Nicolas Cinquini

Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu

Tag: responsiblestatecraft

  • [Sharing] Getica’s Fifth Column: How an Ilegal Armed Group on Ukraine’s Payroll Blacklists EU and US Citizens – Stéphane Luçon

    Since the annulment of the 2024 election, Romania’s rule of law keeps crumbling. Here comes Getica – a paramilitary unit who puts EU and US citizens on a Fifth Column list and jokes about war crimes

    Romania annulled its presidential election in December 2024 amid allegations of Russian interference. Eighteen months later, Romanian authorities still have not publicly produced evidence showing that Russian influence determined the result.

    Yet, those who challenge that narrative increasingly find themselves labeled as pro-Russian, fact-checked, publicly denounced, censored, or added to the “Fifth Column” blacklist of Romanian Battlegroup Getica, an armed group linked to Ukrainian military structures.

    The story of how I ended up on that blacklist reveals something larger than a single paramilitary database. It points to an ecosystem of media outlets, NGOs, activists, fact-checkers, and an armed group that appears to use accusations of Russian influence to stigmatize political opponents and critics of Romania’s (and the EU’s) official electoral narrative.

    The question is not only why journalists, politicians, academics, and activists end up on Getica’s Fifth Column database, but most importantly why Romanian and Ukrainian authorities continue to tolerate an armed group threatening civilians while nobody accepts responsibility for it.

    Getica’s “Fifth Column” database has grown far beyond Romanian politics. At some point, Donald Trump was on it. Steve Bannon is still on it. Republicans for National Renewal and its leader Mark Ivanyo were recently added — alongside European politicians and journalists. Including myself.

    To some targets, Getica confirmed modeling their “Fifth Column” list on Ukraine’s infamous Myrotvorets death list. Those armed men wearing military uniform with Ukrainian and Romanian flags and, for some of them, on Ukraine’s army’s payroll, have joked about war crimes, war time rape, doxxed a civilian, constantly lied on their nature, and, last but not least, kept emitting threat no later than this week

    Screenshot from the last Getica video, threatening Sebastian Dracopol for his reporting and pushback on Getica’s Fifth Column

    In 2024, Getica’s Fifth column’s manifesto declared possible terrorist action if Ukraine loses the war.

    Protected Speech or Military Misconduct?

    I had been monitoring the Fifth Column site for a while when I appeared on the list. The move was an anticipated one after recurring signaling from Newsweek Romania trying to frame me as being aligned with Russia — despite not having posted anything in support of Russia. It came first as the logical conclusion of a pattern of smear and harassment coming from people connected to Newsweek România, Alianța — a US 501(c)(3) meddling with Romanian politics — and the local businessman Marius Bostan, who consolidated his fortune on state contracts awarded during the COVID crisis.

    But then came the questions — is it a real thing? Is it dangerous? Unfortunately, it is. Especially in the context of a country whose rule of law was buried altogether with the 2024 election.

    I contacted Getica to receive an explanation and clarify the label of “enemy of Romania”. An anonymous representative replied that nobody had ever suffered consequences from inclusion and argued that the project merely exercised free speech. They also explained that they used to be affiliated with Ukrainian military intelligence, but are now under the authority of the Ukrainian Armed Forces… Further investigation would reveal how blurred are the lines under which Getica operates.

    The answer regarding free speech raises an obvious problem. You can’t claim free speech protection while operating as a military organization targeting civilians. If they’re civilians, Getica’s members enjoy broad free-speech protections — that is, up to the point where speech crosses into incitement or creates immediate, real-world threats. In that case, law enforcement and civilian justice should handle them. If they’re military, the problem is different. Military organizations operate under rules of engagement. They don’t target civilians. They don’t maintain independent blacklists of enemies. They answer to a chain of command. If they’re out-of-control military members, they should answer before a military tribunal.

    Getica claims both at once: military affiliation when it suits them (Ukrainian unit emblems on the website, Ukrainian battlegroup membership, fundraising for its activities), and civilian free speech protection when confronted with responsibility for the Fifth Column database. Right after I sent them a series of questions on the way they were assessing people to put them on their “Fifth Column” list, they blocked me on Facebook although I didn’t even ever tag them nor publish anything on them yet. The honor and ethics of military service were traded for the methods of petty mobsters.

    But the question goes beyond the activities of Getica. If Ukraine is supporting these activities, then it is crossing another line, in a context already extremely loaded due to the recent attribution of the Nord Stream sabotage to a Ukrainian agent by a German tribunal — the worst attack on a NATO country infrastructure so far has been performed by somebody affiliated with the Ukrainian military. The atmosphere is even more loaded since a Ukrainian drone recently exploded in the Romanian port of Constanta — the biggest NATO port on the Black Sea — a few hundred meters away from the oil terminals and from an ammonium nitrate deposit, a chemical product that made major damages in the port of Beirut in 2020. With Getica, the question of Ukraine’s willingness to target Western civilians and western infrastructure is all the more acute. You can’t receive Western support and attack the West. You can’t claim funding for your military and pay the members of Getica as they target EU and US civilians. If Ukraine can’t court-martial those targeting EU and US citizens, if it covers for them, then the whole story of defending a democracy against an autocracy crumbles and, with it, part of the reasons to support Ukraine against the Russian invasion.

    Getica — illegal, dangerous and… aligned with Macron?

    In Romania, paramilitary organizations operating outside state command are constitutionally prohibited. Yet, Romanian Battlegroup Getica appears to operate openly: armed men claiming ties to Ukrainian military structures, running a blacklist of civilians, and even claiming to have conducted two operations on Romanian soil.

    Its historical founder and commander, Sergiu Meșeșan, claims participation in dozens of combat missions in Ukraine. Its members and supporters have doxed critics and targeted family members. Meșeșan recently returned to Romania to teach people how to use FPV drones, including arming them with explosives. In public exchanges, the group has joked about war crimes, rape, disappearances, and other conduct that would normally trigger serious scrutiny.

    In one live exchange on X, the Romanian Legion Getica account replied to another user with language trivializing rape and invoking Azov: “Several army groups participated in your creation, Azov too I think. The woman didn’t complain.” The reference is not incidental. Azov’s neo-Nazi origins were documented to the point that the US Congress prohibited weapons transfers to the unit in 2018, a restriction that remained in place until 2024. During that period, Radu Hossu — Getica’s main fundraiser and co-founder — appeared in a June 2023 interview wearing an Azov emblem containing the Wolfsangel, a symbol with direct Nazi lineage. In one of his own fundraising reports, he also acknowledged purchasing equipment for two military personnel enrolled in Azov, adding parenthetically: “yes, that AZOV”

    Radu Hossu, on the Romanian podcast Vorbintorici, wearing the Azov Wolfsangel in June 2023, when the US congress ban on arming Azov was still enforced due to Azov’s neo-nazi elements

    The point is not guilt by association. It is that an armed group maintaining a civilian blacklist, joking about rape and war crimes, invoking disappearances, and displaying proximity to military formations controversial enough to trigger years of congressional restrictions should have attracted institutional scrutiny long before journalists, politicians, and foreign citizens began appearing on its list.

    Whose Army?

    Some Getica members hold Ukrainian military ID cards and receive Ukrainian Army salaries

    Sergiu Meseșan military document shared on the Romanian Battlegroup Getica Facebook account – A0515 is a Military Intelligence Directorate Unit

    According to representatives of the group contacted directly for this investigation, Getica has operated under Ukrainian military command — initially under GUR, the Ukrainian military intelligence directorate, and later under ZSU, the Ukrainian Armed Forces. When pressed on the specifics of their affiliation, they directed us to their website.

    That website has been telling its own story. Until May 30, 2026, it displayed the emblem of the 4th Heavy Mechanized Brigade of the Ukrainian Army

    On that date — shortly after this investigation began sending right-of-reply letters to Romanian and Ukrainian institutions — the emblem was quietly removed, with an announcement that a new unit affiliation would be revealed. Days later, two new emblems appeared: that of the 1230th Separate Engineering and Technical Support Battalion, part of the 48th Engineering Brigade of the Ukrainian Support Forces; and that of the International Legion of Defense Intelligence of Ukraine, MUNA 3449 — a separate unit of foreign fighters subordinated to the Main Directorate of Intelligence of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, which is the GUR

    International Legion of Defense Intelligence of Ukraine
    1230th Separate Engineering and Technical Support Battalion

    No Ukrainian institution has formally claimed oversight of the group. No Romanian institution has either.

    The people behind Getica form an unusual partnership. On one side, Sergiu Meșeșan, the group’s historical founder and commander, is a Romanian volunteer fighter in Ukraine who was previously sentenced in Sweden to three years in prison for aggravated fraud as the leader of a bank-card-skimming and phishing operation active across Sweden, Finland, and Denmark.

    On the other is Radu Hossu, a self-described founding father of the project: a prominent pro-Ukraine activist, fundraiser, and politician from USR — the party created by Romania’s current president and aligned with Macron’s Renew Europe group — as well as an “embedded” war journalist, covering military operations and units he simultaneously helped finance.

    One man built and commanded the organization, and would publish the manifesto of the Fifth Column blacklist and maintain it. The other provided funding, public legitimacy, media access, and political connections.

    Questions about Getica’s financing had already produced one of the earliest public conflicts surrounding the group. IT specialist Sebastian Dracopol, later added to the Fifth Column database himself, challenged the use of funds raised by Hossu through a personal Revolut account. After being doxxed and threatened, Dracopol sued Hossu. Although he did not obtain a restraining order, the proceedings produced one of the few official records concerning Getica, including admissions regarding Hossu’s fundraising role, his creation and ownership of the group’s Telegram channel, and the armed nature of the combatants operating under the Getica banner. We will return to that case later.

    The April 2024 “Fifth Column” Manifesto

    In April 2024, Getica commander Sergiu Meșeșan published what amounts to the founding document of the Fifth Column project, laying out his program in explicit terms:

    We believe it is normal to have different opinions and freedom of expression. That is what democracy is about. But we wish to warn, through this message, that there is a limit to the subversive activities we will tolerate — I am referring to ‘Getica’ — on the territory of Romania or the Republic of Moldova.

    And we are EXTREMELY ready to act from the shadows to limit the impact of Russian influence in both states.

    Thus, when Ukraine collapses — as this category of Russophiles maintains, and if it should actually come to pass — we will be ready to strike with an intensity and firepower the likes of which Romania has never seen, in order to defend the national and vital interests of the nation.

    We are aware that there is a legal framework that is not exactly favorable for state defense institutions to act freely and effectively. Laws change, however, and for the homeland, ‘Getica’ is ready even to circumvent them. We own that. We might be called terrorists. But the terrorists of some are the freedom fighters of others.

    […] We already have a website, a secure server, and a domain. We will publish them very shortly. Beyond the information and presentation images you have been able to see on our page over time, we wish to put into practice the concept of the #coloana5 database. We firmly believe that exposing the identity of subversive elements and useful idiots will deter them more or less from their activities of sabotaging public opinion, and will spare us other actions — unfortunately far more invasive — in the near future

    Meșeșan’s manifesto remains live on Facebook today. He has since returned to Romania.

    The idea of an armed group on Ukrainian payroll going rogue and targeting citizens of NATO member states should have warranted a reaction from authorities, at least from Romania and from Ukraine. In response to our inquiry, the Armed Forces of Ukraine stated that the matter fell within the competence of the Main Intelligence Directorate (GUR) of the Defense Ministry. The Romanian Defense Ministry denied any affiliation. No further clarification was provided.

    A year after its manifesto, Getica goes… “clandestine”?

    In a lengthy statement published on April 14, 2025, Getica founder Sergiu Meșeșan described himself as having conducted 37 combat missions in Ukraine, including infantry, SIGINT, drone ISR, and attack-drone roles. He stated that Getica had approximately 50 members over its existence and never more than 20 active fighters at any given time.

    More importantly, he publicly acknowledged that the group had carried out “2 limited surveillance operations on Romanian territory.” Meșeșan did not disclose the targets, legal basis, beneficiaries, or institutional authorization of the two Romanian surveillance operations. No Romanian authority contacted during this investigation acknowledged requesting, supervising, authorizing, or even being aware of them. The statement raises obvious questions about the legality of intelligence-style activities conducted on Romanian territory by individuals presenting themselves as members of a foreign military structure. If they are a paramilitary group, their activities are unconstitutional and illegal in Romania. If they are affiliated to Ukraine’s military, this is a serious breach of the treaties that prevent any such activity. If these missions were happening with the blessing of the Romanian Army, then somebody at the MaPN lied to us and covered up for Getica – and this person should answer before the law too.

    In the same statement, Meșeșan proclaimed that: “From today, Getica becomes a multinational, global and clandestine operation.”

    By any reasonable definition, Getica does not display the characteristics of a regular military force. Regular military forces operate with rules of engagement, a formal conduct code, and an accountable command hierarchy — constraints that precisely prevent armed groups from targeting civilians, engaging in public discourse, or taking sides in political debate.

    Getica’s Fifth Column

    Coloana 5 — Fifth Column — is Getica’s blacklist. By May 2024, the page was online. It currently lists over 150 American and European citizens and organizations accused of serving Russian interests, acting as useful idiots, or being enemies of Romania.

    Inclusion is not notified in advance. According to the operators themselves, a profile can be spotted automatically by a combination of alleged military AI systems — an OSINT database and an LLM — and then approved by a human operator. The list is not static: operators state they monitor listed individuals and may revise positions over time, an implicit form of pressure to coerce people into alignment. The original version of the site included a “Recommended actions” rubric specifying measures such as localization and monitoring of listed individuals. That section has since been removed. At some point, the site began blocking web archiving tools, making earlier versions inaccessible.

    In direct communication with a listed person, Getica leadership referenced Myrotvorets explicitly as a model — the Ukrainian hit list on which was Chilean-American influencer Gonzalo Lira, whose case gained attention in 2023 when Elon Musk publicly questioned his detention. According to Ukrainian officials, Lira died in detention from pneumonia and health complications; his family and supporters alleged mistreatment and torture

    Lira’s last tweet

    A development in sync with the election calendar

    Getica’s Fifth Column project did not emerge during an ordinary political period. In 2024, every major elected office was scheduled for renewal in Romania.

    In late April, the European Union activated its Rapid Response System to flag content during the European Parliament election campaign, and Getica simultaneously began listing members of the opposition on its website. The framing had been set weeks earlier: on March 6, Ursula von der Leyen, campaigning for her reelection, made the stakes explicit in her Bucharest rally cry:

    [..] Putin’s friends are trying to rewrite our history and hijack our future. They are spreading hate from behind their keyboards. And let there be no doubt what’s at stake in this election. Our peaceful and united Europe is being challenged like never before by populists, nationalists, and demagogues. Whether it is the far right or the far left. Whether it is the AfD, the Rassemblement National, the confederatia or Wasraschdene. The names may be different, but the goal is the same: They want to trample on our values, and they want to destroy our Europe. But we, the EPP, will never let that happen

    Following the Russiagate playbook, critics and opposition to power are “Russian influence” – this would become a recurring theme during the long Romanian election cycle. Getica’s project, supposedly aimed at exposing Russian influence, would just plainly overlap with domestic political conflicts, opposition figures, journalists, commentators, and critics of power.

    The involvement of USR member Radu Hossu makes an obvious case for direct political support or, at least, convenient complacency, with the criminal activities of Getica. Contacted, neither Dominic Fritz – leader of USR – nor USR Brașov provided a statement to distance themselves from Hossu. Bucharest leader of USR, Vlad Voiculescu, replied in a direct message that he didn’t see how the matter was related to USR. Yet, the fact that a USR member helped and covered for a coercion gang is obviously a USR problem. None of the questions sent to USR-founder, and now President Nicusor Dan, to the Ministry of Defence, led by USR member Radu Miruta, nor to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, led by USR member Oana Toiu, delivered a significant assessment, response, let alone an acknowledgement of the gravity of the matter. Silence seems to clearly mean consent, and Getica’s utility for the USR could be summarized like that: if propaganda fails, if censorship and the weaponization of the DSA fails, then an informal tool to threatens or silences people find its full utility.

    Who makes it to the list?

    The progression from media labeling to blacklisting can be observed directly in my own case. Since December 2024, I have repeatedly described the absurdity of framing as pro-Russian people who — like most of the Romanian conservatives — have condemned Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and hold Russia in distrust for many historical reasons. In a country where 87.5% of the people are West-oriented and consider EU and NATO membership as warranties of security and prosperity, framing a part of the population — the conservatives — as anti-EU, anti-NATO, pro-Russia only serves a propaganda machine.

    Before appearing in the Fifth Column database, I had already been repeatedly smeared as pro-Russian, pro-Orbán, pro-Georgescu or part of various influence networks — and this without ever having published pro-Russian, pro-Georgescu or pro-Orbán material. The attacks had far more to do with the reporting I published than with any pro-Russian content.

    I have documented how the current implementation of the EU Digital Services Act created a growing ecosystem of censorship actors while leaving user protections largely theoretical (see DSA: Europe’s Injustice System).

    Later this year, I contributed to The Managed Ballot, published through MCC Brussels, with a chapter on Romania’s Hybrid Regime and its European Accomplices. It argued that the country’s democratic downgrade was driven by the regime itself — the government and the intelligence community — working hand in hand with a local “fake civil society” that lacked real constituencies and ran on foreign executive-power funding, including the EU’s. Behind it, external interference from Brussels and from Macron. The result: a country the Economist’s Democracy Index had reclassified as a “hybrid regime” — no longer a democracy. The publication of the MCC report triggered an ad hominem attack in a media outlet owned by Marius Bostan.

    The combination placed me in direct conflict with actors who considered the Russian-interference narrative settled fact. Beyond my own reporting, I also publish the Romanian edition of Le Monde diplomatique and regularly translate writers who frequently challenge official foreign-policy narratives and oppose censorship, including Serge Halimi, Pierre Rimbert, Matt Taibbi, Aaron Maté, Thomas Fazi, Jeffrey Sachs and John Mearsheimer.

    A few days ago, another Newsweek Romania “embedded journalist” — mixing coverage of the Ukraine war with support for Ukraine —, Remus Cernea, alleged that Sachs and Mearsheimer were “Putin’s intellectuals”.

    Newsweek România, Alianța and the Bostan ecosystem

    But things accelerated when I debunked a hit piece published by Newsweek România targeting Georgică Severin, one of the few members of the National Audiovisual Council (CNA) consistently opposing censorship measures within Romania’s media regulator. My article also noted how the advertorial section of Newsweek România only contained representatives of the government. Before publishing my rebuttal, I sent detailed questions to Newsweek România. No answer was received. Two days later, Newsweek România published a new article targeting both Severin and me. Another article followed in Newsweek, reminding readers of my positive reaction to AUR’s medical caravan project and the fact that my wife is an AUR member.

    Facing calls for deportation, I debunked the most outrageous allegations in a single published response, rather than engaging every online harasser.

    Shortly afterwards, I appeared on Getica’s Fifth Column database, directly tagged as an “enemy of Romania” and a “potential collaborator.” Getica’s file referenced articles published by two media outlets in which a key stakeholder is Marius Bostan — În Linie Dreaptă and Newsweek România (a local licensee, not the US edition, with full editorial autonomy). Bostan is a former Romanian Telecommunications Minister from the “technocratic government” that governed Romania from 2015 to 2017, formed after the Colectiv nightclub fire protests. Later, Bostan largely benefited from government contracts during the COVID crisis. In 2018, Newsweek România was launched, at an event where the head of the Romanian Intelligence Service would participate. Bostan exerts further influence via Alianța, a US 501(c) originally created to nurture US-Romania friendship, gathering former US ambassadors on its board. Through Newsweek România and Alianța-related actors, a common pattern emerges: individuals challenging dominant narratives are first publicly framed as vectors of disinformation before some eventually find themselves referenced by Getica’s Fifth Column project.

    In one instance, the Getica Twitter account even asked the editor of În Linie Dreaptă when to add an academic to the list — which raises the question of direct management of the Getica list by Bostan’s employees.

    On July 22, 2025, Getica publicly justified AUR MEP Gheorghe Piperea’s inclusion by posting a screenshot of a Digi24 article reporting that the European Commission considered his motion of censure against Ursula von der Leyen to be linked to Moscow’s interests. Getica’s accompanying comment was: “connecting the dots 😉” A normal parliamentary procedure — a motion of censure, one of the European Parliament’s standard checks-and-balances instruments — had already been reframed by Newsweek România as an initiative of the “Russophile extremist AUR party” before Getica treated it as a Russian-interference signal.

    Getica’s list has kept growing since its launch. In April 2025, Donald Trump was added. He was removed shortly after — no removal date confirmed.

    Months later, the operators claimed it had been a test to confuse enemies. That explanation is difficult to take at face value: it is more plausible that internal pushback warned them of the risk of directly targeting a sitting US president. What followed makes the Trump removal look less like a policy and more like damage control — the additions continued. The targeting pattern is hard to separate from the political positioning of Getica’s main fundraiser, Radu Hossu, and his party USR, which has maintained a radically conflicting stance toward Donald Trump, the MAGA movement, and USR’s local rivals, the AUR party.

    The same chronology appears around Republicans for National Renewal. In early 2026, Newsweek România published an article about a distinction awarded by the American organization to AUR’s leader George Simion. Shortly afterwards, RNR leader Mark Ivanyo was added to the Fifth Column database together with the organization itself. Dragoș Moldoveanu, an AUR member, was added in the same batch, and a Bulgarian figure associated with the same political ecosystem was also added. More additions followed after public discussions involving AUR MP Mihai Neamțu and sovereignty-oriented commentators, including Laurențiu Țîrcă.

    Țîrcă received some of the most radical messaging from Getica. The group confirmed to him that Myrotvorets was its model, and pointed to how people on such lists suffer “accidental” deaths. Țîrcă reported seeing a now-removed image of his name written on a rocket launcher. When he challenged Getica over alleged war crimes committed during the Kursk incursion, where elderly civilians died, the Getica account replied: “I don’t deal with pensioners only, I deal with students too.” Țîrcă was a student at that time.

    Although Newsweek România carries the name of the American weekly, asked about editorial oversight and accountability, Newsweek USA told us that its international publishing partners are responsible for their own editorial operations and content, while also stating that Newsweek expects organizations operating under its brand to uphold responsible journalism standards.

    The concentration of impostors at the local edition of Newsweek goes so far that it receives contribution from Ovidiu Nahoiu, Chief Editor of Radio France International Romania, who shone a year ago with an obsequious interview of the French Ambassador — that is the representative of the government that pays Nahoiu’s salary — were 3 blatant lies went uncheck on air in order to support the Russian influence narrative justifying the annulment of the election. Newsweek also hosts editorial from Adrian Zuckerman — a former ambassador who constantly meddles with Romanian politics, sometimes to praise the Ministry of Internal Affairs for his role in the 2024 coup – naturally framed as “saving Romania”-, sometimes to urge the Romanian Presidency not to join Trump board of Peace.

    A few years ago, a reporting by Recorder had already highlited one of the key reason explaining the journalistic fraud within Newsweek and a large part of the press — government money flooding them.

    “The destruction of these emitters of toxic ideas must be part of the response.”

    The overlap with Getica’s rhetoric extends beyond Newsweek itself. One recurring node is Alianța, a network whose members and participants have included business leaders, activists, former diplomats, former American ambassadors, media figures and public officials. On September 20, 2025, Alianța member Andrei Caramitru publicly defended Getica and its blacklist, describing Getica as Romanian patriots and heroes and claiming the list contained pro-Russian actors from Romania and Moldova. He added that the list was probably already known to Azov, Ukrainian services, Western services and others. We offered a right of reply to Alianța in letters addressed to each board member and to former US ambassadors — no answer was received.

    Alianța bills itself as a nonpartisan 501(c)(3), yet its own Board Chair, former US Ambassador Adrian Zuckerman, used an interview to declare the leading conservative opposition party, AUR, “a party dangerous to Romania, dangerous to democracy, dangerous to the West — a party that shouldn’t exist in Romania.” A US tax-exempt nonpartisan organization is, on its own platform, calling for the elimination of a Romanian parliamentary party.

    One of the most revealing pieces of language in this ecosystem has been recently supplied by Marius Bostan, shareholder of Newsweek România and central actor in the Alianța network. At the Newsweek IT & Cyber Summit 2026, Bostan compared ideological opponents to pests invading a field and argued that rapid intervention was necessary: “When pests invade a field you need to spray quickly. If you don’t react immediately, you lose.” He continued: “Sometimes attack is a better form of defense. The destruction of these emitters of toxic ideas must be part of the response.”

    The wording mirrors the coercive logic already present in Meșeșan’s Fifth Column manifesto. Bostan was not speaking as an anonymous extremist but as a Newsweek România shareholder and Alianța figure, at a Newsweek-branded event, immediately after a Presidential Palace summit devoted to informational resilience where the leading opposition faces were put on display as “public vectors of disinformation”. The pinnacle of Romania’s executive power hosting an event targeting the opposition as an enemy in an information war. When a democracy crumbles, signs are everywhere.

    This is why the Fifth Column database cannot be understood as an isolated website run by a fringe armed group. The labels appearing on the list often predate the list itself. They emerge first in media coverage, public campaigns, anti-disinformation initiatives, political commentary and institutional discourse.

    At the end of the day, the tabloidisation of Newsweek România, the extremely low level of “hit job journalism,” is a matter that would be solved by the market and readers’ interest. Except for the government money that flows into this ecosystem, directly or indirectly. Which leads to the bigger issue — more problematic than Newsweek România producing trash news and hit pieces: the role of Romania’s regime.

    The Consequences of a Lie — The 2024 Election Annulment

    To understand the current situation in Romania, we need to go back to the 2024 presidential election, when an outsider candidate, Călin Georgescu, won the first round with 23% of the vote. A second round was scheduled for December 8, 2024. It never happened. On December 6 — with voting in Romania’s large overseas diaspora already under way — the Constitutional Court annulled the entire electoral process. The annulment followed roughly two weeks of public signaling about alleged Russian interference and algorithmic manipulation, driven by a series of NGOs financed by the European Commission calling on Brussels for help.

    What followed was a ritual of whitewashing the decision, by European leaders spinning the idea that Russia was behind Georgescu’s success. Macron offered one of the most revealing examples, declaring in a February 2025 live broadcast that the court had detected fraud, vote purchases, and annulled the election because of Russian interference. One fabrication after another. In reality, the Constitutional Court had validated the first round (Decision 31), finding no electoral fraud, and its annulment decision contains no attribution of the result to Russia (Decision 32).

    We are now in June 2026. Romania has never formally attributed the Georgescu campaign to Russia. Romanians are still being told that proof is about to be released by President Nicușor Dan. The implicit conclusion is twofold: at the time of the annulment, the Constitutional Court had no proof of Russian meddling — yet it annulled the election. And eighteen months later, the reason proof has not been produced is likely that there was no provable decisive Russian interference.

    Alternative Explanations Identified After the Annulment

    The few operations that were identified — including those referenced in the Defense Council meeting that served as justification for the annulment — actually originated from Romania and Ukraine.

    On December 6 and 13, 2024, French daily Le Monde identified a Ukrainian sponsor behind the Georgescu influencer campaign: Dmitriy Makarov, a 32-year-old Ukrainian entrepreneur who had previously publicly supported Ukraine against Russia, whose companies — FA Agency, GMG, and Zlodeї — recruited influencers to promote Georgescu.

    On December 18, the Romanian outlet Snoop.ro revealed that PNL, the National Liberal Party, a member of the governing coalition, had financed one of the campaigns promoting its own competitor, Georgescu. That a governing party financed the rise of a candidate deemed so dangerous the election had to be annulled — leaving that party in power — remains one of the least addressed paradoxes of Romania’s democratic regression.

    2024 — a Modern Taboo

    Since then, saying there is no proof of Russian involvement has become the new taboo. On March 5, 2026, journalist Lucian Davidescu was fact-checked by Romania’s leading fact-checker, Factual — run by Funky Citizens, on Meta’s platform — for stating precisely that there was no real Russian implication in the 2024 election. The “fact-check” affirmed information directly contradicted by the Constitutional Court’s own decisions it was referring to. Davidescu obtained the publication of a Right of Reply response, but the fact-check stayed for months as a “flagged issue” on his Facebook account. Challenging the “successful Russian interference” narrative is nevertheless a widespread opinion, shared by former president Traian Băsescu, and even by Georgescu’s opponent in the second round that never took place, Elena Lasconi — at the time endorsed by Macron himself.

    Also on the Getica list, journalist Marius Tuca had been censored by the National Council for Audiovisual in March 2025 for calling the 2024-2025 sequence a coup — two months before the rerun of the presidential election, which Georgescu was barred from running in. One of the grievances against me is precisely to have described a judicial coup (see the timeline of the coup here).

    In May 2026, eighteen months after the annulment, President Nicușor Dan delivered yet another interview promising the long-awaited report.

    Proper attribution should be the golden rule when framing anything as a Russian influence. As I argue in my articles “The Iceberg That Can Sink Europe” and in “European Diplomacy Seems too Ashamed to Look at What Happened in Romania”, using the concept of Foreign Influence to target people who have no ties to a foreign power is an extremely dangerous game – one that leads to more “fifth column” craze and McCarthyism.

    It’s all the more important to remember that, since when it comes to attribution, Romania is far from being a powerless state.

    The State That Chose Not to See

    Romania’s internal intelligence service, the SRI, operates on a budget of over one billion dollars annually — three times that of France’s DGSI in nominal terms, six times in purchasing power parity, for a country three to four times smaller. All in all, ten to twenty times more resources per capita dedicated to surveillance and control. Not to mention that France has numerous terrorist threats to handle, whereas Getica seems to be the only one the Romanian authority have to deal with… The overpowered capacity of Romania’s intelligence services was praised in 2023 by Brigadier General Anton Rog, head of Cyberint — SRI’s cyber intelligence division — explaining in precise terms what his agency could do when democracy was under attack. It could counter campaigns online, take down websites, shut down operations. “We can get such a warrant in less than an hour,” he said.

    Yet when the Georgescu campaign was running in late 2024, nothing happened.

    When Getica published its blacklist, threatened journalists, doxxed families, and announced missions on Romanian soil, nothing happened.

    When AUR MP Dan Tanasă sent a formal parliamentary question (PDF) about the armed paramilitary group Getica to the government — still nothing, just a four page reply (PDF). The response, Tanasă said, contained no indication that the matter had been referred to DIICOT (the Directorate for Investigating Organized Crime and Terrorism) or any other investigative authority.

    A member of Parliament asked them about a band of volunteers that carry arms and that make lists of the enemies [including members of] the Romanian Parliament and they did nothing

    Tanasă said, adding that

    The purpose of this list is to silence the people on it one way or another, either through public shaming or, who knows, by a lunatic who would believe that I or any other person on this list is paid by Russia and would try to harm us physically

    Tanasă is currently preparing a criminal complaint against those responsible for the project.

    And the Media That Chose Not to See

    Since its first appearance in September 2023, Getica has drawn more than forty favorable pieces in the Romanian press — nearly half of them published after the blacklist’s existence was already known. The most revealing reporting on the matter came instead from Sebastian Dracopol, one of the people Getica blacklisted: first on his Substack, and more recently through his NGO, Patria Prima. He documented Meșeșan’s criminal past, the opacity of Hossu’s fundraising, and unresolved questions about the group’s actual combat record. Meșeșan’s answer to the latest reveal was to launch a fresh fundraising campaign on June 6, 2026 — to cover legal fees for suing Patria Prima and to buy military gear — this time routed through an NGO ostensibly dedicated to civilian aid, Volunteers Without Borders. The NGO did not respond to our request for comment.

    Recently, Patria Prima started asking every outlet why they presented Getica as a military unit, implicitly helping them to raise money, whereas the Ukrainian army denied any responsibility for it and Mesesan – as well as Hossu – reframed the group as an informal one. As a response, yet another article was published, by Veridica, in support of Getica. Patria Prima announced suing again. The author, Alex Craiu Rosenberg then published a video to frame Dracopol’s actions as SLAPP – Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation. The missing element of this analysis is the relation of power – Getica is a criminal, illegal, anti-constitutional and dangerous group who raised money in an illegal manner, yet benefits from the complacency of power, serves the interests of one or more parties of the governing coalition, and receives positive coverage from a press that lives off some executive power money (may it be the Romanian government or the money from Foreign countries – as Veridica does). Like for Newsweek’s hit pieces, Veridica’s work doesn’t qualify for the SLAPP victim card – it is part of the larger propaganda, censorship and coercion machine that targets critics, the opposition, and other nonaligned voices.

    When asked about the impunity that Getica enjoys, several journalists present on the list pointed to the entanglement with Romania’s intelligence services and how Romanian military personnel often go on leave to participate in paid missions — as mercenaries. This is corroborated by something I found out investigating the DSA in September 2025, when I was told by Freedom House Romania’s Director, Cristina Guseth, that Getica was part of the support provided by Romania to Ukraine, and “something that the Romanian government decided not to make public.”

    This could explain a part of the ambiguity and the silence our investigation received. Why public responsibility for Getica’s activities remained unclaimed.

    On October 27, 2025, Romania’s Intelligence Service — the SRI — responded to a formal parliamentary question submitted by AUR MP Fabian Radu, a member of the Joint Standing Committee exercising parliamentary oversight of SRI’s activities. The response invoked information classification and the “need to know” principle, offering no substantive answer. The formulation leaves two possibilities open: either the issue is being monitored and is too sensitive to be made public, or the non-answer is itself a cover.

    The months that followed make the silence harder to explain. Between late 2025 and mid-2026, the list expanded further — adding US politicians, more members of the opposition, and me, a French journalist. During the same period, Getica’s founder began publishing video tutorials on preparing First-Person View (FPV) drones for military use.

    On June 7, the Getica account republished on X a video montage of FPV drone footage reaching their targets: 67 different Russian soldiers (with possibly a civilian among them)

    original tweet here

    Monitoring Failure or State Complicity?

    If Romania’s Intelligence Services’ intent was to monitor — through surveillance or infiltration — before acting against Getica, eight months seem more than enough time to assess and intervene. But if Romanian intelligence services have some form of control over the battlegroup, then the continued expansion of the blacklist to include opposition politicians, journalists, and US citizens during that period is not a failure of oversight, but a state scandal.

    The Ministry of Internal Affairs (MAI) did respond to our investigation, but only to state that, pursuant to Article 285(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code, criminal investigation proceedings are non-public — neither confirming nor denying that any proceeding exists.

    Romania’s Intelligence Service (SRI) also replied, citing the classified nature of its activities, and neither confirmed nor denied whether Getica had ever been assessed as a national-security concern, whether information had been transmitted to Romanian authorities, or whether any monitoring or investigation existed.

    As mentioned, formal inquiries sent to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Romanian Presidency, and the French Presidency received no reply. The atmosphere is one of pervasive institutional ambiguity, in which responsibility is continually deferred while the blacklist continues to expand.

    Three months ago, in a private conversation with a member of the Romanian government, I asked about the incapacity to prove Russian interference and the widespread suspicion that what happened was an inside job — the answer was unambiguous: “Of course. But you do realize that if they admit it wasn’t the Russians, the country would descend into chaos.”

    Three months later, the credibility and legitimacy of Romania’s current regime are lower than ever. A vote of no confidence brought down the government on May 5. One month later, a Ukrainian drone exploded in the Romanian port of Constanța, and the authorities failed to obtain a clear explanation from Ukraine or to provide the public with a convincing account of the incident. The prospect of impeaching President Dan — unthinkable until recently — is now on the table [end]

    The original article

    Stéphane Luçon is a French journalist based in Romania. After Romania’s annulled elections, he began investigating the EU’s Digital Services Act — censorship, transparency failures — and its impact on the information flow

    Related

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    August 2, 2025: Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    Ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    December 12, 2024: McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    December 3, 2024: EU and NATO are attempting to foment a Ukraine-style coup in Georgia – Thomas Fazi

    They’re applying the Euromaidan playbook all over again

    November 2, 2024: The West is goading Georgia – Thomas Fazi, UnHerd

    Tbilisi has been ensnared by Nato hypocrisy

    August 27, 2024: Pavel Durov and the Abuse of Law – Craig Murray

    June 3, 2023: EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    February 7, 2023: Thousands NATO soldiers have already been killed in Donbass and Ukraine

    clues of NATO fatalities in Donbass and Ukraine

    September 21, 2022: The Western operatives in Mariupol

    clues of the involvement of Western operatives, especially French ones, trapped in March 2022 in Mariupol, that the Russian forces liberated in May

    L’engagement français dans les rangs ukrainiens

    chronique alphabétique et nécrologique de l’engagement français dans les rangs atlantistes en Ukraine, ce que les journalistes serviles ne vous raconteront pas

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    Nazism in Ukraine

    its roots before WW2, its collaboration with Nazi Germany, its legacy in modern Ukraine, how NATO has continually supported Nazism in Ukraine, chronicle

    The footprint of the Ukrainian Nazism in the West

    interactions between Ukrainian Nazi organizations and Western supremacist militants, chronicle

  • [Sharing] Just Get Out! Now! – Ron Paul

    As is becoming clearer from President Trump’s own statements and those of his staff, along with press reporting, the US has launched a major [war] without the input of the experts we pay to advise the President on such matters. The State Department, Pentagon, National Security Council Staff, Defense Intelligence Agency, and NSA were simply bypassed because, as White House Spokesperson Karoline Leavitt said, President Trump “had a feeling” Iran would attack.

    The President’s real estate developer son-in-law and friend reinforced that “feeling” when they returned from the second round of talks with the Iranian foreign minister and his team. However, as the news outlet Responsible Statecraft (RS) reported over the weekend, both son-in-law Jared Kushner and friend Steve Witkoff appear to have mis-represented those talks in a way that helped push President Trump toward war. No State Department officials were on hand to ensure the reporting was accurate.

    Also, arms control experts at home, according to the RS report, believe that “the duo appeared to have fatally misunderstood a series of basic technical and historical matters” regarding Iran’s nuclear program leading to inaccurate information conveyed to the President.

    Congress was completely out of the picture – seemingly uninterested in performing its Constitutional duty – and no case was made to the American people that they must sacrifice and die once again for a war in the Middle East.

    Trump’s repeated promises to not start new wars, especially in the Middle East, have turned out to be empty, and Republicans are set for a crippling defeat in the upcoming midterm elections.

    Iran had been warning for months – since the last US/Israeli surprise attack in June – that if they were attacked again they would not hold back on US bases in the region and that they would close the Straits of Hormuz. Trump and Netanyahu attacked anyway, and Iran has done what it said it would do.

    Now the Strait of Hormuz is closed, oil is about to go out of control, and the global economy – along with the US dollar – seems about to implode.

    On March 6th, President Trump refused a UK offer of help, saying we don’t need help when we’ve already won the war. Five days later, at a rally in Kentucky, President Trump repeated that “We’ve won the Iran war!”

    It was his “Mission Accomplished” moment, because this weekend, just days after declaring victory against an “obliterated” Iran, Trump began begging other countries to send ships to help the US open the Strait of Hormuz.

    Thus far every country has declined, understanding that such a mission has little chance of success.

    Tragically, the war thus far has claimed at least 14 servicemembers. It is likely the toll is far worse than they are telling us. Every US military facility in the region is either damaged or destroyed. Billions of dollars of radar and other equipment are destroyed. Our allies in the region, because they allowed their territory to be used to attack Iran, have also seen massive retaliatory destruction.

    This is surely one of the worst military disasters in US history. There are no military options available beyond the unthinkable: the use of nuclear weapons.

    The only viable option that remains is one that was often urged in the Vietnam War: Just get out. Now! No return to US bases, no security guarantees to Gulf States. End the US empire in the Middle East and elsewhere. If not, it’s only going to get worse [end]

    The original article

    Related

    Operation Epstein Files

    once more, the US and Israel attack Iran, chronicle

    March 15, 2026: Israel is running critically low on interceptors, US officials say – Shelby Talcott, Semafor

    March 7, 2026: Blinded giant: How Iran crippled America’s multi-billion dollar THAAD network in days – Ivan Kesic, Press TV

    In the first week of the US-Israeli aggression on Iran, the Islamic Revolution Guards Corps (IRGC) conducted a series of precision strikes that systematically degraded the much-hyped US integrated air and missile defense architecture across the region

    March 6, 2026: STOP THE IRAN WAR! – Eisenhower Media Network

    Eisenhower Media Network is an organization of expert former military, intelligence, and civilian national security officials who have an independent, alternative story to tell

    March 6, 2026: « The operation failed in the first hours»: The Iranians trapped the US military – Arguments & Facts

    Story: Escalation of the conflict between Israel, the US, and Iran in 2026

    February 15, 2026: Rubio gives green light to new era of US-European colonialism – Roger McKenzie, Morning Star

    January 29, 2026: Manufacturing martyrdom: The west’s cynical use of Iranian protest figures – Robert Inlakesh, The Cradle

    The US-funded ecosystem of Iranian ‘rights groups,’ Israeli operatives, and monarchist activists has become a revolving door of unverifiable statistics and atrocity propaganda

    January 12, 2026: Western Media Whitewashes Deadly Riots in Iran – Max Blumenthal & Wyatt Reed, Internationalist 360°

    As deadly riots burn Iranian cities, Western media ignores the shocking wave of violence, turning instead to US government-funded NGOs for data. The one-sided portrayal has helped push Trump to the brink of authorizing renewed US attacks

    January 3, 2026: Make Israel great again

    July 9, 2025: Israel is the Middle Eastern boil of Western imperialism

    the novelty is that the corrupt West is showing signs of sepsis

    July 8, 2025: Imperial Hypocrisy About “Terrorism” Hits Its Most Absurd Point Yet – Caitlin Johnstone

    July 2, 2025: Sudden acceleration of the Western decline

    the failure of the infamous Israeli attack against Iran

    June 30, 2025: 以色列上空的煙 Fireworks over Israel

    英之子樂隊 innokids

    June 13, 2025: Israel attacks Iran

    as thanks to the West, the rogue State gets away with its genocide in Gaza

    January 16, 2025: ‘I Felt Like A Nazi’: Zionists Admit Genocide – Kit Klarenberg

  • [Sharing] Sanctionnez-Moi, Sale Garce! – Scott Ritter, Forum Geopolitica

    In the Jacques Baud case, the EU is sanctioning, for the first time, an analyst not for spreading disinformation but for expressing a politically inconvenient truth, all while admitting he has broken no law. Will it have the courage to go after an American citizen?

    The European Union has sanctioned the veteran Swiss Intelligence Officer and Geopolitical analysts, 70-year-old Colonel Jacques Baud.

    His crime?

    He is a “regular guest on pro-Russian television and radio programs,” which makes him “a mouthpiece for pro-Russian propaganda” who “makes conspiracy theories” such as “accusing Ukraine of orchestrating its own invasion in order to join NATO.”

    Damn, this dude is bad ass.

    I quiver in fear at the thought of this septuagenarian “making conspiracy theories.”

    What’s a world powerhouse like the European Union to do in the face of such a threat?

    Why sanction the bugger, of course!

    Which is precisely what Kaja Kallas, the Estonian-born High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, did, promulgating a notice on December 15, 2025 which added twelve “natural persons” and two “entities” to a list of people and entities deemed to have run afoul of Council Regulation (EU) 2024/2642 (“EU Russia Destabilization Sanctions”). Passed in October 2024, this regulation introduced “new restrictive measures against Russia in response to its destabilizing activities against the EU and EU Member States.” The regulation was “designed to respond to Russia’s campaign of hybrid activities against the EU and its Member States.”

    The EU deemed this regulation necessary to counter alleged Russian hybrid actions designed to undermine elections, support violent demonstrations, commit acts of sabotage against democratic institutions, economic activities, or services of public interest, exploiting armed conflict for the purposes of illicit trade, and instigating or facilitating armed conflict.

    All the above listed actions could—and should—constitute criminal acts if carried out by any person.

    The question is, which of these nefarious deeds is Colonel Baud accused of undertaking?

    None of the above.

    Instead, he has fallen afoul of an additional listed activity, “supporting or otherwise facilitating the use of coordinated information manipulation and interference.” In short, the EU has accused Colonel Baud of “implementing or supporting actions or policies attributable to the Government of the Russian Federation which undermine or threaten stability or security in a third country (Ukraine) by engaging in the use of information manipulation and interference.”

    Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI) is the recent brainchild of the European External Action Service (EEAS), the diplomatic service in charge of executing all international relations of the European Union. Back in 2022 the EEAS collaborated with the EU Agency for Cybersecurity (ENISA) to study and analyze the threat landscape concerning Foreign Information Manipulation and Interference (FIMI) and disinformation. The mandate for this action was direction derived from the November 27, 2019, European Democracy Action Plan, which tasked the EEAS to “work with Member States, civil society and industry towards refined common definitions and methodologies in order to address different categories of disinformation and influence activities.”

    FIMI is defined by the EEAS as follows: “A mostly nonillegal pattern of behavior that threatens or has the potential to negatively impact values, procedures and political processes. Such activity is manipulative in character, conducted in an intentional and coordinated manner. Actors of such activity can be state or non-state actors, including their proxies inside and outside of their own territory.”

    By its own admission, the EEAS definition of what constitutes FIMI “puts emphasis on manipulative behavior, as opposed to the truthfulness of the content being delivered.”

    In short, the “crimes” Colonel Baud is accused of are procedural in nature and not derived from any actual disinformation or promulgation of lies or mistruths. Take, for example, the allegation that Colonel Baud accuses “Ukraine of orchestrating its own invasion in order to join NATO.”

    The basis for this accusation is Colonel Baud’s 2024 book, L’art de la guerre russe. Comment l’Occident a conduit l’Ukraine à l’échec (The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat), published by Max Milo Editions, a French publisher.

    The offending passages read as follows:

    Zelensky’s decree of March 24, 2021 for the reconquest of Crimea and the Donbass was the real trigger for the SMO. From that moment on, the Russians understood that if there was military action against them, they would have to intervene. But they also knew that the cause of the Ukrainian operation was NATO membership, as Oleksei Arestovitch had explained. That is why, in mid-December 2021, they were submitting proposals to the USA and NATO on extending the Alliance: their aim was then to remove Ukraine’s motive for an offensive in the Donbass.

    The reason for the Russian Special Military Operation (SMO) is indeed the protection of the populations of Donbass; but this protection was necessary because of Kiev’s desire to go through a confrontation to enter NATO. The extension of NATO is therefore only the indirect cause of the conflict in Ukraine. The latter could have spared itself this ordeal by implementing the Minsk Agreements—but what we wanted was a defeat for Russia.

    Jacques Baud in Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat

    Nothing Colonel Baud wrote is a lie, distortion of fact, or mistruth.

    Moreover, he published his work using a well-known French publisher—not a Russian mouthpiece.

    And it turns out every thing Colonel Baud wrote about Ukraine and NATO was true.

    Amanda Sloat, the former Biden Administration senior director for Europe at the National Security Council whom Politico has labeled “an architect of President Joe Biden’s Europe policy,” has recently admitted that the Russian initiation of the SMO could have been avoided if the US took NATO membership off the table when it came to Ukraine.

    “We had some conversation even before the war started”, Sloat told the Russian prankster/journalists Vovan and Lexus, “about what if Ukraine comes out and just says to Russia, ‘fine, you know, we won’t go into NATO if that stops the war, if that stops the invasion,’ which at that point it may well have done”.

    Amanda Sloat

    Sloat, however, noted that she was “uncomfortable with the idea of the US pushing Ukraine not to do that, and sort of implicitly giving Russia some sort of sphere of influence or veto power on that”, adding “I don’t think Biden felt like it was his place to tell Ukraine what to do then, to tell Ukraine not to pursue NATO”.

    In conclusion, Sloat admitted that

    “I guess if you want to do an alternative version of history, one option would have just been for Ukraine to say in January of 2022, ‘fine, you know, we won’t go into NATO, we will stay neutral.’ Ukraine could have made a deal around March/April of 2022 around the Istanbul talks. There is certainly a question,” she added, “almost three years on now, would that have been better to do before the war started, would that have been better to do in Istanbul talks, it certainly would have prevented the destruction and the loss of life”.

    Amanda Slout

    Damn.

    I guess the EU had better fire up its sanction machine.

    Amanda Sloat, how dare you say such things!

    You see, it doesn’t matter that what she said is true.

    What matters is that it goes against the official narrative promulgated by Ukraine, which has been adopted without question by the EU.

    Colonel Jacques Baud is guilty of nothing more than telling the fact-based truth, no matter how inconvenient it may be to the established powers in the EU.

    He has committed no crime—by their own admission, the EU states that the FIMI “crime” Colonel Baud has been convicted of, without benefit of due process, is nothing more than a “nonillegal pattern of behavior” in which the fact that he told the unvarnished truth is no factor.

    Colonel Baud told the truth outside the officially mandated informational pathways established by the EU, and in a manner which contradicted the lies and distortions being promulgated by Ukraine, and he had to be punished.

    Well, Ms. Kallas, I have a challenge for you.

    I, too, have been telling the truth about the Russian-Ukraine conflict.

    I have been put on the Mirotvorets death list by the Unkrainian intelligence service for the crime of telling the truth.

    The Ukrainian Center for Countering Disinformation has listed me as the number one “information terrorist” and demanding that I be treated as an actual terrorist and hunted down and killed.

    What the hell.

    I need a little more adventure in my life.

    Sanction me, Bitch.

    Do it.

    “F” around and find out.

    I’m an American.

    We believe in free speech.

    Seriously.

    Like, we will fight and die over this issue.

    Sanction me, and my country will fuck you up.

    It’s a damn shame Switzerland has abandoned Colonel Baud to his fate.

    The Swiss were once viewed as the defenders of democracy and all that attends it, inclusive of free speech.

    But no more. So pick on someone your own size.

    Sanction an American citizen.

    I dare you [end]

    The original article

    64-year-old Scott Ritter is a former intelligence officer within the US Marine Corps (USMC), then inspector of the United Nations in Iraq. When in 2003, the US and their British minions were about to invade the country under this false pretext, Ritter was claiming that there was no weapon of mass destruction (WMD) there. He was right.

    Related

    December 13, 2025: Jacques Baud nous répond – Hélène Richard-Favre

    December 10, 2025 : Censorship in Western Academia and the War in Ukraine – New Global Politics

    Why are liberal institutions censoring discussion of forced mobilization in Ukraine? – Volodymyr Ishchenko, Marta Havryshko, Tarik Cyril Amar, Milica Popović and Almut Rochowanski

    December 1, 2025 : Psychose – Pierre Rimbert, le Monde diplomatique

    November 11, 2025 : Der Krieg

    ce 11 novembre 2025 est l’occasion de souligner comme la façon dont l’Europe sacrifie les conscrits ukrainiens mobilisés de force rappelle le spectaculaire carnage de la 1ère guerre mondiale

    August 29, 2025 : How U.S. Support for Ukraine’s Neo-Nazis Imperils Diplomacy – Harrison Berger, The American Conservative

    Since the Cold War, Washington has empowered violent anti-Russian extremists

    August 21, 2025 : « Ukraine über alles! » – Susann Witt-Stahl, junge Welt

    Azov paramilitaries are aiming to debunk Kremlin « myths ». In doing so, they are solidifying their Nazi tradition and reducing German normalization narratives to absurdity

    August 2, 2025 : Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    Ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    March 14, 2025 : « Pensions ou munitions ? » : la fabrique du consentement à « l’effort de guerre » – Pauline Perrenot, Acrimed

    Depuis l’allocution d’Emmanuel Macron à propos de la guerre en Ukraine, le 5 mars, les grands médias sont en ordre de marche. Réhabilitation du président en « chef de guerre », patriotisme exacerbé, concert militariste et glorification des industriels de guerre… Mené tambour battant, le SAV du discours présidentiel s’accompagne d’une nouvelle séquence de matraquage patronal contre le « modèle social » et pour « travailler plus » au nom, prétendument, de l’« effort de guerre » : « Pensions ou munitions ? » ; « Les canons ou les allocations ? » Signés Dominique Seux (Les Échos, 10/03) et Étienne Gernelle (RTL, 10/03), les deux slogans donnent le ton

    December 12, 2024 : McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    November 26, 2024 : How the Strategy of Fighting to the Last Ukrainian Was Sold to the Public as Morally Righteous – Glenn Diesen

    April 11, 2024 : U.S. Government Helps Pro-Ukraine Media Spread Propaganda And Silence American Critics – Lee Fang, RealClearInvestigations

    Media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government have supported censorship, disseminated disinfo, and sought to silence American critics of the war

    January 1, 2024 : The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat – Jacques Baud, The Postil Magazine

    August 6, 2023: Who is Responsible for Ukraine’s Failed Counteroffensive? – Scott Ritter, Sputnik

    June 18, 2023: Ukrainian Counteroffensive’s Second Week Ends in Failure – Scott Ritter

    Operation enters the second week of Ukraine’s long-awaited and highly touted counteroffensive, some basic conclusions can be drawn even though the fighting continues, and will continue to rage, for some time to come

    June 10, 2023: Finally the Bull Charged – Scott Ritter

    June 3, 2023 : EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    March 9, 2023 : How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    The West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    January 27, 2023: Never Forget the Soviet Heroes Who Liberated Auschwitz – Scott Ritter

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Partage] Jacques Baud nous répond – Hélène Richard-Favre

    Bonjour Jacques BAUD! Vous vous rappelez bien sûr la série d’entretiens que nous avions menés ensemble sur ce blog. C’était un article de Sylvain Besson qui avait motivé ma démarche auprès de vous pour en savoir un peu plus. Nous étions début septembre 2020. 

    Voici ce même journaliste reprendre un article paru sur Radio free Europe et parler de vous en termes que je vous serais reconnaissante de commenter. L’article en question, paru sur le site de la Tribune de Genève, est déjà suivi de plus de 300 commentaires. Qu’avez-vous à nous en dire ?

    Merci pour votre question. Oui, j’ai été surpris par cette information, même si je ne sais pas encore en ce moment si elle est vraie ou non. Je pars de l’idée qu’elle l’est.

    Mon approche du conflit russo-ukrainien (comme des autres, d’ailleurs) est d’exposer les faits afin de comprendre ce qui se passe, avec la finalité d’y trouver une solution. Comme je le répète souvent: « de la manière de comprendre une crise découle celle de la résoudre ». Cette compréhension doit se faire indépendamment de toute préférence pour l’une ou l’autre des parties en présence. Aujourd’hui, particulièrement en Europe, si votre appréciation s’écarte un tant soit peu de la ligne officielle, vous êtes considéré comme « pro-russe » ou « conspirationniste ». Si vous lisez les commentaires des différentes interviews que j’ai accordées, les commentaires « équilibrés », « factuels » ou « balancés » reviennent le plus souvent. Après une interview qui a été publiée sur un média américain, un internaute a commenté: « Bien que Baud soit pro-ukrainien, il a bien compris la position russe! ». On est aux antipodes de ce que racontent nos journalistes. En novembre 2022, le journaliste suisse Jean-Philippe Schaller de la RTS déclarait que j’étais un agent au service de Vladimir Poutine! Quelles sont ses sources? Aucune: c’est du conspirationnisme pur et simple.

    Le problème aujourd’hui est que si l’on dit que « la Russie gagne » on est automatiquement considéré comme « pro-russe ». Mais la victoire ou la défaite de l’un ou de l’autre ne dépend pas de ce que nous disons ou pensons! C’est une réalité. On pourrait même aller plus loin, j’ai expliqué dès 2022 pourquoi l’Ukraine perdait. Si on en avait tenu compte et aidé l’Ukraine non pas pour affaiblir la Russie mais pour qu’elle gagne, elle gagnerait aujourd’hui. Tout était parfaitement clair à la fin 2022. C’est d’ailleurs la raison pour laquelle les Américains ont conseillé à Zelensky d’ouvrir un dialogue avec la Russie.

    Nos journalistes croient aider l’Ukraine, mais c’est faux. À Bruxelles, j’ai été à quatre reprises arrêté dans la rue par des Ukrainiens (de Kharkiv, Odessa et Dniepropetrovsk) qui m’ont remercié pour ce que je fais. Un Ukrainien m’a même envoyé une carte postale avec le timbre de l’attaque contre le croiseur russe Moskva dans la Mer Noire. Nous avons un regard plus polarisé que les Ukrainiens eux-mêmes sur ce conflit. D’ailleurs, pour ceux qui veulent prendre la peine de lire mes livres, ils constateront que je n’utilise aucune source russe, mais exclusivement la presse ukrainienne et américaine: je prends la presse européenne (suisse en particulier) pour les mauvais exemples! Nos journalistes n’utilisent que l’information qui sort des bureaux de l’administration ukrainienne. Les journalistes ukrainiens sont beaucoup plus honnêtes et professionnels que les nôtres. La catastrophe de la bataille de Krinky, sur le Dniepr, par exemple, a été rapportée en grands détails avec des critiques sérieuses contre les militaires britanniques qui l’avaient planifiée et dirigée. Pas un mot dans nos médias. Lisez mes livres. Il y a des centaines de notes: elles viennent presque toutes de médias ukrainiens ou américains.

    Aujourd’hui, même le premier-ministre belge reconnaît qu’une défaite de la Russie est une illusion. C’était déjà ce que les Américains pensaient en novembre 2022, lorsqu’ils ont conseillé à Zelensky d’ouvrir un dialogue avec Moscou. Dire que la Russie ne perd pas ne signifie pas que l’on est pro-russe, c’est un avertissement. Qu’ont fait les Besson et autres plumitifs pour tenir compte de ces avertissements et faire en sorte que l’on aide l’Ukraine efficacement ? Rien! Rien du tout, à part vociférer contre la Russie. Le problème est qu’aujourd’hui le narratif entre en collision avec la réalité et, après 4 ans (!), le système se défend en interdisant les vues qui ne lui plaisent pas. J’ai décrit exactement les mécanismes internes à la conduite ukrainienne qui la défavorisaient sur le terrain. Qui s’en est soucié pour améliorer la conduite ukrainienne? Personne. Aujourd’hui, on s’aperçoit qu’on a loupé une occasion. Cette guerre, qu’on le veuille ou non, est plus dictée par la haine de la Russie que par l’amour de l’Ukraine. Même Zelensky s’en est aperçu.

    Lorsque Sylvain Besson m’a appelé vendredi 12 décembre, il m’a demandé si je croyais que la Russie avait bien attaqué l’Ukraine, j’ai répondu que oui, mais que je pense qu’il y a eu provocation, exactement comme en Géorgie en 2008, et que je m’appuyais sur une interview d’Olekseï Arestovitch (alors conseiller de Zelensky), dans une interview du 18 mars 2019 au média ukrainien Apostrof’, lors de laquelle il explique qu’il faudra une guerre avec la Russie pour pouvoir entrer dans l’OTAN et que cette guerre aurait probablement lieu en « 2021-2022 ».  À ceci s’ajoutent les observations faites par les observateurs de l’OSCE entre le 16 et le 21 février 2022, qui montraient une claire intensification des frappes contre les populations du Donbass. Sans compter le décret du 24 mars 2021 de Zelensky qui déclare la reprise de la Crimée et qui marque le début de la montée en puissance de l’Ukraine sur les pourtours du Donbass. Évidemment, Besson s’est bien gardé de le mentionner dans son article!… et pour cause!

    Mais il y a d’autres choses pas honnêtes. Par exemple, j’ai toujours refusé les invitations de médias officiels russes, parce que je voulais éviter que mes analyses puissent être instrumentalisées à des fins de propagande. J’ai expliqué ça aux journalistes russes qui l’ont très bien compris. Les médias mentionnés par Besson (Agoravox, media 4-4-2 et RT) sont des médias qui ont repris (sans me le demander) des interviews faites sur d’autres plateformes et/ou vendues par elles. Omerta est un média qui m’interviewe occasionnellement, dont le directeur (Régis le Sommier) apparaît également sur Europe 1 et d’autres médias mainstream français.

    Quant à la présence de soldats nord-coréens en Ukraine, je ne l’ai pas mise en doute. J’ai mis en doute leur intégration dans les forces russes. Et les faits m’ont donné raison.  La conférence à laquelle j’ai participé à Winterthour portait sur la neutralité de la Suisse. Je ne me suis jamais exprimé sur les questions liées au Covid et aux vaccins, comme le suggère Besson. Contrairement à ce qu’il affirme, je n’ai jamais participé à la « formation d’armées locales », j’ai toujours été engagé dans le cadre des Nations Unies et sous leur contrôle.

    Conclusion: une fois de plus, Sylvain Besson ne s’est pas montré comme un  journaliste intègre. Une étude de l’Université d’Uppsala (pas une officine comme Conspiracy Watch payée par le gouvernement britannique!) le qualifie de conspirationniste et d’inspirateur d’Anders Breivik, responsable de la tuerie d’Utoya.

    Dans tous les cas de figure, penser que l’UE conduit l’Ukraine à sa perte n’est – à ma connaissance – pas un délit!

    Merci beaucoup de vos réponses, Jacques Baud. Et juste encore pour préciser à nos lecteurs que si vous avez donc eu droit à être fiché conspirationniste par Conspiracy Watch, du seul fait de vous avoir interrogé sur mon blog m’a valu d’être étiquetée telle sur ledit site. C’est dire où on en est! [fin]

    L’article original

    Jacques Baud a été colonel du renseignement suisse, spécialiste de l’Europe de l’Est. Entre 2009 et 2011, il dirigeait à New York l’équipe Politiques et Doctrine du Bureau des affaires militaires du Département des opérations de maintien de la paix des Nations Unies. Ce fut dans le cadre de l’OTAN qu’il participa à des programmes en Ukraine en 2014 et 2017

    Articles connexes

    10 décembre 2025 : Censorship in Western Academia and the War in Ukraine – New Global Politics

    Why are liberal institutions censoring discussion of forced mobilization in Ukraine? – Volodymyr Ishchenko, Marta Havryshko, Tarik Cyril Amar, Milica Popović and Almut Rochowanski

    1er décembre 2025 : Psychose – Pierre Rimbert, le Monde diplomatique

    11 novembre 2025 : Der Krieg

    ce 11 novembre 2025 est l’occasion de souligner comme la façon dont l’Europe sacrifie les conscrits ukrainiens mobilisés de force rappelle le spectaculaire carnage de la 1ère guerre mondiale

    29 août 2025 : How U.S. Support for Ukraine’s Neo-Nazis Imperils Diplomacy – Harrison Berger, The American Conservative

    Since the Cold War, Washington has empowered violent anti-Russian extremists

    21 août 2025 : « Ukraine über alles! » – Susann Witt-Stahl, junge Welt

    Azov paramilitaries are aiming to debunk Kremlin « myths ». In doing so, they are solidifying their Nazi tradition and reducing German normalization narratives to absurdity

    2 août 2025 : Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    Ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    14 mars 2025 : « Pensions ou munitions ? » : la fabrique du consentement à « l’effort de guerre » – Pauline Perrenot, Acrimed

    Depuis l’allocution d’Emmanuel Macron à propos de la guerre en Ukraine, le 5 mars, les grands médias sont en ordre de marche. Réhabilitation du président en « chef de guerre », patriotisme exacerbé, concert militariste et glorification des industriels de guerre… Mené tambour battant, le SAV du discours présidentiel s’accompagne d’une nouvelle séquence de matraquage patronal contre le « modèle social » et pour « travailler plus » au nom, prétendument, de l’« effort de guerre » : « Pensions ou munitions ? » ; « Les canons ou les allocations ? » Signés Dominique Seux (Les Échos, 10/03) et Étienne Gernelle (RTL, 10/03), les deux slogans donnent le ton

    12 décembre 2024 : McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    26 novembre 2024 : How the Strategy of Fighting to the Last Ukrainian Was Sold to the Public as Morally Righteous – Glenn Diesen

    11 avril 2024 : U.S. Government Helps Pro-Ukraine Media Spread Propaganda And Silence American Critics – Lee Fang, RealClearInvestigations

    Media outlets organized with substantial funding and direction from the U.S. government have supported censorship, disseminated disinfo, and sought to silence American critics of the war

    1er janvier 2024 : The Russian Art of War: How the West Led Ukraine to Defeat – Jacques Baud, The Postil Magazine

    3 juin 2023 : EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    9 mars 2023 : How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    The West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Sharing] Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    Ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    There’s a peculiar affliction that’s gripped the Western commentariat for decades now. I first diagnosed it in June 2015 and gave it a name: Russophrenia. The tell-tale sign? That deep-set conviction that Russia’s about to keel over economically—then somehow rise from the wreckage to take Brussels by breakfast. In those ten years, the condition’s only become more widespread—like a political variant of Covid, except there’s no PCR tests, and the worst sufferers have column inches.

    Back in 2015, it was already clear. Read any English-language piece on Russia and you’d find the same breathless contradictions. “The ruble is in freefall”… followed two paragraphs later by “Russian ‘oligarchs’ (sic) are buying up half of France.” Russia, we were told, was a “gas station with nukes,” a “mafia state,” “on the brink of collapse.” That was just before the same experts warned it could manipulate every Western election, hack every NATO server, and brainwash half of Ohio.

    So let’s rummage through the old press clippings, shall we? Some of them haven’t aged as well as their writers hoped.

    In 2001, The Atlantic boldly declared “Russia Is Finished.” Spoiler: as we know, it wasn’t. Nearly a quarter century on, that headline now looks more like a cry for help.

    In 2008, the Guardian’s Luke Harding—who’s always good for a prediction—declared Russia “close to economic collapse” due to falling oil prices. Within a year, the economy had bounced back and Harding was warning of a “new arms race.” Later, he authored an extensively debunked book built around the mirage of “RussiaGate”—now widely discredited thanks to U.S. intelligence disclosures.

    Julia Ioffe joined in 2014 with her own “Russia is falling apart” prophecy—echoing Masha Gessen’s 2011 forecast that “Putin’s world is falling apart.” Over a decade later, Putin’s still at the desk, and those takes have aged like unrefrigerated milk.

    And then there was Mark Galeotti, who warned in 2015 that Putin’s brief disappearance might trigger “succession wars.” He reappeared days later looking mildly bored. Leaving a lot of ridiculous-looking tweets.

    But perhaps the finest specimen of advanced-stage Russophrenia was the late US Senator John McCain, who famously called Russia “a gas station masquerading as a country.” This from a man who once took a break from posing with Islamist rebels to compare Putin to Hitler. The irony? Russia’s economy—gas station or not— is now the largest in Europe. After passing out Germany a few years ago on PPP rankings. And McCain’s rhetorical gas ran out long before Russia’s did.

    Of course, none of this means Russia is a utopia. Far from it. The economy has structural problems. The political system is more fortress than forum. And yes, the Ukraine conflict has triggered enormous costs. But facts are stubborn things. Despite the most aggressive sanctions regime in history, Russia hasn’t imploded. The Moscow stock exchange, after being written off in early 2022, was at 2,727 points on Friday. Far off its all time high (4,292), but hardly on its knees. Agricultural exports have soared. The birth rate, albeit not great, is still better than much of Europe. And those American-made “devastating sanctions”? India, China, Turkey, and most of the Global South didn’t get the memo.

    The Western media, however, hasn’t changed its tune. They’ve just layered it. Now it’s: yes, Russia is collapsing… but it’s also exporting authoritarianism, destabilising Africa, puppeteering Hungary, and might invade the Baltics on Tuesday. Russophrenia 2.0.

    And what drives it all? Familiarity’s absence. Sanctions, the forced closure of consulates, shuttered news bureaus—it’s never been harder for a Westerner to visit Russia. And the fewer people who go, the more powerful the myths become. Russia becomes a Rorschach test—some see Mordor, others a 1980s cartoon villain. Almost no one sees it as it is: complex, contradictory, sometimes maddening, sometimes magnificent. In short, a real country, not a narrative prop.

    Back in Ireland, when I mention Russia, I often get two reactions: one, that Russia’s economy is in ruins; two, that it’s plotting world domination. The contradiction passes without comment. That’s the thing about Russophrenia—you don’t notice the absurdity when you’re living inside it.

    Meanwhile, most coverage of Russia isn’t even produced from inside Russia anymore. It’s written from Riga, or Warsaw, or Zoom calls with the same four exiled pundits. The actual country is missing. And with it, any chance of nuance.

    Of course, Russia’s no tidy postcard. It sprawls out like it means to confuse you. One minute it’s throwing you a smile over breakfast, and by tea it’s broken your heart. You touch down thinking you’ve got the place half-sussed, and by the time you hit passport control, you’re not so sure of anything. That’s not some bug in the system—it’s the system. And for all its mess and mischief, it’s still real. Real enough to deserve being seen on its own terms, not squeezed to fit the shape of someone’s word count.

    It’s been ten years since I first gave a name to this fever, and still it burns. The same old phantoms—maps from another century, clichés with the ink worn thin—held up as gospel. The patient isn’t getting better. Just louder.

    So here’s my prescription: less punditry, more plane tickets. Less projection, more proximity. And above all, less fear.

    You don’t have to toast the place or take its side. Just stop seeing ghosts. Wipe your lens, look again. That’s where recovery begins [end]

    The original article

    Related

    July 17, 2025: La Russie est notre Rorschach – Emmanuel Todd

    May 9, 2025: Victory Day

    April 30, 2025: IGNORANCE – Scott Ritter

    December 13, 2024: McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    October 7, 2024: Is Russia Really The “Greatest Threat” To France? – Andrew Korybko, Oriental Review

    Russia’s support of multipolar processes in West Africa has dealt a heavy blow to French hegemony there, which France has responded to by waging a proxy war on Russia in Mali while going on the strategic offensive in the South Caucasus and Eastern Europe

    July 5, 2024: The Franco-British Plot to Dismember Russia [1917 – ?] – Kit Klarenberg

    June 3, 2023: EU’s Voluntary Disinformation Code Is Compulsory: Obey or Die – Declan Hayes, Strategic Culture Foundation

    Though Musk is still playing at being NATO’s token non-conformist, the EU is essentially telling him and all of us that any dissent from its Russophobic, Slavophobic and Sinophobic narratives will be severely punished

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Sharing] Even if the war ended tomorrow, Ukraine could end up broke by 2026 – Ian Proud, Responsible Statecraft

    There’s a gaping hole in Kyiv’s finances that no amount of tax increases or Western donations will be able to fill

    There is no plan in place to fund the Ukrainian budget after 2025.

    Even if the war ends by the summer of 2025, it will take some time to reduce military expenditures, leaving European nations on the hook. It’s not clear that European elites have fully understood the political costs, however much longer the war continues.

    With intensive, U.S.-brokered negotiations ongoing in Saudi Arabia involving separate Ukrainian and Russian delegations, hopes are rising that the Trump administration will finally be able to bring an end to the war.

    But even if the war ends tomorrow, it would be unwise to assume that Ukraine could reduce military spending close to prewar levels.

    Ukraine now has almost 900,000 men and women at arms, a threefold increase from peacetime, and that doesn’t take into account irrecoverable losses through death and injury. Estimates vary widely, but the casualty rate is commonly thought to number in the hundreds of thousands, with compensation provided to the injured and families of the deceased.

    The war in Ukraine has therefore come at a vast financial cost to that country. Ukraine’s defense spending has risen tenfold since the 2021 budget was announced, when social welfare payments were the country’s biggest expenditure.

    This has left a gaping hole in Ukraine’s finances that no amount of tax increases or Western donations will be able to fill over a sustained period without political consequences.

    Since 2022, Ukraine has run an average budget deficit of over 22% of GDP. Based on the current exchange rate, Ukraine’s budget shortfall in 2025 amounts to around $41.5 billion. And that assumes defense spending falling slightly this year. In the hopefully unlikely event that war continues to the end of the year, the Ukrainian state would need to revise its budget upwards as it did in 2024.

    Today, Ukraine’s domestic revenue, including taxes, excise, and duties, just about covers the cost of the defense effort, which in 2024 accounted for 64% of its total budget expenditure. That includes significant tax increases as the war has gone on. Total tax revenue will have risen by more than 100% since the war started and personal income taxes by over 200%. This in a country in which, according to the Wilson Center, 50% of the population lives at a basic subsistence level.

    As Ukraine is cut off from international capital markets, it has had to meet the difference through aid and loans from Western nations.

    Put simply, Western donations and loans have paid the salaries of Ukrainian state officials and kept the lights on in their buildings. At the start of the war, donations took the form of free financial aid to meet the country’s budgetary and military needs. According to the Kiel Institute, the United States has provided just above $50 billion in direct budgetary assistance. The European Union provided $51.5 billion in financial assistance – i.e., budgetary support – between 2022 and 2024.

    However, since the start of 2024, free aid has progressively shifted to lending as Western governments have felt the political and economic cost of unlimited financial assistance.

    So, Ukraine has increasingly resorted to borrowing money. In some regards, that is to be expected. Governments tend to borrow heavily at times of war. The UK only settled its World War II war debts to the United States and Canada in 2006.

    Ukrainian debt has therefore soared to over 100% of GDP and, critically, the cost of servicing its debt has tripled, and now makes up the second largest line of expenditure in Ukraine’s budget, after military spending. To put that into context, Ukraine will spend more than twice the amount on servicing its debt in 2025 than it spends on the health of its population. That ratio will only widen the longer the war continues.

    Ukraine should just about be able to make ends meet in 2025 thanks to the G7 Extraordinary Revenue Acceleration loan agreed in June 2024. As part of a last-ditch compromise by the outgoing Biden Administration, the $20 billion U.S. contribution to the G7 loan was directed through the World Bank to provide specific project-based support – i.e., to help rebuild power infrastructure – rather than generalized budgetary support.

    The crucial point is that I’ve seen no plans for how Ukraine’s budgetary needs will be met from 2026 onward. Even if the war ends tomorrow, Ukraine may still be at risk of running out of money in 2026 if Western donor countries falsely assume that it will be able to return to prewar spending on Day One.

    Therefore, the big question is how quickly Ukraine can reduce military spending in 2026 and who will cover the shortfall. To balance the books in 2026, Ukraine would need to reduce its military spending by 80%, or around $41 billion.

    But decision-makers in Kyiv may understandably push to maintain a big army against the threat of future Russian aggression. While the huge expenditure in weapons and ammunition from war fighting may fall away, maintaining a standing army, even if its numbers are reduced, would still carry a heavy price. Even if Ukraine’s future budget deficit wasn’t as high as $41 billion, it is easy to imagine that it might be $20 billion.

    The International Monetary Fund also doesn’t expect Ukraine to be able to access international lending markets before 2027. That will leave the Ukrainian state reaching out to donor nations for additional funding. With the Trump administration looking to pare back its financial commitments to Ukraine and focus instead on investing, including in minerals, the pressure will be on European states. There is significant political risk here. In the past few days, the Europeans struggled to agree to an additional weapons package of $5 billion for Ukraine. Funding $20 billion in budgetary support to Ukraine in 2026 following a ceasefire this year may still herald a backlash from those on the nationalist left and right who believe the war should have ended in 2022. I assess the UK and Europe would find it economically and politically unsustainable to prop up the war beyond this year without the United States. That’s another reason why European leaders should get behind ongoing peace negotiations [end]

    The original article

    Ian Proud was a member of His Britannic Majesty’s Diplomatic Service from 1999 to 2023. He served as the Economic Counsellor at the British Embassy in Moscow from July 2014 to February 2019. Prior to Moscow, he organized the 2013 G8 Summit in Lough Erne, Northern Ireland, working out of 10 Downing Street. He recently published his memoir, “A Misfit in Moscow: How British diplomacy in Russia failed, 2014-2019”

    Related

    March 16, 2025: The Minsk Agreements and why they failed – Ian Proud, Strategic Culture Foundation

    The Minsk agreements fell apart because delivering special status for the Donbas was politically too difficult in Ukraine

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

  • [Sharing] McCarthyism, European style: The elite crackdown on Ukraine dissent – Eldar Mamedov, Responsible Statecraft

    Experts lambasted as Kremlin mouthpieces turned out to be right

    As the war between Russia and Ukraine is framed by the ruling politicians and commentators in Europe and America as part of a purported global struggle between democracies and autocracies, the quality of democracy in the West itself has taken a hit.

    The dominant voices advocating for Ukraine’s victory and Russia’s defeat, both defined in maximalist and increasingly unattainable terms, are intent on snuffing out more thoughtful and nuanced perspectives, thus depriving the public of a democratic debate on the existential questions of war and peace.

    In a familiar pattern throughout the West, respected academics who correctly predicted the quagmire Ukraine and the West now find themselves in have been smeared and delegitimized as Kremlin mouthpieces, subjected to harassment, marginalization and ostracism.

    The situation is particularly alarming in Europe. While the Ukraine debate in the U.S. is, to a worrying extent, shaped by pro-militarist think tanks, such as the Atlantic Council, hawkish politicians and neoconservative pundits, a countervailing movement consisting of pro-restraint voices has been growing. They include Defense Priorities, the CATO Institute, publications like The Nation on the left, and The American Conservative on the right, and academics like Stephen Walt, John Mearsheimer, and Jeffrey Sachs, among others. There is more space for alternative voices in American discourse.

    In Europe, by contrast, foreign policy debates tend to simply echo the most hawkish voices inside Washington’s Beltway.

    Sweden is a particularly telling illustration of that trend. After Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the Swedish government and political class swiftly moved to join NATO. Yet, as one of the leading Swedish international relations scholars Frida Stranne told me in an interview, “No proper debate was held on the key questions, like whether Russia’s aggression against Ukraine indeed was such an immediate security threat for Sweden that it had to ditch the neutral status it enjoyed even during the Cold War?” (I can testify myself, from my work as a senior foreign policy adviser in the European Parliament in early 2022, that even some members of the then-ruling Swedish social-democratic party were aghast at the government running roughshod over alternative views on NATO).

    Further, in a conversation with me, Stranne, while acknowledging that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine was “an egregious breach of international law,” pointed to U.S. policies since 2001, such as the invasion of Iraq, noting that they “have helped to undermine international legal principles and set the precedent for other countries acting ‘preemptively’ against perceived threats.”

    In the same interview, she also warned that “a refusal to countenance a negotiated settlement to the war in Ukraine is leading the world perilously close to the brink of a major military conflict between NATO and Russia.”

    While such points are routinely made by fairly mainstream scholars in the U.S., in Sweden they triggered a vicious campaign against Stranne and made her nearly untouchable by the media and in foreign policy circles. Leading media outlets vilified her as a U.S. hater and a “Putinist.”

    Germany is another example of how enforced groupthink led to a marginalization of dissenting perspectives in political debates. What is particularly noteworthy is the speed and radicalism with which the hawks in think tanks, media, and political parties managed to redefine the debate in a country previously known for its now-defunct Ostpolitik, a policy of pragmatic engagement with the Soviet Union and later Russia.

    One of Germany’s most prominent foreign policy experts, Johannes Varwick of the University Halle-Wittenberg, has long defied the trend and advocated for diplomacy. In December 2021, together with a number of high-ranking former military officers, diplomats and academics, he warned that a massive deterioration in relations with Russia could lead to war — due, in part, to the West’s refusal to take seriously Russia’s security concerns, chiefly related to the prospects of NATO’s eastward expansion.

    Yet such views earned Varwick accusations of “serving Russian interests.” As a result, as he told me in an interview, his “ties with the political parties and ministries responsible for conducting Germany’s foreign and security policy were severed.”

    Experts in neutral countries were not spared marginalization as well. Austrian Prof. Gerhard Mangott, one of the most eminent experts on Russia in the German-speaking world, pointed to a “shared responsibility” of Russia, Ukraine, and Western countries for the failure to resolve the post-2014 Ukrainian conflict peacefully. Such analysis, as Mangott told me, led to his “prompt excommunication by the German-speaking scientific community which turned quickly to political activism and became party to the war.”

    The tragic irony, of course, is that these ostracized voices have proved to be correct in most respects about this war.

    When, despite his warnings, the Russian invasion of Ukraine did occur, Varwick, who condemned it as illegal and unacceptable, called for further efforts to find a realistic negotiated solution to the conflict. As he told me, this should “firstly include a neutral status for Ukraine with strong security guarantees for the country. Secondly, there would be territorial changes in Ukraine that would not be recognized under international law but must be accepted as a temporary modus vivendi, and thirdly, the prospect of suspension of some sanctions in the event of a change in Russia’s behavior must be on offer.”

    In March 2022, both Ukraine and Russia were close to a deal broadly along these same parameters. It did not work, because, among other reasons, the West encouraged Ukraine to believe that a military “victory” was possible. The role of then-British Prime Minister Boris Johnson in undermining the talks is now generally acknowledged. What is, however, particularly striking is that Johnson recently himself admitted that he saw the war in Ukraine as a proxy war against Russia — a claim made by Stranne and the Quincy Institute’s Trita Parsi in their 2023 book, in Swedish, “The Illusion of American Peace,” for which they were lambasted for purportedly pushing Russian narratives.

    Fast forward to late 2024, and, faced with growing difficulties on the battlefield, Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky is now signaling that he could go along with some of the elements outlined by Varwick; namely, accepting some de facto territorial losses to prevent even bigger ones should the war continue.

    Today, Ukraine is farther away from achieving anything remotely resembling a military victory than at any point since February 2022. Contrary to the expectations in the U.S. and EU, sanctions neither tanked Russia’s economy nor changed its policies in the ways the West sought.

    In the West itself, political forces that urge negotiations to end the war are ascendant, as evidenced by the election of Donald Trump as president in the United States and the rise of anti-war parties in Germany, France and other EU countries. Public opinion surveys consistently show a preference of the majority of Europeans for a negotiated end to the war.

    The reality is, irrespective of the outcome of the war in Ukraine, a modus vivendi between the West and Russia will have to be reestablished to ensure, in Varwick’s words, “their coexistence in a Cold War 2.0 without a permanent escalation.” Restoring an open democratic debate about this vital issue is long overdue.

    Listening to the experts who have a proven track record of correct analysis would be a necessary first step [end]

    The original article

    Related

    29 novembre 2023 : How American Neocons Wrecked the Middle East and Ukraine – David Stockman, Antiwar.com

    This is part 2 of “Why There Is Still No Peace on Earth: Washington’s Folly From The Persian Gulf to Ukraine.”  Read part 1

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Ukraine against Russia