Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu
[my illustration: on September 6, 2023, his Ukrainian counterpart Dmitro Kuleba and Secretary of State Antony Blinken visit a Ukrainian cemetery, while the counter-offensive is a failure and the whole proxy war is a carnage for the Ukrainian cannon fodder (official)]
For almost three years, NATO countries have boycotted diplomatic contacts with Russia, even as hundreds of thousands of men have died on the battlefield. The decision by diplomats to reject diplomacy is morally repugnant as diplomacy could have reduced the excess of violence, prevented escalation, and even resulted in a path to peace. However, the political-media elites skilfully sold the rejection of diplomacy to the public as evidence of their moral righteousness.
This article will first outline how NATO planned for a long war to exhaust Russia and knock it out from the ranks of great powers. Second, this article will demonstrate how the political-media elites communicated that diplomacy is treasonous and war is virtuous.
NATO’s Long War
To exhaust Russia in a long war, the goal was to ensure that the Russians and Ukrainians kill each other for as long as possible. The US Secretary of Defence Lloyd Austin outlined the US objective in the Ukraine War as weakening its strategic adversary: “We want to see Russia weakened to the degree that it can’t do the kinds of things that it has done in invading Ukraine”.1 In late March 2022, Zelensky revealed in an interview with the Economist: “There are those in the West who don’t mind a long war because it would mean exhausting Russia, even if this means the demise of Ukraine and comes at the cost of Ukrainian lives”.2
The Israeli and Turkish mediators confirmed that Russia and Ukraine agreed to the terms of a peaceful settlement in Istanbul, in which Russia would withdraw its forces and Ukraine would restore its neutrality. However, why would the US and its allies accept that Ukraine return to neutrality, when the alternative was to use the powerful proxy army they had built in Ukraine to bleed and weaken Russia?3
The Turkish Foreign Minister acknowledged that there are “NATO member states that want the war to continue—let the war continue and Russia gets weaker. They don’t care much about the situation in Ukraine”.4 The former Israeli Prime Minister also confirmed that the US and UK “blocked” the peace agreement as there was a “decision by the West to keep striking Putin” to destroy a strategic rival.5 The retired German General, Harald Kujat, a former head of the German Bundeswehr and former chairman of the NATO Military Committee, also argued that this was a war deliberately provoked by NATO, while the US and UK sabotaged all paths to peace “to weaken Russia politically, economically and militarily”.6 Interviews with American and British leaders in March 2022, revealed that a decision had been made for “the conflict to be extended and thereby bleed Putin” as “the only end game now is the end of Putin regime”.7
Chas Freeman, the former US Assistant Secretary of Defence for International Security Affairs and Director for Chinese Affairs at the US State Department criticised Washington for the objective to prolong the fighting to “fight to the last Ukrainian”.8 Republican Senator Lindsey Graham argued that the US was in a favourable position as it could fight Russia to the last Ukrainian: “I like the structural path we’re on here. As long as we help Ukraine with the weapons they need and the economic support, they will fight to the last person”.9 Republican leader Mitch McConnell was similarly explicit:
the most basic reasons for continuing to help Ukraine degrade and defeat the Russian invaders are cold, hard, practical American interests. Helping equip our friends in Eastern Europe to win this war is also a direct investment in reducing Vladimir Putin’s future capabilities to menace America, threaten our allies, and contest our core interests.10
Senator Mitt Romney argued that financing the war was “the best national defense spending I think we’ve ever done” as “We’re diminishing and devastating the Russian military for a very small amount of money” and “we’re losing no lives in Ukraine”. US Congressman Dan Crenshaw also celebrated the proxy war as “investing in the destruction of our adversary’s military, without losing a single American troop, strikes me as a good idea”.11
Retired US General Keith Kellogg similarly called for extending the war in Ukraine as knocking out Russia would allow the US to focus on China: “if you can defeat a strategic adversary not using any US troops, you are at the acme of professionalism”. NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg shared this logic as he argued defeating Russia on the battlefield will make it easier for the US to focus also on China. Stoltenberg also noted that “if Ukraine wins, then you will have the second biggest army in Europe, the Ukrainian army, battle-hardened, on our side, and we’ll have a weakened Russian army”.12
Diplomacy as Treason and War as Virtue
When the decision had been made for a long war, the politicians and media began to construct narratives and a moral case for a long war, which would convince the public that diplomacy is treasonous, and war is virtuous.
Presenting the world as a struggle of good versus evil lays the foundation for effective war propaganda, as perpetual peace can be achieved by defeating the evil opponent while negotiations entail sacrificing indispensable values and principles. To this end, the Hitler analogy is very effective as diplomacy becomes dangerous appeasement while peace requires military victory. Reminiscent of George Orwell’s “war is peace”, Stoltenberg argues that weapons are the path to peace.
The Western public was reassured that fuelling the war was required to push Putin to the negotiation table, however, during almost three years of war the West never proposed negotiations. Reading the Western media, one gets the impression that Russia would not negotiate. However, Russia never opposed diplomacy or negotiations, it was the West that shut the door. So-called “peace summits” were held to give the public the impression that governments pursued peace, although Russia was not invited and the stated purpose was to mobilise public opinion and resources against Russia.
In November 2022, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Mark Milley argued for starting negotiations with Russia. Ukraine had just captured large swaths of territory in Kherson and Kharkov, and General Milley argued Ukraine would not be in a better position to negotiate a peace deal. General Milley was correct in this assessment, yet he neglected that the principal objective of the war was to keep it going to bleed Russia. General Milley had to walk back his statements that threatened to end the war.13
The EU almost always advocates for immediate diplomacy and negotiations in conflicts around the world. In Ukraine, the EU’s foreign policy chief at the beginning of the war, Josep Borrell, argued that the war would be won on the battlefield.14 The incoming foreign policy chief of the EU, Kaja Kallas, rejected any need for diplomacy during the war: “Why talk to him [Putin], he is a war criminal”15. Diplomacy now entails sitting in a room with people who agree with you, and pat each other on the shoulder for having isolated the adversary. The EU has completed its transition from a peace project to a geopolitical project.
Anyone suggesting to restore diplomacy or start negotiations is immediately smeared as a far-left or far-right pro-Russian stooge. It is hardly original to present the opposition to war as taking the side of the adversary, yet the accusation of treason is a powerful instrument to crush dissent. The Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban travelled to Ukraine, Russia, China, and the US (to meet with Trump) to explore the possibility of charting a path to peace. The EU responded by punishing Hungary and the political-media elites sought to delegitimise him as a puppet of Putin. The same script is applied to anyone suggesting to end the war.
Arguing against the dangerous precedent of “rewarding” Putin’s aggression with territory has been another seemingly moral argument against peace negotiations. However, this argument is based on the false premise that the war began as a territorial dispute. As we learned from the Istanbul peace agreement, Russia agreed to pull back its troops in return for Ukraine restoring its neutrality. Furthermore, the proxy war has been lost and Ukraine will only lose more men and territory with each passing day.
The Coming Backlash
As the Ukrainian frontlines collapse and their causalities subsequently intensify, the Americans are pushing Ukraine to lower its conscription age as sacrificing the youth could keep the war going for a bit longer. The Ukrainian public no longer wants to fight, desertions increase drastically, and “recruitment” consists of grabbing civilians off the streets and throwing them into vans that take them almost directly to the front lines. A recent Gallup poll found that there is not a single oblast in Ukraine where the majority support continuing the war.16
Oleksyi Arestovych, the former advisor to President Zelensky, predicted in 2019 that the threat of NATO expansion would “provoke Russia to launch a large-scale military operation against Ukraine”. NATO would then use the Ukrainian army to defeat Russia: “In this conflict, we will be very actively supported by the West—with weapons, equipment, assistance, new sanctions against Russia and the quite possible introduction of a NATO contingent, a no-fly zone etc. We won’t lose, and that’s good’.17
The war did not go as planned and Ukraine is being destroyed, and Arestovych recognises the folly of continuing the war. There is a growing realisation in Ukrainian society that NATO sabotaged the peace to fight Russia to the last Ukrainian. Ukrainians will resent Russia for decades to come, although there will also be hatred against the West. The war propagandists in the Western media will then surely act bewildered and blame Russian propaganda.
G. Carbonaro, ‘U.S. Wants Russia ‘Weakened’ So It Can Never Invade Again’, Newsweek, 25 April 2022. ↩︎
The Economist. ‘Volodymyr Zelensky on why Ukraine must defeat Putin’ The Economist, 27 March 2022. ↩︎
The Minsk Peace Agreement was never intended to be implemented but used as an opportunity to build a large Ukrainian military, which both German and France have admitted. ↩︎
R. Semonsen, ‘Former Israeli PM: West Blocked Russo-Ukraine Peace Deal’, The European Conservative, 7 February 2023. ↩︎
N. Bennett, ‘Bennett speaks out’, YouTube Channel of Naftali Bennett, 4 February 2023. ↩︎
Emma, ‘Russland will verhandeln!’ [Russia wants to negotiate!], Emma, 4 March 2023.↩︎
N. Ferguson, ‘Putin Misunderstands History. So, Unfortunately, Does the U.S.’, Bloomberg, 22 March 2022. ↩︎
A. Maté, ‘US fighting Russia ‘to the last Ukrainian’: veteran US diplomat’, The Grayzone, 24 March 2022. ↩︎
A. Maté, ‘US, UK sabotaged peace deal because they ‘don’t care about Ukraine’: fmr. NATO adviser’, The Grayzone, 27 September 2022. ↩︎
M. McConnell, ‘McConnell on Zelenskyy Visit: Helping Ukraine Directly Serves Core American Interests’, Mitch McConnell official website, 21 December 2022. ↩︎
L. Lonas, ‘Crenshaw, Greene clash on Twitter: ‘Still going after that slot on Russia Today’’, The Hill, 11 May 2022. ↩︎
T. O’Conner, ‘So, if the United States is concerned about China and wants to pivot towards Asia, then you have to ensure that Putin doesn’t win in in Ukraine’, Newsweek, 21 September 2023. ↩︎
Media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government have supported censorship, disseminated disinfo, and sought to silence American critics of the war
chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia
How are “death travel agencies” organized for those who like to hunt people in foreign lands, and who want to send regular French and Polish units to Ukraine?
French military in Ukraine. Why did Paris’s statements about its official dispatch alarm the whole of Europe, but did not surprise Moscow? Is it true that career officers of the French army appeared in the Donbass even before the start of the Northern Military District?
A new investigation of the “Evidence from the Past” program about the presence in Ukraine of foreign “soldiers of fortune” and military personnel of the regular troops of NATO countries. How many mercenaries from which countries are currently fighting on the side of the Ukrainian Armed Forces? How is the recruitment of thugs around the world going through Ukrainian embassies?
Through a risky and visual experiment, we will show the secret mechanics of recruiting mercenaries in Western Europe. How are “death travel agencies” organized for those who like to hunt people in foreign lands, and who want to send regular French and Polish units to Ukraine? Watch the new episode from the series “Evidence from the Past”
The embedding of the video is automatically censored
Our world is holding many secrets, from ancient mysteries and inexplicable miracles to incredible turns in human history. One thing is certain: these events are leaving us with more questions than answers. It would seem that nothing can shed light on these mysterious incidents, but is this so? Armed with the latest discoveries in science, we will try to get to the bottom of the truth, and evidence from the past will help in the investigation. Nothing will remain unsolved, because after any crime there remains evidence. In our case, this is evidence from the past.
English mercenaries, Poles, miraculously, the French survived. There are plenty of soldiers of fortune from European countries in Ukraine from the very beginning. Europe needs to prepare its regular units to be sent to Ukraine. We are certainly approaching a point in Europe where it will be appropriate not to be a coward. I think our countries are well aware that war has returned to our soil.
When asked whether France itself would send its troops to Ukraine, the president gave an unequivocal answer. Representatives of Britain and Germany, Canada and the United States hastened to soften Macron’s belligerent statements. President Biden has made it incredibly clear that the United States is opposed to sending troops to Ukraine, and the NATO Secretary General has repeated that. Maybe he’s just trying to stop hiding the obvious fact of the presence of professional Western military personnel in Ukraine? German Chancellor Olaf Scholz added fuel to the fire when he casually blurted out that the British and French were helping to launch Storm Shadow missiles. The French, apparently, did not bypass Ukraine either.
Spring 2022: Russian units were liberating Azovstal metallurgical plant in Mariupol. Militants of the Ukrainian National Battalions were holed up in concrete basements. Our intelligence service then more than once intercepted enemy communications which included French speech. When it became obvious that there were only a few days left before the capture of the metallurgical bastion, President Macron himself sounded the alarm. Like, let’s open a humanitarian corridor for the wounded. Representatives of the Elysee Palace began calling our Foreign Ministry directly to the Kremlin. And the real reason for the fuss of French politicians became clear only when the helicopters were shot down. And at the crash site near the village of Rybatskoye, these tokens and berets were found among the remains. The same ones can be seen on soldiers of the French Foreign Legion. So who was hiding at Azovstal? Career French soldiers dressed as mercenaries? And besides, who organized the death travel agency for foreign specialists? Let’s try to figure it all out.
Mercenaries or professional soldiers? Who is now joining the ranks of the Ukrainian foreign legion? How were more than 20 thousand foreigners lured to Ukraine to fight for the Kiev regime? And why did they run back en masse? I hit a mine and may lose my leg. How much were and are paid to the soldiers of fortune in Ukraine? Why do some mercenaries from Western countries leave their wives and children and go to Kyiv? How do Ukrainian diplomats recruit thugs through embassies? We will find out during the investigative experiment. Thank you for filling out the form to the International Legion of Ukraine. Why are Poles less and less welcome in Ukraine? Revelation of soldiers of fortune from Warsaw: we ourselves ate rotten meat and cereals. Why do Odessa beaches attract French strategists? The French are now actively working in Moldova. And this must also be understood.
January 2024: a high-precision strike in Kharkov destroyed the location of foreign mercenaries. According to the Russian Ministry of Defense, as a result, about 60 Frenchmen who fought on the side of Ukraine were killed. But in that case there was no point in denying it, because French volunteers quickly published a list of foreigners killed in Kharkov. Some studied these names in their homeland with alarm, others with interest. Former French intelligence officer Nicolas Cinquini is bit by bit collecting information about his fellow countrymen who disappeared in Kharkov, Ukraine, since official Paris is silent about the tragedies of its citizens who became mercenaries. Especially for Evidence from the Past, Cinquini shared secret information about the French in Ukraine. To date, there are 63 French fighters on the list, some of whom have already left Ukraine. Ten or so were killed and at least three of them were permanently disabled due to severe wounds. 20% of irretrievable losses among the French is an excellent indicator for Russian troops. Cinquini obtained these figures through painstaking private investigation. However, he admits that his list of losses among the French military is far from complete.
The camera lenses repeatedly caught the patches of the French killed in Ukraine. These, for example, were found at the site of a helicopter crash that was trying to get some important people out of the Azovstal plant. What can these insignia tell about their owners? To find out, we will conduct an investigative examination. This is, accordingly, a Legionnaire’s field patch. The historian of the Museum of Military Uniforms identified them as signs of the French Foreign Legion. Foreigners are taken into this unit, promising them a residence permit in France. And they can even receive French citizenship five years after the end of the contract. According to the statute, the Legion is personally subordinate to the President of France. This is almost his personal army. Now there are about nine thousand soldiers. This patch is assigned to the third regiment of the foreign legion, which is stationed in French Guiana. If this is indeed a patch from a killed Frenchman, then it could be an officer who either coordinated the troops, or was, accordingly, well, in the capacity of such a military adviser. The sending of military personnel from the remaining colonies to Ukraine is not surprising. After all, almost 200 years ago, the French Foreign Legion was created by King Louis Philippe in order to use it not in Europe, but somewhere far away, in overseas territories. Until recently, the command of that unit was not very interested in the background of the recruits, so fugitives often joined it under false names.
Ukrainian recruiters also adopted this experience from the French. Ukraine also has its own international legion. Back in March 22, Minister of Foreign Affairs Dmytro Kuleba said without hesitation that the Kiev regime was using mercenaries from 52 countries. Unless they tried to recruit penguins from Antarctica here. In total, at that time, about twenty thousand soldiers of fortune were among the participants in the international Ukrainian legion. By the spring of 2024, their ranks, however, are very cold. Here is a report from the Russian Ministry of Defense on foreign mercenaries killed in Ukraine. Almost one and a half thousand irretrievable Polish losses. Behind them are Georgian militants. In third place are US citizens. Not even one and a half hundred French mercenaries returned home. But how were they recruited? And for what money were they willing to give their lives? To understand this, let’s follow the path of one of the French mercenaries.
Maxime Bronchain, former chef. In July 22, he left his child and wife at home, and he went to work to the same International Legion of Ukraine. True, Maxim did not have time to get rich. Max, we are right with you, you will be evacuated. Soon after the start of his service, the soldier’s luck was very bad. He hit a mine. In this footage, he is being evacuated with a serious leg injury. I heard the call of President Zelensky and since I once served in the army and was a firefighter, I decided that I could be useful. But did the desire to help Zelensky really bring Bronchain to Ukraine? Weren’t there other motives? Thirst for fame, extreme sports, money? Or maybe hatred of Russia and Russians? To understand the Frenchman’s true reasons, during the investigation we carefully studied his biography. Who or what kept Bronchain in Ukraine, even after being seriously wounded? We’ll tell you a little later.
Why do some mercenaries from Western countries leave their wives and children and go to Kyiv? He longs for fame so that society will recognize him as a hero. How do Ukrainian diplomats recruit thugs through embassies? We will find out during the investigative experiment. Thank you for filling out the form to the International Region of Ukraine. How were more than 20 thousand foreigners lured to Ukraine to fight for the Kiev regime? And why did they run back en masse? I hit a mine and may lose my leg. How much were and are paid to the soldiers of fortune in Ukraine? Why do Odessa beaches attract French strategists? The French are now actively working in Moldova. And this must also be understood. Why are Poles less and less welcome in Ukraine? We ourselves ate rotten meat and cereals. Who is now joining the ranks of the Ukrainian foreign legion? We spoke with a career military man who served in the US Navy with a classified clearance.
Bronchain’s boss and fellow countryman Gaston Besson will definitely not return home. Once upon a time, this is how he lured everyone into the International Legion of Ukraine, the creator of which Besson is considered. A variety of people from Finland, Norway, England, France, Italy are coming to our International Legion. As much as we may look like crazy fanatics, we are actually here to gain combat experience. And Ukraine was not Besson’s first military experience. A former paratrooper and special forces soldier. Back in the 90s, he realized that on the battlefield you can not only risk your life, but also make good money. I went through three revolutions and two wars. Besson settled in Ukraine back in 2014, immediately after the coup in Kyiv. In 2014, he became one of the founders of Azov battalion. The second was Karel Cherel Salzburg, also French. In December 2022, a friend of Besson said that the recruiter had died. But how and when in France did it become more profitable to be a soldier of fortune than a career French officer? Who and why becomes a mercenary in Europe? He longs for fame so that society will recognize him as a hero. To understand the motivations of modern Western mercenaries, let’s look at important clues from the past: 60s of the 20th century.
The old colonial system is coming apart at the seams. Because of this, in the newly liberated young states, mini-Maidans and military coups occur every now and then, during which the places of the killed leaders of national liberation movements are taken by puppet dictators. Look, it’s like Che Guevara in reverse. Yes, if Che Guevara, appearing in the Congo or Bolivia, was a revolutionary who risked his life, the tyrants who eliminated Che Guevara, Patrice Lumumba or Salvador Allende, valued their lives and tried to get along with military advisers from Europe, who in fact, were mercenaries. They no longer had formal relations with the official armies of the colonial countries.
Take a look at the face of this good-natured man with blue eyes. At first glance, it may seem that he is an ordinary European pensioner. But in the circles of the military and intelligence services, this person will not be confused with anyone. This is the most famous French mercenary of the second half of the last century: Bob Denard. Congo, Nigeria, Angola, Gabon, Benin. That list can be continued for a long time. In Comoro Islands, by his own admission, Denard staged either two or three coups. And it was here that he began to build his republic of mercenaries. Yes, at first it was a small base, and already in 1989 the presidential guard of that state was subordinate to him. How did Denard manage to stage military coups for decades and still remain unscathed? While doing his dirty work, the legendary French soldier of fortune never hid his face, as if emphasizing that he was not afraid of either criminal prosecution at home or assassination attempts in overseas countries. Bob Denard, like all other mercenaries who do not hide their faces, unmasks, so to speak. Ambition, then, allows these people to make themselves simply famous. Because of Denard’s ostentatious fearlessness, many believed that very influential patrons were behind him. It seemed that he was specially made a hero, a kind of exemplary super-soldier and an example for young Frenchmen. But the 60s and 70s in the West became the era of hippies and pacifism. Many politicians liked their politics to be conducted with clean hands, so that someone did the dirty work for them, organized genocide of the population in some country, took away power, took away resources, and handed it all over on a silver platter. Instead of their own armies, leaders undesirable to the West were overthrown by private military companies, of which Denard became a pioneer. Such formations helped former empires maintain influence in their former colonies, while seemingly maintaining neutrality. But even the services provided by Bob Denard to Paris officials did not save him from criminal prosecution. He was captivated by various crimes, including attempts on political figures, in particular, the murder of one of the leaders of African states. Once in the dock, the fearless Denard eventually stopped pretending to be a gallant soldier of fortune and spoke up. It turned out that no matter where he fought, his actions were always coordinated with the official French authorities. I worked with the secret services, they were aware of everything that I did, because such things are not done without the consent of your country. So they have their own archives, but often I supplied them with certain information. Sometimes I was not hired by the French authorities, but paid by the states for which I worked. Since Denard’s time, cooperation between Western PMCs and official security forces has only become even closer.
Satellite communications, weapons, some kind of satellite portals which are providing target designations for drones and other types of technical support, equipment. All that, of course, is provided to the Main Directorate of Defense of Ukraine. Experts are claiming that even before the North Military District, Western PMCs and NGOs, under the leadership of NATO intelligence services, began recruiting mercenaries for Ukraine around the world. Those who most actively agreed to the adventure were nationalists, neo-Nazis and professional soldiers of fortune who killed in Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria.
Many people become hooked on Ukrainian Nazi propaganda from sources such as the Right Sector or the Misanthropic Division. Isn’t it for that reason that the Frenchman Maxime Bronchain, who was blown up by a mine, went to Ukraine? During the interview in the hospital, the patches on his uniform were caught in the frame. One of them depicts the so-called valknut, the sign of the Scandinavian pagans, popular among the nationalists of Western Europe, is no less than the so-called wolf hook of werewolves. Maxime Bronchain fought with typical patches. Also a diamond with the battalion number and, accordingly, he had a Right Sector badge on his backpack. It is possible that it was precisely because of Bronchain’s radical views that French officials were in no hurry to return him to his homeland, even when he began to openly ask for it ? I hit a mine and may lose my leg. It all depends on how long my repatriation will take. Bronchain’s leg really wasn’t saved. We’ll tell you. Very soon.
Apparently, professional military personnel from Western countries also received serious injuries in Ukraine. Former French intelligence officer Nicolas Cinquini has an explanation why Emmanuel Macron was so nervous and asked Moscow to open a humanitarian corridor for militant groups settled in Azovstal. In the days following the failure of Emmanuel Macron’s plan to remove French operatives from Mariupol, Ukrainian military intelligence attempted evacuation by helicopter. As far as I know, at least seven sorties were made and at least five helicopters were shot down. These repeated failures led to the dismissal of the French general who at the time, was heading France’s military intelligence agency. It is known from reliable sources that active military personnel, specialists in their field, are offered fictitious resignations by their superiors with a guarantee of subsequent reinstatement in service. During their retirement, military personnel are receiving a salary that is difficult to refuse. And these seemingly retired military personnel, while in Ukraine, are continuing to carry out orders from NATO headquarters. Roughly speaking, these are people not from a private company, these are former military people who were recruited by official structures. But this process is simply veiled. The scheme has become so transparent that real mercenaries themselves are already openly talking about professional Western security forces in Ukraine. I know that there were often CIA operatives or special forces here. They were trying to convey to certain members of the Ukrainian command structure a very good idea of what to do. This confession was made by a high-ranking Polish military officer during a risky investigative experiment carried out by Russian pranksters known under the pseudonyms Vovan and Lexus.
This is the largest PMC in Europe at the moment. It is known about this academy that the entire Azov battalion was trained there. Since 2014, all Azov members learned both coordination and combat operations from these very clearings. The Polish mercenary commander opened up, thinking that he was communicating with former Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko, who judging by leaks from Kyiv, indeed, from the beginning of 2024, personally began inviting foreign officers to join the new PMC. I was surprised by the ending, how they joyfully swore allegiance to Petro Poroshenko and were even ready to go and stage a coup in Ukraine, overthrow Zelensky, so that the wonderful Poroshenko would become the new president, because he promised them mountains of everything. Cooperation with official recruiters from Kyiv in 2024 no longer attracts soldiers of fortune. According to the Polish mercenary with whom Lexus and Vovan spoke, foreigners in Ukraine were too often deceived. The amounts that are needed are not paid, and there is no security which is prescribed there. Of course, all mercenaries are complaining a lot about Ukrainians. Weapons are often hidden and lost. I’ve met officers selling new weapons. Foreigners who have visited Ukraine believe that even from the deaths of mercenaries, Ukrainian partners manage to make money. And they are rather treated as consumables, which is why they hate their Ukrainian commanders. The commanders of the Armed Forces of Ukraine are directly interested in the quick death of foreigners, since the contract concluded with the mercenaries stipulates that in the event of his death, compensation to the family is not guaranteed.
Although overall the agreement looks quite solid, the whole process is taking place officially. In Ukraine, the recruitment method is extremely simple. The Americans and Australians with whom we communicated, as a rule, they all did this through embassies. The Ukrainian embassies, which had already directly contacted the Ministry of Defense, assigned them a person who met them directly at the border. Is this system of recruitment through embassies well established? Let’s check it out during another investigative experiment. French military pensioner Nicolas Cinquini will help implement it. On the website of the Ukrainian embassy, he filled out a form to join the International Legion. We will tell you very soon how quickly and what exactly the Ukrainians will respond.
Until recently, Ukrainian Internet resources lured volunteers in many countries with videos like this. The mercenaries were promised not only allowances, but also comfortable barracks, and in the evenings a song by the fire in warm company. This brave warrior from the Bolivar battalion is confident that he will return home a winner. True, he fights not with a machine gun in his hands, but with a smartphone. In fact in Ukraine, mercenaries from other countries sometimes have to fight with Ukrainian Armed Forces soldiers. I instructed people, and we were treated like animals. Here you see how the Ukrainian authorities are treating those who help them. How Colombians are treated. They came in wearing balaclavas and beat our guys. Actually, there are not enough so-called volunteers in Ukraine.
This is Krzysztof, the only Pole who was at Azovstal when our troops surrounded the territory of the plant. His shocking revelations scared off many potential mercenaries. We ourselves ate rotten meat and cereals. This entire foreign legion, of course, was destroyed in the first year, most of it. And then many left, disappointed. The shortage of personnel in the Armed Forces of Ukraine is acute.
During the experiment, pranksters Vovan and Lexus found out that, for example, the American military, although unofficially, has been in Ukraine for a long time. We spoke with a career military man who served in the US Navy with a classified clearance. But American military personnel disguised as mercenaries are an expensive commodity. And Kyiv cannot afford it in large quantities. Prices on the mercenary market have been steadily falling since February 2022. If at the beginning of the Special Operation, the Ukrainian authorities were ready to pay up to 5,000 euros per month to every foreigner who wanted to fight, then two years later the average salary is fluctuating no more than three thousand euros. The cheapest personnel, of course, are from Latin American countries. Here you can find soldiers of fortune for two thousand dollars. At the same time, not everyone receives this money either. And if a mercenary dies, it is almost impossible to obtain compensation from Ukrainian or international recruiters.
So why do people agree to go to certain death for next to nothing? Why do some mercenaries from Western countries leave their wives and children and go to Kyiv? How do Ukrainian diplomats recruit thugs through embassies? We will find out during the investigative experiment. Thank you for filling out the form to the International Legion of Ukraine. Why do Odessa beaches attract French strategists? And what is the chance that the history of the French on the Black Sea will repeat itself a hundred years later?
During the investigation, we received this copy of an email from a Mexican citizen. He wrote to the Russian authorities about the recruitment in Latin America for the Ukrainian Armed Forces. We cannot disclose the author’s personal information for security reasons. Both units do not guarantee the return of the bodies of killed mercenaries to their homeland or payments to their families. This same Mexican found that many of his fellow countrymen who went to Ukraine were connected with drug cartels in their homeland and were recruited, most likely, simply to escape prison. If we talk about the Mexican drug cartels, then these organizations are tightly tied to the Central Intelligence Agency. From that, we can draw a very simple conclusion that some militants from these drug cartels, on the instructions of the CIA or other American intelligence services, may well be transferred to various locations of military conflicts. While remaining free, Mexican drug traffickers can simultaneously develop new markets for selling datura. Perhaps this motive forces them to go to Ukraine even more than the mercy of a mercenary or a CIA agent.
But what made the now legless French soldier of fortune Maxime Brochain return to Ukraine? The fact is that he was not a member of the French Foreign Legion, and for mercenarism in the Fifth Republic, one can give a real sentence of up to five years, plus a fine of 75 thousand euros. Maxime Brochain, this Frenchman, certainly did not find support for social payments after he was maimed in Ukraine, for the simple reason that, by and large, all these countries will disown their dead or wounded soldiers. In Ukraine, he married again. And he clearly doesn’t want to help his first wife, who is left in France, alone with the child. The Kyiv regime has little hope left for rabble like Bronchain or for the fed-up units in the armed forces.
But even if emboldened President Macron dares to send regular French troops to Ukraine, will that be able to seriously affect the course of the Northern Military District? That is, from two to four and a half, five thousand people at best. Such a contingent, of course, will not be able to significantly influence the course of the Northern Military District. And even Macron is not convinced to send more soldiers to Ukraine. French society remembers too well how the French military presence on the historical lands of Russia ended. Novorossia, that is the Black Sea, south of our country, including Crimea and Odessa, was considered theirs in Paris. Then a French contingent of 15 thousand people landed in Odessa. But in fact, the French got along poorly with Denikin’s White Guards. Numerous disagreements ultimately contributed to the victory of the Bolsheviks, who also freed Ukraine from dictator Semyon Petliura. The French fled from Odessa in the spring of 1919. Perhaps history really doesn’t teach us anything. And why is Odessa so important to them? Odessa has really been exciting the minds of French politicians for a long time. It’s not about the beaches of the Black Sea, but about the trade routes which are going through the city. Look, with the Black Sea cities, the French want to control grain. They want to somehow participate in the grain deal, because they have a certain friction in the middle of the Earth with Turkey. And this must also be taken into account. What Odessa has in quality, Macron did not name the possible landing site for the French by chance. Paris’s activity in neighboring Moldova also proves it. The French are now actively working in Moldova. And this must also be understood. They landed troops there in quotation marks in order to somehow influence Maia Sandu. And that region, Moldova, is not adjacent to Odessa, but very close to the Black Sea. Therefore, the French will try to be there.
To understand this, let’s see how our investigative experiment ended with an attempt to recruit a French citizen through the Ukrainian embassy in Paris. It would seem that a retired career military man is a godsend for Kyiv. But Monsieur Nicolas had to wait more than two weeks for an answer. And judging by the message in Ukraine, the French are not so welcome. Thank you for filling out the form to the International Region of Ukraine. We will compile all the data and transmit it to the recruiting officer. Essentially, this is an unsubscribe. A polite Ukrainian official named Kormin informs that he has handed over the documents of a potential volunteer to the right person, and asks to continue to wait for an answer. But he was not there a week or two later. Thus, it turns out that the interest of the Ukrainian authorities in French mercenaries is not so great now. It is difficult to imagine that all that recruitment could have taken place without the participation of the secret services of NATO countries, but the secret services are secret for that reason, their involvement is difficult to prove. Did NATO really understand that relying on mercenaries didn’t work? Or did the military in Ukraine begin to tinker with wayward foreigners who do not want to die silently in ridiculous and murderous attacks? However, even without taking into account Kyiv’s policies, Paris officials have their own motives for openly sending at least some of their soldiers to Ukraine. The desire of French politicians to wave their fists seems to have several reasons. First. Prove your leadership in the European Union. In the absence of a powerful German economy and advanced German technology, Paris is showing its willingness to take political risks. And finally, the third thing is the thirst for historical revenge. After all, the French had to flee Russia not only in 1919, but also in 1812. And here’s the funny thing. Macron’s harsh statements strangely come exactly 210 years after the fall of the French capital. You had the program “Evidence from the Past”. See you in a week [end]
in French, my alphabetical chronicle of the French involvement in the Atlanticist ranks in Ukraine: several characters of the report, Mickaël Sciacca, Maxime Bronchain, Gaston Besson…, by order of appearance, as well as many others, are precisely identified
clues of the presence of Western operatives, in particular French ones, trapped in March 2022 in Mariupol, whose Russian forces completed the liberation in May
We are very happy to bring you this excerpt from Colonel Jacques Baud’s latest book, The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat (L’art de la guerre russe : Comment l’Occident conduisit l’Ukraine à l’échec). This is a detailed study of the two-year old conflict in which the West has brutally used the Ukrainians to pursue an old pipedream: the conquest of Russia.
The book is being translated into English, and we will update this page when it is published. In the meantime, we provide a generous excerpt, along with a detailed Table of Contents, to give you a taste of this very important and much-needed book.
Russian Military Thought
Throughout the Cold War period, the Soviet Union saw itself as the spearhead of a historical struggle that would lead to a confrontation between the “capitalist” system and “progressive forces.” This perception of a permanent and inescapable war led the Soviets to study war in a quasi-scientific way, and to structure this thinking into an architecture of military thought that has no equal in the Western world.
The problem with the vast majority of our so-called military experts is their inability to understand the Russian approach to war. It is the result of an approach we have already seen in waves of terrorist attacks—the adversary is so stupidly demonized that we refrain from understanding his way of thinking. As a result, we are unable to develop strategies, articulate our forces, or even equip them for the realities of war. The corollary of this approach is that our frustrations are translated by unscrupulous media into a narrative that feeds hatred and increases our vulnerability. We are thus unable to find rational, effective solutions to the problem.
The way Russians understand conflict is holistic. In other words, they see the processes that develop and lead to the situation at any given moment. This explains why Vladimir Putin’s speeches invariably include a return to history. In the West, we tend to focus on X moment and try to see how it might evolve. We want an immediate response to the situation we see today. The idea that “from the understanding of how the crisis arose comes the way to resolve it” is totally foreign to the West. In September 2023, an English-speaking journalist even pulled out the “duck test” for me: “if it looks like a duck, swims like a duck and quacks like a duck, it’s probably a duck.” In other words, all the West needs to assess a situation is an image that fits their prejudices. Reality is much more subtle than the duck model….
The reason the Russians are better than the West in Ukraine is that they see the conflict as a process; whereas we see it as a series of separate actions. The Russians see events as a film. We see them as photographs. They see the forest, while we focus on the trees. That is why we place the start of the conflict on February 24, 2022, or the start of the Palestinian conflict on October 7, 2023. We ignore the contexts that bother us and wage conflicts we do not understand. That is why we lose our wars…
****
In Russia, unsurprisingly, the principles of the military art of the Soviet forces inspired those currently in use:
readiness to carry out assigned missions;
concentration of efforts on solving a specific mission;
surprise (unconventionality) of military action vis-à-vis the enemy;
finality determines a set of tasks and the level of resolution of each one;
totality of available means determines the way to resolve the mission and achieve the objective (correlation of forces);
coherence of leadership (unity of command);
economy of forces, resources, time and space;
support and restoration of combat capability;
freedom of maneuver.
It should be noted that these principles apply not only to the implementation of military action as such. They are also applicable as a system of thought to other non-operational activities.
An honest analysis of the conflict in Ukraine would have identified these various principles and drawn useful conclusions for Ukraine. But none of the self-proclaimed experts on TV were intellectually able to do so.
Thus, Westerners are systematically surprised by the Russians in the fields of technology (e.g., hypersonic weapons), doctrine (e.g., operative art) and economics (e.g., resilience to sanctions). In a way, the Russians are taking advantage of our prejudices to exploit the principle of surprise. We can see this in the Ukrainian conflict, where the Western narrative led Ukraine to totally underestimate Russian capabilities, which was a major factor in its defeat. That is why Russia did not really try to counter this narrative and let it play out—the belief that we are superior makes us vulnerable….
Correlation of Forces
Russian military thought is traditionally linked to a holistic approach to warfare, which involves the integration of a large number of factors in the development of a strategy. This approach is materialized by the concept of “correlation of forces” (Соотношение сил).
Often translated as “balance of forces” or “ratio of forces,” this concept is only understood by Westerners as a quantitative quantity, limited to the military domain. In Soviet thinking, however, the correlation of forces reflected a more holistic reading of war:
There are several criteria for assessing the correlation of strengths. In the economic sphere, the factors usually compared are gross national product per capita, labor productivity, the dynamics of economic growth, the level of industrial production, particularly in high-tech sectors, the technical infrastructure of the production tool, the resources and degree of qualification of the workforce, the number of specialists and the level of development of theoretical and applied sciences.
In the military field, the factors compared are the quantity and quality of armaments, the firepower of the armed forces, the fighting and moral qualities of the soldiers, the level of staff training, the organization of the troops and their combat experience, the character of the military doctrine and the methods of strategic, operative and tactical thinking.
In the political sphere, the factors that come into consideration are the breadth of the social base of state authority, its organization, the constitutional procedure for relations between the government and legislative bodies, the ability to take operational decisions, and the degree and character of popular support for domestic and foreign policy.
Finally, when assessing the strength of the international movement, the factors taken into consideration are its quantitative composition, its influence with the masses, its position in the political life of each country, the principles and norms of relations between its components and the degree of their cohesion.
In other words, the assessment of the situation is not limited to the balance of forces on the battlefield, but takes into account all the elements that have an impact on the evolution of the conflict. Thus, for their Special Military Operation, the Russian authorities had planned to support the war effort through the economy, without moving to a “war economy” regime. Thus, unlike in Ukraine, there was no interruption in the tax and welfare mechanisms.
This is why the sanctions applied to Russia in 2014 had a double positive effect. The first was the realization that they were not only a short-term problem, but above all a medium- and long-term opportunity. They encouraged Russia to produce goods it had previously preferred to buy abroad. The second was the signal that the West would increasingly use economic weapons as a means of pressure in the future. It therefore became imperative, for reasons of national independence and sovereignty, to prepare for more far-reaching sanctions affecting the country’s economy.
In reality, it has long been known that sanctions do not work. Logically enough, they have had the opposite effect, acting as protectionist measures for Russia, which has thus been able to consolidate its economy, as had been the case after the 2014 sanctions. A sanctions strategy might have paid off if the Russian economy had effectively been the equivalent of the Italian or Spanish economy, i.e., with a high level of debt; and if the entire planet had acted in unison to isolate Russia.
The inclusion of the correlation of forces in the decision-making process is a fundamental difference from Western decision-making processes, which are linked more to a policy of communication than to a rational approach to problems.
This explains, for example, Russia’s limited objectives in the Ukraine, where it does not seek to occupy the entire territory, as the correlation of forces in the western part of the country would be unfavorable.
At every level of leadership, the correlation of forces is part of situation assessment. At the operational level, it is defined as follows:
The result of comparing the quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the forces and resources (sub-units, units, weapons, military equipment, etc.) of one’s own troops (forces) and those of the enemy. It is calculated on an operational and tactical scale throughout the area of operations, in the main and other directions, in order to determine the degree of objective superiority of one of the opposing camps. Force correlation assessment is used to make an informed decision about an operation (battle), and to establish and maintain the necessary superiority over the enemy for as long as possible, when decisions are redefined (modified) during military (combat) operations.
This simple definition is the reason why the Russians committed themselves with forces inferior to those of Ukraine in February 2022, or why they withdrew from Kiev, Kharkov and Kherson in March, September and October 2022.
****
Structure of the Doctrine
The Russians have always attached particular importance to doctrine. Better than the West, they have understood that “a common way of seeing, thinking and acting”—as Marshal Foch put it—gives coherence, while allowing for infinite variations in the conception of operations. Military doctrine is a kind of “common core” that serves as a reference for designing operations.
Russian military doctrine divides military art into three main components: strategy (strategiya), operative art (operativnoe iskoustvo) and tactics (taktika). Each of these components has its own characteristics, very similar to those found in Western doctrines. Using the terminology of French doctrine on the use of forces:
The strategic level is that of conception. The aim of strategic action is to lead the adversary to negotiation or defeat.
The operative level is that of cooperation and coordination of inter-force actions, with a view to achieving a given military objective.
The tactical level, finally, is that of maneuver execution at weapon level as an integral part of the operational maneuver.
These three components correspond to levels of leadership, which translate into leadership structures and the space in which military operations are conducted. For simplicity’s sake, let us say that the strategic level ensures the management of the theater of war (Театр Войны) (TV); a geographically vast entity, with its own command and control structures, within which there are one or more strategic directions. The theater of war comprises a set of theaters of military operations (Театр Военных Действий) (TVD), which represent a strategic direction and are the domain of operative action. These various theaters have no predetermined structure and are defined according to the situation. For example, although we commonly speak of the “war in Afghanistan” (1979-1989) or the “war in Syria” (2015-), these countries are considered in Russian terminology as TVDs and not TVs.
The same applies to Ukraine, which Russia sees as a theater of military operations (TVD) and not a theater of war (TV), which explains why the action in Ukraine is designated as a “Special Military Operation” (Специальная Военная Операция – Spetsial’naya Voyennaya Operatsiya—SVO, or SMO in English abbreviation) and not a “war.”
The use of the word “war” would imply a different structure of conduct than that envisaged by the Russians in Ukraine, and would have other structural implications in Russia itself. Moreover—and this is a central point—as NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg himself acknowledges, “the war began in 2014” and should have been ended by the Minsk Agreements. The SMO is therefore a “military operation” and not a new “war,” as many Western “experts” claim.
****
The Special Military Operation in Ukraine
The Correlation of Forces
Consider all the factors that directly or indirectly influence the conflict. Conversely, as we have seen in Ukraine and elsewhere, Westerners have a much more political reading of the war, and end up mixing the two. This is why communication plays such an essential role in the conduct of war: the perception of the conflict plays an almost more important role than its reality. This is why, in Iraq, the Americans literally invented episodes that glorified their troops.
Russia’s analysis of the situation in February 2022 was undoubtedly considerably more pertinent than that of the West. They knew that a Ukrainian offensive against the Donbass was underway and that it could endanger the government. In 2014-2015, after the massacres in Odessa and Mariupol, the Russian population was very much in favor of intervention. Vladimir Putin’s stubborn clinging to the Minsk Agreements was poorly understood in Russia.
The factors that contributed to Russia’s decision to intervene were twofold: the expected support of Ukraine’s ethnically Russian population (which we will call “Russian-speaking” for convenience) and an economy robust enough to withstand sanctions.
The Russian-speaking population had risen up en masse against the new authorities following the coup d’état of February 2014, whose first decision had been to strip the Russian language of its official status. Kiev tried to backtrack, but in April 2019, the 2014 decision was definitively confirmed.
Since the adoption of the Law on Indigenous Peoples on July 1, 2021, Russian speakers (ethnic Russians) are no longer considered normal Ukrainian citizens and no longer enjoy the same rights as ethnic Ukrainians. They can therefore be expected to offer no resistance to the Russian coalition in the eastern part of the country….
Since March 24, 2021, Ukrainian forces have been stepping up their presence around the Donbass and have increased the pressure against the autonomists with their fire.
Zelensky’s decree of March 24, 2021 for the reconquest of Crimea and the Donbass was the real trigger for the SMO. From that moment on, the Russians understood that if there was military action against them, they would have to intervene. But they also knew that the cause of the Ukrainian operation was NATO membership, as Oleksei Arestovitch had explained. That is why, in mid-December 2021, they were submitting proposals to the USA and NATO on extending the Alliance: their aim was then to remove Ukraine’s motive for an offensive in the Donbass.
The reason for the Russian Special Military Operation (SMO) is indeed the protection of the populations of Donbass; but this protection was necessary because of Kiev’s desire to go through a confrontation to enter NATO. The extension of NATO is therefore only the indirect cause of the conflict in Ukraine. The latter could have spared itself this ordeal by implementing the Minsk Agreements—but what we wanted was a defeat for Russia.
In 2008, Russia intervened in Georgia to protect the Russian minority then being bombed by its government, as confirmed by the Swiss ambassador, Heidi Tagliavini, who was responsible for investigating this event. In 2014, many voices were raised in Russia to demand intervention when the new regime in Kiev had engaged its army against the civilian population of the five autonomist oblasts (Odessa, Dnepropetrovsk, Kharkov, Lugansk and Donetsk) and applied a fierce repression. In 2022, it could be expected that the population of Russia would not understand the government’s inaction, after no efforts were made from the Ukrainian and Western sides to enforce the Minsk Agreements. They knew that they did not have the means to launch an economic retaliation. But they also knew that an economic war against Russia would inevitably backfire on Western countries.
An important element of Russian military and political thinking is its legalistic dimension. The way our media present events, systematically omitting facts that could explain, justify, legitimize or even legalize Russia’s actions. We tend to think that Russia is acting outside any legal framework. For example, our media present the Russian intervention in Syria as having been decided unilaterally by Moscow; whereas it was carried out at the request of the Syrian government, after the West had allowed the Islamic State to move closer to Damascus, as confessed by John Kerry, then Secretary of State. Nevertheless, there is never any mention of the occupation of eastern Syria by American troops, who were never even invited there!
We could multiply the examples, to which our journalists will counter with the war crimes committed by Russian forces. This may well be true, but the simple fact that these accusations are not based on any impartial and neutral investigation (as required by humanitarian doctrine), nor on any international one, since Russia is systematically refused participation, casts a shadow over the honesty of these accusations. For example, the sabotage of the Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines was immediately attributed to Russia, which was accused of violating international law.
In fact, unlike the West, which advocates a “rules-based international order,” the Russians insist on a “law-based international order.” Unlike the West, they will apply the law to the letter. No more, no less.
The legal framework for Russia’s intervention in Ukraine has been meticulously planned. As this subject has already been covered in one of my previous books, I will not go into details here…
****
The Objectives and Strategy of Russia
On February 23, 2023, Swiss military “expert” Alexandre Vautravers commented on Russia’s objectives in Ukraine:
The aim of the Special Military Operation was to decapitate Ukrainian political and military governance in the space of five, ten, maybe even two weeks. The Russians then changed their plan and their objectives with a number of other failures; so they change their objectives and their strategic orientations almost every week or every month.
The problem is that our “experts” themselves define Russia’s objectives according to what they imagine, only to be able to say that it has not achieved them. So. Let us get back to the facts.
On February 24, 2022, Russia launched its “Special Military Operation” (SMO) in Ukraine “at short notice.” In his televised address, Vladimir Putin explained that its strategic objective was to protect the population of Donbass. This objective can be broken down into two parts:
“demilitarize” the Ukrainian armed forces regrouped in the Donbass in preparation for the offensive against the DPR and LPR; and
“denazify” (i.e. “neutralize”) the ultra-nationalist and neo-Nazi paramilitary militias in the Mariupol area.
The formulation chosen by Vladimir Putin has been very poorly analyzed in the West. It is inspired by the 1945 Potsdam Declaration, which envisaged the development of defeated Germany according to four principles: demilitarization, denazification, democratization and decentralization.
The Russians understand war from a Clausewitzian perspective: war is the pursuit of politics by other means. This then means that they seek to transform operational successes into strategic successes, and military successes into political objectives. So, while the demilitarization evoked by Putin is clearly linked to the military threat to the populations of the Donbass in application of the decree of March 24, 2021, signed by Zelensky.
But this objective conceals a second: the neutralization of Ukraine as a future NATO member. This is what Zelensky understood when he proposed a resolution to the conflict in March 2022. At first, his proposal was supported by Western countries, probably because at this stage they believed that Russia had failed in its bid to take over Ukraine in three days, and that it would not be able to sustain its war effort because of the massive sanctions imposed on it. But at the NATO meeting of March 24, 2022, the Allies decided not to support Zelensky’s proposition.
Nevertheless, on March 27, Zelensky publicly defended his proposal and on March 28, as a gesture of support for this effort, Vladimir Putin eased the pressure on the capital and withdrew his troops from the area. Zelensky’s proposal served as the basis for the Istanbul Communiqué of March 29, 2022, a ceasefire agreement as a prelude to a peace agreement. It was this document that Vladimir Putin presented in June 2023, when an African delegation visited Moscow. It was Boris Johnson’s intervention that prompted Zelensky to withdraw his proposal, exchanging peace and the lives of his men for support “for as long as it takes.”
This version of events—which I have already presented in my previous works—was finally confirmed in early November 2023 by David Arakhamia, then chief negotiator for Ukraine196. He explained that Russia had never intended to seize Kiev.
In essence, Russia agreed to withdraw to the borders of February 23, 2022, in exchange for a ceiling on Ukrainian forces and a commitment not to become a NATO member, along with security guarantees from a number of countries….
Two conclusions can be drawn:
Russia’s objective was not to conquer territory. If the West had not intervened to push Zelensky to withdraw his offer, Ukraine would probably still have its army.
While the Russians intervened to ensure the security and protection of the population of the Donbass, their SMO enabled them to achieve a broader objective, which involves Russia’s security.
This means that, although this objective is not formulated, the demilitarization of Ukraine could open the door to its neutralization. This is not surprising since, conversely, in an interview with the Ukrainian channel Apostrof’ on March 18, 2019, Volodymyr Zelensky’s advisor Oleksei Arestovitch cynically explains that, because Ukraine wants to join NATO, it will have to create the conditions for Russia to attack Ukraine and be definitively defeated.
The problem is that Ukrainian and Western analysis is fueled by their own narratives. The conviction that Russia will lose has meant that no alternative contingency has been prepared. In September 2023, the West, beginning to see the collapse of this narrative and its implementation, tried to move towards a “freeze” in the conflict, without taking into account the opinion of the Russians, who dominate on the ground.
Yet Russia would have been satisfied with a situation such as that proposed by Zelensky in March 2022. What the West wants in September 2023 is merely a pause until an even more violent conflict breaks out, after Ukrainian forces have been rearmed and reconstituted.
****
Ukrainian Strategy
The strategic objective of Volodymyr Zelensky and his team is to join NATO, as a prelude to a brighter future within the EU. It complements that of the Americans (and therefore of the Europeans). The problem is that tensions with Russia, particularly over Crimea, are causing NATO members to put off Ukraine’s participation. In March 2022, Zelensky revealed on CNN that this is exactly what the Americans told him.
Before coming to power in April 2019, Volodymyr Zelensky’s discourse was divided between two antagonistic policies: the reconciliation with Russia promised during his presidential campaign and his goal of joining NATO. He knows that these two policies are mutually exclusive, as Russia does not want to see NATO and its nuclear weapons installed in Ukraine and wanted neutrality or non-alignment.
What is more, he knows that his ultra-nationalist allies will refuse to negotiate with Russia. This was confirmed by Praviy Sektor leader Dmitro Yarosh, who openly threatened him with death in the Ukrainian media a month after his election. Zelensky therefore knew from the start of the election campaign that he would not be able to fulfill his promise of reconciliation, and that there was only one solution left: confrontation with Russia.
But this confrontation could not be waged by Ukraine alone against Russia, and it would need the material support of the West. The strategy devised by Zelensky and his team was revealed before his election in March 2019 by Oleksei Arestovitch, his personal advisor, on the Ukrainian media Apostrof’. Arestovitch explained that it would take an attack by Russia to provoke an international mobilization that would enable Ukraine to defeat Russia once and for all, with the help of Western countries and NATO. With astonishing precision, he described the course of the Russian attack as it would unfold three years later, between February and March 2022. Not only did he explain that this conflict was unavoidable if Ukraine is to join NATO, but he also placed this confrontation in 2021-2022! He outlined the main areas of Western aid:
In this conflict, we will be very actively supported by the West. Weapons. Equipment. Assistance. New sanctions against Russia. Most likely, the introduction of a NATO contingent. A no-fly zone, and so on. In other words, we won’t lose it.
As we can see, this strategy has much in common with the one described by the RAND Corporation at the same time. So much so, in fact, that it is hard not to see it as a strategy strongly inspired by the United States. In his interview, Arestovitch singled out four elements that would become the pillars of the Ukrainian strategy against Russia, and to which Zelensky returned regularly:
International aid and arms supplies,
International sanctions,
NATO intervention,
Creation of a no-fly zone.
It should be noted that these four pillars are understood by Zelensky as promises whose fulfillment is essential to the success of this strategy. In February 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of Ukraine’s Defense and National Security Council, declared in The Kyiv Independent that Ukraine’s objective was the disintegration of Russia. The mobilization of Western countries to supply Ukraine with heavy weapons then seems to give substance to this objective, which is consistent with what Oleksiy Arestovich had declared in March 2019.
A few months later, however, it became clear that the equipment supplied to Ukraine was not sufficient to ensure the success of its counter-offensive, and Zelensky asked for additional, better-adapted equipment. At this point, there was a certain amount of Western irritation at these repeated demands. Former British Defense Minister Ben Wallace declared that Westerners “are not Amazon.” In fact, the West does not respect its commitments.
Contrary to what our media and pseudo-military experts tell us, since February 2022, it has been clear that Ukraine cannot defeat Russia on its own. As Obama put it, “Russia [there] will always be able to maintain its escalation dominance.” In other words, Ukraine will only be able to achieve its goals with the involvement of NATO countries. This means that its fate will depend on the goodwill of Western countries. So, we need to maintain a narrative that encourages the West to keep up this effort. This narrative will then become what we call, in strategic terms, its “center of gravity.”
As the months went by, the course of operations showed that the prospect of a Ukrainian victory was becoming increasingly remote, as Russia, far from being weakened, was growing stronger, militarily and economically. Even General Christopher Cavoli, Supreme American Commander Europe (SACEUR), told a US congressional committee that “Russia’s air, naval, space, digital and strategic capabilities have not suffered significant degradation during this war.”
The West, expecting a short conflict, is no longer able to maintain the effort promised to Ukraine. The NATO summit in Vilnius (July 11-12, 2023) ended in partial success for Ukraine. Its membership is postponed indefinitely. Its situation is even worse than it was at the beginning of 2022, since there is no more justification for its entry into NATO than there was before the SMO.
Ukraine then turned its attention to a more concrete objective: regaining sovereignty over its entire 1991 territory.
Thus, the Ukrainian notion of “victory” rapidly evolved. The idea of a “collapse of Russia” quickly faded, as did that of its dismemberment. There was talk of “regime change,” which Zelensky made his objective by forbidding any negotiations as long as Vladimir Putin was in power. Then came the reconquest of lost territories, thanks to the counter-offensive of 2023. But here, too, hopes quickly faded. The plan was simply to cut the Russian forces in two, with a thrust towards the Sea of Azov. But by September 2023, this objective had been reduced to the liberation of three cities.
In the absence of concrete successes, narrative remains the only element Ukraine can rely on to maintain Western attention and willingness to support it. For, as Ben Wallace, ex-Defence Minister, put it in The Telegraph on October 1, 2023: “The most precious commodity is hope.” True enough. But Western appraisal of the situation must be based on realistic analyses of the adversary. However, since the beginning of the Ukrainian crisis, Western analyses have been based on prejudice.
****
The Notion of Victory
Russia operates within a framework of Clausewitzian thinking, in which operational successes are exploited for strategic ends. Operational strategy (“operative art”) therefore plays an essential role in the definition of what is considered a victory.
As we saw during the battle of Bakhmut, the Russians adapted perfectly to the strategy imposed on Ukraine by the West, which prioritizes the defense of every square meter. The Ukrainians thus played into the hands of the attrition strategy officially announced by Russia. Conversely, in Kharkov and Kherson, the Russians preferred to cede territory in exchange for the lives of their men. In the context of a war of attrition, sacrificing potential in exchange for territory, as Ukraine is doing, is the worst strategy of all.
This is why General Zaluzhny, commander of the Ukrainian forces, tried to oppose Zelensky and proposed withdrawing his forces from Bakhmut. But in Ukraine, it is the Western narrative that guides military decisions. Zelensky preferred to follow the path laid out for him by our media, in order to retain the support of Western opinion. In November 2023, General Zaluzhny had to openly admit that this decision was a mistake, because prolonging the war will only favor Russia.
The Ukrainian conflict was inherently asymmetrical. The West wanted to turn it into a symmetrical conflict, proclaiming that Ukraine’s capabilities could be enough to topple Russia. But this was clearly wishful thinking from the outset, and its sole purpose was to justify non-compliance with the Minsk Agreements. Russian strategists have turned it into an asymmetrical conflict.
Ukraine’s problem in this conflict is that it has no rational relationship with the notion of victory. By comparison, the Palestinians, who are aware of their quantitative inferiority, have switched to a way of thinking that gives the simple act of resisting a sense of victory. This is the asymmetrical nature of the conflict that Israel has never managed to understand in 75 years, and which it is reduced to overcoming through tactical superiority rather than strategic finesse. In Ukraine, it is the same phenomenon. By clinging to a notion of victory linked to the recovery of territory, Ukraine has locked itself into a logic that can only lead to defeat.
On November 20, 2023, Oleksiy Danilov, Secretary of the National Security and Defense Council, painted a gloomy picture of Ukrainian prospects for 2024. His speech showed that Ukraine had neither a plan to emerge from the conflict, nor an approach that would associate a sense of victory with that emergence: he was reduced to linking Ukraine’s victory to that of the West. In the West, however, the end of the conflict in Ukraine is increasingly perceived as a military, political, human and economic debacle.
In an asymmetrical situation, each protagonist is free to define his or her own criteria for victory, and to choose from a range of criteria under his or her control. This is why Egypt (1973), Hezbollah (2006), the Islamic State (2017), the Palestinian resistance since 1948 and Hamas in 2023 are victorious, despite massive losses. This seems counter-intuitive to a Western mind, but it is what explains why Westerners are unable to really “win” their wars.
In Ukraine, the political leadership has locked itself into a narrative that precludes a way out of the crisis without losing face. The asymmetrical situation now working to Ukraine’s disadvantage stems from a narrative that has been confused with reality, and has led to a response that is ill-suited to the nature of the Russian operation [end]
Jacques Baud was a member of the Swiss strategic intelligence, a specialist of Eastern European and a former head of the United Nations peace operations doctrine. In NATO, he was involved in programs in Ukraine in 2014 and 2017
chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia
China is not in vain the oldest alive civilization on earth. Chinese bloggers are discussing the Chinese peace plan for Ukraine, that Volodymyr Zelenskyy, a cocaine addict actor, the alibi of the Ukrainian Nazi deep State as well as the stooge of the US, has already rejected. Dnieper river is indeed a relevant boundary line.
Here are the main points of that plan
international law must be respected equally by both sides, without double standards,
all parties should work together for peace and stability on the Eurasian continent, abandon the cold war mentality,
all parties must cease fire and hostilities,
dialogue between Russia and Ukraine should resume as soon as possible,
the UN should be supported in playing a coordinating role in channeling humanitarian aid to conflict zones,
all parties should strictly avoid attacking civilians or civilian facilities [obvious attacks or false flags], protect women, children and other victims of the conflict and respect the basic rights of POW [prisoners of war],
the threat or use of nuclear weapons should be opposed,
the export of food, within the framework of the grain deal, must be ensured,
unilateral sanctions must end,
all parties must oppose the weaponization of the world economy,
the international community should take part in the reconstruction of the conflict zone.
Jens Stoltenberg is a former Norwegian social-democratic politician, the current general secretary of NATO and a representative of the barbaric roots in northern Europe of the teenage Anglo-Saxon civilization, which is now covering the Atlanticist block. He comments that there is not much confidence in China, during a press conference alongside Kaja Kallas, the neurotic Estonian prime minister [cf. February 19, 2023], Ursula von der Leyen, the corrupted and unfit president of the European Commission, executive body of the birthplace of fascism.
The New York Times called it a “mystery,” but the United States executed a covert sea operation that was kept secret—until now
“Biden’s decision to sabotage the pipelines came after more than nine months of highly secret back and forth debate inside Washington’s national security community . . .”
[Norway was in the thick of it. This article is a journalism lesson for a coterie of mediocre minions within Western mainstream media]
NORD STREAM
The U.S. Navy’s Diving and Salvage Center can be found in a location as obscure as its name—down what was once a country lane in rural Panama City, a now-booming resort city in the southwestern panhandle of Florida, 70 miles south of the Alabama border. The center’s complex is as nondescript as its location—a drab concrete post-World War II structure that has the look of a vocational high school on the west side of Chicago. A coin-operated laundromat and a dance school are across what is now a four-lane road.
The center has been training highly skilled deep-water divers for decades who, once assigned to American military units worldwide, are capable of technical diving to do the good—using C4 explosives to clear harbors and beaches of debris and unexploded ordinance—as well as the bad, like blowing up foreign oil rigs, fouling intake valves for undersea power plants, destroying locks on crucial shipping canals. The Panama City center, which boasts the second largest indoor pool in America, was the perfect place to recruit the best, and most taciturn, graduates of the diving school who successfully did last summer what they had been authorized to do 260 feet under the surface of the Baltic Sea.
Last June, the Navy divers, operating under the cover of a widely publicized mid-summer NATO exercise known as BALTOPS 22, planted the remotely triggered explosives that, three months later, destroyed three of the four Nord Stream pipelines, according to a source with direct knowledge of the operational planning.
Two of the pipelines, which were known collectively as Nord Stream 1, had been providing Germany and much of Western Europe with cheap Russian natural gas for more than a decade. A second pair of pipelines, called Nord Stream 2, had been built but were not yet operational. Now, with Russian troops massing on the Ukrainian border and the bloodiest war in Europe since 1945 looming, President Joseph Biden saw the pipelines as a vehicle for Vladimir Putin to weaponize natural gas for his political and territorial ambitions.
Asked for comment, Adrienne Watson, a White House spokesperson, said in an email, “This is false and complete fiction.” Tammy Thorp, a spokesperson for the Central Intelligence Agency, similarly wrote: “This claim is completely and utterly false.”
Biden’s decision to sabotage the pipelines came after more than nine months of highly secret back and forth debate inside Washington’s national security community about how to best achieve that goal. For much of that time, the issue was not whether to do the mission, but how to get it done with no overt clue as to who was responsible.
There was a vital bureaucratic reason for relying on the graduates of the center’s hardcore diving school in Panama City. The divers were Navy only, and not members of America’s Special Operations Command, whose covert operations must be reported to Congress and briefed in advance to the Senate and House leadership—the so-called Gang of Eight. The Biden Administration was doing everything possible to avoid leaks as the planning took place late in 2021 and into the first months of 2022.
President Biden and his foreign policy team—National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan, Secretary of State Tony Blinken, and Victoria Nuland, the Undersecretary of State for Policy—had been vocal and consistent in their hostility to the two pipelines, which ran side by side for 750 miles under the Baltic Sea from two different ports in northeastern Russia near the Estonian border, passing close to the Danish island of Bornholm before ending in northern Germany.
The direct route, which bypassed any need to transit Ukraine, had been a boon for the German economy, which enjoyed an abundance of cheap Russian natural gas—enough to run its factories and heat its homes while enabling German distributors to sell excess gas, at a profit, throughout Western Europe. Action that could be traced to the administration would violate US promises to minimize direct conflict with Russia. Secrecy was essential.
From its earliest days, Nord Stream 1 was seen by Washington and its anti-Russian NATO partners as a threat to western dominance. The holding company behind it, Nord Stream AG, was incorporated in Switzerland in 2005 in partnership with Gazprom, a publicly traded Russian company producing enormous profits for shareholders which is dominated by oligarchs known to be in the thrall of Putin. Gazprom controlled 51 percent of the company, with four European energy firms—one in France, one in the Netherlands and two in Germany—sharing the remaining 49 percent of stock, and having the right to control downstream sales of the inexpensive natural gas to local distributors in Germany and Western Europe. Gazprom’s profits were shared with the Russian government, and state gas and oil revenues were estimated in some years to amount to as much as 45 percent of Russia’s annual budget.
America’s political fears were real: Putin would now have an additional and much-needed major source of income, and Germany and the rest of Western Europe would become addicted to low-cost natural gas supplied by Russia—while diminishing European reliance on America. In fact, that’s exactly what happened. Many Germans saw Nord Stream 1 as part of the deliverance of former Chancellor Willy Brandt’s famed Ostpolitik theory, which would enable postwar Germany to rehabilitate itself and other European nations destroyed in World War II by, among other initiatives, utilizing cheap Russian gas to fuel a prosperous Western European market and trading economy.
Nord Stream 1 was dangerous enough, in the view of NATO and Washington, but Nord Stream 2, whose construction was completed in September of 2021, would, if approved by German regulators, double the amount of cheap gas that would be available to Germany and Western Europe. The second pipeline also would provide enough gas for more than 50 percent of Germany’s annual consumption. Tensions were constantly escalating between Russia and NATO, backed by the aggressive foreign policy of the Biden Administration.
Opposition to Nord Stream 2 flared on the eve of the Biden inauguration in January 2021, when Senate Republicans, led by Ted Cruz of Texas, repeatedly raised the political threat of cheap Russian natural gas during the confirmation hearing of Blinken as Secretary of State. By then a unified Senate had successfully passed a law that, as Cruz told Blinken, “halted [the pipeline] in its tracks.” There would be enormous political and economic pressure from the German government, then headed by Angela Merkel, to get the second pipeline online.
Would Biden stand up to the Germans? Blinken said yes, but added that he had not discussed the specifics of the incoming President’s views. “I know his strong conviction that this is a bad idea, the Nord Stream 2,” he said. “I know that he would have us use every persuasive tool that we have to convince our friends and partners, including Germany, not to move forward with it.”
A few months later, as the construction of the second pipeline neared completion, Biden blinked. That May, in a stunning turnaround, the administration waived sanctions against Nord Stream AG, with a State Department official conceding that trying to stop the pipeline through sanctions and diplomacy had “always been a long shot.” Behind the scenes, administration officials reportedly urged Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, by then facing a threat of Russian invasion, not to criticize the move.
There were immediate consequences. Senate Republicans, led by Cruz, announced an immediate blockade of all of Biden’s foreign policy nominees and delayed passage of the annual defense bill for months, deep into the fall. Politico later depicted Biden’s turnabout on the second Russian pipeline as “the one decision, arguably more than the chaotic military withdrawal from Afghanistan, that has imperiled Biden’s agenda.”
The administration was floundering, despite getting a reprieve on the crisis in mid-November, when Germany’s energy regulators suspended approval of the second Nord Stream pipeline. Natural gas prices surged 8% within days, amid growing fears in Germany and Europe that the pipeline suspension and the growing possibility of a war between Russia and Ukraine would lead to a very much unwanted cold winter. It was not clear to Washington just where Olaf Scholz, Germany’s newly appointed chancellor, stood. Months earlier, after the fall of Afghanistan, Scholtz had publicly endorsed French President Emmanuel Macron’s call for a more autonomous European foreign policy in a speech in Prague—clearly suggesting less reliance on Washington and its mercurial actions.
Throughout all of this, Russian troops had been steadily and ominously building up on the borders of Ukraine, and by the end of December more than 100,000 soldiers were in position to strike from Belarus and Crimea. Alarm was growing in Washington, including an assessment from Blinken that those troop numbers could be “doubled in short order.”
The administration’s attention once again was focused on Nord Stream. As long as Europe remained dependent on the pipelines for cheap natural gas, Washington was afraid that countries like Germany would be reluctant to supply Ukraine with the money and weapons it needed to defeat Russia.
It was at this unsettled moment that Biden authorized Jake Sullivan to bring together an interagency group to come up with a plan.
All options were to be on the table. But only one would emerge.
PLANNING
In December of 2021, two months before the first Russian tanks rolled into Ukraine, Jake Sullivan convened a meeting of a newly formed task force—men and women from the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the CIA, and the State and Treasury Departments—and asked for recommendations about how to respond to Putin’s impending invasion.
It would be the first of a series of top-secret meetings, in a secure room on a top floor of the Old Executive Office Building, adjacent to the White House, that was also the home of the President’s Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board (PFIAB). There was the usual back and forth chatter that eventually led to a crucial preliminary question: Would the recommendation forwarded by the group to the President be reversible—such as another layer of sanctions and currency restrictions—or irreversible—that is, kinetic actions, which could not be undone?
What became clear to participants, according to the source with direct knowledge of the process, is that Sullivan intended for the group to come up with a plan for the destruction of the two Nord Stream pipelines—and that he was delivering on the desires of the President.
THE PLAYERS Left to right: Victoria Nuland, Anthony Blinken, and Jake Sullivan.
Over the next several meetings, the participants debated options for an attack. The Navy proposed using a newly commissioned submarine to assault the pipeline directly. The Air Force discussed dropping bombs with delayed fuses that could be set off remotely. The CIA argued that whatever was done, it would have to be covert. Everyone involved understood the stakes. “This is not kiddie stuff,” the source said. If the attack were traceable to the United States, “It’s an act of war.”
At the time, the CIA was directed by William Burns, a mild-mannered former ambassador to Russia who had served as deputy secretary of state in the Obama Administration. Burns quickly authorized an Agency working group whose ad hoc members included—by chance—someone who was familiar with the capabilities of the Navy’s deep-sea divers in Panama City. Over the next few weeks, members of the CIA’s working group began to craft a plan for a covert operation that would use deep-sea divers to trigger an explosion along the pipeline.
Something like this had been done before. In 1971, the American intelligence community learned from still undisclosed sources that two important units of the Russian Navy were communicating via an undersea cable buried in the Sea of Okhotsk, on Russia’s Far East Coast. The cable linked a regional Navy command to the mainland headquarters at Vladivostok.
A hand-picked team of Central Intelligence Agency and National Security Agency operatives was assembled somewhere in the Washington area, under deep cover, and worked out a plan, using Navy divers, modified submarines and a deep-submarine rescue vehicle, that succeeded, after much trial and error, in locating the Russian cable. The divers planted a sophisticated listening device on the cable that successfully intercepted the Russian traffic and recorded it on a taping system.
The NSA learned that senior Russian navy officers, convinced of the security of their communication link, chatted away with their peers without encryption. The recording device and its tape had to be replaced monthly and the project rolled on merrily for a decade until it was compromised by a forty-four-year-old civilian NSA technician named Ronald Pelton who was fluent in Russian. Pelton was betrayed by a Russian defector in 1985 and sentenced to prison. He was paid just $5,000 by the Russians for his revelations about the operation, along with $35,000 for other Russian operational data he provided that was never made public.
That underwater success, codenamed Ivy Bells, was innovative and risky, and produced invaluable intelligence about the Russian Navy’s intentions and planning.
Still, the interagency group was initially skeptical of the CIA’s enthusiasm for a covert deep-sea attack. There were too many unanswered questions. The waters of the Baltic Sea were heavily patrolled by the Russian navy, and there were no oil rigs that could be used as cover for a diving operation. Would the divers have to go to Estonia, right across the border from Russia’s natural gas loading docks, to train for the mission? “It would be a goat fuck,” the Agency was told.
Throughout “all of this scheming,” the source said, “some working guys in the CIA and the State Department were saying, ‘Don’t do this. It’s stupid and will be a political nightmare if it comes out.’”
Nevertheless, in early 2022, the CIA working group reported back to Sullivan’s interagency group: “We have a way to blow up the pipelines.”
What came next was stunning. On February 7, less than three weeks before the seemingly inevitable Russian invasion of Ukraine, Biden met in his White House office with German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, who, after some wobbling, was now firmly on the American team. At the press briefing that followed, Biden defiantly said, “If Russia invades . . . there will be no longer a Nord Stream 2. We will bring an end to it.”
Twenty days earlier, Undersecretary Nuland had delivered essentially the same message at a State Department briefing, with little press coverage. “I want to be very clear to you today,” she said in response to a question. “If Russia invades Ukraine, one way or another Nord Stream 2 will not move forward.”
Several of those involved in planning the pipeline mission were dismayed by what they viewed as indirect references to the attack.
“It was like putting an atomic bomb on the ground in Tokyo and telling the Japanese that we are going to detonate it,” the source said. “The plan was for the options to be executed post invasion and not advertised publicly. Biden simply didn’t get it or ignored it.”
Biden’s and Nuland’s indiscretion, if that is what it was, might have frustrated some of the planners. But it also created an opportunity. According to the source, some of the senior officials of the CIA determined that blowing up the pipeline “no longer could be considered a covert option because the President just announced that we knew how to do it.”
The plan to blow up Nord Stream 1 and 2 was suddenly downgraded from a covert operation requiring that Congress be informed to one that was deemed as a highly classified intelligence operation with U.S. military support. Under the law, the source explained, “There was no longer a legal requirement to report the operation to Congress. All they had to do now is just do it—but it still had to be secret. The Russians have superlative surveillance of the Baltic Sea.”
The Agency working group members had no direct contact with the White House, and were eager to find out if the President meant what he’d said—that is, if the mission was now a go. The source recalled, “Bill Burns comes back and says, ‘Do it.’”
“The Norwegian navy was quick to find the right spot, in the shallow water a few miles off Denmark’s Bornholm Island . . .”
THE OPERATION
Norway was the perfect place to base the mission.
In the past few years of East-West crisis, the U.S. military has vastly expanded its presence inside Norway, whose western border runs 1,400 miles along the north Atlantic Ocean and merges above the Arctic Circle with Russia. The Pentagon has created high paying jobs and contracts, amid some local controversy, by investing hundreds of millions of dollars to upgrade and expand American Navy and Air Force facilities in Norway. The new works included, most importantly, an advanced synthetic aperture radar far up north that was capable of penetrating deep into Russia and came online just as the American intelligence community lost access to a series of long-range listening sites inside China.
In return, the Norwegian government angered liberals and some moderates in its parliament last November by passing the Supplementary Defense Cooperation Agreement (SDCA). Under the new deal, the U.S. legal system would have jurisdiction in certain “agreed areas” in the North over American soldiers accused of crimes off base, as well as over those Norwegian citizens accused or suspected of interfering with the work at the base.
Norway was one of the original signatories of the NATO Treaty in 1949, in the early days of the Cold War. Today, the supreme commander of NATO is Jens Stoltenberg, a committed anti-communist, who served as Norway’s prime minister for eight years before moving to his high NATO post, with American backing, in 2014. He was a hardliner on all things Putin and Russia who had cooperated with the American intelligence community since the Vietnam War. He has been trusted completely since. “He is the glove that fits the American hand,” the source said.
Back in Washington, planners knew they had to go to Norway. “They hated the Russians, and the Norwegian navy was full of superb sailors and divers who had generations of experience in highly profitable deep-sea oil and gas exploration,” the source said. They also could be trusted to keep the mission secret. (The Norwegians may have had other interests as well. The destruction of Nord Stream—if the Americans could pull it off—would allow Norway to sell vastly more of its own natural gas to Europe.)
Sometime in March, a few members of the team flew to Norway to meet with the Norwegian Secret Service and Navy. One of the key questions was where exactly in the Baltic Sea was the best place to plant the explosives. Nord Stream 1 and 2, each with two sets of pipelines, were separated much of the way by little more than a mile as they made their run to the port of Greifswald in the far northeast of Germany.
The Norwegian navy was quick to find the right spot, in the shallow waters of the Baltic sea a few miles off Denmark’s Bornholm Island. The pipelines ran more than a mile apart along a seafloor that was only 260 feet deep. That would be well within the range of the divers, who, operating from a Norwegian Alta class mine hunter, would dive with a mixture of oxygen, nitrogen and helium streaming from their tanks, and plant shaped C4 charges on the four pipelines with concrete protective covers. It would be tedious, time consuming and dangerous work, but the waters off Bornholm had another advantage: there were no major tidal currents, which would have made the task of diving much more difficult.
After a bit of research, the Americans were all in.
At this point, the Navy’s obscure deep-diving group in Panama City once again came into play. The deep-sea schools at Panama City, whose trainees participated in Ivy Bells, are seen as an unwanted backwater by the elite graduates of the Naval Academy in Annapolis, who typically seek the glory of being assigned as a Seal, fighter pilot, or submariner. If one must become a “Black Shoe”—that is, a member of the less desirable surface ship command—there is always at least duty on a destroyer, cruiser or amphibious ship. The least glamorous of all is mine warfare. Its divers never appear in Hollywood movies, or on the cover of popular magazines.
“The best divers with deep diving qualifications are a tight community, and only the very best are recruited for the operation and told to be prepared to be summoned to the CIA in Washington,” the source said.
The Norwegians and Americans had a location and the operatives, but there was another concern: any unusual underwater activity in the waters off Bornholm might draw the attention of the Swedish or Danish navies, which could report it.
Denmark had also been one of the original NATO signatories and was known in the intelligence community for its special ties to the United Kingdom. Sweden had applied for membership into NATO, and had demonstrated its great skill in managing its underwater sound and magnetic sensor systems that successfully tracked Russian submarines that would occasionally show up in remote waters of the Swedish archipelago and be forced to the surface.
The Norwegians joined the Americans in insisting that some senior officials in Denmark and Sweden had to be briefed in general terms about possible diving activity in the area. In that way, someone higher up could intervene and keep a report out of the chain of command, thus insulating the pipeline operation. “What they were told and what they knew were purposely different,” the source told me. (The Norwegian embassy, asked to comment on this story, did not respond.)
The Norwegians were key to solving other hurdles. The Russian navy was known to possess surveillance technology capable of spotting, and triggering, underwater mines. The American explosive devices needed to be camouflaged in a way that would make them appear to the Russian system as part of the natural background—something that required adapting to the specific salinity of the water. The Norwegians had a fix.
The Norwegians also had a solution to the crucial question of when the operation should take place. Every June, for the past 21 years, the American Sixth Fleet, whose flagship is based in Gaeta, Italy, south of Rome, has sponsored a major NATO exercise in the Baltic Sea involving scores of allied ships throughout the region. The current exercise, held in June, would be known as Baltic Operations 22, or BALTOPS 22. The Norwegians proposed this would be the ideal cover to plant the mines.
The Americans provided one vital element: they convinced the Sixth Fleet planners to add a research and development exercise to the program. The exercise, as made public by the Navy, involved the Sixth Fleet in collaboration with the Navy’s “research and warfare centers.” The at-sea event would be held off the coast of Bornholm Island and involve NATO teams of divers planting mines, with competing teams using the latest underwater technology to find and destroy them.
It was both a useful exercise and ingenious cover. The Panama City boys would do their thing and the C4 explosives would be in place by the end of BALTOPS22, with a 48-hour timer attached. All of the Americans and Norwegians would be long gone by the first explosion.
The days were counting down. “The clock was ticking, and we were nearing mission accomplished,” the source said.
And then: Washington had second thoughts. The bombs would still be planted during BALTOPS, but the White House worried that a two-day window for their detonation would be too close to the end of the exercise, and it would be obvious that America had been involved.
Instead, the White House had a new request: “Can the guys in the field come up with some way to blow the pipelines later on command?”
Some members of the planning team were angered and frustrated by the President’s seeming indecision. The Panama City divers had repeatedly practiced planting the C4 on pipelines, as they would during BALTOPS, but now the team in Norway had to come up with a way to give Biden what he wanted—the ability to issue a successful execution order at a time of his choosing.
Being tasked with an arbitrary, last-minute change was something the CIA was accustomed to managing. But it also renewed the concerns some shared over the necessity, and legality, of the entire operation.
The President’s secret orders also evoked the CIA’s dilemma in the Vietnam War days, when President Johnson, confronted by growing anti-Vietnam War sentiment, ordered the Agency to violate its charter—which specifically barred it from operating inside America—by spying on antiwar leaders to determine whether they were being controlled by Communist Russia.
The agency ultimately acquiesced, and throughout the 1970s it became clear just how far it had been willing to go. There were subsequent newspaper revelations in the aftermath of the Watergate scandals about the Agency’s spying on American citizens, its involvement in the assassination of foreign leaders and its undermining of the socialist government of Salvador Allende.
Those revelations led to a dramatic series of hearings in the mid-1970s in the Senate, led by Frank Church of Idaho, that made it clear that Richard Helms, the Agency director at the time, accepted that he had an obligation to do what the President wanted, even if it meant violating the law.
In unpublished, closed-door testimony, Helms ruefully explained that “you almost have an Immaculate Conception when you do something” under secret orders from a President. “Whether it’s right that you should have it, or wrong that you shall have it, [the CIA] works under different rules and ground rules than any other part of the government.” He was essentially telling the Senators that he, as head of the CIA, understood that he had been working for the Crown, and not the Constitution.
The Americans at work in Norway operated under the same dynamic, and dutifully began working on the new problem—how to remotely detonate the C4 explosives on Biden’s order. It was a much more demanding assignment than those in Washington understood. There was no way for the team in Norway to know when the President might push the button. Would it be in a few weeks, in many months or in half a year or longer?
The C4 attached to the pipelines would be triggered by a sonar buoy dropped by a plane on short notice, but the procedure involved the most advanced signal processing technology. Once in place, the delayed timing devices attached to any of the four pipelines could be accidentally triggered by the complex mix of ocean background noises throughout the heavily trafficked Baltic Sea—from near and distant ships, underwater drilling, seismic events, waves and even sea creatures. To avoid this, the sonar buoy, once in place, would emit a sequence of unique low frequency tonal sounds—much like those emitted by a flute or a piano—that would be recognized by the timing device and, after a pre-set hours of delay, trigger the explosives. (“You want a signal that is robust enough so that no other signal could accidentally send a pulse that detonated the explosives,” I was told by Dr. Theodore Postol, professor emeritus of science, technology and national security policy at MIT. Postol, who has served as the science adviser to the Pentagon’s Chief of Naval Operations, said the issue facing the group in Norway because of Biden’s delay was one of chance: “The longer the explosives are in the water the greater risk there would be of a random signal that would launch the bombs.”)
On September 26, 2022, a Norwegian Navy P8 surveillance plane made a seemingly routine flight and dropped a sonar buoy. The signal spread underwater, initially to Nord Stream 2 and then on to Nord Stream 1. A few hours later, the high-powered C4 explosives were triggered and three of the four pipelines were put out of commission. Within a few minutes, pools of methane gas that remained in the shuttered pipelines could be seen spreading on the water’s surface and the world learned that something irreversible had taken place.
FALLOUT
In the immediate aftermath of the pipeline bombing, the American media treated it like an unsolved mystery. Russia was repeatedly cited as a likely culprit, spurred on by calculated leaks from the White House—but without ever establishing a clear motive for such an act of self-sabotage, beyond simple retribution. A few months later, when it emerged that Russian authorities had been quietly getting estimates for the cost to repair the pipelines, the New York Times described the news as “complicating theories about who was behind” the attack. No major American newspaper dug into the earlier threats to the pipelines made by Biden and Undersecretary of State Nuland.
While it was never clear why Russia would seek to destroy its own lucrative pipeline, a more telling rationale for the President’s action came from Secretary of State Blinken.
Asked at a press conference last September about the consequences of the worsening energy crisis in Western Europe, Blinken described the moment as a potentially good one:
“It’s a tremendous opportunity to once and for all remove the dependence on Russian energy and thus to take away from Vladimir Putin the weaponization of energy as a means of advancing his imperial designs. That’s very significant and that offers tremendous strategic opportunity for the years to come, but meanwhile we’re determined to do everything we possibly can to make sure the consequences of all of this are not borne by citizens in our countries or, for that matter, around the world.”
More recently, Victoria Nuland expressed satisfaction at the demise of the newest of the pipelines. Testifying at a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing in late January she told Senator Ted Cruz, “Like you, I am, and I think the Administration is, very gratified to know that Nord Stream 2 is now, as you like to say, a hunk of metal at the bottom of the sea.”
The source had a much more streetwise view of Biden’s decision to sabotage more than 1500 miles of Gazprom pipeline as winter approached. “Well,” he said, speaking of the President, “I gotta admit the guy has a pair of balls. He said he was going to do it, and he did.”
Asked why he thought the Russians failed to respond, he said cynically, “Maybe they want the capability to do the same things the U.S. did.
“It was a beautiful cover story,” he went on. “Behind it was a covert operation that placed experts in the field and equipment that operated on a covert signal.
Seymour Hersh is a venerable US investigative journalist, who received the 1970 Pulitzer Prize for exposing the My Lai massacre and its cover-up during the Vietnam war.