Nicolas Cinquini

Analista senior di l'intelligenza in u campu di a gestione di i risichi di sicurezza, sò un anzianu tenente detective è ufficiale di l'intelligenza in l'agenzie di u Statu francese. A bona pronuncia hè Николай Чинкуини, in russu

Tag: kishoremahbubani

  • [Sharing] Too late to save Europe: What Putin, Lavrov, Oreshkin, and Karaganov told me at the Valdai Summit 2026 – Lorenzo Maria Pacini, Strategic Culture Foundation

    If the door that Moscow says is open is actually closed, it’s closed on this side – and it wasn’t Rome that closed it of its own accord

    A Valdai summit off-site

    What I’m going to share in this article is less technical and more personal than usual. It concerns the information gathered over several days of dialogue, discussion, and, apparently, a “scandalous” question that became a media sensation in Europe – because I asked the President of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, what will become of Europe.

    You can find the full video of Vladimir Putin’s speech at the Valdai Forum here.

    You can find my remarks and Putin’s responses here.

    This year, the Valdai Forum did not meet in Sochi. Invitations sent out in the summer still listed the Black Sea city as the venue, but then, in late August, the organizers announced the move to the Moscow region. According to FT, the Federal Protective Service demanded the relocation, concerned about the threat of Ukrainian drones following a summer of attacks on coastal refineries. This logistical detail carries its own weight. The war – which at Valdai is always discussed in the language of the international system – is now also influencing the practical organization of the forum.

    The 23rd Annual Meeting took place from September 28 to October 1 under a title that to a European sounds almost like a personal question: “Responsibility for the Future: The Limits of the Possible or Limitless Possibilities?” The opening featured the Club’s annual report, Keep Calm. The State and Responsibility for the Future, which the authors present – with a nod to Kubrick – as a manual for stopping worrying and learning to love chaos. This was followed by nine thematic sessions, a special session, and, on the final day, the plenary session with the President.

    I arrived as an Italian and a European, knowing that in those halls, the two identities carry different weight. Over the course of the week, I spoke, in particular, with four high-level interlocutors: Sergey Karaganov, Maksim Oreshkin, Sergey Lavrov, and, during the plenary session, Vladimir Putin. The first three conversations took place on the sidelines of the sessions, and I’m recounting them from my notes – in essence, not word for word. The fourth exchange is public and documented by a transcript, from which I’m quoting directly.

    Taken one by one, the four dialogues convey things that anyone following the Russian debate is already familiar with. When viewed in sequence, however, they paint a clearer picture: a shared assessment of Europe and four different ways of drawing conclusions from it. And, above all, a future that is by no means bright.

    Karaganov: Europe as the source of evil

    Sergei Karaganov is one of the founders of the Valdai Club, honorary chairman of the Council on Foreign and Defense Policy, and for years has been the most radical voice of Russian realism. With him, the conversation began immediately with the most contentious point. Europe, he said, is the root of all evil. If it were destroyed, no one would mourn it. A tactical nuclear conflict on its territory would not involve other actors. Europeans have had plenty of time to find a solution to their own problems; now that they have chosen to prepare for war against Russia, it is too late to offer them another chance.

    I must be honest: I’ve never been a fan of Karaganov; I’ve often found his views too radical and old-fashioned. But starting with an after-lunch coffee together – and continuing over the course of a week of discussions – I discovered that we think very similarly and that his views are by no means trivial. Anyone who has read his recent statements will recognize this line of thinking. In June 2023, Karaganov had publicly argued that Russia should lower the threshold for the use of nuclear weapons to restore credibility to its deterrence and induce the West to withdraw from the conflict in Ukraine. Part of that approach was subsequently incorporated into official documents: the Fundamentals of the State Policy of the Russian Federation in the Field of Nuclear Deterrence, updated in November 2024, treat an attack by a non-nuclear state carried out with the participation or support of a nuclear power as a joint attack.

    His words, however, contain three distinct assertions, and it is worth keeping them separate. The first is a historical and civilizational judgment: Europe as the source of modernity’s great catastrophes, from the world wars to colonialism. This is a thesis that Karaganov has long argued and which can be contested, but it belongs to the realm of interpretation. The second – that no one would mourn Europe – is a prediction about others’ reactions; from what I observed during those days, it resonates with a significant portion of the Asian, African, and Latin American participants. The third is a strategic hypothesis that underpins everything else: a nuclear escalation in Europe would remain confined to Europe.

    On this point, the literature on deterrence has been debating for seventy years, and – fortunately – empirical evidence is lacking. The factor that complicates this hypothesis lies within Europe itself. France and the United Kingdom possess national arsenals, and in March 2025, Paris formally opened the debate on the European dimension of its own deterrence. A “solely European” nuclear conflict presupposes that two European nuclear powers would stand idly by. This is the weakest assumption in the entire argument, regardless of how one assesses the other two.

    It should also be noted that Karaganov does not speak on behalf of the government. At the Valdai Forum, he represents the wing of the Russian debate that pushes the Kremlin toward more definitive positions, and one of his roles is precisely to push the boundaries of what can be said. Viewed in this light, his “too late” is an indication of a trend rather than a doctrine.

    Oreshkin: The market that no longer exists

    With Maksim Oreshkin, the tone has shifted entirely. Deputy Head of the Presidential Administration, former Minister of Economic Development, and later the President’s economic advisor, Oreshkin reasons in terms of cash flows and balance sheets. His assessment was blunt: Europe is finished. There is no longer any viable competition in the energy market, because China and India now occupy the top spots among Russia’s customers. And there is no reason to invest in a European bailout, since the Europeans, to date, have shown no interest in finding a peaceful and reasonable solution. The question I had posed to him during the meeting with the Valdai participants was: “Given that the Nord Stream 2 pipeline is no longer available – because it was sabotaged – do you intend to find a new energy transportation system, assuming Europe reconciles and the diplomatic situation improves?” His blunt – and perhaps brutal – response is like a dagger of truth plunged into the conscience of every European.

    “Over” should be understood in a technical sense. Oreshkin was not speaking directly about European civilization but about Europe as a trading partner: a market that has ceased to be central to Russia and therefore does not warrant political concessions to win it back. After 2022, Russian crude oil found its main buyers in China and India, while Brussels, through the agreement between the Council and the European Parliament in December 2025, committed to phasing out imports of Russian gas – including pipeline gas and LNG – by 2027. The energy interdependence that had kept Europe and Russia connected for half a century – even during the worst moments of the Cold War – has been dismantled by both sides. Oreshkin’s reasoning captures the simplest consequence of this: whoever is no longer the main customer no longer has leverage. These are the laws of the market, and neither in London, nor in Berlin, nor in Brussels are there any politicians or power groups left who can tell Russia “what to do”.

    The flip side is well known in Moscow, too. A market dominated by two major buyers allows them to demand discounts, and replacing Europe with Asia comes at a cost in terms of price and access to technology. But according to the logic presented to me, the question is no longer whether Europe is in Russia’s interest. It is how much it would cost to make it beneficial again, and the implicit answer is that Europeans must bear that cost.

    Lavrov: the door closed on “this” order

    With Sergey Lavrov, the discussion shifted from the economy to diplomacy, without changing the conclusion. Europe, he said, had many opportunities to reestablish a dialogue with Russia and chose instead to fuel direct confrontation. Now it is too late to turn back: all limits have been crossed, and with the current European order, there is no way to return to previous relations.

    I’d like us to pause for a moment to consider the weight of these words. Those who know Lavrov know that he is a politician capable of weighing every word with great intelligence, even in more relaxed settings such as the Valdai Summit. “The limits have been crossed.” It would be pointless to list these limits, because they are so obvious to the whole world that it would simply be a waste of time. But the look in Lavrov’s eyes as he spoke about Europe – I will never forget that. I have met him many other times, but on this occasion, there was something different.

    The minister has a track record of events that Russian diplomacy regularly references: the Minsk agreements, the draft treaties on security guarantees submitted to the United States and NATO on December 17, 2021, and the Istanbul negotiations in the spring of 2022. The Russian interpretation of each of these developments is controversial, and it is contested in Europe. What interests me here is another element – a qualification that, upon re-reading after the plenary session, proved to be the key to the entire week. A return is impossible under this European framework. Not with Europe, in its current form – that is, the EU and NATO. The rejection concerns a ruling class and an institutional architecture, not the countries that are part of it.

    I wonder just how much Russian patience has been abused to reach the point of saying such things? Classic Russian literature offers us admirable examples of how Russian politicians are capable of stalling, ignoring, and being patient. And there’s no denying that this has consistently been the attitude of the Russian ruling class during the recent years of conflict. To go so far as to say that the limit has been crossed – something Putin would later echo in the summit’s plenary session – means there are no more resources to waste on patient waiting; it means the Bear has been awakened from its hibernation at the wrong moment; it means the consequences of these actions will be of epochal significance.

    Lavrov added one more thing:

    We are ready to strike Europe in an exemplary manner, not as we did in Ukraine

    Take note of these words, dear European friends. Reread them and reflect on their weight. Nothing more needs to be said.

    An Italian professor asks Putin a question

    We come now to one of the most dangerous moments of my career. The plenary session took place, as is traditional, with the Russian president in attendance and Fyodor Lukyanov moderating. I took the floor and asked a two-part question:

    I come from Italy, a country that currently does not have good relations with Russia. As a European, I would like to ask you: What conditions will Russia set for developing a new security system for European countries? And, if we imagine a post-European Union Europe, will you consider it part of a great Eurasian partnership, or, in your view, will the United States and Russia always be competing for these territories?

    Putin began with the second part, and the order is no coincidence:

    Italy is, in fact, located in Europe, and I am speaking of a Eurasian partnership: it goes without saying, therefore, that we will consider – and already do consider – Italy a Eurasian partner as well

    Immediately afterward, he clarified that the fate of the European Union, and Italy’s continued membership in it, “is none of our business.” Moscow does not even intend to discuss it, because any comment on the matter would be interpreted as an attempt to break up the EU, “while we do not want to break up anything at all. We only want to build and cooperate.”

    On the conditions for a new security system, the response was clear: “We have no preconditions.” The obstacle, in his view, lies on the other side. Some European politicians consider it unacceptable for a single country to open a dialogue with Russia, and Putin has called this demand a diktat even harsher than that of the Soviet era. The comparison was carefully crafted: the USSR was a unitary and highly centralized state, whose republics were part of a single state structure; the European Union, in theory, is not, but in practice behaves as if it were. “No one is forbidding us; we’re ready.”

    At that point, Lukyanov interjected with a provocative remark typical of an experienced moderator: since Brussels forbids it, wouldn’t it be better to contribute a little to the disintegration of the EU, so as to make it easier to deal with individual countries? The answer came without hesitation: “But there’s no need – they’ll fall apart on their own.”

    Then Putin addressed me directly. “Our Italian colleague knows this better than we do,” he said, and began running the numbers: Italian public debt at 140%, the deficit around 3%, and in other European countries close to 5%. The figures were rounded but not far from the truth. According to Istat and Eurostat, at the end of 2024, Italy’s public debt stood at 135.3% of GDP and its net borrowing at 3.4%. The point of the passage, however, wasn’t about the decimal points. All problems start with the economy: living standards fall, unemployment rises, and citizens of the major European economies feel it firsthand – and this, he said, “also undermines the very foundations of the European Union. But that’s not our business; we don’t interfere.”

    He concluded by reiterating the offer in a balanced manner: dialogue with the Union as a whole, if the Union so desires, or with individual countries, without preconditions. “But there must be no preconditions on the European side either.”

    Trying to grasp the magnitude of these words, the political balance they reveal, and the strength of a statesman who cares not only about the good of his own country but also that of an entire other continent is a true lesson in what politics is all about.

    Listen to Putin’s entire speech, and you will understand how, in less than five minutes, it is possible to capture the decline of all of Europe, in all its facets, while at the same time wistfully reiterating that Russia has done everything in its power to offer its assistance. But the choices of Europeans are their own, whatever flag they may fly. Russia respects and will always respect the fundamental principles of its foreign policy and its political tradition. No miraculous messianism, no improvised savior.

    Europe – or rather, the Europeans of this Europe – what do they intend to do?

    Rereading my travel notes

    Rereading my notes upon my return, the first thing that stands out is the convergence of views. The strategist, the economist, the foreign minister, and the President have each expressed, in their own words, the same assessment: today’s Europe has exhausted its credit with Moscow. The second thing that stands out is that each draws a different conclusion from that diagnosis.

    For Karaganov, the conclusion is coercive and takes on an almost eschatological tone: Europe has had its chance, and what follows is no longer a matter for diplomacy. For Oreshkin, it is a matter of cold, hard accounting: Europe is not worth the investment needed to win it back. For Lavrov, it is a limited diplomatic withdrawal, focused on the political structure rather than the people. Finally, for Putin, the door remains open – but toward individual states, not toward Brussels – accompanied by the expectation that economic erosion will do the rest.

    The apparent contradiction between the “too late” stance of the first three and the “no preconditions” stance of the fourth is resolved precisely in Lavrov’s characterization. The result is a coherent line, which I would call “bilateralization”: Moscow will not deal with the Union as a political entity as long as its current leadership remains in place; it offers individual member states channels without preconditions and lets Europe’s internal difficulties make those channels attractive. The reference to Italy as a Eurasian partner “already today” must be understood within this framework: it is not a courtesy; it is an indication of which interlocutor Moscow prefers.

    I certainly cannot claim that the four exceptional interlocutors had reached an agreement – that goes without saying – but I found this convergence truly “prophetic.” Valdai has always been the venue where the breadth of Russian debate is showcased to a foreign audience. I can say that these perspectives are compatible and mutually reinforcing: Karaganov’s tough stance makes Putin’s offer appear moderate; Oreshkin’s figures lend credibility to the idea that Moscow does not need to make concessions; and Lavrov’s formula balances firmness with openness.

    The 2010–2012 sovereign debt crisis gave rise to the European Stability Mechanism and the banking union; the pandemic led to Next Generation EU and the first large-scale common debt. Within the Union, crises have generated at least as much centralization as fragmentation. “They will fall apart on their own” is therefore a gamble, not an observation – even if the gamble costs little to those making it: if the EU holds together, Moscow has at least offered dialogue; if it collapses, it already has bilateral channels in place.

    The indicators to watch over the next twelve to eighteen months are fairly clear. The first concerns bilateral visits to Moscow by EU heads of government, in addition to the previous visits by Viktor Orbán in July 2024 and Robert Fico in May 2025. The second is whether unanimity holds during the semi-annual renewals of sanctions, where a single veto is enough to open a crack. The third concerns national exemptions from the timeline for phasing out Russian gas. The fourth – and most significant for us – is the possible opening of a structured channel by a major capital, including Rome.

    What do I take away from this? As an Italian, the phrase I’m taking with me isn’t the one about disintegration; it’s the other one: “We already consider Italy a Eurasian partner as well.” It contains both an offer and an observation directed at us. If the door that Moscow says is open is actually closed, it’s closed on this side – and it wasn’t Rome that closed it of its own accord.

    How long can a country with a debt exceeding 135% of GDP afford to leave it up to others to decide who can speak with whom? No one in Moscow asked me that. It’s a question I brought home with me on my own. And every Italian of good conscience, every European who still has a heart, knows the answer [end]

    The original article

    you may need a VPN, because Strategic Culture Foundation is censored in the European Union

    Related

    October 5, 2026: A Report from Russia: How Close are Europe and Russia to a Wider Conflict? – Scott Ritter

    this article is the product of visits to Russia I made in June and September 2026 where I met with senior Russian leaders, leading academics, and specialists in military and security issues

    September 26, 2026: Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s statement at the General Debate of the 81st Session of the UN General Assembly

    September 24, 2026: Four thousand pages of plans, none for peace: NATO’s insane provocations toward war – Lorenzo Maria Pacini, Strategic Culture Foundation

    What does Europe gain from a war it can’t win? Nothing. 1914 is calling

    September 8, 2026: The West has engineered its own downfall – Kishore Mahbubani, Institute of Art and Ideas

    the West has become a lonely, narcissistic civilization

    August 6, 2026: 40 Days that Shook the West – Scott Ritter

    Zelensky and his Western overlords thought they could compel Russia to enter into peace negotiations. All they did is seal Ukraine’s tragic fate

    July 19, 2026: Decision Point – Scott Ritter

    Ukraine is defenseless in the face of Russian missile attacks. Now is not the time for negotiations. Russia must finish the job

    February 23, 2026: The Flamingo Effect – Scott Ritter

    Ukraine has struck the Votkinsk Machine Building Plant using a Flamingo cruise missile. The ramifications of this event could reverberate globally

    November 11, 2025: Der Krieg

    in French, ce 11 novembre 2025 est l’occasion de souligner comme la façon dont l’Europe sacrifie les conscrits ukrainiens mobilisés de force rappelle le spectaculaire carnage de la 1ère guerre mondiale

    September 28, 2025: Dislocation de l’Occident : les menaces – Emmanuel Todd

    in French, la perversité de Trump se déploie au Moyen-Orient, le bellicisme de l’OTAN en Europe

    September 16, 2025: On European imperialism – Events in Ukraine

    EU responsibility and hypocrisy. The angry, betrayed Ukrainians. Update on the forever war

    August 2, 2025: Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    March 7, 2025: Paralyzed by acute dementia, Europe declares war on Russia all over again – Pepe Escobar, Strategic Culture Foundation

    the SMO will keep rollin’ on. And as the Europeans want it, to the last Ukrainian

    March 6, 2023: How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    the West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

  • [Sharing] Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s statement at the General Debate of the 81st Session of the UN General Assembly

    [September 26, 2026]

    Mr President,

    Excellencies,

    Ladies and gentlemen,

    In recent days, we have heard repeatedly – from this rostrum and in the corridors of the General Assembly – that tectonic shifts are underway in global politics, and that a more just, multipolar world order is emerging before our very eyes. Countries of the Global South and East are asserting themselves as sovereign centres of growth and are assuming responsibility for ensuring security in their respective regions. They demonstrate a commitment to international law, a rejection of external pressure, and an interest in the prosperity of all states – not merely the chosen few. This constructive philosophy also underpins Russian foreign policy; it is shared by our many like-minded partners and forms the foundation of cooperation within the CIS, the SCO, BRICS, and other associations of the Global Majority.

    However, this is not to everyone’s liking. The Western minority, which has dominated for five centuries by exploiting the resources of others, persists in its attempts to retain its privileges and impose its “rules” on everyone else. The West increasingly resorts to the use of brute force, acts unpredictably and recklessly, and jeopardises the lives and well-being of millions – if not billions – of people on our shared planet. As Russian President Vladimir Putin has put it, the dictatorship of a single hegemon “…is getting out of control and is simply dangerous for others.”

    Earlier this year, in violation of all norms, including moral ones, a US invasion of Venezuela culminated in the capture of President Nicolás Maduro and his wife, and their detention without trial in an American prison – even though international law explicitly mandates respect for the immunity and inviolability of high-ranking state officials. We insist on the immediate release of the Venezuelan leader and his spouse and demand that such outrages not be repeated in the future.

    We regard the killing of Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, along with members of his family and the military and political leadership of the Islamic Republic, as an unacceptable manifestation of the diktat of force. It is especially alarming that the US-Israeli aggression, which began last June, targeted not only Iran’s civilian infrastructure but also peaceful nuclear facilities protected by IAEA safeguards. This has caused irreparable damage to the Agency’s credibility and to the entire nuclear non-proliferation system.

    Armed confrontations continue to recur in the Gulf region and the Strait of Hormuz, despite the obvious damage inflicted on global shipping and trade. We believe that establishing trust between the Gulf’s littoral states – the Arab nations and Iran – is a necessary condition for resolving the crisis. Our Concept for Collective Security in the Gulf is aimed at establishing a stable regional architecture. Russia, together with other responsible nations, stands ready to make a constructive contribution to stabilising this strategically vital region.

    We are convinced that the time has also come to resolve the Middle East’s central issue: securing statehood for the Palestinian people in accordance with numerous UN resolutions. Almost a year ago, the Security Council endorsed a US-championed “peace plan” for Gaza – yet peace has not been achieved. Senior citizens, women, and children continue to lose their lives, and the humanitarian situation remains critical. The West Bank, for its part, is sliding further into crisis, as Israel expands settlement activity. If this trend continues, establishing a Palestinian state will become impossible – there simply will be no room left for it. Yet, in that scenario, Israel’s own security would also be under constant threat – a fact experts fully acknowledge.

    The UN, and all of us as member states, must take urgent and unconventional steps to reverse these trends in the Middle East and beyond. This applies not only to Palestine, but also to Lebanon, Syria, Yemen, Iraq, Sudan, Somalia, South Sudan, and other African nations where conflicts continue to rage.

    Urgent measures are likewise needed to address the dire humanitarian situation in Cuba, which faces unprecedented pressure from its northern neighbour. We reaffirm our solidarity with the Cuban people and government. We strongly urge the lifting of the naval blockade against the “Island of Freedom,” the removal of all trade restrictions, and the country’s removal from the long-discredited list of state sponsors of terrorism.

    These are merely the most glaring examples that demand the international community’s priority attention. But we cannot confine ourselves to them. The West’s power politics and double standards are destabilising the situation everywhere. In the Balkans, the European Union flagrantly disregards Security Council Resolution 1244 and pressures Serbia to accept the loss of Kosovo and to turn its back on its own history and the memory of its ancestors. Belgrade is being forced, in effect, to impose sanctions against Russia – offered in return the prospect of European integration, which everyone now recognises as illusory. In an attempt to unitarise Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Serbs are being pushed to surrender constitutional powers guaranteed by the Dayton Peace Agreement and by the UN Security Council.

    In the same spirit of disregard for international law, the reckless actions of the external sponsors of the Kiev regime pose a serious threat to international peace and security. For the sake of the utopian goal of containing Russia, the West has destroyed the European security system with its own hands and nurtured the Russophobic regime in Kiev. Now, realising the futility of their efforts, Europe is doing everything to prevent a peaceful settlement and to derail negotiations – a process many are interested in, including the Trump administration. The West continues the endless flow of weapons into Ukraine and helps the regime target drones and missiles at civilians and civilian infrastructure. In the West, they dream of inflicting a “strategic defeat” on Russia. But those dreams, as has happened many times before, will lead the warmongers themselves to a strategic dead end.

    Colleagues,

    A year ago, we marked the 80th anniversary of the Victory over German Nazism and Japanese militarism. Next week, on October 1, we will mark the 80th anniversary of the conclusion of the International Military Tribunal in Nuremberg. The historic verdict of the Court of Peoples – as the Nuremberg Tribunal is known – condemned Nazi criminals harshly and unequivocally, and outlawed and placed beyond the pale of morality the misanthropic ideology of Nazism.

    Yet 80 years on, not everyone has learned the lessons of Nuremberg. Judging by the statements of their representatives, the ruling elites of many EU countries are clearly afflicted by the virus of racial superiority and are nurturing extremist, Russophobic ideas. They condone the leaders of the Ukrainian regime in Kiev as they honour inveterate war criminals and Nazi collaborators – individuals whose arms are up to their elbows covered in the blood of Russians, Jews, Belarusians, Ukrainians and people of other nationalities. Almost the entire West votes here in this hall, year after year, against the Russia-sponsored resolution condemning the glorification of Nazism. Germany, Japan, and all NATO countries – many of them guilty of crimes against humanity during World War II – vote against it. This does not surprise us.

    But I would like to stress: the outcomes of World War II formed the foundation of the post-war world order and they are enshrined in the UN Charter. By ratifying this document, the former Axis states admitted their historical responsibility for the countless calamities caused to the world by Nazi ideology and practices. By bashfully turning a blind eye to the increasingly evident manifestations of Ukrainian Nazism, one imperils the very foundations of the UN-centric world order.

    While downplaying Nazi Germany’s responsibility for the genocide of the Soviet people and feeling no shame about Germany’s role as a primary sponsor of the Nazi regime in Kiev, Chancellor Merz declares that Germany must “once again” become the biggest military power in Europe. Do they realise in Berlin what “once again” means and where it can lead? Did the outcome of World War II teach you nothing?

    The Ukrainian regime is openly overriding such cornerstones of the UN Charter as respecting human rights and freedoms for all with no discrimination as to race, gender, language or religion. There is no other country in the world but Ukraine where the law prohibits a language. The Russian language is banned in Ukraine. Using the Russian language is punishable, up to and including imprisonment. But the European Union, taking pride in its “European values,” seems to have sewn its mouth shut, with not a word of condemnation. All they say is Ukraine is helping to defend these very European values. Inadvertently, one starts to think that both Nazism and the outrageous violations of the freedom of speech, information and faith by the Ukrainian regime actually form the core of these very “European values.”

    Having launched the special military operation in 2022 to defend the people of Donbass and Novorossiya from extermination by the Kiev regime, Russia continues to fight for their security and rights in full compliance with the letter and spirit of the UN Charter. We will carry through our fight for the truth and justice: the goals of the special military operation will be achieved; threats to Russia’s security will be eliminated and peaceful life restored. It will happen despite any circumstances, including the inability of the current UN leaders to take the only right stance with regard to Ukraine, which is the defence of the principles of the UN Charter – not selectively but in their entirety, completeness and interconnectedness.

    We expect that the new Secretary-General, who is to be elected by the end of the year, will rigorously adhere to their mandate and the principles of impartiality and neutrality stipulated by the Charter; that they will represent the entire international community rather than serve the interests of certain states; that they will not undermine the intergovernmental nature of the UN system or erode the prerogatives of the UN Security Council and its permanent members.

    Our principled approach is that a reform of the Security Council cannot provide any extra seats to the Western countries – especially Germany and Japan – that have taken the path of militarisation and revanchism. We advocate solely for the expansion of representation by Asia, Africa and Latin America and support the candidacies of Brazil and India for permanent seats while – and I want to stress this – the interests of the African continent shall be met with due account for the Ezulwini Consensus and the Sirte Declaration.

    Ladies and gentlemen,

    By pursuing its responsible foreign policy, Russia seeks to improve the international climate, in unity with our allies and strategic partners, including BRICS, the SCO, the EAEU, the CIS and the CSTO. We propose a uniting agenda, specific ideas and projects.

    International information security is a matter currently moving to the forefront. It is evident that the UN, rather than non-transparent and private mechanisms, must play the central role in this issue. Last October in Hanoi, the UN Convention against Cybercrime, developed at Russia’s initiative, was opened for signature. We welcome the launch of the global mechanism under the aegis of the UN for its implementation – the first permanent format in this area.

    The UN is vested with special responsibility due to the rapid development of AI technology. It is hard to dispute the fact that generally recognised rules of AI application can only be developed on an equal basis, with all countries involved. We consider the launch of the Global Dialogue on AI Governance and the Independent International Scientific Panel on Artificial Intelligence as steps in the right direction. China’s initiative to create the World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organisation, backed by Russia, is another project of similar purpose.

    In the 1950s, the Soviet Union helped African, Asian and Latin American countries to break free from the shackles of colonial dependence. Further democratisation of international affairs is impossible without eradicating the neo-colonial practices that persist to this day. The adoption of a General Assembly resolution declaring December 14 the International Day Against Colonialism in All Its Forms and Manifestations was a landmark event in this regard. We will be glad to see supporters of the struggle against modern neo-colonial practices from all states at the 1st For the Freedom of Nations International Inter-Party Movement World Assembly that is taking place in Russia within a few months.

    Colleagues,

    It is only possible to secure a lasting peace by ending the dangerous rivalry between the largest global players. We can only achieve this by strictly adhering to the UN Charter and the principle of equal and indivisible security. Let me remind you that this principle means refraining from ensuring the security of one state at the expense of others; that it is unacceptable for any country or a group of countries or an organisation to claim dominance in security. This mainly applies to NATO, which seeks to spread its destructive influence far beyond the geography of its domain, including Southeast and Northeast Asia.

    The values of broad equal cooperation are the bedrock of the initiatives to build a Greater Eurasian Partnership and the security architecture across Eurasia, proposed by Russian President Vladimir Putin. Yesterday here, in New York, Russia, Belarus and other like-minded states adopted a statement on the beginning of the work on the Eurasian Charter of Diversity and Multipolarity in the 21st Century. We call for everybody who is willing to become part of the new pancontinental architecture of peace and development to contribute to the success of this important project that will complement and harmonise the existing mechanisms in the spirit of the geopolitical realities of the emerging multipolar world.

    Thank you [end]

    The original article

    Related

    Operation Epstein Files

    once more, the US and Israel attack Iran, chronicle

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    Nazism in Ukraine

    its roots before WW2, its collaboration with Nazi Germany, its legacy in modern Ukraine, how NATO has continually supported Nazism in Ukraine, chronicle

    The footprint of the Ukrainian Nazism in the West

    chronicle of interactions between Ukrainian Nazi organizations and Western supremacist militants

    September 8, 2026: The West has engineered its own downfall – Kishore Mahbubani, Institute of Art and Ideas

    The West has become a lonely, narcissistic civilization

    February 15, 2026: Rubio gives green light to new era of US-European colonialism – Roger McKenzie, Morning Star

    January 3, 2026: Make Israel great again

    9 mai 2025 : Victory Day

    December 24, 2024: The Moral Bankruptcy of the West – John J. Mearsheimer

    October 10, 2023: African revolution

    France is expelled from its former colonies in West Africa

  • [Sharing] Four thousand pages of plans, none for peace: NATO’s insane provocations toward war – Lorenzo Maria Pacini, Strategic Culture Foundation

    What does Europe gain from a war it can’t win? Nothing. 1914 is calling

    Everything is ready to explode

    In Copenhagen, before the chiefs of staff of the 32 countries of the Atlantic Alliance, Admiral Giuseppe Cavo Dragone chose the words with which to address the European public. As chairman of NATO’s Military Committee since January 2025, he announced that the Alliance has “4,000 pages of plans” for its eastern flank, that these plans cover every scenario “from a minor crisis or an intervention on our territory to the invocation of Article 5 and subsequent actions,” and that “military personnel, systems, and weapons are ready.” Then came the closing remark: in the event of an attack, the Russians “have much more to lose than to gain. This is absolutely certain. And that is what constitutes deterrence.”

    The admiral intended this to be a reassuring message. Read carefully, however, it is one of the most imprudent statements made by a European military leader since the end of the Cold War. It is worth breaking it down piece by piece.

    The words spoken in Copenhagen did not fall on deaf ears. Just a few hours earlier, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk had predicted that Moscow might launch drones or missiles into the territory of a NATO country “in the coming months” to demonstrate that Article 5 is nothing more than a promise on paper; Paris, meanwhile, was preparing a plan to counter drone attacks. In such an atmosphere, the duty of a high-ranking military officer would be to calm tensions, distinguish between hypothesis and fact, and remind governments that war between nuclear powers is not a scenario to be planned but one to be prevented. The admiral did the opposite: he added fuel to the fire.

    And this isn’t the first time. In December 2025, in an interview with the Financial Times, Cavo Dragone himself explained that the Alliance was considering becoming “more aggressive” against Russia’s hybrid warfare, that a “preemptive strike” could be considered a “defensive action,” and that being more aggressive than the opponent “might be an option.” Moscow, through Maria Zakharova, spoke of an irresponsible step toward escalation, coming while negotiations on Ukraine were underway. Ten months later, the tone hasn’t changed. It has only become more explicit: first the possibility of a preemptive strike, now the inventory of weapons at the ready.

    Deterrence isn’t achieved through proclamations

    The admiral calls all of this “deterrence.” But the theory of deterrence – the serious kind – says otherwise. Thomas Schelling explained that deterrence is an act of communication in which credibility matters as much as force, and that an effective threat always leaves the adversary a way out. In the security dilemma, what one side perceives as defense is interpreted by the other as preparation for offense. Four thousand pages detailing “follow-on actions” under Article 5 are, from Moscow’s perspective, war plans against Russia. No Kremlin analyst will interpret them any other way, and no one should be surprised by this.

    There is also a question of role. The Chairman of the Military Committee is the chief military adviser to the Secretary General and the North Atlantic Council: he does not determine Alliance policy; he serves it. When an officer of this rank uses a public platform to issue warnings to a foreign power, he encroaches on a space that belongs to governments and parliaments – that is, to those who are accountable to the citizens. In a democracy, the decision to go to war does not rest with the generals. Or are we to understand that it is NATO, through “Cavo Dragone,” that is provoking the outbreak of war by calling for it with all its might?

    And above all, there is the nuclear weapon. Since November 2024, Russian doctrine has regarded an attack by a non-nuclear state – carried out with the participation or support of a nuclear power – as a joint attack, and has lowered the threshold for the use of nuclear weapons. One may judge that doctrine as one wishes. It is impossible to ignore it. Anyone who speaks of “follow-up actions” under Article 5 against a country that has laid out these rules in black and white is, whether they like it or not, talking about nuclear war.

    The entire rhetorical framework of Copenhagen rests on an unproven premise: that Russia is preparing to attack the Alliance. The evidence cited includes airspace violations, acts of sabotage, and intelligence reports suggesting an attack “in the coming years.” The Kremlin has denied such plans, and the denial alone proves nothing. But strategic logic does. Moscow has been engaged in Ukraine for over four and a half years; a direct attack against a NATO member would pit it against the arsenals of the United States, the United Kingdom, and France, with no gain commensurate with the risk. Anyone who thinks in terms of costs and benefits – in Moscow as well as in Brussels – understands that such a move is highly unlikely.

    Why, then, insist on the imminence of the threat? One answer – one that is hard to dismiss – lies in the budgets. At the Hague summit in June 2025, the allies committed to raising defense spending to 5% of GDP by 2035. Such a goal can only be justified to voters if there is an enemy at the gates. Fear has become a budget line item.

    That leaves the other half of the problem – the more serious one. If a Russian attack on NATO is unlikely, a NATO war against Russia is unthinkable. According to estimates by the Federation of American Scientists, the Russian Federation possesses the largest nuclear arsenal on the planet. There is no such thing as a military victory against a power of this kind: there is only mutual destruction, and its geography is already set in stone. The fighting would take place right here.

    Admiral, please explain

    Admiral, now calm down, wipe the drool from your mouth, and explain to us exactly what we have to lose from a confrontation with Russia. You’ve quantified the losses of others with absolute certainty. You haven’t mentioned ours.

    Let’s try to do that ourselves. Italy hosts bases that open sources have for years identified as U.S. nuclear weapons depots, in Aviano and Ghedi; it hosts Sigonella, the Allied Command in Naples, as well as ports and infrastructure that are prime targets in any adversary’s planning. Poland, the Baltic states, and Germany are the very theater of the “4,000 pages.” The United States has an ocean between it and Europe. Europe has its cities, its factories, and its children. In a war with Russia, Europe is not a player: it is the battlefield.

    And so the second question – the one no Copenhagen statement addresses – is this: What exactly would we gain from a nuclear conflict fought on our own soil? What political objective, what Italian national interest, what European principle would be worth the loss of Milan, Munich, or Warsaw? The honest answer is simple: nothing. A war that cannot be won is not a policy. It is suicide with an attached operational plan.

    In its 77-year history – which the admiral cites – the Alliance has produced plans for every contingency. Other pages are missing – the ones Europe should demand from its own governments: a continental security architecture that also includes Russia, measures to build mutual trust, permanent military channels of communication, and arms control treaties to be rebuilt after nearly all of them have been allowed to lapse. In 1975, with the Helsinki Final Act, two blocs armed to the teeth were able to sit down at the same table. It was not weakness. It was the realization that the continent’s survival was worth more than any tactical advantage.

    Today, that realization seems to have vanished precisely from those who, by profession, should know better than anyone else the price of war. When generals speak in ultimatums and governments remain silent, the risk is not that war will be declared. It is that war will arrive on its own, by inertia, driven by words that no one has had the courage to retract.

    Europe has already traveled this path, in the summer of 1914. It would be unforgivable to travel it again, this time with nuclear warheads in tow [end]

    The original article

    you may need a VPN, because Strategic Culture Foundation is censored in the European Union

    Related

    September 8, 2026: The West has engineered its own downfall – Kishore Mahbubani, Institute of Art and Ideas

    the West has become a lonely, narcissistic civilization

    November 11, 2025: Der Krieg

    in French, ce 11 novembre 2025 est l’occasion de souligner comme la façon dont l’Europe sacrifie les conscrits ukrainiens mobilisés de force rappelle le spectaculaire carnage de la 1ère guerre mondiale

    September 28, 2025: Dislocation de l’Occident : les menaces – Emmanuel Todd

    in French, la perversité de Trump se déploie au Moyen-Orient, le bellicisme de l’OTAN en Europe

    September 16, 2025: On European imperialism – Events in Ukraine

    EU responsibility and hypocrisy. The angry, betrayed Ukrainians. Update on the forever war

    August 2, 2025: Russophrenia: the West’s favourite delusion about Russia – Brian McDonald

    ten years after I coined the term, the media’s still convinced Russia is both collapsing, and conquering the world

    March 7, 2025: Paralyzed by acute dementia, Europe declares war on Russia all over again – Pepe Escobar, Strategic Culture Foundation

    the SMO will keep rollin’ on. And as the Europeans want it, to the last Ukrainian

    March 6, 2023: How Could Western Intelligence Have Got It Wrong, Again? They Didn’t. They Had Other Purposes – Alastair Crooke, Strategic Culture Foundation

    the West now faces the task of de-fusing the landmine of their own electorate’s conviction of a Ukraine ‘win’, and of Russian humiliation

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    The Western disinformation about Ukraine

    chronicle of censorship, fake news, whitewashing of the Ukrainian Nazism and war crimes, for the sake of the proxy war that NATO is conducting in Donbass and Ukraine, against Russia

  • [Enemy British media] Claude: tyranny’s little helper – Peter Frankopan, UnHerd

    Our enemies are weaponising AI [mwahaha]

    Over the past year, the AI community has become increasingly worried over the behaviour of autonomous agents. Over the past week, that worry has hardened into panic — not least given the chatter, if vague and hard to verify, about a significant advance in recursive self-improvement at one of the world’s biggest frontier firms. Yet amid rumours and counter-rumours, and the recent suggestion by Donald Trump that “whoever wins AI wins”, one document may offer answers — less about the existential dangers of AI, and more about the threat it poses in the here-and-now.

    Over 154 pages, a new report by Anthropic details some of the ways in which its Claude model has been misused over the past several months. With its talk of cyber-attacks, espionage and propaganda, it makes for terrifying reading, especially given how many actors — from Russian hackers to Chinese spies to Iranian propagandists — are now using the technology. As for Anthropic, it is able to monitor and assess how its systems are being used in real time, allowing the firm’s threat-intelligence team to track how Claude is being used.

    One of the most eyebrow-raising examples comes from Yemen, particularly striking given the Houthis have established a presence on Perim Island, a strategically important position in the Bab al-Mandab Strait. Control of the island could strengthen the militants’ ability to threaten shipping through this narrow southern gateway to the Red Sea and Suez Canal, the primary maritime corridor linking Asia and Europe.

    It’s striking, then, that Anthropic’s team identified a weapons-engineering cell in the north of the country that used Claude to work on three distinct programmes, including a guided rocket and a ballistic missile with a range exceeding 2,000 kilometres. Tracking this activity made it possible to reconstruct the militia’s engineering workflows.

    To put simply: the Houthis — or their affiliates or hired helpers — effectively used Claude Code as a substitute for software engineers, getting it to help develop guidance, navigation and control systems; integrate an open-source autopilot into a flight computer; tune controls; and even run simulations. Several Claude operations ran at once: one coding, another researching, and a third checking the first agent’s work. This was not mere experimentation by geeks with laptops. After all, it apparently resulted in the test-firing of a guided rocket. When this seemingly failed, the results were quickly plugged back into Claude to diagnose what had gone wrong.

    Anthropic says it has no evidence that an operational weapon was ultimately fielded, but the episode exposes an uncomfortable weakness in the way AI safety controls currently work. It is worth noting that Claude would not simply agree to design a missile on request; in fact, Anthropic says its safeguards blocked many of the Houthi cell’s requests. Still, they did not block all of them. By disguising the purpose of individual requests, and distributing the work across multiple sessions, the engineers were able to bypass controls.

    Next stop: Iran. Here, we’re shown evidence of how Claude has been used to support propaganda, espionage and domestic repression. Again, this was not simply a matter of asking a chatbot to knock out a few inflammatory posts. Anthropic describes three operations in which Claude helped construct the machinery of an influence campaign: including writing campaign manuals; designing fake online personas; and compiling databases of people and organisations to target.

    In one example, official intelligence bulletins were fed into Claude and transformed into content for different audiences — from Farsi to Arabic, Urdu to English — with the tone shifting alongside the language.

    Iran also used Claude to disguise government narratives as the work of foreign writers. One network produced material intended for more than 100 online Iranian channels, including ones linked to the IRGC. More than that, Anthropic found evidence that Iranian propaganda was being camouflaged, falsely attributing arguments and findings to respected Western institutions like CSIS or the Brookings Institute.

    More specific examples of Iranian AI-built propaganda are just as disturbing. Tehran-linked actors have been using Claude to build detailed profiles of hundreds of Israelis, and members of the Jewish diaspora, installing malicious software to steal people’s usernames, passwords and other login details. Elsewhere, Claude built a system to track US naval forces, securing personnel information from military photographs, among other sources.

    The implications here are stark. Iran is hardly a superpower — and the Houthis certainly aren’t either — yet AI allows both to develop systems that would once have taken armies of engineers, programmers, analysts and linguists. That, in turn, opens the door to further disruption by non-state actors, causing chaos on the cheap. If the war in Ukraine shows how drones and other simple gadgets can nonetheless hamstring a well-armed opponent, AI could now do the same for espionage, cyber-warfare, propaganda and weapons development.

    It’s telling, here, that even serious powers are learning these lessons too. After all, Anthropic’s tools have also been extensively used in Russia, despite the latter already boasting a formidable espionage apparatus of its own. That, however, hasn’t stopped Moscow from using Anthropic’s tech to make its activities better, faster and harder to tackle. That’s clear enough in the case of Midnight Blizzard, a hacking group closely linked to, or indeed part of, Russia’s SVR foreign intelligence service.

    In practice, the hackers seemingly used Claude to make phishing attacks more convincing, while also helping them break into computer systems more effectively. For instance, hackers used the AI to double-check whether security software had spotted newly installed malware and, if it had, rewrite the code and try again until it slipped past the defences. These tools were then deployed against a swathe of targets outside Russia: including government ministries, intelligence and defence bodies, think-tanks, and more. Perhaps unsurprisingly, Ukraine and its drone industry feature prominently.

    It has been fascinating, too, to see Claude turning up in the toolkit of another major power: China. Again, the examples here are remarkable in their scope, with an outfit likely based in central China using Claude to spy on roughly 50 organisations worldwide, spanning industries from energy and healthcare to finance and technology.

    One obvious question is why China would plump for the foreign-made Claude, not least given the People’s Republic has DeepSeek, Qwen, Kimi and other domestic AI tools to choose from. Though Anthropic’s report does not address this, the obvious explanation is that, for some jobs — not least a Chinese police-surveillance project — China thought Claude was the best option: particularly for coding, technical research, and coordinating complicated tasks.

    According to Anthropic’s report, Chinese companies have also attempted to scale and distil Claude’s capabilities. Again, China hardly lacks engineers, data or computing power. But, just as a pace-setter is invaluable in a marathon, so too can Anthropic be exploited by its rivals, another reason to doubt Trump’s latest claims.

    Nevertheless, it would be a stretch to conclude, as Trump has done, that America is winning, let alone has “won”, the AI race. If anything, indeed, the episode illustrates the peculiar nature of that contest. American companies may build the most capable models — but once those capabilities exist, the US’s adversaries can use them to their own advantage.

    In a broader sense, meanwhile, these varied use cases put a subtler spin on all that breathless talk of AI collapse. The technology has hardly invented espionage, or propaganda, or ballistic missiles. But it is reducing the amount of expertise, labour and time required to do them all. Whatever the claims of looming extinction, the technology is being used, in nefarious ways, by a variety of flesh-and-blood actors right now. Rather than mass suffering and death, we should perhaps be more immediately worrying about our credit-card details being sold and our accounts drained — not by AI agents, but by human criminals a lot like us.

    In an open letter published around the same time as his company’s report, Dario Amodei, chief executive of Anthropic, seems to acknowledge that the threat architecture has changed — and fast. Building AI too quickly is dangerous, he writes, but failing to build it risks placing the most powerful technology of the age “in the hands of authoritarian powers”. Any attempt to slow AI and tech development in the US is a threat: if the democratic world slows down, Amodei argues, “CCP-associated projects will pull ahead, creating significant national security risk”.

    Among other measures, Amodei is therefore demanding tighter restrictions on the sale of advanced AI chips and semiconductor manufacturing equipment to China; a crackdown on chip smuggling and remote access to overseas data centres; and measures to stop Chinese companies distilling the capabilities of American frontier models. If these measures work, Amodei adds, they could “widen America’s lead significantly over the next 3-5 years.”

    Seen in another light, though, Amodei’s proposals look a little more complicated. As CEO of a company preparing one of the largest flotations in history, arguing that its technology is so dangerous that the government needs to intervene in the market around it is unusual. He wants tighter controls on advanced chips; stronger restrictions on the dissemination of frontier capabilities; measures to stop competitors catching up; and government assistance to overcome antitrust problems. In all, it looks like a bid towards establishing a monopoly, rather than simply a concern with the consequences of new technologies. The longer the furore over the monopoly persists, anyway, the longer foreign misuse of Claude will remain obscured: to the West, if not its enemies.

    This is a field that is moving extraordinarily fast, reason enough to take the warnings seriously. But the last few days have raised more questions than they have answered: about how immediate the dangers really are, who should decide how quickly AI develops, and about where safety and national security end and commercial self-interest begins. The risks are plainly enormous, as are the opportunities. What is less clear is whether we are witnessing genuine panic among those closest to the technology, or the opening moves in a struggle over who gets to control it. It may well be both [end]

    The original article

    Peter Frankopan is Professor of Global History at Worcester College, Oxford

    Related

    September 8, 2026: The West has engineered its own downfall – Kishore Mahbubani, Institute of Art and Ideas

    the West has become a lonely, narcissistic civilization

    March 8, 2026: Blinded giant: How Iran crippled America’s multi-billion dollar THAAD network in days – Ivan Kesic, Press TV

    in the first week of the US-Israeli aggression on Iran, the Islamic Revolution Guards Corps (IRGC) conducted a series of precision strikes that systematically degraded the much-hyped US integrated air and missile defense architecture across the region

    October 26, 2024: US authorizes CIA mercenaries to run biometric concentration camps in Gaza Strip – Dan Cohen, Uncaptured Media

    a private intelligence corporation billed as “Uber for war zones” is preparing to create what Israel hopes will be the model for supplanting Hamas rule in Gaza

    January 3, 2024: The EU Is Willing to Go to War Over Lithium? – Phil Butler, New Eastern Outlook

    November 15, 2023: The French National Police is unlawfully using an Israeli facial recognition software – Disclose

    in 2015, law enforcement secretly acquired surveillance video image analysis software from the Israeli company Briefcam. For eight years, the Ministry of the Interior concealed the use of his tool, which enables facial recognition

    January 28, 2023: The Battle for Ukraine’s Titanium – David Brennan, Newsweek

  • [Sharing] The West has engineered its own downfall – Kishore Mahbubani, Institute of Art and Ideas

    The West has become a lonely, narcissistic civilization

    Our world is full of divides. Yet, the greatest divide is between the 12% of the world’s population who live in the West and the 88% who live outside. When the West looks at itself in the mirror, it sees itself as the most virtuous civilization on planet Earth, taking care of its own citizens and generously and selflessly making the world a better place. And when the rest of the world looks at the West, they see a trigger-happy, violent civilization which has killed more innocent people in unnecessary wars than any other civilization in recent decades. So where does the truth lie?

    Sadly, the data doesn’t lie. Since the end of the Cold War, when the world was expected to receive a peace dividend, the West has involved itself in one misadventure after another. The results have been disastrous. The Brown University Watson School of International and Public Affairs’ Cost of War Project has estimated that at least 940,000 people were killed directly by violence in the post-9/11 wars between 2001 and 2023, and a further 3.6–3.8 million people died indirectly due to secondary causes such as diseases, malnutrition and so on. Many of these wars were initiated by the West.

    Curiously, for a civilization that prides itself on intellectual honesty and deep introspection, there has been little reflection on how and why the West has gone so wrong with its constant interventions. Initially, the intervention in Afghanistan was legal and justified under international law, on the basis of UNSC Resolution 1386 (20 December 2001). Yet, after removing the Taliban government, which had harbored the Al-Qaeda terrorists, the West had no strategy for managing its exit from Afghanistan. Instead, it stayed on for 20 years in Afghanistan, only to go from rescuing the Afghan people from the Taliban government to returning the Afghan people to the Taliban government. And in those 20 years, apart from the soldiers who died in battle, over 100,000 Afghan civilians were killed or wounded. No one in the West has been held accountable for this incredible disaster.

    Unlike the Afghan invasion, which was legal under international law, the invasion of Iraq in March 2003 was illegal. The former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan bravely declared that it was illegal and was persecuted by the Bush Administration for stating the truth. Here, too, a huge number of innocent civilians lost their lives in an illegal war. Yet no one has been held accountable, although Western public opinion has reluctantly conceded that the war was illegal and unnecessary.

    The Western reaction to the failed intervention in Libya has been even more callous. “We came. We saw. He died.” So said Hillary Clinton, the then US Secretary of State, proudly when Gaddafi was killed on October 20, 2011. Yet, while Gaddafi was alive, the majority of Libyans enjoyed a decent life, particularly from the 1990s onward, which was a period of relative political stability and economic growth. No war or conflict. Each Libyan household also received extensive welfare benefits from the state. GDP grew from US$ 31 billion in 1990 to $75 billion in 2010. Libya’s per capita GDP in 2010, at $11.6 thousand, was the highest in Africa. By 2020, 10 years after Gaddafi was removed, Libya’s GDP declined to $47 billion. Its GDP per capita declined to $6.7 thousand. Millions of ordinary Libyans were transported from a safe and secure existence to hell. The West never said sorry to them.

    This callous indifference to the pain and suffering that the West has clearly wrought on so many innocent civilians undermines the Western self-belief that they are an inherently virtuous civilization. And the West is also unaware of how its claims to moral virtue have been further eroded by the manifest double standards it has applied when passing judgements on human rights violations.

    For decades, the West had preached that torture was abominable and was outlawed by several human rights conventions. Indeed, the West had regarded the UN Convention against Torture, adopted on December 10, 1984, as a great leap forward. President Reagan stated, when transmitting the Convention to the US Senate for ratification in May 1988, that doing so would “clearly express United States opposition to torture, an abhorrent practice unfortunately still prevalent in the world today.” Yet, when the Bush Administration became the first modern developed country to reintroduce torture in Guantánamo, the erstwhile defenders of human rights in Europe didn’t just fail to condemn the Bush Administration. They aided and abetted this torture with several “rendition” programs, kidnapping people and sending them to countries where they face a high risk of torture or abuse.

    The Western double standards on human rights were further exposed in the contrasting reactions of the West to the loss of innocent civilian lives in Ukraine and Gaza. Many Western leaders correctly expressed moral outrage when innocent Ukrainian civilians or children were killed in Ukraine. Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, after the Russian missile and drone attack on Kyiv in August 2025, said, “Another night of Russia’s relentless bombings struck civilian infrastructure and killed innocents.” Kaja Kallas, then EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, stated that “Russia once again deliberately targeted and killed Ukrainian civilians”. President Joe Biden, after the July 2024 Russian missile strikes that killed civilians, including children at Kyiv’s Okhmatdyt children’s hospital, described the attacks as a “horrific reminder of Russia’s brutality” and said that Russia had “targeted Ukrainian civilians.” The UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, responding to the same attack on the children’s hospital, described “attacking innocent children” as “the most depraved of actions.” Western leaders broadly described the killings as atrocities and war crimes. Yet, when many more innocent civilians, including children, were killed in the Gaza conflict, the same Western leaders remained largely silent on Gaza.

    No single event has damaged the moral credibility of the West as much as Gaza has. As modern cell phones have become ubiquitous, we have seen with our own eyes how millions of innocent Palestinian civilians have suffered in Gaza. The 88% of the world’s population who live outside the West have also heard the loud silence of the West on Gaza. Pankaj Mishra, the Indian novelist and author of The World After Gaza, said in January 2025, “Gaza has really damaged American institutions, Western institutions, international institutions, to an extent no previous war, no previous conflict has.” The Booker Prize-winning Indian novelist, Arundhati Roy, has said more starkly, “What is under the rubble in Gaza is not just the bodies of Palestinians, but the carcass of Western liberal democracy.”

    Yet, even if Western external interventions and policies have been disastrous, many leading Western thinkers and politicians console themselves with the thought that domestically they still have the best-performing societies. Josep Borrell, the then European Union High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, said on 13 October 2022, “Europe is a garden. We have built a garden. Everything works. It is the best combination of political freedom, economic prosperity and social cohesion that humankind has been able to build … Most of the rest of the world is a jungle, and the jungle could invade the garden.”

    There’s no question that people living in the modern, advanced Western societies still enjoy better standards of living than their counterparts in the Global South. The current citizens of the West are the beneficiaries of the wise and sound public policies made by their ancestors. But what are they leaving behind for their future generations? Will future generations in Europe and North America have equally good lives? Or will they see a steady decline?

    Surveys show that most Western populations do not believe that their children and grandchildren will enjoy equally good lives. A January 2025 Pew Survey revealed that over 75% of respondents in Europe as well as in the US and Canada believed that their children would be financially worse off than their parents.

    Indeed, even today, large segments of the population in the West have experienced a deterioration, not improvement, in their lives. The Brookings Institution reported in May 2026 that “In 2024, 45.5% of US households did not earn enough to make ends meet. In nearly every year since 2014, more than 40% of American households struggled to make ends meet.” The report added, “As it stands, the cost of living will never be affordable if wages do not substantially increase. Evidence shows that even though US productivity nearly doubled between 1979 and 2025, average hourly pay increased by only 34%. In other words, productivity gains have concentrated wealth among capital owners and the highest-earning Americans, hollowing out the middle class rather than driving broad-based wage growth.”

    Angus Deaton and Anne Case have documented in Deaths of Despair that the US faces an epidemic of “deaths of despair”—that is, deaths from drug overdoses, suicides, and alcohol—among midlife non-Hispanic white Americans. They wrote: “Deaths of despair among white men and women aged forty-five to fifty-four rose from thirty per one hundred thousand in 1990 to ninety-two per one hundred thousand in 2017. In every US state, suicide mortality rates for whites aged forty-five to fifty-four increased between 1999–2000 and 2016–17. In all but two states, mortality rates from alcoholic liver disease rose. And in every state, drug overdose mortality rates increased.”

    Most Western eyes do not see a connection between their failed external geopolitical ventures and the internal despair of their populations. Actually, the two are linked. Money and resources wasted on unnecessary external interventions could have been better spent on their populations. Speaking about the Iraq war, the Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz wrote, “For one-sixth of the cost of the war, the US could put its Social Security system on sound footing for more than a half-century, without cutting benefits or raising contributions.”

    Even if some thoughtful people in the West may agree with the arguments so far, acknowledging that many Western interventions in the Global South were unnecessary and disastrous, they would not in any way agree that the Ukraine war also reflects Western geopolitical incompetence. There’s no question that the Russian invasion of Ukraine was illegal. Russia deserves to be condemned for the loss of thousands of innocent lives.

    Yet, when the West imposed sanctions on Russia for invading Ukraine, it didn’t notice that 85% of the world’s population did not follow suit. Why not? Does this reflect a lack of moral integrity in the Global South? Or does it reflect a shrewd geopolitical assessment? When countries like Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, and South Africa did not impose sanctions on Russia, this did not mean that they supported the Russian invasion. It signaled their rejection of the Western claim that the war in Ukraine was “unprovoked” and only Russia was to blame for the Ukraine invasion.

    It’s truly shocking how many Western leaders have used the word “unprovoked” to describe the Ukraine war. President Joe Biden, US President, said, on 24 February 2022, “The Russian military has begun a brutal assault on the people of Ukraine without provocation, without justification, without necessity.” Around the same time, Prime Minister Boris Johnson described Russia’s action as a “brutal and unprovoked attack on a free and sovereign European country.” Justin Trudeau, the Canadian Prime Minister, said, “Today, we woke up to a changed world. Russia has launched a brutal and unprovoked attack on the sovereignty of Ukraine.” The leaders of G7 collectively described Russia’s action as “this unprovoked and completely unjustified attack on the democratic state of Ukraine.”

    Little do these leaders realize that when they use the word “unprovoked” to describe the war in Ukraine, they are effectively insulting the intelligence of the countries of the Global South, including thoughtful leaders like Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. He captured a more nuanced view on the war in Ukraine when he said, in May 2022, “Putin shouldn’t have invaded Ukraine. But it’s not just Putin who is guilty. The United States and the EU are also guilty. What was the reason for the Ukraine invasion? NATO? Then the United States and Europe should have said: ‘Ukraine won’t join NATO.’ That would have solved the problem.”

    This great gap in perceptions between the West and the rest on recent geopolitical developments is both surprising and paradoxical. In theory, our world is shrinking. We have more information available today, even from our cell phones, than at any other time in human history. Yet, when we witness the same recent events, the Western perceptions and those in the rest of the world seem to exist in two different universes. What is even more shocking is that most Western leaders and pundits seem completely unaware that they have lost the support and confidence of the majority of the world’s population. This is why the words of S. Jaishankar, the Indian foreign minister, resonated strongly in the Global South when he said, in June 2022, “Somewhere Europe has to grow out of the mindset that Europe’s problems are the world’s problems but the world’s problems are not Europe’s problems.” A year later, in February 2023, the then German Chancellor Olaf Scholz admitted that Jaishankar “has a point.” Referring to the countries of Latin America, Africa and Asia, Scholz further stated, “We have to generally address the interests and concerns of these countries as a basic prerequisite for joint action.”

    Despite the growing differences between the United States and Europe, both share a common concern on China and will work in one way or another to isolate and stop China. However, when they do so, they will find that the rest of the world will ignore them and continue engaging with China. Hence, instead of isolating China, the West will be isolating itself from the world.

    At the end of the day, the refusal of the West to acknowledge that they have lost the rest represents a massive act of self-deception. The West wants to continue believing that it is still the most virtuous civilization on planet Earth. The longer this self-deception persists, the more the West will be seen as a lonely, narcissistic civilization which is self-absorbed and unaware of how the majority of humanity views them. If this gap between the West and the rest is not addressed effectively and soon, the world will be headed into more troubled waters.

    The original article

    Related

    The Atlanticist defeat in Donbass and Ukraine

    chronicle of a new catastrophic NATO venture

    December 26, 2024: The Moral Bankruptcy of the West – John J. Mearsheimer

    October 20, 2024: Assassination for fraudulent motives

    Pan-Africanist leader Muammar Gaddafi was killed on October 20, 2011

    June 8, 2023: The West Must Prepare for a Long Overdue Reckoning – Chandran Nair, The National Interest

    five major trends illustrate how the world is changing, and that the West must grapple with the reality that it can no longer impose its “leadership” on the world as it once did

    January 7, 2023: « Freedom fighters » are defending Ukraine

    that is for « democracy »

    August 2, 2022: Gone with the wind

    the « war on terror »