Nicolas Cinquini

Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu

Tag: switzerland

  • [Partage] Lyon – Fascistes et néonazis érigent Quentin Deranque en martyr – Ricardo Parreira, Stup.media

    Mensonges, coups de communication, complaisance médiatique, fascisation du débat public : la mort de Quentin Deranque a servi de catalyseur à l’ensemble de l’échiquier politique, du centre à l’extrême droite, pour en faire un puissant instrument de récupération politique. Ce climat a permis à des groupes néonazis et fascistes d’organiser des hommages publics saturés de références idéologiques explicites au nazisme, sans susciter la moindre réaction politique

    Quentin Deranque était un militant actif au sein de plusieurs groupes d’extrême droite radicale. Après avoir créé un groupuscule local, Allobroges Bourgoin, il participe en 2025 à la marche néonazie organisée à Paris par le Comité du 9 mai. Il a également milité au sein de Action française, organisation monarchiste, nationaliste, considérée comme la plus ancienne formation antisémite active en France. Le 12 février 2026, à Lyon, Quentin Deranque accepte de participer à un service d’ordre mis en place par des militantes du collectif d’extrême droite fémonationaliste Némésis. À l’issue d’un affrontement impliquant plusieurs membres du service d’ordre de Némésis (dont certains étaient armés) et un groupe d’antifascistes, il est grièvement blessé. Il décède deux jours plus tard des suites de ses blessures

    Le 14 février le procureur de la République de Lyon communique à la presse qu’une enquête judiciaire est ouverte pour homicide volontaire et quelques jours plus tard, sept personnes ont été mises en examen, soupçonnées d’avoir participé au tabassage. Parmi elles se trouve un assistant du député de LFI Raphaël Arnault, Jacques-Élie Favrot.

    Dans les premiers jours de cette affaire, on a assisté à un déferlement de haine de la part de l’extrême droite, ainsi qu’à de multiples mensonges sur le déroulement des faits. Les « antifascistes » sont accusés par M Fabien Rajon, avocat de la famille de Quentin Deranque de lui avoir tendu un « guet-apens », pour le tuer. D’autres acteurs d’extrême droite ont évoqué l’existence de « coups de couteau », en s’appuyant sur une source présentée comme proche de l’enquête, dont l’identité n’a jamais été établie. Ils ont également avancé des affirmations faisant état de « militants antifa surarmés », ainsi que de la présence, lors du tabassage, d’une militante lyonnaise, Blandine B., ancienne membre de la Jeune Garde. Rien de tout cela n’était vrai : pas de « guet-apens », pas de « coups de couteau », pas de « militants antifa surarmés », et Blandine B. se trouvait à l’étranger au moment des faits. Une plainte pour diffamation, visant notamment l’influenceur d’extrême droite Damien Rieu a été déposée.

    Cinq jours plus tard, le 17 février, une vidéo a été révélée par Le Canard Enchaîné, démontre qu’il y a eu bel et bien une rixe entre militants fascistes et antifascistes. Cela n’a pourtant pas épargné, spécialement La France Insoumise, d’être ciblée avec une virulence sans précédent : menaces de mort, menaces à la bombe et menaces de viol visant certaines femmes du mouvement, seulement en quelques jours. Du gouvernement aux Les Républicains, jusqu’au Rassemblement National, tous ont saisi l’opportunité pour déboulonner leur principal opposant politique.

    Une extrême droite armée

    Pendant quelques jours, les médias classés à gauche tentent, d’un côté, de sortir du récit imposé par l’extrême droite et, de l’autre, de replacer l’affaire dans une dynamique de violences d’extrême droite propres à Lyon. Le manque de spécialistes de l’extrême droite s’est largement fait ressentir sur les plateaux télévisés, même si quelques chiffres, après avoir été martelés en continu, ont finalement été repris par BFM TV, TF1 et LCI.

    Il y a eu 57 morts liées à des violences entre groupes politiques de 1986 à 2017 – 52 du fait de la droite radicale et cinq du fait de la gauche radicale

    explique Isabelle Sommier au Monde

    Le jeudi 19 février, lors de la conférence de presse du procureur de la République de Lyon, un journaliste lui a demandé s’il comptait également « poursuivre les militants d’extrême droite » qui, à la suite de l’affrontement du 12 février, auraient blessé plusieurs personnes antifascistes. « Les juges d’instruction sont saisis de l’ensemble des faits », a répondu Thierry Dran. Les militants d’extrême droite pourraient donc être poursuivis, notamment pour association de malfaiteurs et violences aggravées.

    De militant à martyr

    Le 21 février 2026, une marche en hommage à Quentin Deranque a rassemblé environ 3 200 personnes selon la préfecture, dans les rues de Lyon. Un événement d’ampleur, marqué par la présence de groupes venus de toute la France, mais aussi de l’international : Allemagne, Suisse et Italie. À l’instar de l’extrême droite parlementaire, les groupuscules radicaux n’ont pas manqué l’occasion de participer à cette manifestation afin de rendre hommage à leur martyr, mais aussi bien plus stratégique, d’en faire un outil de propagande et de recrutement. Les membres du collectif Némésis étaient en première ligne, accompagnés par Aliette Espieux, organisatrice de la marche.

    À chaque fois qu’un « Français blanc » est tué par une personne française non blanche, elle tente d’en faire un martyr, comme ce fut le cas pour Thomas, Lola, Philippine ou Kylian. Mais malheureusement, pour l’extrême droite radicale, ces jeunes n’étaient ni des nationalistes, encore moins des fascistes. C’est pourquoi, cette fois-ci deux récits s’affrontent. D’un côté, celui de l’avocat de la famille Deranque, qui cherche à imposer l’image d’un jeune homme pacifique et religieux. De l’autre, celui des mouvances radicales, qui exposent dans les réseaux sociaux l’ensemble des engagements politiques de Quentin Deranque

    Avant même que le procureur n’annonce officiellement son décès, le samedi 14 février à midi, la veille déjà, la grande majorité des groupuscules fascistes et néonazis avaient érigé Quentin Deranque en martyr, faisant de lui un « héros tombé au combat ». Le groupuscule Luminis Paris, dans un post sur X, écrivait : « Comme lui, la lutte à mort nous rend joyeux ».

    Encore un détail crypto-fasciste : comme le relevait sur Bluesky l’historien Pierre-Louis Landureau, lors des hommages entre le 13 et le 21 février, plusieurs banderoles avec la mention « Quentin présent » étaient déployées dans différentes villes de l’Hexagone. Ce type d’hommage fait référence à des rituels fascistes, d’abord dans l’Italie de Benito Mussolini dans les « Sanctuaires des martyrs », puis repris plus tard par les nazis pour glorifier leurs martyrs tombés pour la « Fatherland ».

    Étaient également présents dans la marche des militants de Les Nationalistes, un groupuscule pétainiste et antisémite, avec en tête de cortège Yvan Benedetti et Alexandre Gabriac. Dans le cortège figurait également Renaud Mannheim, chanteur du groupe néonazi Match Retour. Le néonazi Marc de Cacqueray-Valménier, récemment condamné à de la prison ferme et employé par le groupe Bolloré, a, comme lors de la marche du Comité du 9 mai en 2025, assuré le service d’ordre et participé à l’organisation de la manifestation. Enfin, le pur jus du racisme et de l’antisémitisme que la société française ait pu produire

    STUP a pu confirmer la présence de plusieurs militants issus d’au moins une vingtaine de groupuscules d’extrême droite radicale, à affiliation fasciste ou néonazie : La Ligue du Midi, Parti de la France, Aurora Lorraine, Audace Lyon, Luminis Paris, Bloc Montpelliérain, Patria Albiges, La Cocarde Étudiante, Tenesoun, Clermont Non Conforme, Mouvement Chouan, An Tour-Tan, entre autres.

    Du côté du Rassemblement national, c’est Vincent Claudin, collaborateur parlementaire de la députée RN de la 2ᵉ circonscription de la Drôme, Lisette Pollet, et proche de Quentin Deranque, qui pose sur place face aux caméras du média d’extrême droite Ligne Droite. Vincent Claudin était auparavant militant au sein du groupe violent d’extrême droite Lyon Populaire, créé après la dissolution du Bastion social. Lyon Populaire a été dissous en mai 2025 pour « agissements violents contre les personnes, provocations bien souvent suivies d’effets », ainsi que pour « l’apologie de la collaboration avec le nazisme et la provocation à la haine, à la violence et à la discrimination envers les étrangers ». Sans oublier la présence de Eliot Bertin, responsable de l’attaque d’une conférence sur la Palestine à la Maison des Passages, actuellement sous contrôle judiciaire avec interdiction de manifester.

    La haine et le symbole vont de pair

    Malgré les efforts de l’organisation de la marche pour empêcher l’exhibition de symboles fascistes et néonazis sur place et des consignes ayant été envoyées en amont à l’ensemble des groupes appelés à participer, demandant explicitement aux militants de ne pas arborer de « tatouages ou symboles distinctifs » et « de ne pas dissimuler leurs visages », STUP a pu identifier de nombreux symboles fascistes, catholiques intégristes et néonazis au sein du cortège.

    Comme lors de la marche du C9M à Paris, plusieurs militants ont utilisé des cache-cou de la marque fasciste Reliqua, des drapeaux cathos intégristes, des vêtements de Helly Hansen — marque régulièrement détournée dans les milieux néonazis en référence aux initiales « HH pour Heil Hitler » — ainsi que des marques explicitement néonazies telles que European Brotherhood et Svastone. Dans les rangs figuraient également plusieurs militants des Hammerskins, arborant des tatouages représentant le chiffre 28 (référence à Blood & Honour, devise des Jeunesses hitlériennes) ainsi que l’Irminsul, symbole associé à l’Ahnenerbe, institution nazie

    Même si le service d’ordre a à plusieurs reprises insisté sur la « propreté » devant les caméras, que ce soit lors des prises de parole avant la marche ou pendant le parcours, plusieurs personnes ont effectué sans ambiguïté des saluts hitlériens. STUP a pu repérer plusieurs militants faisant ce geste

    Au long de la marche, on a pu entendre des insultes racistes et, à l’approche de la rue Victor-Lagrange, le slogan « On est chez nous ». Ce slogan s’inscrit dans une tradition antisémite dont les origines remontent à Édouard Drumont, figure emblématique de l’antisémitisme français de la fin du XIXᵉ siècle, qui fut l’un des premiers à employer cette rhétorique dès 1889, dans un contexte de forte hostilité envers les Juifs. Au cours du XXᵉ siècle, ce slogan raciste a trouvé de nouvelles expressions, notamment à travers le théoricien de l’Action française, Charles Maurras, qui reprend cette rhétorique en 1894, à l’époque où la France se déchirait dans l’affaire Dreyfus. Il emploie alors l’expression « maîtres chez nous », affirmant que la France serait, selon lui, aux mains des Juifs.

    Arrivés au 11 de la rue Victor-Lagrange, lieu du passage à tabac de Quentin Deranque, des rites aux allures fascistes débutent. Deux banderoles sont déployées : « Justice pour Quentin » et « Adieu camarade ». Sur cette dernière figure un chrisme, symbole christiano-romain régulièrement adopté par l’extrême droite lors de ses actions islamophobes et racistes. Ce symbole est également présent sur l’oriflamme du Chœur Montjoie Saint-Denis, dont l’un des chants, la Ligue noire — qui commémore le massacre des contre-révolutionnaires lyonnais de 1793 par la Convention, entonné tandis que des torches sont allumées pour Quentin D. À noter que le Chœur Montjoie Saint-Denis est une chorale proche de l’extrême droite française et des milieux catholiques traditionalistes. De plus, puisque rien n’est laissé au hasard, la calligraphie utilisée pour écrire « Adieu camarade » est celle du canal néonazi OuestCasual, encore un dog whistling destiné aux militants néonazis

    Le 21 février, dans une communication adressée à la presse, Grégory Doucet, maire de Lyon, a déclaré vouloir « collaborer » avec les autorités afin que chaque auteur de saluts nazis soit « traduit en justice ». Mais la réalité pourrait s’avérer tout autre. Le lendemain de la manifestation du Comité du 9 mai à Paris en 2025, Bruno Retailleau avait lui aussi annoncé avoir saisi la justice après la manifestation néonazi du « C9M », pour des faits similaires. À ce jour, aucune suite judiciaire n’a été rendue publique concernant ce dossier.  Pendant que le discours politique s’acharne à stigmatiser l’antifascisme, les groupes néonazis, enhardis, ne se cachent plus, ils occupent l’espace public en pleine lumière sans entrave.

    FAITS COMPLÉMENTAIRES

    Le climat de tension lors de la marche s’est traduit par des entraves systématiques au travail des journalistes. Plusieurs confrères ont rapporté avoir subi des pressions physiques de la part du service d’ordre : invectives, bousculades et usage coordonné de parapluies pour masquer les objectifs et empêcher toute documentation visuelle.

    Alors qu’il couvrait l’événement, notre journaliste Ricardo Parreira a été formellement identifié par deux militants du Bloc Montpelliérain. L’information a circulé immédiatement au sein du service d’ordre, alors dirigé par Marc de Cacqueray-Valménier. Suivi et surveillé de près par plusieurs individus durant le cortège, notre reporter a dû, pour sa propre sécurité, interrompre sa mission avant la fin du rassemblement.

    La rédaction condamne fermement ces méthodes de harcèlement et toute forme de menace visant à entraver le travail d’information de nos journalistes [fin]

    L’article original

    Article connexes

    22 février 2026 : Dans les conversations secrètes entre Némésis et des néonazis pour agresser des militants de gauche à Lyon – Thomas Lemahieu, l’Humanité

    22 février 2026 : Des nazis allemands rendent hommage à Quentin Deranque

    beau et raccord, puisque les droitardés pinzuti sont des pétainistes ataviques, sinon congénitaux

    20 février 2026 : À Lyon, 102 agressions fascistes recensées depuis 2010, dans une impunité presque totale – Contre Attaque

    Le contexte : dans la métropole lyonnaise, un climat de terreur et de violence entretenu par l’extrême droite depuis 15 ans

    17 février 2026 : Mort de Quentin Deranque : qui sont les Allobroges Bourgoin, son groupuscule néofasciste – Daphné Deschamps, StreetPress

    Quentin Deranque, militant d’extrême droite, est mort le 14 février à Lyon après une rixe avec des antifascistes. Très bien implanté dans la mouvance, il était l’un des fondateurs du groupuscule berjallien Allobroges Bourgoin

    16 février 2026 : Drame politique au pays des pinzuti

    la mort de Quentin Deranque, petit ange parti trop tôt

    15 novembre 2025 : « Gardez votre confiance en la France éternelle »

    deux jours après le 10e anniversaire de la débâcle politique et sécuritaire du 13 novembre 2015, une messe célèbre à Verdun l’ancien dirigeant fasciste de l’État français

    23 mars 2025 : Contre le racisme

    pertinente mais incomplète affiche de la CGT, pour une journée de manifestations à travers la France, contre racisme et xénophobie

    7 janvier 2025 : Le Pen est mort, vive Le Pen

    né en 1928, le militant pétainiste breton Jean-Marie Le Pen est décédé le 7 janvier 2025 dans les grand-bourgeois Hauts de Seine

    26 novembre 2023 : Romans-sur-Isère : les médias au secours des néo-nazis – Contre Attaque

    pour France Info et BFM, poursuivre des arabes et des noirs dans la rue pour les tabasser est un acte militant

    12 novembre 2023 : Mais que fait la police ?

    30 mai 2023 : Fils de Pétain

    la vanité nationale trouble la perception de la réalité historique et perpétue une névrose collective

    22 juillet 2022 : Loïk Frédéric Marie le Priol

  • [Sharing] The Flamingo Effect – Scott Ritter

    Ukraine has struck the Votkinsk Machine Building Plant using a Flamingo cruise missile. The ramifications of this event could reverberate globally

    On the night of February 20-21, 2026, Ukraine launched an intermediate-range missile at the Votkinsk Machine Building Plant, a strategic defense industrial facility located in the Republic of Udmurtia, some 1,300 kilometers from the Russian-Ukrainian border. The missile, equipped with a 1,000-kilogram warhead, struck a building housing Workshop 19, which houses a critical electroplating and stamping workshop. It is here that Russian technicians carry out the metal stamping and forming processes related to the manufacture of missile body elements, as well as the galvanic processing of parts, including the application of protective and functional coatings and surface preparation for further assembly. Workshop 19 plays a critical role in the manufacture of some of Russia’s most strategically vital ballistic missiles. The Flamingo’s warhead blasted a 30-by-24-meterhole in the roof of the structure, setting its interior on fire. At least 11 workers were wounded in the attack.

    It is not known the extent to which the attack on Workshop 19 has impacted Russia’s ability to produce strategically important missiles such as the Topol-M and Yars intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs), the Bulava submarine-launched ballistic missile. The Iskander and Oreshnik missiles are manufactured at the Votkinsk plant, as well as research and development on follow-on strategic delivery systems like the Kedr ICBM.

    What is known is that the Ukrainian’s have struck at the very heart of Russia’s strategic defense industry, delivering a blow which is not just politically damaging in terms of the image it creates regarding the status of Russia’s war with Ukraine, which is entering its 5th year, but also potentially crippling Russia’s ability to keep pace with any increase in strategic nuclear delivery systems now that the last remaining arms control treaty between the US and Russia—New START—has expired

    Russian President Putin meets with the Russian Security Council to discuss an draft agreement of strategic stability in Europe

    Russia has long been alerted to this very possibility. Back in December 2021, Russia sent a clear signal to both the United States and NATO that it viewed the stationing of intermediate- or short-range missiles on the territory of Ukraine was a red line which, if crossed, presented an unacceptable threat to the security of Russia. In draft treaties addressed to both parties, Russia defined one of the bedrock conditions needed to be met for stability in Europe. Article 6 of the US treaty stated that “The Parties shall undertake not to deploy ground-launched intermediate-range and shorter-range missiles outside their national territories, as well as in the areas of their national territories, from which such weapons can attack targets in the national territory of the other Party.” Article 5 of the draft NATO treaty likewise stated that “The Parties shall not deploy land-based intermediate- and short-range missiles in areas allowing them to reach the territory of the other Parties.”

    In the weeks prior to the Russian initiation of the Special Military Operation, the Russians went out of their way to communicate to the Biden administration the seriousness to which they attached this issue. Senior Biden administration officials acknowledge that Russian President Vladimir Putin had specifically accused the United States of seeking to place missiles inside Ukraine, something the Biden administration assured Russia it had no intention of doing. While the US declared that it was open to “discussing the future of certain missile systems in Europe, along the lines of the INF treaty, which Russia violated and the previous U.S. administration withdrew from,” little movement in that direction took place when US Deputy Secretary of State Wendy Sherman and Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov met for more than seven hours in Geneva, Switzerland on January 10, 2022. The two sides talked cross purposes, with Russia looking for a concrete response to its December draft treaties, and the US indicating there could be no agreement without additional consultation with allies, including Ukraine

    US Secretary of State Tony Blinken shakes hands with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, January 21, 2022

    A follow-on meeting between US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov held on January 21 produced no results, other than a pledge by the United States to provide a written response to the Russian draft treaties “soon.” On January 26, the US and NATO did just that, rejecting outright Russia’s conditions for European stability and security, including a rejection of Russia’s concerns about the stationing of intermediate- and short-range missiles on Ukrainian soil. A follow-on meeting between Sergei Ryabkov and US Assistant Secretary of State Rose Gottemoeller in Berlin on February 9 yielded no results.

    Since the SMO began, Russia has made it clear that the provision of long-range strike capability to Ukraine by the US and NATO represented a serious threat to Russian national security. The use by Ukraine of British-made Storm Shadow missiles and their French analog, the SCALP, together with US-provided ATACMS missiles, were permitted by the providing nations only on the conditions that these weapons not be used to strike targets inside the boundaries of the Russian Federation as recognized in 1991. Russian threats about holding Germany accountable helped convince the German government not to provide the Taurus cruise missile to Ukraine (the Storm Shadow/SCALP missiles possess a range of 250 kilometers, while the ATACMS possesses a range of up to 300 kilometers; the Taurus, with a range of up to 500 kilometers, would have represented a major upgrade to Ukraine’s ability to strike targets inside Russia).

    In September 2024 the US and UK governments were actively considering authorizing Ukraine to use Storm Shadow and ATACMS missiles to strike targets inside Russia proper. Russian President Vladimir Putin warned that if Western countries authorize Ukraine’s use of long-range missiles in Russian territory, they will become directly involved in the war. “It will mean nothing less than the direct involvement of NATO countries, the United States and European countries in the war in Ukraine,” Putin said. “This will be their direct participation, and this, of course, will significantly change the very essence, the very nature of the conflict.” Based on such threats, Putin warned, Russia would be forced to take “appropriate actions.” Putin’s threats came at a time when Russia had issued a new nuclear doctrine which allowed Russia to use nuclear weapons in retaliation for the very kind of attacks the US and UK were considering

    Rear Admiral Thomas Buchanan addresses CSIS, November 2024

    The danger of nuclear conflict was very high. In November, the head of plans for Strategic Command, Rear Admiral Thomas Buchanan, told a Washington, DC think-tank that the Biden administration was ready to fight and win a nuclear exchange with Russia, and in early December 2024 the CIA, responding to an announcement by the administration that it would greenlight the use by Ukraine of ATACMS missiles to strike targets inside Russia, briefed members of Congress that there was a greater than 50% chance there would be a nuclear war between Russia and the US before years end.

    While President-elect Trump helped lower tensions by pledging that he would reverse the Biden administration’s decision once he came into office (something he did, in fact, do), his inability to follow through on his pledge to bring a rapid end to the Russian-Ukraine conflict led to increasing frustration and resentment toward Russia and its leadership, prompting President Trump to announce that he was considering providing Ukraine with the Tomahawk cruise missile—the very weapons system Russia had declared would never be permitted to be stationed on Ukrainian soil.

    The threats to provide Ukraine with Tomahawk missiles were more of a negotiating ploy than real threat, however. The real threat came from elsewhere—a missile designed by the British using indigenous Ukrainian parts and manufacturing infrastructure known as the FP-5 Flamingo.

    The Flamingo made its debut at the international defense industry exhibition IDEX-2025, which took place from February 17 to 21, 2025 in Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates, when the Emirati-British Milanion Defense Industry Group unveiled a prototype missile. Built around the Ivchenko AI-25 turbo-fan jet engine, which had been developed in the 1950s by the Ivchenko Design Bureau in the Soviet Union, and produced at the Motor Sich aircraft factory in Zaparozhia, the Flamingo was a derivative of the Soviet-era Tu-141and Tu-143 reconnaissance drones, which had been repurposed by Ukraine into ground-attack cruise missiles. The warhead appeared to be based upon Ukrainian gravity bombs. The goal behind the Milanion design was to provide Ukraine with an affordable indigenous long-range strike capability which bypassed the Russian restrictions on foreign weapons

    The Milanion-designed FP-5 Flamingo

    This subterfuge, however, is shallow. Fire Point, the company which oversees the manufacture of the FP-5 Flamingo, is little more than a shell company overseen by a CEO, Iryna Terekh, who has zero education or experience which would lend itself to missile production. The task of coordinating Ukrainian defense manufacturing with foreign suppliers is well above her paygrade. The FP-5 Flamingo is exactly what it portends to be—a British-made weapon designed to get around the legalities, and consequences, of Russian red lines regarding the use of long-range missiles based in Ukraine against Russia targets.

    Moreover, Russian military strikes have severely disrupted Ukraine’s ability to assemble the FP-5 on Ukrainian soil—the near complete destruction of the Motor Sich factory earlier this year stands as a harsh example. Fire Point has opened a Flamingo production facility in Denmark, near Skrydstrup Air Base and the town of Vojens in Southern Jutland, that will produce solid rocket propellant used to boost the FP-5 into flight during ground operations. The Danish defense minister, when asked whether establishing Ukrainian arms production in Denmark would make the country a target for Russian attacks, noted that Denmark was not at war and that an open Russian attack on Denmark would constitute an attack on a NATO country.

    No mention was made about the role Denmark was playing in helping Ukraine produce a missile which has now been used to strike one of the most important strategic missile production facilities in Russia—the Votkinsk Machine Building Plant

    Sergei Karaganov (right) with Russian President Vladimir Putin (left)

    Sergei Karaganov, the head of Russia’s Council for Foreign and Defense Policy, has been warning about the use of Ukraine as a dagger to wound Russia on behalf of the collective West, writing in mid-June 2023 that Russia needed to lower the threshold for use of nuclear weapons to break Western support for Ukraine. If the West did not back down, Karaganov stated, then “we will have to hit [with nuclear weapons] a group of targets in a number of countries,” adding that if Russia failed to do this, “not only may Russia perish, but most likely the whole of human civilization will end.”

    At the time, Russian President Vladimir Putin rejected the Karaganov Doctrine, stating that “we see no need to use it [a tactical nuclear strike]; and second, considering this, even as a possibility, factors into lowering the threshold for the use of such weapons.”

    Such “factors” included the use by Russia of the Oreshnik intermediate range ballistic missile twice against targets inside Ukraine—both times to send a signal to Ukraine and its supporters in the West about the dangers inherent in any escalation of the conflict.

    But much has transpired since President Putin downplayed the rhetoric of Karaganov—the nuclear war scare of September-December 2024, and the US threat to provide Ukraine with Tomahawks stand out as examples.

    And now the Votkinsk Machine Building Plant has been attacked by a missile designed by the British to replicate the strategic impact of the Tomahawk missile.

    Votkinsk is the heart and soul of Russia’s strategic defense industry.

    And now it has been attacked by a British-designed weapon using intelligence provided by the CIA.

    This attack is as close to an act of war by both the United States and the United Kingdom as one can imagine.

    Suddenly Karaganov’s June 2023 nuclear posturing doesn’t seem so far-fetched.

    Russia is at a crossroads.

    In the short term, Russia needs to find a solution to the Flamingo threat to Votkinsk and other strategic defense industries located in the Ural regions that are now under threat of attack (a solid rocket motor production facility in Perm, for example.) Given the role played by Europe in designing, funding, and manufacturing the Flamingo, a response limited to striking targets inside Ukraine would achieve no fundamental change.

    Missiles would still be built, and these missiles would continue to be launched at strategic targets deep inside Russia.

    If Europe is not deterred once and for all from delivering this kind of military assistance to Ukraine, then Russia will be at risk of dying a death by a thousand cuts.

    But then there is the larger issue of what to do with Ukraine itself. Russia is currently engaged in a drawn out “peace” negotiation with Ukraine, overseen by the United States, which has now been exposed—thanks to the attack on Votkinsk—as little more than a cover for Ukraine to develop the military capacity to strike Russia’s strategic interior in an effort to pressure Russia into ending the conflict on terms less than those previously set forth by President Putin.

    If the Russian-Ukrainian conflict ends on such terms, then Russia will have conceded the very thing it said was a red line back in December 2021—the deployment of NATO-affiliated intermediate-range missiles on the soil of Ukraine.

    It will represent a strategic defeat for Russia in every sense of the term

    Kiril Dmitriev (left) with Steve Witkoff (right)

    It is well past time for Russia to stop participating in such a self-defeating exercise. The United States is not a trustworthy negotiating partner in this regard—the attempted assassination of President Putin on December 29, 2025, by 91 Ukrainian drones guided to their target by CIA intelligence should underscore this reality. The continued use by President Trump of sanctions designed to cripple the Russian economy should be viewed not in the light of “business as usual”, but rather from the perspective of its current author, Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent, who envisions such sanctions as “bringing Russia to its knees”, a literal overt act of surrender. And the 7-point economic plan being promulgated by Kiril Dmitriev at the behest of Steve Witkoff is nothing more than a re-working of the economic domination plans of the US employed in the 1990’s and attempted to foist on Russia during the regime change-disguised-as-reset policies promoted under the Obama administration.

    The Trump administration is not looking for a mutually beneficial peace with Russia, but rather to achieve a strategic victory over Russia, just like the Biden administration before.

    If this wasn’t clear before the Flamingo attack on Votkinsk, there is no excuse for it not being painfully so now.

    Simply put, the Votkinsk attack underscores the reality that Ukraine as it is currently configured cannot be allowed to exist once the conflict is ended. As former Russian President Dmitri Medvedev has pointed out, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is a “green bug” that needs to be “swatted.”

    The same holds for the totality of the existing Ukrainian government. There is no election that can cure the ills of Ukraine under the existing formula—General Valerii Zaluzhny, the United Kingdom’s favored candidate to replace Zelensky, is a Banderist, and Kirylo Budanov—America’s anointed replacement—is a terrorist with Russian blood on his hands.

    If Ukraine survives intact, so, too, does the FP-5 Flamingo missile program, meaning Russia will never again go to sleep at night without the fear of a Ukrainian attack.

    The FP-5 Flamingo must be eradicated in totality.

    And to do that, Ukraine in its current configuration must likewise be eradicated.

    This is the very definition of an existential issue for Russia.

    One that demands an adequate response to Europe as well.

    Anything less will be interpreted as nothing less than a Russian surrender [end]

    The original article

    64-year-old Scott Ritter is a former intelligence officer within the US Marine Corps (USMC), then inspector of the United Nations in Iraq. When in 2003, the US and their British minions were about to invade the country under this false pretext, Ritter was claiming that there was no weapon of mass destruction (WMD) there. He was right.

    Related

    January 9, 2026: Sanctionnez-Moi, Sale Garce! – Scott Ritter, Forum Geopolitica

    In the Jacques Baud case, the EU is sanctioning, for the first time, an analyst not for spreading disinformation but for expressing a politically inconvenient truth, all while admitting he has broken no law. Will it have the courage to go after an American citizen?

    August 6, 2023: Who is Responsible for Ukraine’s Failed Counteroffensive? – Scott Ritter, Sputnik

    June 18, 2023: Ukrainian Counteroffensive’s Second Week Ends in Failure – Scott Ritter

    Operation enters the second week of Ukraine’s long-awaited and highly touted counteroffensive, some basic conclusions can be drawn even though the fighting continues, and will continue to rage, for some time to come

    June 10, 2023: Finally the Bull Charged – Scott Ritter

    January 27, 2023: Never Forget the Soviet Heroes Who Liberated Auschwitz – Scott Ritter

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Sharing] Sanctionnez-Moi, Sale Garce! – Scott Ritter, Forum Geopolitica

    In the Jacques Baud case, the EU is sanctioning, for the first time, an analyst not for spreading disinformation but for expressing a politically inconvenient truth, all while admitting he has broken no law. Will it have the courage to go after an American citizen?

    The European Union has sanctioned the veteran Swiss Intelligence Officer and Geopolitical analysts, 70-year-old Colonel Jacques Baud.

    His crime?

    He is a “regular guest on pro-Russian television and radio programs,” which makes him “a mouthpiece for pro-Russian propaganda” who “makes conspiracy theories” such as “accusing Ukraine of orchestrating its own invasion in order to join NATO.”

    Damn, this dude is bad ass.

    I quiver in fear at the thought of this septuagenarian “making conspiracy theories.”

    What’s a world powerhouse like the European Union to do in the face of such a threat?

    Why sanction the bugger, of course!

    Which is precisely what Kaja Kallas, the Estonian-born High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, did, promulgating a notice on December 15, 2025 which added twelve “natural persons” and two “entities” to a list of people and entities deemed to have run afoul of Council Regulation (EU) 2024/2642 (“EU Russia Destabilization Sanctions”). Passed in October 2024, this regulation introduced “new restrictive measures against Russia in response to its destabilizing activities against the EU and EU Member States.” The regulation was “designed to respond to Russia’s campaign of hybrid activities against the EU and its Member States.”

    The EU deemed this regulation necessary to counter alleged Russian hybrid actions designed to undermine elections, support violent demonstrations, commit acts of sabotage against democratic institutions, economic activities, or services of public interest, exploiting armed conflict for the purposes of illicit trade, and instigating or facilitating armed conflict.

    All the above listed actions could—and should—constitute criminal acts if carried out by any person.

    The question is, which of these nefarious deeds is Colonel Baud accused of undertaking?

    None of the above.

    Instead, he has fallen afoul of an additional listed activity, “supporting or otherwise facilitating the use of coordinated information manipulation and interference.” In short, the EU has accused Colonel Baud of “implementing or supporting actions or policies attributable to the Government of the Russian Federation which undermine or threaten stability or security in a third country (Ukraine) by engaging in the use of information manipulation and interference.”

    Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI) is the recent brainchild of the European External Action Service (EEAS), the diplomatic service in charge of executing all international relations of the European Union. Back in 2022 the EEAS collaborated with the EU Agency for Cybersecurity (ENISA) to study and analyze the threat landscape concerning Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI) and disinformation. The mandate for this action was direction derived from the November 27, 2019, European Democracy Action Plan, which tasked the EEAS to “work with Member States, civil society and industry towards refined common definitions and methodologies in order to address different categories of disinformation and influence activities.”

    FIMI is defined by the EEAS as follows: “A mostly nonillegal pattern of behavior that threatens or has the potential to negatively impact values, procedures and political processes. Such activity is manipulative in character, conducted in an intentional and coordinated manner. Actors of such activity can be state or non-state actors, including their proxies inside and outside of their own territory.”

    By its own admission, the EEAS definition of what constitutes FIMI “puts emphasis on manipulative behavior, as opposed to the truthfulness of the content being delivered.”

    In short, the “crimes” Colonel Baud is accused of are procedural in nature and not derived from any actual disinformation or promulgation of lies or mistruths. Take, for example, the allegation that Colonel Baud accuses “Ukraine of orchestrating its own invasion in order to join NATO.”

    The basis for this accusation is Colonel Baud’s 2024 book, L’art de la guerre russe. Comment l’Occident a conduit l’Ukraine à l’échec (The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat), published by Max Milo Editions, a French publisher.

    The offending passages read as follows:

    Zelensky’s decree of March 24, 2021 for the reconquest of Crimea and the Donbass was the real trigger for the SMO. From that moment on, the Russians understood that if there was military action against them, they would have to intervene. But they also knew that the cause of the Ukrainian operation was NATO membership, as Oleksei Arestovitch had explained. That is why, in mid-December 2021, they were submitting proposals to the USA and NATO on extending the Alliance: their aim was then to remove Ukraine’s motive for an offensive in the Donbass.

    The reason for the Russian Special Military Operation (SMO) is indeed the protection of the populations of Donbass; but this protection was necessary because of Kiev’s desire to go through a confrontation to enter NATO. The extension of NATO is therefore only the indirect cause of the conflict in Ukraine. The latter could have spared itself this ordeal by implementing the Minsk Agreements—but what we wanted was a defeat for Russia.

    Jacques Baud in Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat

    Nothing Colonel Baud wrote is a lie, distortion of fact, or mistruth.

    Moreover, he published his work using a well-known French publisher—not a Russian mouthpiece.

    And it turns out every thing Colonel Baud wrote about Ukraine and NATO was true.

    Amanda Sloat, the former Biden Administration senior director for Europe at the National Security Council whom Politico has labeled “an architect of President Joe Biden’s Europe policy,” has recently admitted that the Russian initiation of the SMO could have been avoided if the US took NATO membership off the table when it came to Ukraine.

    “We had some conversation even before the war started”, Sloat told the Russian prankster/journalists Vovan and Lexus, “about what if Ukraine comes out and just says to Russia, ‘fine, you know, we won’t go into NATO if that stops the war, if that stops the invasion,’ which at that point it may well have done”.

    Amanda Sloat

    Sloat, however, noted that she was “uncomfortable with the idea of the US pushing Ukraine not to do that, and sort of implicitly giving Russia some sort of sphere of influence or veto power on that”, adding “I don’t think Biden felt like it was his place to tell Ukraine what to do then, to tell Ukraine not to pursue NATO”.

    In conclusion, Sloat admitted that

    “I guess if you want to do an alternative version of history, one option would have just been for Ukraine to say in January of 2022, ‘fine, you know, we won’t go into NATO, we will stay neutral.’ Ukraine could have made a deal around March/April of 2022 around the Istanbul talks. There is certainly a question,” she added, “almost three years on now, would that have been better to do before the war started, would that have been better to do in Istanbul talks, it certainly would have prevented the destruction and the loss of life”.

    Amanda Slout

    Damn.

    I guess the EU had better fire up its sanction machine.

    Amanda Sloat, how dare you say such things!

    You see, it doesn’t matter that what she said is true.

    What matters is that it goes against the official narrative promulgated by Ukraine, which has been adopted without question by the EU.

    Colonel Jacques Baud is guilty of nothing more than telling the fact-based truth, no matter how inconvenient it may be to the established powers in the EU.

    He has committed no crime—by their own admission, the EU states that the FIMI “crime” Colonel Baud has been convicted of, without benefit of due process, is nothing more than a “nonillegal pattern of behavior” in which the fact that he told the unvarnished truth is no factor.

    Colonel Baud told the truth outside the officially mandated informational pathways established by the EU, and in a manner which contradicted the lies and distortions being promulgated by Ukraine, and he had to be punished.

    Well, Ms. Kallas, I have a challenge for you.

    I, too, have been telling the truth about the Russian-Ukraine conflict.

    I have been put on the Mirotvorets death list by the Unkrainian intelligence service for the crime of telling the truth.

    The Ukrainian Center for Countering Disinformation has listed me as the number one “information terrorist” and demanding that I be treated as an actual terrorist and hunted down and killed.

    What the hell.

    I need a little more adventure in my life.

    Sanction me, Bitch.

    Do it.

    “F” around and find out.

    I’m an American.

    We believe in free speech.

    Seriously.

    Like, we will fight and die over this issue.

    Sanction me, and my country will fuck you up.

    It’s a damn shame Switzerland has abandoned Colonel Baud to his fate.

    The Swiss were once viewed as the defenders of democracy and all that attends it, inclusive of free speech.

    But no more. So pick on someone your own size.

    Sanction an American citizen.

    I dare you [end]

    The original article

    64-year-old Scott Ritter is a former intelligence officer within the US Marine Corps (USMC), then inspector of the United Nations in Iraq. When in 2003, the US and their British minions were about to invade the country under this false pretext, Ritter was claiming that there was no weapon of mass destruction (WMD) there. He was right.

    Related

    December 13, 2025: Jacques Baud nous répond – Hélène Richard-Favre

    December 10, 2025 : Censorship in Western Academia and the War in Ukraine – New Global Politics

    Why are liberal institutions censoring discussion of forced mobilization in Ukraine? – Volodymyr Ishchenko, Marta Havryshko, Tarik Cyril Amar, Milica Popović and Almut Rochowanski

    December 1, 2025 : Psychose – Pierre Rimbert, le Monde diplomatique

    November 11, 2025 : Der Krieg

    ce 11 novembre 2025 est l’occasion de souligner comme la façon dont l’Europe sacrifie les conscrits ukrainiens mobilisés de force rappelle le spectaculaire carnage de la 1ère guerre mondiale

    August 29, 2025 : How U.S. Support for Ukraine’s Neo-Nazis Imperils Diplomacy – Harrison Berger, The American Conservative

    Since the Cold War, Washington has empowered violent anti-Russian extremists

    August 21, 2025 : « Ukraine über alles! » – Susann Witt-Stahl, junge Welt

    Azov paramilitaries are aiming to debunk Kremlin « myths ». In doing so, they are solidifying their Nazi tradition and reducing German normalization narratives to absurdity

    August 2, 2025 : Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    Ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    March 14, 2025 : « Pensions ou munitions ? » : la fabrique du consentement à « l’effort de guerre » – Pauline Perrenot, Acrimed

    Depuis l’allocution d’Emmanuel Macron à propos de la guerre en Ukraine, le 5 mars, les grands médias sont en ordre de marche. Réhabilitation du président en « chef de guerre », patriotisme exacerbé, concert militariste et glorification des industriels de guerre… Mené tambour battant, le SAV du discours présidentiel s’accompagne d’une nouvelle séquence de matraquage patronal contre le « modèle social » et pour « travailler plus » au nom, prétendument, de l’« effort de guerre » : « Pensions ou munitions ? » ; « Les canons ou les allocations ? » Signés Dominique Seux (Les Échos, 10/03) et Étienne Gernelle (RTL, 10/03), les deux slogans donnent le ton

    December 12, 2024 : McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    November 26, 2024 : How the Strategy of Fighting to the Last Ukrainian Was Sold to the Public as Morally Righteous – Glenn Diesen

    April 11, 2024 : U.S. Government Helps Pro-Ukraine Media Spread Propaganda And Silence American Critics – Lee Fang, RealClearInvestigations

    Media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government have supported censorship, disseminated disinfo, and sought to silence American critics of the war

    January 1, 2024 : The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat – Jacques Baud, The Postil Magazine

    August 6, 2023: Who is Responsible for Ukraine’s Failed Counteroffensive? – Scott Ritter, Sputnik

    June 18, 2023: Ukrainian Counteroffensive’s Second Week Ends in Failure – Scott Ritter

    Operation enters the second week of Ukraine’s long-awaited and highly touted counteroffensive, some basic conclusions can be drawn even though the fighting continues, and will continue to rage, for some time to come

    June 10, 2023: Finally the Bull Charged – Scott Ritter

    June 3, 2023 : EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    March 9, 2023 : How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    The West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    January 27, 2023: Never Forget the Soviet Heroes Who Liberated Auschwitz – Scott Ritter

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Partage] Jacques Baud nous répond – Hélène Richard-Favre

    Bonjour Jacques BAUD! Vous vous rappelez bien sûr la série d’entretiens que nous avions menés ensemble sur ce blog. C’était un article de Sylvain Besson qui avait motivé ma démarche auprès de vous pour en savoir un peu plus. Nous étions début septembre 2020. 

    Voici ce même journaliste reprendre un article paru sur Radio free Europe et parler de vous en termes que je vous serais reconnaissante de commenter. L’article en question, paru sur le site de la Tribune de Genève, est déjà suivi de plus de 300 commentaires. Qu’avez-vous à nous en dire ?

    Merci pour votre question. Oui, j’ai été surpris par cette information, même si je ne sais pas encore en ce moment si elle est vraie ou non. Je pars de l’idée qu’elle l’est.

    Mon approche du conflit russo-ukrainien (comme des autres, d’ailleurs) est d’exposer les faits afin de comprendre ce qui se passe, avec la finalité d’y trouver une solution. Comme je le répète souvent: « de la manière de comprendre une crise découle celle de la résoudre ». Cette compréhension doit se faire indépendamment de toute préférence pour l’une ou l’autre des parties en présence. Aujourd’hui, particulièrement en Europe, si votre appréciation s’écarte un tant soit peu de la ligne officielle, vous êtes considéré comme « pro-russe » ou « conspirationniste ». Si vous lisez les commentaires des différentes interviews que j’ai accordées, les commentaires « équilibrés », « factuels » ou « balancés » reviennent le plus souvent. Après une interview qui a été publiée sur un média américain, un internaute a commenté: « Bien que Baud soit pro-ukrainien, il a bien compris la position russe! ». On est aux antipodes de ce que racontent nos journalistes. En novembre 2022, le journaliste suisse Jean-Philippe Schaller de la RTS déclarait que j’étais un agent au service de Vladimir Poutine! Quelles sont ses sources? Aucune: c’est du conspirationnisme pur et simple.

    Le problème aujourd’hui est que si l’on dit que « la Russie gagne » on est automatiquement considéré comme « pro-russe ». Mais la victoire ou la défaite de l’un ou de l’autre ne dépend pas de ce que nous disons ou pensons! C’est une réalité. On pourrait même aller plus loin, j’ai expliqué dès 2022 pourquoi l’Ukraine perdait. Si on en avait tenu compte et aidé l’Ukraine non pas pour affaiblir la Russie mais pour qu’elle gagne, elle gagnerait aujourd’hui. Tout était parfaitement clair à la fin 2022. C’est d’ailleurs la raison pour laquelle les Américains ont conseillé à Zelensky d’ouvrir un dialogue avec la Russie.

    Nos journalistes croient aider l’Ukraine, mais c’est faux. À Bruxelles, j’ai été à quatre reprises arrêté dans la rue par des Ukrainiens (de Kharkiv, Odessa et Dniepropetrovsk) qui m’ont remercié pour ce que je fais. Un Ukrainien m’a même envoyé une carte postale avec le timbre de l’attaque contre le croiseur russe Moskva dans la Mer Noire. Nous avons un regard plus polarisé que les Ukrainiens eux-mêmes sur ce conflit. D’ailleurs, pour ceux qui veulent prendre la peine de lire mes livres, ils constateront que je n’utilise aucune source russe, mais exclusivement la presse ukrainienne et américaine: je prends la presse européenne (suisse en particulier) pour les mauvais exemples! Nos journalistes n’utilisent que l’information qui sort des bureaux de l’administration ukrainienne. Les journalistes ukrainiens sont beaucoup plus honnêtes et professionnels que les nôtres. La catastrophe de la bataille de Krinky, sur le Dniepr, par exemple, a été rapportée en grands détails avec des critiques sérieuses contre les militaires britanniques qui l’avaient planifiée et dirigée. Pas un mot dans nos médias. Lisez mes livres. Il y a des centaines de notes: elles viennent presque toutes de médias ukrainiens ou américains.

    Aujourd’hui, même le premier-ministre belge reconnaît qu’une défaite de la Russie est une illusion. C’était déjà ce que les Américains pensaient en novembre 2022, lorsqu’ils ont conseillé à Zelensky d’ouvrir un dialogue avec Moscou. Dire que la Russie ne perd pas ne signifie pas que l’on est pro-russe, c’est un avertissement. Qu’ont fait les Besson et autres plumitifs pour tenir compte de ces avertissements et faire en sorte que l’on aide l’Ukraine efficacement ? Rien! Rien du tout, à part vociférer contre la Russie. Le problème est qu’aujourd’hui le narratif entre en collision avec la réalité et, après 4 ans (!), le système se défend en interdisant les vues qui ne lui plaisent pas. J’ai décrit exactement les mécanismes internes à la conduite ukrainienne qui la défavorisaient sur le terrain. Qui s’en est soucié pour améliorer la conduite ukrainienne? Personne. Aujourd’hui, on s’aperçoit qu’on a loupé une occasion. Cette guerre, qu’on le veuille ou non, est plus dictée par la haine de la Russie que par l’amour de l’Ukraine. Même Zelensky s’en est aperçu.

    Lorsque Sylvain Besson m’a appelé vendredi 12 décembre, il m’a demandé si je croyais que la Russie avait bien attaqué l’Ukraine, j’ai répondu que oui, mais que je pense qu’il y a eu provocation, exactement comme en Géorgie en 2008, et que je m’appuyais sur une interview d’Olekseï Arestovitch (alors conseiller de Zelensky), dans une interview du 18 mars 2019 au média ukrainien Apostrof’, lors de laquelle il explique qu’il faudra une guerre avec la Russie pour pouvoir entrer dans l’OTAN et que cette guerre aurait probablement lieu en « 2021-2022 ».  À ceci s’ajoutent les observations faites par les observateurs de l’OSCE entre le 16 et le 21 février 2022, qui montraient une claire intensification des frappes contre les populations du Donbass. Sans compter le décret du 24 mars 2021 de Zelensky qui déclare la reprise de la Crimée et qui marque le début de la montée en puissance de l’Ukraine sur les pourtours du Donbass. Évidemment, Besson s’est bien gardé de le mentionner dans son article!… et pour cause!

    Mais il y a d’autres choses pas honnêtes. Par exemple, j’ai toujours refusé les invitations de médias officiels russes, parce que je voulais éviter que mes analyses puissent être instrumentalisées à des fins de propagande. J’ai expliqué ça aux journalistes russes qui l’ont très bien compris. Les médias mentionnés par Besson (Agoravox, media 4-4-2 et RT) sont des médias qui ont repris (sans me le demander) des interviews faites sur d’autres plateformes et/ou vendues par elles. Omerta est un média qui m’interviewe occasionnellement, dont le directeur (Régis le Sommier) apparaît également sur Europe 1 et d’autres médias mainstream français.

    Quant à la présence de soldats nord-coréens en Ukraine, je ne l’ai pas mise en doute. J’ai mis en doute leur intégration dans les forces russes. Et les faits m’ont donné raison.  La conférence à laquelle j’ai participé à Winterthour portait sur la neutralité de la Suisse. Je ne me suis jamais exprimé sur les questions liées au Covid et aux vaccins, comme le suggère Besson. Contrairement à ce qu’il affirme, je n’ai jamais participé à la « formation d’armées locales », j’ai toujours été engagé dans le cadre des Nations Unies et sous leur contrôle.

    Conclusion: une fois de plus, Sylvain Besson ne s’est pas montré comme un  journaliste intègre. Une étude de l’Université d’Uppsala (pas une officine comme Conspiracy Watch payée par le gouvernement britannique!) le qualifie de conspirationniste et d’inspirateur d’Anders Breivik, responsable de la tuerie d’Utoya.

    Dans tous les cas de figure, penser que l’UE conduit l’Ukraine à sa perte n’est – à ma connaissance – pas un délit!

    Merci beaucoup de vos réponses, Jacques Baud. Et juste encore pour préciser à nos lecteurs que si vous avez donc eu droit à être fiché conspirationniste par Conspiracy Watch, du seul fait de vous avoir interrogé sur mon blog m’a valu d’être étiquetée telle sur ledit site. C’est dire où on en est! [fin]

    L’article original

    Jacques Baud a été colonel du renseignement suisse, spécialiste de l’Europe de l’Est. Entre 2009 et 2011, il dirigeait à New York l’équipe Politiques et Doctrine du Bureau des affaires militaires du Département des opérations de maintien de la paix des Nations Unies. Ce fut dans le cadre de l’OTAN qu’il participa à des programmes en Ukraine en 2014 et 2017

    Articles connexes

    10 décembre 2025 : Censorship in Western Academia and the War in Ukraine – New Global Politics

    Why are liberal institutions censoring discussion of forced mobilization in Ukraine? – Volodymyr Ishchenko, Marta Havryshko, Tarik Cyril Amar, Milica Popović and Almut Rochowanski

    1er décembre 2025 : Psychose – Pierre Rimbert, le Monde diplomatique

    11 novembre 2025 : Der Krieg

    ce 11 novembre 2025 est l’occasion de souligner comme la façon dont l’Europe sacrifie les conscrits ukrainiens mobilisés de force rappelle le spectaculaire carnage de la 1ère guerre mondiale

    29 août 2025 : How U.S. Support for Ukraine’s Neo-Nazis Imperils Diplomacy – Harrison Berger, The American Conservative

    Since the Cold War, Washington has empowered violent anti-Russian extremists

    21 août 2025 : « Ukraine über alles! » – Susann Witt-Stahl, junge Welt

    Azov paramilitaries are aiming to debunk Kremlin « myths ». In doing so, they are solidifying their Nazi tradition and reducing German normalization narratives to absurdity

    2 août 2025 : Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    Ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    14 mars 2025 : « Pensions ou munitions ? » : la fabrique du consentement à « l’effort de guerre » – Pauline Perrenot, Acrimed

    Depuis l’allocution d’Emmanuel Macron à propos de la guerre en Ukraine, le 5 mars, les grands médias sont en ordre de marche. Réhabilitation du président en « chef de guerre », patriotisme exacerbé, concert militariste et glorification des industriels de guerre… Mené tambour battant, le SAV du discours présidentiel s’accompagne d’une nouvelle séquence de matraquage patronal contre le « modèle social » et pour « travailler plus » au nom, prétendument, de l’« effort de guerre » : « Pensions ou munitions ? » ; « Les canons ou les allocations ? » Signés Dominique Seux (Les Échos, 10/03) et Étienne Gernelle (RTL, 10/03), les deux slogans donnent le ton

    12 décembre 2024 : McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    26 novembre 2024 : How the Strategy of Fighting to the Last Ukrainian Was Sold to the Public as Morally Righteous – Glenn Diesen

    11 avril 2024 : U.S. Government Helps Pro-Ukraine Media Spread Propaganda And Silence American Critics – Lee Fang, RealClearInvestigations

    Media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government have supported censorship, disseminated disinfo, and sought to silence American critics of the war

    1er janvier 2024 : The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat – Jacques Baud, The Postil Magazine

    3 juin 2023 : EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    9 mars 2023 : How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    The West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Partage] Dislocation de l’Occident : les menaces – Emmanuel Todd

    La perversité de Trump se déploie au Moyen-Orient, le bellicisme de l’OTAN en Europe

    Je viens d’écrire à la demande de mon éditeur slovène une nouvelle préface à La Défaite de l’Occident, qu’il m’apparaît nécessaire de publier sur Substack immédiatement. La menace d’une aggravation de tous les conflits se précise. On trouvera dans ce texte une interprétation schématique et provisoire, mais actualisée du développement de la crise que nous vivons. Ce texte est de fait la conclusion de mon dernier entretien avec Diane Lagrange sur Fréquence Populaire : « Victoire de la Russie, enfermement et fracturation de la France et de l’Occident ».

    Préface à l’édition slovène

    De la défaite à la dislocation

    Moins de deux ans après la publication en français de La Défaite de l’Occident, en janvier 2024, les principales prédictions du livre sont vérifiées. La Russie a militairement et économiquement tenu le choc. L’industrie militaire américaine est épuisée. Les économies et les sociétés européennes sont au bord de l’implosion. Avant même que s’effondre l’armée ukrainienne, le stade suivant de la dislocation de l’Occident est atteint.

    Je suis depuis toujours hostile à la politique russophobe des États-Unis et de l’Europe mais, en tant qu’occidental attaché à la démocratie libérale, Français formé à la recherche en Angleterre, enfant d’une mère réfugiée aux États-Unis pendant la deuxième guerre mondiale, je suis catastrophé par les conséquences pour nous, Occidentaux, de la guerre menée sans intelligence contre la Russie.

    Nous ne sommes qu’au début de la catastrophe. Un point de bascule approche au-delà duquel se développeront les conséquences ultimes de la défaite.

    Le « Reste du monde » (ou Sud global, ou Majorité globale), qui s’était contenté de soutenir la Russie en refusant de boycotter son économie, affiche désormais ouvertement son soutien à Vladimir Poutine. Les BRICS s’élargissent en acceptant de nouveaux adhérents, ils accroissent leur cohésion. Sommée par les États-Unis de choisir son camp, l’Inde a choisi l’indépendance : les photos de Poutine, Xi et Modi réunis à l’occasion de la réunion d’aout 2025 de l’Organisation de Coopération de Shanghai resteront comme le symbole de ce moment clef. Les médias occidentaux ne cessent pourtant de nous représenter Poutine comme un monstre et les Russes comme des serfs. Ces médias avaient déjà été incapables d’imaginer que le Reste du monde les voit comme un dirigeant et des êtres humains ordinaires, porteurs d’une culture russe spécifique et d’une volonté de souveraineté. J’ai peur désormais que nos médias n’aggravent notre aveuglement en étant incapables d’imaginer le regain de prestige de la Russie dans ce Reste du monde, exploité économiquement et traité avec arrogance par l’Occident durant des siècles. Les Russes ont osé. Ils ont défié l’Empire et ils ont gagné.

    L’ironie de l’histoire, c’est que les Russes, peuple européen et blanc, de langue slave, sont devenus le bouclier militaire du Reste du monde parce que l’Occident a refusé de les intégrer après la chute du communisme. J’imagine les Slovènes particulièrement bien placés culturellement pour apprécier cette ironie même si ce que je sais bien, en tant qu’anthropologue de la famille et de la religion, que, malgré sa langue slave, la Slovénie est beaucoup plus proche socialement et idéologiquement de la Suisse que de la Russie.

    Je peux ébaucher ici un modèle de la dislocation de l’Occident, malgré les incohérences de la politique de Donald Trump, président américain de la défaite. Ces incohérences ne résultent pas, je pense, d’une personnalité instable, et sans doute perverse, mais d’un dilemme insoluble pour les États-Unis. D’une part, leurs dirigeants, au Pentagone comme à la Maison blanche, savent que la guerre est perdue et que l’Ukraine devra être abandonnée. Le bon sens les conduit donc à vouloir sortir de la guerre. Mais d’autre part, le même bon sens leur fait pressentir que le retrait d’Ukraine aura pour l’Empire des conséquences dramatiques que n’avaient pas eu ceux du Vietnam, d’Irak ou d’Afghanistan. Il s’agit en effet de la première défaite stratégique américaine d’échelle planétaire, dans un contexte de désindustrialisation massive des États-Unis et de réindustrialisation difficile. La Chine est devenue l’atelier du monde ; sa très faible fécondité, certes, lui interdira de remplacer les Etats-Unis, mais il est déjà trop tard pour la concurrencer industriellement.

    La dédollarisation de l’économie mondiale a commencé. Trump et ses conseillers n’arrivent pas à l’accepter car ce serait la fin de l’Empire. Un âge post-impérial pourtant devrait être le but du projet MAGA, Make America Great Again, qui cherche un retour de l’état-nation américain. Mais pour une Amérique dont la capacité productive en biens réels est aujourd’hui très faible (voir chapitre 9 sur la vraie nature de l’économie américaine), il est impossible de renoncer à vivre à crédit comme elle le fait en produisant des dollars. Un tel retrait impérial-monétaire impliquerait une chute brutale de son niveau de vie, y compris pour les électeurs populaires de Trump. Le premier budget de la deuxième présidence Trump, le « One Big Beautiful Bill Act », reste donc impérial malgré les protections tarifaires qui incarnent le projet ou rêve protectionniste. L’ OBBBA relance les dépenses militaires et le déficit. Qui dit déficit budgétaire aux États-Unis dit, inévitablement, production de dollars et déficit commercial. La dynamique impériale, l’inertie impériale plutôt, n’en finit pas de miner le rêve d’un retour à l’état-nation productif.

    En Europe, la défaite militaire reste mal comprise des dirigeants. Ils n’ont pas dirigé les opérations. C’est le Pentagone qui avait mis au point les plans de la contre-offensive ukrainienne de l’été 2023 (durant laquelle j’avais écrit La Défaite de l’Occident). Les militaires américains, même s’ils ont fait mener la guerre par leur proxy ukrainien, savent qu’ils se sont brisés sur la défense russe – parce qu’ils ne pouvaient produire assez d’armes et parce que les militaires russes ont été plus intelligents qu’eux. Les dirigeants européens n’ont fourni que des systèmes d’armes et pas les plus importants. Inconscients de l’ampleur de la défaite militaire, ils savent en revanche que leurs propres économies ont été paralysées par la politique de sanctions, tout spécialement par la rupture de leur approvisionnement en énergie russe bon marché. Couper en deux économiquement le continent européen fut un acte de folie suicidaire. L’économie allemande stagne. Partout à l’ouest, la pauvreté et les inégalités augmentent. Le Royaume-Uni est au bord du gouffre. La France le suit de près. Sociétés et systèmes politiques sont bloquées.

    Une dynamique économique et sociale négative préexistait à la guerre et mettait déjà l’Occident sous tension. Elle était visible, à des degrés divers, dans toute l’Europe de l’Ouest. Le libre-échange y mine la base industrielle. L’immigration y développe un syndrome identitaire, particulièrement dans les classes populaires privées d’emplois sûrs et correctement payés.

    Plus en profondeur, la dynamique négative de fragmentation est culturelle : l’éducation supérieure de masse crée des sociétés stratifiées dans lesquelles les éduqués supérieurs – 20%, 30%, 40% de la population – se mettent à vivre entre eux, à se penser supérieurs, à mépriser les milieux populaires, à rejeter le travail manuel et l’industrie. L’éducation primaire pour tous (l’alphabétisation universelle) avait nourri la démocratie, créant une société homogène dont le subconscient était égalitaire. L’éducation supérieure a engendré des oligarchies, et parfois des ploutocraties, sociétés stratifiées envahies par un subconscient inégalitaire. Paradoxe ultime : le développement de l’éducation supérieure a fini par produire dans ces oligarchies ou ploutocraties une baisse du niveau intellectuel ! J’avais décrit cette séquence il y a plus d’un quart de siècle dans L’Illusion économique, publiée en 1997. L’industrie occidentale s’en est allée dans le Reste du monde et aussi, bien sûr, dans les anciennes démocraties populaires d’Europe de l’Est qui, libérées de leur sujétion à la Russie soviétique, ont désormais retrouvé leur statut pluriséculaire de périphérie dominée par l’Europe de l’Ouest. Je parle en détail au chapitre 3 de cette espèce de Chine intérieure où les ouvriers d’industrie restent nombreux. Partout cependant en Europe l’élitisme des éduqués supérieurs a engendré le « populisme ».

    La guerre a fait monter d’un cran la tension européenne. Elle appauvrit le continent. Mais surtout, échec stratégique majeur, elle délégitime des dirigeants incapables de mener leurs pays à la victoire. Le développement de mouvements populaires conservateurs (habituellement désigné par les élites journalistiques par des termes comme « populistes » ou « d’extrême droite » ou « nationalistes ») s’accélère. Reform UK au Royaume-Uni. AfD en Allemagne, Rassemblement national en France… Ironie toujours : les sanctions économiques dont l’OTAN attendait un « regime change » en Russie sont sur le point d’apporter à l’Europe occidentale une cascade de « regime changes ». Les classes dirigeantes occidentales sont délégitimées par la défaite au moment même où la démocratie autoritaire russe est relégitimée par la victoire, ou plutôt, surlégitimée puisque le retour de la Russie à la stabilité sous Poutine lui assurait au départ une légitimité incontestée.

    Tel est notre monde à l’approche de 2026.

    La dislocation de l’Occident prend la forme d’une « fracturation hiérarchique »

    Les États-Unis renoncent au contrôle de la Russie, et je le pense de plus en plus, de la Chine. Mis sous blocus chinois pour leurs importations de samarium, cette terre rare indispensable à l’aéronautique militaire, les États-Unis ne peuvent plus rêver d’affronter la Chine militairement. Le Reste du monde – Inde, Brésil, monde arabe, Afrique – en profite et leur échappe. Mais les États-Unis se retournent vigoureusement contre leurs « alliés » européens et est-asiatiques, dans un effort ultime de surexploitation, et aussi, il faut l’admettre, par pur et simple dépit. Pour échapper à leur humiliation, pour cacher au monde et à eux-mêmes leur faiblesse, ils punissent l’Europe. L’Empire se dévore lui-même. C’est le sens des tariffs et investissements forcés imposés par Trump aux Européens, devenus sujets coloniaux dans un empire rétréci plutôt que partenaires. Le temps des démocraties libérales solidaires est fini.

    Le trumpisme est un « conservatisme populaire blanc ». Ce qui émerge en Occident n’est pas une solidarité des conservatismes populaires mais une rupture des solidarités internes. La rage qui résulte de la défaite conduit chaque pays, pour éponger son ressentiment, à se retourner contre plus faible que lui. Les États-Unis se retournent contre l’Europe ou le Japon. La France réactive son conflit avec l’Algérie, ancienne colonie. Nul doute que l’Allemagne, qui, de Scholz à Merz, a accepté d’obéir aux Etats-Unis, ne retourne son humiliation contre ses partenaires européens plus faibles. Mon propre pays, la France, me semble le plus menacé.

    L’un des concepts fondamentaux de la défaite de l’Occident est le nihilisme. J’explique comment « l’état zéro » de la religion protestante – la sécularisation arrivée à son terme – n’explique pas seulement l’effondrement éducatif et industriel américain. L’état zéro ouvre aussi un vide métaphysique. Je ne suis pas personnellement croyant et je ne milite pour aucun retour du religieux (je ne le crois pas possible) mais je dois, en tant qu’historien, constater que la disparition des valeurs sociales d’origine religieuse mène à une crise morale, à une pulsion de destruction des choses et des hommes (la guerre) et ultimement à une tentative d’abolition de la réalité (le phénomène transgenre pour les démocrates américains et la négation du réchauffement climatique pour les républicains par exemple). La crise existe pour tous les pays complètement sécularisés mais elle est pire dans ceux dont la religion était le protestantisme ou le judaïsme, religions absolutistes dans leur recherche du transcendant, plutôt que le catholicisme, plus ouvert à la beauté du monde et de la vie terrestre. C’est bien en aux États-Unis et en Israël que l’on voit se développer des formes parodiques des religions traditionnelles, parodies d’essence selon moi nihiliste.

    Cette dimension irrationnelle est au cœur de la défaite. Celle-ci n’est donc pas seulement une perte « technique » de puissance mais aussi un épuisement moral, une absence de but existentiel positif qui mène au nihilisme.

    Ce nihilisme est derrière la volonté des dirigeants européens, particulièrement sur les bords protestants de la Baltique, d’élargir la guerre contre la Russie par des provocations incessantes. Ce nihilisme est aussi derrière la déstabilisation américaine du Proche-Orient, lieu par excellence d’expression de la rage qui résulte de la défaite américaine face à la Russie. Surtout, ne cédons pas à l’évidence trop facile d’une autonomie guerrière du régime Netanyahu en Israël dans le génocide de Gaza ou dans l’attaque contre l’Iran. Protestantisme-zéro et judaïsme-zéro mêlent certes tragiquement leurs effets nihilistes dans ces accès de violence. Mais partout au Moyen-Orient ce sont bien les États-Unis qui, en fournissant les armes et parfois en attaquant eux-mêmes, sont en dernière instance les décideurs du chaos. Ils poussent Israël à l’action comme ils ont poussé les Ukrainiens. La première présidence Trump avait établi l’ambassade des États-Unis à Jérusalem et c’est bien Trump qui le premier a imaginé Gaza transformé en station balnéaire. Je suis conscient qu’il faudrait un livre pour démontrer cette thèse, un livre qui démonterait une à une les interactions entre les acteurs. Mais, historien de métier, et faisant de la géopolitique depuis un-demi-siècle, je sens que, comme l’Europe otanienne, Israël a cessé d’être un état indépendant. Le problème de l’Occident est bien la mort programmée de l’état-nation.

    L’Empire est vaste et il se décompose dans le bruit et la fureur. Cet Empire est déjà polycentrique, divisé sur ses buts, schizophrène. Mais aucune de ses parties n’est indépendante du tout. Trump est son « centre » actuel ; il est aussi sa meilleure expression idéologico-pratique en ce qu’il mêle une volonté rationnelle de repliement sur sa sphère de domination immédiate (l’Europe et Israël) à des impulsions nihilistes de préférence pour la guerre. Ces tendances – repliement et violence – s’expriment aussi à l’intérieur du cœur américain de l’Empire où le principe de fracturation hiérarchique fonctionne en interne. Des auteurs anglo-américains de plus en plus nombreux évoquent la venue d’une guerre civile.

    La ploutocratie américaine est pluraliste. Il y a celle des financiers, celle des pétroliers, celle de la Silicon Valley. Les ploutocrates trumpistes, pétroliers texans ou ralliés récent de la Silicon Valley, méprisent les élites éduquées démocrates de la côte Est, qui méprisent elles-mêmes les petits-blancs trumpistes du heartland, qui méprisent eux-mêmes les Noirs démocrates, etc…

    L’une des particularités intéressantes de l’Amérique actuelle est que ses dirigeants ont de plus en plus de mal à distinguer l’interne de l’externe, malgré la tentative MAGA d’arrêter par un mur l’immigration venue du sud. L’armée tire sur des bateaux qui sortent du Vénézuéla, elle bombarde l’Iran, elle entre dans le centre des villes démocrates des États-Unis, elle commandite l’aviation israélienne pour une attaque sur le Qatar où se trouve une immense base américaine. Tout lecteur de science-fiction reconnaîtra dans cette énumération inquiétante l’amorce d’une entrée en dystopie, c’est-à-dire dans un monde négatif où se mêlent puissance, fragmentation, hiérarchie, violence, pauvreté et perversité.

    Restons donc nous-mêmes, hors de l’Amérique. Gardons notre perception de l’intérieur et de l’extérieur, notre sens de la mesure, notre contact avec la réalité, notre conception de ce qui est juste et beau. Ne nous laissons pas non plus entraîner dans une fuite en avant guerrière par nos propres dirigeants européens, ces privilégiés égarés dans l’histoire, désespérés d’avoir été vaincus, terrorisés à l’idée d’être un jour jugés par leurs peuples. Et surtout, surtout, continuons de réfléchir au sens des choses.

    Paris, le 28 septembre 2025 [fin]

    L’article original

    voici la synthèse de Grok, l’outil US d’intelligence artificielle de X

    A blog preface to the Slovenian edition of Emmanuel Todd’s 2024 book La Défaite de l’Occident, updating his analysis of Western geopolitical failures, including Russia’s resilience in Ukraine and Global South alignment against U.S. dominance.

    Todd critiques Trump’s Middle East policies as extensions of U.S. imperial nihilism, linking them to actions like arming Israel for Gaza operations, while highlighting NATO’s bellicose Ukraine strategy as a catalyst for European economic stagnation and rising populist movements.

    Amid de-dollarization and China’s industrial ascent, Todd warns of deepening Western internal fractures, such as U.S. tariffs on allies and moral exhaustion from Protestant secularization, potentially eroding liberal democracies without viable paths to recovery.

    Articles connexes

    31 août 2025 : Niouzes du pays des pinzuti

    et des vastes restes du monde

    17 juillet 2025 : La Russie est notre Rorschach – Emmanuel Todd

    2 juillet 2025 : Sudden acceleration of the Western decline

    the failure of the infamous Israeli attack against Iran

    30 avril 2025 : IGNORANCE – Scott Ritter

    Scott Ritter is a former intelligence officer (1984-1996) within the US Marines corps, became famous as weapons inspector (1991-1998) within the United Nations special commission about weapons of mass destruction (WMD) in Iraq. With professionalism and foresight, he warned that the US and British governments were using the myth of Iraqi WMD as a pretext for invasion in 2003. He was right

    17 février 2025 : La bourgeoisie n’a plus les moyens intellectuels, ni culturels, de sa domination de classe – Harold Bernat, Quartier Général

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    en Anglais, chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    L’engagement français dans les rangs ukrainiens

    chronique alphabétique et nécrologique de l’engagement français dans les rangs atlantistes en Ukraine, ce que les journalistes serviles ne vous raconteront pas

    The footprint of the Ukrainian Nazism in the West

    chronique en Anglais, interactions between Ukrainian Nazi organizations and Western supremacist militants

    Nazism in Ukraine

    chronique en Anglais, its roots before WW2, its collaboration with Nazi Germany, its legacy in modern Ukraine, how NATO has continually supported Nazism in Ukraine

  • Images du jour : die deutsche Frage

    les boches, en quelques mots

    Juste après la victoire de son camp aux élections fédérales du 23 février 2025, Johann Wadephul fut piégé par deux humoristes russes qui se faisaient passer au téléphone pour des membres de l’équipe du président ukrainien Voldodymyr Zelenskyy. Celui qui est aujourd’hui le ministre allemand des affaires étrangères leur déclara

    Russland wird immer ein Feind und eine Gefahr für unsere europäische Sicherheit sein [La Russie sera toujours un ennemi et une menace pour notre sécurité européenne]

    Ce véritable coming out n’a pas échappé à la sagacité de journalistes suisses

    En cette mi-août, les gesticulations et déclarations enflammées d’un Friedrich Merz, d’une Ursula von der Leyen ou de leur caniche Emmanuel Macron m’insupportent au point de devoir énoncer quelques vérités simples

    Le problème majeur de cette Europe en déclin vertigineux est aujourd’hui l’Allemagne, dont la réunification en 1990 fut une catastrophe pour la paix. Moins d’un an plus tard, ses services secrets, le Bundesnachrichtendienst, contribuèrent à semer le chaos en Yougoslavie. Un pays que les partisans communistes de Josip Broz Tito étaient parvenus à libérer seuls en 1945, détruisant les petits États fantoches nazis instaurés par les Allemands en 1941

    Pour raisons personnelles, je connais bien les Allemands. D’ailleurs, je regarde presque quotidiennement leurs journaux télévisés, où l’incantation unsere Demokratie [notre démocratie] est prononcée avec une emphase suspecte toutes les trois phrases. Quand de vils commentateurs français invoquent la liberté ou la démocratie au sujet du conflit en Ukraine, ils singent le révisionnisme allemand, un peu de la même façon que l’immense majorité de leurs anciens faisaient des ronds de jambe dans les Kommandanturen entre 1940 et 1944

    Les Allemands se rêvent dans une mythologie nationale qui leur fait croire qu’ils auraient été les victimes [je sais bien que c’est grotesque] d’une dictature nazie, dont les USA et nul autre les auraient libérés. Mais la Russie leur rappelle perpétuellement ce qu’ils étaient en réalité. Les boches n’ont toujours pas accepté d’avoir été vaincus en 1945 par l’Union soviétique, voudraient encore se croire sortis de la cuisse de Siegfried. C’est pourquoi je me délecte de leur déconfiture. Et si les pinzuti [Français, en Corse] devaient sombrer avec eux, inchallah.

    Articles connexes

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    en Anglais, chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    9 mai 2025 : Victory Day

    6 novembre 2024 : The fall guy

    the Germans have bowed down to the US sabotage by Joe Biden administration of Nord Stream pipelines, only to end up with Donald Trump’s America First doctrine in economy and defense

    12 avril 2024 : Germany stands on wrong side of history again – Strategic Culture Foundation

    Germany and the United States along with other Western powers are continuing deep-seated historical crimes by way of their proxy war against Russia

    19 février 2023 : Annalena Baerbock, the most arrogant lettuce in the world

    ahead of Liz Truss

    10 décembre 2022 : Happy days

    Europe was far happier when Germany was cut in two parts and I was occupying her with pleasure

  • [Sharing] French mercenaries active in Ukraine war: Ex-Intel Officer – Al Mayadeen

    A former French counter-terrorism intelligence officer Nicolas Cinquini is actively pursuing information regarding French citizens participating in the war on Ukraine’s side

    Nicolas Cinquini, a former French counter-terrorism intelligence officer currently looking into information regarding French citizens participating on Ukraine’s side in the conflict, informed Sputnik on Thursday that approximately 75 French mercenaries in Ukraine have either been killed, injured, or have returned to France since the beginning of the conflict

    Including those killed, wounded, and those who have returned, the list I have published as of today includes 75 individuals who have been identified accurately or under pseudonyms, which can already tell us a lot

    Cinquini said.

    He mentioned that the list also comprises two individuals whom French authorities refer to as “volunteers”

    The government presented them as ‘humanitarian workers’, employees of a Swiss NGO, but I am convinced that they were government agents. Their existence was revealed to us with their death on February 1

    the former intelligence officer said.

    He also indicated possessing information about additional mercenaries who engaged in hostilities on behalf of Kiev

    The rest have just been discovered and there is not yet enough information about them to publish

    Cinquini stressed.

    Simultaneously, the French Foreign Ministry has refuted the existence of French mercenaries within the Ukrainian Armed Forces, attributing such claims to Russian “disinformation”, despite reports in the French media about French citizens killed in Ukraine.

    Several statements released ever since the beginning of the Ukraine-Russian conflict show that Kiev’s Western allies have mercenaries fighting in Ukraine.

    Dive deeper

    In mid-March, the Russian Defense Ministry announced more than 13,387 foreign mercenaries arrived in Ukraine to participate in hostilities against Russia.

    Within that timeframe, 5,962 militants were eliminated, according to the ministry. Poland was identified as the leading contributor in terms of the number of slain mercenaries, with 2,960 individuals arriving from there, out of which 1,497 were killed.

    Following Poland, Georgia saw 561 casualties out of 1,042 mercenaries, while arrivals from the United States suffered 491 losses out of 1,113 individuals.

    Additionally, 422 out of 1,005 Canadian mercenaries, 360 out of 822 British mercenaries, and 349 out of 784 Romanian mercenaries were also killed. Germany contributed 235 mercenaries, with 88 of them perishing.

    Not only American troops but also the CIA

    According to US Defense Department documents leaked in March 2023, National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby refused to verify the number but validated “a small US military presence” there.

    A recent The New York Times report based on interviews with more than 200 current and former officials showed that there were “scores”, at least more than 40, of CIA officers in Ukraine.

    In a transcript of a February 19 conversation between senior German Air Force officials, one official stated, “It’s known that there are numerous people there in civilian attire who speak with an American accent.”

    It further exposed that there are UK personnel on the ground. One official, amid discussions on how German Taurus long-range missiles could function in Ukraine, revealed that the Germans “know how the English do it. . .. They have several people on-site.”

    The British prime minister’s office has verified that the UK has soldiers on the ground saying

    Beyond the small number of personnel we do have in the country supporting the armed forces of Ukraine, we haven’t got any plans for large-scale deployment

    Russia, since 2022, has repeatedly warned the US and its Western allies, including France, against partaking in the war, emphasizing that it will defend itself in any way possible. It also stressed that the West and NATO have been playing a direct role by continuously aiding Ukraine with advanced weapons and military equipment [end]

    The original article

  • Images du jour : EPER, personne morale

    deux Français sont tués en Ukraine le 1er février 2024

    En début de soirée, le 1er février 2024, le parquet ukrainien annonce qu’à Berislav, sur la rive droite du Dniepr, environ 75 km en amont de Kherson, une attaque de drones russes a tué vers 16:00 deux volontaires étrangers. Trois autres ont été blessés. Pour sa part, l’autorité administrative locale confirme ensuite la mort de deux Français.

    La presse ukrainienne aux ordres précise plus tard que ces volontaires étaient des civils, des travailleurs humanitaires, ce que les premières déclarations officielles n’ont pas infirmé, ni affirmé.

    Dans la nuit, la presse française commence à rapporter les déclarations des autorités ukrainiennes et souligne que malgré la demande de l’AFP, le quai d’Orsay n’a pas encore réagi. Il devra s’y résoudre sous la pression médiatique. Le gouvernement ne s’exprime qu’en fin de matinée, le 2 février, par le clavier sur X du ministre Stéphane Séjourné, procédure inhabituelle qui remplace le communiqué de presse du ministère

    La barbarie russe a visé des civils en Ukraine. Deux humanitaires français ont payé leur engagement auprès des Ukrainiens de leur vie. Trois sont blessés. Mes pensées vont vers eux et leurs proches. La France se tient à leurs côtés. La Russie devra répondre de ses crimes

    Plusieurs paradoxes intriguent l’observateur suspicieux. À l’occasion des précédents décès violents confirmés, la coutume consistait généralement à désigner les défunts, le plus souvent combattants, par leurs prénoms et la première lettre de leurs noms, rien dans le cas présent. En outre, aucune ONG n’a encore communiqué pour déplorer des pertes. Selon le Monde, ils travaillaient pour l’association Entraide protestante suisse, connue sous l’acronyme allemand EPER, qui revendique le pain pour le prochain. Le 19 décembre 2023, un drone russe frappa le bureau de l’EPER à Kherson. Probablement une attaque ciblée, mais certainement pas pour y tuer des poulets.

    Pourtant peu suspects de sympathie pour la cause russe, même des journalistes français, dans la plupart des articles en ligne, placent le mot humanitaires entre guillemets et lui ajoutent selon Paris.

    Une demi-heure après le ministre des affaires étrangères, Emmanuel Macron puis Volodymyr Zelenskyy se succèdent sur les réseaux sociaux, dans une opération concertée de propagande, pour dénoncer un acte lâche et indigne. Dont les victimes ne sont toujours pas connues, car en début d’après-midi, l’EPER se manifeste enfin, par un communiqué laconique, sans les identifier.

    L’apothéose se produit dans la soirée du 2 février. En raison de la mort des deux Français, le Parquet national antiterroriste (PNAT) ouvre d’initiative une enquête contre la Russie. Si le ridicule tuait en France, des figures comme Jean-François Ricard auraient été arrachées depuis longtemps à l’affection des Français. Qui doivent à de tels organismes de courtisans leur protection, que le monde entier ne leur envie pas, contre le terrorisme. Un indice supplémentaire que le drone russe de Berislav n’a pas manqué sa cible.

    Des hommages sur le web et fuites dans la presse permettent le 3 février d’identifier les deux humanitaires, selon Stéphane Séjourné et Emmanuel Macron. Mais en raison de leurs personnalités conjuguées, je vois plutôt des opérateurs missionnés par le gouvernement français

    Guennadi Guermanovitch, 52 ans, a été policier scientifique biélorusse jusqu’en 1996, puis légionnaire du 2e REP (régiment étranger de parachutistes) jusqu’en 2007, au 3e REI (régiment étranger d’infanterie) de Kourou, Guyane, jusqu’en 2009. Spécialiste des transmissions, il était entrepreneur en sûreté privée, formait des Ukrainiens à son art depuis 2019

    Adrien Baudon de Mony Pajol, 42 ans, était homme d’affaires et spécialiste vinicole au large réseau international, le profil idéal d’un honorable correspondant de la DGSE. SKEP, Société Khersonaise d’Élevage de Poulets.

  • [Sharing] The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat – Jacques Baud, The Postil Magazine

    We are very happy to bring you this excerpt from Colonel Jacques Baud’s latest book, The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat (L’art de la guerre russe : Comment l’Occident conduisit l’Ukraine à l’échec). This is a detailed study of the two-year old conflict in which the West has brutally used the Ukrainians to pursue an old pipedream: the conquest of Russia.

    The book is being translated into English, and we will update this page when it is published. In the meantime, we provide a generous excerpt, along with a detailed Table of Contents, to give you a taste of this very important and much-needed book.

    Russian Military Thought

    Throughout the Cold War period, the Soviet Union saw itself as the spearhead of a historical struggle that would lead to a confrontation between the “capitalist” system and “progressive forces.” This perception of a permanent and inescapable war led the Soviets to study war in a quasi-scientific way, and to structure this thinking into an architecture of military thought that has no equal in the Western world.

    The problem with the vast majority of our so-called military experts is their inability to understand the Russian approach to war. It is the result of an approach we have already seen in waves of terrorist attacks—the adversary is so stupidly demonized that we refrain from understanding his way of thinking. As a result, we are unable to develop strategies, articulate our forces, or even equip them for the realities of war. The corollary of this approach is that our frustrations are translated by unscrupulous media into a narrative that feeds hatred and increases our vulnerability. We are thus unable to find rational, effective solutions to the problem.

    The way Russians understand conflict is holistic. In other words, they see the processes that develop and lead to the situation at any given moment. This explains why Vladimir Putin’s speeches invariably include a return to history. In the West, we tend to focus on X moment and try to see how it might evolve. We want an immediate response to the situation we see today. The idea that “from the understanding of how the crisis arose comes the way to resolve it” is totally foreign to the West. In September 2023, an English-speaking journalist even pulled out the “duck test” for me: “if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, it’s probably a duck.” In other words, all the West needs to assess a situation is an image that fits their prejudices. Reality is much more subtle than the duck model….

    The reason the Russians are better than the West in Ukraine is that they see the conflict as a process; whereas we see it as a series of separate actions. The Russians see events as a film. We see them as photographs. They see the forest, while we focus on the trees. That is why we place the start of the conflict on February 24, 2022, or the start of the Palestinian conflict on October 7, 2023. We ignore the contexts that bother us and wage conflicts we do not understand. That is why we lose our wars…

    ****

    In Russia, unsurprisingly, the principles of the military art of the Soviet forces inspired those currently in use:

    • readiness to carry out assigned missions;
    • concentration of efforts on solving a specific mission;
    • surprise (unconventionality) of military action vis-à-vis the enemy;
    • finality determines a set of tasks and the level of resolution of each one;
    • totality of available means determines the way to resolve the mission and achieve the objective (correlation of forces);
    • coherence of leadership (unity of command);
    • economy of forces, resources, time and space;
    • support and restoration of combat capability;
    • freedom of maneuver.

    It should be noted that these principles apply not only to the implementation of military action as such. They are also applicable as a system of thought to other non-operational activities.

    An honest analysis of the conflict in Ukraine would have identified these various principles and drawn useful conclusions for Ukraine. But none of the self-proclaimed experts on TV were intellectually able to do so.

    Thus, Westerners are systematically surprised by the Russians in the fields of technology (e.g., hypersonic weapons), doctrine (e.g., operative art) and economics (e.g., resilience to sanctions). In a way, the Russians are taking advantage of our prejudices to exploit the principle of surprise. We can see this in the Ukrainian conflict, where the Western narrative led Ukraine to totally underestimate Russian capabilities, which was a major factor in its defeat. That is why Russia did not really try to counter this narrative and let it play out—the belief that we are superior makes us vulnerable….

    Correlation of Forces

    Russian military thought is traditionally linked to a holistic approach to warfare, which involves the integration of a large number of factors in the development of a strategy. This approach is materialized by the concept of “correlation of forces” (Соотношение сил).

    Often translated as “balance of forces” or “ratio of forces,” this concept is only understood by Westerners as a quantitative quantity, limited to the military domain. In Soviet thinking, however, the correlation of forces reflected a more holistic reading of war:

    There are several criteria for assessing the correlation of strengths. In the economic sphere, the factors usually compared are gross national product per capita, labor productivity, the dynamics of economic growth, the level of industrial production, particularly in high-tech sectors, the technical infrastructure of the production tool, the resources and degree of qualification of the workforce, the number of specialists and the level of development of theoretical and applied sciences.

    In the military field, the factors compared are the quantity and quality of armaments, the firepower of the armed forces, the fighting and moral qualities of the soldiers, the level of staff training, the organization of the troops and their combat experience, the character of the military doctrine and the methods of strategic, operative and tactical thinking.

    In the political sphere, the factors that come into consideration are the breadth of the social base of state authority, its organization, the constitutional procedure for relations between the government and legislative bodies, the ability to take operational decisions, and the degree and character of popular support for domestic and foreign policy.

    Finally, when assessing the strength of the international movement, the factors taken into consideration are its quantitative composition, its influence with the masses, its position in the political life of each country, the principles and norms of relations between its components and the degree of their cohesion.

    In other words, the assessment of the situation is not limited to the balance of forces on the battlefield, but takes into account all the elements that have an impact on the evolution of the conflict. Thus, for their Special Military Operation, the Russian authorities had planned to support the war effort through the economy, without moving to a “war economy” regime. Thus, unlike in Ukraine, there was no interruption in the tax and welfare mechanisms.

    This is why the sanctions applied to Russia in 2014 had a double positive effect. The first was the realization that they were not only a short-term problem, but above all a medium- and long-term opportunity. They encouraged Russia to produce goods it had previously preferred to buy abroad. The second was the signal that the West would increasingly use economic weapons as a means of pressure in the future. It therefore became imperative, for reasons of national independence and sovereignty, to prepare for more far-reaching sanctions affecting the country’s economy.

    In reality, it has long been known that sanctions do not work. Logically enough, they have had the opposite effect, acting as protectionist measures for Russia, which has thus been able to consolidate its economy, as had been the case after the 2014 sanctions. A sanctions strategy might have paid off if the Russian economy had effectively been the equivalent of the Italian or Spanish economy, i.e., with a high level of debt; and if the entire planet had acted in unison to isolate Russia.

    The inclusion of the correlation of forces in the decision-making process is a fundamental difference from Western decision-making processes, which are linked more to a policy of communication than to a rational approach to problems.

    This explains, for example, Russia’s limited objectives in the Ukraine, where it does not seek to occupy the entire territory, as the correlation of forces in the western part of the country would be unfavorable.

    At every level of leadership, the correlation of forces is part of situation assessment. At the operational level, it is defined as follows:

    The result of comparing the quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the forces and resources (sub-units, units, weapons, military equipment, etc.) of one’s own troops (forces) and those of the enemy. It is calculated on an operational and tactical scale throughout the area of operations, in the main and other directions, in order to determine the degree of objective superiority of one of the opposing camps. Force correlation assessment is used to make an informed decision about an operation (battle), and to establish and maintain the necessary superiority over the enemy for as long as possible, when decisions are redefined (modified) during military (combat) operations.

    This simple definition is the reason why the Russians committed themselves with forces inferior to those of Ukraine in February 2022, or why they withdrew from Kiev, Kharkov and Kherson in March, September and October 2022.

    ****

    Structure of the Doctrine

    The Russians have always attached particular importance to doctrine. Better than the West, they have understood that “a common way of seeing, thinking and acting”—as Marshal Foch put it—gives coherence, while allowing for infinite variations in the conception of operations. Military doctrine is a kind of “common core” that serves as a reference for designing operations.

    Russian military doctrine divides military art into three main components: strategy (strategiya), operative art (operativnoe iskoustvo) and tactics (taktika). Each of these components has its own characteristics, very similar to those found in Western doctrines. Using the terminology of French doctrine on the use of forces:

    • The strategic level is that of conception. The aim of strategic action is to lead the adversary to negotiation or defeat.
    • The operative level is that of cooperation and coordination of inter-force actions, with a view to achieving a given military objective.
    • The tactical level, finally, is that of maneuver execution at weapon level as an integral part of the operational maneuver.

    These three components correspond to levels of leadership, which translate into leadership structures and the space in which military operations are conducted. For simplicity’s sake, let us say that the strategic level ensures the management of the theater of war (Театр Войны) (TV); a geographically vast entity, with its own command and control structures, within which there are one or more strategic directions. The theater of war comprises a set of theaters of military operations (Театр Военных Действий) (TVD), which represent a strategic direction and are the domain of operative action. These various theaters have no predetermined structure and are defined according to the situation. For example, although we commonly speak of the “war in Afghanistan” (1979-1989) or the “war in Syria” (2015-), these countries are considered in Russian terminology as TVDs and not TVs.

    The same applies to Ukraine, which Russia sees as a theater of military operations (TVD) and not a theater of war (TV), which explains why the action in Ukraine is designated as a “Special Military Operation” (Специальная Военная Операция – Spetsial’naya Voyennaya Operatsiya—SVO, or SMO in English abbreviation) and not a “war.”

    The use of the word “war” would imply a different structure of conduct than that envisaged by the Russians in Ukraine, and would have other structural implications in Russia itself. Moreover—and this is a central point—as NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg himself acknowledges, “the war began in 2014” and should have been ended by the Minsk Agreements. The SMO is therefore a “military operation” and not a new “war,” as many Western “experts” claim.

    ****

    The Special Military Operation in Ukraine

    The Correlation of Forces

    Consider all the factors that directly or indirectly influence the conflict. Conversely, as we have seen in Ukraine and elsewhere, Westerners have a much more political reading of the war, and end up mixing the two. This is why communication plays such an essential role in the conduct of war: the perception of the conflict plays an almost more important role than its reality. This is why, in Iraq, the Americans literally invented episodes that glorified their troops.

    Russia’s analysis of the situation in February 2022 was undoubtedly considerably more pertinent than that of the West. They knew that a Ukrainian offensive against the Donbass was underway and that it could endanger the government. In 2014-2015, after the massacres in Odessa and Mariupol, the Russian population was very much in favor of intervention. Vladimir Putin’s stubborn clinging to the Minsk Agreements was poorly understood in Russia.

    The factors that contributed to Russia’s decision to intervene were twofold: the expected support of Ukraine’s ethnically Russian population (which we will call “Russian-speaking” for convenience) and an economy robust enough to withstand sanctions.

    The Russian-speaking population had risen up en masse against the new authorities following the coup d’état of February 2014, whose first decision had been to strip the Russian language of its official status. Kiev tried to backtrack, but in April 2019, the 2014 decision was definitively confirmed.

    Since the adoption of the Law on Indigenous Peoples on July 1, 2021, Russian speakers (ethnic Russians) are no longer considered normal Ukrainian citizens and no longer enjoy the same rights as ethnic Ukrainians. They can therefore be expected to offer no resistance to the Russian coalition in the eastern part of the country….

    Since March 24, 2021, Ukrainian forces have been stepping up their presence around the Donbass and have increased the pressure against the autonomists with their fire.

    Zelensky’s decree of March 24, 2021 for the reconquest of Crimea and the Donbass was the real trigger for the SMO. From that moment on, the Russians understood that if there was military action against them, they would have to intervene. But they also knew that the cause of the Ukrainian operation was NATO membership, as Oleksei Arestovitch had explained. That is why, in mid-December 2021, they were submitting proposals to the USA and NATO on extending the Alliance: their aim was then to remove Ukraine’s motive for an offensive in the Donbass.

    The reason for the Russian Special Military Operation (SMO) is indeed the protection of the populations of Donbass; but this protection was necessary because of Kiev’s desire to go through a confrontation to enter NATO. The extension of NATO is therefore only the indirect cause of the conflict in Ukraine. The latter could have spared itself this ordeal by implementing the Minsk Agreements—but what we wanted was a defeat for Russia.

    In 2008, Russia intervened in Georgia to protect the Russian minority then being bombed by its government, as confirmed by the Swiss ambassador, Heidi Tagliavini, who was responsible for investigating this event. In 2014, many voices were raised in Russia to demand intervention when the new regime in Kiev had engaged its army against the civilian population of the five autonomist oblasts (Odessa, Dnepropetrovsk, Kharkov, Lugansk and Donetsk) and applied a fierce repression. In 2022, it could be expected that the population of Russia would not understand the government’s inaction, after no efforts were made from the Ukrainian and Western sides to enforce the Minsk Agreements. They knew that they did not have the means to launch an economic retaliation. But they also knew that an economic war against Russia would inevitably backfire on Western countries.

    An important element of Russian military and political thinking is its legalistic dimension. The way our media present events, systematically omitting facts that could explain, justify, legitimize or even legalize Russia’s actions. We tend to think that Russia is acting outside any legal framework. For example, our media present the Russian intervention in Syria as having been decided unilaterally by Moscow; whereas it was carried out at the request of the Syrian government, after the West had allowed the Islamic State to move closer to Damascus, as confessed by John Kerry, then Secretary of State. Nevertheless, there is never any mention of the occupation of eastern Syria by American troops, who were never even invited there!

    We could multiply the examples, to which our journalists will counter with the war crimes committed by Russian forces. This may well be true, but the simple fact that these accusations are not based on any impartial and neutral investigation (as required by humanitarian doctrine), nor on any international one, since Russia is systematically refused participation, casts a shadow over the honesty of these accusations. For example, the sabotage of the Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines was immediately attributed to Russia, which was accused of violating international law.

    In fact, unlike the West, which advocates a “rules-based international order,” the Russians insist on a “law-based international order.” Unlike the West, they will apply the law to the letter. No more, no less.

    The legal framework for Russia’s intervention in Ukraine has been meticulously planned. As this subject has already been covered in one of my previous books, I will not go into details here…

    ****

    The Objectives and Strategy of Russia

    On February 23, 2023, Swiss military “expert” Alexandre Vautravers commented on Russia’s objectives in Ukraine:

    The aim of the Special Military Operation was to decapitate Ukrainian political and military governance in the space of five, ten, maybe even two weeks. The Russians then changed their plan and their objectives with a number of other failures; so they change their objectives and their strategic orientations almost every week or every month.

    The problem is that our “experts” themselves define Russia’s objectives according to what they imagine, only to be able to say that it has not achieved them. So. Let us get back to the facts.

    On February 24, 2022, Russia launched its “Special Military Operation” (SMO) in Ukraine “at short notice.” In his televised address, Vladimir Putin explained that its strategic objective was to protect the population of Donbass. This objective can be broken down into two parts:

    • “demilitarize” the Ukrainian armed forces regrouped in the Donbass in preparation for the offensive against the DPR and LPR; and
    • “denazify” (i.e. “neutralize”) the ultra-nationalist and neo-Nazi paramilitary militias in the Mariupol area.

    The formulation chosen by Vladimir Putin has been very poorly analyzed in the West. It is inspired by the 1945 Potsdam Declaration, which envisaged the development of defeated Germany according to four principles: demilitarization, denazification, democratization and decentralization.

    The Russians understand war from a Clausewitzian perspective: war is the pursuit of politics by other means. This then means that they seek to transform operational successes into strategic successes, and military successes into political objectives. So, while the demilitarization evoked by Putin is clearly linked to the military threat to the populations of the Donbass in application of the decree of March 24, 2021, signed by Zelensky.

    But this objective conceals a second: the neutralization of Ukraine as a future NATO member. This is what Zelensky understood when he proposed a resolution to the conflict in March 2022. At first, his proposal was supported by Western countries, probably because at this stage they believed that Russia had failed in its bid to take over Ukraine in three days, and that it would not be able to sustain its war effort because of the massive sanctions imposed on it. But at the NATO meeting of March 24, 2022, the Allies decided not to support Zelensky’s proposition.

    Nevertheless, on March 27, Zelensky publicly defended his proposal and on March 28, as a gesture of support for this effort, Vladimir Putin eased the pressure on the capital and withdrew his troops from the area. Zelensky’s proposal served as the basis for the Istanbul Communiqué of March 29, 2022, a ceasefire agreement as a prelude to a peace agreement. It was this document that Vladimir Putin presented in June 2023, when an African delegation visited Moscow. It was Boris Johnson’s intervention that prompted Zelensky to withdraw his proposal, exchanging peace and the lives of his men for support “for as long as it takes.”

    This version of events—which I have already presented in my previous works—was finally confirmed in early November 2023 by David Arakhamia, then chief negotiator for Ukraine196. He explained that Russia had never intended to seize Kiev.

    In essence, Russia agreed to withdraw to the borders of February 23, 2022, in exchange for a ceiling on Ukrainian forces and a commitment not to become a NATO member, along with security guarantees from a number of countries….

    Two conclusions can be drawn:

    • Russia’s objective was not to conquer territory. If the West had not intervened to push Zelensky to withdraw his offer, Ukraine would probably still have its army.
    • While the Russians intervened to ensure the security and protection of the population of the Donbass, their SMO enabled them to achieve a broader objective, which involves Russia’s security.

    This means that, although this objective is not formulated, the demilitarization of Ukraine could open the door to its neutralization. This is not surprising since, conversely, in an interview with the Ukrainian channel Apostrof’ on March 18, 2019, Volodymyr Zelensky’s advisor Oleksei Arestovitch cynically explains that, because Ukraine wants to join NATO, it will have to create the conditions for Russia to attack Ukraine and be definitively defeated.

    The problem is that Ukrainian and Western analysis is fueled by their own narratives. The conviction that Russia will lose has meant that no alternative contingency has been prepared. In September 2023, the West, beginning to see the collapse of this narrative and its implementation, tried to move towards a “freeze” in the conflict, without taking into account the opinion of the Russians, who dominate on the ground.

    Yet Russia would have been satisfied with a situation such as that proposed by Zelensky in March 2022. What the West wants in September 2023 is merely a pause until an even more violent conflict breaks out, after Ukrainian forces have been rearmed and reconstituted.

    ****

    Ukrainian Strategy

    The strategic objective of Volodymyr Zelensky and his team is to join NATO, as a prelude to a brighter future within the EU. It complements that of the Americans (and therefore of the Europeans). The problem is that tensions with Russia, particularly over Crimea, are causing NATO members to put off Ukraine’s participation. In March 2022, Zelensky revealed on CNN that this is exactly what the Americans told him.

    Before coming to power in April 2019, Volodymyr Zelensky’s discourse was divided between two antagonistic policies: the reconciliation with Russia promised during his presidential campaign and his goal of joining NATO. He knows that these two policies are mutually exclusive, as Russia does not want to see NATO and its nuclear weapons installed in Ukraine and wanted neutrality or non-alignment.

    What is more, he knows that his ultra-nationalist allies will refuse to negotiate with Russia. This was confirmed by Praviy Sektor leader Dmitro Yarosh, who openly threatened him with death in the Ukrainian media a month after his election. Zelensky therefore knew from the start of the election campaign that he would not be able to fulfill his promise of reconciliation, and that there was only one solution left: confrontation with Russia.

    But this confrontation could not be waged by Ukraine alone against Russia, and it would need the material support of the West. The strategy devised by Zelensky and his team was revealed before his election in March 2019 by Oleksei Arestovitch, his personal advisor, on the Ukrainian media Apostrof’. Arestovitch explained that it would take an attack by Russia to provoke an international mobilization that would enable Ukraine to defeat Russia once and for all, with the help of Western countries and NATO. With astonishing precision, he described the course of the Russian attack as it would unfold three years later, between February and March 2022. Not only did he explain that this conflict was unavoidable if Ukraine is to join NATO, but he also placed this confrontation in 2021-2022! He outlined the main areas of Western aid:

    In this conflict, we will be very actively supported by the West. Weapons. Equipment. Assistance. New sanctions against Russia. Most likely, the introduction of a NATO contingent. A no-fly zone, and so on. In other words, we won’t lose it.

    As we can see, this strategy has much in common with the one described by the RAND Corporation at the same time. So much so, in fact, that it is hard not to see it as a strategy strongly inspired by the United States. In his interview, Arestovitch singled out four elements that would become the pillars of the Ukrainian strategy against Russia, and to which Zelensky returned regularly:

    • International aid and arms supplies,
    • International sanctions,
    • NATO intervention,
    • Creation of a no-fly zone.

    It should be noted that these four pillars are understood by Zelensky as promises whose fulfillment is essential to the success of this strategy. In February 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of Ukraine’s Defense and National Security Council, declared in The Kyiv Independent that Ukraine’s objective was the disintegration of Russia. The mobilization of Western countries to supply Ukraine with heavy weapons then seems to give substance to this objective, which is consistent with what Oleksiy Arestovich had declared in March 2019.

    A few months later, however, it became clear that the equipment supplied to Ukraine was not sufficient to ensure the success of its counter-offensive, and Zelensky asked for additional, better-adapted equipment. At this point, there was a certain amount of Western irritation at these repeated demands. Former British Defense Minister Ben Wallace declared that Westerners “are not Amazon.” In fact, the West does not respect its commitments.

    Contrary to what our media and pseudo-military experts tell us, since February 2022, it has been clear that Ukraine cannot defeat Russia on its own. As Obama put it, “Russia [there] will always be able to maintain its escalation dominance.” In other words, Ukraine will only be able to achieve its goals with the involvement of NATO countries. This means that its fate will depend on the goodwill of Western countries. So, we need to maintain a narrative that encourages the West to keep up this effort. This narrative will then become what we call, in strategic terms, its “center of gravity.”

    As the months went by, the course of operations showed that the prospect of a Ukrainian victory was becoming increasingly remote, as Russia, far from being weakened, was growing stronger, militarily and economically. Even General Christopher Cavoli, Supreme American Commander Europe (SACEUR), told a US congressional committee that “Russia’s air, naval, space, digital and strategic capabilities have not suffered significant degradation during this war.”

    The West, expecting a short conflict, is no longer able to maintain the effort promised to Ukraine. The NATO summit in Vilnius (July 11-12, 2023) ended in partial success for Ukraine. Its membership is postponed indefinitely. Its situation is even worse than it was at the beginning of 2022, since there is no more justification for its entry into NATO than there was before the SMO.

    Ukraine then turned its attention to a more concrete objective: regaining sovereignty over its entire 1991 territory.

    Thus, the Ukrainian notion of “victory” rapidly evolved. The idea of a “collapse of Russia” quickly faded, as did that of its dismemberment. There was talk of “regime change,” which Zelensky made his objective by forbidding any negotiations as long as Vladimir Putin was in power. Then came the reconquest of lost territories, thanks to the counter-offensive of 2023. But here, too, hopes quickly faded. The plan was simply to cut the Russian forces in two, with a thrust towards the Sea of Azov. But by September 2023, this objective had been reduced to the liberation of three cities.

    In the absence of concrete successes, narrative remains the only element Ukraine can rely on to maintain Western attention and willingness to support it. For, as Ben Wallace, ex-Defence Minister, put it in The Telegraph on October 1, 2023: “The most precious commodity is hope.” True enough. But Western appraisal of the situation must be based on realistic analyses of the adversary. However, since the beginning of the Ukrainian crisis, Western analyses have been based on prejudice.

    ****

    The Notion of Victory

    Russia operates within a framework of Clausewitzian thinking, in which operational successes are exploited for strategic ends. Operational strategy (“operative art”) therefore plays an essential role in the definition of what is considered a victory.

    As we saw during the battle of Bakhmut, the Russians adapted perfectly to the strategy imposed on Ukraine by the West, which prioritizes the defense of every square meter. The Ukrainians thus played into the hands of the attrition strategy officially announced by Russia. Conversely, in Kharkov and Kherson, the Russians preferred to cede territory in exchange for the lives of their men. In the context of a war of attrition, sacrificing potential in exchange for territory, as Ukraine is doing, is the worst strategy of all.

    This is why General Zaluzhny, commander of the Ukrainian forces, tried to oppose Zelensky and proposed withdrawing his forces from Bakhmut. But in Ukraine, it is the Western narrative that guides military decisions. Zelensky preferred to follow the path laid out for him by our media, in order to retain the support of Western opinion. In November 2023, General Zaluzhny had to openly admit that this decision was a mistake, because prolonging the war will only favor Russia.

    The Ukrainian conflict was inherently asymmetrical. The West wanted to turn it into a symmetrical conflict, proclaiming that Ukraine’s capabilities could be enough to topple Russia. But this was clearly wishful thinking from the outset, and its sole purpose was to justify non-compliance with the Minsk Agreements. Russian strategists have turned it into an asymmetrical conflict.

    Ukraine’s problem in this conflict is that it has no rational relationship with the notion of victory. By comparison, the Palestinians, who are aware of their quantitative inferiority, have switched to a way of thinking that gives the simple act of resisting a sense of victory. This is the asymmetrical nature of the conflict that Israel has never managed to understand in 75 years, and which it is reduced to overcoming through tactical superiority rather than strategic finesse. In Ukraine, it is the same phenomenon. By clinging to a notion of victory linked to the recovery of territory, Ukraine has locked itself into a logic that can only lead to defeat.

    On November 20, 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of the National Security and Defense Council, painted a gloomy picture of Ukrainian prospects for 2024. His speech showed that Ukraine had neither a plan to emerge from the conflict, nor an approach that would associate a sense of victory with that emergence: he was reduced to linking Ukraine’s victory to that of the West. In the West, however, the end of the conflict in Ukraine is increasingly perceived as a military, political, human and economic debacle.

    In an asymmetrical situation, each protagonist is free to define his or her own criteria for victory, and to choose from a range of criteria under his or her control. This is why Egypt (1973), Hezbollah (2006), the Islamic State (2017), the Palestinian resistance since 1948 and Hamas in 2023 are victorious, despite massive losses. This seems counter-intuitive to a Western mind, but it is what explains why Westerners are unable to really “win” their wars.

    In Ukraine, the political leadership has locked itself into a narrative that precludes a way out of the crisis without losing face. The asymmetrical situation now working to Ukraine’s disadvantage stems from a narrative that has been confused with reality, and has led to a response that is ill-suited to the nature of the Russian operation [end]

    The original article

    Jacques Baud was a member of the Swiss strategic intelligence, a specialist of Eastern European and a former head of the United Nations peace operations doctrine. In NATO, he was involved in programs in Ukraine in 2014 and 2017

    related

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

  • [Sharing] How America Took Out The Nord Stream Pipeline – Seymour Hersh

    The New York Times called it a “mystery,” but the United States executed a covert sea operation that was kept secret—until now

    [Norway was in the thick of it. This article is a journalism lesson for a coterie of mediocre minions within Western mainstream media]

    NORD STREAM

    The U.S. Navy’s Diving and Salvage Center can be found in a location as obscure as its name—down what was once a country lane in rural Panama City, a now-booming resort city in the southwestern panhandle of Florida, 70 miles south of the Alabama border. The center’s complex is as nondescript as its location—a drab concrete post-World War II structure that has the look of a vocational high school on the west side of Chicago. A coin-operated laundromat and a dance school are across what is now a four-lane road.

    The center has been training highly skilled deep-water divers for decades who, once assigned to American military units worldwide, are capable of technical diving to do the good—using C4 explosives to clear harbors and beaches of debris and unexploded ordinance—as well as the bad, like blowing up foreign oil rigs, fouling intake valves for undersea power plants, destroying locks on crucial shipping canals. The Panama City center, which boasts the second largest indoor pool in America, was the perfect place to recruit the best, and most taciturn, graduates of the diving school who successfully did last summer what they had been authorized to do 260 feet under the surface of the Baltic Sea.

    Last June, the Navy divers, operating under the cover of a widely publicized mid-summer NATO exercise known as BALTOPS 22, planted the remotely triggered explosives that, three months later, destroyed three of the four Nord Stream pipelines, according to a source with direct knowledge of the operational planning.

    Two of the pipelines, which were known collectively as Nord Stream 1, had been providing Germany and much of Western Europe with cheap Russian natural gas for more than a decade. A second pair of pipelines, called Nord Stream 2, had been built but were not yet operational. Now, with Russian troops massing on the Ukrainian border and the bloodiest war in Europe since 1945 looming, President Joseph Biden saw the pipelines as a vehicle for Vladimir Putin to weaponize natural gas for his political and territorial ambitions.

    Asked for comment, Adrienne Watson, a White House spokesperson, said in an email, “This is false and complete fiction.” Tammy Thorp, a spokesperson for the Central Intelligence Agency, similarly wrote: “This claim is completely and utterly false.”

    Biden’s decision to sabotage the pipelines came after more than nine months of highly secret back and forth debate inside Washington’s national security community about how to best achieve that goal. For much of that time, the issue was not whether to do the mission, but how to get it done with no overt clue as to who was responsible.

    There was a vital bureaucratic reason for relying on the graduates of the center’s hardcore diving school in Panama City. The divers were Navy only, and not members of America’s Special Operations Command, whose covert operations must be reported to Congress and briefed in advance to the Senate and House leadership—the so-called Gang of Eight. The Biden Administration was doing everything possible to avoid leaks as the planning took place late in 2021 and into the first months of 2022.

    President Biden and his foreign policy team—National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan, Secretary of State Tony Blinken, and Victoria Nuland, the Undersecretary of State for Policy—had been vocal and consistent in their hostility to the two pipelines, which ran side by side for 750 miles under the Baltic Sea from two different ports in northeastern Russia near the Estonian border, passing close to the Danish island of Bornholm before ending in northern Germany.

    The direct route, which bypassed any need to transit Ukraine, had been a boon for the German economy, which enjoyed an abundance of cheap Russian natural gas—enough to run its factories and heat its homes while enabling German distributors to sell excess gas, at a profit, throughout Western Europe. Action that could be traced to the administration would violate US promises to minimize direct conflict with Russia. Secrecy was essential.

    From its earliest days, Nord Stream 1 was seen by Washington and its anti-Russian NATO partners as a threat to western dominance. The holding company behind it, Nord Stream AG, was incorporated in Switzerland in 2005 in partnership with Gazprom, a publicly traded Russian company producing enormous profits for shareholders which is dominated by oligarchs known to be in the thrall of Putin. Gazprom controlled 51 percent of the company, with four European energy firms—one in France, one in the Netherlands and two in Germany—sharing the remaining 49 percent of stock, and having the right to control downstream sales of the inexpensive natural gas to local distributors in Germany and Western Europe. Gazprom’s profits were shared with the Russian government, and state gas and oil revenues were estimated in some years to amount to as much as 45 percent of Russia’s annual budget.

    America’s political fears were real: Putin would now have an additional and much-needed major source of income, and Germany and the rest of Western Europe would become addicted to low-cost natural gas supplied by Russia—while diminishing European reliance on America. In fact, that’s exactly what happened. Many Germans saw Nord Stream 1 as part of the deliverance of former Chancellor Willy Brandt’s famed Ostpolitik theory, which would enable postwar Germany to rehabilitate itself and other European nations destroyed in World War II by, among other initiatives, utilizing cheap Russian gas to fuel a prosperous Western European market and trading economy.

    Nord Stream 1 was dangerous enough, in the view of NATO and Washington, but Nord Stream 2, whose construction was completed in September of 2021, would, if approved by German regulators, double the amount of cheap gas that would be available to Germany and Western Europe. The second pipeline also would provide enough gas for more than 50 percent of Germany’s annual consumption. Tensions were constantly escalating between Russia and NATO, backed by the aggressive foreign policy of the Biden Administration.

    Opposition to Nord Stream 2 flared on the eve of the Biden inauguration in January 2021, when Senate Republicans, led by Ted Cruz of Texas, repeatedly raised the political threat of cheap Russian natural gas during the confirmation hearing of Blinken as Secretary of State. By then a unified Senate had successfully passed a law that, as Cruz told Blinken, “halted [the pipeline] in its tracks.” There would be enormous political and economic pressure from the German government, then headed by Angela Merkel, to get the second pipeline online.

    Would Biden stand up to the Germans? Blinken said yes, but added that he had not discussed the specifics of the incoming President’s views. “I know his strong conviction that this is a bad idea, the Nord Stream 2,” he said. “I know that he would have us use every persuasive tool that we have to convince our friends and partners, including Germany, not to move forward with it.”

    A few months later, as the construction of the second pipeline neared completion, Biden blinked. That May, in a stunning turnaround, the administration waived sanctions against Nord Stream AG, with a State Department official conceding that trying to stop the pipeline through sanctions and diplomacy had “always been a long shot.” Behind the scenes, administration officials reportedly urged Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, by then facing a threat of Russian invasion, not to criticize the move.

    There were immediate consequences. Senate Republicans, led by Cruz, announced an immediate blockade of all of Biden’s foreign policy nominees and delayed passage of the annual defense bill for months, deep into the fall. Politico later depicted Biden’s turnabout on the second Russian pipeline as “the one decision, arguably more than the chaotic military withdrawal from Afghanistan, that has imperiled Biden’s agenda.” 

    The administration was floundering, despite getting a reprieve on the crisis in mid-November, when Germany’s energy regulators suspended approval of the second Nord Stream pipeline. Natural gas prices surged 8% within days, amid growing fears in Germany and Europe that the pipeline suspension and the growing possibility of a war between Russia and Ukraine would lead to a very much unwanted cold winter. It was not clear to Washington just where Olaf Scholz, Germany’s newly appointed chancellor, stood. Months earlier, after the fall of Afghanistan, Scholtz had publicly endorsed French President Emmanuel Macron’s call for a more autonomous European foreign policy in a speech in Prague—clearly suggesting less reliance on Washington and its mercurial actions.

    Throughout all of this, Russian troops had been steadily and ominously building up on the borders of Ukraine, and by the end of December more than 100,000 soldiers were in position to strike from Belarus and Crimea. Alarm was growing in Washington, including an assessment from Blinken that those troop numbers could be “doubled in short order.”

    The administration’s attention once again was focused on Nord Stream. As long as Europe remained dependent on the pipelines for cheap natural gas, Washington was afraid that countries like Germany would be reluctant to supply Ukraine with the money and weapons it needed to defeat Russia.

    It was at this unsettled moment that Biden authorized Jake Sullivan to bring together an interagency group to come up with a plan. 

    All options were to be on the table. But only one would emerge.

    PLANNING

    In December of 2021, two months before the first Russian tanks rolled into Ukraine, Jake Sullivan convened a meeting of a newly formed task force—men and women from the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the CIA, and the State and Treasury Departments—and asked for recommendations about how to respond to Putin’s impending invasion.

    It would be the first of a series of top-secret meetings, in a secure room on a top floor of the Old Executive Office Building, adjacent to the White House, that was also the home of the President’s Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board (PFIAB). There was the usual back and forth chatter that eventually led to a crucial preliminary question: Would the recommendation forwarded by the group to the President be reversible—such as another layer of sanctions and currency restrictions—or irreversible—that is, kinetic actions, which could not be undone?

    What became clear to participants, according to the source with direct knowledge of the process, is that Sullivan intended for the group to come up with a plan for the destruction of the two Nord Stream pipelines—and that he was delivering on the desires of the President.

    THE PLAYERS Left to right: Victoria Nuland, Anthony Blinken, and Jake Sullivan.

    Over the next several meetings, the participants debated options for an attack. The Navy proposed using a newly commissioned submarine to assault the pipeline directly. The Air Force discussed dropping bombs with delayed fuses that could be set off remotely. The CIA argued that whatever was done, it would have to be covert. Everyone involved understood the stakes. “This is not kiddie stuff,” the source said. If the attack were traceable to the United States, “It’s an act of war.”

    At the time, the CIA was directed by William Burns, a mild-mannered former ambassador to Russia who had served as deputy secretary of state in the Obama Administration. Burns quickly authorized an Agency working group whose ad hoc members included—by chance—someone who was familiar with the capabilities of the Navy’s deep-sea divers in Panama City. Over the next few weeks, members of the CIA’s working group began to craft a plan for a covert operation that would use deep-sea divers to trigger an explosion along the pipeline.

    Something like this had been done before. In 1971, the American intelligence community learned from still undisclosed sources that two important units of the Russian Navy were communicating via an undersea cable buried in the Sea of Okhotsk, on Russia’s Far East Coast. The cable linked a regional Navy command to the mainland headquarters at Vladivostok.

    A hand-picked team of Central Intelligence Agency and National Security Agency operatives was assembled somewhere in the Washington area, under deep cover, and worked out a plan, using Navy divers, modified submarines and a deep-submarine rescue vehicle, that succeeded, after much trial and error, in locating the Russian cable. The divers planted a sophisticated listening device on the cable that successfully intercepted the Russian traffic and recorded it on a taping system.

    The NSA learned that senior Russian navy officers, convinced of the security of their communication link, chatted away with their peers without encryption. The recording device and its tape had to be replaced monthly and the project rolled on merrily for a decade until it was compromised by a forty-four-year-old civilian NSA technician named Ronald Pelton who was fluent in Russian. Pelton was betrayed by a Russian defector in 1985 and sentenced to prison. He was paid just $5,000 by the Russians for his revelations about the operation, along with $35,000 for other Russian operational data he provided that was never made public.

    That underwater success, codenamed Ivy Bells, was innovative and risky, and produced invaluable intelligence about the Russian Navy’s intentions and planning.

    Still, the interagency group was initially skeptical of the CIA’s enthusiasm for a covert deep-sea attack. There were too many unanswered questions. The waters of the Baltic Sea were heavily patrolled by the Russian navy, and there were no oil rigs that could be used as cover for a diving operation. Would the divers have to go to Estonia, right across the border from Russia’s natural gas loading docks, to train for the mission? “It would be a goat fuck,” the Agency was told.

    Throughout “all of this scheming,” the source said, “some working guys in the CIA and the State Department were saying, ‘Don’t do this. It’s stupid and will be a political nightmare if it comes out.’”

    Nevertheless, in early 2022, the CIA working group reported back to Sullivan’s interagency group: “We have a way to blow up the pipelines.”

    What came next was stunning. On February 7, less than three weeks before the seemingly inevitable Russian invasion of Ukraine, Biden met in his White House office with German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, who, after some wobbling, was now firmly on the American team. At the press briefing that followed, Biden defiantly said, “If Russia invades . . . there will be no longer a Nord Stream 2. We will bring an end to it.”

    Twenty days earlier, Undersecretary Nuland had delivered essentially the same message at a State Department briefing, with little press coverage. “I want to be very clear to you today,” she said in response to a question. “If Russia invades Ukraine, one way or another Nord Stream 2 will not move forward.”

    Several of those involved in planning the pipeline mission were dismayed by what they viewed as indirect references to the attack.

    “It was like putting an atomic bomb on the ground in Tokyo and telling the Japanese that we are going to detonate it,” the source said. “The plan was for the options to be executed post invasion and not advertised publicly. Biden simply didn’t get it or ignored it.”

    Biden’s and Nuland’s indiscretion, if that is what it was, might have frustrated some of the planners. But it also created an opportunity. According to the source, some of the senior officials of the CIA determined that blowing up the pipeline “no longer could be considered a covert option because the President just announced that we knew how to do it.”

    The plan to blow up Nord Stream 1 and 2 was suddenly downgraded from a covert operation requiring that Congress be informed to one that was deemed as a highly classified intelligence operation with U.S. military support. Under the law, the source explained, “There was no longer a legal requirement to report the operation to Congress. All they had to do now is just do it—but it still had to be secret. The Russians have superlative surveillance of the Baltic Sea.”

    The Agency working group members had no direct contact with the White House, and were eager to find out if the President meant what he’d said—that is, if the mission was now a go. The source recalled, “Bill Burns comes back and says, ‘Do it.’”

    “The Norwegian navy was quick to find the right spot, in the shallow water a few miles off Denmark’s Bornholm Island . . .”

    THE OPERATION

    Norway was the perfect place to base the mission.

    In the past few years of East-West crisis, the U.S. military has vastly expanded its presence inside Norway, whose western border runs 1,400 miles along the north Atlantic Ocean and merges above the Arctic Circle with Russia. The Pentagon has created high paying jobs and contracts, amid some local controversy, by investing hundreds of millions of dollars to upgrade and expand American Navy and Air Force facilities in Norway. The new works included, most importantly, an advanced synthetic aperture radar far up north that was capable of penetrating deep into Russia and came online just as the American intelligence community lost access to a series of long-range listening sites inside China.

    A newly refurbished American submarine base, which had been under construction for years, had become operational and more American submarines were now able to work closely with their Norwegian colleagues to monitor and spy on a major Russian nuclear redoubt 250 miles to the east, on the Kola Peninsula. America also has vastly expanded a Norwegian air base in the north and delivered to the Norwegian air force a fleet of Boeing-built P8 Poseidon patrol planes to bolster its long-range spying on all things Russia.

    In return, the Norwegian government angered liberals and some moderates in its parliament last November by passing the Supplementary Defense Cooperation Agreement (SDCA). Under the new deal, the U.S. legal system would have jurisdiction in certain “agreed areas” in the North over American soldiers accused of crimes off base, as well as over those Norwegian citizens accused or suspected of interfering with the work at the base.

    Norway was one of the original signatories of the NATO Treaty in 1949, in the early days of the Cold War. Today, the supreme commander of NATO is Jens Stoltenberg, a committed anti-communist, who served as Norway’s prime minister for eight years before moving to his high NATO post, with American backing, in 2014. He was a hardliner on all things Putin and Russia who had cooperated with the American intelligence community since the Vietnam War. He has been trusted completely since. “He is the glove that fits the American hand,” the source said.

    Back in Washington, planners knew they had to go to Norway. “They hated the Russians, and the Norwegian navy was full of superb sailors and divers who had generations of experience in highly profitable deep-sea oil and gas exploration,” the source said. They also could be trusted to keep the mission secret. (The Norwegians may have had other interests as well. The destruction of Nord Stream—if the Americans could pull it off—would allow Norway to sell vastly more of its own natural gas to Europe.)

    Sometime in March, a few members of the team flew to Norway to meet with the Norwegian Secret Service and Navy. One of the key questions was where exactly in the Baltic Sea was the best place to plant the explosives. Nord Stream 1 and 2, each with two sets of pipelines, were separated much of the way by little more than a mile as they made their run to the port of Greifswald in the far northeast of Germany.

    The Norwegian navy was quick to find the right spot, in the shallow waters of the Baltic sea a few miles off Denmark’s Bornholm Island. The pipelines ran more than a mile apart along a seafloor that was only 260 feet deep. That would be well within the range of the divers, who, operating from a Norwegian Alta class mine hunter, would dive with a mixture of oxygen, nitrogen and helium streaming from their tanks, and plant shaped C4 charges on the four pipelines with concrete protective covers. It would be tedious, time consuming and dangerous work, but the waters off Bornholm had another advantage: there were no major tidal currents, which would have made the task of diving much more difficult.

    After a bit of research, the Americans were all in.

    At this point, the Navy’s obscure deep-diving group in Panama City once again came into play. The deep-sea schools at Panama City, whose trainees participated in Ivy Bells, are seen as an unwanted backwater by the elite graduates of the Naval Academy in Annapolis, who typically seek the glory of being assigned as a Seal, fighter pilot, or submariner. If one must become a “Black Shoe”—that is, a member of the less desirable surface ship command—there is always at least duty on a destroyer, cruiser or amphibious ship. The least glamorous of all is mine warfare. Its divers never appear in Hollywood movies, or on the cover of popular magazines.

    “The best divers with deep diving qualifications are a tight community, and only the very best are recruited for the operation and told to be prepared to be summoned to the CIA in Washington,” the source said.

    The Norwegians and Americans had a location and the operatives, but there was another concern: any unusual underwater activity in the waters off Bornholm might draw the attention of the Swedish or Danish navies, which could report it.  

    Denmark had also been one of the original NATO signatories and was known in the intelligence community for its special ties to the United Kingdom. Sweden had applied for membership into NATO, and had demonstrated its great skill in managing its underwater sound and magnetic sensor systems that successfully tracked Russian submarines that would occasionally show up in remote waters of the Swedish archipelago and be forced to the surface.

    The Norwegians joined the Americans in insisting that some senior officials in Denmark and Sweden had to be briefed in general terms about possible diving activity in the area. In that way, someone higher up could intervene and keep a report out of the chain of command, thus insulating the pipeline operation. “What they were told and what they knew were purposely different,” the source told me. (The Norwegian embassy, asked to comment on this story, did not respond.)

    The Norwegians were key to solving other hurdles. The Russian navy was known to possess surveillance technology capable of spotting, and triggering, underwater mines. The American explosive devices needed to be camouflaged in a way that would make them appear to the Russian system as part of the natural background—something that required adapting to the specific salinity of the water. The Norwegians had a fix.

    The Norwegians also had a solution to the crucial question of when the operation should take place. Every June, for the past 21 years, the American Sixth Fleet, whose flagship is based in Gaeta, Italy, south of Rome, has sponsored a major NATO exercise in the Baltic Sea involving scores of allied ships throughout the region. The current exercise, held in June, would be known as Baltic Operations 22, or BALTOPS 22. The Norwegians proposed this would be the ideal cover to plant the mines.

    The Americans provided one vital element: they convinced the Sixth Fleet planners to add a research and development exercise to the program. The exercise, as made public by the Navy, involved the Sixth Fleet in collaboration with the Navy’s “research and warfare centers.” The at-sea event would be held off the coast of Bornholm Island and involve NATO teams of divers planting mines, with competing teams using the latest underwater technology to find and destroy them.

    It was both a useful exercise and ingenious cover. The Panama City boys would do their thing and the C4 explosives would be in place by the end of BALTOPS22, with a 48-hour timer attached. All of the Americans and Norwegians would be long gone by the first explosion. 

    The days were counting down. “The clock was ticking, and we were nearing mission accomplished,” the source said.

    And then: Washington had second thoughts. The bombs would still be planted during BALTOPS, but the White House worried that a two-day window for their detonation would be too close to the end of the exercise, and it would be obvious that America had been involved.

    Instead, the White House had a new request: “Can the guys in the field come up with some way to blow the pipelines later on command?”

    Some members of the planning team were angered and frustrated by the President’s seeming indecision. The Panama City divers had repeatedly practiced planting the C4 on pipelines, as they would during BALTOPS, but now the team in Norway had to come up with a way to give Biden what he wanted—the ability to issue a successful execution order at a time of his choosing.  

    Being tasked with an arbitrary, last-minute change was something the CIA was accustomed to managing. But it also renewed the concerns some shared over the necessity, and legality, of the entire operation.

    The President’s secret orders also evoked the CIA’s dilemma in the Vietnam War days, when President Johnson, confronted by growing anti-Vietnam War sentiment, ordered the Agency to violate its charter—which specifically barred it from operating inside America—by spying on antiwar leaders to determine whether they were being controlled by Communist Russia.

    The agency ultimately acquiesced, and throughout the 1970s it became clear just how far it had been willing to go. There were subsequent newspaper revelations in the aftermath of the Watergate scandals about the Agency’s spying on American citizens, its involvement in the assassination of foreign leaders and its undermining of the socialist government of Salvador Allende.

    Those revelations led to a dramatic series of hearings in the mid-1970s in the Senate, led by Frank Church of Idaho, that made it clear that Richard Helms, the Agency director at the time, accepted that he had an obligation to do what the President wanted, even if it meant violating the law.

    In unpublished, closed-door testimony, Helms ruefully explained that “you almost have an Immaculate Conception when you do something” under secret orders from a President. “Whether it’s right that you should have it, or wrong that you shall have it, [the CIA] works under different rules and ground rules than any other part of the government.” He was essentially telling the Senators that he, as head of the CIA, understood that he had been working for the Crown, and not the Constitution.

    The Americans at work in Norway operated under the same dynamic, and dutifully began working on the new problem—how to remotely detonate the C4 explosives on Biden’s order. It was a much more demanding assignment than those in Washington understood. There was no way for the team in Norway to know when the President might push the button. Would it be in a few weeks, in many months or in half a year or longer?

    The C4 attached to the pipelines would be triggered by a sonar buoy dropped by a plane on short notice, but the procedure involved the most advanced signal processing technology. Once in place, the delayed timing devices attached to any of the four pipelines could be accidentally triggered by the complex mix of ocean background noises throughout the heavily trafficked Baltic Sea—from near and distant ships, underwater drilling, seismic events, waves and even sea creatures. To avoid this, the sonar buoy, once in place, would emit a sequence of unique low frequency tonal sounds—much like those emitted by a flute or a piano—that would be recognized by the timing device and, after a pre-set hours of delay, trigger the explosives. (“You want a signal that is robust enough so that no other signal could accidentally send a pulse that detonated the explosives,” I was told by Dr. Theodore Postol, professor emeritus of science, technology and national security policy at MIT. Postol, who has served as the science adviser to the Pentagon’s Chief of Naval Operations, said the issue facing the group in Norway because of Biden’s delay was one of chance: “The longer the explosives are in the water the greater risk there would be of a random signal that would launch the bombs.”)

    On September 26, 2022, a Norwegian Navy P8 surveillance plane made a seemingly routine flight and dropped a sonar buoy. The signal spread underwater, initially to Nord Stream 2 and then on to Nord Stream 1. A few hours later, the high-powered C4 explosives were triggered and three of the four pipelines were put out of commission. Within a few minutes, pools of methane gas that remained in the shuttered pipelines could be seen spreading on the water’s surface and the world learned that something irreversible had taken place.

    FALLOUT

    In the immediate aftermath of the pipeline bombing, the American media treated it like an unsolved mystery. Russia was repeatedly cited as a likely culprit, spurred on by calculated leaks from the White House—but without ever establishing a clear motive for such an act of self-sabotage, beyond simple retribution. A few months later, when it emerged that Russian authorities had been quietly getting estimates for the cost to repair the pipelines, the New York Times described the news as “complicating theories about who was behind” the attack. No major American newspaper dug into the earlier threats to the pipelines made by Biden and Undersecretary of State Nuland.

    While it was never clear why Russia would seek to destroy its own lucrative pipeline, a more telling rationale for the President’s action came from Secretary of State Blinken.

    Asked at a press conference last September about the consequences of the worsening energy crisis in Western Europe, Blinken described the moment as a potentially good one:

    “It’s a tremendous opportunity to once and for all remove the dependence on Russian energy and thus to take away from Vladimir Putin the weaponization of energy as a means of advancing his imperial designs. That’s very significant and that offers tremendous strategic opportunity for the years to come, but meanwhile we’re determined to do everything we possibly can to make sure the consequences of all of this are not borne by citizens in our countries or, for that matter, around the world.”

    More recently, Victoria Nuland expressed satisfaction at the demise of the newest of the pipelines. Testifying at a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing in late January she told Senator Ted Cruz, “​Like you, I am, and I think the Administration is, very gratified to know that Nord Stream 2 is now, as you like to say, a hunk of metal at the bottom of the sea.”

    The source had a much more streetwise view of Biden’s decision to sabotage more than 1500 miles of Gazprom pipeline as winter approached. “Well,” he said, speaking of the President, “I gotta admit the guy has a pair of balls.  He said he was going to do it, and he did.”

    Asked why he thought the Russians failed to respond, he said cynically, “Maybe they want the capability to do the same things the U.S. did.

    “It was a beautiful cover story,” he went on. “Behind it was a covert operation that placed experts in the field and equipment that operated on a covert signal.

    “The only flaw was the decision to do it.” [end]

    The original article

    Seymour Hersh is a venerable US investigative journalist, who received the 1970 Pulitzer Prize for exposing the My Lai massacre and its cover-up during the Vietnam war.

    my related piece

    US operatives have sabotaged Nord Stream

    a humble assessment on September 27, 2022 : the motive, the opportunity and the means