those negotiations are forced upon Ukraine.

    The most immediate cost of diverting elite troops and Western equipment from Donbas to Kursk is the further deterioration and weakening of Ukraine’s defences along the Donbas front. Russia’s military is taking advantage of that costly decision. Though Ukraine had counted on the invasion pulling Russian troops out of Donbas, so far, that does not seem to have happened. The Ukrainian armed forces say that the “relatively small” number of Russian forces that have been drawn out of Ukraine is “not…enough to indicate any differences or weakening in…hostilities.”

    Russian President Vladimir Putin says both that, far from relieving pressure on the Donbas front, “on the contrary,” Russian offensive operations will increase and that, far from expediting negotiations, the incursion into Russia has made negotiations less likely.

    Both claims appear to be true. The Ukrainian General Staff reports that the number of Russian assaults in the area of Pokrovsk have roughly doubled since the Kursk offensive and that they are increasing every day. On August 19, as Russian forces advanced to within six miles of Pokrovsk, Ukraine ordered the evacuation of families with children.

    As for negotiations, there is not only the possibility that the Ukrainian offensive could derail future negotiations but the actuality that it already has. The Washington Post reports that Russia and Ukraine had both “signaled their readiness to accept the arrangement in [a] lead-up to the summit” in Qatar that would have seen both sides agree to cease strikes on the other’s energy and power infrastructure. The negotiations would have been the first since the peace talks and grain deal in Istanbul in the first months of the war. There were “just minor details left to be worked out” when the Qatar talks “were derailed by Ukraine’s surprise incursion into Russia’s western Kursk region.” Russia has not completely killed the talks but has put them on pause.

    Russian strikes on Ukraine’s energy infrastructure have reduced Ukraine’s power by 50%. One Ukrainian official said that Ukraine has “one chance to get through this winter, and that’s if the Russians won’t launch any new attacks on the grid.” A very cold winter could be an additional painful cost of the Kursk offensive.

    And, as if trust could be hurt any further, a final cost of the Kursk offensive could be the continued erosion of trust. Russia was already distrustful of talks of peace since the recent revelations that Germany, France, and Ukraine were just using the 2014-2015 Minsk process to lull Russia into a ceasefire with the promise of a peace settlement in order to buy time for the Ukrainian armed forces to build up for a military solution. That distrust has now been fed by the Kursk offensive. Recent statements by Zelensky about the preparedness of Ukraine to negotiate, and even to negotiate territory, may be seen by Russia, rightly or wrongly, as once again anesthetizing Russia with promises of peace while preparing for war. As The New York Times reports, “Even as Ukraine was signaling its readiness to talk, its military was preparing for one of its most daring attacks since Mr. Putin’s invasion began in February 2022.” The Times suggests that “[t]he flurry of Ukrainian talk about peace may have served in part as strategic deception, encouraging Russia’s leadership to see meekness and let down its guard.”

    Barring a sudden reversal and a spectacular success, the Kursk offensive brings the risk of ephemeral gain at enormous cost. Those costs might include accelerated defeat in Donbas, a reduced likelihood of future negotiations, a lost opportunity for current negotiations, a very cold winter for Ukraine, and further loss of trust that erodes the chance for peace [end]

    The original article

    related

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    Kursk in the new Bulge, same ills, same blunder